Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 421 › Conversation 421-018

Nixon, Haldeman & Dean on Watergate and Grand Jury

Wednesday, March 21, 1973 · 4:53 PM–6:01 PM ET · Old Executive Office Building · 1 hr 7 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Ziegler, Ronald L.; White House operator; Rogers, William P.; Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob"); Dean, John W., III; Ehrlichman, John D.Conversation421-018 on Tape 421StartWednesday, March 21, 1973 at 4:53 PMEndWednesday, March 21, 1973 at 6:01 PMRecording deviceOld Executive Office BuildingSourceNixon Library record for 421-018 ↗

President Nixon met with H.R. Haldeman, John Dean, and John Ehrlichman to discuss strategy and public relations concerning the Watergate scandal. They debated various approaches to managing the ongoing investigations and press inquiries, including the potential benefits of a new grand jury, releasing a presidential statement, and attacking the Senate committee. The conversation also touched upon historical precedents for handling such crises and the potential impact of different disclosure strategies on the administration's standing.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 25.7 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 5.7 MB

On March 21, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, Ronald L. Ziegler, White House operator, William P. Rogers, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, John W. Dean, III, and John D. Ehrlichman met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 4:53 pm to 6:01 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 421-018 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 421-18

Date: March 21, 1973
Time: 4:53 pm-6:01 pm
Location: Executive Office Building

The President met with Ronald L. Ziegler.

       News report
            -Detroit

       Press briefing
             -Kenneth R. Cole, Jr.
             -Gerald L. Warren
             -Food prices
             -Positive tone

       Watergate
                                              -12-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 421-18 (cont’d)

            -President’s statement
                  -A letter
                        -Questions from press
            -Strategy
                  -Statement on Dwight L. Chapin
                  -Disclosures for the record
                        -Washington Post story
                        -Public reaction
            -Grand jury
                  -Convocation
                  -Findings
                        -Investigations of H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman, John D. Ehrlichman,
Charles W. Colson, Donald H. Segretti
            -Statement by President
                  -Attack on Ervin Committee
                        -William J. Baroody, Jr.
                        -Infringement on constitutional principles
                               -Publicity
            -“5 percenter cases”

The President talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 4:53 pm and
Show the rest of the log (89 more lines)
4:58 pm.

[Conversation No. 421-18A]

[See Conversation No. 37-194]

[End of telephone conversation]

       Watergate
            -Harry S. Truman administration

The President talked with William P. Rogers between 4:58 pm and 5:00 pm.

[Conversation No. 421-18B]

[See Conversation No. 37-195]

[End of telephone conversation]
                                             -13-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                         Conversation No. 421-18 (cont’d)

      Watergate
           -Gen. Harry H. Vaughn’s testimony during Dwight D. Eisenhower administration
           -Chapin
           -President’s statement
                 -John W. Dean, III’s call to Segretti
                 -Segretti’s activities
                 -Disclosure of information
                 -Haldeman
                       -Knowledge of Chapin and Segretti
                 -Segretti’s activities
                 -White House staff testimony
                       -Letters
                 -Segretti case
                       -Case of bad judgment
           -Attacks on administration
           -Grand jury
                 -White House staff testimony
                       -Dean
                 -Investigation
                       -Advantage to administration over Senate hearing
           -Ervin hearings
           -Letter
           -President’s statement
                 -Timing

Haldeman and Dean entered at 5:20 pm.

      Trip to California
            -Press relations
            -Assistance
            -John Ford dinner

      Watergate
           -Publicity for administration's side

      Press relations
            -White House correspondents
            -Television [TV]
                                              -14-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                               Conversation No. 421-18 (cont’d)

             -[Unintelligible]
             -Banquet
                  -Format
                  -Timing
                  -Questions for President
                         -Watergate

       Theodore H. White

Ehrlichman entered and Ziegler left at 5:25 pm.

[A transcript of the remainder of the conversation may be found in 8RPC, pp. 131-145; U.S. vs.
Mitchell, Ex. 13, pp. 00208-00236 (1-27); SRPC, pp. 250-269 (1-20); RG 460, Box 171, pp 1-38;
SI Pres. Nixon, pp. 56, 185; SI, Bk. III, pt. 2, pp. 1149-1180 (1-38); Bk. VII, pt. 4, pp. 1831-2
(20-21)].

An unknown man entered and left at an unknown time during the transcribed portion.

[End of transcribed portion]

Haldeman, Dean, and Ehrlichman left at 6:01 pm.

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 2 parts and the right one starts.

