President Nixon, along with H.R. Haldeman, J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr., and Alexander Haig, discussed the escalating Watergate crisis, focusing on the potential release and legal implications of Haldeman's notes, the strategy for handling document requests from the Senate committee and grand jury, and the President's own knowledge and role in the events. Key concerns included the risk of executive privilege being overridden, the potential for damaging information to be leaked or misinterpreted, and the need to coordinate a White House legal strategy to protect the presidency.
On May 9, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, Alexander M. Haig, Jr., Manolo Sanchez, White House operator, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, and J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr. met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 6:35 pm to 8:26 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 434-009 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 434-9
Date: May 9, 1973
Time: 6:35 pm - 8:26 pm
Location: Old Executive Office Building
The President met with Alexander M. Haig, Jr.
Watergate
-J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr.
-Knowledge
-Daniel Ellsberg trial
-William M. Byrne, Jr.
-Request for documents
-H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman
-Notes
-Removal from office
-Destruction by burning [?]
-Buzhardt’s concerns
-Senate committee
-Questions
-Executive privilege
-6-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Location of notes
-Partial release of documents
-John D. Ehrlichman
-Information turned over to grand jury
-Content
-Charles W. Colson
-Copies of Ehrlichman’s notes
-Buzhardt
-Buzhardt’s opinion
-Colson, Jeb Stuart Magruder and John N. Mitchell
-Haldeman
-Notes
-Partial release
-Ramifications
-Ehrlichman
-Report on investigation
-Conversation with John W. Dean, III
Show the rest of the log (677 more lines)
-Money for defendants
-Outcome
-Buzhardt
-John J. Wilson
-Conversation with J. Bruce Whelihan
-Notes
-President’s papers
-Ownership issue
-Lyndon B. Johnson
-President’s role
-Wilson
-Buzhardt’s assessment
-H. Chapman (“Chappie”) Rose
-Haldeman’s notes
-Content
-Buzhardt’s assessment
-Partial release
-Haldeman’s possible grand jury testimony
-Use of notes
-White House strategy
-7-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Buzhardt’s assessment of notes
-Wilson’s strategy
-Haldeman’s ownership of notes
-White House strategy
-Pre-emptive action
-Congress
-Possibility of impeachment
-President’s conversation with John W. Dean, III, March 21, 1973
-Money for defendants
-Ehrlichman
-Report
-Haldeman’s assessment
-Response to charges
-Need to protect Presidency
-Release of documents
-Mitchell [?]
-Ronald L. Ziegler
-Haig’s role
-Buzhardt
-Relationship with John C. Stennis
-Haig’s recommendation
-Congressional hearings
-Possibility of delay
-Stennis’s role
-Committee membership
-National security concern
-Ehrlichman and Haldeman
-Documents
-President’s knowledge
-March 21, 1973 conversation with Dean
-Credibility of Haldeman, Dean
-Content
-Money for defendants
-William O. Bittman’s conversation with Paul L.
O’Brien
-E. Howard Hunt, Jr.
-Threats
-8-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Amount of money needed
-Conduit
-Cuban connection
-Las Vegas
-Money laundering
-President’s response
-Clemency
-Hunt
-Haldeman, Herbert W. Kalmbach,
Ehrlichman’s roles
-Ehrlichman’s notes
-Mitchell, Magruder, and Dean
-Haldeman’s notes
-Possible release to court
-Assessment
-Selective release
-Pre-emptive release
-Watergate compared to national security
-Use of executive privilege
-Possession
-Haldeman
-Court response
-President’s counsel
-Haldeman, Ehrlichman, Dean
-Lawyers
-Objectivity
-Buzhardt
-Compared to Leonard Garment
-Damage assessment
-Partial release of documents
-Ehrlichman’s report
Manolo Sanchez entered at 6:55 pm.
President’s telephone call
-Time of day
-9-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
Sanchez left at 6:55 pm.
Watergate
-Haldeman’s grand jury testimony [?]
-Haldeman’s notes
-Contents
-Need for White House Counsel to examine notes
-Possible release to Ervin Committee
-Pre-emptive partial release by White House
-Ehrlichman’s opinion [?]
-Garment
-President’s knowledge
-Haldeman’s notes
-Possible subpoena
-Buzhardt’s possible screening
-Haig’s support
-Haig’s possible screening
-Buzhardt’s objection
-Garment’s possible screening
-Rose’s recommendation
-Request for Haldeman’s documents
-Screening of Haldeman’s notes
-Haldeman’s house
-Buzhardt’s conversation with Wilson
-Location of Haldeman’s notes
-Use of executive privilege
-Haldeman’s appearance before grand jury
Haig talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9A]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-177]
[End telephone conversation]
-10-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
Watergate
-Haldeman’s notes
-Retrieval
-Executive privilege
Alexander M. Haig, Jr. talked with H. R. Haldeman at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and
7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9B]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-178]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Haig’s previous conversation with Haldeman
-Haldeman’s notes
-Haldeman’s possession
-Extracts
-Return
-Attorneys’ knowledge
-Conversation with Buzhardt, Garment, and Rose
Alexander M. Haig, Jr. talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 6:55
pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9C]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-179A]
Haig conferred with the President at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
-11-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
[Begin conferral]
Problem
[End conferral]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Buzhardt
-President’s choice as counsel
-Haig’s conversation with Haldeman
-Garment
Haig’s previous conversation with Haldeman
Haig talked with J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr. at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9D]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-179B]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Haldeman’s notes
-Wilson
-Meeting with Buzhardt, Rose, and Garment
-Reading of notes
-Executive privilege
-Haldeman’s comments
-Garment
-Possible contents
-President’s conversations with Haldeman
-Buzhardt
-12-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Haig’s support
-Knowledge of issues, temperament
-Experience with Congress
-Executive privilege
-Ehrlichman’s report
-Garment and Rose
-Handling of Watergate
-Buzhardt’s knowledge
-Contents of Haldeman’s notes
-President’s conversation with Dean, March 21, 1973
-Haig’s concern
-Haldeman’s and Ehrlichman’s involvement
-“Devil’s advocate”
-Acquisition of facts
-Henry A. Kissinger
-Possibility of Buzhardt’s review of Haldeman’s notes
-Meeting with Wilson
-Problem with Garment
-Anti-Semitism
-Haldeman
-Possible meeting between President and Haldeman
-Ehrlichman’s appearance before grand jury
-Information
-Ervin Committee hearings
-Commencement
-Dean’s appearance
-Immunity
-Dean’s documents
-Judge John J. Sirica
-Motion to release
-Timing
-Contents
-Garment’s opinion
-President’s actions after March 21, 1973
-Request for report
-Ehrlichman investigation
-President’s desire for full disclosure
-13-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Magruder, Mitchell, and Dean involvement
-Frederick C. LaRue’s involvement
-Money to defendants
-Haldeman and Ehrlichman’s involvement
-Haig’s opinion
-Ehrlichman
-Haldeman
-$350,000
-Haldeman’s notes
-Possible effect on Haldeman
-Contents
-March 21, 1973 conversation between President, Haldeman, and
Dean
-Intent of Haldeman’s attorneys
-Rose
-President’s possible resignation
-Haig’s forthcoming call to Haldeman
-Request for information
Haig talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9E]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-180]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Haldeman’s notes
-Meeting with President
-Executive Office Building [EOB]
Haig talked with H. R. Haldeman at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9F]
-14-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-181]
Haig conferred with the President during the conversation.
[Begin conferral]
Watergate
-President’s conversation with Dean and Haldeman, March 21, 1973
[End conferral]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Wilson
Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 6:55 pm.
Refreshment
Sanchez left at an unknown time before 7:55 pm.
Watergate
-Meeting between Haldeman’s lawyers, Buzhardt, Garment, and Rose, May 9,
1973
-Executive privilege
-Garment
-Content of Haldeman’s notes
-Haldeman’s lawyers’ knowledge
-Dean’s telephone conversation with Haldeman, March 26, 1973
-President’s meeting with Dean and Haldeman, March 21, 1973
-Dean’s interpretation
-Money for defendants
-Cubans
-15-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Las Vegas
-Clemency
-Hunt
-Amnesty
-Haldeman’s notes
-Wilson’s strategy
-March 26, 1973 conversation with Dean
-White House counsel
-Division of responsibilities
-Garment
-Buzhardt
-Ervin Committee hearings
-Attempt to delay
-Stennis
-Buzhardt
-Conversation with Samuel J. Ervin, Jr.
