President Nixon and H.R. Haldeman discussed campaign strategy, including the effectiveness of negative ads and positive messaging, and the potential impact of Watergate and other issues on public opinion polls. They also debated the necessity and format of press conferences, favoring smaller, more controlled events like regional receptions and radio talks over large press gatherings. A significant decision was made to have Nixon stay overnight in New York after an event to save travel time back to Washington.
This clip of the conversation was cut from the tape by the National Archives (catalog record ↗).
NARA Description
On September 19, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon and H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David from 6:23 pm to 6:55 pm. The Camp David Hard Wire taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 212-001 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 212-1
Date: September 19, 1972
Time: 6:23 pm - 6:55 pm
Location: Camp David Hard Wire
The President met with H.R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.
*****************************************************************
BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 1
[Personal returnable]
[Duration: 11m 59s ]
END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 1
*****************************************************************
Issues
-Watergate
-Effect on polls
-Albert E. Sindlinger
-Indictments
-Comparison to grain deal issue
*****************************************************************
BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
[Personal returnable]
[Duration: 22m 4s ]
END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
*****************************************************************
Haldeman left at 6:55 pm.
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).
Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.
NixonI think that the Connally observation is a [cough]
NixonI think he's absolutely being extremely helpful, and we probably should have caught ourselves, and uh, he's absolutely right. You know, he's got a hell of a sense for the [unintelligible].
NixonI should have, I, well, I sensed it. I sensed it in terms of, Patricia had too, you know. In terms of not having the political press conferences. Yep, I knew that, but I
Nixonwhat I just wanted to be sure of is that they just didn't have that too much in, basically, well partisan activity. You know what I mean? I think the, I really,
Nixonand I think what happened here is that, well, maybe they've got, I mean and and of course Pat approved, but I, but we've got to, I should look over her schedules too or somebody should, to, to be sure that, that, that they, they don't,
NixonI know we've set them, you know, for her to do these things. Well, we told them to do some part of that thing like that headquarters thing, you know Mrs. Reagan's
NixonI just don't think you know, and Connally put it very well, "McGovern is now the issue. Unless don't make me the issue, and unless don't make uh, Agnew the issue, unless don't make uh uh, the family the issue. That's the thing we have to be concerned about, right?
NixonYou know, it's too bad that you, I guess we don't have somebody like Ziegler to do Pat's press relations.
HaldemanShe is, and and it's she'll do what she's told. That's the key is we've just got to make sure she clearly understands She understands what up try, you mean. Just
NixonIf you give the speech, she gets through, she makes a thank you. She says 5, 3 minutes, you know, "I'm glad to be here." and gets the hell out, and just looks pretty. That's what we've got to understand. Well, I think people like that better than a smart dame who gets up there and tries to show that she knows everything.
NixonYou remember the old lady, Roosevelt, how up, they turned it off because she was always talking. Now, Pat should not talk, she just shouldn't get caught, she shouldn't get out there yakking around, you see.
NixonAnd uh that's why Well, they're both the both the kids they should always talk positive, and that's why by not taking questions they don't get into negative things, you see.
NixonYou out, you'll have to follow through on this, and follow through with Chapin here, right? Who does the scheduling, Chapin? Well, then tell, you agree though that Connally's intuition's correct? Yeah. I mean think maybe we're overreacting to what he said, but I think
NixonI think Connally, the thing that concerns me is that we didn't see it, you know, and it shows you why this kind of a meeting is important, goddammit. You've got to constantly check You've got to check our, you know, check our own intuitions with other people.
NixonNow Mitchell didn't raise this. No, not at all.
NixonNo, Connally does, and Connally's right. He's right. See, it's She's a hell of an asset, Pat, but it can be
HaldemanAnd the other side of it is you don't need any assets. Oh yes, that's one of the things we've gotta keep in mind. I mean, so we have assets, so put them in the bank, and leave them there. We don't need to spend our assets.
NixonYou stopped, you stopped in the convention, uh and it's I'm so glad Gallup went up there, and said the polls will close. That's great. Why his check is when they do, that's fine, and if they don't, that's fine, too.
NixonThey're gonna have a hell of a time closing in Sindlinger's, unless he's, unless he's smoking, or drinking. Uh, you're not going to see any much shift in the polls this week, you realize that? I don't think you are. They can't. Well you might, I don't know.
