Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 668 › Conversation 668-012

Nixon, Haldeman & Ziegler on Vietnam War and Presidential rhetoric

Wednesday, February 9, 1972 · 8:45 AM–10:40 AM ET · Oval Office · 1 hr 43 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob"); [Unknown person(s)]; Ziegler, Ronald L.; Woods, Rose Mary; Sanchez, Manolo; White House operator; Bull, Stephen B.; Butterfield, Alexander P.Conversation668-012 on Tape 668 (tape position 00:48:58–02:35:06)StartWednesday, February 9, 1972 at 8:45 AMEndWednesday, February 9, 1972 at 10:40 AMRecording deviceOval OfficeSourceNixon Library record for 668-012 ↗

President Nixon and H.R. Haldeman met to finalize the President's upcoming radio speech concerning his foreign policy report. They discussed the political strategy of criticizing presidential candidates who were undermining Vietnam peace negotiations, framing these candidates as irresponsible for potentially prolonging the war for electoral gain. Additionally, the President reviewed his public relations approach, deciding to minimize direct press interactions to avoid further controversy while emphasizing his role as the sole negotiator for an honorable peace.

Download MP3 · 141.7 MB

This clip was extracted from the full tape recording by Easy Nixon.

Listen to the full tape segment

Position in tape: 00:48:58 – 02:35:06

part A, 48:56

668a.mp3
668b.mp3
668b_i.mp3

On February 9, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, unknown person(s), Ronald L. Ziegler, Rose Mary Woods, Manolo Sanchez, White House operator, Stephen B. Bull, and Alexander P. Butterfield met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 8:45 am and 10:40 am. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 668-012 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 668-12

Date: February 9, 1972
Time: Unknown between 8:45 am and 10:40 am
Location: Oval Office

The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.

     Foreign policy meeting
          -Analysis
          -Vietnam
          -News summary
               -Importance
          -Reaction
               -Hugh Scott
          -Dock strike
          -Editorials and columns
          -Reaction
               -William P. Rogers and John B. Connally
               -Ronald L. Ziegler
          -Rogers and Connally
               -Talk with Haldeman
                      -Countries
                           -Proposal for Rogers
                                 -Country visits
                           -People’s Republic of China [PRC]
          -Europe
               -Henry A. Kissinger
                      -Wilderberg [sp?] conference
                      -Canada
                           -Kissinger’s attendance
                                 -Number of years
                      -Southern New England
                      -Vienna
                      -Munich

     Invitations
           -Japan
                 -Kissinger
                 -Timing after upcoming trip to PRC
                 -University

                -Possible plans
     -Rogers
          -Latin American countries
Show the rest of the log (662 more lines)
     -Japan
          -Vice President Spiro T. Agnew
                -Proposed announcement
          -Haldeman’s instructions to Rogers

PRC Trip
    -Briefings
          -Types

Rogers’s schedule
    -Kissinger
    -South America
    -North Atlantic Treaty Organization [NATO] meeting
    -Central Treaty Organization [CENTO] meeting
    -Southeast Asia Treaty Organization [SEATO] meeting
    -Romanians
    -Yugoslavs
    -Latin America
           -Rogers’s duties

Japan
     -Kissinger
          -Invitation
     -Rogers
          -Possible significance of Kissinger trip

Rogers
    -Reaction to handling of Haldeman’s Today show interview

Nicholas and Alexandra premiere
     -Location
     -Haldeman’s attendance
          -Rasputin
          -The President’s attendance
                -Florida
          -Audience support for Haldeman
                -Betty Beale

An unknown person entered at an unknown time after 8:45 am.

     Stephen B. Bull’s return
          -President’s questions

The unknown person left at an unknown time before 9:19 am.

     Nicholas and Alexandra preview
          -Support for Haldeman
               -Beale
               -Helena M. (“Obie”) Shultz

     Democrats

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 49s ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2

******************************************************************************

     Vietnam negotiations
          -Ngo Dinh Diem
               -Death criticized by the President
          -The President’s posture as candidate

     News stories
         -Connally
         -Rogers
               -Talk with Haldeman
         -Washington Post editorial
               -State of the Union Message
         -Administration response
               -Rogers
               -Ziegler

          -Haldeman
          -Agnew
               -Crosby S. Noyes
          -Ziegler
          -Kissinger
               -Vietnam

February 7, 1972 speech [Remarks to White House Conference on Industrial World Ahead]
     -Raymond K. Price, Jr.
     -William L. Safire
     -PRC
           -President’s “ad lib” near end of speech
     -Maurice H. Stans
           -Previous conversation with Haldeman
           -PRC
                 -Foreign policy

Speech
     -Connally
         -Stans
               -Timing

Draft of Foreign Policy Report radio speech, February 9, 1972
      -The President’s efforts to end the war
      -Honorable peace
      -Withdrawal of troops
            -Number
      -Casualties
      -Air power
      -Budget costs
      -Draft
      -Peace offer
      -Criticism
      -1968
            -Negotiations
                  -The President’s comments as candidates
      -Criticism
            -Candidates’ responsibility
                  -Avoiding prolonging war
      -Peace
      -Trust in US

