Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 37 › Conversation 037-176

Nixon, Dean & Sanchez on Senate hearings and Patrick Gray

Tuesday, March 20, 1973 · 7:29 PM–7:43 PM ET · White House Telephone · 14 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Dean, John W., III; Sanchez, ManoloConversation037-176 on Tape 37StartTuesday, March 20, 1973 at 7:29 PMEndTuesday, March 20, 1973 at 7:43 PMRecording deviceWhite House TelephoneSourceNixon Library record for 037-176 ↗ · National Archives Catalog, NAID 417195481 ↗

President Nixon and John Dean discussed the ongoing Senate Watergate hearings, focusing on the difficulties faced by acting FBI Director Patrick Gray and the potential confirmation vote. They also reviewed new witnesses being subpoenaed, including individuals linked to the Finance Committee and Thomas Lombard, and strategized on how to respond to inquiries. Dean proposed a meeting with Nixon to present a comprehensive overview of the investigation's implications, and they discussed the possibility of a limited, general statement to reassure the public and Congress without revealing sensitive details.

Download MP3 · 5.8 MB

On March 20, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, John W. Dean, III, and Manolo Sanchez talked on the telephone from 7:29 pm to 7:43 pm. The White House Telephone taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 037-176 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 37-176

Date: March 20, 1973
Time: 7:29 pm-7:43 pm
Location: White House Telephone

The President talked with John W. Dean, III.

[Transcripts of the following conversation may be found in RG 460, Box 173, pp. 1-17; SRPC,
pp. 161-169 (1-9); SI, Bk. III, pt. 2, pp. 980-87 (161-168, 1-8).]

[See Conversation No. 422-5A]

       Senate hearings
              -Thomas E. Bishop
              -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI]

[Transcription resumes]

[End of transcribed portion]

The President conferred with Manolo Sanchez at an unknown time.

       Instructions
               -Schedule book

[End of conferral]
                                               - 123 -

                                NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY

[See Conversation No. 422-5B]

[Transcription resumes]

[End of transcribed portion.]

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).

Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.

