President Nixon and H.R. Haldeman discussed the unfolding Watergate scandal, focusing on the testimony of Jeb Magruder and John Dean. They reviewed Magruder's evolving story regarding his involvement, the plan for intelligence operations, and cash disbursements to G. Gordon Liddy, as well as Dean's role in coordinating testimony and potential perjury. The conversation also touched upon Charles Colson's alleged involvement and the broader implications for White House staff facing Senate investigations and potential executive privilege claims.
On March 28, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, White House operator, Camp David operator, and John W. Dean, III met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 12:45 pm to 1:45 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 425-010 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 425-10
Date: March 28, 1973
Time: 12:45 pm - 1:45 p.m.
Location: Executive Office Building
The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.
Watergate
-John D. Ehrlichman
-Conversation with John W. Dean, III
-Jeb S. Magruder's story
-Responsibility for plan
-E. Howard Hunt, Jr., G. Gordon Liddy, Charles W. Colson
-Colson's calls to Magruder
-Lawrence F. O'Brien information
-Hunt and Liddy with Colson
-Frederick C. LaRue with Magruder
-O'Brien information
-Florida convention
-Liddy
-Connection with Gordon C. Strachan
-Wire tap information
-Notes given to James W. McCord, Jr. by Baldwin [first name unknown]
-Liddy's copies
-Magruder
-White House
-Strachan, Colson
-Strachan's conversation regarding approval of plan
-Haldeman
-The President
-John N. Mitchell
-White House knowledge
-Colson, W. Richard Howard, Strachan and Haldeman
-5-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 425-10 (cont’d)
-Colson
-Howard
-Strachan
-Haldeman
-Strachan's story
Show the rest of the log (225 more lines)
-Haldeman's knowledge
-Mitchell's conversation with Haldeman
-Dean's agreement with Magruder prior to Magruder's testimony
-Subjects discussed during January 1972 meetings in Mitchell's office
-Magruder's story
-Herbert ("Bart") Porter
-Conversation with Dean regarding forthcoming testimony
-Disbursement of cash to Liddy
-Dean
-Subornation of perjury
-Magruder
-Porter
-Role of Mitchell and their lawyers
-Mitchell's and Magruder's testimony regarding meetings on intelligence
proposals
-Haldeman's request to come to Washington, DC
-Magruder's story
-Meetings in Mitchell's office
-Liddy
-Presentation
-Budget authorization
-Mitchell
-Magruder
-Dean
-Colson
-Magruder's authority
-Liddy
-Employment by Magruder
-Firing by Magruder
-Strachan's order to Magruder
-Magruder's story
-Porter's forthcoming testimony on cash payments
-Pre-April 1972 payments
-6-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 425-10 (cont’d)
-Colson
-Howard
-Purchase of books
-Effort to increase sales of Edith Efron's book
-Colson
-Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy mailing in New Hampshire
-Authorization
-Liddy's work, January-March 1972
-Colson's statement about President's ordering mailing
-Mitchell
-Testimony on meetings in Mitchell's office
-Dean's influence
-Liddy's role in committee
-Magruder's diary showing several meetings
-Mitchell's story of post-Watergate meetings regarding forthcoming
testimony on Liddy
-Meetings
-Credibility of witnesses
-Subjects discussed
-Prior knowledge of Watergate
-Rejection of plan
-Liddy's and McCord's work on budget
-$250,000 for Liddy
-Credibility
-Fear of exposure of perjury
-Colson
-Previous testimony
-Strachan
-Dean
-Magruder
-Family
-Money
-Reassurance by Mitchell and Haldeman
Haldeman talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 12:45 pm and 1:45
pm.
[Conversation No. 425-10A]
-7-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 425-10 (cont’d)
[See Conversation No. 44-48]
[End of telephone conversation]
Haldeman talked with the Camp David operator at an unknown time between 12:45 pm and 1:45
pm.
[Conversation No. 425-10B]
[See Conversation No. 44-49]
Haldeman talked with John W. Dean, III at an unknown time between 12:45 pm and 1:45 pm.