-Buzhardt and Thomas C. Korologos
-Ervin Committee
-Special prosecutor
-Television [TV]
-Hearings
-White House response
-Haldeman’s notes
-Location
-Executive privilege
-Possible meeting between Haldeman, Wilson, and Buzhardt
-Haldeman
-Meeting with Dean and the President, March 21, 1973
-President’s conversation with Richard A. Moore
-Dean’s knowledge of Watergate
-President’s telephone call to Dean, March 20, 1973
-Moore’s conversation with Dean
-Donald H. Segretti
-Haldeman
-President’s meeting with Dean, March 21, 1973
-Bittman threats
-Response
-16-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Necessity for Haldeman to convey story
-Compared to paper evidence
-Buzhardt
-Possible meeting between President and Haldeman
-Buzhardt, Garment, Rose
-“Feeling the cancer”
-President’s schedule
-Cabinet meeting
-Meeting with Buzhardt
-Meetings with Haldeman, Ehrlichman
-Buzhardt
-Possible role
-Documents
-Release
-Effect on Haldeman, Ehrlichman
-Ellsberg break-in
-Ehrlichman’s involvement
-Plumbers
-Ehrlichman’s involvement
-Documents in Hunt’s safe
-L[ouis] Patrick Gray, III
-Dean’s story
-Gray’s story
-Role
-Ehrlichman and Haldeman
-Mitchell’s request
-Dean
-Telephone call to Kalmbach
-Ehrlichman’s report
-Grand jury
-Kalmbach’s role
-President’s conversation with Ehrlichman, April 1973
-Dean report
-Ehrlichman investigation
-Submitted report, April 15, 1973
-White House’s assistance in breaking case
-Magruder
-17-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Magruder and Mitchell
-Ehrlichman’s report
-Grand jury
-Garment’s knowledge
-President’s actions
-Haig’s forthcoming conversation with Buzhardt
-Ervin Committee hearings
-Strategy
-Haldeman
-Wilson
-Possible meetings between President, Haldeman, and Ehrlichman
-Resignations of Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Reactions
-Richardson
-Confirmation hearings
-Ehrlichman’s involvement
-Haldeman’s notes
-Buzhardt
-Misunderstanding
-Wilson’s conversation with Garment
-Location
-Ehrlichman’s appearance before grand jury
-Haldeman
-Buzhardt
-Meeting with President and Haig
Haig talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9G]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-182]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-18-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Buzhardt
-Frustration
Haig talked with J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr. at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
[Conversation No. 434-9H]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 45-183]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Haldeman’s notes
-Buzhardt’s review
-Haig
-Interpretation
-Meeting between Buzhardt and Haldeman
-Haldeman’s conversation with Dean, March 26, 1973
-Dean’s report
Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 6:55 pm.
Announcement of Buzhardt’s arrival
Sanchez left at an unknown time before 7:55 pm.
Watergate
-Wilson’s meeting with Garment, Rose, and Buzhardt
-Executive privilege
Buzhardt entered at 7:55 pm.
President’s schedule
-Republican fundraising dinner
-Haig’s attendance [?]
-19-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 7:55 pm.
Refreshments
Sanchez left at an unknown time before 8:26 pm.
Watergate
-President’s knowledge and role
-Mitchell
-Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Possible guilt
-Possible indictments
-Mitchell’s indictment
-Ehrlichman’s report
-Grand jury
-Ervin Committee
-Effect on Ehrlichman, Haldeman, Dean, Mitchell, Magruder
-Magruder and Dean
-Mitchell
-Funds for defendants
-Ehrlichman, Haldeman, and Kalmbach
-President’s campaign role
-Motives
-Mitchell, Haldeman, Ehrlichman
-Evidence
-Hush money
-Hearsay
-White House staff
-Moore
-Public relations [PR]
-President’s conversation with Henry E. Peterson
-Garment
-President’s counsel
-Haig
-Buzhardt’s forthcoming meeting with Haldeman
-Haldeman’s papers
-20-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Haldeman’s conversation with Dean, March 26, 1973
-Wilson
-Meeting with White House lawyers
-Executive privilege
-Relationship with Garment
-Ronald L. Ziegler’s view
-Buzhardt’s role on White House staff
-Compared to Garment
-Ervin Committee
-President’s papers
-Haldeman, Haig, and Kissinger
-Haldeman’s papers
-Grand jury schedule
-Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Haldeman’s papers
-Executive privilege
-Ehrlichman’s and Dean’s papers
-Haldeman’s notes
-Executive privilege
-Buzhardt
-President’s papers
-Haldeman’s papers
-Ehrlichman
-Leaks
-India-Pakistan
-Press reaction
-Buzhardt’s legal experience
-Possession
-Papers compared to oral conversations
-Ehrlichman’s conversations with President
-Grand jury testimony
-Haldeman’s conversations with President
-Ervin Committee
-Wilson’s viewpoint
-Buzhardt’s conversation with Stennis, May 3, 1973
-Buzhardt’s possible role on White House staff
-Stennis’s willingness to assist the President
-21-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Stennis’s position in Senate
-Stennis compared to Ervin
-Ervin Committee hearings
-President’s efforts in investigating
-Mitchell, Ehrlichman, Haldeman, and Stennis
-Compared to Alger Hiss case
-Grand jury activities
-Compared to Lavelle case
-Ervin Committee hearings
-Effects on possible defendants
-Ervin
-Republicans
-Howard H. Baker, Jr.
-Scope
-Segretti
-Members’ desire for publicity
-Possible pressure from peers
-Stennis and Barry M. Goldwater
-Lawrence F. O’Brien
-Korologos
-Bryce N. Harlow
-Buzhardt’s priorities for action
-Haldeman’s possible meetings with Haig, President
-Buzhardt’s role
-Richardson’s concerns regarding Buzhardt
-Haig
President’s schedule
-Republican National Committee [RNC] fundraising dinner, May 9, 1973
Watergate
-President’s conversation with John B. Connally
-Resignations
-Ehrlichman and Haldeman
-President
-Possible impeachment
-Obstruction of justice
-22-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 434-9 (cont’d)
-Bella S. Abzug and Paul N. McCloskey, Jr.
-December 1972 bombing
-Rules
-Possible White House response
-Possible effect on nation
-Compared to 1964 campaign bugging
-J. Strom Thurmond’s campaign [?]
-Buzhardt
-Buzhardt’s classmates
Haig and Buzhardt left at 8:26 pm.
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
HaigHe says all the documentation, while we held the notes, they were all here. In a technical sense, we could prevail with executive privilege. We cannot prevail if they have, have asked for the documents.
NixonThey have not yet, so he better get them back here.
HaigYes, well, I think they're frantically trying. You got to remember that he doesn't have [unintelligible]. Well, that's one side then.
HaigThe next thing he had said that they're in a terrible quandary because there's nobody who can defend the, in a sense, defend you, Mr. President.
HaigI, I told them, "It isn't, this is serious, serious enough, but, by God—"
HaigTheir great fear, every turn, as you go down the road, hey, that the documents will become compromised. He's certain that that'll hurt you. And, uh, if there's even a copy of them, if there could be a leak, or there could be stolen pieces of records. Some took copies before you even put uh, put on.
HaigAnd, uh, that's very, some of it's stuff the people damn Marjorie implicating John, but very bad Colson. All may damned and about four other, very tough ones for the staff, because they get contacts that they shouldn't have had.
HaigHe has facts, uh, hard, uh, facts about contacts. Buzhardt asked, he went over it, John, uh, he said,
HaigJohn's judgment's follow and he's probably in pretty good shape, based on those documents.
HaigAnd their views this, this afternoon about, they're going to ask Bob for his documents.
HaigAnd they said if he, if he takes the position that, uh, no, they can't have them, say, "Do you got them?" and, "You have no thanks to ask."
HaigAnd then they'll, subpoena whatever, and they'll put him in jail, holding him in contempt. And a lawyer will get him out of jail, of course, but it's a very tough position for him.
HaigSo what they concluded is that in the best case, probably the documents would come out if they were selectively treated with more needs.