DeanHello?
NixonYes, sir.
NixonYou're having rather long days these days, aren't you?
DeanI guess we all have.
NixonYeah.
DeanAnd they will continue to be longer.
NixonWhat happened today on the Senate? Anything?
DeanWell, I understand that Gray took a little beating up there today.
DeanHe was, the approach they're working is that he's been an abandoned man.
NixonOh, boy.
DeanEvidenced by the fact that Kleindienst would not let him, excuse me, insert things in the record that he desired to insert in the record, and that it was quite clear that he has been left hanging by being countermanded by you and
NixonWell, you know, in a sense I didn't countermand him at all. I said, fine.
DeanI know, but this is the theme they're playing.
NixonFine.
DeanThey're trying to play.
NixonThis is in the committee or on the floor?
DeanIt's in the committee.
NixonOpen or executive?
DeanThis was an open session.
NixonYeah.
DeanThey are They subpoenaed three additional witnesses: Tom Bishop, who is a former FBI man who was canned by Gray, who used to run their PR section.
NixonGood.
DeanAnd trying to pull him in there on sour grapes and
NixonGood. Well, that wouldn't bother me. Does it bother you?
DeanNo, and it sets the precedent for this fellow Sullivan going up.
NixonRight.
DeanWhich is interesting.
NixonYeah.
DeanThen, uh Well, and the fellow, the week before, isn't Gurney a member of that committee?
DeanGurney is.
NixonHe could just ask for Sullivan. Why not? How would that be?
DeanThat wouldn't be bad at all.
NixonYou don't have Sullivan's report yet?
DeanNo, Sullivan told me he's out of town, he said he will have it for me tomorrow, and he will skip a meeting he has in the morning to make sure he gets it delivered over to me.
NixonJust a second. [calling] Manolo?
Sanchez[unintelligible]
Nixonthe schedule book, too. The brown one. That's right. You can leave that there. That's fine.
NixonYeah, go ahead.
DeanSo, he will have it over to me tomorrow, and I said, "I absolutely have to have it tomorrow, there just can't be any further deadline, the time is here to look and see what you've got." And he said, "Well, I think I've got good stuff. I think it's supportable,
Deandocumentable."
DeanAnd I said, "Well, Bill, I want to see it just as quickly as possible tomorrow morning." He said it would be over.
NixonGood.
DeanThe other witness they've now subpoenaed, or two other witnesses, is this Hoback girl from the Re-election Committee, who says that she was interrogated by committee staff and counsel as a result of her confidential
Deaninterviews with the FBI,
Deanalleging that that had been leaked by me to them, and, of course, that was not That's not true. not true.
DeanAnd the other fellow they're calling is a fellow by the name of Thomas Lombard,
Deanwho they're trying to establish a link between Liddy and Dean on that one.
DeanLombard did volunteer work for me in my office,
Deanand did volunteer work for Liddy.
DeanAnd at one time he saw Liddy in my office. Big deal.
DeanAnd it's purely campaign,
Deanyou know.
NixonWell, is that what Lombard will testify to, or will he testify to that?
DeanNo, that's what He's written a very lengthy letter to the committee asking declining to testify, originally, and saying, "This is all I'd have to say, it's obviously not relevant. I know nothing of a Dean and Liddy connection."
NixonYeah, right.
NixonWell, that's not bad then. Maybe he'll make a pretty good witness.
DeanHe might.
NixonHow about the Hoback girl?
DeanHoback girl should be broken down. She should come out in tears as a result of the fact she's virtually lying about what's saying.
NixonAnd are our people will be armed to
NixonAre you I mean do our people know what to ask her?
DeanYes, they do.
DeanYes, they do.
NixonMhm.
NixonWhy's she doing it? Do we know?
DeanShe, uh, disgruntled.
NixonA lot of money?
DeanDisgruntled, she's been fairly disgruntled all along. She's a she's a Democrat that worked over there in the Finance Committee, and she professes a personal loyalty to Maury Stans, but that's about the extent of it.
DeanAny particular loyalty.
NixonYeah.
DeanNobody can figure out how she got in there.
DeanSo, all told, I'm told that today was another bad day for Gray, and not much of a
Dean[unintelligible] but they're taking a whip check out on the floor to see what the
NixonYeah.
Deanis out there. Yeah, should have that tomorrow morning.
NixonWhat's your feeling, though, John, about Gray? Uh, Aren't you aren't you, I just feel comfortable letting him go down?
DeanI don't I don't.
NixonWhat's he want? I mean, we can we can put some pressures on, and I I just wonder.
DeanI don't think it's worth saving, sir. I really don't.
NixonWell, that's my point. Isn't it really a case if they want to if they want to make him the They're going to make him the martyr.
DeanThat's right.
NixonDo you agree or not? Or if you feel differently, tell me. No.
DeanI would I would agree that they're trying to make him a martyr. I think that Pat Gray has been so damaged by these hearings that he couldn't be the head of the bureau. It will be very difficult for him to be the head of the bureau.
NixonThat's right.
DeanIt'll take a year or two years for him to recover.
NixonThat's right.
DeanIt's sort of like Vic Taft when he decided to withdraw, even from consideration for the court, knowing that he'd never be an effective justice for years.
NixonThat's right.
NixonThe thing is, too, that Gray, though, has got to make up his mind on that pretty soon, don't you think so?
DeanI was, you know, I thought, [unintelligible]
NixonIn fact, I was thinking he ought to do it fairly soon.
DeanMhm.
NixonExcuse me, what were you going to say?
DeanNo, I was I was thinking he might call today very easily and say, you know, at least make a pro forma gesture to see if someone over there, you know, if you were interested.
NixonMhm.
NixonNow, what's Kleindienst's view of the whole thing now? Is he staying a mile away?
DeanDick tonight, so I don't know what his reading is on the recent activity.
NixonYeah.
DeanIt uh It might be better to let it just die in committee
NixonYeah.
Deanand not get it out of there. Apparently there's a it's tied up at seven-seven now
Deanon the votes.
NixonWell, they had seven to seven in the committee?
DeanThat's right.
DeanAnd, uh, McClellan and Eastland, uh, are hanging and knowing not knowing which way McClellan and Mathias are hanging in the balance.
DeanThey suspect we could probably get McClellan's vote and lose Mathias's.
NixonBe eight to eight, huh? Right.
DeanThat'll tie it up, and that will not confirm it. It won't get it out.
NixonYeah.
DeanWell, if you got an eight-
NixonHuh, McClellan surprises me. God, he knows better than this.
DeanHe's he's turned a little funny recently. He's generally, you know, pretty much of a soldier on
Nixondo that. That's rather interesting, isn't it? Something ought to be made of that.
DeanUnless they get, they're taking more evidence on the obvious, they were this the other two witnesses.