[End of telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Magruder's concerns
-Colson
-Involvement
-Magruder
-Mitchell
-Campaign irregularities
-Mitchell
-Ehrlichman
-View of testimony before Ervin Committee
-Senior White House staff
-Providing information
-Grand jury
-Magruder
-Dean
-Possible denial of involvement
-Liddy
-Possible testimony regarding Watergate
-White House involvement
-Others' involvement
-Lawyer-client privilege
-Colson
-8-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 425-10 (cont’d)
-Possible challenges to testimony
-Magruder
-Strachan
-Dean
-Possible immunity
-Mitchell
-Involvement in Watergate
-Meetings with Liddy
-Testimony
-Magruder's story
-Perjury
-Effect on Mitchell
-Jail
-Fears
-Los Angeles Times article
-Ervin Committee investigation of political activities
-Suit in California
-$65,000 payment to unknown person
-Ervin Committee
-Richard G. Kleindienst
-McCord
-Kleindienst
-Ervin and Howard H. Baker, Jr.
-William E. Timmons's role as White House Congressional liaison
-Dean
-John G. Tower
-Lowell P. Weicker, Jr.'s vote
-Edward J. Gurney and Baker
-Weicker's interest
-Haldeman
-Committee staff's opinion
-Weicker
-Donald H. Segretti
-White House cooperation
-Effect
-TV
-Kleindienst's efforts
-Public hearings
-9-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 425-10 (cont’d)
-Question of executive privilege
-White House staff members
-Majority and minority counsel
-Committee members
-Dean
-Role as White House counsel
-Possible testimony
-Exercise of privilege
-Colson
-Haldeman
-Hearsay
-Notes
-Diary
-Magruder's date book
-Strachan and Dean
-Haldeman
-Record-keeping
-Strachan
-Campaign records kept for President
-Dean
-Conversations with Haldeman
-TV cameras
-Suggestions for handling
-Timing
-Dean's conversations with Mitchell and Magruder
-Testimony
-Need to be truthful
-Role as White House counsel
-Privilege
-Magruder
-Perjury
-Defense
-Orders from Colson
-Money given to Colson for mailing
-Authorization
-Committee for Kennedy write-in New Hampshire
-Hunt
-Ronald L. Ziegler's concern
-10-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 425-10 (cont’d)
-Testimony
-Charges against Colson regarding Watergate break-in
-Possible explanation of Colson's activities
-Lawrence F. O'Brien's activities
-Howard Hughes
-International Telephone and Telegraph [ITT]
-Kleindienst
-Schedule
-California
Haldeman left at 1:45 p.m.
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
Haldemanthe the facts, as Dean understands the facts as tried and they owe me thanks to nobody's [unintelligible]. What happened here? He says that the whole intelligence plan was hatched here at the White House by Hunt, Liddy, and Colson. Colson called Jeb twice
Haldemantelling him to get going on this thing, and specifically referred to the Larry O'Brien information, when he hired him. And Jeb says Hunt and Liddy were in Colson's office, and Colson was on that phone call, or he assumes that that,
Haldemanand Liddy— Well, what he told him. He told Colson, "Well, that's what the bugging wire is for," that kind of, Jeb tries to use that to say Colson was directly tied into wiretapping, but he didn't know the origin. And I said, "Well, did—"
HaldemanJohn clarified as to when Colson was in the Larry O'Brien— how did Larry O'Brien information regarding Florida at the convention stuff? All of it, and, uh, well that would be Colson's best bet. And then Liddy
Haldemantold LaRue later, uh, that Liddy was in Colson's office and Colson called Colson, something like that. Anyhow, Gordon Strachan probably had a lot of direct dealings with Liddy, and knows he had some direct dealings with him.
HaldemanThat's Gordon's line. We've got to pour over Strachan's line. He says a copy of the output of the wiretap process, and what happened there is that this guy Baldwin made notes on what he listened to gathered on a tap,
Haldemanand wrote those up, gave them to McCord. And McCord— McCord gave them to Liddy. Liddy made two copies: one copy was delivered to Magruder, and one copy was delivered to the White House.
HaldemanUh, Liddy This This is what what McCord says, this is what Magruder says. Liddy didn't McCord knows, cuz they went from Liddy, but McCord McCord was not aware of the White House and wasn't at Liddy. But he says, he says Jeb had a copy and the White House had a copy. And he doesn't know where the White House copy went, whether it went to Strachan or to Colson.