HaigMaybe not, but it's one we have to make that judgment call, that's why they're so they want to make that judgment call.
HaigIf it's the worst case, then it will be very critical on Bob's terms.
HaigThat may be all of that. At least they know what they have to do, and then they have strategy so they'll have to to go from there, but with explanations, they will be very helpful.
HaigA selective release or more even, you know, they think would be very helpful, quite candidly. Did John, his investigation, did John?
NixonGrand jury, no, excuse me, our green counsel. Can he get them okay?
HaigWell, they got him, I'm sure he's studying it before he testifies to be sure he's totally, and stuff.
NixonWell, then he's still safe. I think he's got to say that they they belong to the President. I if we can conquer those documents.
HaigWell, I don't know, I, I don't either. He has no justification.
NixonI know, they say that the, if they're principled, that Johnson used to insist on all of every note made the case of the best for the media and belongs to him. The notes were The notes made by ministers and the staff belong to the President. And that's the line, cough, cough, that we're going to have here.
HaigAnother thing, Fred told me that they shouldn't answer, there's always one, they'll be fined.
NixonAnd that for the conversation, that's the first time he told me about it. The whole conversation was one of exploring what the hell they were all up to. And I said, "This is absolutely incredible."
NixonHe said, "Yes." And we turned, we talked about that, especially in, you know, with John's
Nixonreports to his credibilities and so forth. Exactly. That's right.
UnknownAll right, now, he now did a very damnable problem. He wants me to present a question. Can you take notes?
UnknownYeah, notes.
UnknownNow, he, now, who shot someone already he saw.
UnknownYeah. What happened, this is
UnknownWhat actually will, it has to have, What actually has to be protected in this bunch?
UnknownHis own personal notes.
UnknownNothing has been asked for.
UnknownI agree.
UnknownHis concern about protecting himself, well, who's the lawyer? That's right, Mr. President.
UnknownWhy would we choose to come out, clear, in understanding. Why don't you talk to him, and see
Unknownto the town counsel, check it.
NixonNo, I told Haldeman here Mr. President, I testified before.
UnknownI don't. I don't.
UnknownSo I'm far more confident than either of your agents. In fact, if we should shoot this through and say that that night, right, he can pour it for us.
UnknownThey are very, very close to Sturgis. The Senate's What you got to understand, I'm already recommended, right? We're all right down there.
UnknownWe can the committee can discuss that and having all that they can win away.
UnknownWhy? There's no other way to stop these damn hearings. Okay.
UnknownCounsel for the defendants can't do it, they're cancelled.
UnknownYeah. The Attorney General can't swing it. There's only one way.
UnknownAnd that is for these senators to have Stennis
Unknownmove for a delay of the hearings for [unintelligible]
UnknownHe wants to blast this in Stennis and say, "Look, this is a matter of vital interest. You're going to force up the national security status violently if you get this thing on the control."
UnknownAnd had to find out from Stennis who else we should deal with, and at least get on the sex problem. That doesn't cost anything [crosstalk] with Stennis.
NixonI have no objection. Let me say, I have nothing to hide. Believe it.
UnknownThat's, that's what we understand.
NixonAnd I didn't think, from what I know, I now worry more about
UnknownThings we shouldn't worry about. Al,
UnknownHoney, listen.
Nixonthe the whole business, you know, mean, when you talk about this the other day, the one conversation with Dean, and the only one that you could was the one on March 21st, that I told you about.
Nixonif it was, if you saw it in cold print, and it was interpreted by Dean in the light of an innocent, But by Bob Haldeman, it's going to look exactly the opposite.
NixonBecause what happened was he came in and for the first time said, "Look, there's a cancer around the White House." "Well, John, you never told me, and you've got to tell me the facts." He says, "Yes, I will." And so he proceeded to go down the line.
NixonAnd that's when he got into for the first time
Nixonhis own recriminations, which I told you about, the warning, perjury and all that, but he got into this business of
Nixonthe use of the raising the funds for the defendant.
NixonAnd I, you went into that. Well, it's, it's, how's your wife, and is it a legal, and I asked him if that's
NixonHe said, "Well, if it is for purposes to shut him up."
NixonAnd then he raised the, the one point, the one point of a, of a current thing.
NixonShit, for a chance overnight, would be to the tune of, you know, how much. It did seem quite cold hard.
NixonBlackmail. There's no more, and it's been in the papers for months. It's called, you know, a bribe and turned into this thing several times.
NixonNot attorney fees and other money too, but mainly $120,000 I think for the fees.
NixonAnd I said, "Well, what's, what's all that mean?" And that evening Haldeman said he didn't, and Bennett says to O'Brien, "We don't get it, that he said that Hunt will blow the lid off of everything, the same as other work he's done."
NixonI said, "Well, what do you mean with other stuff?" And he started to go into that, that whole of that crap at that time, so forth. And I said, "Well,
Nixonwhy? Well, he can get the $120,000, but how long, how do you, how's, how's this going to work out?"
NixonI said, "What, what, that, that takes care of it now. What happens over the next four, for the next four years?"
NixonAnd uh he went into, and Bob Haldeman's recollection is exactly mine, my recollection.
UnknownBob is the same.
NixonAnd I said, we, what did he take? He said, "It'll take a million, probably a million dollars." I said, "Well, we could probably get that, but how would you get it to him?"
NixonI could go to a Cuban committee or something like that, you know, we're not very good at that.
Nixonmention anything. We can't use Dean about that either. You know, you got to take the money through Vegas, wash it, and send it around, all that kind of stuff. But again, he indicated that he was to know what the hell was going on.
NixonI said, "Well, they did. The way the whole thing went wrong." I finally said, "I thank God I have I have in the conversation with Bob later on, in which I said, well, part of the meaning is first it won't work, second it's wrong."
NixonAnd then I also had in there, I said clemency. I said, "For example, Hunt wants clemency." I said, "I couldn't even think of clemency till after 1974." Wouldn't even think of it. I said, "Even considered it." I said therefore that, uh, "this whole thing is, this just won't work."
NixonAnd then I also have in the word, er, Bob has a recollection that's wrong. I'm sure that it was. Whatever.
HaigAll right, you see, that's that's very nice. It really is. And what worries me is, you know, they're probably some, uh,
NixonI worry about it because I know how how Dean might try to interpret it. Now Dean was not Dean, on the other hand, you see, Al, that was the first time,
Nixonafter 9 months of investigation, that Dean came in and said that money was being raised for the purpose to get people to hush up. I never knew about Bob's transfer of 350,000, he never told me about it. I never knew about the fact that they've sold some launch in there that they've been getting fund off of their wives.
HaigRight. I'm sure that's the trouble. I don't know about Ehrlichman's, why if they're showing them that, then I'm sure that John and Bob Did you hear anything about them? No, I haven't read them. But they shouldn't give extracts from that.
HaigWell, mostly it's hearsay. Different people accusing other people. Yeah. And that's what, yeah, and they all accuse him. And all were to indict each other.
NixonAnd didn't they, uh, and didn't Magruder mention Finch and Dean, all that?
NixonI don't mind that he puts his in. Uh, but, in other words, what are you saying here about Bob's package? In other words, you have you have him turn them over to the court? No.
NixonI I mean, I hate I hate that he will go to jail if he doesn't, is that the problem? But, on the other hand, I didn't want to see that. Well, I think they can get him.
HaigI I think they can get him. It's far better for us to look right now and think, think of damages, sir. Yeah. And and consider whether or not we shouldn't make a selected release.
HaigMake that judgment. So, we're saying in the worst case, if they we can preempt. We can say, "Hold on here, all national security we can't give, but we'll give you and our counsel, all professional judgment"
HaigWell, now In other words, what we could do here is, even if we had Bob's documents, we could say at this point we determined that in privilege, no matter what he's done, or he can't, because, as he said, you can't sustain it because executive privilege is no more than raw power.
HaigFine, but existing power is what the executive privilege is. If you've got the fourth troops and you've got it in hell. In this instance, the documents are out of our power.
HaigRight now, they're not under presidential control. Originals are, copies are not. And if they say to Bob, "Do you have your notes?" And he says, "Yes."
Haighis lawyers do, because they've told him they've begged him to get every They'll say, "Tomorrow on the stand, be with those. You must have." And if he won't give it, then they can hold him in contempt. They can tell him to yell if they get them now. But they have the legal authority to then, to break executive privilege.
