Conversation 016-076

TapeTape 16StartThursday, December 9, 1971 at 7:42 PMEndThursday, December 9, 1971 at 8:10 PMTape start time02:33:08Tape end time03:00:32ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President);  Colson, Charles W.Recording deviceWhite House Telephone

On December 9, 1971, President Richard M. Nixon and Charles W. Colson talked on the telephone from 7:42 pm to 8:10 pm. The White House Telephone taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 016-076 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 16-76

Date: December 9, 1971
Time: 7:42 pm - 8:10 pm
Location: White House Telephone

The President talked with Charles W. Colson.

     Tax legislation
          -Senate

     President's veto message
           -[Economic Opportunity Amendments]
                 -Elliot L. Richardson
                 -Reaction

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w001]
[Duration: 1m 40s]

     The President’s veto message
          -Effect on conservatives
               -Charles W. Colson’s opinion
               -Patrick J. Buchanan
               -Barry M. Goldwater, Sr. speech
                      -Charles W. Colson’s view
                      -Testimony of John S. Farland [?]
                      -Support of the President

     1972 campaign
          -John N. Ashbrook
               -Campaign
                    -Inability to garner Republican support
                    -Bryce N. Harlow
                          -Samuel L. Devine
                    -Ohio
                    -Barry M. Goldwater, Sr.
                    -Hugh Scott

*****************************************************************

     India-Pakistan War
           -US policy
                -Critics
                      -Democrats
                      -John A. Scali
                           -Press briefing
                      -Marvin L. Kalb
                -Public opinion
                      -Mail count
                           -Telegrams
                      -Network time
                      -Mail count
                           -Compared to George Meany incident

                     -Apathy
                          -State Department reaction

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w002]
[Duration: 1m 33s]

     1972 campaign
          -Edmund S. Muskie
               -Columbia Broadcasting System [CBS] coverage
                     -Campaign film
                     -Robert J. Dole
               -Momentum
               -John V. Tunney
               -Press reaction
               -Liberals
               -Timing of campaign
          -The News Twisters book
               -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman
               -Bestseller
               -Today Show visit by Edith Efron

*****************************************************************

     Thelma C. (“Pat”) Nixon's visit to Sears Roebuck
          -Public reaction
               -Citizens Committee
               -Stores
          -Margeretta (“Happy”) Rockefeller
               -New York Daily News

     Business
          -Attitudes
          -Stock Market
                -Profit-taking
                -Confidence

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w003]
[Duration: 2m 15s]

     1972 campaign
          -Republican National Committee [RNC] meeting
               -Charles W. Colson’s report on response
          -Edmund S. Muskie
          -John V. Tunney
               -Polls
          -Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
               -Possible candidacy
          -Edward W. Brooke
          -John V. Tunney
          -Media
               -Edmund S. Muskie

*****************************************************************

     Administration’s plan on pensions
         -Response
               -Groups
                     -Briefings
                     -Labor
                     -Business
                     -Doctors
                     -Lawyers
                           -American Bar Association [ABA]
                     -Public interest groups
         -Issue
               -Importance
                     -Retirement
         -Mutual Funds
         -Insurance companies
         -Jacob K. Javits

          -Political effects
                -Property taxes
                -Conservatives

     James R. (“Jimmy”) Hoffa parole
          -Colson’s call to Frank E. Fitzsimmons
                -John N. Mitchell

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w004]
[Duration: 2m 28s]

     1972 campaign
          -Building trades
               -Administration position
               -Leaders
                     -George Meany
               -Support
          -Teamsters
               -Strategy
          -Edmund S. Muskie
               -Poll standing
          -Henry M. (“Scoop”) Jackson
          -Hubert H. Humphrey
               -Gaining
               -Threat to Edmund S. Muskie

*****************************************************************

     1972 campaign
          -George S. McGovern
                -Use of Senate Stationery
                     -Campaign contributions
          -Poll
                -Louis Harris

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w005]
[Duration: 51s]

     1972 campaign
          -Louis Harris
               -Poll results
                     -George S. McGovern falling
               -Edmund S. Muskie
                     -Effect in pushing left
               -Hubert H. Humphrey
               -Public perception

*****************************************************************

     1972 campaign
          -Cartoon
               -Edmund S. Muskie and Edward M. Kennedy

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w006]
[Duration: 36s]