HaldemanSubject to other events, if nothing's What the hell happened to changed the polls? And nothing's happened. Watergate's on. But that's reflected in Sindlinger already. It's reflected in Sindlinger and Watergate didn't have that much of a bounce. That indictments didn't weren't that much of an event. And Watergate is pretty much gone away. Actually, the grain deal is worse than Watergate at the moment, probably.
HaldemanThat is, it's there's gonna be one of those, it's whatever it is. Oh, sure. How is Pat Nixon campaigning, or something? I mean, they're just, they're dealing with those things. Those, none of those are things that are gonna cause somebody not to vote for you for president.
NixonTake the pole about the the wife of campaigning, I wonder if that doesn't say, "Well what the hell, he's sitting in the White House, and his wife's out working." Well, that it says he's working at the White House, and his wife, because he's busy back at the White House, his wife's
Haldemangetting out to make sure the folks know he's also interested in their help, right? Wants their help. But we don't need much. That's all. Sure. We don't need too much, no.
NixonAll right. We got Colson all set. He He will quit putting out those releases. I don't know whether he put them out, or the Re-Elect Committee, or what. Does he put out those schedules? I can't imagine he would, but he may have. I wouldn't think so, but I would guess, as he's said,
NixonHe said it could be RNC, and he said it was quite funny. He said, "Well we'll stop it." He said, "we," so I don't know, maybe he meant Of course, he controls, basically, what they put out. All right, well that's in there. But he He said they put, I said, "How the hell did they get this?" "Well, we put it out." That's what he told me.
HaldemanWe've been I wonder if that, if they get it from Monday. We've been running, I haven't even thought about it, but we run all the key people's schedules in Monday, and we have been for a year, just so people know.
NixonKnock it off. Let's stop that, too. Knock it off. Knock it off. Don't put it in Monday. Let it be out, I mean, that's Now is the time to to put everything undercover. Always do that way. I think
NixonThe other thing I want to ask you about, and I I don't know what you think, Bob, is, I I think I think we got Connally sold on the foreign affairs speech. That'll be a blockbuster. It'll be a hell of a speech. He's the one to make it, and I'm so delighted he's not going to go out for Democrats for Nixon alone, he'll just say, "I call on the Democrats, call on everybody." That's brilliant what he thought about, about the retreat from sworn, to show that vote up there.
HaldemanYeah, and Nixon, John Connally. Yeah. And McGovern was against it. He was for Henry Wallace's position. Right? Sure. And that, that just visibly demonstrates his, this whole point of the tradition. That's right. A strong America, and all, every president has regardless of his party, he stood for that, right? Right.
NixonNow when is, when and, when and comes uh I think it's 5 minutes, what is, when is this 5 minute, when, when Tonight at 10:55.
NixonHe and I are as well, you know, which which network is it? American Network. So, let's share a secret. Don't tell me, I don't want to watch. Now, the other thought I was going to say is that do you feel
Nixonrather comfortable? I think it's I really feel he ought to run the negative ad. You know, Democrats ad, next week. I really think he should. I don't think there's any reason why he shouldn't, and it will set the stage for what is happening after, do you agree? Yeah, and it isn't that bigger thing either way, I mean, most people won't see it, that's right.
NixonThe second point is the question is whether or not you agree with MacGregor on running that positive, you know, Yeah, I do. Why? The only Because I think it's it's good, there's no way you can lose by it, and it's it rekindles in the minds,
Haldemandoesn't matter with our people, well, it's good with our people, it stirs their juices again, but where it matters is the that fringe kind that China made the difference to, or that Russia made the difference to, that that young people, Yeah.
Haldemanthe folks Yeah, but have you seen them, and are they that good? Oh, yeah. 5 minute ones. They are. Very. They're very good. And 5 minutes is a marvelous length, because it, you know, it's over before you realize it started, pretty much.
HaldemanAnd they're interesting, they hold your interest. There's no pitch, you know, it's not a not a hard sell type thing at all. But it makes the points, and it re-establishes those pictures
Haldemanthat are in people's minds, of Nixon in China, Nixon in Russia, at the time that they're seeing on the news, the pictures of McGovern running around, making an ass of himself, and Shriver even more so.