HaldemanHe feels sure it went to Strachan, and probably, or possibly, to Colson or Colson. He said Gordon Strachan told him that I had approved the plan. Told Mitchell, in the presence of of Dean,
HaldemanWhite House had given the go, Mitchell, that Mitchell had approved it. Disapproved of wiretap. He says that there were four people in the White House that had full knowledge of the wiretap operation: Colson, uh, Dick Howard, works for Colson,
HaldemanGordon Strachan, and Haldeman. What basis does he base that with those four people, on? Because Colson, he knows had knowledge because of the phone call phone calls. Howard, he knows had knowledge because of conversations they had.
HaldemanGordon Strachan, he knows had knowledge because he got copies of what Liddy of what the reports were saying. And you and Haldeman, because Gordon Strachan told him that I had approved the money. And Gordon Strachan says firmly and absolutely that he did not tell him and that I didn't approve the money.
HaldemanGordon Strachan, Strachan, Strachan didn't approve it. He says, "I did not."
HaldemanUh, but I need to see Strachan. Strachan says Strachan and Magruder's story,
HaldemanMitchell also told me this his personal knowledge. That's, so that's all Strachan's hearsay. And he says then, he agreed with Magruder in Mitchell's office,
Haldemanand it may have prior to giving testimony, this latter half, after the event now, before Magruder went to the FBI, or the grand jury, or the several occasions where he was called to step up to testimony, that Magruder and Dean,
Haldemanin Mitchell's presence, continually rehearsed or agreed that the purpose of the meetings that were held in the Attorney General's office in January of '71— of '72, were to go over the Corrupt Practices Act, kind of campaign spend laws, and that sort of thing.
HaldemanMitchell says also, that Magruder told him, that Bart Porter talked to Dean about his testimony with regard to having for the purposes of money, cash, that Porter gave to Liddy.
HaldemanPorter had the uh the revolving cash fund, and was instructed to, and did, give amounts of cash to Liddy, and, uh, discussed what the purpose of that would be and how it was accounted for, and so on, with Dean, before he went up to give his testimony, which was after he'd serve testimony.
HaldemanAnd Porter has Porter has testified. In fact, Porter did testify [unintelligible] perjury. Well, whether he actually said it, but he set this with Dean, and it's all public, worked this out with me ahead of time,
Haldemanwhat he was to say. The problem is Porter perjured himself, so did Magruder. Now what they're both saying is that they worked out their perjury with or through Dean. Magruder and Porter also talked to Mitchell and to LaRue.
HaldemanMr. Mitchell concurs with this and says [unintelligible]
HaldemanUh, Dean can trace certainly the facts. Colson's problem He says that Liddy,
HaldemanDean pretending that they have a problem on those two meetings, in Mitchell's office, because both Mitchell and Magruder have specifically testified that there were no meetings to talk about wiretaps or proposals. Uh, Dean says he has to testify that there were.
HaldemanThere again, raises the question, and here again, those here say this may be the type of writing, you can't find out. But, uh, I think it's so fundamental to Dean's testimony. What what I said, in all this, is this is obviously something that you and John Mitchell had ought to talk about. So that I called John Dean and had him tell that to John,
Haldemanand he said he would be glad to do that. John Mitchell's supposed to be somewhere and so, John, [sigh]
HaldemanThe point is, though, after three meetings, Liddy came in with elaborately prepared plans.
HaldemanHe, according to Magruder, was told that he would have a million-dollar budget for intelligence operations, and he drew up the plans for how he was going to handle them. And that's what he did. And then he came in with big charts that showed what they were going to do, and all sorts of stuff. And we don't pick up million-dollar budgets, that's exactly the point. He did.
HaldemanYeah, it says that he did not, and Magruder did not, and they can only assume that Dean told them, or, possibly, Colson. Jeb won't, I mean Magruder won't have any, all right. I said, "How come?" And he said, "Well, okay, that's the one that he questioned, right?"
HaldemanThen, there's another interesting question, which is apparently Magruder hired Liddy at general counsel for the campaign. He had no responsibility for intelligence. Liddy was a very peculiar guy and was engaged in very peculiar mental gymnastics around there, and caused Magruder and he not to like, to not trust him, and so he decided to fire him, which he did.
HaldemanAnd Jeb had no other communication with him.
HaldemanLiddy, then, getting kicked out of the committee, came over to Gordon Strachan. And says, and said, "Magruder's fired me and you can't do that, and the White House wants me there, and everything." And Strachan took it to Colson's shop.
