President Nixon met with John Dean and Richard Moore to strategize on managing the Watergate disclosures and related legal challenges. Key topics included the extent of potential disclosures, the use of executive privilege, and responses to press inquiries and the Common Cause lawsuit. A significant development was the discussion around Dean's deposition in the Common Cause case, with consideration given to asserting executive privilege versus cooperating with the legal process to avoid appearing evasive.
On March 19, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, John W. Dean, III, Richard A. Moore, and John C. Stennis met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 5:03 pm and 5:41 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 420-024 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 420-24
Date: March 19, 1973
Time: Unknown between 5:03 pm and 5:41 pm.
Location: Executive Office Building
The President met with John W. Dean, III and Richard A. Moore.
Greetings
Watergate
-Disclosures by administration
-Strategy
[The President talked with John C. Stennis between 5:05 pm and 5:07 pm.]
[Conversation No. 420-24A]
[See Conversation No. 37-157.]
[End of telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Disclosures
-Extent
-Problems and dangers
-Executive privilege
-51-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 420-24 (cont’d)
-Press inquiries
-President's willingness to cooperate
-Ronald L. Ziegler's statement
-Press relations
-Administration's point of view
-Meetings with congressmen
-Scott
-Edward J. Gurney
-Appearance on "Today" show
-Executive privilege
-Hugh Scott
-Separation of powers
-Common Cause lawsuit
-Disclosure of contributors prior to April 7, 1972
-Depositions to Dean
-Maurice H. Stans
-Dean's response
-Compliance with campaign laws
-Department of Justice's ruling on Dean's testimony
-Executive privilege
-Attorney-client privilege
-Disclosures
-Extent
-President's cooperation
-Confidentiality
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
DeanWell, [unintelligible] get even more detailed in what we have, taking all the risks. Ah, well that's the trouble though.
NixonI don't think we're prepared to let it all hang out [unintelligible] fully better that we know it. I doubt it, John. Yeah. Just think about it. Don't, don't, I don't think it could hold it.
DeanWhat's very clear just right now uh I think there might be a middle ground.
NixonWell, I just take to mind checkers. You know, you know, your show's still coming off. Yeah. Yeah. Well? And uh well of course, of course. But uh but if the prognosis is good,
Nixonthat's good. That's good. When do you think you'll be uh be uh back uh on the job again? Not if you're not on the job all the time. [laughter]
NixonOh, I know. Yeah. Yeah. Well, the main thing is John, just uh don't move too fast, and we'll, we'll, we'll hold the fort, and uh we'll uh, and uh, everybody's uh you know uh uh, uh we'll be ready for you.
NixonYeah. Yeah. Well, good. And after all, the uh we we you're the old you're the old champ that's counted. We just want you know we're with you 100%.
DeanA middle, we're in the middle ground between letting it all hang out, which uh like a horror hangout in a way doesn't solve any problems, but only part of it hang out.
NixonThat's the trouble. [unintelligible] pull a little thread out and whole door opened [unintelligible] they want to get this here, then open to that, and this to
Deanand there's some differ- different ways. The press thus far has really laid off Ron, and they've kind of accepted his [unintelligible] as the fact that the President is trying to be, the other side of the story is the people saying, well, the President is willing to provide information. They've been trying to insist on that for two days. That's, they've accepted that for the day, in fact,
Deanthey didn't jump into that very much. They don't, they want to have it. They just don't have a cover up, they want a cover up, you know.
DeanI don't know the other press would say that. That's the really frustrating thing. Well, just keep hammered. It has all the people with them. But see I can't go out every week
Nixonand and, I've said it once. We got to keep somebody, I can't say it every week. No. That's right. It infects itself. Well other people got to keep saying it. These are good people.
DeanI wonder if we shouldn't get a group of congressmen and senators in, get them to listen to this. In fact, Gurney, for example, caught it right on the Today show. He thinks executive privilege is fine, and you know, if it's played out, and covers these reports, closer to the President, [unintelligible] these things. But they're more concerned than the appearance of somebody in,
DeanI think which you need really probably go with some allies like Everett Dirksen, Scott, Gurney, Hansen,
DeanNobody has brought that out. The biggest problem we have, though, is the Common Cause lawsuit. They have a lawsuit that's seeking all contributors prior to April 7th, who contributed, you recall, they all were promised, that's right, secrecy. And they have a civil deposition schedule on which I now understand is pending where they have served it.