NixonMcGovern going out to the having a conversation with this person, or a conversation with that. I don't think we want to load a big bundle of them on, and I don't think we want to do any more weight than McGovern is. That's the only negative I see in that is looking like we're outspending him. Sure. I think we've got to make sure he's outspending us.
NixonCould we get our story right away as to how that he started his ads earlier than anybody ever did. Yeah. They ought to do that. They've done that, but now he's, it's interesting, he today tried to buy a 1/2 hour on CBS tomorrow night.
HaldemanAnd CBS wouldn't sell it to him. Uh he didn't try on ABC, or NBC. He has now canceled his spots for next week, his 1-minute, his commercials on television.
HaldemanThe story being to use the money for a 1/2 hour speech. So, he's going to go on the air next week with
Haldemanthing. Uh the story that we get from the we're talking about our [unintelligible] who are guy traveling with him is that they're the way that
Haldemanuh He's tired. We cling up after the No, the the problem is is he's he got pissed off last night after this miserable days schedule, and today is just as bad, and they got him this week just running his ass off. Any holiday the candidate gets sick and he gets mad. I've been through it. I've been mad.
HaldemanBut uh he's he's I can't take it. He said, "I'm not going to do any more of this. Uh the There's no point in all the press all over the country looking at me. We'll go back to Washington. We'll sit there, and I'm going on television to ask for money, and make my pitch to the people." He's probably right to do it.
NixonIt won't do him any good, I don't think, cuz he isn't any good on television. Well, the point is, he's
HaldemanHe's on one network. And nobody'll watch. He'll have a Hooper about 10.
Nixon15 A paid political? No, he won't get any He won't get that much.
HaldemanA paid political? No, he won't get any He won't get that much.
NixonParticularly I hope he go goes up against good programs.
HaldemanWell, he can't avoid it now because this is the introductory season. Everybody's going to be looking for the new programs. This will be a very interesting thing to see how much he gets.
NixonOn the Texas thing, I I have a deep feeling in my mind reaction is correct. But I should um But I should not have the Q&A. Why?
HaldemanAll right. I think it would be desperately I mean I mean, John was just thinking, "Well, it was good the other times, so we'll do it again." But we don't want to make it an end thing. We're going to get some asshole dumb question, and it's a big audience. There's a lot of other reasons why.
NixonI want to get around and move them. I want to be friendly and all the rest of them. Be very above the battle. I'm going to tell them that and tell and tell John that I want him to be thinking of taking Connally. I'd like Mrs. Connally to take Mrs. Nixon to the other table, see what I mean? We'll We'll all do a little table-hopping
Nixonand have sort of an a chair saved around, move around from the tables, and then we'll try to all, both of us, and that and I think that both the Connallys and the Nixons should both eat after the dinner. See? So that we can feel free to move during the dinner, see? Use the time during the dinner to move among the people
Nixonand talk with them a little bit. That's going to make time, believe me.
Haldemanyou do a table and talk to a couple of people there, you've, in effect, done the whole table. So, you don't have to talk to each individual, but you get They think you have.
NixonThat's right, and shake This is Connally's trip taking. This is excellent around there. But, I think the personal touch is what they really like. Tell him, for example, the Fitzsimmons or uh on that guest, he'll be there, It'll mean far more to him and his wife if we go to his table and say how much we appreciate what he did, and also, for everybody who appears at the seat.
HaldemanEspecially meet the wives. That's Boy, that's it.
NixonMeet the wives, cuz they'll all look Nice makes the wives. Cuz then they go through the line, it will be quick and they're run and pushed, then we have a chance to move around. And, even though we miss others, they'll all say how nice. That's right.
NixonWe should eat afterwards. Tell them that we will try to grab a little something in the middle of the afternoon, and then the Connallys and we'd like to have dinner after the guests leave with them.
NixonEating is terribly, really It's terrible to do, you sit there and you show everybody's watching. I hate it. I don't like didn't like to do it anyway. We'd like to have dinner afterwards.
NixonGives you time with the guests. Now, the other thing is that uh is that because of that, I am re-evaluating, too, whether we ought to do the regional press conference.