HaldemanAnd Strachan told Magruder to rehire Liddy, which he did.
HaldemanNow, this, if this is true, and I guess I'm going to find out, is definitely a link to Colson, but whether Colson, now I don't know why, why in the petition to did Gordon point it's not a link to Colson. Now, he also says,
Haldemanthat there is a problem, that Porter's going to have to testify that, they called on Porter to sign receipts for where he gave a lot of cash payments, and he made a lot of cash payments to Colson.
HaldemanCreative or sell for Colson. Now, once the specific payment of $8,000 made to Dick Howard, which Howard is, they're not trying yet to cover it up, and Magruder said that's one of the facts why Gordon couldn't keep doing this cover-up that's in this situation. So, what is it? He said he was, he had Howard needed $8,000 to buy some books.
HaldemanSo what's embarrassing about that? So, Colson, and can't let it get out. I said, "Well, hell, I'm sure what that was." He said, "He was going around to bookstores all over town buying up a lot of books for some reason." Well, obviously, what that was was Colson put out, I don't know, says we get, get on the best-seller list.
HaldemanSo, I couldn't see any problem with that. He said, "This is a book that we, that a lot of people have, and we, we wanted to take care of it and get it out to distribution." He says, "Well, it can't, Colson says you can't let that out."
HaldemanHe says there were a lot of other cash payments to Colson, almost all of them for ads. And he said they were all, I'm told, legal. And someone wanted to keep it secret, so they, because they were. They also
HaldemanYeah. Gave Colson the money to pay for the Kennedy mailing petition, which Colson reported was ordered by the President. And that was one Colson had opened in the campaign, and Jeb said, "I won't do that. That won't happen. That won't be financed." And Colson said, "This is ordered by the President, and it must be done." Jeb said. Uh,
Haldemanthat was when this guy here ran away with the Kennedy-
HaldemanThat's another question of how would you handle, how will we handle that for Colson's part.
HaldemanAnd then Liddy was working at the committee, in January, February, and March, but he wasn't working for the committee. He was doing things at other people's direction, and Jeb doesn't know what he was doing.
HaldemanAnd he was traveling some, and uh, he was engaged in a lot of activities, and uh, you know, I would be surprised—
NixonI, well, I would be surprised if Colson ever, we're talking about Colson, the order to buy in
HaldemanWell, I, I absolutely challenged that, and said, "There's no, that, I know damn, I'm certain is not true." Mitchell interjected. I said, "Colson would, even if that were the case, Colson wouldn't have said that to have him see to it. It would be to Haldeman. And if it were not the case, I know Colson didn't do that kind of thing."
HaldemanMitchell laughed, and he said, "That's, huh, he cheers you, and I can tell you Colson did nothing but that with me." Liddy and Colson did that in conversation with Mitchell.
NixonHe didn't mean Colson didn't use your name. [crosstalk] Hell, Mitchell [unintelligible] you know.
HaldemanUm, now Magruder also says that after a meeting with John Dean, "I testified, and I had to testify that there was only one meeting in Mitchell's office, and this was after Liddy's hiring by the committee, and we discussed his role at the committee." And he said, "It was Dean's idea that I so testify,"
Haldeman"And Dean also told me to destroy my diaries, which I did not do, because they'd already subpoenaed them and they had, anyway. And my diary shows that there were several meetings, so I have to say one was with, was cancelled. And it showed on my diary that it was cancelled, so there was only one meeting."
HaldemanMitchell, interjected on that one, and said, "There's no question in my mind about the meetings. After the Packers' conference, they brought Liddy over to the park to use his office. This was after one meeting where we discussed how to testify regarding the meetings. This is before you went to the grand jury." Jeb said, "I, I agreed, who said we did have the meetings,
Haldemanbut I didn't, because Dean told me not to." And he said, "So, Dean cannot now go and say that we did have the meeting, because that leaves, it puts it, it's either his perjury or mine, and then we got a problem." And Magruder's point is everybody's, "I want everybody to corroborate what I say, and make sure that no one will get into these."
Nixon[sighs] Well, how would that hurt Dean, if they say that he's lying? You see, Dean, well yeah.
