Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 419 › Conversation 419-023

Nixon, Moore & Dean on Watergate investigation and Ervin Committee

Wednesday, March 14, 1973 · 12:47 PM–1:30 PM ET · Old Executive Office Building · 43 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Moore, Richard A.; Dean, John W., IIIConversation419-023 on Tape 419StartWednesday, March 14, 1973 at 12:47 PMEndWednesday, March 14, 1973 at 1:30 PMRecording deviceOld Executive Office BuildingSourceNixon Library record for 419-023 ↗

President Nixon met with John Dean and Richard Moore to discuss strategy for responding to congressional investigations, particularly the Ervin Committee's inquiries into Watergate. They debated the extent of executive privilege, the administration's cooperation with subpoenas, and potential press strategies. Key action items included managing public statements, preparing for potential legal challenges, and considering counter-offensives regarding Democratic campaign activities.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 9.1 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 5.6 MB

On March 14, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, Richard A. Moore, and John W. Dean, III met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 12:47 pm to 1:30 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 419-023 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 419-23

Date: March 14, 1973
Time: 12:47 pm - 1:30 pm
Location: Executive Office Building

The President met with Richard A. Moore and John W. Dean, III.

       Ronald L. Ziegler's briefing on Watergate
            -Length
                  -Comparison to James C. Haggerty
                  -Limits
            -Format
            -Subjects
                  -Written interrogatories
                  -President's appearance
                        -Congressional investigation
                               -Compared with Henry A. Kissinger’s informal consultations
                               -Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy and Birch Bayh
                               -Samuel J. Ervin, Jr., Howard H. Baker, Jr.
                                     -Meeting with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman, John D.
                                      Ehrlichman and lawyers
                  -Peter M. Flanigan
            -Separation of powers

       Watergate
            -Thomas Lumbard's interview with Washington Post
                             -35-

     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                               Conversation No. 419-23 (cont’d)

      -Work for Committee to Re-elect the President (CRP)
      -Dean's conversation with Donald E. Santarelli
      -Washington Post report
            -Link between G. Gordon Liddy and Dean
                  -Counsel duties
-Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI]
      -L[ouis] Patrick Gray, III
      -William C. Sullivan
-Ervin Committee
      -Subpoenas
            -Authority over administration
-Common Cause law suit
Show the rest of the log (143 more lines)
      -Dean's subpoena
      -Administration lawyers
            -Abilities
            -John W. Gardner
      -Lawrence F. O'Brien's suit, Maurice H. Stans's libel suit
      -Administration counter-offensive
-Ervin Committee
      -March 13, 1973 issuance of subpoenas for Dean, Jeb Stuart Magruder, Hugh
       W. Sloan, Jr., Murray M. Chotiner
-Ervin Committee
      -Objectives
            -Investigation of Stans
      -Questions for Dean
            -CRP personnel structure
-O'Brien suit against CRP
      -Dean subpoena
      -Use of executive privilege
            -Court fight
            -Haldeman and Ehrlichman
            -Written interrogatories
            -Congress
                  -Rules
                  -Subpoena
                         -Court challenge
-Executive privilege
      -Dan Rather's questions
                               -36-

       NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                 Conversation No. 419-23 (cont’d)

             -President's statements
                   -Alger Hiss case
                          -President's criticisms of White House
                          -Harry S Truman's non-cooperation
                          -Response of press corps
       -Previous appearance before Congressional Committee as Vice-President
-FBI
       -Sullivan
             -Problems
             -Knowledge of certain activities
                    -Trust settlement
                    -Democratic abuses
                          -Possible release
       -President's statements for press
             -Release of material
                    -Precedents
       -1968 campaign
             -Allegations of wiretapping
             -Sullivan
                    -Knowledge of illegal activities by Democrats
             -Corroborating evidence
             -John N. Mitchell's conversation with Cartha D. DeLoach
                    -Spiro T. Agnew [?]
                    -J. Edgar Hoover
                          -Conversation with President
             -Sullivan
                    -Use of information
             -Hoover
                    -Conversation with President
                          -Wire taps
                                 -National security
                                 -Removal of equipment
             -Sullivan’s testimony
                    -Impact on Democrats
       -Attorney General Richard G. Kleindienst
             -Job performance
                    -John B. Connally’s viewpoint
       -Gray
                                      -37-

             NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                   Conversation No. 419-23 (cont’d)

                -Intelligence
                -Political skills

          -Testimony to Congress
                -Affidavit
                      -Herbert W. Kalmbach
                -Contacts with Dean
     -Donald H. Segretti
          -White House response
                -Policy statement
          -Dean's reports to President
                -Questions from press
                      -Responses
          -Investigation of Segretti

Campaign contributions
    -Robert L. Vesco
          -Connection with Stans
                -Seriousness of problem
                -Cash contribution
                -DeVan L.Shumway
          -Donald A. Nixon
                -Work with Vesco
    -Dick Tuck
    -Mexican banks
          -Stans' role
          -Current investigation

