Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 427 › Conversation 427-012

Nixon, Rogers & Ehrlichman on Watergate and John Dean

Monday, April 16, 1973 · 4:55 PM–6:01 PM ET · Old Executive Office Building · 47 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Rogers, William P.; Sanchez, Manolo; Ehrlichman, John D.; White House operator; Agnew, Spiro T. (Vice President); Rogers, Adele (Langston); Ziegler, Ronald L.Conversation427-012 on Tape 427StartMonday, April 16, 1973 at 4:55 PMEndMonday, April 16, 1973 at 6:01 PMRecording deviceOld Executive Office BuildingSourceNixon Library record for 427-012 ↗

President Nixon met with William Rogers to discuss the unfolding Watergate scandal, focusing on the potential testimony of John Dean, Jeb Magruder, and John Mitchell. They reviewed the role of Henry Petersen in the investigation, the disposition of materials from E. Howard Hunt Jr.'s safe, and the implications of Dean's negotiations with prosecutors. The conversation also touched upon President Nixon's schedule and potential actions, including involving Leonard Garment.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 74.6 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 11.5 MB

On April 16, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, William P. Rogers, Manolo Sanchez, John D. Ehrlichman, White House operator, Vice President Spiro T. Agnew, Adele (Langston) Rogers, and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 4:55 pm to 6:01 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 427-012 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 427-12
Date: April 16, 1973
Time: 4:55 pm - 6:01 pm
Location: Executive Office Building

The President met with William P. Rogers.

     Greetings

Manolo Sanchez entered at 4:55 pm.

     Refreshments

Sanchez left at 4:55 pm.

       Watergate
             -President’s situation
                    -Advisory role fulfillment
                             -Attorney General
                                    -Henry E. Petersen
                                    -Richard G. Kleindienst
                                    -Difference from traditional role
             -John W. Dean, III
                    -March 21, 1973 meeting
                    -Jeb Stuart Magruder
                                       -23-

            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                        Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

        -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman, John D. Ehrlichman
                -Petersen
        -John N. Mitchell, Magruder
        -Possible testimony
                -Effect on Haldeman’s position
                        -Question of disposition of money
                                -Conversation
                                -Dean
        -Petersen
        -President’s schedule
                -Organization of American States [OAS]
                -White House correspondents event
                -Speech to building trades union officials April 16, 1973
        -Proposed action
Show the rest of the log (276 more lines)
                -Leonard Garment
        -Dean’s negotiations with prosecutors
        -White House staff involvement
                -The President’s query to Dean
                        -Response
                -Dean report
                -President’s role
                        -Limitation to investigation
                        -Magruder
                        -Mitchell
                        -Responsibility
        -E. Howard Hunt, Jr.
                -Ehrlichman
                -Petersen
                -Dean’s possible testimony
                -L. Patrick Gray, III’s custody of materials from safe
                        -Recollection on transfer
                -Material political, not Watergate
                        -Transfer to Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI]

William Rogers’ schedule
    -Dinner
        -Spiro T. Agnew
                                             -24-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

The President talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and
5:45 pm.

[Conversation No. 427-12A]

[Begin telephone conversation]

[See Conversation No. 38-72]

[End telephone conversation]

Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 4:55 pm.

     President’s schedule
         -Evening outing on Sequoia
              -Rogers
              -Arrangements

Sanchez left at an unknown time before 5:45 pm.

William Rogers talked with Agnew at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 5:45 pm.

[Conversation No. 427-12B]

[Begin telephone conversation]

[See Conversation No. 38-73]

[End telephone conversation]

     Schedule
         -Adele Rogers

     Watergate
        -Dean
             -Defense
                                           -25-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                          Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

William Rogers talked with Adele Rogers at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 5:45 pm.

[Conversation No. 427-12C]

[Begin telephone conversation]

[See Conversation No. 38-75]

[End telephone conversation]

       Watergate
             -White House staff roles
                    -Ehrlichman
                           -Responsibilities
                                   -National security leaks
                                   -Daniel Ellsberg
                                   -Hunt’s operation
                    -Testimony
                           -Mitchell, Dean, Magruder
                                   -Haldeman
                                   -G[eorge] Gordon Liddy
                    -Ehrlichman
                           -Materials from Hunt’s safe
                           -Relevance to Watergate
                           -Transfer to Gray of FBI
                    -Dean’s claim to act as agent only
                           -Ehrlichman, Haldeman, Mitchell
                           -Cover-up
                           -Placement of blame on Haldeman and Ehrlichman
                           -Lawyer Charles Shaffer
                    -Ehrlichman’s log of meetings with Dean
                           -Non-Watergate subjects
                                   -The President’s estate
                    -Dean
                           -Responsibility for investigation
                    -Post-Watergate break-in activities
                                             -26-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                              Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

