Nixon White House Tapes — Conversation 021-068 Date: Tuesday, March 14, 1972 at 4:18 PM Participants: Nixon, Richard M. (President); Colson, Charles W. Recording device: White House Telephone Source: https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/021-068 National Archives Catalog: https://catalog.archives.gov/id/646310136 (NAID 646310136) This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (google/gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference. Verify against the audio before citing. [0:00] OPERATOR: Hello. [0:01] NIXON: Hello. [0:03] OPERATOR: Mr. Colson. [0:04] COLSON: Yeah. Yes, sir, Mr. President. [0:05] NIXON: Well, how'd our boy Mitchell do today? [0:08] COLSON: Well, I think he did very, very well. He went up there with— [0:14] NIXON: Of course, he's like a rock of granite. [0:16] COLSON: Yes, he is. And we we tried to get him a little fired up to sort of take the take the bull by the horns and fight back, which he didn't in his statement. His statement was pretty tame. It was pretty restrained and defensive. He just sort of took himself out of the middle of the case. [0:29] NIXON: I know. [0:30] COLSON: On the other hand, as they got into the questioning, then the stuff that we had prepared for him that kind of fired up, he he came out with that that some good and decent men have been smeared in this thing, or I don't know whether he used the word smear, but— [0:42] NIXON: Got to use the word smear. I tell you, every day, somehow. [0:45] COLSON: I've talked to Bob Dole today, and I've just said, "Bob, you you you're going to have to go on that floor every day and talk about smear and—" [0:53] NIXON: Well, the point is, instead of doing the business of the government, this Congress is This is a smear-a-day Congress rather than a law-a-day Congress. [0:58] COLSON: God, that's a great phrase. Yes, sir. [1:03] NIXON: They ought to have a law day. We've got 91 programs up there, and they haven't passed anything. Now goddamn it, this smear-a-day Congress, it'll go down in history. A smear-a-day, rather than law a day. [1:12] COLSON: Smear-a-day Congress. That's a great phrase. Well, let's start We'll start using that one. [1:19] COLSON: Our fellows are getting a little better, Mr. President. We We've gotten— [1:24] NIXON: I noticed they really whipped That Eagleton hit Peter Flanigan. Eagleton's crooked as a dog's hind leg. How the god had damn hate him get into this, I don't know. [1:33] COLSON: Always has been. Of course, he's always had a thing in for Peter. [1:37] NIXON: Well, why doesn't somebody go after him? Is uh Is anybody checking his stuff? [1:42] COLSON: Yes, sir. And, uh, Norris— [1:44] NIXON: Goddamn it, break it on him. [1:45] COLSON: Norris Cotton went after him hard today, and, uh— [1:49] NIXON: Did he? [1:49] COLSON: Yes, sir. They Eagleton put his thing out early, which got into the Star, but, uh, but Cotton was right on the same wire service stories with him, so I think they're going to have to play it. He just rose up indignantly and cut him back. [2:02] COLSON: Uh, and and, uh, our fellows are are They're getting a little more fired up. I must say, we've gotten them some stuff that's pretty good and they're using it. [2:15] NIXON: Right. [2:16] COLSON: And, uh— [2:16] NIXON: What's the news from Denver? [2:19] COLSON: Well, a little bit of intelligence. She has made it very clear that parts of that memo are not are not true. [2:28] NIXON: Well, how'd they do it? How'd they get it? Why'd she sign it then? [2:34] COLSON: Well, we She She doesn't She's She's not answered that question. [2:38] NIXON: I see. [2:38] COLSON: And, when we get the answer to that, we're going to unlock a lot of things. Uh— [2:44] NIXON: If she ever says that, it'll kill them. [2:47] COLSON: Of course. They're done. [2:50] NIXON: If she ever says that the parts— [2:52] COLSON: We found out the problem we had with the typewriter, and and uh— [2:58] NIXON: Right. [2:58] COLSON: I'm awfully glad that that that you told me what you did yesterday