Watergate
     -Gray
           -Testimony to Congress
           -Press conference
           -Ehrlichman
     -Segretti case
           -Questions for President
                  -Response
                  -Ehrlichman
     -Executive privilege
                                          -38-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 419-23 (cont’d)

                -Guidelines
                -Double privilege
                -Washington DC Court of Appeals
                       -David L. Bazelon
                -Supreme Court
                       -Attitude toward executive privilege
                       -William H. Rehnquist
                -Justification
                       -Colson
                -Truman administration
                       -Total non-cooperation in Hiss case
                             -Justice Department raw files compared to summary report
                             -Contrast with administration's position
                -Ervin Committee
                       -Administration cooperation
                -Dan Rather
                       -Hiss case
                             -Truman administration's non-cooperation
            -Democratic illegalities
                -Press leaks
                -Need for publicity

Moore and Dean left at 1:30 pm

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 2 parts and the right one starts.

NixonHow's Ron's briefing today?
DeanA bad, uh, briefing. They kept him, kept Ron about an hour and a half.
NixonI wonder if he, uh, Ron should do that, or Ron and Ziegler.
DeanJim, Hagerty used to do it, Mr. President. He had [unintelligible] I guess you'd say that an hour and a half
NixonI know, but Hagerty never had, did he?
MooreWell, a standard rule of briefings will be an hour. A half, a standard rule for all briefings, I guess, would be an hour.
NixonAnd the point is that it gets substantially more of an hour and a half to be, uh--
DeanNow, I'll see Ron. Ron didn't brief the whole time himself. There was a prior briefing on some other subject. Oh, it is. The, uh, the FAA was on at 10:20, and then Jim covered for-- But, uh, Ziegler went on and, and went for an hour.
NixonHe's pretty good at cutting them off. When he gets tired, he taking another question. He says, "Fellows, that's it." Then what's that ball game? That they've labored, labored, labored,
DeanYeah.
Deanhe had to field every conceivable question. He did a remarkable job in responding, but it was just like tearing a flesh out to get, get off the podium.
NixonYeah. What did he do? Did you see the whole show?
MooreI only, me, me, I only know the answer to what he has briefed and so forth, whether you'd approve or disapprove.
DeanI think you'd approve of the briefing. I was putting out some other fires, until--
NixonThe briefing, now, you haven't worked with him?
DeanOh, I've got, you know, what he, what he, what he had, what he had.
DeanUh, they didn't, they uh, briefing didn't add anything. It went back, it was more technical, and, what they wanted to understand became why, uh, distinction was being made between, uh, written, uh, format personal and witness [unintelligible]
NixonThe informal.
Deanand that, and a whole lot, "How do you answer that?" Well, it's just never been done.
DeanRon probably briefed well, uh, this morning, and then said, "I think I put it to sleep."
DeanThe fact is we would not do what Kissinger does and have this informal meeting with the committee on this subject. Uh, the next question was, "Well, would he accept a phone call from the chairman?" And Ron said, "Well, of course he would."
NixonYeah.
DeanNow, I would say that we, you know, we would not want to get into any informal uh, give-and-take with Kennedy and Bayh and--
NixonRight. Hell, no. Hell, no.
DeanAnd hell, no. If they want to, they say, what of the ranking member and the chairman?
Nixon[unintelligible]
DeanI think that's a bad precedent to begin, anyway, because then Ervin and Baker, I mean now they can call early in the morning.
NixonYeah, that's right.
MooreWith their counsel.
DeanWith their counsel.
MooreI think we've got to hold right here. You reiterated and toned down the fact that we're willing, what about Kissinger who's a different matter?
NixonKissinger's a totally different matter. Foreign policy [unintelligible].
MooreWell, look at Flanigan's answer. He said, and he said, "Now, I'm not going to get into that. It was totally different situation, different individuals, different facts, different circumstances, but with respect to this, that indicate the history of previous, uh, appearances in the Senate.
NixonDid you, did John tell you how the Flanigan thing set up the fight? Did they tell you about that?
MooreNo, sir.
NixonFlanigan, Flanigan agreed that he, the, Senate, the committee would submit, Flanigan could answer by letter and say, if there are any questions pertaining to it--
NixonAre there any other cases in connection with the, with the committee? But it should be handled in that manner.
MooreYeah, and keep pretty close to that tract.
DeanI keep, I keep, because depending on what they want to inquire in, determine whether it violates, whether it intrudes into executive privilege.
MooreSeparation of powers.
DeanSeparation of powers. You have, you have claimed the general policy, and you can only make decisions on given facts and given circumstances. You don't have to give hypothetical--