HaldemanI mean, that's what, that's what I keep saying, "I don't see why they have to." But, they seem to think it's a very, you know, they think credibility of witnesses and all that. My view is, so what? So, so they're lying, what should we do? We're trying to [unintelligible]
HaldemanYou see, their point is, that, and Mitchell feels this strongly, that if they admit to a presentation of an intelligence plan and that it's prior knowledge of Watergate, even though Mitchell says flatly, and Magruder's not shaken on that point, there was no specific mention of bugging the Democratic headquarters in that intelligence plan,
Haldemanincluded in that plan, bugging operations.
NixonDidn't they ever figure out [unintelligible] specific place, or did they? Take specific options. Say they, they probably didn't.
HaldemanJust flatly rejected. They rejected it. And they're questioning him, and that's the other point. I say, "If they rejected the plan,"
HaldemanAnd uh, then, the other thing they're worried about is that Porter, who was working on budgets and stuff, probably, and even has copies of the charts and stuff and we'd need that. Probably worked with him on it, and because Liddy said, "I have a million dollars and got to work out a budget as to how I, how I
Haldemanutilize the million dollars." So, Porter probably worked with him on it.
HaldemanHe did get approval for 250,000 and he took action on the 250,000, which was carried out by Gordon Liddy. It was carried out [unintelligible]
Haldeman[unintelligible] and he got, three months later he got someone at the White House to approve the damn thing. So [unintelligible]
HaldemanNow Jeb intends to stay with his story, he told me yesterday.
NixonThe only hope is that he still stays with the story, then, that he's got on the grand jury and not say anything about the White House.
HaldemanHe is There's no question in his mind about staying with the story. He's been settling it with somebody else's initiation. It sounds going to screw them on his story. And uh they even have uh one of the McCord has now first folks on the scene, who's going to testify
Haldemanand uh go the other way. And uh if he's not careful, it could be
Haldemana perjury for them. On the other hand, somehow Jeb needs some legal testimony. And if we get our people to go up there and counter his testimony,
Haldemanprobably could get a pretty clear case for him. Jeb's point is the initiation.
HaldemanThe root of the initiation is Colson. Colson's demand. I told him I don't think he'll have any problems with Colson, because Colson has already testified under oath that he knew nothing about the 1970 stuff, but Colson
Haldemancould be strong. I said, "I don't think Colson knows." "At least this position is that he didn't know about it. That's what he's told me. That's what he swore to. That's his position." But he should talk to Colson about that.
HaldemanSomehow Gordon has got through to all this testimony, through the grand jury testimony, and Jeb says, he says, you know, "Strachan.
HaldemanSimply because "you and John Mitchell are the only two people I trust in all this.
HaldemanAnd I just want you to understand the problem that I am faced with and be able to help. I want you to know what I view the truth as, as well as what my legal testimony is.
HaldemanThe other thing he wanted to talk to me about was what would happen to his wife and children if he's indicted, and uh what would happen to him during the months [unintelligible]
HaldemanCarefully back me up on that. And my confidence in his abilities and all that sort of thing. But behind this, he'd be in uh his family would be taken care of was an obligation.
HaldemanUh it would not be in terms of a question of what he says or doesn't say. He'd never jeopardize me or the President. Uh
HaldemanAnd that, honestly, it was no wonder anybody had taken care of him and made under an obligation, but that I thought that he must understand that and he must further understand that high regarded, which he held by all
HaldemanI wanted to fight it that way, and then I told him, we'd tried to He wanted more than that. And I can understand that, make sure it would be about. And uh
HaldemanI said, "Jeb, I can't say more than that. You couldn't say more than that if I were to ask for it." So then, he talked John. And then he said, "Well, would would would you" I said, "I'm I'm sitting here as a
Haldemancitizen, as a person, I'm not in a position to make any such statement." I said, "On a personal basis, as a friend of yours, I can assure you that that night, you know, if I personally can do anything to help
HaldemanWell, they saw, true, they've got a lot of people to go through. But, they're not going to hurry, all right?
HaldemanIt's so important that we don't, you know, hang ourselves with conspiracy, cover up, and quiet.
HaldemanGet off the charges. And I, also, carefully reiterated that I didn't know anything about the facts of what he said. I had listen to what he had testified to, to be the truth.