DeanThe question really is, is my response to that civil deposition. When they called in, they came to counsel and asked to see if they can supply the structure and the mechanism by which the law is complied with. There were a number of cases with that, but in my case, where I was just bring this counsel and kept reverse his counsel back to what was coming here.
DeanThe basis for my role may have assured him, look, act as if, we have complied with all the state laws, and how we are structuring, making sure all of this goes [unintelligible] my role to advise the committee and not be the violator or in any way separate from any other counsel in the press, but the question comes down, do I go for a total executive privilege in the judicial branch, or do I,
Deanfor example. They've stopped his deposition and then what happened is that take my deposition, like so, without my assertion of privilege and they get the double rule of privilege that might apply to it.
NixonAll right, this is this. It's much finer right now because the Democrats are in town.
DeanI see uh I think the answer probably is to go forward and uh and to accept the service. I take it that the Justice Department will fall along on that.
MooreWell, we don't know the virtue, I take it, one is it leaves you still with privilege.
NixonCouncil is an extension of the President, does not serve all who appear by right, nothing, but he will cooperate, and he will provide information provided it doesn't transfer into the area of privileged, right?
MooreWell, it's just the fact, and I think that you have.
DeanAnd uh and right now, uh you take here, I've got questions like 30, that's what, 31 questions we're talking about, and 31 days did they define an answer.
DeanAnd uh the thing is if they were really seeking information, I had thought the best thing to do is give them the information because the real key interpretation of a statute was laid out by the Corrupt Election Law Act that uh it uh they didn't hand over the money because some had been given as cash.
DeanNow uh, [unintelligible] enforce it, it should not become an issue.
MooreThat's the point. It's consistent with what you've advised all that you would.
DeanWell, let's say. It takes time. They just sent for April 9th depositions uh, beyond April 9th, like probably before the 9th, we would quash service. We'd ask the court to quash service on us.
DeanAnd then it started to court's way, right away, and I would say by the time it gets, it takes three weeks. The hearing is usually a couple weeks after they file that, and that uh takes three weeks for a ruling.
DeanAnd if the Court decides the issue, highly civil suit, there will be a rush for it. I would think it'll be a year before it goes all the way.
NixonSo far, I'd say, that he wants to make this matter a matter of litigation. I mean, that's what I think it's going to come out, eventually, and that uh sure far way of having this tossed into that marsh and that's what
MooreAnd those things don't go into the hands of the
Nixonmarsh. All right. Good. Why should it, why should we cover up? Why should we cover up?
MooreThey figure that a whole mess, a bucket of marbles in here. We're willing to throw everything in the street, but
NixonAin't gonna That's what, that's their whole idea, huh?
NixonThey consider this, why don't you go out to the public, why don't we give the damn thing publicly?
DeanIt's then I I promptly went into their hands in prints. I am, I'm hiding it. Uh that uh that's I think they have all they've asked for, because when I had the notes to reach in and grab mine, properly I have a solid waiver and
Deanyesterday so to speak to back them up. And Ervin went through all that politically motivated information. I did listen, and certainly as we got into court they maybe recommend one lump of that if only a portion of it.
DeanI always prefer the the ready made that this that the exceptions, we bring in another and make them move into court each exception. You know that. And on each one, and and every day [unintelligible]
Deanthey'll answer. I can, uh this country is going to be so weary [unintelligible] in an hour.
NixonWell, I need, this is, I mean this, the more there's lawyers, the better it is for us, believe me. Because they all be, they'll argue around.
MooreWell, I certainly would like to emphasize again that we want to cooperate with them. The fact is you have said we will cooperate. We are cooperating.
NixonSix lawyers who have answered questions for three days.
MooreI think it would definitely indicate that I don't think you're going to get away with the idea of they're going to be sworn and do it that way. You'll like to keep that ground away, and holding a line to Senator
NixonOh, no. When I can do, why do it? Why the hell? Because we also said they can, they've said, at this stage uh you got to like
MooreThat's where the trumpets, sweet trumpets, blow.
NixonYou think they've in fact when they get that, that is the point that we're like you've been forced to, we try to get that the more this can get out the more this get out uh the more it is unearned. All this bullshit. And uh it would uh, it really would.
MooreWhy do they know watch you said they don't, when you said that. They won't buy it, but there it is, put it out and say there it is.