     -John A. Scali
     -Press
           -Selling out
                 -A question of sincerity
     -The President’s policy
           -Critics
     -Presidential candidates
           -Criticism
                 -Prolonging the war
                 -Responsibility
                      -Comparisons
     -Kissinger
     -“Postpone the Peace”
           -Line from the President
                 -Optimism
           -Candidates’ statements
     -Wording
           -Cautiousness
           -Surrender compared with victory
                 -Nicholas and Alexandra
                      -Comparisons to the present time
                            -Alexander Kerensky and Tsar Nicholas II
     -Criticism
           -Presidential candidates
     -Honorable peace
     -Communists
           -Cold War
           -South Vietnam
                 -Haldeman’s opinion
     -Scali’s statements
           -Prisoners of war [POWs] compared to Gen. Nguyen Van Thieu
                 -Ziegler
                 -American support
                      -Surrender option
                            -“Peace with honor”

Press conference
      -Possible appearance on television by the President

Vietnam
     -Rogers

           -The President’s forthcoming radio speech
                -Candidates’ criticism
                      -Possible enemy incentive
                      -Prolong the war
                            -Election
                      -Presidential statements
                      -Haldeman statements
                      -Agnew statements
                      -Editorials
                            -A question of patriotism
                                  -[Arnold] Eric Sevareid
                                  -Haldeman’s comments
                                        -Claim
                      -Ziegler

An unknown person entered and left at an unknown time before 9:19 am.

     Request for Ziegler

     The President’s forthcoming radio speech
          -Scali
                -Concern
          -State of the World report
          -Press conference
                -PRC
                      -Plan by the Administration

Ziegler entered at 9:19 am.

     Ziegler’s schedule
          -Call from the President, February 8, 1972
          -Parent-Teacher Association [PTA] meeting
          -Compared to Kissinger’s trips to Paris

**************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 14
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 36s ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 14

**************************************************************************

    Vietnam statements
         -Involvement
               -Scali
               -Kissinger
               -President’s responsibility
         -Democrats
               -Criticism and accusations
               -James B. (“Scotty”) Reston
                     -Haldeman
               -Walter L. Cronkite, Jr.
               -Sevareid
               -Washington Post
                     -Editorial
                           -Timing
                     -Agnew
                     -Rogers
                     -The President
                     -Haldeman
         -Statement about PRC
         -Democrats
               -Noyes
               -Negotiations
                     -Criticism
                           -Assessing blame
         -Scali
               -Possible press briefing by Ziegler

    The President’s forthcoming radio speech
         -Reading of draft
              -Ziegler’s opinion
         -Copies of to press
              -Distribution
                     -Herbert E. Kaplow
                     -11:00 pm news
              -Candidates

                      -Criticism
          -Haldeman statements
                -New York Times
                -Ziegler
                -Washington Post
                      -Ziegler’s complaint
          -Candidates
                -Prolong the war
                -Leaders meeting
                      -Timing
                -Negotiations
                -Ziegler’s view
                      -Responsibilities
                -Statements
                -Wording of speech
                      -Ziegler’s opinion
                            -Assistance to the President
                      -George S. McGovern
                -Surrender
                      -Context
                      -Muskie
                      -McGovern
          -Kissinger
                -Briefing
                -Statements
          -Safire
          -Kissinger
          -PRC
                -Name
                      -Taiwan, Republic of China
                      -Corrections of text
          -Vietnam War
          -Radio
          -Wording
                -Candidates’ criticism
                      -Compared to Lyndon B. Johnson
                -Prolonging the war

Rose Mary Woods entered at 9:38 am.

          -Typing

               -Instructions
          -Ziegler’s opinion

Woods left at 9:43 am.

          -Draft
               -POWs
                     -Wording
                     -Possible consequences
                     -President’s view
          -Teleprompter
               -Camera
                     -President’s instructions
                     -Distribution
               -Newsmen
                     -Number
               -Location
               -Executive Office Building [EOB]
          -Broadcast
               -Amount of time
          -Preparation by the President
               -Schedule
          -Press
               -Ziegler
               -Haldeman
               -News
                     -Editorials

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 5
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 45s ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 5

******************************************************************************

          -Haldeman
               -Call to Charles G. (“Bebe”) Rebozo
                     -George C. Wallace
                          -Cousin
                                -Rebozo contact
                                -Edmund S. Muskie
                                -Hubert H. Humphrey
                          -Lyndon B. Johnson
                                -1968
                          -Muskie
                          -Florida primary
                          -Agnew

Haldeman’s Today show interview
     -Press conference
          -Peter Lisagor
          -Dan Rather
          -Briefing
     -PRC
          -Story
     -Ziegler
     -Press
     -Barbara Walters’s point
          -National Broadcasting Company [NBC]
                -Transcript availability
                      -Newspapers
                      -Television news services
                      -Timing
     -Press
          -Patriotic forces in US
                -Underestimation
          -Washington, DC
     -Reaction
          -Nicholas and Alexandra
                -Beale
                -Anna C. Chennault
                      -PRC ambassador

Vietnam
     -Noyes
         -Story

                      -Surrender
          -1970 campaign
                -Issue
                      -Peace initiative
          -Public opinion
                -US involvement
                      -Possible movement to undermine the President’s efforts
          -Critics
                -Haldeman’s statements
                      -Possible administration response
                -Reston
                      -Kissinger
                           -John W. Gardner
                                  -Visit to Reston’s home
                      -Tone of columns
                      -Kissinger
                           -Popularity with the media
          -Haldeman’s comments
                -Durability as story
                      -PRC trip
                      -Democrats
                -Future comments

     The President’s forthcoming radio speech
          -Kissinger
               -Vietnam section
               -Note from Ziegler
          -Woods
               -Typing
          -Teleprompter

[The President talked with Woods at an unknown time between 9:43 and 10:09 am.]