                             -Funds for accused burglars
                                    -Dean’s conversation with Haldeman
                                           -Request for money
                                           -Herbert W. Kalmbach
                             -Dealings with defendants
                                    -Paul L. O’Brien
                                    -Liddy
                                    -E. Howard Hunt, Jr., Dorothy Hunt
                                    -Reasons for giving money
                                           -Mitchell
                                           -Campaign period post-June 1972
                                                   -Possible effect of allegations
                                           -Effect
                                                   -Ervin Committee
                                                   -Compounding of problem
                                           -Instructions to defendants
                                    -Lawyer for Cubans
                                           -Henry B. Rothblatt
                                    -Responsibility for money disbursement
                                           -Haldeman, Kalmbach
              -Ehrlichman
                     -Dean
              -Haldeman
              -Petersen

The President talked with Ehrlichman at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 5:45 pm.

[Conversation No. 427-12D]

[Begin telephone conversation]

       Watergate
             -President’s meeting with Rogers
             -Money [?]
                    -Purpose
                           -Ehrlichman’s knowledge
                                            -27-

                     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

       President’s schedule
              -Sequoia

       Watergate
             -Activities
                     -Magruder, Mitchell
                     -Petersen
                            -Materials from Hunt’s safe

[End telephone conversation]

Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 4:55 pm.

       Sports coat

Sanchez left at an unknown time before 5:45 pm.

       Watergate
             -Materials from Hunt’s safe
                    -Reason for characterization as non-Watergate related material
                            -Dean as source of information
                            -FBI

Rogers talked with Ehrlichman at an unknown time between 4:44 pm and 5:54 pm.

[Conversation No. 427-12E]

[Begin telephone conversation]

       Watergate
             -Recollection of activities
                    -Magruder
                    -Transfer of materials to FBI
                            -Gray

[End telephone conversation]
                                    -28-

           NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                    Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

Watergate
      -Materials from Hunt’s safe
              -Transfer by Dean to Gray
              -Characterization of material
      -Dean
              -Petersen
      -Possible White House action
              -Timing effect
      -Dean
              -Alleged pre-break-in conversation with Haldeman about proposed
               intelligence gathering plan
                       -Culpability
                              -Haldeman, Dean
                       -Fund
                       -Kalmbach
      -Pre-election action by defendants
              -Silence
                       -Press
      -White House staff’s relation to 1972 campaign staff
              -Money
              -Mitchell
              -Dean-Haldeman meeting about intelligence gathering plan
                       -Disapproval of plan
                       -Petersen’s interpretation of inaction
                              -Haldeman’s lack of role in campaign
                              -Dean’s role
      -Magruder’s testimony
              -Mitchell
              -Haldeman
                       -Role in campaign
                              -Separation of White House from campaign
                              -Campaign finances
      -Liddy’s proposals on intelligence gathering
      -Mitchell
              -Role in campaign
      -Haldeman, Ehrlichman
              -Vulnerability
                                              -29-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                              Conversation No. 427-12 (cont’d)

                              -President’s conversation with Petersen
                              -Possible indictments
               -Dean
                      -Actions
                              -Agent of President
               -Haldeman, Ehrlichman
                      -Position
                              -Retention of lawyer
               -Petersen’s conversation with President
                      -Haldeman, Ehrlichman
                      -Possible indictments
               -Magruder’s forthcoming testimony
                      -Promise by Ervin Committee
                      -Possibility of guilty plea
                      -Judge John J. Sirica
               -Dean
                      -Position
                      -Magruder statement
               -Grand jury

      Rogers’ car
         -Arrangements

      Watergate
         -Kleindienst

Ronald L. Ziegler entered at an unknown time after 4:55 pm.

       Car

       Press relations

The President, Rogers, and Ziegler left at 6:01 pm.
                                             -30-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 2 parts and the right one starts.

