President Nixon, H.R. Haldeman, John Dean, Julie Nixon Eisenhower, and Charles Colson discussed the ongoing Watergate investigation and potential strategies. Key topics included John Dean's potential grand jury testimony, the possibility of an independent commission, and how to manage public perception. A significant development was the proposal for Attorney General Kleindienst to meet with Judge Sirica to suggest options like a special prosecutor or a new grand jury, coupled with an assurance of full White House cooperation and a waiver of executive privilege.
On March 27, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, John W. Dean, III, Julie Nixon Eisenhower, Charles W. Colson, and unknown person(s) met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 4:20 pm to 5:20 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 423-013 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 423-13
Date: March 27, 1973
Time: 4:20 pm – 5:20 pm
Location: Executive Office Building
The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.
Weather
Watergate
-Richard G. Kleindienst
-Meeting with John D. Ehrlichman
-Postponement
-John W. Dean, III
-John N. Mitchell
-Talk with Haldeman
-Lawrence F. O'Brien
-Jeb Stuart Magruder's testimony
-Talked with Dean
-Dean's testimony before grand jury
-Appearance before grand jury
-John J. Sirica
-Call
-William P. Rogers
-Dean
-Independent commission
-Advantages
-Problem
-Exaggeration of case
-President's discussion with Rogers
-Ehrlichman
-Importance of case
-Other stories
-Ronald L. Ziegler
-Prisoners of war [POWs] release
-News reports
POWs
-21-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 423-13 (cont’d)
Show the rest of the log (188 more lines)
-Patriotism
Watergate
-Rogers's advice
-Ehrlichman
-Statement by President
-Value
-Washington Post
-Public statement by President
-Impact
-Lyndon B. Johnson
-Walter Jenkins
-Homosexuality
-Robert D. (“Bobby”) Baker
-Abe Fortas
-Sirica
-Independent commission
-Mitchell's opinion
-Dean appearance before grand jury
-Dean
-Testimony to grand jury
- Magruder’s testimony
-Ehrlichman
-Dealings with L. Patrick Gray, III
Ehrlichman
-Vacation
-Return to Washington
Haldeman talked with Dean at an unknown time between 4:20 pm and 4:57 pm.
[Conversation No. 423-13A.]
[See Conversation No. 44-27]
[End of telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Grand jury
-22-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 423-13 (cont’d)
-Dean's plans
-Written statements
-Report from Henry E. Peterson
-Mitchell
-Call from F. Lee Bailey
-Representation of James W. McCord, Jr.
-Bernard Fensterwald
-Meeting with McCord and Sirica
-Gerald Alch
-President as target of case
-Fensterwald
- Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
-Senator Committee
-Russell B. Long
-McCord
-Naming of White House staff in Watergate
-Magruder and Dean
-Revelations
-Disclosure
-Investigation of Kennedy
-Involvement
-Kennedy
-Investigation
-Magruder
-Legitimate intelligence activities
-Washington Post stories
-Dramatic steps by President
-Necessity
-Dean's advice
-Ehrlichman's advice
-McCord
-Howard H. Baker, Jr.
-Criticism of Commission counsel's conduct
-News reports
-Fensterwald
-McCord
-Source of funds
-Mitchell
-Magruder
-23-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 423-13 (cont’d)
-Independence commission
-Rogers's opposition
-President's public statement
-Comments on Mitchell
-Charles W. Colson's advice
-Executive privilege
-Executive privilege
-Uses
-Pre-June 17, 1972
-Testimony to Congress
-Criminal case
-Justice Department's jurisdiction
-Mitchell's interpretation
-Kleindienst
-Call to Sirica
-Special counsel
-Sirica's plans
-Cooperation of White House staff
The President talked with Julie Nixon Eisenhower between 4:57 pm and 4:58 pm.
[Conversation No. 423-13-B]
[See Conversation No. 44-28]
[End of telephone conversation]
Watergate
-White House staff
-Cooperation with courts
-Clemency
-President's opposition
-Dean's investigation
-Ziegler's statement
-Grand jury appearances
-Sirica's agreement
-Ervin Committee
-William P. Rogers
-Jurisdiction over criminal cases
-24-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 423-13 (cont’d)
-Colson
-Advice on issue
-Ervin Committee
-Need to neutralize
Haldeman talked with Colson at an unknown time between 4:48 pm and 5:20 pm.
[Conversation No. 423-13C]
[See Conversation No. 44-30]
[End of telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Special prosecutor
-Colson's opposition
-James W. McCord Jr.'s charges
-Substance
-Administration overreaction
Haldeman talked with an unknown person at an unknown time between 4:57 pm and 5:20 pm.