[Conversation No. 668-12A]

          -Typing

[End of telephone conversation]

     Jaycees
          -US Jaycees Governmental Affairs Leadership Seminar

     -Convention
         -Atlanta
               -Timing

The President’s schedule
     -Haldeman’s upcoming conversation with Connally
          -Abilene, Texas
          -Unknown Houston publisher
          -San Antonio
                 -Texas newspapers
          -Abilene Christian Conference
     -Rotary
          -Timing
     -Jaycees
          -Timing
     -Campus Crusade
          -Timing
     -Houston
          -Governors’ conference
                 -Timing
                      -President’s attitude

Kissinger’s location
     -Ziegler’s office
           -Briefing
                 -Foreign policy report

The President’s forthcoming radio speech
     -Broadcast
          -Instructions for Ziegler, Haldeman
          -Coverage

1972 Environmental Program
     -News coverage
     -Tape
     -Camera
          -Number
     -Mark I. Goode
     -Teleprompter
     -Executive Order

Woods entered at 10:09 am.

     The President’s forthcoming radio speech
          -Copy
               -Typing

     [No conversation]

                     -Corrections
          -Subtleties
          -Gerald L. Warren
               -Pick-up
               -Press
               -Typing
                      -Corrections

Woods and Ziegler left at an unknown time before 10:15 am.

     The President’s schedule
          -Camp David
               -Timing

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 7
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 26s ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 7

******************************************************************************

Woods entered at an unknown time after 10:09 am.

     Buzzer
         -Manolo Sanchez

     Camp David

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 8
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 1m 15s ]

Woods left at an unknown time before 10:15 am.

An unknown Navy steward and Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 10:09 am.

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 8

******************************************************************************

The steward and Sanchez left at 10:15 am.

[The President talked with the White House operator at 10:15 am.]

[Conversation No. 668-12C]

[See Conversation No. 20-81]

[End of telephone conversation]

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 9
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 2m 4s ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 9

******************************************************************************

     The President’s schedule
          -Frank E. Fitzsimmons
                -Teamsters Union
          -Letters
                -Purpose
          -Notes and phone calls
                -Effect and advantages
                      -Frequency of telephone calls
                      -Notes
                           -Publication
                           -New York police

[The White House operator talked with the President at an unknown time between 10:15 am and
10:33 am.]

[Conversation No. 668-12D]

[See Conversation No. 20-82]

[End of telephone conversation]

          -Notes
               -Widows, parents
               -Brevity
               -Writers
               -One-liners
               -Type

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 10
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 3m 2s ]

Stephen B. Bull entered at an unknown time after 10:15 am.

Bull left at an unknown time before 10:33 am.

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 10

******************************************************************************

     Forthcoming press conference
          -Briefing books
          -PRC
          -Timing
          -Phraseology
                -Substance

     Llewellyn E. (“Tommy”) Thompson, Jr.
         -Funeral
               -Timing
               -Attendance
                     -Wreath

     Kissinger
          -Safire
          -Marilyn B. (“Missy”) Chandler
                -Support

     Otis Chandler
          -Robert H. Finch
          -Economy in California
               -Unemployment
               -Los Angeles Times
               -Administration efforts

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 11
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 4m ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 11

******************************************************************************

     Busing
          -Dallas

Alexander P. Butterfield entered at an unknown time after 10:15 am.

     Thompson funeral
         -Signature for letters for Jane (Monroe Goelet) Thompson
              -Rogers
                    -Attendance

Butterfield left at an unknown time before 10:33 am.

     [No conversation]

     The President’s forthcoming radio speech
          -Teleprompter
               -Rogers
          -Microphone
               -Desk
          -Cameras
               -Goode

               -Ziegler
                    -Press office
                         -Teleprompter
               -Messages
                    -Dock strike

Woods entered at 10:33 am.

     The President’s schedule

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 12
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 1m 45s ]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 12

******************************************************************************

          -Helicopter
               -Timing
          -Speech
               -Typing

******************************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 13
[Personal Returnable]
[Duration: 3m 45s ]

Woods left at 10:35 am.

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 13

******************************************************************************

     Attitude of White House staff
           -National attitude

     Speech
          -Teleprompter

Haldeman left at 10:40 am.

This transcript was generated automatically by AI (WhisperX) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Names and numbers are often wrong; speakers are not identified. Do not cite it as authoritative — verify against the audio and the finding aid.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).

Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.