NixonBill, how are you? Bring Bring the Secretary's coffee, Manolo.
SanchezYes, sir.
W. RogersYes, we are. We are.
NixonWell, here's the situation, Bill.
W. RogersWell, [unintelligible] I tried to be totally impartial. In this particular case, though, you know, it's uh, it's uh, it's almost impossible. They all think that they're innocent of doing it, that it happened and so forth.
Nixonuh Listen, the thought the other day occurs to me that the problem that you have and that I have, you see, is that nobody's turned to me really. Well, there's no one to turn to. Usually a person has somebody that you take it over and—
W. RogersWell then how they turn to you, and how they turn to you and say, "Well then, putting aside I mean be truthful—"
NixonYeah.
W. Rogers"—and it would be best for them. What would be best for you?" And they're thinking about quite a few things that fit your your problem.
NixonYeah, but they have nobody else to turn to to tell their problems.
W. RogersI really, for the last three weeks, I've had really problems with my conscience. I kept hoping that that they had handled it.
NixonI must say that the— you see, when I went to see you the other day, you remember we were talking about that the
W. RogersWell, we get out [unintelligible]
Nixonand we were uh like the case could get to the Attorney General
W. RogersI'm terribly thrilled that it did.
NixonThe only part was he didn't get him, Petersen.
W. RogersReally?
NixonHe said Petersen. And that uh Petersen ran that. But he ran, of course,
W. RogersNow do you remember why did that? I don't care who ran it as long as it gets out. Now Petersen really surprised them by looking into it and putting on the pressure.
NixonAnd he had to Petersen had to report back to Dick on on everything that had happened to the President's people.
W. RogersI'm quite thrilled.
NixonAnd that's to Petersen. From everything I've heard he's a damn good, independent guy.
W. RogersYeah.
NixonHe is for the party.
W. RogersHe's for,
NixonHe took over there, but that, Petersen, Petersen is a
W. RogersHe did, but the fact, you know, for two months, Mr. President, they've had problems with him.
NixonYeah, I had suspected pretty fair occasionally. You know that. Because you see, that's what, they were afraid that the prosecution would look for the defendants to keep from talking.
W. RogersThey have only the guilty.
NixonSure, and Petersen and Dick, to their credit, said, "Halt. We can't shut it off. It's too late for that. We can't do it." Now,
W. RogersWe're in a situation where—
NixonIn this situation, they are what they assert about, Petersen has told Dick, that Bob, John, that John Mitchell and Magruder are going to testify against
W. RogersWell, the fact is, what Bob told me is the only information he's got is this prosecution, that this is the prosecution's belief.
NixonYeah, this is what the prosecution says, Magruder says, "Bob, John—"
W. RogersYou asked for money?
NixonSo, in other words, you get it out, and who it was, someone, uh, it's Mexican plan. Did you say Mexico there, but Dean testified it was Bob to Mitchell,
W. RogersWell, look, did they ask, "Why did you set up that fund?" The question is kind of an easy one, you can't blame them for the White House.
NixonDean.
W. RogersWell, what I start to say is, what Petersen said,
NixonWell, yes. But, what I'm supposed to tell them is that I did look for it today, and I found out
W. Rogersand you tell them what it is. It's like a the way to handle this thing.
NixonAnd so say counteracting anything they had.
W. RogersOh, a final alternative pretty much like everyone else's.
NixonUh,
W. RogersThe problem with it is that they have to get a fair shake, too.
NixonThat's true.
W. RogersI don't think you ought to be, uh, I think you ought to so will you, before they give them a call for a while? I don't want them to play the trick tonight.
NixonWell, Petersen didn't tell me this. He did speak well, so far, to me and he
W. RogersOn the line, I've asked if anybody's involved.
NixonAnd he did. It's the, so later, tell him what happened since.
W. RogersAnd then they spell it out. They get their shot.
NixonWell, why shouldn't, why shouldn't we do that? Because then they are, they make a statement. All the reason why this happens.
W. RogersThat's the reason which is true.
NixonWell, then, you see, the other thing that when he talked to me about that, that was all right. I got it all over again. I almost stopped in the, you know, in the middle of it. And that's what I wrote to them, then, so to speak.
W. RogersIt really wasn't my job to get the attention of the prosecutor, but I had stepped to try to check into it, and I found things that, well, it was considered a good idea. But then, that's what, that's what I did such as it was, and the prosecutor did it.
NixonThat's fine.
W. RogersWell here's, well, here's what the situation can be.
NixonAt least he soon will be.
W. RogersIf the first thing that happens is this leaks, it looks like it was all because this, like it's all over you know, with the with the pressure
NixonYeah. What if they get Petersen?
W. RogersThey are.
NixonThey are through.
W. RogersI know they will be, yeah. And then they'll say, "Why did you wait?" What about there being a gag on it, I mean half of this gag, because there isn't.