MooreWe're in complete agreement with each other. Good.
NixonAll right, well, now, there's coming the other problems. What you have to fight?
DeanWell, this crap on the fellow, Lombard, who they also invited. He was once invited by the, uh, by the committee. Uh, who's he? Lombard is a young man who used to work at the Justice Department. He was a friend of Gordon Liddy's.
DeanUh, who gave a private interview to the Washington Post sometime last fall, and it was never printed until recently. Lombard did volunteer work
Deanfor, for me, my office, in researching all of the state campaign, election laws, to determine the needs for each state would be, and as he has, he relayed into what Lombard has worked for the [unintelligible] of the committee
NixonUh-huh.
DeanWhy did he need an interview at all? We don't know. He was apparently did, but he called Don Santarelli this morning and said, "What in the hell have I got myself into? And I talked to Don late last night and said, "You get a hold of Lombard and tell him not to go up there before that committee." And Don said, "I'll take care of it."
DeanI don't know what happened, so he's not going to be here. He had already accepted and had already agreed that he'd run today, and we've got it turned off, so he's not one problem. He's safe. He just testified that, and this could be very helpful to the committee.
NixonHmm. He did?
DeanBecause the only job he did for me is the volunteer, the thing he was wanting to do, tell everybody how he dealt directly with me when I was on my staff.
DeanExcept, I think he said, "I was researching the state laws because they, they're bothered [unintelligible]"
NixonWhat did the Post, what did the Post put out on this?
DeanWell, they tried to play it as some link, link between Liddy and Dean. And he, there was, the link was that Liddy had the responsibilities for the campaign--
NixonYeah.
Deanand compliance over there, and I had it here, and I was keeping an eye and making sure that they were in conformance.
MooreWell, you see that's more reading, it ain't all, it's more circumstantial, like the good
NixonWell let's come to the general problem. Let's show, uh, what the plan should be.
DeanAll right.
DeanWell, there're two, there are two issues that are ready. One is: where we go now with Pat Gray? And, the second is, did we try and do something dramatic with this whole stall?
NixonUh-huh.
DeanJust take the initiative for once. Now, on the first, on Gray,
Deanuh, I think that is best to watch and wait. We don't know how the Senate's going to respond to my letters. We just--
NixonWell, the point is they may take it out of our hands by simply saying, "Well, he's a hostage until Gray comes, until Dean comes up." If they say that, what's your answer to that?
MooreThere's no, there's no likelihood that they'll be able to hurt Gray with this move.
DeanSure.
MooreI think they can say that the, the reason that he's forced to do it, because hell with you know that he's, the, the honest thing that they could do, they've got to take the lead in.
DeanThat's right.
MooreNow throw it, then the next business will be now and the next hour and a half, that, uh, they'll figure out what they can do with it.
DeanYeah.
NixonYeah.
NixonWell, they can't do shit with that, can they?
DeanWell, I thought that, uh--
NixonWhy not?
DeanWhy not subpoena him to find out? Well they say I, I wouldn't, I, I wouldn't, uh, be concerned if the committee subpoenaed me, because only because I think we would win in the courts.
NixonYeah.
DeanThey are going to say, well, uh, oh, I don't, I mean, maybe you shouldn't make that decision until they do the first one, but if they subpoena the [unintelligible]
MooreHave you dealt with under-the-table subpoena on a test case?
DeanYes, I think emotionally this would take the, the offensive, but fighting every, and that be the offensive clerk, try to get
MooreWell, it works as a test.
DeanIn that sense,
Mooreyeah, because, yeah, with a good deal of what you've seen here, but because it's a test, of course we shouldn't test it.
DeanYeah.
Nixon[unintelligible] what if they take their chance so that every time that they out of them are forced, and what would we do, go up to a Federal judge?
DeanWell, what they would have to do,
NixonWell, I don't think we go.
Deanwe can either go out, or they, but I think they're coming out,
DeanNo, we don't. We parallel litigation on all subjects, I had this evening now. Sullivan
NixonYeah.
Deanis bound by the subpoena in the Common Cause lawsuit.
NixonWell, what? Did he have any lawyers?
DeanYes, we do. They, we've hired--
DeanWell, we have hired Hurd. They've interfered there, but made no contributions with him.
NixonYeah, and they took depositions, didn't they?
DeanYes, this and that. We've got them on the run, on the run, on the fact that he wants to settle the case because the fact that he says it's costing him to keep the case on. It's costing Common Cause the dough on.
NixonYeah.
DeanYeah, and Gray, I think, yes, they've fallen on both of them, and we have been reduced, and you know O'Brien's too has been, bothered some.
DeanWell, then they moved down and dumped him out, and then came to me. And they said, "No way, can any of that," you have the copy of that that I took?
MooreYes, I have it here.
DeanSomebody's using it.
MooreWell, that's what, I had been reading of that.