ZieglerYes sir.
ZieglerOn our [unintelligible] there's a riot in Detroit. They're shutting down the uh news blocks today. It's a circus. It takes on NBC now.
NixonOh, yeah?
ZieglerMm-hmm. Quite an open uh quite an open [unintelligible] I won't eat dinner tonight.
NixonYeah. Yeah. How are your [unintelligible]?
ZieglerVery good today. Very good. We did a briefing. Ken Cole briefed. [unintelligible] showed decent positive on the food prices. Better than anything else in the whole briefing.
ZieglerThe food price aspect expressed deep concern that steps that were taken by him about it did the did a lot.
ZieglerSo we had a positive play and nice control of positive play, which we can't ignore, but we had today's positive carrier [unintelligible].
NixonFuck we've got to we've got to drive in. What are our spirits? What are our spirits going to be like?
Ziegler[unintelligible] Good gosh. I know, but good gosh.
ZieglerThey just ducked out from [unintelligible] but they aren't going to stick with it that much longer, it raises so many hell. The President [unintelligible]
NixonWell, how do you think the I mean the generally Watergate and so forth? Anything that you think of over that statement that raises a lot of questions?
ZieglerWell that's my point, that position, I look at the version of the letter.
ZieglerWell first of all I'd say if you can put out a letter, it would be very good to put out a letter.
NixonYeah.
ZieglerBut I was addressing my comments from the first draft in points number two, three, five, six, four, seven where the question is not answered.
NixonYeah.
Zieglerbut it's raised and once you raise in a public document like that questions, then it focused attention on them and, and, and there happen to be six follow up questions immediately to a press conference in there.
NixonWhat do you think of the [unintelligible] I'm sure that we can
Nixondecide not to all way honest [unintelligible] not at all.
ZieglerMy judgment would hold that if there were a way and a way could be found to make our position clear
NixonPut on the record. Put it on the record, four or five hundred pages.
Ziegler[unintelligible] fall back on and always have. But every time that you answer it, it still cannot [unintelligible]
NixonSee also, the whole point is, too, that every time you raise something like, I was thinking of that rather inoffensive statement about Dwight Chapin. If you hadn't checked that fact that is fundamentally correct, if we knew that the way you'd handle that that is to say, they raise that, again, I would say for example, way I'd handle it. Well, for example, the Washington Post had a story that said Dwight Chapin this is fundamentally correct, they go and look at the facts of who was this, well, that's what
NixonSee, that way you can handle it. On the other hand, I think a lot of people I think a lot of people are knocking down every damn thing that comes back and doing
Zieglera lot of people who they say rather than just hit back, a lot of people they just want to know, "Why the hell doesn't the President say something? We hear something. You send someone. Why don't you--? Why don't you respond? Why don't you find a way to say something?"
NixonYeah.
ZieglerYeah.
NixonThe course what I propose to, it's already, it's already, another way you can go.
ZieglerAnother way you can do it, of course, is you can ask for another grand jury.
NixonThat's right. See what you do there,
ZieglerSure.
Nixonafter they finish this thing, then ask for, ask the prosecutor to call another grand jury and everybody in the White House can testify. And you know, we'll start a bloody trump and just let everybody go.
ZieglerThat way, when they go into the grand jury, that cuts off their-- they've got to give their view.
NixonYes, sir.
ZieglerThe hearings are--
NixonRight, for a whole year.
ZieglerFor a whole year, you have-- That's a good-- yeah. See what
NixonWell, let's look at the--
ZieglerThe grand jury has witnessed anything and every aspect of this case, yes.
NixonWell at least they'd have Haldeman, they'd have Ehrlichman, they'd have Colson. Well they wouldn't have Colson.
ZieglerFrankly, we have Colson. And had Stans. They'd have all--
NixonEhrlichman, Haldeman, and knock off
ZieglerAnd they'd say, all come out and say, "Here it is, and all of these, in light of all these dietary secret meetings that have been held--"
NixonRight.
Zieglerthen we would tell them.
NixonThat's another way to take the offensive, Ron.
ZieglerYes, sir.
NixonThe other, the only other thing is, we can't take a stance where we hunker down and say, "We're going to fight all summer this thing, and then you've got to have that fact that they wanted."
ZieglerThat's right, Mr. President.
NixonYou can't allow a situation where we want every detail, you know, everything, that you're going to attack the committee for wanting the facts. You say, "We've offered this information.
ZieglerYes, we have.
NixonNow, you've got that story out. We offered [unintelligible] at my additional portion [unintelligible] that didn't [unintelligible] to you. That's, gee, that's up one day in the press, and we offered, and so the committee then, and you keep coming back to that. What's the matter with the committee? If they want the facts, why don't they ask for them? Or they just being stubborn? They want it done their way, or it's got to be done the right way. That's the way I'd get it.
ZieglerThey're insisting that it only be their way. Their way, their way [unintelligible]
Nixonvery seriously infringes upon constitutional principles that the President is sworn to uphold.
ZieglerUphold, that's right. And this doesn't help us get the facts. We've got them anyway. That's his view, Mr. President. But they're not trying to get the facts.
NixonI think that's the can we can assemble, assemble to prove it, and everything he did
ZieglerBill Baroody, um, came in and he was fostering their haven't got anywhere [unintelligible] they're fostering really punching. For certain, that we've got problems in how to handle this case now.
NixonYes, sir.
ZieglerAnd I think probably by afternoon tomorrow it's an issue that could be promising.
NixonOne thing incidentally, I can check. That I haven't watched much check, uh,
ZieglerYou'll remember, the old, that they call the five percent cases.
NixonSecretary Rogers, please.