NixonWell then they go to the, to the grand jury, but not now.
W. RogersThe point is it doesn't preclude you
NixonNo.
NixonNow that the only thing—
RogersYes, but wait a minute, who told who? Who told who to do it?
NixonWho told—Hunt told, apparently—
RogersNow let's see. Hunt told—did Hunt say to him?
NixonHunt told Liddy. Let's see who was the first person that they spoke to about this. I think it was Hunt to Liddy.
RogersDid Hunt, and then Hunt instruction did did Hunt give instructions to get out of town?
NixonTo get out of town. Right. Did he walk with him down the street and said, "Well, maybe you ought to leave town?" You know Hunt was a CIA fellow.
RogersYeah, so did he. He was ex-CIA. It could be that he said to him, "You better get out of town." He said, "Yeah, sure." And then he went to Dean.
NixonNow, he'll say Dean, he will say Dean said that he should.
RogersAnd Dean said, "Oh, maybe you had Hunt told Hunt to tell him to do it, see? Who knows?
NixonHe did say, but he said that it was Dean's suggestion. He talked about that. Then he talked to Ehrlichman. Ehrlichman said, "My God, get him back here."
RogersHe this way he's doing the best he can, right? Being the pack rat, right? Piling up the pack rat.
NixonThat's right.
RogersI tell you what the trouble is.
NixonBecause Hunt told about this with relation to that information was got by Lord and Ehrlichman—
RogersWho? John—
NixonJohn Ehrlichman told, did make it in this. Not about Watergate. He had some files. He had some files that was not Watergate.
RogersAnd he was told, so that Ehrlichman would say, "It has nothing to do with Watergate. So what is hunt to do with it?" And he's gone and destroyed a bunch of, and thrown it in the street.
RogersNothing to do with it. But you do it, you better get a degree.
NixonDean. Dean threw his papers. See, and gave it to the acting head of the FBI, Gray. Dean. He gave it to Gray.
RogersThere's what he said last night. He's sure he knows it's true.
NixonGray threw them away. Gray called Kleindienst and said, "Information for the Justice Department to show you."
RogersWho did?
NixonGray. Kleindienst called Gray and Dean said, "No, they're political, you better destroy them."
RogersYeah. What if Gray did it, then why would that affect anybody?
NixonRight. And Gray didn't say, who said to get this information. He said, "Dean called me
Nixonand Ehrlichman and gave me this political stuff. And I'm going to tell them that you better take this out and throw it away."
RogersSo, Gray will say, "Dean gave it to me, Watergate." He said,
NixonRight. He said, "Give it to the head of the FBI." So, he didn't do it to help the FBI.
RogersSure. So the head of the FBI, that makes it silly, well, I don't think Gray, Gray wouldn't want to testify that way.
NixonNo, I wouldn't like for him to testify about it.
RogersWhy would Gray say, that Dean gave him—
NixonHe has told the prosecutors that. Yes, he's told the prosecutor.
RogersGray has?
NixonHe was talked to last night, after Petersen talked to him.
RogersOh.
NixonI think it was, I got a call also to Petersen.
RogersDid Gray say that he destroyed it?
NixonI think he threw them in the burn bag, I think that's what he was instructed to do. He threw them in the burn bag.
RogersDestroyed it? He threw them in the burn bag, and threw them in the ash can.
NixonDid he, Gray?
RogersDid he do that? Did they find a lot of them?
NixonDid he destroy them? Yes.
RogersYes.
NixonYes.
RogersWell, now, so far as Dean is concerned, what do you think is going to happen in the Dean case? Is Dean, does he, he has to deal with other people, though, that they'll charge them if he gives them the White House?
RogersThey just, they can't let him off, can they? I suppose so, on that kind of money.
NixonI can't imagine, with what they had, on Ehrlichman and Haldeman.
RogersThey'd have to allow him in to do it. It's I would only
NixonYeah, I agree. I agree.
RogersI don't think they'd Now, they will, there's other things that Dean I mean think what Dean's forgotten about doing. That's the real problem.
NixonYeah. What do you mean?
RogersWell, I didn't say uh, I'm thinking about the lawyers.
RogersI coached uh, I talked, I've talked to lawyers who've warned that, "You want him? We'll give you a lawyer."
NixonYeah.
RogersWell,
NixonYeah.
Rogersother things, like they've
Rogersalready been charged, with uh and the whole, and the whole business with the
RogersThey start to try to find out where the money came from, and they get this [unintelligible] who gets on the track, and then the money's paid, and they couldn't possibly tell what Dean did.
NixonYeah, well Dean—
Rogersthat's pretty well covered. It's pretty well covered.
RogersThe fact that now, if he got all the lawyers that's the only thing that's so, could be that's all he has, all of that.
NixonWhat is that, Bob? First of all, the perjury,
Rogersthey're doing it to say they did it because Dean did it, and uh and the lawyers and the lawyers' fees, Dean handles
NixonRight. Right.
Rogersall the uh payments. Who did this? Did who had who called him up to have somebody send him some money?
NixonWait. Wait a minute. Wait a minute.