[Conversation No. 423-13D]
Haldeman's schedule
[End of telephone conversation]
Watergate
-White House
-Cooperation with investigators
-Compared with Warren Commission
-Colson
-Mitchell
-Dean
-Role in Watergate
-Comment about McCord
-Implication of Mitchell, Magruder
-25-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 423-13 (cont’d)
-Magruder
-Former White House job
-Herbert G. Klein
-Colson
-Mitchell
The tape ends before the convulsion of the conversation. The conversation is continued in
Conversation No. 424-1. A portion of the conversation was not recorded while the tape was
being changed.
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
HaldemanDean has had some more conversation, says that, says, but, Paul O'Brien
Haldemanhad talked to Mitchell today, and Mitchell had told him that he was having Jeb come over to see him.
HaldemanSo that they should, Mitchell should talk to Magruder. And O'Brien said Mitchell,
Haldemanin effect, told him that he's going to make the point to Magruder that Jeb's got to make his own decision on how he approaches this thing, that he's a big boy, and that he can't, Jeb can't hang on Mitchell on where he goes.
HaldemanDean talked to Mitchell today, also, and Mitchell told him that he should sit tight
Haldemanand said, "You should understand that when you go in, if you go up before the grand jury, you've got a problem, because won't believe you
Haldemanbecause your story won't jibe with mine. It doesn't jibe with mine." And all that he will open a can of worms.
HaldemanDean had the same feeling, that Mitchell was saying to him that he, John Dean, should consider adjusting his story so that it fit, wanted to fit Mitchell's.
HaldemanDean said, "You've got to understand my position. If, by God, I could take the guilt and solve this thing, I'd do it in a minute, but I cannot do it.
HaldemanBut, I cannot go to the grand jury and not tell the truth, because I know how it is. I'm unable. I have to lie." And he said, "If I start doing that, my hands will start trembling, and my voice
Haldemanwill start shaking, and I can't hold up." So, he said, "I'm, you've just got to understand, if I go, I
Haldemanwill do the best I can, but I will not, can't commit perjury."
HaldemanBill's for it, he says Kleindienst should go
Haldemanand talk to Sirica and run that through him and see how, and approve it as a, as a proper proper approach.
HaldemanEhrlichman, Bill Rogers' thought that is. Dean is opposed to that, because he said
Haldeman"Lobbing the whole thing at Sirica will scare everybody, because, hell, he's liable to lock them in anyway." That would be Sirica. They don't feel they have no chance in a third trial because any judge has got his last big case and has to make a name.
HaldemanAnd you have that problem. He thinks the panel idea is much better because they can make a fair assessment of the facts out of the public eye and the court can't, but
Haldemannobody has an answer. Ehrlichman talked to Rogers,
Haldemanand he had a panel, kind of poor, a reason offered that had nothing to do with it, which is that that the fact of my doing that will automatically escalate this to the biggest event of your administration. It's true. Of the whole eight years, he said.
HaldemanAnd, you should not go into that unless you are overly, word, obsessed with this thing. Now Rogers
NixonI said that. I also told Rogers tonight, Rogers tomorrow.
HaldemanRogers is, Rogers thinks that on that one, that if he does throw the explanation, yes, to mine so a lot of people around here to work. But he still wants you to go on television
Haldemanwhich is the biggest, goddamned ignorance. So his his and in that I would total, totally disagree with John, I mean, with Bill,
Haldemanand agree with John. You can't, you can't get up there and that sort of, oh, I said, "I don't know what you'd say when you go on."
HaldemanJohn's point had been that he said, "We need to, you want, we need other stories now to get out." And so, on that tack, what they need to do and, and he wanted
Haldemanwanted Ziegler to announce something today, and look for that. He says, "Double shove the stories." And first, we've got other stories. All he needs to do is pick up the newspaper. You know what the story is?
HaldemanThe last of the prisoners are on their way home.
HaldemanThat's the story. You turn on television, they're interviewing them all over, and they did all night last night again. They keep,
Haldemanthey're obsessed with the damn prisoners, and I can't imagine why. It must have occurred to somebody that it's helping us, but uh they do it anyway, I guess because that's what the people really are interested in.
HaldemanAnd they get those damn guys on, and they wave at the Nixon banners and Clark is
HaldemanThey sure go hell for leather. I don't know about this last batch, but they're on their way now. 58th in the military, so they would probably charge.