NixonUh, ought to just be more. Yeah.
DeanSame stuff.
DeanI had a conversation with John Ehrlichman this afternoon before he came down to visit with you.
DeanAnd I think that one thing we have to continually do, and particularly right now, is to examine the broadest, broadest implications of this whole thing, and, you know, maybe 30 minutes of just
Deanmy recitation to you of the facts, so that you operate from the same facts that everybody else has.
NixonRight.
DeanAnd I don't think we've we've never really done that. It's been sort of bits and pieces, just paint the whole picture for you, the soft spots, the the potential problem areas,
NixonMm-hmm.
Deanand the like, so that you know, when you when you make judgments, you'll
NixonYeah.
Deanhave all that information that
NixonWould you like to do that, when?
DeanI would think whenever it's convenient for you, sir. I'm I would I'd like to sort of draw all my thoughts together and have a, you know, just make some notes to myself so I didn't
NixonWould you could do it, could you do it, could you do it tomorrow?
DeanYes, sir.
NixonYes, sir.
DeanMm-hmm.
NixonWell, then we could probably do it, say, around 10:00.
DeanThat would be fine, sir.
NixonFine.
NixonDo you just want to do it alone, or anybody else there?
DeanI think I think just
NixonBetter with nobody else there, isn't it?
DeanAbsolutely. I think that's the best way.
NixonAnybody else you, [laughs] they're all parties and interests, virtually.
DeanThat's right.
NixonRight. Fine. The other thing I was going to say is this, that
DeanFine.
Nixonjust for your own thinking, I don't want to see though, although you and Dick, I guess, have still worked on your letter and all that sort of thing,
DeanWe are, and [laughter] we're coming away as the more we work on it, the more questions we see that
NixonYou don't want to answer.
Deanare creating problems by answering.
NixonYeah.
NixonAnd so and so, you're coming up, then, with the idea of just a stonewall then. Is that right?
DeanThat's right.
NixonIs that what you come down with?
DeanA stonewall with lots of noises that we're always willing to cooperate, but no one's asking us for anything to
NixonAnd they never will, either. But there's no way that you could make even a
DeanRight.
Nixongeneral statement that I could You understand what I'm See, for example, I was even thinking if you could even
DeanI think I think we could
Nixontalk to the Cabinet, to the leaders, you know. Just you, just orally say, "I've looked into this, and this is that." Period. You know, so that people get sort of a feeling that, you know, your own people have got to be reassured.
DeanMm-hmm.
NixonCould you do that?
DeanWell, I think I can, but I don't think you'd want to make that decision until we have about a, you know
NixonNo, I want to know. I want to know where all the bodies are, first.
DeanRight, and then once you decide after that,
NixonYeah.
Deanwe can program it any way you want to fix it.
NixonYeah, because I I think, for example, you could do orally, for example, even if you don't want to make the written statement, you could do orally with the Cabinet, and the leaders, and the rest. Lay it all out, say, "Look, I've" So I would not be present, you just lay it all out, and I'll just, see what I mean? That's one thing. The other thing is that I do think there is something to be said for
DeanMm-hmm.
Nixonjust not maybe this complete answer to this fellow, but maybe just a written statement to me, [laughter] saying, "My conclusions are this: bing, bing, bing, bing.
DeanMm-hmm.
NixonEven that's a possibility. So, what I mean is, we need something to answer somebody, answer things, you know, to say that what are you basing this on? You could say, "Well, I've my Counsel has advised me that." Is that possible, or not, or?
DeanWell, you know, there's that, and there is always
Deanthe FBI report that we have probably not relied upon enough,
NixonRight.
Deanthat there is not one scintilla of evidence.
NixonI know. But I mean, can't you say that? Or do you want to put it out?
DeanIt could be said, and it's something we haven't really emphasized. Pat Gray is the only person that has said it, and it's really never gotten picked up.
NixonHow would you do it then? What I mean is, isn't that something that you could say, I don't want to publish the FBI report?
DeanOh, no. Oh, no, because then it violated our own, our strictures we're trying to place on it, right.
NixonRight. But what, what, but you could say, "I I have this, and this is that." Fine.
DeanFine.
NixonSee, what I'm getting at is if apart from a statement to the committee, or anything else, you just make a statement to me that we can use, you know, for internal purposes and to answer and so forth.
DeanAs we did when you back in August made the statement that's been pulled and parsed on and
NixonThat's right. You've got to, you've got to have something where
Deanthrough all the things.
Nixonwhere it doesn't appear that I'm just doing this, you know, just in a saying, "To hell with the Congress, and to hell with the people. We're not going to tell you anything because of executive privilege." That they don't understand, but if you say, "No, we're willing to cooperate,
Nixonand he's made a complete, you've made a complete statement," see, but make it very incomplete. See, that's what I mean.
DeanRight.
NixonI don't want to too much in chapter and verse, as you did in your in your letter.
DeanRight.
NixonI just want just a general
DeanGeneral, right.
DeanLet me
NixonJust try just something general that you've that that like, "I have checked into this matter. I can say categorically, based on my investigation, the following: Mr. Haldeman has not not involved, or this, and that, and the other thing. Mr. Colson did not do this, and Mr. So-and-So did not do this,
Nixonand Mr. Blank did not do this, and da-da-da-da-da-da." Right down the line, see?
  • 037-173 7:10 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 7:10 pm and 7:24 pm.
  • 037-174 7:24 PM · 3 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Julie Nixon Eisenhower talked on the telephone from 7:24 pm to 7:26 pm.
  • 422-003 7:24 PM · 3 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Julie Nixon Eisenhower met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 7:24 pm to 7:26 pm.
  • 037-175 7:26 PM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 7:26 pm and 7:29 pm.
  • 422-004 7:26 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 7:26 pm and 7:29 pm.
  • 422-034 7:26 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 7:26 pm and 7:29 pm.
  • 422-005 7:29 PM · 14 min — President Richard M. Nixon, John W. Dean, III, and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 7:29 pm to 7:43 pm.
  • 037-177 7:43 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 7:43 pm and 7:48 pm.

Conversation 037-176, March 20, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417195481). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/037-176 (accessed November 16, 2026).