Why don't we get up there, you know, to acknowledge this.
Before I do this for them all, sorry.
How they, how they, how they, how they're voicing this morning.
The story is playing.
I don't understand.
Yeah, the reaction.
Well, there, yeah, the reaction, so it's faded back to a less important story to Scott.
Less important for a lot of reasons.
We have the brave doctor coming out, which was the lead story.
But it's, uh,
It's moving to the editorials and the columns, which is what you'd expect to happen.
And what reaction have you had?
I was wondering.
It might be useful, if you have not done so, to get a broader judgment.
And maybe college, doesn't it?
That's true.
Maybe it would be useful to see what I had as the push that Sidney is getting from, or has gotten from.
All right.
For that day.
I think what I'm trying to do is to see what, I mean, see what my, I mean, tomorrow's,
Have you talked to Bill or anybody of that type?
Talk to Bill?
I haven't talked to Sonny about this.
Why are you talking to Bill?
Oh, well, I wasn't in my mind.
On the country thing, if he could give me an idea, I think it would be a good thing for him to visit some countries afterwards to inform them of China.
Give me a job.
Give me a list of things.
I know what the Henry thing in Europe is.
It's the builder of the conference.
For God's sake.
He always goes to it.
He's been going to it.
He went up to it in Canada.
Yeah, he's been going to it for 20 years.
No, it's up in New England here.
Yeah, it's going to be in Vienna or some damn place.
It's going to be all the way up.
Yeah.
All the way up to the Americans.
That's right.
It's going to be in the United States.
He's going up to Europe.
And he's been invited to the Gap and has been.
Yeah.
And so I'd like to go to Europe, is what he said.
And make this a day over.
Do you ever think about it?
to the Build-A-Bird Conference.
But that's the only thing that's on his schedule.
In fact, it's invitations because he's not going to be letting me play.
He's accepted none.
And that was the first of the ensemble.
He's been invited to Japan.
He's not decided anything about that yet.
He's going to wait a little after he gets back.
He's been invited to go there to do something at a university.
in Japan, but we decided not to do that yet.
But I think it'd be, as I said before, I think it'd be very useful for Bill to do Latin American countries or anything else he wants.
You see the thing that they assume the vice president, someone announced the vice president is going to Japan.
I don't think we've got that scheduled either, is there?
Correct.
Why is he going?
I don't know, but I think he'd be good for a pretty good ride over there.
Like if he got ridden on a ride, is that what you mean?
Yeah.
A huge old bill.
That's got to be checked out.
He's got to check her name with it.
The old bill, I think it's...
I have no concern at all.
That will avoid my having to breed people and so forth.
We've got to think very, very carefully about what kind of breeding to do, of having that before, you know, everybody wants about the giant shrimp and he's got some ideas on the mind.
Now he just wants to cut Henry out, I don't know what he thinks he ought to do.
He had several ideas.
His thoughts were in South America, to the NATO meeting, which he has to go to, and then he's got sent to a CTO meeting, so he picked those up.
Then he was thinking about the Romanians and Yugoslavs, of course, and then wondering whether he should do that in America.
Well, fine, fine.
I think all of those are very lifelike, very good.
I think they're fine.
He should have been, he should have been carted off.
He should have been taken to the hospital and so forth.
Yeah, well, it's not like he should be dealing with any remains of any kind, that if he was locked up, he'd see no problem at all.
I mean, uh, Darryl, he's a secretary of state, goddammit.
He's, uh, he's gonna do things, you know, let Henry squeal.
Henry is, let me tell you, Henry and Terrence will probably go to Japan.
They very much want him to come.
They haven't asked for Rogers because they want him as a space thing.
They don't want me because they don't want the riots.
They want Henry as a space thing because it'll mean something for him to come here and help out China.
Don't tell Bill then.
You've been invited.
And he's going to Bill DeVere.
That'll really deflate the whole thing a little, I'm assuming.
Yes.
Did Bill have any reactions to what we had talked about with the thing?
He seems to think, at least the impression I get, it's a little hard for me to get a reaction because they don't want to say anything.
I think maybe we've got to get someone else to ask because...
It was funny, last night I went to this premiere of Nicholas Southend, and I was, you know, the invitation.
Thanks to a lot of people.
It was my first time.
It was here in Washington.
It's a movie.
It's a movie.
A new epic movie on the... Well, I saw it.
You mean with Raskin?
Yeah.
We saw it on the floor.
Did you?
Well, I had the Washington premiere of it last night.
Everybody was there.
And it was amazing the sense of experience that we had.
As it is, a number of people during their mission that made a point of coming all the way across the theater or something to come up to me and say, thank God you said something.
And I'm sure Pete said, don't let them back you off of it.
But people like Betty Neal who was sitting behind me.
Oh, uh...
When she gets back, I want to ask her about something I talked about earlier tonight.
She poked me in the back, and she said, I have you in my bedroom every morning now, and all I can say is it's just a damn good thing somebody's saying sometimes.
And a lot of our OB shows, practically tears in her eyes.
She came running up through the crowd, and she said,
I saw that Monday morning.
It made me feel good again.
Do you like a little remote voice?
Yeah, certainly.
I have a positive.
The negatives are the, which we have to recognize, is the Democrats' wheel, the American crimes, the press rules.
Not one word was uttered.
I was pretty godlike responsible.
In fact, a lot of our people thought you were responsible.
I remember a great frustration.
Well, it probably is.
Wouldn't call him in.
I think.