DeanAll right, well anyway, that, that has just been dormant until yesterday or today when they dropped the subpoena against, in the Moore, Sloan, [unintelligible] what we can do with that.
DeanWell, the first question is who represents me. The Department of Justice, we had that problem with Colson, in the O'Brien suit and got into the conflict with the Department of Justice [unintelligible] I don't think it's the same conflict because this purely in a official capacity. Can't get that right then I'll probably have to have a solemn question.
NixonUh, once it is all bad, then we'll quash the subpoena.
DeanYeah, but I happen to actually serve the,
NixonYeah.
Dean[unintelligible] the moved to quash, Mr. President.
DeanUh, well you see, one. Once they're after the fact, they could be, if Paul O'Brien's got a stop the lawyer. Uh, he called and gave me a great, a couple calls. He called me a couple times, said, one, we've got these old charts from '68. Will you look at them and tell me if they're still good. I did that. Uh, then he asked me a couple of questions about,
Deanuh, forms and structures of the committee, relations to the big committee and the, what they call the separate know,
NixonSuppose you're asked, suppose you're audio recorded.
DeanThe purpose might have been that, but then after they get done with that, the next thing is O'Brien's suit, which is Watergate suit against uh, uh, the Re-election Committee. They want to subpoena me in that. And we have no, and they'll be saying we want deep investigation, we want all your records, files, everything else.
DeanAnd getting what they can't get frankly, by pride.
NixonHow did you plan on that?
DeanWell, again, there is no, there is judicial executive privilege that could totally protected.
NixonOf course it is.
DeanAnd we'd fight that to the courts.
NixonThat's right. Well, hell, seeing it was pending. How can a judge tell you well you don't have executive privilege. How could he do it?
DeanNever has.
DeanCivil suit to happen into my knowledge. Right. The only question, the only thing they might do again is,
DeanSay that we got a lot of phone, right? But uh, alright, all right.
NixonYeah, that's it. Right.
NixonOkay. That's, how how they fight back of course uh, them them better that'd be good, but
DeanAll right. Uh, the other issue, Common Cause, uh, again what I had tried to do to keep them, find push to the fire, because they they want they'd like to rely on the committee's work too.
DeanThey want to take this huge subpoena, that they have, they really have actually, just first, we have defeated U.S. vs. AT&T. We were successful. AT&T refused to turn over toll slips they were subpoenaing and uh,
DeanThere's quite an order, apparently the subpoena has been, huh, they thought of that. So.
NixonYeah. What press did this cause could have cause could there have been protest in the press conferences?
DeanWell there has been a few questions, but uh, we got big questions. I don't know the whole suggestion of
NixonThursday, Thursday. [crosstalk] You got think it'll work, but you got to like it.
DeanOne thing else which uh, uh, yeah I bet it'll get out to you this afternoon, is one a former White House aide who may be called as a witness in this case. His whole testimony is not going to fall out very great, but once they that would be fresh in your mind. But I suspect that a question may be a little more off the substance, sir,
Deanof uh, Watergate-related things, too. Well that is not executive privilege. It's coming up quite frequently, yeah. The other thing uh,
Deanyes, the uh,
Deanyour past statements
Deanin the Congress. I want to talk about this the other day. Uh, they were, Dan Rather has already asked me the question the press conference, "Didn't the President criticize this when he was a member of the House? Isn't he in this case?" "Sure I am." Not his tension. And I told, I told our press office people, is that he was criticizing the withholding of documents and information.
DeanWhich we have offered, which we have never done. We've evoked three times.
DeanNow the President, the fact is in 1948, the President never criticized,
DeanOh rather Dan Rather was stepping through a mind field when he raised that. That's right. Because if he if he's saying if he's saying find twenty of our staff up here then you're doing the right thing to criticize. That all, there's that that distinct I told him that the committee was not asking for their testimony. They were asking for information. And they'd been quiet. Did you know we did they ask you for information?
NixonYeah.
DeanAnd that's evidence. You were Oh you're furnishing information. That is the question. We didn't ask Truman to testify. We didn't ask Hoover to testify.
DeanWe didn't ask John to testify. We asked for information.
MooreOh kill. Wonderful. I'm gonna ask
NixonThe President Truman took an executive order there would be no cooperation whatever, and I'll say to this day, and that that was that was received with one hundred percent approval by the Washington press corps. Bastards. Hell, it'll burn their ass.
MooreThat's good, John. That's, that's good.
NixonYeah, I remember it very well.
DeanDamn right.
MooreYeah.
NixonIt's not being a kid about it, test me on that one. What about the what a partisan committee? But against the Democratic 100 percent approval. Saying that member of Congress should not, the executive should not cooperate with a member of Congress in any way.