NixonSecretary Sloan before they asked about presidents, I ordered you go back to, wonder where it was. It's true it's called up, too.
ZieglerYeah, it's good.
NixonToo much knowledge with the
NixonBack.
NixonHello?
NixonOh, Bill, I wonder I was sitting talking to Ron here. So, uh, I couldn't remember. Uh, you know when you handled the five-percenter cases years ago, you remember, back in 1948?
NixonThe, the point is, uh, did you, did you have Harry Vaughn to testify?
NixonYeah.
NixonYeah, yeah. But he was, did you, did you try to get anybody else from the
Rogersfrom the White House.
NixonYeah. Were there any reviews of how long, did that figure arise in that line?
RogersThe first point was, upon this case, then a person could quite uniquely have happened. charged with charged with an all being charged with that.
NixonThat's the point, the Boss Tweed, sure, sure, sure. That thing is true of shark cooks that have grabbed both hands, a lot.
RogersHere it is.
NixonYeah.
RogersAnd they did I don't think it was as clear as that, but he asked [unintelligible] asked [unintelligible]
Nixonwhatever because he was honest about that.
RogersSure. Sure.
RogersAnd that takes also the virtual public.
NixonYeah. Yeah. Well, you know, we declared it where the facts,
Rogersright.
RogersYeah.
NixonBoy, did I I know you told me, but this morning I urge you.
RogersAs a matter of fact, the it's actually a 5 volt. it's actually 5 volt defense and national security. He would care about the whole thing too. It has I put my swallowed by the National Security budget and that being the best plus, a military section.
Rogersquestion
NixonRight.
RogersI had talked I had talked with myself [unintelligible] they're all, you know, the big guys [unintelligible] he wouldn't come out the first thing that you want [unintelligible] Anyway,
RogersDent and Weicker both told me they were so surprised by it, and they brought it up with me and said, "You say this is important for First? 75% of us will support it." Said, "We've always talked about it."
RogersSo, I said, "Well, how about the story about Rogers?
RogersThey called it bullshit and horrible. And I said, "Well, [unintelligible]
RogersI think we can do pretty well on the Republican side [unintelligible] I think, I took 43 votes. I had been on both vents, The thing I'm concerned about basically, actually, as some of them they couldn't run [unintelligible]
Rogersif the more partisan people get picked for a reading, this is a way to screw to screw up the peace. Now, that's what's at stake here.
NixonRight.
RogersRight.
NixonThe nomination, you got to understand,
Nixonnow, that I mean that I think that's it's been pretty clear. As a matter of fact, when I made it again, you know, in January of 1971, the January 25th speech, and that was all about that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
RogersGood. Yeah. The the other thing I wanted to ask you, this one on OAS, was Steve was asking me about the OAS thing. And as you know, I very good,
RogersIf you were to be in Florida work it out, what how do you feel about it, sir? If it comes to that, how do you mean is it-
NixonWell, if it's if it's the jet the gesture to Latin America. The problem is if you're I got I don't have to be back. I thought of doing it on the fall, except I got Vietnam and all the other. 11/8, I can get in at sometime. We've got to get Fowler in on all these and we got and what we're really doing, we're worrying about
NixonSee, see we got now and they're all they're all got to be and then uh So, who was gonna be dinner and all,
Rogersyeah.
NixonWell, Certainly no, I I would say this: I think that someone has an [unintelligible] a dinner at night is not that much of a problem, but if you have to have the welcoming ceremonies, and all that crap, that that shoots the day.
RogersYeah.
NixonThe OAS, the only thing that occurred to me is, well a gesture to Latin America so much in the news with the canal, docs in Santa Maria, oh that's a lot of argument I didn't know if you were into it but, a gesture of almost any sort, a reception, or the handshaker back and forth. But I would probably have to stay, since I
RogersWell, sir,
NixonNow, how long did they last in April 4th?
NixonAll right. Well, I'd rather consider it if it's if it's if it's not that much work provided that
Unknown[unintelligible]
NixonWell, what do you think is going to happen?
ZieglerWell, looking at it either way, Mr. President, I was just thinking [clears throat] the Dean option, the Dean statement scenario.
ZieglerI I suppose that there are two if not more options. One is [unintelligible] Chapin [unintelligible]
Zieglertwo ways, honest. One is to move ahead, the other is to let him bring it up and then we respond to it.
ZieglerThe other is to cross the bridge now of saying that Chapin put them that's really no shock. See, this is what we got into when that Dean letter came out.
ZieglerOnce even you say, not you, but we say that Dean saw Segretti in Miami, then he got whole series. Now, if we cross the bridge it really isn't that difficult that difficult now. But
Zieglerif you if that is done, then I think you're moving all the way to the other option. If that is done,
Zieglerthere's not that much there to redeem on. But the standpoint from the impression of the whole question once, I think would require some final statement by the President, which states
Zieglerthat whatever took place, you know, in this type of activity, although there were no [unintelligible]
NixonThat is something that I would rather do rather than hold a press conference. I would think that that should just be a letter
Nixonto the committee. That's what I would say. Now, I—your hearing began, you say we'll do this, we'll furnish all the information with regard to this and that [unintelligible]
Nixonbased upon the report of the Dean hearing, and such and such and such and such and such. Whack! Now, it takes even Bob Haldeman's name [unintelligible]
ZieglerThe truth is not that bad anyway. The fact of the matter is, let's say that Bob did know that Chapin was putting Segretti in motion. None of I happened to know what a different bit of truth.
NixonUnited against [unintelligible]
ZieglerYeah, but although he did not know of Segretti, this thing was put in motion now. When did it come to a head? When