because it— [3:03] NIXON: They hadn't checked it. [3:04] COLSON: Well, they haven't been able to fully, and the rea- The reason was that the original— [3:08] NIXON: They haven't got it. [3:09] COLSON: memo uh which the Committee gave to the Justice Department, Justice gave to the FBI. The FBI did their their cursory analysis and— [3:19] NIXON: Well, goddamn it, the FBI can check typewriters. They did it in the Hiss case. [3:24] COLSON: Well, that's right, but they didn't in this case, and I think it's— [3:29] NIXON: Pain in the ass. [3:30] COLSON: Well, what we did better than that, we got the memo away from them last night. [3:34] NIXON: Mm-hmm. [3:35] COLSON: And it's in the hands of the private investigators, and they now are doing a a— [3:44] NIXON: Typewriting check. [3:45] COLSON: typewriting check, and they now come back and say to us very preliminarily, I I probably shouldn't even tell you this, but but very preliminarily, they don't think it was on her typewriter. [3:56] NIXON: Oh. [3:57] COLSON: And, uh— [3:57] NIXON: Oh, they don't? [3:58] COLSON: No, sir. And if that's the case, it ties in with another bit of information this afternoon, which is very significant, and that is that the Evening Star has received an anonymous letter, [4:09] NIXON: Yeah. [4:09] COLSON: although the writer of the letter says that he will make himself known provided they give him some assurance that he will be protected, [4:19] NIXON: Yeah. [4:20] COLSON: in which he details everything that happened in the in the case: [4:26] NIXON: Yeah. [4:26] COLSON: Mrs. Beard knew she was being fired, went to New York, who she saw, who she talked to when she came back, and then she confided to some of her friends she was going to write this memo and give it to Jack Anderson. [4:37] NIXON: Yeah. [4:37] COLSON: And that the letter is so complete in terms of detail that it had to be written by someone on the inside. [4:47] NIXON: Yeah. The Star— [4:48] NIXON: How do you know the Star's got it? [4:49] COLSON: Because they went to ITT and showed it to them for comments. [4:54] NIXON: They did? Good. [4:56] COLSON: And, uh, they may Of course, it could be somebody— [5:04] NIXON: Will they run it? [5:05] COLSON: Well, it It won't They won't run it anonymously, but if they If the author of that letter comes forward, [5:16] NIXON: Yeah. [5:16] COLSON: and if he has the information that he apparently has in as the letter would indicate he has— [5:23] NIXON: Can we, by any way, guess who it is? [5:26] COLSON: Oh, we're working there. Oh, boy, I'll tell you if we If we— [5:30] NIXON: That's a fine— [5:31] NIXON: I have an idea: In terms of an anonymous letter, why not one to Kennedy? It might scare the living bejesus out of him. [5:39] COLSON: Mm. [5:40] NIXON: Saying, "Senator, get off of this. It's It's She's ready to—" You know, you get my point? [5:48] COLSON: Mhm. Mhm. [5:49] COLSON: That's a thought, too. [5:52] COLSON: She's She's ready to tell the whole story and— [5:55] NIXON: Yeah. Well, no, that she isn't. There's somebody There's one night ready to That is, the truth is going to come out and get off of it fast, you've got to do it, or one— She? [6:04] COLSON: Yeah, that's a very good thought. [6:07] NIXON: to protect yourself. "We We just urge you. I I you know, I I don't know about others, I worked for ITT, I'm scared to death that truth, I mean the the the memo is a fake." [6:20] COLSON: Mhm. [6:20] NIXON: "And, uh, you'd better get protect yourself fast. It'll, within the next three few days, it's going to come out." Okay? [6:27] COLSON: That's a That's a damn good idea. [6:28] NIXON: Damn good idea. [6:30] NIXON: Well, the Star, they must have thought that much of it. It must have sounded fairly credible or they wouldn't have asked, uh— [6:41] COLSON: Yes, sir. They, uh The reporter they have is the same fellow who wrote that dastardly story last— [6:48] NIXON: Walters? Yeah. [6:49] COLSON: And he told the ITT fellows that he thinks it's that this has been his theory all along, that it