HaldemanWell, you don't know. Some of the newest ones have been some of the most solid. But you see,
HaldemanThat's, that's why it's valuable to get a guy and even he is damn close to what they have sitting here in Washington, reads the Post and the sensitive to this matter. Sir, I talk to these people. If you have a Bill Rogers' fight out in Chicago
HaldemanCall him in and say, "Well, what are you going to do about this?" He would, he would think he had lost his senses over, over talking to them about that.
NixonWell, John said he's been talking to lots of people, but Ehrlichman's whole whole focus has been quite pressed from Washington.
HaldemanI don't know who John's talking to, though. Some of our people did, but they don't think through what, what that does. They they fight this until when you fall in love with them.
NixonAnd Bill's point is that if I go on, it looks like I'm guilty. I haven't thought of that, but I think that's true.
HaldemanYeah, and they had, they makes a comparison. He says if you think this is bad, think of what Johnson must have gone through when he caught one of his top guys in a men's room, a homosexual, and the other one, as a crook.
HaldemanBobby Baker. And his, Fortas, his top lawyer, whom he wanted to make Chief Justice, turned out to be a crook.
NixonThat's three. That's true. Those were, in fact, true.
HaldemanOurs are, ours are not. Ours are, someone stole something.
NixonAnd, Fortas was close to you, wasn't he? Well, Fortas was his crony.
HaldemanNot crony, but his, you know, his, through his whole career, holding stuff for him, deliver it to him.
NixonClear sense of who's on the spot, I don't know what's going to happen. So, if he doesn't want Sirica, I can keep in mind of that. A panel, then, just, just wouldn't work.
HaldemanYou see, he doesn't have any option. That's why Mitchell saying you shouldn't go up to the grand jury, because they'll, they'll uh they won't believe you will break his. That's a terrible thing to say to, in the first place, it is Dean's decision when he goes to the grand jury.
NixonWell, how can he Dean's, is he afraid that he might have to jump on to the White House? He's afraid that that might be it.
HaldemanDean's afraid it'll lead to, it will turn all the piss onto Dean, and the, you know, the two of them should line up to tell the truth and hang Dean.
NixonThe point is, that doesn't solve a goddamn thing.
HaldemanFor them it might. While getting Dean in sure doesn't help them.
NixonNo. They can make the case that Dean acted on his own responsibility.
HaldemanWhat's the plan? Has he given a written statement answering some specific technical questions they've raised which don't do us any harm at all, and then take the position [unintelligible]
HaldemanI guess he can't, so we'll get a report from Peterson about later because there was a meeting of all counsel in the court at two o'clock today, and then they'll go in again immediately afterwards, so, and Peterson doesn't get hourly reports. He gets a report from the
HaldemanU.S. attorney. Petersen does report at the end of each day to Kleindienst.
HaldemanSaid there's a new development. F. Lee Bailey called Mitchell today.
HaldemanOh, his firm represents— No, uh, his firm represents McCord. Oh, here, Alch. Alch is his firm, it's F. Lee Bailey firm. Still does.
HaldemanThat's the interesting thing. He uh he represents McCord in the in the case before Sirica. Fensterwald apparently represents McCord in his dealings with the Hill, and in handling his publicity.
HaldemanBailey Bailey had some thing going. He has a client that has that has uh 200,000 tons of gold, or something, hidden, or something else that probably ought to get legalized,
Haldemanand he he talked to Mitchell about that. And, uh, that's good. However, in the process, uh, after that, Bailey talked like Grover Cleveland, and he said to Mitchell, uh, that Fensterwald had called
HaldemanJohn— She blew it. He called Alch for Bailey, but he he thanks you for calling Bailey. Uh, to request that Fensterwald be present as, what, uh, McCord
HaldemanFensterwald called Alch. He thinks he called Bailey, but he just, you know, being Alch, Bailey's firm.
HaldemanTo request that Fensterwald be present as co-counsel, uh, to sit in during the questioning, and then he made the remark, "We don't give a damn about McCord. We're after Richard Nixon."
HaldemanFensterwald did to Bailey, so Bailey told Mitchell that.
HaldemanAnd they're flying around the back now with the thought that Bailey might go out publicly and say that.
HaldemanDean also says that thinking about it that he thinks Fensterwald is linked to maybe a link to Kennedy, and maybe his tie, because he was chief counsel of the Administrative Practice Subcommittee along with Carmine Bellino.
HaldemanAnd he was the uh sub-chair. And then, Kennedy-Long when- Now Kennedy succeeded Long,
HaldemanI gather. And, he thinks Fensterwald may still have that counsel, or why did Kennedy succeed him? Anyway, Kennedy was- was in there and had close ties with him,
Haldemanor had the potential for close ties with him on the committee counsel.