RogersIf uh, if Hunt's lawyer called him up and said, "Look, Hunt wants to give a testimony, if you don't take care of this, he's going to tell them that you did it."
NixonRight.
RogersWhatever he said. Uh, the lawyers could have said that to Dean. So, Dean could've been, could've had a blackmail problem.
NixonEhrlichman took it, what did John say? He talked to Bob and Dean and said, "Well, you've got to do it, you've got to deal with them," he said.
NixonAnd he did not say they were paying the legal fees. He said they're dealing with them, and Dean
Nixonturned that information over to the head of the FBI.
RogersYeah, and that doesn't say whose instruction. That was Dean's instruction, wasn't it?
NixonYou know, and this yet uh is uh, Hunt is caught with this, for one, and Dean didn't protect them, did he?
RogersNo, who did it have to protect?
NixonHuh?
RogersWho did he have to protect?
NixonI think so, but he decided, in other words, that he wouldn't turn the FBI onto it. John, neither one thought that.
NixonNow the Peterson facts, [unintelligible] are substantially these, John and Bob and Ehrlichman and Mitchell,
Nixonand uh who else did he mention? He put Kalmbach in, but he didn't he said he never did a thing about all of that. He's not He's going to try and hold Ehrlichman to the [unintelligible] what he did in regard to the cover-up.
RogersYeah. What about Magruder?
NixonMagruder. He said, Magruder, Dean, Gordon Strachan, and uh well, Jeb. Strachan has split.
RogersYeah, Strachan. Not on the, not on the cover-up though.
NixonNot on the cover-up. Dean. Now, Strachan hasn't admitted anything about Dean and Mitchell, Strachan. You know?
RogersYeah.
NixonStrachan goes with John Mitchell and those people, although Strachan took the money, and the problem with Strachan, Dean will swear to that.
RogersYeah.
NixonAnd Dean will put him, Dean will put him, well Strachan got a lawyer, Strachan
RogersDean Dean said that Strachan told Haldeman?
NixonI don't He said Strachan took the money to the committee. And they gave it, Strachan gave it, gave it to him, to Gordon Strachan.
RogersAnd why is Bob involved?
NixonBecause Bob was the fellow who told Strachan to do it.
RogersStrachan says that?
NixonStrachan says Strachan says Bob said, Strachan called up Bob, Bob told him, "Get the money back." You see? But Dean—
RogersYeah.
NixonDean, that's what Dean says Bob Strachan told him.
RogersYeah, yeah.
NixonNow, but as far as Bob is concerned,
Nixonhe says he can't count really that, they don't, Peterson doesn't say,
RogersUh-huh.
NixonListen to the caterer. But Dean is pretty bad news for Bob, because Dean says Bob knew about it all.
RogersMhm.
NixonHe can't He had a talk with him, "Well, John, is that all?" [snorts] He's talking about a conversation in early December.
RogersThe three of them had a talk?
NixonBob, Dean, and Ehrlichman, and Dean took up the fact that that the defendants were beginning to press, they got to have some help.
RogersYeah, and they have to have more money?
NixonAfter Now, that's what Peterson told me Dean said.
NixonAfter, after the Goddamn thing happened,
Nixonthey uh they had to have money to take care of the defendants' lawyers' fees and to take take care of their of their families.
RogersYeah.
NixonApparently, Dean helped them. And he was he went to uh, well, this is another factor, Herb Kalmbach. He went to Kalmbach once, but uh I don't know who got this money to give it to them.
NixonThey had some other they got other sources, but Kalmbach did say he raised, well, Bob Kalmbach, they checked. Kalmbach did this under Dean's instructions.
RogersYeah.
NixonDean told Kalmbach it was all cleared. It was all for a great cause, humanitarian,
RogersLawyers' fees.
Nixonand so they got that in. That ain't Bob, you know, but apparently the money was raised through that bunch. The point is:
RogersWho dealt with the defendants?
NixonApparently, they, that was done by uh O'Brien, and the lawyers,
RogersMhm.
NixonHunt
RogersYeah.
Nixonand and Bittman. And Bittman received the money for them.
RogersMhm.
NixonNow, the question is, why did they give it to them?
NixonAnd why did they get it to them? I said I asked him that question. He said, "Well,
RogersMhm.
Nixonthat's just what the prosecution has to prove." He says, "You can't say it was blackmail. We're worried about that."
RogersAnd—
NixonHe said, "They were worried about campaign and they're worried about about this, that, and the other, they were worried about higher-ups involved, they were worried about who knows what." They were, Nixon was in the election. That's why he kept the God damn thing closed.
RogersKeep it closed so it wouldn't hurt during the election?
NixonWell, he was talking, yeah. He was talking about campaign. Isn't that right?
RogersSure.
NixonYeah. But anyway, that's what they were told. What happened then, they say—
NixonI uh uh then then the money kept going. Now, the question is:
NixonWere the defendants told, and finally, not to talk?
NixonThe defendants can't be told, not to talk, you know. That would be obstruction of justice, you see. If they were not to be up.
RogersMhm.
NixonIf they were told not to talk, it means go to the grand jury.