HaigYou see, every day, we come to a harder place. Blessing. Well, now, I think we're very close to [unintelligible] what to do. We've got a strategy. You must think it through. Absolutely, I don't think so permanent,
Haigbut I think the worst part is, apparently, now, even after rollover, shit, you're getting your counsel from people who have no engaged.
HaigAnd they, and they can't sit here, and I hate for you to be subjected to that, but I really think, you know, what, what are the things you've said, it's constantly been about the same picture. There being a chance in the world of being able to defend John. Right.
HaigYour council who support you in this is totally dedicated to only your interests. Right. And I, and I have great respect for Bob and and for John, but they're, their lawyers are, are taking the view despite their own
HaigThey they consider themselves you and, and you see they're not.
NixonAnd I must look out for them. I can't help it, uh, uh,
HaigWell, I What I would need would be play it straight with them and tell them that we have to make sure you have decided that you are one council. One. Right. Personally. It's my own man.
HaigIt's your own man. John and Bob. And then you will make it. And damage assessment is whether it's better to gird ourselves in every way for the take, under no circumstances [unintelligible]
HaigFine. Or whether perhaps selective release will not serve the best interests of us.
NixonWell, I wonder if they won't accept a selective release.
HaigWell, that's what John's report was. Huh? That's what John's report was.
NixonWell, I said you mean and have him turn over the notes.
HaigEven if we have the documents here to be sure that the judgment is being made by your council are totally in your interest.
HaigThat they're not being distorted by that. And twice, it's been, in fact, well they're trying to see they're not trying to hurt the President, they want to sort of that.
HaigAnd, uh, now what could happen here, that one piece of paper, God, interpreted in that form, could be murderous. On the other hand, that same piece of paper, under our control, which we've explained, the entry,
NixonPick up Pick up, Al, if you kind of expect me not to work too much tonight. I would totally trust Mr. Buzhardt. You know, look you get into a wedge, not because I would distrust him, because I don't trust his judgment. Judgment. No, no. He'd be all excited.
HaigWell, I take poor Buzhardt's, they're they're having to hurry in the background, Huh? they're operating in the background, we cannot give even in that sense. It's not worth it.
HaigEven having permit isn't worth that, because they have to know what's impossible in that area. You're right. If Bob's papers are near,
Haigand obtained by the court, or if at some point er we get caught with
NixonWell, you know, I suppose he's actually put on even the notes on the night I talked to him about his resigning too. Boy. Rough trip.
NixonFor now, I issue a seven-minute discussion of Watergate.
NixonLet me say this, Al: I am not concerned myself about anything incriminating and anything that I've done. You know what I mean? I know what I've done. You know, I mean I told everybody, you know, there's nobody else. That's, you know, I mean I frankly, I was not informed, and I don't blame people for not informing me because I was too busy with other things.
NixonAnd that's a reason, and probably if I had been informed, I must say maybe I wouldn't have done anything anyway. You know, you know how busy we were, goddamnit. September and October and November, then the peace crisis and December and January, and I didn't worry about this goddamn Watergate.
NixonThat's right. I wouldn't let people talk to me about it. Other people were running the campaign. I tried to run the campaign, but not that part of it, the same thing.
NixonAs they said, the only, the only thing that I knew this thing was getting kind of thick, I I said, "I have no problem with Buzhardt looking over anyway, got to have somebody to look at those, that's not what I'm concerned about, your plans. You know, you, Mr. President.
NixonWell, the point is the point is, well, maybe we have no choice. I think, "I don't quite, quite get your point there." When I say that they're going to get the guy, they're going to just subpoena all these documents anyway and subpoena all those books. Yeah.
NixonNow I'm saying there, I want to see what the issue is. If the issue is that, then what the hell, why does anybody have to look them over? Well, they'd have to do that to know what what they're going to have to do, that's their opinion. Buzhardt says that if he can screen these very quickly. Well, I'm talking about his plans. Not that much. Huh? That's not that much.
NixonA bunch of material, I'm sure, of screening. Making sure that Bob's notes were just on Watergate matters. And well, if they get, if they have different things, he can take all the the other, you know, the worldwide things out. And I'm sure that's what more of the trouble would be than in the Watergate in that instance.
NixonNow, I have confidence in this guy Buzhardt, he's sound for one. And damn it, he's done it. So do you know what first crossed my mind?
NixonI said, "Good, I do that." I said, "Why do I get to screen this stuff?" And he said, "No, you can't do that, of course, then you're not legal counsel." And that is sound thinking. Even if you said, "Counsel"
NixonYou haven't got that legal communication with the courts. Way of thinking counsel did. But Buzhardt in his form, well, how would Howard know? I would never have let Howard go through any damned documents. Doesn't
NixonI'm not sure to use a prosecutor, are you? But he could have had an auditor or, you know, this man is certainly sound. That would be respected, you see.
NixonDetective to you. The reason, what they should do, what first he asked Bob for his documents, first before Bob screams this stuff.
NixonYour plans? Bob. I would do that, but I'd tell Bob. "Then why don't you go secretly to Bob's house?" I know, but, well, the lawyer told him even though that Bob okayed, "You, personally, haven't viewed them."
NixonThen, the lawyer told, told Buzhardt the same thing. Apparently, Buzhardt asked him for them. "No," he said, "I'm advising you you have them, you have Bob's notes out of the building?" He said, "Yes." So, that shattered their whole approach if they were going to play, going to take the position
NixonLet us suppose that he doesn't. There's a chance, I suppose, if they don't get the that then Bob turned around to turn it in. He
HaigHe said, "Now, I can't guarantee you call this in, if it's true, all that, can we get them all?"
NixonNow, if they haven't got them, I think I think the other course of action would be to get the goddamned things back this morning. Because there'll shit to gear if Bob, all of them got in. And we can turn them in, but they've asked for it.
NixonNow, they, Cheney, is on the code line. Well, let me, they, we're not to panic at all. Maybe, maybe they haven't. Hey. Yeah, Bob? How'd you do?
NixonBob, have you, have you got copies of your notes out of the building here in your lawyer's hands? And have they told our people that they did? Be sure of that.
NixonWell, our people, by, I shouldn't say that, our people. Buzhardt said that your lawyers said that you had copies in the hands of the, had copies in the [unintelligible] the answer was yes, they tested Buzhardt.
NixonWell, what they're worried about Well, they gave me copy, they gave copies [unintelligible] that's all he gets.
NixonDo they have to be back? See, I understand that if you were asked if you had any notes you wouldn't have to pledge privilege, but the problem is, if they're outside they may have
NixonWell, who told, did they, yeah, they told me they had to be destroyed.
NixonYou opened it, they came in or that they destroyed it? Yeah. Buzhardt did.
NixonWell, it was Chapman, Buzhardt, and Ehrlichman were all in the section came out. Into all of those that they found out.
NixonYeah. Well, the point is we, he said, you answered my question. You answered my question. If you didn't turn them over to them, and they described them and they [unintelligible]
NixonWell, but they, yeah. Yeah, well, but they can't subpoena Just a minute, hold you a minute, will you? And if we can force him to march over to search, [unintelligible]
NixonAll right, well let's put it this way: what he should have done was call me. Now, Bob,
HaigI don't think it was malicious, Mr. President.
BuzhardtSo, we call him in. So, he knows the chapter and verse on [unintelligible] that we're talking about here. He came in and offered, and I said, "Do you mean to tell me that this is what you want me to have?" And he said, "Yes."
BuzhardtAnd they're either, and he'll know it. And then, he said on page 4,
Buzhardtfour-page portion of it, which he said he read to me, it's very, very damaging to Bob. [unintelligible]
Buzhardtbe sure, and a boy to bob it to Carmon, and
Buzhardtand telling him, "What did you say tonight?" So that, and it's some of the pitch that everybody.
NixonWell the point, however, is some problem and having trusted—
Nixon[unintelligible] I'm glad you came over here, Al. You have to step across this.
NixonTo always bring these things directly to me, because I’m uh and I don't want you, you must never have any doubts about am I being afraid of anything now. You know what I mean. I'm not afraid of anything in Bob's notes, I'm really not.