DeanIn an investigation.
NixonThat's what Truman thought.
DeanDo you recall ever having been asked when you after you left the Vice Presidency to appear before a committee of Congress?
NixonI didn't.
DeanYou did go once.
NixonUh, what happened was uh uh
DeanThe uh the question came up partway through Congress.
DeanBecause the uh they were considering
Deanuh constitutional
Deanamendment.
NixonOh, that's before on the question of the 25th Amendment, that's the session, succession, presidential succession. And they had asked, they asked whether he would they asked him, I look at that, every body did on the issue. And of course,
NixonAny, but they were assisting. I wouldn't testify. I mean I made statements, not that I testified.
DeanIt wasn't an inquiry. It was they weren't sworn.
NixonWe've had these these hearings, on the question of the 25th Amendment.
DeanAnother item that's on this, this thing that we're talking about today, dealing with Sullivan, Gray. Uh,
Deanthat is, Dick and I have kicked around, is potential, and both regard it potentially dangerous, and potentially helpful.
MooreUh,
DeanOne, right now we don't know everything Sullivan knows. You know, he's has, for a couple of days, been put together. And I'd be sure I get the whole panorama before we go into that. That's right. In any event, get that out of it.
NixonYeah.
DeanOnce we get that down, we are theoretically always,
Deanhe said, we're taking this power. Right now, I don't I'd read to distrust them, yeah. But I've been given this chance get on a plane, uh,
Deanit could be dangerous,
Deanbut still it could buy clear. He would say, and wouldn't go into this town, and that's seem to be the next step down the sulfer.
DeanThen, we come to the being of the state, whether it should or shouldn't be used.
NixonI would say it would be pretty good for Mark to talk to Sullivan.
DeanYes, sir.
NixonI wouldn't hesitate.
DeanWhy doesn't Sullivan shoot John Erlichman's name?
DeanFirst he went in, then he went through for uh
DeanWell, I, I certainly, that we have no one who's safe.
NixonThe wiretapping?
DeanYes, sir. Well, not necessarily the wiretapping. But it's [unintelligible] wiretapping. Well, I, I guess it connects to the White House.
NixonIt's connected with that?
DeanYes, sir.
NixonWell, connect with who then? That's what I'm [unintelligible]
DeanWell, connects with Hunt.
NixonYes. But who were they wiretapping? Somebody connected with the White House? I, I didn't know it personally. Tell me this: This has to be, this can't be connected to the White House. At the, at the request of the White House?
DeanWell, that's not, we have nothing to do with it.
NixonYeah.
DeanThere is a cable. There is a cable. Counsel who received it, made it available.
DeanNow, the parts that may have been redone concerning information he had that the, that's detrimental to the current Democratic Administration, that's been thrown out. But what Hunt went into the department to know, the White House connection with it.
DeanHe had a security clearance, that facets his, that this has been handled directly for Howard. But it's shaken out of it. If this happens, we take it with the fact that it's disconnected
NixonWhat about for whom the secret cable was drawn?
DeanWe don't. We've tried to get all—
NixonWell, that's very fine.
Deanget all.
DeanYou see, the factor is that that's, it's true for the White House spokesman to say that there's nothing, is that before President Nixon became president,
Deanand took the oath of his office, and Hunt is not going to be employed,
Deanthere was. If then they'll ask, "Well, what was Hunt then hired by the press for? For personal, political purposes at the White House? What makes him stand out so?" That's not the point. We don't have to say
DeanThe establishment, part of the '68 campaign was something to find and not for the direct, everybody's mind that it's taken through it.
DeanThe fact they've leaked it before the FBI, that's sensational by it
Deanbecause the, it, it tells us the whole story is here.
DeanThe first thing to be, it's what they said about the, through the media is sensational news. '68 campaign and he brought this stuff and he gave that back to me.
DeanI really, it's, well first, the allegation about the White House. It's truly a White House,
DeanWe don't know whether he,
Deanwe've been unable, thus far, to behold that.
NixonI'm sure, nobody will be, nobody is [unintelligible] that's right. It's just a craft to behold.
DeanGive me all the emotions there. The emotions I think is what's [unintelligible] and Hank, you know he hasn't responded.
DeanThey did not respond to the state's, cracked him off from all from this narrative.
NixonSo badly? That's, that's,
DeanIt's unfortunate.
NixonI'm tired of caring who had it.
DeanHank, Hank is not there and cannot carry a couple of your words. And I'd have to talk with him.
NixonSure, sure.
DeanHe's crying. He's crying.
NixonAnd they were ordered to destroy all this stuff. He was ordered to withdraw it, then they carry out the order.
DeanYeah. [unintelligible]
NixonThat person should be completely—
DeanIf they had done that,
NixonBecause he doesn't know. He wouldn't know.
DeanNo, I didn't think he did.
DeanIt's well married [unintelligible] right now.
NixonYeah.
DeanWe have not won't. I'm afraid to get him on all fours.