was a trumped-up deal. [6:58] NIXON: Well. [6:58] COLSON: Uh, well, he's a he's a snake, but Clawson I tried to reach Smith Hempstone last night on that, and Smith is on vacation, but gets back Monday. [7:07] NIXON: All right. I don't know. [7:07] COLSON: But Clawson— [7:08] NIXON: Well, at least we gave this— Go ahead. [7:11] COLSON: Well, Clawson called John Cassels, who's their national editor, and just raised holy hell with him. Shouted over the phone at him, and Cassels said, "I agree with you. It was a It was a terrible story. We We apologize," and, uh— And so— [7:26] NIXON: Right. [7:27] NIXON: I had just done something real nice for the Star, as you noticed. You know, that— [7:31] COLSON: Oh, boy, that was a— [7:32] NIXON: fantastic break for them. You know that You noticed that was on all three networks? [7:36] COLSON: Yes, sir. Yes, sir. [7:38] NIXON: That's a hell of a good story. [7:39] NIXON: And, and, and get Crosby Noyes get the byline, too. [7:43] COLSON: Well, we uh I think we'll get something out of the Star. I Smith Hempstone is the fellow who I can appeal to on this. I can't get him until next week, but, uh— [7:54] NIXON: Yeah. [7:55] COLSON: At least At least they know that they overstepped. God, that was a horrible story. [8:01] NIXON: Well, I know. Just a horrible story. [8:04] COLSON: The, uh But we're we're continuing to push, Mr. President, on the— [8:08] NIXON: You know, this thing could turn if we just uh if we could if we ever break If we If Dita Beard, she cracks— [8:12] NIXON: and his his daughter's getting married this weekend. We just figured he had a rough break in those in in that respect, but be sure Be sure his daughter gets a letter. [8:19] COLSON: Yes, sir. I shall do that. McLaren is uh which is quite an extraordinary thing for a sitting judge has agreed to go on Face the Nation this Sunday. [8:29] NIXON: Right. [8:30] COLSON: And our fellows talked to him today, and he is just boiling mad. He regards [8:37] NIXON: Well, God damn it, they're they're He should, you know, look. [8:38] NIXON: I ordered from Haldeman the other day figuring that you fellows are too busy. I said, "Now, for Christ's sakes, get back. Find out. Does any- has anybody checked to see how much IT&T grew during the Kennedy years, how much it grew during the Johnson years?" [8:54] COLSON: Mhm. [8:55] NIXON: See what I mean? [8:56] COLSON: Mhm. [8:56] NIXON: You'll find most of the growth occurred in the eight years before we ever got in. [9:00] COLSON: Oh, hell, that was their big period of growth. [9:02] NIXON: All right, fine. And then we'll say, "What was done? That's when they grew. What the hell happened?" Mc- Get that to McLaren so that he's got some ammunition, you see? Or he certainly knows that. [9:13] COLSON: Oh, he knows that. And and he- Of course, is he really mad? But Yeah. [9:18] NIXON: He knows. Look, McLaren, let's face it. He would have rather appealed the case, I assume, because he's that fe- But he's an honest man. He would He would have resigned before he would have settled the case. [9:28] COLSON: Oh, I don't think I think he felt that he got the best deal he could get. [9:31] NIXON: Right. [9:32] COLSON: It's uh The statement that we worked on last night and got Geneen to issue is a very good statement because what it says, for the first time, and it's now being printed, Times had it this morning, the Star tonight, is that all of this happened to ITT when McLaren came in and changed the antitrust policies in a way that [9:48] NIXON: That's right. [9:49] COLSON: that was uh began to force them to divest, and that's why he came out and sued everybody, because we came in and toughened up the antitrust policies. [9:54] NIXON: That's right. I know. We were the ones that started after conglomerates. Hell, we started the policy. And, frankly, I think it was wrong, but we did. [10:01] COLSON: Well, Oswald Beasen tonight Star, I think it was wrong, too, uh said that he he's got it right up high in the story that uh the the the problem here was