NixonExcept for the fact that uh we had a hell of a lot of free discussion about this, you know what I mean. Not about pay
Haigpaying anybody off, or something like that. I mean,
NixonGood God almighty! They can't have his notes of his conversation with me any more than this conversation like this. You don't want that in the courtroom.
HaigJohn is sure he knows the worst situation, Bob doesn't. Hey, didn't Bob say to you on
HaigAnd if he knows one thing, and how easy it is.
HaigNow, he said if it's just a question of money, I'm only concerned if it's in the basement in this discussion, but I didn't want you to succumb. He said hang on that.
NixonAnd that that's what being a pro is, as I told you. If you go through something like that in public, well, you don't want to be disgusted. But the point is,
NixonAnd on the view, who saw it that part, and Bob was honest and brought it forward. That is the point. That was the day that I started my investigation, see the point?
NixonThat he revealed this. We discussed the matter, but we didn't devil man, we didn't do, we didn't do anything about it. We talked about it.
NixonWe talked about I told about I and I brought up the the impossibilities of it, you know, and so forth, and so on. Arguably,
Nixonwhat if people do it, how would it work, and so forth.
NixonAnd I realized then that these boys were in way over their heads.
HaigThat's right. That's right. My greatest concern here causes me causes me, John and Bob,
NixonYeah, well, I meant at that point, Dean was in over his head, Dean was it Those guys were Way! Dean was the one that was talking about this. He, uh, the money.
NixonLet me come back to this judge thing. That that What in the name of God is he, uh, asking for having those documents?
HaigWell, Byrne's Byrne claims his docket is his scheduling problem. He claims his docket's full, and he won't be able to address the motion until Wednesday.
HaigThat's the he doesn't trust he's so completely distracted.
NixonHis memcons are going to be what he remembers for Christ's sakes, and
Nixonhe's got to have it in a way It's only a self-serving twist, I'm sorry, who is it that had He's done it a couple of times on others. Second, his 43-page thing, for Christ's sakes, why did he write it months ago?
NixonTold me he'd get something done. He didn't get anything done. He didn't come to talk to March 21st, when he told me the story. And I did something, that's the point.
NixonWell, I think, uh, told him to write a report. He put Ehrlichman to work, and Ehrlichman ran his report. And finally, what happened is Magruder and Dean both, sort of, cracked pretty much the same day, surely, you know. Which is all right, I'm glad they did now.
HaigAnd his lawyer said he would run down the street if he saw it. That's what he called.
NixonNow listen, one thing you can't discount, these guys, how to be able to find out what the hell's going on, well motivated, but also perhaps just what it is.
NixonWell, Bob understands though that I want you to
HaigHe's sure, and he's sure. He understands that the 21st conversation is one that can't be explained.
NixonAll he has to do though, he said it would be difficult, right? But it's explainable. It'd be difficult, but explainable. I told you, I've you know heard the way it comes out.
HaigHe hasn't heard it, I guess. That's, but how else would he
NixonWell because he, you know, I just took the stance that I don't give a damn. But how are you going to explain the instances of the 21st? All right,
NixonI think I know. He's told you twice now, why don't I try this? I just don't think it's, I don't think it's unmatched in any way.
HaigAll depends on who tries to match it to say that it's contradictory. Right.
NixonDean will say that they responded well and the way that he saves the $120,000 commission, why did you get that?
NixonHow much did they take before here? They get that whole dog and pony show together. No, but
Nixonwith that, Christ, we had to go back to see if we could put in it, and then some hour later get a deliver it all to Cubans, all these that, and see why now they had to do it for legal expenses.
NixonI don't know what, all Clemency, Clemency's hard to deal with. Hunt was scared to death.
NixonClemency, how does that talk happen? What about What about the piracy thing? You can't give anybody Clemency. Well, they had said before that there is Hope. I said, "In what way?"
NixonThey've been talking, but look, you know somebody's there been rumors floating around about giving Clemency by Christmas.
NixonBullshit. Nobody had ever discussed such a damn thing to me, and I wouldn't dream of it.
NixonAnd I told him sitting, do you want that guy to be a damn fool to be talking about a wired ear? Not in here.
NixonAnd Bob said he, what's, so what about him was he wired during that scare?
HaigAnd that doctoring paper business done the 21st and the 26th serves to totally break down any confidence in Bob.
HaigAnd that's dangerous. To have it in both areas could could double Bob to the point that he couldn't play tough. Said his lawyers are gonna tell him, listen, don't trust
NixonThat's bad, yeah. But the problem is other things are much, other allegations that are bad.
HaigI don't know if you get what I mean, Buzhardt's feather in the mind, but the sentiment exists and each one man does belong is probably the council for the he understands
Haiguh that, I think there's enough work there that there's got to be a lawyer to do some fighting. But I want Buzhardt to be the man who gets holds the information problem and makes basic choices.
NixonWhich we're going to have to have to make, Hugh, and certainly decide uh what to do about the Senate next Thursday. You got to get that actually blocked
Nixonor postponed. I believe we're going to have to get uh some work done on the Hill. I'd like to tell to go and have a discussion with Stennis,
HaigAll right, and then come back to see if we're successful. Find out who says so we need to help.
NixonThen they'd be two or three other guys we should talk to.
HaigI don't know whether, I don't see how Stennis could do it for the reason that Stennis is not on the Ervin committee, and neither is Eastland.
NixonErvin would, well, if Stennis would talk to Ervin, wouldn't he? I think so. I uh I like to get his strategy in detail
Haigdeeply wants to fix this off, does he ever? We fucked with him about, though, getting heavy flak and he's delicate.
NixonI know. I know how delicate he is. I talked to him three times only. Yeah.
HaigWell, should we get into Buzhardt's lunch tomorrow then on that on that? I think we should. And that's We've gotta tend to text changes, and so we have that on the PM program.
NixonYeah, put Buzhardt, put uh Korologos in and everybody concerned in that these hearings have to be What What arguments can be made about postponing them besides the prosecutor?
HaigThe due process of justice, the goddamn committee first insisted that we appoint a a special prosecutor. We sit down and we appoint a special prosecutor. We are in the process of doing it.
HaigNo sooner do we start that, then they usurp the whole goddamn thing and make his task, before he even takes an oath, an impossible one
Haigby conducting a television circus at the risk of the the witnesses, the facts. That's right. We've got to fight the hearings.
NixonThat's that's And if we don't, if we don't, we will fight it. By fighting it, even if we lose, it will help to discredit it.
HaigThat's right. That's right. It will all come out just that way.
NixonWell, I think we can I think we can do something. Well, damn it, I'm glad you got hold of Garment. Shift your mind's attention to that. To that documenting business, and so forth, because I just damn well don't see how that fits, you know.
HaigYou know a thing like that could leak out the wrong way, and Bob was so conscious of that, and I couldn't even see Bob.
NixonOh, wait. And he says he does not have, he doesn't have his papers outside of it, you see. That's some expense, and he'll realize that they in here gets them
Haigback on it. Trying to study his testimony. Should've seen Ehrlichman today, too. Yeah.
NixonYou can't risk having any papers home that he doesn't want to just be able to hand over. That's right.
HaigThat's right, because we can assert privilege on the papers we hold and we control.
NixonAnd that and I think we should. I do too. I really do. I don't believe they're that I don't mind Buzhardt look over papers, you know, thing of that sort that I mean not giving them to. But but leave that stuff to Bob.
NixonBecause Bob. Look, let me say this, you will know how to frame Bob conversation better than me. It's obvious it's screwed up because I just don't know.
HaigI don't think it would be too hard, yeah. All what I was hoping to do was to have Bob talk to this guy Buzhardt and have Bob's lawyer talk to him and let them build some confidence between the two because right now it's all skepticism.
HaigAll suspicion. See that's Bob's concern about anybody who defuses information.
NixonI don't blame him. He's bound to, unless he's Bob, Bob knows, Bob's so truthful about what a loyal guy.
NixonNot for the whole time. You see, I called him in and Dean and Dean started out and spoke with confidence of the story, but the extraordinary thing was Dick Hartley had come in last night with that
Nixonthat I had kept insisting for a Dean Report, and Dick said, Dick told him that. He had had Dean call me Sunday night.
NixonAnd look, I'd like to see you, tomorrow or something like that, because Dick said,
Nixontold Dean had sort of confided in him, you know, "I don't think the President realizes how all things are involved in this case."