NixonJust not sure. We can just walk into I don't I don't think you need to prove a god damn
HaldemanUh I don't know what we could substitute for it. But let's just remember, we're not going to let the fucking press determine what we do here. You know what I mean? You've just got to remember that and uh and, or influence what we're going to do.
NixonI've demonstrated I can do a press conference.
HaldemanYep. And this won't demonstrate it anymore anyway.
NixonNo one's in it, come on. We've got the national press, and so, they squeal around, and you go, let's face it, it's predictable what they want to hear, Watergate, and all that. Now, the one thing I could do,
Nixonin order to in order to blunt the whole thing, is to have one in the god damn office. You know what I mean? Just to have the bastards in on a
NixonAnd uh unlike which I think is worthwhile. I think it's worth just having one so that you get it out of the way on a day that you're doing something else, just so to speak. Th- That's That's what I have. I'm telling you. But, I think going out to the country having a press conference, I mean, it's it's a good event,
Nixonbut I'd like to find some other event to do in Atlanta, some other event.
NixonI'm just thinking I'm just thinking, you know, the thing of again, thinking back to that damn Italian picnic. So, maybe I go there for the purpose of going to a to honor somebody, or or uh, you know,
Nixona couple of wreaths, and the rest say I go to Martin Luther King and lay a wreath, and my god. But, uh there must be something you can do in Atlanta that's uh
NixonLike Yep. I just don't think the press conference is the is is the point. Why greet them? Why greet them?
NixonOr you go Or maybe Maybe there is something to be said for it. I don't know it's My My point is I've done the drill. I've proved the performance. So, I think we could do a press conference, I mean, I I mean an office press conference. I mean, I'll just catch them unawares sometime when I don't want to say much, you know, and knock off a few questions
Nixonafter Watergate is passed, and the rest, just as we come into the Soviet thing, period. Right? See the point?
NixonWhat the hell would you do? I, in Atlanta? The other thing you can do is to is to finally go in, and then make it basically a political appearance.
NixonYou motorcade in. What I would do is simply have a reception, basically, for all of our chairmen, the Nixon chairmen, the Democrats for Nixon, the candidates, and so forth, and so on. In other words, just a a private reception.
NixonHave the Have Have the people come in. So, I just come in for a reception, shake their hands, and stuff like that. I guess it can't be private. The press would have to be there. But, the motorcade would still make the news. Or, could it be private? Maybe it could be, couldn't it?
NixonSee, I'd like I'd like to have basically a I'm going in there for a regional reception for all of the candidates, and so forth, and so on, and uh we should drop a statement or do something that that touches some kind of Well, drop a statement, so if the press gets under it,
NixonOr the other thing could be to the radio, is it is to come in and make a er when they come in and then I'll I'll have a reception and do a radio talk.
NixonSee, I'm doing a radio talk and to in New England for the New England area and so forth and so on. And, uh, I don't know how we'd talk about the five. Sharp that, as you say, release the radio talk that gives an opportunity to right out. You might say that he's going to make a radio talk while he's here.
NixonNot a television talk. It would kill the television, you know, for the other. I'm telling you, I don't want a television. I don't want a television thing at all.
NixonYou see, you basically end up with two of them. You end up with a reception for the your your committee to re-elect the various candidates and the rest and shake their hands and do that as low key as possible and do a radio talk and make that be the statement for the suburban area.
NixonAnd then you go to the other place and these are basically political events. You call everybody out to get out the vote and so forth and so on. Yeah. Doing that, I think you do that, but I think that's better than going in and doing press conferences.
NixonI think it's far less dangerous. And, uh, it's less work.
HaldemanAnd they don't get you anything, and they don't get you anymore in the writing press than you would get by issuing a statement or making a radio speech, which is no work at all.
NixonAnd there's no risk. I would like to have them prepared. I mean they should be 1,500 words. 15-minute things. Well, 1,500 words. That's basically what we're talking about, because we say 15 minutes they'll give you 2,000. 1,500 words.
NixonAnd, uh, it would, uh, just a couple three or more crisp lines in it, the rest of it's charges.
HaldemanMaybe those speeches are where you do the thing Teddy White's talking about, where you, at some point, you've got to say something about the four years. Yeah, about four years. What you, why you, why you want to come back. What you what you want to finish.