that the Nixon administration had uh toughened up the antitrust policy and Geneen came down to try to complain to everybody. And uh [10:16] COLSON: so that we're we're beginning to get out that it that it was a tougher settlement. I think this You see pieces of this, and Geneen will get that in his te- testimony today. He He's [10:26] NIXON: He's scheduled to testify today? [10:28] COLSON: He'll He follows Mitchell. Now I don't The last time I checked, which was a half hour ago [10:31] NIXON: Mitchell still on? [10:32] COLSON: Mitchell was still on a half hour ago. Of course, they He didn't start until 11:30 because the executive session took the first hour. Then they broke for lunch uh, and then they've had a couple of quorum calls and votes during the afternoon, so probably hasn't had a [10:43] NIXON: I understand Eastland said that he's telling the un- unvarnished truth, huh? [10:47] COLSON: I didn't hear that, but that's good. Uh well, John is, you know, John is good that way. He's [10:52] NIXON: He is an honest man. [10:53] COLSON: He sits there very calmly and uh just just lays it right on the line. [10:58] NIXON: Right. [10:58] COLSON: Uh And I think he'll be helpful. I I know Geneen will. The more I think about it uh, he's he's an evangelist uh and he's tough and he uh doesn't mind biting right back at people. I think he'll hold his ground. He's been well briefed. [11:11] NIXON: Yeah. [11:11] COLSON: Uh and is going to make some good points. [11:14] NIXON: Yeah. [11:14] COLSON: Uh Hell, what's what's happened to ITT since that settlement is uh [11:16] NIXON: Yeah. What's the What's the situation with regard to that jerk uh Reinecke? Is he going to testify and Finch and all that? Those are the ones that I just don't Wilson? [11:27] COLSON: Yeah, I know. They want them all. They want Bob Wilson. They want Reinecke. They want uh this fellow Gillenwater. They want uh [11:35] NIXON: Gillen- Oh, well Gillenwater's smart enough, he can handle it. But I just don't Bob Wilson is an utter disaster. [11:39] COLSON: The thing I'm afraid of, Mr. President, uh that worries me in this, is that if I were on the Democratic side, I'd fold those hearings up fast now. I'd figure that I'd smeared everybody publicly and uh if I had any whiff that this thing could turn around, [11:54] NIXON: Yeah. [11:54] COLSON: I'd just clamp them down and and uh confirm Kleindienst after some [11:58] NIXON: Or never confirm him. [12:00] COLSON: the stuff on the floor. Or never confirm him, yeah. That's right. But I would I'd close the damn hearings down because if they've [crosstalk] but [12:04] NIXON: Right. You know when you win your case in the Supreme Court, you stop arguing. [12:08] COLSON: Any court. That's right. [12:09] NIXON: Any court. And they uh Because this thing can just begin to turn with uh with Mitchell, [12:14] COLSON: Yeah. [12:14] NIXON: uh who I suspect will come through very strong uh and who we've programmed to go out and talk to the cameras outside and be very firm in what he says. [12:21] COLSON: Uh No cameras in the room? [12:23] NIXON: No, sir. The The writing press is in there, but they're not allowing TV coverage inside. Eastland apparently doesn't [12:31] COLSON: Well, I'm I agree I think he's right. Yeah, I think he's absolutely right. [12:35] NIXON: I've always opposed it. [12:35] COLSON: But I uh and McLaren also is getting some support on the outside, some other lawyers and uh the Bar Association and professors and that sort of stuff and uh [12:46] NIXON: Well, they can turn this thing, Chuck. They just work hard at it. [12:51] COLSON: Well, we just we just sent up to the Hill, Mr. President, as part of the package of things, all of the comments that were made at the time of the settlement by Business Week and legal publications. [13:01] NIXON: What did they say? [13:02] COLSON: Well, hell, they all said it was the toughest, biggest, most far-reaching uh case in history that uh you know, it was it was supporting what a tremendous antitrust Sure was. [13:10] NIXON: