Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 37 › Conversation 037-116

Nixon, Ziegler & Dean on Common Cause lawsuit and executive privilege

Thursday, March 15, 1973 · 9:20 AM–10:05 AM ET · White House Telephone · 7 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Ziegler, Ronald L.; Dean, John W., IIIConversation037-116 on Tape 37StartThursday, March 15, 1973 at 9:20 AMEndThursday, March 15, 1973 at 10:05 AMRecording deviceWhite House TelephoneSourceNixon Library record for 037-116 ↗ · National Archives Catalog, NAID 417195365 ↗

President Nixon, John Dean, and Ron Ziegler discussed the strategy for responding to a subpoena issued to Dean in a Common Cause civil suit. They debated the legal basis for Dean refusing to testify, particularly if the questions related to his role as President's counsel versus his personal capacity. The conversation also touched upon precedents involving congressional aides and White House staff depositions, with a focus on distinguishing between questions related to official functions and those that are not. A potential speech by Senator Ervin on executive privilege was also noted as being canceled.

Download MP3 · 2.9 MB

On March 15, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, Ronald L. Ziegler, and John W. Dean, III talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 9:20 am and 10:05 am. The White House Telephone taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 037-116 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 37-116

Date: March 15, 1973
Time: Unknown between 9:22 am and 10:05 am
Location: White House Telephone

Ronald L. Ziegler talked with John W. Dean, III. The President can be heard in the background.

       Preparation for press briefing
              -Subpoena of Dean in Common Cause suit
                      -Dean's response
                      -Reason for subpoena
                               -Dean as President's counsel
              -Subpoenas of Congressional aides
                      -Thomas J. Dodd
                      -Daniel Brewster
                      -Clark R. Mollenhoff's response
              -White House staff depositions in civil suits
                      -Precedents
                              -Charles W. Colson
                                      -Type of questions
              -Mollenhoff
                      -Congressional aides' immunity
              -Colson's deposition
                      -Judicial executive privilege
                      -Legislative executive privilege
                                             - 83 -

                           NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY

                            -Differences
                    -Reasons for appearance
                            -E. Howard Hunt, Jr.
              -Samuel J. Ervin, Jr.
                    -Senate committee
                            -Colson's deposition
                    -Speech on executive privilege

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).

Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.