NixonWe've been talking about the whole question of getting a Segretti story out and getting a Pauling report out, a lot of other crap like that. So, he had, and he came in at his own invitation, initially at 10:00.
NixonAnd that's when he made his famous what he calls his "cancer on the heart of the presidency" speech, which was a very responsible thing to do.
NixonA very responsible thing. And in the course of that talk, as an illustration, he gave us the Fitzsimons thing. Now that's how that all came. In a fit of discussion,
NixonThat's manageable, provided Bob tells the story. But I think it's best that Bob tell the story, rather than have a paper.
NixonNow do you think Buzhardt could see that? Do you see what I mean? I know.
NixonThere is the thing I'm concerned about. I- I- I feel- I feel I have no objection if Bob and I can sit down and, uh, go over these notes, reconstruct the damn thing. We can reconstruct, it'll make the best damn reconstruction
HaigWell, we get them all here in a conference room and decide it's all the way through this, and I would also like to have a good talk to Bob, on this. That's right. And to talk to John.
NixonIf if if it ever a push ever came to shove on a fine point, yeah. um He's got to think that Counsel always Counsel Better to be mine. In other words, if, for example, on a fine point as to whether a document is or is not turned over,
Nixonand whether it's in my interest to turn it over, and damn the Ehrlichman, huh, or not, and let the turn over,
NixonOh, and the burglary, the flummery. The plumber thing is basically something that is They're not going to hesitate They're not They're gonna hesitate to indict anybody on that.
NixonThat's No, it's just embarrassing, girl. What is embar- What is embarrassing to him, in this case, he has two vulnerabilities.
NixonUh, one is that he was present at the time that the documents were handed over to Gray, from Hunt's safe, right?
NixonAnd, uh, Dean's story is that Ehrlichman said, uh, that they thought that they've Dean started out with that, Gray said, that Dean tries to claim that Ehrlichman said, "Get rid of them." Ehrlichman didn't Ehrlichman denies that.
NixonSo, that's, uh But anyway then, they gave them to Gray. Gray didn't get rid of them.
NixonIt was Gray's error, and Ehrlichman, he can survive that. ruined that.
NixonHe can forgive the Director of the FBI, but could not could not blame him. The other thing is
Nixonthat Ehrlichman, and Haldeman, as well, at the request of John Mitchell, which was relayed through Dean,
Nixonright after the burglars got in, uh, called Kalmbach in California,
Nixonuh, who does fund who was special kind of, uh, uh, uh, fund-raiser,
Nixonand authorized him to raise some money for the attorney's fees.
NixonNow, that also, in my opinion, was manageable at that stage,
Nixonand that was very early in June. That wasn't That would be before the the the whole question of it has to be acquired and all that, they're just raising money for fees.
HaigThat is early, it's totally divorced from what he's inquired as far as he's concerned. As far as I'm concerned.
NixonThat's right. That's about all of it, you see.
HaigYeah. He said it was for attorney's fees, though, right?
HaigYeah. Then, he also expressed awareness of the
NixonYou know, I- he like- he he never did in fact, but, after the fact, that's correct. He never gave me his report in writing.
NixonHe only had written notes. He gave it to me orally. These are handwritten It's just handwritten on yellow pieces of paper, about eight pages. And, he came he came in this was
Nixonthis was, uh, about three weeks after the 21st, you see. I mean,
NixonDean wouldn't wouldn't write a report, and I then and I was in California, I said, "John, you've gotta get into this goddamned thing and find and get to the bottom."
NixonAnd, he, on the 15th of April, John finished his report. And, that was the time that
NixonBut we helped break it, actually. We were trying, we were asking so many questions to get to that point, because he questioned Magruder, he questioned Mitchell,
NixonThat's in his report, too, if you know what it is. Because this is the nature of John.
HaigWell, the way he did it to Colson see that far. They just turned over a couple pages and said, "Well, this is damaging for the guys below John,
Nixontomorrow tomorrow, I'll talk to Buzhardt, tonight, about strategy for the Senate. Uh,
Nixonokay. And then, get touch, don't know who we can talk to about tomorrow, but we really have to get into this with Bob's lawyer, again, and Kreindler.
NixonWell, suppose finally, you know, they're splendid men, but John just felt he wasn't, frankly. In other words, he just felt that [unintelligible] I don't blame him.
NixonI could I could understand that, for his own view. But, damn it, kill the facts didn't make him It would've killed us to keep him, shouldn't we say?
NixonIt's just like Elliot Richardson, if he loses the
Nixonand when he become attorney general, yeah, he can't be secretary in a minute, he will have to go for confirmation.
NixonYou can trust him. The whole thing, then, I mean, but I don't want to ask. Can't be a client conversation talking about fairness. I don't want him to get into any,
NixonI respect, accept, admire, and everything, but let me say this, I do not believe, Fred Buzhardt,
Nixonthat I should have him, even him, go through Bob's notes.
HaigI'm not even sure that I'd want him to, Al. But, I don't want to. You know what I mean? Even if he did, I I, as I understand, there's not any sense of guilt.
NixonThere is that, but there's always the chance of misinterpretation.
NixonWhen you're not there and hear the inflections or the, or you don't know what has gone before, or what the hell the whole thing is up to, you know what I mean?
HaigI I can assure you that, uh, they've done that. That's true.
NixonHe can have conversations with your clients, like, uh, I didn't want you to know that, I just don't think it's a good idea.
NixonBut, I do know that, uh, Buzhardt wants to uh, I think that's that's that's what, uh, Talk to Bob. That's what, yeah. That's, yeah.
HaigYeah. Because they wanted to sympathize the whole fight. Trust me on that.
NixonYeah. Anything else should come up here, it's gotta be done.
HaigThey shouldn't come back and make a [unintelligible] talk like that.
NixonYou know, I am surprised Bob mentioned the conversation he had with John on the 26th of March, it's five days after, he was after trying to raise support for it.
NixonI don't think it's significant, and in no means less for them to appear to prosecute now. Uh,
Nixonas a matter of fact, they've figured out it's the squarest, quite obvious to people
Nixonit probably is better if they are both indicted, as you know, Bob, because if they aren't, you got,
NixonI don't mean as if they weren't, goddamn it, so that I'm not wishing that at all,
Nixonbut why is that? If they aren't indicted, everyone's going to say that the goddamn [unintelligible] is fixed, that's right. You have that problem. Now,
Nixonat this point, but at this point, let me say, without question, this we're talking about ourselves, and nobody else,
BuzhardtIt's, well Magruder, Magruder's thoughts about Dean are tied in again.
BuzhardtAnd therefore, and therefore, he that basically has some evidentiary problem. But it's just a question of whether anybody is believed Mitchell has an excuse. He is playing it tough. But his, his problem, as I can read the memoranda
Buzhardtwell, some of the people who repeated his help of disapproval, the people who John had helping him, and he was anxious that other and made notes of what other people told him. And some of those people in the meeting, it's not clear whose front was that, that he uh,
Buzhardtthat he said they don't, they're having a system about his prior approval. Maybe no prior approval. But the questions about those documents that Hunt was insisting were agreed, he discussed it repeatedly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I have I think he has after the fact,
Buzhardtuh, he was involved. Hell, well, they're involved in a uh, crime. You know, he's that the place is full of it.
NixonThat's it. Well, the question there, let me ask you this, uh, we have [unintelligible].
NixonUh, if the funds are raised for a purpose, as they were in the very early time, [unintelligible] this is like what Colson, earlier Colson approved copper group [unintelligible] something like they get yelled at for whatever. I don't approve [unintelligible] whatever.
NixonI had a rule, nobody ever discuss money near my campaign. That's the damn good place to spawn it. Anyway,
Nixonuh, that, that kind of activity is not, in and of itself, a crime. No crime until you get to the point that you are trying to keep them from talking, or to shut, or trying to keep them from talking. Talk.
BuzhardtAnd that would be obstruction. That would be obstruction and that would be very difficult to prove and if Haldeman didn't, or John Ehrlichman didn't,
BuzhardtOr even, or wiretap, or if Mitchell was there.
BuzhardtIt's gonna be difficult even if he did it. It's gonna be difficult to prove, the substance of that. You're going to have to prove that when he approved the money,
Buzhardtdid he, in fact, say that they get the men to be quiet, and, you know, that's that's going to be very difficult to prove, because most of the evidence is hearsay, some of it way down the line. And I doubt if it was ever really, clearly discussed with them, and the notes don't show if it indicates it was clearly discussed.