NixonIt's so irresponsible.
NixonSo, so irresponsible of all. If they're all, that really seems to me the electricians who are involved in it
Unknown[unintelligible]
DeanThe Ervin Committee I have had a feeling because Haldeman in fact had a press conference [unintelligible] Ervin problem is not just to the President himself and his staff, but I get the feeling that they are going to subpoena, you know, a lot of people.
DeanVery frankly, to me, some of the people who were in the Johnson campaign, and who are still around the Democratic Party today--
MooreWell, the next step would be if your massive subpoena went into [unintelligible]
DeanThat's what they're going to do. I'm far from serious, and I've got me really worried in that if they keep on going, and going and going and going--
MooreI really think what has to happen, Dick, [unintelligible] to raise [unintelligible] this whole segregation issue, right through [unintelligible]
Mooreas you say they get onto, say, an area where they don't really have any authority. Let's start with, why do you care about
DeanSee, the problem they got on both fibers and the more kind of a, uh, break. Frankly, they got the numbers. They these guys, got a lot of these guys [unintelligible] out of the stand back of what you call it, congress officers,
Dean[unintelligible] Some of the stuff is [unintelligible] you guys
MooreErvin, the hearing is going to be crucial on the Gray [unintelligible] but Gray's a wonderful guy, and Gray's not the smartest guy in the world. He's not. There's, there's the smartest guy [unintelligible]
DeanAnd, ordinarily, this guy could hold his own, right?
MooreAnd I think once he's confirmed he'll get a scrap. Because he got Sullivan [unintelligible] and when Pat goes around, I'm going to have to walk. And with with that expert in the field, so to speak, of the bad the situation, and he will be the best to stick for it. He's, he takes this all very personally.
MooreNow that they've made this scandal, he'll do something, and it's going to hurt, because, everybody's got to take their hats. And, I think, yes sir.
Dean[crosstalk] I feel the FBI issue personally, it shouldn't
Moore[crosstalk] personally, it's totally inappropriate on a Confirmation hearing. It's totally, and the way Pat handled it was totally out of order.
DeanPat believes it, believe me. Because Pat believes the rumor, but it's not true. That wasn't that field. On the other hand, what I say to Mr.
MooreThat's true.
DeanHe just said he has had to bring out fact that he did not realize how bad it would be to bring a report like, fact about it. A guy named Charles Wonderlich brought up the fact that he has never seen anything like this. You know, Pat is kind of a fool when he's around, and, but the facts, that's what he's looking for, you see.
DeanHe's fighting, on that area, people came up and said, "Look at this, look at this, how many [unintelligible]
MooreYeah, and [unintelligible] when it was down there, they fact that [unintelligible] turned out what's really happening.
Dean[unintelligible] now, now, I think that if he Gray had filed it a way that, you've got to watch
MooreWell, and the principle that affects the guy, I think Pat Sullivan's the other guy, and Pat Sullivan has been fighting around on this turf for a number of [unintelligible] that would be funny, wouldn't it?
NixonAll Sullivan's fought for is Sullivan, you know, but the trouble for us he's certainly fought for us
Deanit's uh I think the earlier the better.
NixonThe earlier the better. Why? We had uh a statement. I assume a policy statement on uh
DeanWell, we had the executive privilege policy [unintelligible] yesterday.
NixonYeah, and I put a four-horse plow into that one, didn't I?
DeanYes, sir.
NixonWell, now, Ziegler's briefed on the whole thing. He's got his book, hasn't he?
DeanYes, yes.
NixonWhat will Ziegler see? I suspect that another question to Ziegler would be, "Does that end the whole Watergate thing, or will they'll be more?" That's Ziegler's problem. That's a good question to put to him. What does Ziegler say to that, John, do you know?
DeanYes, sir.
NixonWell, what about, what if they'd seen an FBI report?
DeanCorrect. That's uh
Nixonuh
NixonThere is a serious question, but I would doubt, and Ziegler would say, you know, that this does not have anything to do with other investigations. Suppose they ask, you know, "Did Dean conduct a Watergate investigation? Did he deliver a report, orally or in written [unintelligible]?"
DeanYes, he did.
NixonWhat would Ron say?
DeanHe did, yes, he did, and uh, uh, not only for me, but the cabinet, the order to--
NixonAnd not only, not only for me, and can he handle it that way? I think if anybody in the White House had an
Deansay, "No, they hadn't." Yes, no, we had.
NixonUh-huh.
DeanIt is also a fact that, as Gray testified, there are 82 interviews. I don't know that he told them, though. Well, that's what, yeah, the FBI investigated [unintelligible].
NixonThey are right. Did Dean report to me?
DeanYou're quite right.
NixonWhat's that?
DeanIt's then on the money. It's uh, they had he had a, Stans made some, made some checks, and, uh, it was not considered a serious uh, problem, and uh, the checks beat that. Uh, somebody would have had to send through money. You know, they're they're, the story is that Stans considered it kind of cash, but it was turned over and what have you.