Sure was! No, yes. [13:11] COLSON: And people forget that now, you know. They they they write about dropping the case, but if you go back and look at what they wrote at the time, uh the the the stuff was uh, from our standpoint, [13:24] NIXON: Hit the Hit the Christ out of Kennedy and Johnson that their administrations, that included Bobby Kennedy and it included Ramsey Clark. What did they do all this time? What did they do? See my point? [13:35] COLSON: That's right. [13:36] NIXON: Hit them by name. Ramsey Clark sat by and allowed it to grow. [13:39] COLSON: Yeah, exactly. Uh well, that's That's one of the attacks that we're that we're priming. We did not use that one today for the reason that uh Mitchell's going to dominate the news tonight, but tomorrow [13:52] COLSON: uh our guys are going to get a little rough on Fine. Okay. and uh what the prior administration and what what their involvement was in this thing, which uh which I think will [14:01] NIXON: Well, I bet you're having a lot of fun with it, aren't you? Don't Don't let your people get discouraged, god damn it. They're in a fight. Oh, hell, no! I [laughter] Boy, there was I I remember back in the days of the [14:13] NIXON: Hiss case, poor old Karl Mundt was so scared he came up that year and he left! He left town. That's why I got the credit for breaking the case, cause he left town. Well, I This is a time when men stand up. And you if you stand up, you win. [14:24] COLSON: Of course, I love something like this. I go 24 hours Well, I bet you Clawson loves it. And Clawson loves it. I mean, it's just uh [14:30] NIXON: Yeah. [14:31] COLSON: The trouble with something like this is you get so deep into it, you you don't let other you you uh We've got a lot of other things to keep going around here too. [14:39] NIXON: I know. Don't worry about the other things. Don't worry about Florida and don't worry about primaries or anything like that. Just Well, If we twist this one uh uh well, we just got to bust their ass, right? [14:50] COLSON: One One thing, interesting bit of political uh gossip you might might be interested in, Mr. President. That letter that uh Kennedy's f- friend sent around in New Hampshire [14:59] NIXON: Right. [14:59] NIXON: Yeah. [15:00] COLSON: uh, he had 500 replies, and uh I have 150 of them that uh I've obtained. Of the 150, uh four are positive. [15:09] NIXON: All right. [15:10] COLSON: Uh The other 146 range from hostile to violent, [15:15] NIXON: I see. [15:15] COLSON: uh from people who received it and wrote across the face of it "bullshit" and sent it back to this fellow who originated it. [15:23] NIXON: Well, he may not have this Well Despite the polls, he may not have as much as we think. [15:28] COLSON: I'll I think this is what Lou Harris said, that that man He brings He brings a violent reaction, you know. He One way or the other, yeah. One way or the other, but the the letters uh Right. Good. are very interesting. [15:37] COLSON: Oh, it's fascinating, because it shows that uh that he may not have He His candidacy may not be uh the big ace in the hole that Right. [15:45] COLSON: a lot of the columnists say it is, but [15:48] COLSON: I just thought you'd be interested. Right. They they've gotten that kind of reaction from it. Sure. that we've picked up. [15:53] NIXON: Well, But we'll uh Good luck. Well, anyway, keep keep keep after that typewriter business. I know there's something There's gold in those hills. I bet you the typewriter may break the case. [16:02] COLSON: Well, I'm I'm counting on it, and uh now we've got the pros really in it. Uh by tonight, late, or Mhm. tomorrow noon, they tell us at the outside, they're going to give us a a very [16:12] NIXON: Right. Good. [16:13] COLSON: clear fix on it, and maybe she'll talk. And that by the Well, of course, that'll force her hand if we [16:17] NIXON: Yeah. [16:17] COLSON: if we have this. [16:19] NIXON: Right. [16:19] COLSON: Then we know we can get her to talk. [16:21] NIXON: Okay. [16:22] COLSON: Thank you, Mr. President.