Zieglerthe Watergate thing and the short-circuited hands broke down and it became part of a broad [unintelligible], that made everyone say, "Now wait a minute! You know, that's bad, and we should be convicted for that, but let's make sure nothing else [unintelligible] is going on." Then, there was an examination of the operation.
NixonIt's Bob's
ZieglerHelp, and separate it from Watergate. Because if you do send a letter saying Chapin was taking an emotional part, if there is not a stop gap put on it in this final statement, won't you they're just either way it's either way as I see it, the head.
NixonExcept that by sending the letter that you could respond to them. Well, we told you that. Maybe they might shoot back at that.
ZieglerWell, I don't even know.
NixonThey might say, "Well, you have—"
Zieglersay to be a final letter from the counsel, not only information about the dean, but information on the whole activity, and it could be responding, or sending a letter on your instructions, see, technically better than by you.
NixonAnd then, I have been directed to furnish all the information that I have. Here it is, and I'll be glad to answer further questions, if you wish to, in writing.
ZieglerAnd then the president instruct instruct us to that effect, or directed this to be done. And and the the initial frankly could could deal with all that Dean's done, at your direction, the following is a summary of the facts behind each of these assertions.
NixonMm-hmm.
ZieglerSee? It was covered by Mr. Dean's letter, you know, for propriety, and was considered bad judgment.
ZieglerBad judgment of course is something that is unfortunate, and may be regretted, but the other side will qualify that check, but you can, and they can make that point clear. And then they could put some applause for that portion.
NixonSure.
ZieglerThat scenario also we never got the option by Ron, we
Nixonwere, so this letter [unintelligible]
Ziegler[unintelligible]
NixonThat is what I was afraid of. If the letter is not well prepared [unintelligible]
ZieglerIf we ship quick, that's that's this is [unintelligible]
Nixon[unintelligible]
ZieglerI don't know the specifics of how to deal with this, but I think
NixonWell, it is
Zieglerbecause I think taking it piecemeal the way it is you will run on. Others are going to have to do it anyway. If they're [unintelligible]
ZieglerWell, that's bad. The rules of study [unintelligible] fresh [unintelligible] to come to close on this.
ZieglerAt this point that would create not be hard, but it would have covered up. That's why some definitive statement by Mr. Dean or someone on the panel can clear it, and we'll be done with it.
NixonYeah. It may be that's the way to say, "Are people disgusted with—" What a beautiful attitude you have. So that you can count on [unintelligible]
ZieglerThat's that's that would be a way in which Now, the legal route,
NixonGrand jury
Ziegleris having
Nixonconvocation.
ZieglerFirst. Yeah, that's why we do it. And also has some the grand jury which should be officially reopened on the grounds that this other testimony occurred in the open case and that there have been a reopened charge on a reopened case.
ZieglerThese charges have been made since, then. You know what I mean? The idea of taking the initiative, the idea of the President, himself, rather than
Zieglerhaving the Senate say we want the Senate to find out. Why the hell wouldn't the grand jury find out? Much better procedure.
NixonWell, talking to that effect, wouldn't we?
ZieglerWell, I think the scenario there it has to be
Ziegleryears. The difficult part, absolutely the difficult part is to walk the sensitive line between someone having done this in an unauthorized manner, and they took it upon themselves to serve. That's the way they look at it. Now, the operation, and that is the fact.
ZieglerSo we talk about that in taking it down. They have
Nixon[unintelligible]
ZieglerA statement could be found that would cover Mr. Dean's letter, you know, for propriety, of course, but it had little to, or no relationship to, but little relationship to the Watergate.
ZieglerDean's letter addresses only Segretti.
NixonNow that's to the, that other the other thing though would be the grand jury.
ZieglerYeah.
ZieglerCourse the other thing that again run into the earlier discussion we had, is also a matter of time,
Zieglerin terms of when this should be dealt with, assuming that it's going to be dealt with.
NixonAt some point, in the next two or three years.
ZieglerIt would be far better to have it done today. Now at the early stage in this term,
Zieglerthe 2nd term, than it is, you know, in 1950, in 1974 or '5.
Nixon'74, or '75, or '76. '75 would be [unintelligible] That's right.
Deanto have something like that for everything that we've accomplished, what we've achieved
NixonWell,
NixonWhat is that?
DeanThree documents about what my thought is as far as the presidential statement concerned.
Nixon[unintelligible]
DeanJust to lay out the thought I've, they're going to have to have something, more of that. It's just a, a plan for how to do it. Plus the fact you get down to the study, well, uh,
DeanWell, I think that would be helpful, Mr. President. I think it would be worth considering though, something that would be,
Deanthat'd be broad, more better insurance, and so forth, because that's what, apparently the conversation with the press, the right amount of White House response. If I would make an actual, serious, sober assessment
NixonWhat about the situation, John?
DeanI think this might do it. You could get it direct to the home through television and so forth, right? They get our story out that day at least. I talked to Bob Murphy today who was very impressed about that.
DeanA possibility, he said, was the press could not do anything. He, he recommended the banquet for the leadership, dinner for the leadership. Absolutely buy time to do it in the traditional format, he said. Some people are using the occasion for speech with an anniversary,
Deanuh, at the end of March or that April. He called back later and said, "Well, might be another way to go on national television with a large audience, cheers, applause, that sort of thing. They submit their questions and they have, and so forth. They get their form out.
DeanAnd it would better than having a dean on Watergate here, where everything's been said about that. But this would be considered one of the options had at an hour or the other.
NixonUh, Bob told you about the meeting with Rogers?