NixonBut if they were told not that's he doesn't think they'll have, you know, they'd say, like the FBI investigating and they were being asked, what do you know about any higher-ups? And they wouldn't talk.
RogersYeah.
NixonAnd they cooperated with them by paying for lawyers' fees. And that's obstruction of justice. Now, on that score,
RogersYeah.
NixonPeterson, they uh they uh
Nixonthey've got they've got another factor, another huge problem. The lawyers took guilt.
RogersMhm.
NixonThey have once you took this money and gave it to them, you won't have to worry about this. We will have you out in a year.
RogersMhm.
NixonExecutive clemency.
RogersCould have been done through Hunt.
NixonAnd uh and uh Colson is involved in that.
RogersYeah.
NixonEither Colson or somebody spoke, Colson's Peterson's getting that out from Hunt, and Hunt says that higher-ups promised executive clemency.
RogersYeah.
NixonNow, the question is: who did that? And the point is, everybody promises that. Peterson said, nobody says the President.
RogersExecutive clemency for
NixonHunt.
Unknown[unintelligible]
RogersAnd I think back at what Bob did
NixonI know Bob better. Bob did just what he was told to do.
Unknown[unintelligible]
NixonHow come that Dean didn't find out what else Magruder said? [unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
NixonSee, thing happens is, Dean would, well, uh, let's see. John wouldn't talk to him.
RogersDean wouldn't talk to him.
NixonRight. Dean wouldn't talk to him.
Rogers[unintelligible]
NixonLie and I guess which he did with what occurred, but Magruder lies.
Unknown[unintelligible]
RogersI think John talked to, uh, [unintelligible]
NixonDean talked to the [unintelligible]
RogersJohn told John.
NixonOh, John told John.
Rogers[unintelligible] and he came back and said, "Well, [unintelligible] was doing that." He didn't ask you, did he?
NixonHe asked me.
RogersHe didn't ask you [unintelligible]
NixonWell, Dean said, I recall this, all the, Dean said the grand jury's subpoenaing to that that
RogersMm-hmm.
Nixongrand jury that subpoenas will be issued.
RogersJohn talked to Petersen about the idea of taking a tap off.
Unknown[unintelligible]
RogersNow what about the story that you've had a criminal lawyer? Is that a rumor, too?
NixonDid Haldeman? Hell, no. Did Ehrlichman? No. John-
RogersNo, Ziegler's press conference was raw.
NixonNo, nobody. Nobody. That's another newspaper story. It's ridiculous.
RogersUh-huh.
NixonSee, once--you see what happens to the, to the grand jury, once the question gets raised of crimes, of possible crime,
Nixonhow does how does someone respond to that? Wiretapping is illegal. Destruction of evidence is a
RogersYeah, totally.
Nixoncrime, perjury is a crime, you see. If somebody throws all of those things in-
Rogersexcept this, that opposed to, uh, 50,300. Where does it end? How does it look? Well, we're getting the FBI after that.
NixonGood god.
RogersJust tell the Justice Department to, "Okay, here's the [unintelligible]
NixonOnce you have an election, what should you do with money raised during the campaign?
Unknown[unintelligible]
Nixonand we don't have the answer to that yet.
RogersI thought it'd be good to call,
NixonOh, John.
Unknown[unintelligible]
Rogersfact is that the package would have to be sealed to give notice that by Dean to raise this question.
NixonNo, but Dean didn't raise it. Dean raised it in mid-March, remember?
RogersDidn't he find out?
NixonHe said the prosecutors had called, told me, and that [unintelligible] was in the [unintelligible] that they
Nixonhad, yeah, they were going to do it. The trouble with Dean's position is, uh, having seen all of these people, then is to charge John with it on the other hand. I believe that
RogersEhrlichman?
NixonEhrlichman had questioned, I know that for sure that John, they discussed the water coolers and they did the [unintelligible]
RogersDean?
NixonDean.
RogersDean's in deep trouble.
RogersProbably bound for the clink. If so, they've got no excuse, do they? And none.
NixonIf so, there'll be no problem with that [unintelligible]
RogersI mean,
NixonI don't wish to-
RogersWell, hear the prosecutors [unintelligible] about the question. Why did they wait until something happens and they're through? Well, damn
RogersWait a minute. Then of course, the people up there could argue
Rogers"Well, [unintelligible]"
NixonWell, Dean said, I talked to Dean about this earlier. "How do we get this damn [unintelligible]?" Well, he had to take it, but the thing is
Nixonnone of us questioned it. None of us questioned what it was. We didn't know what it was for.
RogersThere's no question about the money. Now you had to have funds for a national committee. People don't sit around and think about it.
NixonThey had to pay for a recount. And he did talk about this uh, fund that they had for
RogersSure.
Nixon[unintelligible] He said that he did.
RogersYeah.
NixonYeah.
Unknown[unintelligible]
Rogersbefore the election, what did they do? You got a lot of cash, so what? Before the election, hell, and I certainly know of lot of it. See my god, if you buy this car and I give you cash, they look at it, "Where'd you get the cash?" If you bought it from a car dealer, they're standing here. They say, "Well, you have a right to.