That's pretty good.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You ask him.
Yeah.
I think maybe Rogers would, too.
I haven't talked to him this morning.
Let me see what he thinks after last night and today's news and so on.
They've shifted the ground now.
They've started into a pattern that the Washington Post editorial
Well, but it sort of tells you what their approach is, which is that this is a planned move, that you were part of it, that you came out on the high road in your state of the union, let us all go together.
And Rogers.
Rogers hit, and Ziegler hit, and I hit, and... Agnew.
Agnew hit.
Yeah, they keep bringing his...
He was the first one.
What the hell did he say?
He said something about the... Just what he should have said.
I forget.
He had one of them standard lines that we gave him.
Right.
Exactly right.
So what did they say?
They're looking for a sellout or something.
They are.
I probably know he said the best piece.
He hit it really hard, too.
True.
Sure.
And so they're saying that he, the secretary, and Sigler, and me, that this is an orchestrated thing to get them on board.
Well, let me read something to you.
Let me say something.
I think I'm going to do this.
I'm not going to let anybody see it.
They have something to do with it.
And for me, it's satisfying.
Hell, I'm sure that, I'm sure as far as the rate of crisis is concerned, in Sapphire, we'll probably have gotten through at least with the
I think it's bad, but I'm not concerned about that.
Some very disliked it, but most UIB people I'm sure liked it.
They did, I think, particularly they liked it, I must say, though, but they really started to listen with some ad-libs, and then some China thing.
I saw Sands last night, he was, well, I crashed Sands, but he was very enthusiastic about the rest of it.
He said you made some good points in the speech, and it was very good to go into the China foreign policy business.
Cockney read his speech yesterday at lunch.
And Stan said, this is the first time I've seen him read a speech.
And it was kind of interesting.
Let me turn it on again now.
This has been our longest and most difficult war.
It began long before I became president.
And I have been doing everything I can to end it honorably.
Almost one-half-million men hanged and killed in battle.
Catch the panel.
We're answering for the week for being killed in action by intercoms.
This week there were two.
We've reduced air surfeits, budget cuts, draft calls.
We have made the most generous peace offer in the history of warfare.
I have no complaint over the fact that during this period when I have been ending the war, I did not begin.
I have been subjected to unprecedented criticism.
I do not question the patriotism and the sincerity of those who disagree with my policy to bring peace.
As I said in 1968 when I was a candidate for president, we have only one president at a time.
Only the president can negotiate an end to the war.
Let there be free debate and vigorous criticism so that our policy will represent the best thinking of our nation.
But a candidate for president has a higher responsibility than the ordinary critical.
A candidate should make any criticism he believes would contribute to bringing on for peace
But I would hope that each presidential candidate would examine his statements carefully to be sure that nothing he says might give the enemy an incentive to wallow in war and flash the election.
Let us seek peace with all our might, but let us be united in our determination to seek peace without surrender.
Trust in the United States among the 45 nations which, via treaty commitments, is essential to peace and freedom that can be preserved in the world.
We are ending the war in Vietnam in a way which will not destroy that trust.
That's what Scali wanted to do in his statement thing yesterday, but does it without backing down from it.
Actually,
Now, what would happen out of that is, if they pick it up, which it would, maybe Nixon joins the orchestrated attack or something.
Because it attacks presidential candidates for selling out to the enemy or something.
I do not question patriotism or sincerity, but I disagree with my policies.
I get my point across there, but very few reviews.
You know what I mean?
I did this, or you know, I just flipped in and out.
And I just thought there'd be three or four major criticisms of our policy.
But a candidate for president has a higher responsibility than an ordinary critic.
A candidate should make any criticism he believes would contribute to breaking off the peace.
But I would hope that each presidential candidate would examine his statement carefully to be sure that nothing he says might give the enemy an incentive to prolong the war and revive the election.
But it's the monkey on their back.
You see, that's the point of that.
I think, I think that's the, the thing that I think is, uh, it's got to be, it's got to be left, left there at that, at that division.
And you've got to realize that
Uh, we are building a case here for something very important.
We're building a case, putting the blame on them if they don't have it.
Dan Ryan?
I don't want to, I don't want to shop this around because I don't want Dan, Dan Ryan.
You know, you have, in something you were giving us earlier, you had a great line that we've used, but it hasn't gotten any play picked up, as the other way of saying, quote, prolong the war, which you say there, which was postpone the peace, which is, in a way, a more hopeful.
If money fit right here, right now, that would prolong the war, would I say, candidate
It's not doing anything to prolong the war till after the election.
Postpone the beat.
I don't know that I could...
I know.
Be sure that nothing he says might give the enemy an incentive.
Maybe it's better to prolong the war there.
The other thing is whether we want to put the thing in terms of surrender or in terms of turning over Vietnam to the communists.
I have a feeling we have a stronger thing on the communists than we do on surrender.
I don't know why, in fact.
We're almost getting to the point where surrender is honorable, where they want surrender.
Or let's put it the other way, where surrender is a code word to victory.