DeanYes, he did.
NixonGo round and round and, uh, all questions and no answers, back to where we started. Where we were. Go ahead.
DeanThe, well, I, I just don't think the immunity thing will wash. Grand jury. It may If you talk to Elliott, you know, because that's what he called everybody else. It's a key feature of Janus's on down to a grand jury indictment. He was, uh, the, the immunity though for various witnesses to go before a grand jury, I, I think would have to be handled that, it's not a
Deanvery, oh, a plea to the grand jury or even a try to send a special, that has to be, you ask for a panel to investigate and report back on a whole bag, everything that's been, that's gone on here. And as witnesses show, they'll, they all have to have a can of, have a gag. And, there'd be any fight for presidential panel.
DeanI don't think they'd do that. Well, that would take special legislation to give immunity powers where the Department doesn't right now possess them. Really grasping. Well, that's taken a grand jury without impunity. How about that? Well, there's your idea to get out of it, now.
DeanAnd I think that's a, and there's no impossibility. At least listen for a grasping. Results, absolutely, they may snatch it. And, they're going to want to lock somebody's front gate.
DeanUh, what, how we end up with people in and out of the White House indicted for various, for various offenses.
NixonWait a minute. Can civilly, civilly, yeah, that's right.
DeanNow the other, another route that is worth kind of, actually I wouldn't, I wouldn't spend too much time on it. Now, let me just go off there. Uh, the other route would be to pay this, or posture. You pay this. The third person who asked me, "How can we explain? Where does mine,
Deanwhere does mine really back?" And, uh, if you disagree as to whether that's a viable option or not. I, I think you can get out for a relatively black with the same stuff. And, what have you got back, of a criminal story.
DeanAnd would have the effect of maybe becoming a battleground on a reduced scope, which makes it important that we wait, play the game through the early hearing. Licentious, or run out leads into areas that that would be better not to have to get into.
DeanYou could, you could hate it, that they're straight. And you could put on a basic document that would work. Good morning. It would be sufficient. Even if you want to be able to participate fully in the party,
Deanit might have some, something obviously that you couldn't play. The point about that sir, is anybody who written that 34? No. That's the other, that's the option, true? But it, it might take it out of it down this whole time, which it didn't.
DeanYeah, and everything. There are reasons why we talk about that. We talk about, um, possible opportunities in the Senate. They may turn up that we won't foresee now. You feel like that fight would be odd. You can't put out fires yet.
DeanProbably the Hunt thing and possibly reward for some of these other people for Is there no, there's no,
NixonBlackmail. That's right.
DeanNo, that's the case that they're, what they're going to do is blackmail. Well, about that, sir.
DeanWell, my, my view is that that, uh, Hunt's in for a slide. He may depart, if he can. And that ought to be, some heart into one of the options that he's hoping to get his attorney to turn back. He's, he's, you're in contact with John. How's that going?
DeanI think I'm doing good. This is, you know, $120,000 for, and I take it that's already to spill, you know? But he's got to get that in Christmas in. That's right. And the other, obviously, uh, he's got to figure his, his cross-wires that blow if that blows.
DeanAnd, and that's, it seems to me, to be, uh, all it is, unless someone has another canyon body talking, get parted, in the, the clerk the court. Finally options, obviously nothing has come back from what they had dealt with judge, before sentencing. And I know the judge might be called in before sentencing
Deanthat says, "All right. I'm willing to tell all. Uh, I don't want to go to jail. I'll plead guilty to what I have to, so I'll take that plea, but I don't want to go to jail. I'll cooperate. It will become pretty well impossible, okay? They have no idea how.
NixonAnd does that probably get, uh,
DeanUh, 100%.
Rogerssee the problem, you can-
NixonYeah.
RogersAnd that happened. So, if we fight the act, we got Richard Kleindienst across there, and he's got to cross-examine and question Sloan. That's what will happen.
NixonYeah.
RogersWhat's he going to look like?
DeanThat's right.
RogersHe'll look bad.
DeanHe'll look very bad.
RogersNow, what-
HaldemanThat's why I'm not confident either, I mean with you, Mr. Secretary.
RogersIt's a long road. The way you look back upon it, you see, the thing about that, that's why it's been a long road.
DeanIt's a problem. A problem.
RogersThat's why you're, that's why you are best to decide to get another direction.
RogersAll right, now not only that road, but in this circle of people that got into this thing now, there are a lot of intermediate people. Any one of those, because of the rush, the secretary, the orderly, uh, the small fry who- who've been acquitted.
DeanRight.
RogersWhat's happening?
RogersThey're not, they're not going to fall on a sword for a civil, a civil, blah blah blah.
NixonSomebody making $10,000 [unintelligible]
RogersYeah. What is this? This stuff didn't come out. We're hand in glove with that Senate committee, and they'll take that position, especially since they didn't do anything.
RogersAnd what can the grand jury say? Well, we don't believe the Senate committee. Well, damn fool grand jury like this,
DeanNo.
Rogerswill just go ahead and believe the other way. Have these people come out, come forward,
DeanAnd involve the staff.
Rogersand protect themselves. Why should they face perjury charges? [cough] Now, for these two reasons,
RogersI thought the facts are going to come out, Colson and the people who are involved.
RogersNow we take, how do we handle a self-protection step?
DeanWhat's next?
RogersIf you're faced with a situation that you can't prevent, how do you listen?
RogersAre we good at self-protection? Do you hide it out?
HaldemanWell now, that's, that's what your survey replied. No, I thought, it's not harm the people.
RogersIt's too late for that.
HaldemanWe wanna harm the people. We can't avoid that.