RogersWhy shock somebody because they bought it with cash? You don't know who offered the cash. They offer the cash because they want [unintelligible]
NixonOf course. Well, that's what, turned out the kind of thing that
RogersYou see. Look at this, if
NixonYeah.
Rogersit appears, or it's it appears that he was saying, in effect,
Rogers"Okay, we've got to get some money to this fellow." But, he said, "I'm for this thing.
RogersI don't know." But,
Rogersif it appears that the money is to get them to strike the charge,
Rogersand not to talk,
Rogerswell that is that is another element.
NixonSee,
Nixonthat's right.
RogersIf everybody agreed, "Well, I can't understand it,
Rogersthe fellow was broke, and he had nothing, we had a legal defense, so everybody pitched in and had a few hundred dollars,
Rogersquite a different thing, although that would be, that's bad enough.
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogersif they had defenders [unintelligible],
Rogersno one, as a practical matter, could have shut out it.
RogersAlthough, like you say, it's not done now.
RogersUh, I gather the other thing is
Rogersthat that is the subject,
RogersDean Dean said he got the second meeting of Mitchell and entered in it.
RogersAnd then the whole question of Mitchell's role was discussed.
RogersThat is, we ought not to have any part of it, oh, I shouldn't say, we ought not to have any part,
RogersDean thinks Haldeman agreed.
RogersI haven't got that directly yet from Dean.
RogersDean says, "Haldeman, uh,
RogersWhat is your what is what's your recollection?
NixonWell, Dean was the one who
NixonThe way it came up was that
NixonDean claims that this fear of deception, I think that Haldeman,
Nixonand we've got to do something about this. And, so,
Nixonand Haldeman couldn't, I totally agree.
RogersYeah.
NixonNow, I think he thinks that took a great deal of credit,
Nixonand saying Haldeman,
Rogersall right.
NixonDealing with the fact, yeah.
NixonTherefore, it's- You get my point? I mean, why he went- I said, Haldeman is not going to be the candidate.
NixonHaldeman was not charging the budget.
RogersHe wasn't, no, he wasn't after all.
NixonDean, I would think, had a hell of a lot of responsibility there.
NixonHe should have gone right back and said, "Listen, whatever Haldeman said this is bad business."
NixonNow, Haldeman can't be hung on that.
RogersNo, I don't think he can, but,
RogersI really Haldeman did run a thing.
RogersHaldeman could know if he wanted to know, how about it?
RogersCan't, the rest of them would say
Rogers[unintelligible]
RogersWait, Dean was the chief guy, and Dean was the chief [unintelligible] for sure.
Nixon[unintelligible]
RogersI don't think so.
NixonIn other words, you have a truck driving crime, [unintelligible] they're trying to get a truck driver?
RogersThat's right.
Rogers[unintelligible]
NixonThe difficulty I have with this is that
Nixonif Dean is getting an immunity,
Nixonthey're doing it to get to the higher-ups.
NixonMitchell is higher,
RogersYeah, but Mitchell, they would get Mitchell anyway.
RogersThe person they get from Dean that they wouldn't get from anyone else is Haldeman.
NixonThat's
RogersAnd and maybe Ehrlichman, but Dean thinks he gets both.
RogersAnd, in fact, they've already told Haldeman, well, not Ehrlichman on that,
Rogersand Haldeman, if somebody else testified about that,
Rogers[unintelligible]
NixonGoddamn, it, that's impossible to believe that.
RogersWhy do you have why do you get that feeling, Dick?
NixonBecause Bob
Nixonhas made such, you know, has made such a big point, about
Nixonhaving nothing to do with the campaign and that he never saw anybody.
NixonAnd, whenever anybody talked about any
Nixonillegal, rather, tricky campaign, stuff he always
Nixonstood clear. He ran the paper, he ran the ads, he ran this, and he ran the television production.
NixonYeah.
RogersWell, I would take it on this,
Rogersthat he thinks that it's all right
Rogersto pay [unintelligible] this fellow,
Rogersthat, in other words,
Rogersif there's another part for the legal defense,
Rogersand fact is, that the fellow took it, that's his affair.
RogersIn other words, that's what, that's the distinction.
RogersIf you hire a lawyer for a fellow,
Rogersand you don't say to the lawyer,
Rogers"Now you shut up, and tell him to shut up.
RogersTake care of it, we'll give him some legal defense fund.
RogersAnd then the lawyer gets the money, and gives it to him,
Rogersand, and,
Rogersand he says, "Well,
Rogersshut up, for Christ's sake."
RogersAnd the lawyer says, "Yeah, I'll pay you,
Rogersand Haldeman could say,
Rogers"Well, look, the whole question was, whether
Rogerswe're doing it to shut him up,
Rogersand, that's what made the difference.
RogersCould have been that way.
NixonYeah.
RogersYeah, and they won't want to give-
RogersThey want to get immunity for higher, you know, to get the higher ups.
RogersWell, if they can't get immunity-
NixonExcuse me. If Dean makes a deal with Ziegler and and [unintelligible]
Nixonhe'd give immunity? Isn't that right?
RogersThat's right, to get Bob Haldeman or Ehrlichman.
RogersOr both, because they can get Mitchell anyway, and they can get Magruder anyway.
NixonRight.