BuzhardtMight have been implied. In any case, though, it's going to be very difficult to prove.
NixonWell, what I would like to do Fred, if it's uh, agreeable with you is this: I've uh, We've got a lot of very good people around here, and let's put it that way. I want to be sure that you more and more begin to move into a, into a consulting
BuzhardtUh, the fact that he's a potential witness?
NixonYeah. He's had to excuse himself, certainly. Other things, he can do very well. The PR side, yes. PR side or
BuzhardtUh, he's, uh, he's a jealous teller, I'm, I'm sure of that. On the other hand, he'll be a witness. He would be he'd not be a party.
NixonThat's what the uh, that's what the, that's what Petersen told me the last time I talked with him. The point that I was going to make is this,
Nixonthat what we need, what I need is, honest to find girl who could go through, play by the rules for what was told. And how I knew this, what I need is one man who basically could be as the President's personal
Nixonand I will uh, I'll ask him to talk very frankly with you. Now, I want to talk a bit about the papers situation, which I think is very important. Uh, now, we will, or, and can they move in, but here's what happened. Haldeman does not have his papers on him.
NixonAnd, what he did have was an extract, apparently of some What really happened He may have a substance of that. He was telling what his lawyer said.
NixonA telephone conversation he had with Dean, from Camp David on March 26. He had that.
NixonYeah. that they no longer wanted one or the other, on their hands, and so they made the decision to get out of the car. I see the problem. You know, we were badly misled.
BuzhardtI know. I've been here 20 minutes before that. Here's the problem. Here's the problem.
NixonNow basically, uh you have your people look at them. They approached Wilson probably is [unintelligible] very good, wise, old boy.
BuzhardtWilson does not trust Len. Part of the reason for that is that
Buzhardthe knows that he's been to see John Dean. So, I don't know whether he trusts me or not, but, you know, we haven't had [laughter] yet.
NixonSo, you get, with the proper permission, if you We've had this discussion with him before.
NixonYeah. But, the Wilson's leak is Wilson's way. Remind Wilson that uh, but I think so for that reason, I think it's very important to have Len
Nixonin the General Counsel role. You know, lean right where he is, you know. He's uh, he does a variety of things. He can work with uh, Ervin committee and all that kind of thing. But I think what I, what I've got Fred for,
NixonI want you to basically, personally pop up that new role that we have to have.
NixonNow, on the papers. I have a very strong view about that,
Nixonnot because I am concerned about, I mean, at any time that everybody sees it in its entirety, fine, but because
Nixonif you start handing, handing to the Senate, Haldeman, Ehrlichman, or anybody, let alone give it just here. Now, I told
Nixonit will be that honest the White House, I, I don't care how carefully they go through. Now, as I understand it, Al, he's
Nixonsent everything back to this White House. Correct?
HaigYes, sir. He said, with one little, 4-page summary
BuzhardtI think it'd be better if he brakes the precedent. All of them. I think it would be better if he did send that back to you.
BuzhardtIt can be kept here. Pull out of here. If they need, they apparently just, they didn't get him with a grand jury today. That Thank God! Thank God. And, they won't get through him for months, you know. Right. They had John on for six, six through three or four [unintelligible].
BuzhardtLook, certainly, if Bob can have this stuff back in here, where it's in your custody, Right. then we have the problem of access, the question arises.
BuzhardtThen, your executive privilege means something because it's in your possession. Well, that's it.
NixonWell, let me say this, look here, Bob has a perfect right to come in any time, after all. He can come in and look at his papers whenever he wants to.
NixonAnd not, hell, no! Dean is taking most of his out.
BuzhardtApparently he's good. Whatever he's made of.
NixonNow, that's what we'll do today, and uh Bob understood that. That he was to get the summary back here, too. Oh yeah, yeah. [unintelligible] first thing tomorrow.
BuzhardtEven though that paper itself is notoriously dangerous, right now, it would be, and he knows that.
NixonYou see, that's what the good thing about having Breck Walker here. Right now.
BuzhardtAll right. But, what I wanted to [unintelligible] Mr. President, he said
NixonI don't mind giving him a call, see, [unintelligible] whatever you'd like. You know what I mean. You can. I don't want We're not trying to hide anything.
BuzhardtFine. I want him to know that. What I don't want in it is too damn formal. But what I do maintain in here On the On the terms of papers I think we simply have to say that
Nixonas far as personal [unintelligible] they are not, they are not washable papers. There's another reason for that, too, Fred. hell, I can't break uh, for example, the whole investigation of the Paxman, and that stuff. And you know how how
NixonWe cannot allow that to get out. We never roll a war. Now, it's safe right now. That's my point. It is in the safe.
BuzhardtSee, I And that we cannot break. No, we cannot break. So, on the papers thing, I want you to know. That's one blind work I don't care if the press can say that I'm hiding everything, but, goddamn it, I might well be able to run there all day. That work can accept that to the Tester.
NixonNow what? My problem is not the blank executive privilege the paper has being able to find it [laughter] That's it. It isn't a subpoena. Well, look, there is one thing I've worked on many legal investigations. [unintelligible] you have motion. One thing I've learned, if you don't have possession,
NixonYeah, from the papers itself. What legal right to [unintelligible] out there? [unintelligible] I think the discussion with Bob would be very useful before we come to a conclusion on the oral conversation or whether we can put it in written form. It maybe that we'll have to
BuzhardtWell, discuss that, in terms of uh, [sighs] uh of a discretionary rule for him, understanding the areas.
BuzhardtYeah. Of course, we won't uh I mean John I bet John had all this problem on oral conversation, so he didn't have as many [unintelligible]
NixonJohn? John took the position, strictly, for executive privilege, pretty much. If he was in doubt, did he?
BuzhardtThey passed it off the grand jury. They brought him back for that period. Uh,
Nixonwith the committee it'll be worse though. John who?
Buzhardtthat Bob took it further and it's not only the conversations with you, but those where he considered himself a confident. That's, no doubt, is your great problem [unintelligible] that brings us to the next point.
Buzhardtis how to deal with committee problem. That is the press job.
NixonWe We We talked about that, Fred, and I uh I certainly I I, I mean your idea to talk to Stennis appeals to me very much. Absolutely. What What the hell good would that do? Stennis is not on the committee.
BuzhardtSee, I talked to Senator Stennis last Thursday morning for an hour and a half. Great. He wanted to talk to me in, and he'd be very frank, about whether I would be willing to come help you. Great.
NixonThat's he, you know, had a more dedicated supporter than anyone. Good. There's no more dedicated, John Stennis, man. And uh he he was very much shocked about the whole problem [unintelligible] We've been on very close relationships and worked closely together. For the last four years,
NixonWork I always supposed is that Worked. I know Senator Stennis, but
Buzhardthe is prepared, I'm quite sure, to think, go to great lengths for any uh thought to be [unintelligible]. He would not like to go back on SWALLIS. He would not not like to go back on the budgetary files, or something of that type. But on major policy issues, he will become very active, even at this stage. Now, Senator Stennis' history has been
NixonSenate. Depending on which way you look at it. Some call him the conscience of the Senate; others call him the undertaker. Depending, of course, depending on which way you look at it. But he has handled
NixonYeah. In sense uh, it's the one voice that just For their own protection, they've never been able, been in a position to question him with the game to what with what widespread duty in the Senate.
BuzhardtNow, he, himself, has a party to questions of executive privilege more than anybody else [unintelligible] issue. Uh, he's a former judge.
BuzhardtHe's the one man that rivals Senator Ervin, or, or dozen certainly in respect to this courage from a judicial, oh, point of view or its dance. In substance dance, or has this the people that can talk to him,
Buzhardtthe telltale Senator Ervin and they're from very biased parties, or what hope is to hear. Well, that might be, I think, it'd be your best bet [crosstalk] for pulling off.
NixonWell, certainly, he gave his advice. That's, try it, uh, uh, Friday. Quickest as you can. Fair enough. Now, the point about this is this: the arguments we have started. Frankly, this whole judicial process, we aren't going forward with this investigation, we're covering up. I have martyred Attorney General, I have martyred the and I have chopped off the head of my two top advisors. What the hell more do they want?