NixonDid you gather Did you not gather from this talk that Colson was more involved than uh
HaldemanUm Magruder and Mitchell are certainly totally convinced of that. And it was obvious that he was involved with some of the activities. Uh whether he was directly involved with the Watergate, I still am not convinced of that.
HaldemanBut Mitchell and allies had opted to define it generally as down to the fact of knowledge in the area of Watergate. Especially with the Senate, will go into, they'll explore all campaign irregularities, not just Watergate,
HaldemanI guess this is one of the reason why Mitchell is so anxious to Colson out of the White House. But, the checklist: John feels very strongly that we should try to work an accommodation with Ervin.
Haldemanuh that would put us in the position of not appearing to be afraid to have our people testify, in any form. Under the pact, he totally agrees that under no circumstances and even he says that he banged that constantly when he raised that point.
Haldemanhere, that under no circumstances should we commit senior White House people to go up to the Hill, under oath, and testify at the Senate hearings.
HaldemanSo, what he's saying you can work out something back on that, he's not sure you have to go as far as this meeting with the whole committee, that it's anything that
Haldemanthat substantively eats the test of providing them with the information
Haldemanis always, from a public view point, so what you can expect that will work out.
HaldemanUh he believes that before the grand jury the legal principle we should may develop that way, with the
Haldemanand that that won't help us because I'm totally ignoring the rest of us, see? He's convinced the rest of us get into the shark shark stuff, on the Hill, and uh
Haldemanto uh [unintelligible] who is the guy who uh who who ran the [unintelligible]?
HaldemanThey thought it came down [unintelligible], and I said maybe that's the way you solve the problem of uh of this this mysterious 17th people, as John [unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd we they're in a hurry now, Hardon is, to have Dean testify as to his non-involvement.
HaldemanAnd uh and in nine months of campaign of Watergate and abuse toward anyone at the White House, we got at least someone at the White House who was engaged as that report for the President, which obviously got into the questions of of where people have been charged and all their appeals pending and everything else.
HaldemanIf that, his investigation of White House involvement also obviously brought him information regarding other involvement. And it's clear that there were people who were involved in it, who were [unintelligible], but wanted to convict him. So we'd back up.
HaldemanThis leads into an alternate suggestion. [unintelligible] And John says that this could work in a handy way with a little
HaldemanNow there's no way to beat this, because Colson has said, under testimony,
Haldemanhe's already on the problem. These are the people with this, whether somebody tells Colson, somebody tells Mitchell, according to John.
HaldemanI can't do that, you know, that problem. Colson can't do it, because he's already testified, you know. But John's got to possibly play them both, but Jeb, to screw him. You get that?
NixonI think it's clear this conversation Dean has got to have.
HaldemanAnd uh Liddy's one guy, I kinda remember, whose back could be, who's not gonna do that, because John's thinks of that, you know. But there's some person you've asked for,
Haldemanand that's the uh, and Mitchell told me the other day, and he said, "You know what I would do if I were with you? Just just four minutes [unintelligible]
HaldemanSo [unintelligible] lawyer who's a defender and, you know, [unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd Jeb will pay, for courage and self-reliance, and for continuing uh for the humiliating situation that his family and all his associates [unintelligible].
HaldemanI would do my best, recognizing that this whole thing was such a mess anyway. I would do my pretty, darn, best to save him, because I wouldn't let anybody else turn up to screw him anyway."
Haldemanscholarly speaker, but he's just this morning, Dean, they made an appeal to, oh, what's his name, Silbert is out for the holidays, so he's not in court today, and that's, uh, Earl Silbert, who's testifying today, and they didn't know whether he could go ahead with the other
Haldemanguys on it, but the lawyer, on the other hand, thought he should go in.
Haldemanthis morning. It says, "Watergate, an investigation of the Watergate bugging incident and broadened to cover seven other incidents, that was said today by a Capitol Hill source, which close to the Senate committee and [unintelligible] who is preparing to test- investigate.
HaldemanAccording to the source, Senate investigators are now tracking a pattern of events, leading back into the 1960s,
Haldemanin which political operations similar to the Watergate bugging and alleged widespread spying, but funded by campaign finance operations were used.
HaldemanIt is, however, an apparent concern among Senate committee investigators, they should not be rushed into a public hearing, earlier than they're scheduled next month."
