Conversation 143-009

TapeTape 143StartSunday, September 17, 1972 at 1:53 PMEndSunday, September 17, 1972 at 2:22 PMParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President);  Colson, Charles W.Recording deviceCamp David Study Table

On September 17, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon and Charles W. Colson talked on the telephone at Camp David from 1:53 pm to 2:22 pm. The Camp David Study Table taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 143-009 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 143-9

Date: September 17, 1972
Time: 1:53 pm -2:22 pm
Location: Camp David Study Table

The President talked with Charles W. Colson.

[See Conversation No. 211-22]

       Greetings
       Colson's schedule
              -Pool

                                       (rev. Feb-24)

       Colson's residence location
              -Commuting time
                      -Location
       -Comparison to Georgetown

Georgetown
      -Driving through Georgetown
             -Analysis
                    -Secret Service route
             -Comparison to Harvard Square, Massachusetts

Public relations efforts
        -Press stories
                -Washington Star and Washington Post
                        -George S McGovern and Watergate issue
                                -Front page
                                -New York Times
        -McGovern
                -Statement on Watergate
                        -Challenge by press reporter
                -Colson's conversation with Kenneth W. Clawson and Richard A. Moore
                        -Response by Justice Department on Watergate
                                -Henry E. Peterson
        -McGovern and Watergate statement
                -Colson's analysis
                        -Idea of dragging the issue out
                        -Choosing an individual to speak out against
                         McGovern
                                -Richard G. Kleindienst
                -Time duration of the issue
                        -Possible reactions
        -McGovern
                -Colson's analysis
                        -Television news
                                -Appearance
                                        -Results in polls
                -Image
                -Louis P. Harris poll results from McGovern's statement on Watergate
                        -Public opinion
        -Watergate issue
                -Conduct of Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI]

                                         (rev. Feb-24)

            -Investigation
                    -Respect by the general public
            -Grand jury
                    -McGovern's statement
                           -Wait and see attitude by administration
       -McGovern
            -Statement on wage and price controls and food prices

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 07/16/2018.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal returnable]
[143-009-w001]
[Duration: 24m 13s]

       1972 campaign
              -Statement on defense
                     -Response by administration
                             -Meeting between John D. Ehrlichman and Charles W. Colson
                             -Melvin R. Laird on Meet the Press
                             -Statements by Vice President and John B. Connally
              -Main issues
                     -Strategy by administration
                             -Focus on issues

Julie Nixon Eisenhower conferred with the President at an unknown time after 1:53 p.m.

       Julie Nixon Eisenhower's schedule

       [See conversation no. 211-22]

       [End of conferral]

       1972 campaign
              -Main issues
                     -Press coverage
              -George S. McGovern
                     -Reactions to surrogates
                     -Coordinated strategy

                         (rev. Feb-24)

-Wage price issue
        -Campaign issue against George S. McGovern
        -Hobart Rowen of the Washington Post
               -Question of reaction to John D. Ehrlichman's letter
        -Arthur F. Burns
        -George P. Shultz
               -Statements made on wage price issue
        -Congressmen
               -Statements
        -Gallup poll
               -Results
-Utility workers issue
        -Media coverage
               -Columbia Broadcasting System [CBS]
               -National Broadcasting Company [NBC]
                        -Results for administration
        -Newspaper coverage
        -Thomas W. (“Teddy”) Gleason
        -John F. Griner
        -Joseph P. Tonelli
        -American Federation of Labor-Congress of Industrial Organizations
        [AFL-CIO] unions
               -Building trades
                        -Deadline
               -Union endorsements
               -Building trades
                        -Support of the President
-R. Sargent Shriver
        -Financial statement
               -Eunice (Kennedy) Shriver
               -John D. Ehrlichman
-George S. McGovern
        -Financial statement
               -Idea of updating
        -Trust
               -Comparison to Vice President
        -Updating financial statement
               -Clark MacGregor's statement
                        -Press story
                        -Trust
                        -Inclusion of Eunice (Kennedy) Shriver

                       (rev. Feb-24)