NixonNo, it told what he done with the money. How it went to an [unintelligible] who went to Hunt or, you know, that sort of thing?
DeanThat's right.
MooreTotally, Stans acted in the most innocent, uh, innocently drawn in. He was asked to come up to the, to Vespa's office, and uh, and he was asked, uh, "Is cash all right?" And he said, "I don't know, let me call and check." And then they said, okay, to follow it's back and tell this is cash was all right. Followed Warren Warren, "I don't care whether it's cash or a check.
DeanWell, the fact is that they've never been subjected to a subpoena.
NixonThat's only been staff.
DeanThat's only staff [unintelligible]
NixonNever come up before. Because we, we've got Shanley [unintelligible] who came out and said they have all of that [unintelligible]
DeanWell, I don't know if the White House politics is involved in this [unintelligible]
MooreWell, the thing is John [unintelligible]
NixonThat's fine. Go ahead and do that [unintelligible]
MooreYeah, the other thing, of course, John is you're working [unintelligible]
Dean[unintelligible]
MooreYou work for him, John.
DeanI, the question before I ask him was was that he was trying to get out, you know. He knew he was under a bad [unintelligible] bad deal, it was [unintelligible]
Moorethe fact that Shanley and Flanigan were counsel, were acting as counsel. Of course, Shanley had the position of chief advisor on the Senate. And then, Flanigan was counsel, was in a situation where—
DeanFinally, he says, we have no problem.
MooreAnd he was asked to testify. Yeah, I don't really have a factual, counsel has special problems [unintelligible] Shanley, Flanigan,
NixonUh-huh.
DeanWell, [unintelligible] staff members of the White House Staff and know more in regards to immunity and confidential information, because they're familiar with confidential information.
MooreYeah, exactly.
DeanSo, and to see if you have some kind of embarrassed President somewhere.
Nixon[unintelligible]
MooreGreat questions will arise [unintelligible]
Dean[unintelligible] 50 to 60 people who work in the White House [unintelligible] That's right.
MooreI think that should be definitely cleared up. But, like I thought, Ron I think put that down. That wasn't discussed about him and Ron said early, Ron did in a press conference uh just 4 or 5 days ago uh
NixonHe handled that?
Moorehandled that. And they banged at this press conference, they won't remember that, it was so long. And tell them what Ziegler said. 'Cause they didn't record what he said, Huh?
DeanYeah.
NixonWhere are the investigations [unintelligible] What [unintelligible]
MooreWhat about, if I may, FBI?
DeanShall I make this statement, that Mr. Gray ought to be [unintelligible]
NixonNo. Why would you want to?
MooreNo. Certainly not. You go out of the way to to dig it in. But, I think this that in that area, if they asked, if they ask you about it, I think you should say, flatly, by name [unintelligible]
NixonThat's right.
MooreIf they asked, they said, this of course was Mr. Gray. And, I think that the standard answer said, I'm already on record, but, you took an interest to look into it.
NixonUh-huh.
DeanDid you see it?
MooreNo, early, tell them you've got an example of it. And then refer them to Tom [unintelligible] to make the statement so that, you know, it follows the line of honesty and all [unintelligible]
Dean[unintelligible]
DeanOne thing that
Unknown[unintelligible]
DeanThis is this Executive privilege that has had very little study. Nobody's ever looked into it.
NixonWell, let's look into it.
MooreYes. But I mean that Executive privilege has got we don't say that to second cover-up.
NixonYeah.
MooreThat's that's the trouble, you know.
DeanNobody went to court on it. Nobody went to court. Now the Ervin Committee's coming up. We're going to court. But we're not going to court on that.
MooreI think that that option of testing it would be very bad politically, wouldn't it? It'd be a test item,
Deantest the ultimate privilege claim.
MooreHumphrey never had it, Truman never had it. Eisenhower did it another way.
DeanThat's right, he announced it.
DeanI don't I don't think I don't think even with this crazy court that
Deanthe D.C. Court of Appeals that they might do something crazy by the time it got to the court, but the Supreme Court will worked out that
NixonOh, Christ.
DeanEisenhower's basis was not so much separation of powers, in fact, it was less that, but rather he put in a letter to the Attorney General, he argued more on the need for the
Deanthe immediacy of the staff or being on call at any time that they are needed, that they can't go up and be attacked.
NixonAnd I have always thought that was a weak, that's the weakest argument.
DeanWeak argument.
NixonUh, this separation of powers is senior to Truman's.
DeanSee they have separate panels that that that make up reports that they stole.
NixonThe fact is, that is, that it is inhibition to advice when you know that you got to be summoned up there and talk about this conversation.
NixonHow could you advise? Well, I wouldn't want John Dean to advise me like say, well, I, I couldn't I got my, [laughter] That's no advice at all.
DeanNo.
NixonI believe in that whole thing.
DeanIf the weekend show had a formal needs, but that's there's an earlier precedent for it. You wanted that power [crosstalk] to be issued.
Nixon[crosstalk] Well, I'm sure.