God, you sit and watch that Nicholas and Alexandra in the currency of today's times, you know, and they kept saying, we'll go, Kerensky and Mazar both saying, we'll go for victory.
And people kind of, you know, in our time, victory is a dishonorable thing, you know.
This has a long, very, very stagnant share.
And I'm sure that I put in there that, you know, I have no complaint about the fact that this is a very, this is a top-down line that needs to finally be set.
And by me, it's about the fact that I have no complaint about the fact that during this period, when I have been ending the war, I did not begin.
I have been subjected to unprecedented criticism.
Correct?
Because we have been handed the query department, and all the partners who already made it have been handed it, correct?
And you say, I don't question the patriotism and sincerity of those who disagree with my policy.
That way I have, for the press, I don't try to cover that.
They say, what about the sincerity?
See, that's the only thing.
It's just that I'm not correct on that.
I've covered that.
What question?
Patriotism and sincerity.
I'm sorry to say to bring an honorable piece, though.
Oh, yeah.
The difficulty is, if you start turning over the comment, it has the, it has the cohort, you know, I'm sorry.
Yeah, then if you are, I mean, if you've got it, or you can say it without surrendering to the comments, you can come up with that one.
See if I can find it.
It's, it's, maybe it's without abandoning.
It's not abandoning.
Then you get an emeritus.
I think you're better off just the way you are.
See, that's the thing that bothered me about Scali's statement.
It got back to putting it on the, in the framework of the argument of the POWs versus the president too, and that's the last argument.
I agree with, and Ron's absolutely right, that that's the wicket on which we want to be finished or we don't end up.
Because there, you don't have much support from the American people.
I don't think it's against prisoners of war.
On the other hand, it's hard for even the mother of a prisoner of war to get the United States to surrender.
That's right.
It's different.
You're not going for victory.
You're going for peace with honor and without surrender.
It has to be said, I think, by you, that nobody can argue or quarrel with that.
I'm going to say this in
controlled situation of speech today, I didn't use it as a base, but to have to use it as an answer.
If I say this in answer to a question, then they will continue to grow and grow, and I know a little bit of a thing.
If I say it, however, today, it's just part of the speech.
You see, I've covered that.
I've covered it.
I've covered that yesterday in my mind.
Covered it thoroughly.
Yeah, but you're in an office press conference, so you don't have to worry about it.
I have another thing to say about that.
I have another thing.
The president don't know how to discover that, and I'm not going to answer anymore.
You couldn't do that on television.
That's my point.
You'd have to answer again.
But in the office, you don't, because they'd have to be present to be with what you've covered.
Sure, they could pick up.
I mean, I agree they can pick up the one thing.
and say that I have joined them back to virtue.
But I have not the virtue.
God damn, I'm the president.
And just a promise is that we've got to urge that they say nothing that might give the enemy incentive to prolong the war and go back to the election.
Now, that's blatant and not there for everybody in the city, isn't it?
Yeah.
Huh?
Yeah.
And I put it in a way, I would hope that each presidential candidate would examine his state of concern.
Does that track you into endorsing all of that?
I don't know.
I mean, de facto, because I don't know.
I don't think you'll ever see it.
No, they'll say that.
I tend to realize that they'll interpret this as saying this slaps Haldeman and Hagen on that because he says he doesn't question patriotism or sincerity.
Of course, I don't see that.
I know you didn't.
I know you didn't.
But you see, what the editorials write is they say it's patriotism.
So I don't know that.
So what they should do now, which is much more clever,
And I gave them, it was my fault, I gave them an opportunity to say, now they're all playing, that I would accuse them of treason.
That's the reason the Patriots were so concerned.
Yeah.
You're repudiating me on that, which is good.
That's the thing.
I want to keep them on this issue.
But keep them on the... You're saying they are aiding the enemy.
Absolutely.
That's right.
But you're saying it's not a treasonable...
They're not doing it with treasonable intent.
And I just don't think you want to get locked into a thing where you're accusing them of treason the way I am now.
It's illegal, that's what it is.
And that's the opposite of that.
Except for this, that you can't leave it out unless you do it.
That one line you have there, let them, of course you don't.
You say let them be sure, they're not.
I don't mean by that, I mean the presidential candidate who's amnesty.
That's correct.
Are you sure?
I mean, he says he might hit the enemy.
Yeah.
And I'm saying, we're all in the war.
Yeah, that's completely different.
I see that.
It's a very different way of saying it.
Yeah.
Should we try it on Ziegler?
Yeah.
I think he's the best one.
And he'll keep his mouth shut.
And he'll be much more negative.
He'll be very sensitive.
He'll be as negative as anybody else on this.
And I wrote this, but I think it's, I think, you know, I think this is a good possibility to just copy that figure.
I believe that I'm going to have to say it tomorrow if I don't say it today.
You know what I mean?
I'm going to have to get at the point.
I think having a lot of scouts concerned.
Well, he didn't want me to say anything, which I think is a good point, too.
But I don't like this business to say that I won't speak out on what you say, and that I'm pitching it to others to take the low road and all that bullshit.
This is the goddamn truth.
Well, in a way, isn't it better for it to rhyme in the context of the state of the world?
We have a court and all that stuff.
then if you do it tomorrow, it becomes an overriding lead of your press conferences and tomorrow should be China.
That wraps up the case for having the, well, and also totally lays the groundwork for the case that they, that is their fault.