RogersWe can't, we can't harm the, uh, steps you've taken.
Nixon[unintelligible]
RogersPartly because what they did certainly was not the best because
HaldemanWell, I think the question is ready.
RogersYou don't have any question here of somebody
Rogerssnatching money in his pocket. What- all it, and even like this is something, this is something, this,
NixonTeapot Dome and Sherman Adams.
RogersTeapot Dome, Sherman Adams. Did anyone take it for his own personal comfort, here?
DeanNo, they didn't.
RogersAlbert Fall did it for his own enrichment. John, that's the point, that's why I say that, [clears throat]
RogersNow we have to realize that,
Rogersthat's your point. All of our, in his point,
Rogersand to give him an opportunity to do something like that. But it's also, I think,
Rogersone can instruct that,
Rogersyour missive, your concern about-
UnknownYes. Now, there are other things. Do you like to get all of this information and lay it before the public? Is it not going to come out, people are going to take the fifth amendment, words were never proved. All right.
UnknownAnd isn't that coming out of, they say it's going to come out, but they add it. Now, for those reasons, the heart of that very well may end up [unintelligible].
UnknownThat's right. Or it may never come out, they mean they can probably never get that, either, regardless of how tough their hearing is. But now is the time to pull the horror out instead of having to live with it forever.
UnknownAll right, so therefore [unintelligible] select a panel or a select a special assistant, tell him the head of the criminal division, the head of the civil division, something like that, to call over everybody in the White House.
UnknownAnd tell him, you want, by instructions from the president, you're going to put together exactly what happened, and we don't want you prosecuted for it, because that's not the point now. The point is to get out all of this information.
UnknownAnd then you will make a decision based on what you learn, whether these people can remain in the government or not. And if that's out, then nobody will know that they'll be forced to resign. Something like that.
UnknownIt's possible everyone would get out.
UnknownMay do a great deal to ease this, this suspicion. It seemed that it kind of covered up before, they did try to cover up the information. Now they realize it's regular, it's legal. I'm not so sure how many people will come out guilty, now, after that, the perception is the point.
DeanYeah. What if we do
UnknownAll right, is that, is that better, or is it better to have, uh, just, uh, keep going, and having it build up and all of a sudden collapse? And people can indict you, but go.
DeanYes, sir.
UnknownNaturally, we can show that the President continues covering up that way. That's one possibility. Or there is another way. Yeah, quite, quite. The, the Dean statements
Unknownwhere the President then makes a full disclosure of everything which he then has. And is in a position if it does collapse later on to say,
UnknownI didn't have the FBI, I didn't have the grand jury, I had my own counsel. They've totally lied to me, but I did find, and I rested my confidence in those people who proved, and it's obvious now.
HaldemanA middle-ground thing would be-
Unknown[unintelligible] [laughter] [crosstalk] That's right. That's right, yeah.
Unknown[unintelligible] You, as the White House counsel,
Dean[unintelligible]
Unknownwhich is very general, I understand.
Dean[unintelligible]
Unknownbased upon John's review of the investigation he came to this man, about this, this man about this, this man. If he does that, I am going to have to say that on Donald Segretti. I think he should do that.
DeanYeah, Segretti would be covered. That has to be said. And, so forth, and that has to be, Segretti has to be seen. Right.
UnknownIf you do this, to give some weight to that, you attack this an appendix, a list of the FBI reports which he has access to, interview with Kalmbach, interview with Segretti, interview with Chapin, interview with whoever the name.
UnknownSo the president is telling me the other kind is
Zieglerand what you can say.
NixonI replied.
ZieglerYeah, he also cooperated by taking that. That's right.
HaldemanIt also helps the the Gray situation, because it shows the use made of the FBI reports by you in the course of your work. You're saying there, "I'm not supposed to contest this with anybody else. He has filed his"—
Nixon"I had access to reports for the purpose of carrying out your instructions to find out whether anybody in the White House—here are the people I've talked with. And on the basis of the FBI reports and the reports of people that are around them, that's what I said."
HaldemanI think it puts puts us in a stronger position later and the presidency in a stronger position later if you can be shown to have done the job at this point in time.
NixonWell, the there's the argument now that Dean's credibility is in question. Ah, it was great, and maybe I could build the Dean thing. Why not?
HaldemanIt's not really credibility. You could crack the hell out—as a matter of fact, I don't think his credibility's in much jeopardy. Sure, he's under attack, and they want him up there to testify. I don't think it's credibility. They want him to testify. I would not be too sensitive about that. I think they move on, and they make a hell of a good impression.
HaldemanBeyond that, you can, you can help your, your participation in interviews by saying, uh, in addition to having seen the the FBI synopsis, you were present at the time of the interview of a number of these persons, and you yourself conducted the interviews—
DeanOh, others, I conducted the interviews with all of these people.
NixonI'm just trying to figure out if there's any hole in this damn thing.
HaldemanAnd that you're doing this in furtherance of your role and also that you would prevent such a a lot of crap coming out about uh what you have done and uh and without regarding to the fact. Well, who would make the basic report?
DeanWell, the President, he says,
Haldemancould announce the other reason for this would be a relief to me to say that now the you would face the fact now that the jury's—
NixonNow let me know. "He can now make the report and not jeopardy—" Well,
HaldemanNo, that's what you should say.