     1972 campaign
          -Sindlinger poll
               -Results

*****************************************************************

     Economy

          -General impressions

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[016-076-w007]
[Duration: 5m 29s]

     1972 campaign
          -Louis Harris
                -Edmund S. Muskie
                      -Slight lead
                -Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
                      -Possible candidacy
                -Edmund S. Muskie
                      -Momentum
                      -Poll results
                -Upcoming poll
                      -Gallup poll compared to Harris poll
          -Strategy
                -Play Democrats against each other
                -Unity among Democrats
          -Lawrence F. O’Brien, Jr.
                -Wilbur D. Mills
                      -Tax bill
          -Secret meetings
                -Rowland Evans and Robert D. Novak
                -Summer of 1971
                -Time and Newsweek
                -Lawrence F. O’Brien, Jr.
          -Harris poll
                -Edmund S. Muskie
                      -Popularity
                -Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
                -Hubert H. Humphrey
                -Size of poll
                -Hubert H. Humphrey
                -George S. McGovern
                -Eugene J. McCarthy

               -Henry M. (“Scoop”) Jackson
                    -Gains
                    -Charles W. Colson’s opinion
                    -Un-presidential appearance
               -Edmund S. Muskie
                    -Presidential appearance

*****************************************************************

     George Meany
          -Health
                -President’s concern
          -Jay Lovestone
                -Conversation with Colson
                      -US foreign policy

     Congress
         -William H. Rehnquist
              -Confirmation, December 10, 1971
                   -Javits
                   -William Proxmire
         -James D. Hodgson
              -Emergency strike legislation
                   -Address to Congress
              -Farm Bill
                   -Earl L. Butz

     Kennedy address
         -News summary
         -British House of Commons reaction
         -Chappaquiddick
         -Labour Party
         -Edward R.G. Heath
         -Ireland

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 06/17/2019.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]

[016-076-w008]
[Duration: 1m 39s]

     Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy address
         -Parochial schools
              -Possible political gains
         -Catholic press
              -Catholic Standard
              -Archdiocese

     Catholic support of the President
          -John Cardinal Krol
          -Council of Bishops
          -Possible pickups for the President
                -Strength compared to 1968

*****************************************************************

This transcript was generated automatically by AI and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Do not cite this transcript as authoritative. Consult the Finding Aid above for verified information.