BuzhardtWell, you know what they want. They want blood, do they want? Huh?
NixonThat's right. Like it. Is my argument, Senator Ervin wants that. The point is, the point is that I was an investigator at one time. I remember in Hiss case, we continued to investigate until the grand jury. That's it. until the grand jury got into it, then we quit. That did it? Yes.
BuzhardtBecause, we we wouldn't have thought again, you can't build that. We couldn't continue to have witnesses before committee, at a time they were to appear before a grand jury. Well that's what's involved here. In the Powell case, that committee was arguing with that committee, about three weeks ago, and by some huge demand that the court fight, one breath holding up all of that publicity
Nixonpublicity that he has prejudiced any possible fraud, the supporters, you know. I mean, Bob, He could get by with it.
BuzhardtAnd, they couldn't have spared that jeopardy for themselves. [crosstalk] This time, they've got to, they've got to in the interest of the Senate itself, not only the country. But, there were Even if they, they let me put it this way: we have make a run on this, even if it fails,
NixonBecause the committee'll have a goddamned show up there, at a time Mitchell, Haldeman, Ehrlichman, they're damn lines, if they're That's shame to go up, before a grand jury. It's just, it's just wrong! Isn't it? It's definitely It's bad wrong. Huh? It's bad wrong. That's right. They shouldn't do it.
BuzhardtI anticipate that some of the Republicans on the committee will be as big a problem as the Democrats. Where they want some excitement, or something of that sort. It's more to be seen, on that. Harry's on the television. He want they to show them, let's say to circus the paper for.
Unknownthat universally, plus money was a big business, Dean and these Republicans, right?
NixonThey the committee is supposed to be investigating campaign political practices. It's supposed to be just investigating
Nixondirty tricks and raid, all that crap. Go into that.
NixonBut it's the Watergate and the Watergate is being considered. See, these other matters are not being considered by a grand jury.
NixonAll right. I don't know what what the this is what kind of a deal can be made, but the
Unknowncounsel for the committee can- The thing may be that the best thing to do is for the senior staff to straight take it on-
NixonI don't know if that will work, but I'm convinced it's our best approach.
NixonI think it's better than having counsel for them sit around [laughter] Ha. They they won't get there. They won't get anywhere. The counsel will never be able to admit because the committee members are wired for the publicity that they're waiting for this show. They're already getting their makeup, the bath and eyes. It's the only thing that could put pressure on them right now, it appears,
NixonNow let's start with the senators and how do we do this? This is going to be- That then that basically hits on the presence of rights of all this deep-
UnknownI think we can get help on a slow leak and the other seven, though.
NixonWell, they, they are essential. Hell, I mean, even outside. Larry O'Brien.
UnknownRight. Well, we know his concerns and what else?
UnknownUm, I think if we're going to ask Dennis to do it,
Unknownwe've got to tell him and give him the assets and let him lay it out and play it out. Get his judgment on how to do that.
UnknownHe's going to have to do it and he can't do it on half measures. One, you give his best effort you can and what's his responsibility. Yeah. You get through with Sam Ervin and then see for you.
NixonIs there anybody that can get Her- Herschel assistant through to Florida? I mean, maybe the White House,
Nixonyou know, like Harlow's [unintelligible] you know, that that sort of thing. Could Harlow do that anyway with Florida?
UnknownBryce could always be helpful particularly with Gurney. Let me see.
UnknownBob is willing to pitch in. I've talked to him about that. And anyway,
NixonWell, tell him on Saturday, it'll give us good decision to figure that back.
NixonAnd then I mean, see what I can do with Harlow's, uh, We can put that off because all we can do Friday evening, we can get I think we got to get this We got to get the committee thing is more important, and you can see Elliot Richardson Right, it was not urgent. You can see Harlow on Friday or Saturday. How about that? Make sense, Bryce? Yeah. We'll start on the Senate, tomorrow.
UnknownYeah. We'll start on the Senate tomorrow.
NixonAnd I think it's very important that you reassure Bob that,
Nixonfrom now on, Fred is what the man, you tell him that. You tell him that, I don't want I want him to know that that that that that that. I don't want to go too far tomorrow, so he can know for this. I want him to confide in totally. It's really the problem [unintelligible].
UnknownFred, you should know, I think Elliot has some problems,
Unknownnot with my doing this job.
UnknownHe feels he has to stay on top, then.
UnknownI thought I fought that brief in the water, too. Uh, he feels he has some problem. He has to stay in [unintelligible] for the White House to maintain his position.
UnknownUh, I see. We have been very close, though. It feels some
Unknownproblem with the two of us coming from there. So, Fred, is he here anyway?
UnknownHe'll help, though. What can we do about a visit? I talk very casually with young Richardson,
Nixonand uh, I said I told him we're going to have this, that and the other thing, and uh,
UnknownBecause we need that man. We need this man. We need this associate, meaning the indispensable man here,
Unknownand uh, it's an opportunity for him to, uh, do what the hell he was wouldn't know how they'd want him in that job. He has to have long hours.
UnknownAnd now he's got somebody, you know, been there 90 days, you know, it's not work with him sort of tough, a little bit big for their pants, right?
NixonI think you've got this whole thing under control. All the way up.
NixonI ate, uh, 38 to 800-pound bag of plums. I'd to go over,
Nixontake a shower, get cleaned up, and make a few, touches, makes you safe for Republicans.
UnknownWell, let me just say this. If all the's, uh,
Unknowngoing to hell sometimes, I've had a day like this, uh, we talk totally out of the hold,
Unknownand things are starting to take some shape. It's goddamned chicken crap, mess, though.
UnknownAnd it's we're taking a lot of heat, and we're going to take a lot more. But the main thing you've got to do is realize that we're right.
UnknownAnd we've got a-
NixonWe've got People suggest and tell me thing, and I had, uh- I was going to wire, I'm saying, old John Connally. Connally said, and said, "Well, you tell Haldeman and Ehrlichman to resign because they wouldn't"- they said, they couldn't do their job effectively anymore, even though they weren't guilty. "Maybe I should resign."
NixonHe said, "No." [Laughter] "You don't have that posture."
UnknownUh, if the two of those things and work each of them and want to be very tough. We're bullwhipping it. I don't have to.
UnknownFrosting. Yeah.
NixonYeah, like that. Well, they've tried to impeach me before, you know. I don't think they'd think about it. And what does it take for impeachment?
UnknownIt takes a majority vote of the House. That's all it takes.
NixonWhy do you think you can win, why? Why do you, what if the House, what if they make coughs what you want to vote?
UnknownYeah, you know, do they make coughs?
UnknownSure, uh, if they raise too much ruckus, then it's an offense that will really put them down,
Unknownthen you can get a role conflict, and it's so hard to get a role conflict. I hope they come sometime.
NixonIt may, but let me say this, that would have in my opinion
Nixonquite traumatic for the I don't know the country could withstand quite frankly, yes, a tragic setback to what we're going to try to achieve in the United States and foreign policy, for what?
UnknownI'm gonna leave you. Well, I went through the '64 campaign. You get war hysteria and bloody as an offense.
NixonWere you there? Jesus, that house had- they fought the hell out of each other.
UnknownOne of my well, I worked with some of the down. One of my classmates that speech. That's right. One of my and uh,
Unknownyes, one of my classmates, the race for a black football player who become, you know, fresh,
Unknownand uh, they would take some to compromise on that. He was calm,
434-005 6:17 PM · 37 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 6:17 pm and 6:35 pm.
434-006 6:17 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Alexander M. Haig, Jr. met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 6:17 pm and 6:35 pm.
434-007 6:17 PM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 6:17 pm and 6:35 pm.
434-008 6:17 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 6:17 pm and 6:35 pm.
434-038 6:17 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 6:17 pm and 6:35 pm.
045-177 6:35 PM · 13 sec — Alexander M. Haig, Jr. and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 6:35 pm and 7:55 pm.
045-178 6:35 PM · 6 min — Alexander M. Haig, Jr. and H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 6:35 pm and 7:55 pm.
045-179 6:55 PM · 1 min — Alexander M. Haig, Jr., White House operator, and J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr. talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 6:55 pm and 7:55 pm.
Conversation 434-009, May 9, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/434-009 (accessed November 20, 2026).