We're late.
Can you go back?
Anybody?
Can you go back then?
On the basis of that.
Did he get off?
My wife.
Oh, last night was not better than that.
The PTA was white.
I said, the PTA?
He said, that sounds like a business you're going to.
I don't want to get Scali and everybody else in this conversation up with you here.
I have a reason for it.
It's that we're going to have lots of battles.
I have a rule that I don't want a lot of
I don't want people to feel that you come in and maybe let down somebody or something of that sort, which is the overshadowing, you know, because I have always had the practice of standing up for my people.
I'm just going to say a word.
You see, that's the reason I didn't use that short strip of the skeleton.
I just didn't like them coming at me that way.
On the other hand, I've been thinking about the way this story has evolved into, you know, we had a good break yesterday, but I don't know what led to any of this.
On the other hand, the Democrats were popping around and doing a little bit of a story in this very game about the
the business that we're accusing him of treason.
That's the first line of blow.
I don't think the rest of this one.
The rest of them, that's my opinion.
He has the ultimate case, and then he goes on.
The contacts started to separate a little bit last night.
Separate, separate.
I played around with that and said it's going to post this morning.
But they're lumping in.
Post is now moving to what I told the president I think is the
the new ground or the basic ground they'll use from here on out now, which is there's a conservative thing here that the vice president let it off and the secretary hit it a little harder than you hit it.
And then I took the total load and I did the whole thing.
Shoved it all up.
Well, I think it's possible.
But my feeling is that tomorrow
that I will be in a position of having to duck too much.
And also, my feeling is that what I say on this will override the positive things I'm going to say on China.
Now, the course of action is for you to say something, but I think that would be, if you were to go out and reflect your reaction to the Democrats and hear what they were going to say,
My approach, which I've talked to and I've been waiting for a while to read, is never to have a bunch of people parking around like this.
In a way, you want to realize we've got these bastards.
This isn't out.
on a way that they aren't going to particularly be comfortable with.
The reason that it isn't comfortable to be in a position, and probably, you know, I still come off about it, you know, of, uh, well, what the hell are they for?
You know, what they are for is eternal surrender.
And they are, and they are, they are torpedoing the negotiations.
But do you agree that some of that, that it's to our interest to have that out?
Because basically, right, negotiations aren't going to come off.
They may, they may just, right, we might get a negotiation at Russia.
That's where you want to leave.
That's what we expect to give us a chance.
We're ready to go.
Maybe not.
But if they don't, you have to read it.
But if they don't, we must lay the foundation.
You get my point, correct?
You agree with that?
It's basically an undercut.
It's a motion of undercutting.
Now after you're reading the morning things and so forth, do you go with the skeleton?
You think you ought to say something today.
Now, you understand?
What I'm contemplating is something that goes much further for me to say something.
So let me tell you how that happened one night.
You see, I'm ancient, so I say the word, but I'm saying nothing in it.
And I ask you to correct me.
And I'm going to correct you.
I'm going to read you the hymnal and say the word.
And also a way to answer it so that I don't do it sort of very precisely is to put a paragraph right in there.
Let me turn it over to you, Tom.
This has been our longest semester of the Gulf War.
It began long before I began prison.
And I have been doing everything I can honorably do to end it.
I have brought almost one half million men home from Vietnam.
As high as three hundred wheat were being killed in action when I took office this week for truth.
We reduced air servings, budget cuts, draft calls.
We had made the most generous peace offer in the history of warfare.
I have no complaint with the fact that during this period when I had been ending the war, I did not begin.
I had been subjected to unprecedented criticism.
I do not question the patriotism or the sincerity of those who disagree with my policy to grant peace.
As I said in 1968 when I was a candidate for president, we have only one president at a time.
Only the president can negotiate an end to the war.
Let there be free debate and vigorous criticism so that our policy will represent the best thinking of our nation.
The candidate for president has a higher responsibility than the ordinary great.
A candidate should make any criticism he believes will contribute to bringing an honorable peace.
But I would hope that each presidential candidate would examine his statements carefully to be sure that nothing he says might give the enemy an incentive to prolong the war until after the election.
Let us seek peace with all our might, but let us be united in our determination to seek peace
The trust in the United States, among the 45 nations with which we have created commitments, is essential if peace and freedom are to be preserved in the world.
We are ending the war in Vietnam in a way which will not destroy that trust.
That's very good.
It's much better than me climbing around out there, and I think that puts it in the right place.
How does it tell the sign?
Good.
I know.
In the context of the way it's sent here, it tells a lot.
Is it?
I think so.
It's a hell of a hypo.
Right.
Now, this is something, if I do, I'm just going to put it in the coffee.
And I want you to give the copies out.
the moment I just, I delivered the speech, you know what I mean?
I don't want any, and I'm not going to clear it with anybody.
Or I could do it right after.
Well, do it right after.
Have them ready and give it to them.
Well, give it to them so they can follow.
Yeah.
Yeah, just bring that up.
Here's the speech.