      -Trust
               -Kennedy children
       -Charles W. Colson's analysis
               -Problems
                      -United Auto Workers [UAW] employee, Ted Grones
                               -Response
                               -Reasons
               -Milwaukee, Wisconsin
                      -Interview
                               -Response
                                      -Hanoi
               -Types of response
-Small personal impromptu interviews by candidates
       -Presence of press reporters
       -Analysis
               -Potential problems
                      -Responses
-George S. McGovern’s campaign
       -Charles W. Colson's analysis
               -Type of operation
-The President's campaign
       -Strategy
       -Canvassing
               -Results
       -Columbia Broadcasting System [CBS] coverage
               -Map showing location of principal surrogates
       -Phone calls
       -Thelma C. (Ryan) (“Pat”) Nixon
       -Surrogate issue
               -Results for the President's campaign
                      -Support for the President
-George S. McGovern’s campaign
       -Reactions to surrogates
       -Idea of underdog reactions
-Hubert H. Humphrey
-Harry S Truman
       -Type of campaign
-Hubert H. Humphrey
       -Reactions
               -Comparison to George S. McGovern
-Survey of general atmosphere of campaign

                          (rev. Feb-24)

       -Raymond W. Apple of the New York Times
               -Boston, Massachusetts
       -Interview
               -Results of campaign
                       -The President winning state of Massachusetts
               -Michael Harrington
                       -Reactions to George S. McGovern’s campaign
               -Irish section of Dorchester
                       -George S. McGovern vs. the President
                               -Voting decision on candidates since the primaries
                                       -Reason for article
       -Raymond W. Apple of the New York Times
               -Assignment of reporting on George S. McGovern’s campaign
                       -Actual situation of George S. McGovern support
                               -Harvard Square
                               -Blue collar workers
                                       -Lynn, Massachusetts
                                       -Salem, Massachusetts
       -Survey of Catholics by New York Times
               -[Daniel] Yankelovich poll
               -Connecticut, New York and New Jersey
               -Support for the President vs support for George S. McGovern
                               -Specific issues such as abortion
-New York Times
       -Stories on support of George S. McGovern
               -Editorial on Watergate and one story
                       -Importance of editorials
       -Previous campaigns
               -1968 election
                       -Attacks on Spiro T. Agnew
       -Type of reporting and upcoming treatment by administration
       -Abram J. Chayes
               -Kenneth W. Clawson and Max Frankel of New York Times
                       -Advice to Abram J. Chayes
       -Max Frankel
               -President’s opinion of Max Frankel
       -Conversation between Charles W. Colson and Max Frankel
       -Henry A. Kissinger and Max Frankel
-Attendance by Charles W. Colson at Howard K. Smith's for dinner
       -[David] Kenneth Rush
               -Speech

                         (rev. Feb-24)

                       -Press coverage
-Speech by John B. Connally
       -Press coverage
       -Type of speech
       -Circulation of speech
               -Effect on Democrats and editorial writers
-George S. McGovern’s campaign
       -Idea of George S. McGovern vs George S. McGovern
               -Columns
               -Cartoons
                       -Monday magazine
-John B. Connally
       -Support for the President
               -National television
               -Television commercial
               -Speech
                       -Type of speech
-Fund raising reports on George S. McGovern
       -The Evening Star
       -Question on the filing of reports
               -Contributions of money to George S. McGovern
                       -Amount
       -Report of various sources of income
               -Dr. Alexander Zaffaroni
                       -Uruguay
               -Jay Lovestone's conversation with Charles W. Colson
       -Fund raising issue for George S. McGovern’s campaign
               -Administration's response
                       -Murray M. Chotiner
               -Pattern of fund raising sources
                       -Charles W. Colson's analysis
                       -Neal Freeman
                               -Reporters in Philadelphia
       -George S. McGovern’s money
               -Speculation as to amount and source
                       -Possible response by George Meany
                               -Speech to the steel workers
                               -Charles W. Colson's and Jay Lovestone
                                      -Dr. Alexander Zaffaroni
                               -George Meany's opinion on money
                               -Speech on communism

                                      (rev. Feb-24)