HaldemanAnd what else the one thing that came out during the campaign, which is the only bad thing about this going back to that uh lawsuit in California- oh, uh, on that
Haldemancommittee for the preservation of the Democratic Party, which went out for [unintelligible] and got hit, you know, on all the and all that.
HaldemanThe suit is uh, you know, was dismissed because they couldn't find anyone [unintelligible] so that that got stopped, but
Haldemanthey throw it back in just with someone connecting with that,
Haldemanwhich was the business of uh stopping them out
HaldemanI don't think they're likely to do this. I'm totally [unintelligible]
HaldemanOh God, that, I didn't know how it was done, and then I didn't know. Then, John, the first who's finally who got him in, yes. Next question is to find out how it was done, whether it was in cash, and who is the person involved.
Haldemanthat's that's the actionable move, is to decide who, how do we want to approach Ervin and or whether or not to, and how do we want to do it on that.
NixonThe only actionable that it seems to me, the way to deal with this, to have Kleindienst, because he's already started to set up the meeting before all this stuff broke. He finds, well, he's back. There's no rush on that because Ervin's gone until, well,
HaldemanKleindienst, I get the story, is in a bit in Timmons' press conferences he's acting as a liaison, a go-between, between them. And if Kleindienst asked to meet with Ervin and Baker and says, "Look,
NixonWell, he's already tried to get to them once, hasn't he?
NixonThey've been talking over the weekend. But Baker That's not what Baker's on now, but he is gone, now.
HaldemanWell, our testimony on the Hill is eats on what did John Dean do?
NixonWell, I can tomorrow run at that at lunch, or a little little bit more than that.
HaldemanHe said that'll be, he will satisfy all that.
NixonNeither will be satisfied unless we, you know, we bring Baker Baker believes in executive privilege. He's the only one that believes in that. Well, maybe he does, but the position that executive session, closed session.
HaldemanAnd frank and full, and why have a closed session? He'd like to do it in the open.
NixonWell, I never believed when when Baker said on the on the news stand in public that no one can say,
HaldemanYou see, the trouble is sometimes Baker is honest and forthright, just as half of them they don't have, they don't ask the questions.
NixonSee the Well, that's What Hope is looking at is uh is uh is straining, "Why don't we throw the yell over?
HaldemanNotice that here Washington had an interesting theory. That he is on that committee's staff who are maturely watching over the hearing of the whole story. They did in the position that the White House had apparently had dirty small dirty dealings on its own rather than than for us to surprise, and that neither the fish, nor the presidential might escape in the head of the investigators. This would explain why Weicker followed through
NixonWeicker probably just wants Watergate [crosstalk] to spray on everybody.
HaldemanAnd spill [unintelligible] the ice, so my yesterday, uh I must say put up in print starts.
NixonWhat's that all about? In a separate That's Watergate. It would be wrong, tells us we depend Watergate. There's not any foreigner around about.
NixonTo deal with them not satisfy Congress. I do deal with uh I could deal with that if we could have a deal, that we are cooperating with them and everything that affects everyone on this, on our side.
NixonSee, that doesn't wipe away the fault. It doesn't.
HaldemanAnd frankly, the public, hell, will accept that, John. They'll say, "Well, Jesus, what's not good about that? They did it, and what the hell Dickerson's doing.
HaldemanIf you can hang that on whether there's an equal charge here and there, the only hope to watch it. And I can understand why the special form that we have.
NixonWell, the Christ, then happen inspire which depends whether you can take that call all the way on that. I would spend five days for water.
HaldemanThe problem is stop, go down. What else in Watergate?
NixonThis trial we've got to have. With your being we should go to the table. The the biggest See, you could start you could do it two different ways. You could say, "What will it
Nixonthere's so that had that course, just what mine is, what is supposed to have done originally. Yeah, I think it's not. It's done. But there is a look they might they want full public hearings. Full they want public hearings.
HaldemanRight, we could probably argue them down off of that, see.
NixonSo what he's got to say now is, "We can't do the full public hearing. Short of that, what can we work out? For example, as tickets starting point,
Haldemanany of the White House people will be perfectly willing to meet in private with the majority and minority counsel of the committee, and a recorder,
HaldemanSee, then, with Dean, I've laid somewhat of a foundation for that, in the You know, categorical statement. Of course, I'm not saying this in front of the committee. [unintelligible] the attorneys. As the President's counsel, [unintelligible] privilege.