Operator[unintelligible] please.
ZieglerThank you.
OperatorMr. Dean.
ZieglerJohn.
ZieglerWhat is your thinking this morning on how to handle a question regarding your subpoena before the civil suit, Common Cause suit?
DeanWho is it? For the President?
DeanWell say, first of all, I haven't been informed that Mr. Dean has never been served.
ZieglerYou have not You have not been served yet.
DeanAnd all we have is press speculation or just all we have is press statement that was gonna happen, and we
ZieglerSo what if you are served, John?
DeanIf I am served, uh we'll have to find out why they're Mr. Dean doesn't know why they're calling him. Uh, doesn't know the relevancy of his testimony, what capacity they're calling him in.
ZieglerNo, but, John, but even if you don't know why they're serving, let let's just suppose they do serve you. Constitutional standpoint, what
DeanWell, if they're serving me for something that's unrelated to my capacity as counsel to the President, and that's what really the judgment will be,
Deanif you can separate my hats.
DeanUh
ZieglerIn other words, if you are called to testify in an area unrelated to your capacity as counsel to the President, then you would have to go.
DeanThat's right.
ZieglerBut if you were called testify on a matter related to your capacity as counsel, then you would,
Zieglerunder separation of power, not go.
DeanThat's correct.
ZieglerAnd then there would be a test on that, I suppose.
DeanThat is correct. A court case test on that.
DeanThat's right.
ZieglerOkay, but you have not been served, and you and have no idea
DeanI've not been served, and I think that's the way to leave it right now. I don't think the President ought to get into it until we get well-postured on which position it falls in.
ZieglerRight.
DeanSay that, uh, "Gentlemen, I understand from Mr. Dean that he has not been served."
ZieglerMhm.
DeanAnd just knock it right "What if is it?" "Well, gentlemen, he hasn't been served. He doesn't know what he's going to be served about. He doesn't know the nature [snort] privy to the the reasons for calling him, even. So"
ZieglerDidn't they say in their press release what you were being, though?
DeanNo, I've been unable to find out why they want me.
ZieglerSo you don't know why they want you. Okay.
ZieglerNow did you check to see if in in the history to a congressman or senator, administrative assistant or anyone has ever been called to appear before
Zieglera a a court?
DeanYeah. Yeah.
ZieglerWho, and what?
DeanThe, uh The aides to, uh, Dodd.
DeanDodd's aides, uh, and, uh, Brewster's.
ZieglerBrewster.
DeanYeah.
DeanI would stay out of that analogy to that, frankly, Ziegler.
ZieglerRight.
DeanAnd Mollenhoff, uh, would just come in with 10 ft 10 ft uh deep on that. He's real hot on that one. Using that analogy.
ZieglerHaven't members of the White House staff given depositions in civil suits?
DeanColson. Yes, they have.
ZieglerHow do we distinguish?
DeanWell, they didn't go into [coughs] The The questions that were asked, uh, Mr. Colson did not relate in any way to, uh, his his official functions. They were as Colson, the man.
ZieglerDid not relate to official functions.
DeanMhm.
ZieglerYeah, but, John-
DeanI know it's tough. We got a tough situation with Colson having given that deposition.
DeanHe wanted to.
ZieglerYes.
ZieglerNow tell me: What What is Mollenhoff What's his analogy?
DeanWho Who's in your office? No, I'm here. That's the problem.
DeanUh, Mollenhoff's does not like the use of the analogy that congressional aides
Zieglerare immune from any investigative by the executive branch.
DeanRight.
DeanMhm.
DeanAnd he's got a half a point, and he's so adamant it's not worth getting into the argument with him in a press conference. So
ZieglerAll right. We and we understand that.
DeanYeah.
DeanUh Now on Colson's exception of Colson,
Deanin a civil suit,
Deanuh, so there is a tremendous difference between judicial executive privilege and, uh, legislative executive privilege, which there is.
DeanThere's different case law, there's different precedents, and the whole thing.
DeanColson wanted to appear in this deposition.
DeanUh it was very early in the in the, uh, political fray, and no one objected to him appearing.
ZieglerThe point is it did not relate to his function Colson's case did not relate to his function here at the White House, right?
DeanThat's correct.
DeanWho did relate to it? Well Well, they asked him questions about Howard Hunt.
DeanAnd he tried to establish that Howard Hunt had never worked for him.
ZieglerMhm.
DeanI.e., it didn't relate to his functions.
ZieglerMhm.
ZieglerWell, wouldn't wouldn't the, uh, Ervin Committee hearing be asking about matters that don't relate to their
Zieglertheir function?
DeanThe question is how if they
Deanhow will they draw the line? When they get a If they get a Chuck Colson up there, sure they won't they wouldn't stop with those two or three questions. In the In his deposition, his counsel interposed and didn't let him answer those questions.
ZieglerSure.
ZieglerSo he responded only to information relating to Hunt.
DeanThat's right.
ZieglerMhm.
ZieglerOkay.
DeanApparently, Sam Ervin was going to give a speech this morning that they were heralding as a major statement on executive privilege, but I just got a notice back that he's not giving it.
DeanSo it's just to wipe out.
ZieglerMhm.
DeanMhm.
DeanSo if you hear the same thing, just cancel it.
ZieglerOkay, good. Okay, fine. Bye.
  • 037-115 9:20 AM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at 9:20 am.
  • 416-033 9:20 AM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at 9:20 am.
  • 416-034 9:22 AM · 25 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 9:22 am to 10:05 am.
  • 416-035 10:39 AM · 14 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Henry A. Kissinger met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 10:39 am to 10:55 am.
  • 880-001 11:16 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the Oval Office of the White House from 11:16 am to 11:19 am.
  • 880-002 11:19 AM · 26 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 11:19 am and 11:22 am.
  • 880-025 11:22 AM · 37 sec — unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 11:22 am and 11:58 am.
  • 880-003 11:58 AM · 6 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the Oval Office of the White House from 11:58 am to 12:05 pm.

Conversation 037-116, March 15, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417195365). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/037-116 (accessed November 16, 2026).