NixonThe, uh, foreign policy and so forth. Some of the things we want. Spirit of America kind of thing, what I want to see for this country. Why not that sort of thing in Chicago and others?
NixonA 15-minute speech. It'd be fine. Make one rally speech of 10 minutes at the conclusion of a hell of a show.
NixonThis should be High level. It's the President speaking to the country about his hopes for this country for the next four years. You know, and, uh, what we're trying to do.
NixonLook beyond. I mean, uh, looking beyond to bipartisan [unintelligible]
HaldemanIn New York, Mitchell, one thought he's he's urging is that the way to solve your Jewish thing
Haldemanis not to have a public Jewish event, but when you're in New York, at the Waldorf, let him bring in about 20 to 25 top Jewish Nixon backers
Haldemanfrom around the country. Most of them from New York, but they'd be they'd bring Feuer and, you know, some of those in from L.A., and have a session with them.
HaldemanLet John sit in and, uh, go through it and let that be it. Not have a public Jewish event, but just let the Nixon Jewish leadership meet with you privately, just as we're meeting with the
Haldemanleadership of the South when we're in Atlanta.
HaldemanNow, I think that's a good idea. I think an overt Jewish event ain't going to work.
NixonI don't want an overt Jewish. Well, we talked about that, you know, when Yeah, I I know I did. Because I didn't know anything else. This is much better, much better.
HaldemanAnd also, he says it's much better to do it there than in the White House. It's less noticeable. You're at the Waldorf. You can just have them in, and uh, just say you met with a group of people and
NixonYou've all or you've already talked to Lasker that we aren't going to do the table-hopping, I hope?
HaldemanWell, that's our other problem is this: Lasker will not bring a group of people in ahead of time. He says he can't he can't get down to a small enough group to bring them in.
HaldemanNo, he doesn't want you to table-hop. He's agreed to put the head table on the dais. That's all worked out. And what he's pleading for is that you either come in 15 minutes before the telecast
Haldemanor you stay at the head table for 15 minutes after the telecast so that some of these people can come up and do some handshaking.
HaldemanYeah. Well, you were saying you'd come in and sit an hour.
NixonI know, no, no. I I I would much rather do It wasn't that I was only doing it just to be good. No, I would much rather do it the other way, absolutely, absolutely.
NixonSure, I'll stay afterwards and gass around with them then. And then I'll stay more than that. I'll stay a half hour and let them bring all of them around.
HaldemanAll right, now the problem that creates is it's going to get you back to Washington awful late,
HaldemanWhich raises a question whether you don't want to save yourself a couple hours and go to stay in New York that night at the Waldorf and then leave for California from there.
NixonBecause it and especially if I stay at all after the TV, because that see, it's 10:30, 11:00, 11:30, you know, then I'd have to leave about 9:00 next day, probably.
NixonI don't know, I'd, I'd The more I hear, good god, what I hear, Helms is running a lousy campaign. Jesus Christ, he can't, he couldn't lose in North Carolina.
HaldemanWell, Helms is not a good candidate. He can't get himself going, is what what they're saying. Truly just
NixonHe isn't a good candidate. He's a good campaigner.
783-027 5:41 PM · 16 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 5:41 pm and 11:59 pm.
212-002 6:55 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:46 pm.
144-001 7:45 PM · 15 sec — President Richard M. Nixon, unknown person(s), and Camp David operator talked on the telephone at Camp David at an unknown time between 7:45 pm and 7:46 pm.
212-003 7:45 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Camp David operator met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David at 7:45 pm.
144-002 7:46 PM · 23 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Charles W. Colson talked on the telephone at Camp David from 7:46 pm to 8:10 pm.
212-004 7:46 PM · 13 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Charles W. Colson met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David from 7:46 pm to 8:10 pm.
144-003 8:10 PM · 10 sec — William Hirsch and Camp David operator talked on the telephone at Camp David on an unknown date, sometime between 8:10 pm on September 19, 1972 and 7:10 pm on September 20, 1972.
144-004 8:10 PM · 13 min — Edward R. F. Cox and Allen C. Hall talked on the telephone at Camp David on an unknown date, sometime between 8:10 pm on September 19, 1972 and 7:10 pm on September 20, 1972.
Conversation 212-001, September 19, 1972. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 651228130). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/212-001 (accessed November 2, 2026).