NixonOtherwise, he gave the report because you asked him for it, regardless of the timing of this. Yeah, John followed that and that the Liddy and and the whole as long as the appeals take time on Friday.
DeanYeah.
NixonBlow all of the [unintelligible] Friday and I'm ahead of that. I think you could say that, you could say
Nixonuh, "I had a report. I am not showing Ervin. I will not publish because some of it's private cases fell on—" Well,
DeanLet me say, the problem with that is, uh—
NixonI don't think that helps on our cause. In fact, if, fact is, well, I can see this for— I'm not sure. Maybe I'm wrong. The fact is the President says, "I showed Ervin." What's covered under here is nobody's business. I think something that's clever we put out something covering
HaldemanIf you're worried about the timing, it's trying to hang it on the sentencing, and you don't really have to do that for Dean to say, just ignore the timing, and say you have then had this this this what's happened anyway, Dean has given you a report. We basically said it's an oral report, you could report the fact that Dean has kept you posted from time to time with periodic oral reports
NixonRight.
Haldemanas uh as the thing as as uh as as it's begun to develop and so forth. You have asked him now to summarize those uh into a overall summary.
NixonOverall summary, and I'm making the report available to the Ervin very public. And that, I handed it to Ervin. I can hand it to the Ervin Committee. I'll offer it to the Ervin Committee. I'd say there, Senator Ervin. There is a very, very, full report before you hear any other, you have, we have this. And as I have said previously, that if you've got questions that are not answered here, White House staff, they will be directed to answer, any, in formal—
Unknown[unintelligible]
DeanNow let's suppose you did that, and you did it as to the burglary and you did it as to the money. Correct.
DeanAnd you [unintelligible]
DeanAnd also suppose on the hunt vult situation that I was an investigator, we sat down and did an investigation [unintelligible]
Deanand when we discovered what he was up to, we stopped it. [unintelligible]
DeanNow let's suppose that the Ellsberg, now, search and seizure that may be sufficient at least for a mis-trial and not for getting a [unintelligible] [clears throat] all right, that keeps them all right, they'll go on a while yet.
DeanWell let's suppose that occurred that was an international security situation, exercising bad judgement [unintelligible] never ever been employed by the committee after that after all.
DeanI mean, I mean reflects upon his judgement that way. But beyond that [unintelligible] getting back to this, John.
Nixon[unintelligible]
Deanobviously it's been a great harm. You have a cancer growing on the presidency. [unintelligible]
Dean[unintelligible]
Dean[unintelligible]
Deanwhich I, they rely on. And now, there's this later payment comes up and I didn't know about that. And if I had known about that before, obviously I would have, but I don't know about it now.
NixonYour point John, is that we need to get the cancer out now.
DeanYes, sir. Well how do you do that? You see another way. You see another way than to
Nixonwithout, without Senate, without breaking down the Executive Privilege parts?
DeanI see, you know, a couple of ways you could do it.
NixonCertainly don't want to have the Senate committee do it.
DeanThat's the, that's the worst thing. We've got to do it. We've got to do it. You have to do it.
DeanYou get the credit for it. [unintelligible]
DeanAnd say, "I said they work on this. My counsel reports that they will work. Here it is. Finally."
Dean[unintelligible]
Dean[unintelligible] No, over the dead bodies you send a report over that says, "We're doing this fast."
EhrlichmanAnd then the greater the always
DeanWell, it is. But, this 380, anybody could come in and say,
EhrlichmanThe whole other phenomenon, sure. Well, why don't you do Well, I still tell that you would You sure as hell don't do it in the White House. You draw them out you get uh all the numbers, the names on that hat,
Deanand you draw them out, and see who gets hurt and who doesn't hurt. Jeez.
EhrlichmanThat's right. That's about the very thing you're being confronted with.
DeanDraw, do the same damn thing with it. Draw.
EhrlichmanRight. That's a good idea. That's if you have a problem. Uh, a problem of knowledge, yes, a problem of knowledge.
DeanEverybody has a problem of that.
EhrlichmanAction is pretty Well, Stans, Stans money, that's one.
DeanYeah.
DeanTake white and the the pocket [unintelligible] [whispering] [laughter]
EhrlichmanWhat is what's happened to you is what's happened to John Mitchell.
DeanThat's the interesting kind of thing, that something's there that maybe bowled all of them that way, and there is no, anything starts doing, uh, goes in that direction.
EhrlichmanNow let's take these, these three names that Strachan, Chapin,
DeanSegretti.
Ehrlichmanand Segretti. Now, where does that, where does that take you? That takes you to your shop. It takes you
DeanOther people within the White House were, see, were privy to it all. Who hears about that?
EhrlichmanThen and, then you got another gang of people what, they say, were
DeanWell, if you go your route, you can draw the line now by a scan and say, third party fellows, she can go your route with that.
EhrlichmanThen you're cutting the cancer out of politics, cut it out.
EhrlichmanTake a look.
HaldemanWell, we've got to do is, knock the hell out of the Committee.
EhrlichmanThat's right.
DeanWell, you see you go through and throw Colson's body through, you have asserted
EhrlichmanWell, well, the leader of the pack now, take Chapin, take Segretti,
DeanNow, probably able to get Chapin.
HaldemanChapin's the least, well, certainly Chapin's certainly strong.
DeanI don't think Segretti, well, I think Chapin's strongest, well, Colson's strongest. I think Strachan's toast now that they found this money.
HaldemanYeah.
DeanWhat money? I mean he's an accessory in a in a undeclared campaign fund.
EhrlichmanThat's, that is the only damn responsiblity of the Treasurer, he's the Treasurer.
DeanUnder the law.
EhrlichmanAnd that was for undeclared, why did he send it to me?
DeanYeah, but then it got back into the coffers and uh was used in this campaign.
EhrlichmanAll they can do, well say say the President sends me to a Grand Jury. The Grand Jury. Who would be who could I actively really depend on and publically go for?