RogersNo question about that, you see, so they have to say,
Rogers"If you can't get- If your lawyers can't get-
RogersWell, if Dean's lying, they can't get immunity.
NixonIf Dean is lying, they just don't believe him. Is that it?
RogersHe has to convince them
Rogersthat he can present [unintelligible] they'll take it.
NixonI see.
RogersAnd that's what his lawyers have been doing today. Trying to convince them that he can bring Bob Haldeman
Rogersin it. See, they won't give him immunity
Rogersjust because they like him.
NixonWell, anyway,
Nixonmy point is,
Rogersuh-huh
Nixonnow, that this this story is going to break, I think, in the morning papers.
RogersThat's what I think, too.
RogersNow that this-
RogersI, too, think so.
NixonWhy should the-
RogersIf you can, you should give your story today.
RogersMake a damn good statement, because that's the only way to beat it.
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogersthey're going to try to publish this on the first page.
RogersThey're going to [unintelligible] it tonight.
RogersNow-
NixonWell, Dean Dean hasn't [unintelligible]
RogersRight. I mean, they'll call, and Dean won't
Rogerssay, "I talked to so-and-so,"
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible] this clear
Rogersin my mind. I think that
Rogersit does make sense to do it today.
RogersUh, but I think, if if what you're gonna say
Rogerswhatever it is, requires Dean,
Rogers[unintelligible]
Rogersyou know, if I were in Bob's [unintelligible],
RogersI would say the the president ought to make a statement.
RogersAnd, if my getting out helps, the president,
RogersGod bless you, I'll do it.
NixonWell, Dean said Petersen came in about 2:00 and he said the President, you're the attorney, Petersen, Petersen is a very decent fellow. Very bright fellow. And he said Dean, you're also the attorney. So he called you both in. Then Petersen called Magruder. Magruder told him.
NixonMagruder spilled all this. So, Petersen went back then. Haldeman got hold of Petersen later that evening and Petersen said Haldeman also came out and said I'm fine. On the other hand, so, there's question about about that [unintelligible] questioned, Mitchell [unintelligible] talk to Ehrlichman.
NixonPetersen. So, Mitchell said, and Magruder said now look [unintelligible] Magruder they hadn't mentioned Mitchell.
NixonNow what happened there is that this morning, don't want to go to [unintelligible] to tell Haldeman, Mitchell, and then Mitchell, [unintelligible] here, let Petersen take it over. The only thing is they are only [unintelligible]
NixonMitchell said he got here 1:30. That's right. The first thing you got to do, you're not going to get into it. So why? The prosecution has got problems with that. [unintelligible] they're alright.
RogersThe White House [unintelligible] you know, that might happen. Ehrlichman is going to be convicted. You don't want to get [unintelligible]
NixonI don't think Haldeman is. But Ehrlichman has got a [unintelligible] problem. [unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible] you know what was said [unintelligible] that's fine, but that can fall through really quickly.
NixonSee, Dean wants to tell but they have to protect him. If they don't, he'll tell everything he knows about anybody. That's what he's told Haldeman and Ehrlichman. But the only [unintelligible]
Rogers[unintelligible]
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonHave a fresh drink? You'd be all right. Hell, that's better than nothing.
NixonThen you got to call him. But back here wonder if I could go that way. Yeah, I think that's good advice.
NixonYou think they've got [unintelligible] Yes. Well, they got to hate that. Right. All of it. [unintelligible] Yeah.
RogersIt's good to get it off. Really good.
NixonAbsolutely.
Rogers[unintelligible]
NixonYeah. Not that I need it. That would be awful.
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonHell of a note. I don't know why. Once you come out, that poor fellow's got the [unintelligible]
NixonGive him back the damn money and take that off, the public [unintelligible]
  • 038-071 4:42 PM · 38 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Julie Nixon Eisenhower talked on the telephone at 4:42 pm.
  • 427-011 4:42 PM · 36 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Julie Nixon Eisenhower met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 4:42 pm to 4:43 pm.
  • 038-072 4:55 PM · 26 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 5:45 pm.
  • 038-073 4:55 PM · 1 min — William P. Rogers and Vice President Spiro T. Agnew talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 5:45 pm.
  • 038-074 4:55 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 6:01 pm.
  • 038-075 4:55 PM · 20 sec — William P. Rogers and Adele (Langston) Rogers talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 6:01 pm.
  • 038-076 4:55 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 8:45 pm.
  • 038-077 4:55 PM · 14 sec — White House operator and President Richard M. Nixon talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:55 pm and 8:45 pm.

Conversation 427-012, April 16, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/427-012 (accessed November 20, 2026).