HaldemanAnd we can still exercise privilege, I did, and we could exercise, and would exercise privilege in certain areas, when they're when we get off of ourselves. That's Colson's argument, and I think he's right.
HaldemanI mean, I can't testify to hearsay, because hearsay that I pick up is is is related to my job, and we just claim privilege on that. People talking with me on the basis of things they may want the President to know,
Haldemanand vice versa. You testify about your own actions. If they tried to subpoena my notes, I would refuse to deliver my notes, because my notes are based on my conversations with the President. Right.
HaldemanI don't need I don't have a diary, so I'm not the one they're after.
Nixon[unintelligible] Sure, he wouldn't hold— [unintelligible]
HaldemanRight. There was no point in keeping a file because they were sort of pages on the fact that I do, in our quarters, that they were just of nothing of any interest anyway.
HaldemanYou they call for no action or rare information. If I'd understand correction, I got a pile of stuff that the way they came, they were just tons of stuff. We hadn't got all the time.
HaldemanAll the budgets, tracking, daily plan, whole ball of Christ! We had such a big and all the the people that wanted
NixonIt's It was good that that stuff was kept out of here.
HaldemanAnd uh you caused the file to be kept for use, for all that sort of thing. But not not really kept as a file. Just a scanning routine. That's how our whole campaign files got to be [unintelligible].
HaldemanDean told me that he was the one that was getting the stuff from the case stripped down. So that told us that the stuff came to that same house and went by, then he came home and walk by, you would have to do with something [unintelligible].
NixonAnd why does he have, why is he going off into this aside? He doesn't bring along the other. He's courageous. He's going back [unintelligible] courageous.
HaldemanI feel tough that there's courage trying to, but he wants them all,
HaldemanIt's got that we won't be in collateral. A conversation I had with Dean the same morning the one after this conversation, when he showed, when he went through
Haldemanhis warning hell. It's full of great hope then with the way, whole thing.
NixonYou know what I argued with him? I said, "I don't mind. I don't want to go on." I agree with that. I don't want to go on, for Christ's sakes.
HaldemanAnd uh in fact, for his own terribly sad positions. He can't use counsel to corroborate the testimony of other people. He can only use counsel to testify in his own defense.
HaldemanHe uh I think he's got a better chance with people listening to him than anybody else, because it's certainly not That's why he's in the position he is. Because everybody assumes he was personal counsel.
NixonI threw that, frankly, in that Supreme Court brief.
Haldemanthe horror. Colson says, "Hell, I don't give a damn about it." Magruder says, "God damn, they're having problems, all right." And they sent they sent up an ad, you know, but what he told me, "he had a guy, who was a Democrat-" Right. "-who wanted to do it.
HaldemanYou see, this panic exists with Colson told them to get going, he had to get some stuff on O'Brien.
HaldemanThey still, they didn't know whether one, and that's the big ticket item, good.
HaldemanWhat he was imparting was the effect not the means.
NixonI guess the stuff on O'Brien, I mean who was O'Brien then?
HaldemanThen O'Brien started throwing mud at us. So then we thought, you know, we worked this stuff out, on O'Brien's, business, with Hughes, and they counteract that, ITT thing, yeah, that O'Brien, did, for Hughes.
HaldemanThink this over and over. I agree, Father, sure uh that we should uh, know uh,
Haldemanso how uh why these guys got [unintelligible]
Also recorded on March 28, 1973
044-044 12:30 PM · 7 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:30 pm and 12:34 pm.
044-045 12:30 PM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:30 pm and 12:34 pm.
044-046 12:34 PM · 52 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Thelma C. ("Pat") (Ryan) Nixon talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:34 pm and 12:35 pm.
425-008 12:34 PM · 47 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Thelma C. ("Pat") (Ryan) Nixon met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 12:34 pm to 12:35 pm.
044-047 12:35 PM · 34 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:35 pm and 12:36 pm.
425-009 12:35 PM · 29 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 12:35 pm to 12:36 pm.
044-048 12:45 PM · 6 sec — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:45 pm and 1:45 pm.
044-049 12:45 PM · 38 sec — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and Camp David operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:45 pm and 1:45 pm.
Conversation 425-010, March 28, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417187673). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/425-010 (accessed November 16, 2026).