Hello?
Yes, sir, Mr. President.
Everything all right in your front today?
Well, good day.
Busy day.
Isn't that a good day with the tax bill?
Oh, marvelous.
And it'll go through the Senate like Grant took Richmond.
Sherman through Georgia.
No, we don't say that.
Oh, nothing like that.
No, that's a, that's superb.
And I, I, your veto message, I just think is marvelous, eh?
Elliot, awfully hard.
All right.
Well, he's a good soldier.
I don't think we'll have a problem with him.
We checked it out.
Well, I've known him for almost 20 years, and he's damn good that way.
I mean, he'll fight hard, but once he has a decision to make, he stays with it.
He took off yesterday after the critics of the Pakistan-India policy.
I don't think our Democratic friends are in a good way to bear it.
No, I don't.
I don't.
I think we've got to keep the pressure on the way we're doing it.
Kelly's got another backgrounder set up for the column this weekend, and I think that's important because we have to keep knocking down the Marvin Kelp and...
You know, it's an amazing thing.
I asked for a mail count, a telegram count, to see what we got.
The networks have given us 10 minutes to lead every night.
We had, as of yesterday, something like 80, as of last night, something like 80 communications, either telegrams or letters.
I compare that with
And it just shows you that really the public doesn't care.
And they can watch it night after night, and they can see the banner headlines every day for a week, and there's no impact.
It's just one of the, I think there would be a hell of an impact if they thought we were on the verge of getting into it.
But this way, it's so distant.
And damn few people, I'm convinced damn few people read into the fine print with it.
The State Department said this or said that.
I really just don't think it counts a lot much.
uh we've had a fascinating response to mrs mitchell's visit to sears well i know that was big but well the citizens committee has had now communications from all the major chains and they're completely run out of material i think that i guess it's about half the total numbers store outlets in the country have now pledged to carry that logo in their advertising with signs in the window
It's been a phenomenal response.
This is Rockefeller data yesterday.
It's got the front page of the New York Daily News, and it's filled with a carbon copy of Mrs. Nixon's data.
So that's been damn helpful.
Business attitudes are good.
Mr. President and I still keep getting very healthy reports, and I think the market reflects this.
Yeah, the market's holding us very well.
It sure is.
It's withstood a lot.
Well, every day they start out with profit.
They drop five or six points.
Then before the day is over, it bounces right back up.
So I think the confidence factor is coming back in.
Well, we've had a few things that we can sort of keep in the works that I think will help in that regard.
Got a very good result out of your pension plan yesterday.
Is that a good plan?
I've got a next one for you.
And we had in all of the groups that are affected, labor groups, the business groups, the doctors, the lawyers, the ABA, the...
some of the public interest groups.
We haven't had them all in for briefings the last few days.
Reactions to that have just been sensational.
That may be a much bigger issue than it appears on the surface, because you know, you're talking about... Well, it's a pocketbook issue.
It's something that people...
It's very meaningful to people that they have a means of providing for their own retirement.
So it should be great for the change.
Well, that's weird.
We've decided we want to do some work with the mutual funds and insurance companies.
They ought to go out now and start selling.
That's right.
And promote this.
Promote the legislation.
Put the Nixon stamp on it.
The beauty of this is, you know, that plans like this have been kicking around for so long.
Nobody really gets a great deal of the political identification for this.
You now have, so that almost anything that you...
Javits or anybody else now decides to come up with it, it's going to be the next pension.
I really think that is a great, that property taxes are two areas where we really will be able to score in the constituency we need to.
We'll keep the heat on the conservatives, Mr. President, to see if we talk to them.
I made the call just last night, and I returned his call precisely along the lines that we discussed.
I just told him to sit tight until he would come.
He was very appreciative of you.
We have a little bomb that we're dropping on the government this weekend, which we've been using Senate stationery to send out campaign contributions and solicitations.
We kind of planted a little thing that will come off over the weekend that I think will be very helpful.
I'd kind of like at the moment to...
You asked me last week to get something out on where the kids go to school with Kennedy and Muskie.
We got a hell of a good cartoon out, and a good story of Monday, which was picked up, shows Muskie and Kennedy walking side by side into a private school with a caption that says,
that were getting around the country at that time.
I was wrong when I told you this, but if you didn't have any insight, I think we would have said Kennedy or Corsair or Marlin.
And I think that feeling is being reflected.
Maybe I'm deluding myself, but as I read the columns on the economy, there's a lot less of the feeling of uncertainty, and there's a lot more of the emphasis on some of the positive stuff.
Well, I haven't anything further on Meany's condition.
I don't know whether at some point now it's pretty clear that he's ill, but you would want to think about doing something with him.
Well, maybe when he's out of the hospital, wouldn't you?
I told Bluffstone yesterday that he would ask about it constantly.
Obviously, we're very concerned.
No matter how difficult things have been, the President always respects the fact that he has put the country first in foreign policy.
That message we'll get back on.
I'm confident of that.
Looks like we may get Rehnquist tomorrow with us.
Are they going to have a, do you think the folks are going to work?
I just, I don't know.
I think that the best reason that it will is that they all are anxious as hell up there to get out.
That may be the, that might be enough to get it across.
I'm sure he's all right.
He hasn't lost any folks that I...
No, he doesn't.
But it figures.
Javits is a grandstander, you know.
And he waited until the last moment and did it with typical Javits.
And Bruxmar came out for him, which was a surprise.
I think the count is about what we've just said.
I don't think there are any surprises.
Hudson did a very good job for us today up in the Congress.
He really hit them hard on not having passed the emergency strike legislation.
He played the blame for the problems the farmers have on the Congress and said that we may be back on Christmas Day asking for the legislation to end the strike, but they could have avoided the first place that they did.
legislation that you recommended earlier this year.
He really, we stiffened his back, and he really went up there and did a hell of a job.
We'll have both butts in here.
I just keep hitting at that one.
I think that's in the Farmville case is very important.
Oh, he started out in great shape.
Just a marvelous shape.
Back on Kennedy for a moment.
I'm sure it'll be in large numbers, but apparently the latest communication to the British caused a hell of a number, I think.
The British House of Commons erupted at the beginning of a wire, erupted in shouts of rage over Kennedy's remarks.
And apparently some members of the Parliament got up and talked about Chappaquiddick, and some of the Labour members were...
and booing the gutter politics, he's had to step into it.
And he has an incredible way of...
But he's appealing to that Irish.
Yeah, he is.
To the old hardcore Irish, that's the right way to do it.