DeanAs a practical matter, personally, I'm not. All I can do is get my folks
EhrlichmanThat's right. And they start calling Lee.
DeanRight.
HaldemanAnd they already tried that with Colson.
EhrlichmanWell, that, there again, it is it is with this you don't have to take approximate, like the process that we can do from the outside, problem I have with this is,
DeanWho would you, who would, could call somebody to bring you in, say "John, what does this mean?"
EhrlichmanYes, I don't know how defensible that's all, in that, we got to have a pretty good idea what that's gonna involve,
DeanThere was someone behind the stand.
Ehrlichmanthe autograph, man.
DeanFuck.
HaldemanWho is who is that?
DeanHe said the Republican, they played playing with knowledge that it's safe. Uh
DeanThey have a they have the bumper sticker. Well, that's his problem. That's school stuff.
Haldeman[laughter]
Dean[unintelligible] [laughter]
EhrlichmanI'm gonna be writing a play and a steep uh
DeanIf the Grand Jury is relieved from that situation, that's okay, because they can state that, you know, they did it.
HaldemanThat solves it. Take one more step. Dean does, too.
DeanAnd comes up with a
EhrlichmanThat forces then somebody to ask to go along with the [whispering]
HaldemanWhy not?
DeanI think I would.
HaldemanYeah, but how?
EhrlichmanDid you start back with a bold
Ehrlichman[unintelligible] you know, questions that arise the course of my investigation, but I have no sworn testimony. I didn't take it on that basis." His the answer to everybody could be [unintelligible] not in a position to swear to this. [unintelligible] on the record.
DeanHe thinks it opens up all of your options, Bob.
HaldemanWell, the option first being to move your position in that bottom line. So you have you see that that uh you don't see the uh you don't see the statement thing helping in so far as the-
DeanYou anyway?
HaldemanHelp in so far as- you you must you think that over- [crosstalk]
Dean[crosstalk] I see it as a temporary crack in the dam.
EhrlichmanI agree with that. The trouble is the senior's the way I see the statement this you know our everything we would intend to say [unintelligible] statement anyway. In second [unintelligible]
Ehrlichmanit regards in fact that we've stepped into an ongoing hearing. When you read what I said it we we just can't [unintelligible]. And say, well, again, they offer what quite honestly we offer it to you to know what happened [unintelligible] statement.
EhrlichmanIt's too temporary, but it uh would it mean Sirica would say, well the damned [unintelligible] who knows what he would attack. You'd go on [unintelligible]. And then he will say no, they're not.
DeanHow would ready? I think what will happen is uh I new probably will be so red-hot in a speech in defense of tying his hands.
EhrlichmanYeah. What if he will charge, and I believe [unintelligible] the government presentation on the case that he is not satisfied that it represents the whole situation. Now it's set.
DeanI know, but, I hate to have that dramatic impact on the day [crosstalk]
EhrlichmanYeah. He would dispatch private charges of their hired [unintelligible] Do you think they can come dramatic out like uh you know, appoint a special prosecutor? No.
DeanCan he do that?
EhrlichmanYeah. He could appoint a special prosecutor for a while, or he would reopen the investigation. He could decide to do that. He he can he can present the Grand Jury for a sentencing and I thought about the Grand Jury that morning. We have decided that for a while right after that, and he's got sentencing. And he'll take all these defendants back before a Grand Jury.
DeanThe same ones.
EhrlichmanThe same ones, and see if they won't talk and talk. You'd make a nice, crisp appearance. [unintelligible] no sentence. If they take the fifth, they have no sentence. So if they are helpful, they go back to the Grand Jury, they'll either get sentenced to a small, and if you don't help us you're sentenced-
NixonOh, yeah. You're right, the sentencing.
Ehrlichman[unintelligible] I suppose he doesn't have an inquiry for that, you know, what they could say well,
DeanI don't think that's a surprise move to the defense. I think their counsel must have prepared them for that, [unintelligible]
HaldemanAll right, I wonder, however, how or what they are prepared for.
EhrlichmanWe're damned, but of course we're we're yes. The The only thing that we could say is presume to say, "Well, we've investigated the factors and the horrors of the White House and satisfied on the basis of the report we have that nobody in the White House has been involved in the burglary, nobody had
Ehrlichmanoversight, knowledge of, participated in the planning, or aided or abetted in anyway." Well that's what he said, and that happens to be true. As for that past act- Sure. As for that damn felony.
HaldemanCould John do uh do you want to talk about that? No. I don't think so.
EhrlichmanHow about- Let's try another Let's try another kind of move. How about this? Supposing Mitchell were to step out on that same day, and to say, "I conducted an investigation, as I began on 1,
Ehrlichmanand I find so-and-so and so-and-so with scope of- I don't know what he would say, but maybe you ought to make some kind of disclosure.
HaldemanAt that point what the hell does he want to disclose? He's got to blow something.
  • 037-191 4:41 PM · 13 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at 4:41 pm.
  • 037-192 4:41 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:41 pm and 4:43 pm.
  • 421-014 4:41 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at 4:41 pm.
  • 037-193 4:43 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull talked on the telephone from 4:43 pm to 4:45 pm.
  • 421-016 4:43 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 4:43 pm to 4:45 pm.
  • 421-017 4:45 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Rose Mary Woods met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 4:45 pm and 4:53 pm.
  • 037-194 4:53 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:53 pm and 4:58 pm.
  • 037-195 4:58 PM · 10 min — President Richard M. Nixon and William P. Rogers talked on the telephone from 4:58 pm to 5:00 pm.

Conversation 421-018, March 21, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/421-018 (accessed November 20, 2026).