Unknown[unintelligible] Ervin's people are doing is they're coming [unintelligible] about [unintelligible] as the situation gets clearer and the lines get drawn, you can start getting bully for that. But I wouldn't know.
UnknownThey stole these things, but I would not be with with anything. And they're confident because they feel that there's no way you can stand up to this. I think I would build the dam before I'd reveal it. I put the contest out there instead of submitting, capitulate without fighting. They stole the damn deed.
Unknown[unintelligible] I think it's fair to tell this picture, I would tell him. I drink the, make it fair to tell him that we hold them. Under the Constitution.
UnknownRight. And that the next letter that they stole these documents, that it's a first class publicity. Really tried. I think that the party reputation [unintelligible] You don't have that [unintelligible]
Unknown[unintelligible] We had a chance to talk to them, each one of these guys [unintelligible]
DeanWell, I think I think it would come today. Get an Ervin speech. An Ervin statement on the press that we might write a letter back to, if you want. A bold statement. In the way I write the letter back and say, the President can take it back people [unintelligible]
Deanand offer to answer any written questions they may have. Bring forth questions to me, bring forth questions to Haldeman. I'm responsible.
MooreI think there is something to be said for getting out, not by a long conference, I just wonder because if you stick to an absolute
NixonCan I get him out? What reason? What can he get him out with?
MooreYou're the best one to get it out because you're a reasonable, responsible He's one. He may know something. He's sure. You have got questions to do it. You have to write up something for everybody else to hear. You're whole lot better than by all our or Colson or Ehrlichman.
MooreIf you're dealing with Texas lawyers, the fox that we have [unintelligible] but now Ervin and Gurney are going [unintelligible]
DeanAnd ah, Coleman was careful to state today that he thought there were other areas that we could
UnknownNow that's fine. In fact, we take it as far as having written questions sent. But the trouble with written questions, you can't really put up what makes sense and [unintelligible] But the other point is this,
Deanand it makes me look like I'm guilty. It's covered up for it. Well, it's covered up either way, but it's covered up because they made you make the statement, [crosstalk] instead of us volunteered it.
DeanUh, we couldn't go up there because it was executive privilege, which is very clear, but, hell, they played that out in the media and people think they are dodging. If we got requests for interrogatories and we answered them, the evasion was what has happened, because all your answers are not going to be on the merits [unintelligible]
DeanThat's right. I'm afraid that our interrogatories are going to open the door like an FBI interview did. Now, now that you've said this publicly, I want to respond like this.
DeanThey will come back and say, "He denies that." Or they will come back and say, "Well, we want him to deny it under oath." [crosstalk] Sure, they swear you in.
NixonWell, at some point, it's not going to be an answer. It probably is going to be an answer. It's already the answer. At some point, we have to face the music on that.
Moorethat we have to provide this information. That's why we have to keep that possibility open, that's why.
DeanThat's why we have to keep that possibility open
MooreThat's why you can't say, the tactics would be not to quite bust three so fast today.
NixonYou can not today, but they'll, they'll ask you, because this was thing, our game, wait until the thing gets bigger. We'll pass that, too.
DeanI think at some point, the public and even some of the media are going to recognize that there is a good solid reason for that there are people that shouldn't go up there,
Moorehe's played that country-boy role, I thought was very effective this morning. He talked about that if he wants executive privilege, and now if we want him to come down here to swear under oath, we have to swear under oath.
NixonThat's right, that's right. That's the point.
MooreAnd I think they will say, they'll throw it out of proportion, because you know, John Erlichman hasn't been subpoenaed yet, Maurice Stans
Also recorded on March 19, 1973
037-155 4:59 PM · 18 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at 4:59 pm.
037-156 4:59 PM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:59 pm and 5:03 pm.
420-021 4:59 PM · 17 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at 4:59 pm.
420-022 4:59 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John D. Ehrlichman met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 4:59 pm and 5:03 pm.
420-023 4:59 PM · 16 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 4:59 pm and 5:03 pm.
037-157 5:05 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John C. Stennis talked on the telephone from 5:05 pm to 5:07 pm.
037-158 5:07 PM · 13 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 5:07 pm and 5:54 pm.
037-159 5:54 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Stephen B. Bull, and John D. Ehrlichman talked on the telephone from 5:54 pm to 5:55 pm.
Conversation 420-024, March 19, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/420-024 (accessed November 18, 2026).