HaldemanUh, he thinks maybe there's something going on there that would explain Fensterwald's putting up the bail for McCord, which is an open
Haldemanquestion. McCord isn't paying for it. He's broke. If there's anybody checking, that's what we want him in for.
NixonWell, see, I didn't I didn't think that would be the line. They're all taking that. Everybody from the committee, I don't see why that's so, etc., etc. But, McCord obviously is uh the way that he's pissed off two White House people.
NixonThe way he started by, you know, the way it goes, Fensterwald is doing all that shit. All of sudden, this is the same—
NixonIn other In They name they named White House people. They proposed for, they said, "Well, there's actually Magruder and uh Dean." Yep.
Nixon"We're We'll get McCord's back so he won't be tried to death by his own client." Well, Dean gave up McCord. Then, he had picked their target. They can head try to attack us. McCord will form the bounds.
NixonWas McCord involved in the taking name in uh and they're from tapping?
HaldemanI think so, cuz I don't think McCord was involved in anything that was the job. I don't think, I mean, whatever else that's, was done outside of it.
NixonI know McCord was a friend of the uh of the policeman.
HaldemanWell, Bill said, you know, he said, when I explained, Peterson said, he said, "Well, maybe you mentioned this to him," he said, "You sit there and you you kind of look a little concerned and everything, and you tell me that that you have been putting pressure on on Magruder to get taped recordings of Democratic candidates, as if
Haldemanthat automatically tied you to Watergate." And he said, "You got to realize that what you were doing, you would've been criticized if you hadn't of did."
NixonIntelligence operation. Yeah, he made that point. You said, "Don't make don't make any bones about whether you have an intelligence operation. Why, of course you did."
HaldemanTrying to get I said, "Well, you know, that sounds fine, but when The Washington Post prints it, that isn't the way it looks."
HaldemanI would love to have a story saying I was was pushing. And the other thing, what probable end together, I would call them because I was pushing for reports.
HaldemanNine-quarters probably have. Some of this Hell, if you talk about people who wanted reports coming, you stand there every day. Take three-quarters, haul them, and dump them in a speaker in there to get. Cause they're too lazy to work, you've got to sit and write it.
HaldemanNow Dean's point, in wanting an independent counsel, and Bill sort of agreed with that, too, but—
HaldemanJohn, see, that in John's crowd, I don't criticize the boy, but it's his it's his mental phenomenon that replaced the earlier.
NixonJust as It's over. That's always an offensive, well, always good, you know, to be out.
Nixonand uh, didn't do something. Oh, well. You see, that's why John would've been a disaster as foreign policy adviser.
NixonShit, he could've done everything wrong, you know? Out of the context, you know?
HaldemanWell, you could be the right guy, unless you first got to decide on that that's the right line, and stick with it. Don't take each new [unintelligible]
NixonWhat is uh—what's he think the prognosis is, Bob?
HaldemanWell, he thinks the hurts of this are going to be probably gone tomorrow. We'll get a whole new series of shock waves on Friday.
HaldemanAll right, that's why we've got to get started the other time.
HaldemanIncidentally, Howard Baker did step up and blast the Committee Counsel. Did you hear that?
HaldemanDid—yes. He did it yesterday. The question didn't get reported because nobody took a word of goods in. Now, it's in the paper tonight. What did Howard do?
HaldemanHe hit him for highly improper conduct, and uh, held a press conference.
NixonThat's good. Calls him that very decent thing to do.
HaldemanAnd then the other people, they're not wanting to discuss the politics.
HaldemanNow that dig there is apt to get uh—we're getting not so bad. I think what—I think that's all right for an outline is that because it was improper conduct, where we're sorry, will you recognize that for ourselves?
NixonI mean, to the extent that I told him, see, my guess is that he was, and that he just did the, probably,
Nixonnot not told—I mean, he's just one of those things where he wasn't watching the store and said well, go ahead.
NixonBut, I shouldn't—he shouldn't ask me. And he's right about that, Bob. I don't think I should be in a position to say, if somebody asked me, "What about John Mitchell?"
Haldemanwonder if they've got, you know, "How are you going to not scare him? How can you not go to Sirica to do it anyway? Which way, or how is he going to react?"
HaldemanAll right, rethink Sirica: we've got one, that this but I think we're going to be in that thing, anyway. You've got federal grand jury.