                                                 -Possible press coverage
                                                 -Effect for administration
             -Wage-price issue
                    -Administration's campaign position
                            -George S. McGovern’s standing
                                    -Response from public
                                    -Poll results
                                            -The President's vs George S. McGovern’s position
             -Kenneth W. Clawson
                    -Reports from Detroit
                            -George S. McGovern’s standing with rally audience
             -Anti-war rallies
                    -Type of people attending
             -Vice President Spiro T. Agnew
                    -Speeches against George S. McGovern
                            -Credibility
                            -Welfare
                            -Idea of permissiveness
                                    -Marijuana
                                    -Amnesty
             -Mayor Frank L. Rizzo
                    -George S. McGovern’s supporters
                            -Jerry Rubin
                            -Abbie Hoffman
                            -W. Ramsey Clark
                            -Jane Fonda
                            -Pierre Salinger
                            -Types of people

      The President's schedule

*****************************************************************

This transcript was generated automatically by AI and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Do not cite this transcript as authoritative. Consult the Finding Aid above for verified information.

Good afternoon, Mr. President.
Are you having a quiet Sunday?
Yes, sir.
Just sitting out in the sun and swimming in the pool.
You have a pool in your backyard?
Yes, sir.
That's good.
It's a lifesaver.
Where do you live?
It's in McLean, Mr. President.
How long does it take to get out there?
About 15 minutes.
Is that all?
Yes, sir.
They must know it's a freeway, that's right.
And it's just over the bridge, but...
So it gets close to the district, but it's...
It must be a good choice.
Oh, it's lovely.
So much better than living in that miserable Georgetown.
Oh, I hate that.
All those rats and...
I don't even like to drive through Georgetown.
Oh, God, you know, I think the Secret Service is afraid to go through there.
Well, I don't blame them.
It's a crummy place.
It reminds me of Harvard Square in Massachusetts, which I also dislike.
Yeah, yeah.
Well, how's the... How's the...
Well, I think very good, Mr. President.
I was pleased that neither the Star nor the Post played the McGovern charge on the Watergate as page one.
The Times did.
I understand that around the country it was not a page one story.
And it was almost a predictable thing, I guess.
What he said?
Yeah.
Was exactly what I was going to say.
I think somebody ought to have slept and said, now, look, either put up or shut up.
Well, one of the reporters, an interesting thing, one of the reporters said to him, what evidence do you have of that?
And he finally backed down and said, well, I have no evidence, but it's obvious they haven't answered all the questions, so I'm going to keep pounding them through this campaign until they do.
I talked to Clawson and Dick Moore and others about it today.
We got the Justice Department to put a response out immediately.
That was good.
Peterson, I saw that.
Right.
I think what my own judgment on it, and...
The others feel the same way about this, is that we should let him play this out for a couple of days, or even a week.
And if he continues to pound it, then pick the right person to go forward and say, now, maybe even blindly to go forward and say, now, wait a minute, this has just gone far enough.
This is the worst kind of innuendo and smear, and either put up or shut up.
I mean, this is...
I almost think he...
We almost let him overplay his hand.
I think I'd let it go a week, I think.
Maybe you're right.
Rather than one or two days, because he's likely to... People may just... You never know.
People may tire of it a bit.
I think that's quite a likely possibility, plus the fact, I think, Mr. President, that he sounds desperate as hell.
I saw him on TV last night.
You did?
On the evening news yesterday, and he looked
angered.
He looked mean.
And we know from the polls that that doesn't help him when he does that.
In other words, the only thing he had ever going for him was this Mr. Clean, nice guy, honest, open fella.
And when he gets in there and gets vicious, and remember what that Harris poll found, that only 11 percent of the American people thought you had anything to do with the Watergate.
And when he charges that and charges it in the mean way that he did yesterday, I don't know.
I don't
I kind of have more confidence in the good judgment of the American people.
I don't think they buy that.
Plus the fact that no institution, government at least, has a higher reputation than the FBI.
We made the point over and over that they conducted a thorough investigation.
People think grand juries, you know, they don't really think that a grand jury can be rigged.
They consider a jury something independent, part of the court system.
And he was directly asked, was he accusing us of fixing the grand jury?
And he said, well, I wouldn't go that far.
Now, that's pretty rough stuff.
I think we ought to see how it plays out.
I think he may try to keep this issue alive, and it could backfire on him.
It could make him look more desperate, and it might give us an opportunity to really step on him hard.
Yeah, yeah.
If he does do this.
And frankly, I'd rather hit him right now on the error that he made on the wage and prices controls.
Yeah.
And stay off of this.
And stay off of this, sure.
That's right.