DeanIt's important that this is like the full court. Uh-huh.
DeanAnd Truman would even later, he refused, hell, he wouldn't send them he wouldn't send
NixonHe said, "Hell no."
DeanHe said,
NixonPerson, the say the way I exported it was more positive. "We will cooperate," right? Which we did much, which the Truman administration would not do with regard to the Alger Hiss case. That is what I just remembered,
DeanRight.
Nixonlook at it. There they would not cooperate.
DeanNo. We weren't even asking for raw files.
NixonNo, definitely not. All we were asking for was for a summary of their investigation,
DeanThat's it.
Nixonwhich we knew they had made. And they refused it.
MooreAnd the President has a letter saying
DeanDean sent a letter out, you know, both to cooperate with the committee.
MooreIn any way that is consistent with my policy statement to provide the necessary information.
DeanI think that's the way they're going to put it.
MooreYeah, yeah.
DeanCongress, of course, will resolve the doubt around the staff on what they're, when will they have to make their decision,
Mooredo you argue?
DeanErvin's Committee, the end of the day. Oh, I I I don't catch on that yet,
NixonYeah.
Deanuh,
Moorethey received the letter. This is the letter the gray has sent,
DeanGray has sent, which the committee
Moorewas classified.
NixonYeah.
MooreAnd which they sent the second paragraph, wanted to know if we won't waive it, and provide if they come in they just won't show. And then, "all right."
DeanAll right. And they can handle it. When I had said then, in my brief, if I just come, we wouldn't bother them at all.
DeanWhy they, you know, they they just wanted to push it off and uh Wanting to
DeanThere are good lawyers, probably that that look at the print, that they can't do it because they have to prove that [unintelligible]
MooreThey know, they signaled the day that they did to satisfy the same group,
DeanOh, but they
Mooreand we'll run into the weed. It launched,
NixonWell, I told, I told Haldeman that Ervin's hard on the committee. It could be possible.
DeanAll right.
NixonNow that, that Republicans
DeanWell they don't have weapons, beyond history,
MooreYeah, what we have is good anyway.
NixonYeah.
DeanAnd this thing has less to do as you get it. Now they get behind it and study it,
NixonYeah.
MooreThey'll have to have an answer.
DeanThey'll, and that the highest point,
NixonMm-hmm.
Deanthe executive, we had the absolute power of the presidency, there will be no cooperation whatever.
DeanAnd he did then raw file, he did the summary of the investigation, we got a blank wall.
DeanAnd then they've come back
NixonRight.
Deaneven after the staff [unintelligible] God bless Truman.
MooreThat's what was going to be used, but uh then I think that through it, and that was one problem there.
DeanThey're they are throwing stones in glass houses. And I I've started maybe there ought to be a couple of stories leaked through some people.
MooreThe Democrats didn't Nobody has anything. It's like this one didn't get out, because the Democrats are walking into a bear trap.
DeanYou know, and find out about their own conduct, about their own conduct.
DeanThese investigations do they reflect that other people have knowledge of this, you know, they're they're not a whole lot better off.
NixonWell,
DeanMaybe we can scare them.
DeanWell, let's see, what what they might just think is what they're doing. It also indicated that uh we get more of this stuff out in the public eye,
NixonUh-huh.
Deanthan the Republicans aren't the only ones that have ever engaged in in bad conduct.
DeanIt's very hard to get this I'd be willing to get any kind of play on our side of this. That's then we have to really work on it.
NixonAll right.
DeanOkay.
MooreGood. All right, I feel fine. Much better.
Nixon[laughter] It's going to be a long
DeanPretty tough.
Nixontough thing. What is it? Ervin's going to go on for a long, long, and uh uh But see
MooreYeah.
Nixonthe the uh
DeanIf he can't get,
MooreIt's hard to get. I don't see that.
DeanUh, I think what it really gets down to, Mr. President, they
DeanThis is an entire Democratic press, and devoid of good issues. So they got to have this.
NixonOkay, we'll see the factor tomorrow. See you later.
  • 037-102 12:25 PM · 14 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:25 pm and 12:27 pm.
  • 419-021 12:25 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 12:25 pm and 12:27 pm.
  • 419-036 12:25 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 12:25 pm and 12:27 pm.
  • 879-006 12:25 PM · 26 sec — Unknown person(s) and United States Secret Service agents met in the Oval Office of the White House on an unknown date, sometime between 12:25 pm on March 14, 1973 and 11:16 am on March 15, 1973.
  • 037-103 12:27 PM · 39 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and John W. Dean, III talked on the telephone from 12:27 pm to 12:28 pm.
  • 419-022 12:27 PM · 36 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and John W. Dean, III met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 12:27 pm to 12:28 pm.
  • 037-104 1:30 PM · 15 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 1:30 pm and 4:09 pm.
  • 419-024 1:30 PM · 32 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 1:30 pm and 4:09 pm.

Conversation 419-023, March 14, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/419-023 (accessed November 20, 2026).