HaldemanYes, it is in a way, you can make—you somehow, the point can be made that there is no question of executive privilege in the in the events leading up to the Watergate, because the President has no knowledge of it and had no communication with anybody regarding it. Therefore, no one else the privilege issue doesn't arise.
HaldemanNow, so that the privilege question, on the Hill, is a question of the privilege of being called at all. The question of being called at all.
HaldemanRight. Not the subject. It's the test. Right. Is they are, you're fine, Mr. President.
HaldemanIf the in addition, if they were being called on the Hill on a criminal matter which was not being handled in the proper criminal places, then they'd go up, and sure enough, they're forced to talk.
HaldemanWho cares? Here, Justice Department is prosecuting.
HaldemanThey are appearing. You see, my point is that they are.
HaldemanIf that's that's the that's the way it's done, by god, well, here it is.
NixonNow, this Sirica idea now, if there really if there isn't much in one, except you you're simply saying that Oh, no, no. Kleindienst talks to How would the wording work?
HaldemanHenry, isn't there another Except, I don't tell you.
HaldemanKleindienst talks to goes to see talks to Sirica.
HaldemanDick, and he says the President wants to wants to have this matter forced.
HaldemanWants him to open this whole thing. Now, does he want, what does he want Sirica to do?
HaldemanDoes he want Sirica first, to order a special grand jury and have the special lacks confidence in the prosecution?
HaldemanTwo, whether he wants another grand jury? And, three,
Haldemanwhether he does, one, two, or not, or whether he goes with his present grand jury, that there will be total cooperation from the White House, including testimony
Haldemanby members of the White House staff who have been named, directly or indirectly,
HaldemanYeah. Informing you, that asserting that there was no communication with the President on clemency, you know, we've got to take care of the assholes.
HaldemanNow, you said yourself you had Dean looking into it, informing you on that. That's true, well that, obviously, you could have asked other people to do it. Now, that is it, and then, and then, he says that Sirica will agree to that.
HaldemanThen, you could have Ziegler go out. And Ziegler could definitely announce that this morning, and so this: Kleindienst talked to Sirica,
Haldemanthat all White House people will appear before the grand jury.
HaldemanTell the grand- any new grand jury that's empaneled or walk in the judge who was empaneled for the grand jury in the federal court to sit [unintelligible]
HaldemanSee, that's what that's that's the position.
HaldemanWell, then, I'd like to hear about five more ideas.
NixonI admire, I admire Dean's offer, very constructive.
HaldemanThey are appearing there, and if they're not going to allow them to appear, it's solely that you don't want them to appear in those situations that Sirica, and Ervin, and all, want them.
HaldemanMake the point to him that the President up to this point has been relying on the status of a clean bill of health and so forth and therefore was bomb and cleared the investigation and so on.
Haldemanuh, onto some, in- into some forum where they can testify, which they all want to, and we're forcing an issue today, and that's taking a huge over-reaction.
HaldemanThat's that's the point of of doing it this way rather than appointing an- a- a- a Warren Commission to do it or something like that, which would be taking an overt move, and say
HaldemanAnd, John, he called me, and said, "Well, you have some time now? Why don't you come over to my office, and we can talk?"
Haldemansee, Dean thinks that McCord is going to name Mitchell, too.
NixonSo, what are they going to do about the, about this part, why we named it, what the reason why they're not going to listen? They sold us that, and somebody to blame.
HaldemanLooks to me that that's the way it's going to work out. That's Rogers's system.
HaldemanMagruder called the [unintelligible] grand jury right away to [unintelligible]
HaldemanHe'll be a guest, and he's following Magruder. Everything he's following is Magruder [unintelligible]
HaldemanHe said the rumours linking the White House were definitely direct communications [unintelligible]
Haldeman[unintelligible] they played their speech they tried out
423-011 3:27 PM · 51 min — President Richard M. Nixon and William P. Rogers met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 3:27 pm and 4:16 pm.
423-012 4:16 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 4:16 pm and 4:20 pm.
044-026 4:20 PM · 7 sec — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:20 pm and 4:57 pm.
044-027 4:20 PM · 5 min — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and John W. Dean, III talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:20 pm and 4:57 pm.
044-028 4:57 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Julie Nixon Eisenhower talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:57 pm and 4:58 pm.
044-029 4:58 PM · 7 sec — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:58 pm and 5:20 pm.
044-030 4:58 PM · 5 min — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and Charles W. Colson talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:58 pm and 5:20 pm.
424-001 4:58 PM · 4 min — President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 4:58 pm and 5:20 pm.
Conversation 423-013, March 27, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417187581). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/423-013 (accessed November 16, 2026).