Well, you've got Capo and who's this on at 11?
Live in the White House.
They should not have this until after they go back to the air.
That's right.
I just say that we're, I just give it to them at 11 o'clock.
Now, here's what I had in mind, too.
I mean, you're on at 11 o'clock.
Yeah, I'll give it to you right when you start up.
Yeah, I'll say here's, I just say that they are going to be crashing for the dog.
You know, that's an interesting action story.
But when you see here,
You covered several things.
I don't question patriotism of those who disagree with my policies.
We're in peace.
That covers, that says all of what Scott said.
When he's fallen, some will write it that way.
That's all right.
But I don't agree.
I don't go in person.
I guess I have a question, which is, of course, you said you were speaking for yourself.
So I said I was speaking for myself.
That's clear enough to represent.
It's an amazing thing.
The New York Times, in your story, ran, you know, all in a blast.
And Ziegler says, not necessarily, he's speaking for himself, not necessarily for the president.
Dan Marshall's post book picked that necessarily up and put it in quotes this morning.
I've just checked the tape of my transcripts.
I did not say necessarily, and I'm going to skewer them to death.
There's a lot of stuff everywhere you can find it.
What about the fact that the president joins others in saying that presidential candidates prolong the war?
And my answer is, that's just fine.
Because I said that to the leaders the other day.
I said, no, if the candidate, if they say, we'll wait for the candidate, that screws in with the sabotage of the negotiations.
I think we want that issue.
I are on the right.
I feel that we want the issue along this line that they can criticize the human being, but they should not undercut what is being done in negotiations.
Because one man has responsibility, and that man who has responsibility is doing what he can to end war.
And that is separate from the being critical.
It's attempting to present a program
which goes around the program in the manner that it's responsible for.
That's the issue.
Right, that's not a bad thing, too.
A candidate should make any criticism that he believes would contribute to bring an honorable release, that lets him get out and beat for a cop all he wants.
That's like, for an honorable, of course, I'd cop right there.
And then I say, but I would hope
I've done this very carefully.
I worked up to, well, I had a bunch of talk earlier.
I said, I think that if it's well included in the chapel way, I will, each presidential candidate, will examine his statements carefully.
So it puts them in an above-the-battle way of, oh, you're all around here running for president.
I just said, just examine your statements carefully.
So I have to be sure, I think, because everybody has to be sure that nothing is said.
might give the enemy an incentive to go on the war without resolution.
Now that lays it out there very simply.
Does it bother you?
No.
I would have only one suggestion, which would put it into a little deeper.
Instead of saying presidential candidate, where you who hold the highest office in the land, it gives the person listening to it a sense of here's a man who is in the position thinking about other seats.
Each man who is seeking the highest office in the land, or each man who is seeking the presence, instead of...
I had that in my first draft.
Instead of referring to them as presidential candidates, it's sort of, what's the highest rank?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Those who seek the presence.
Right.
Because if...
But I can say, as additional burden of responsibility, I can say that a candidate, well, I can say, but it doesn't bother you to say that a candidate for president has a higher responsibility or an inquiry.
It doesn't bother you at that point.
A candidate.
But I would hope that anyone seeking the presidency.
Right.
That's it.
Seeking the presidency.
Seeking the presidency.
Don't you want credit?
For the examiner's sake, it's fair that you should.
I think he says to give you the 19 cents along the bar to let you collect your money.
You know, I'm the candidate up above here.
I can't say something.
No, no, no.
Because you covered in the next sentence.
So you say he should make it?
There's a part I'm trying to recall where you refer to, you use the word surrender
Yeah, if you don't like surrendering.
How does that... Let us seek peace with all our might.
Let us be united in our determination to seek peace without surrendering.
It doesn't bother me as a statement.
I'm just trying to put it in perspective of the news flow of today and what is being said and how they may seize upon that word used by you and apply it out of context.
Do you see what I mean, Mike?
Well, yeah, I can put it in.
We could go on for the rest of the next... Maybe we could strike that out totally.
and simply let it be.
We could end this way, but I would hope that any man seeking the presidency would examine his statements carefully to be sure that nothing he says might give the enemy an incentive to prolong the whole of the election period.
And then, trust in the United States among the 45 nations which we have created as a sanctuary of peace and freedom for the Earth.
We are ending our war in a way which will not destroy it.
Our duty is to say, let us end our involvement in the war.
Let me in a way.
Let us end our war.
Let us end our war.
Let us end our war.
In a way.
End our involvement in the war.
In a way which will not destroy that trust.
That surrender thing is common.
It's a code word thing.
That's right.
Others say it.
But this is a perfect way to put it in perspective.
If you use that word, then they will take that and generalize it.
And then the question.
Does that mean that he feels that Senator Huss is calling for a cease-back bond for victims?
That's right.
Now Henry's going to greet me this morning, and I'm not going to discuss this with him.
But I'm going to make it clear that if that's, you know, the subject that he should just say it's been covered, period.
There's no reason why he should say anything at all.
He doesn't want to anyway, so there's no problem.
The last thing he's got to do is say anything about it.
I think.
Boy, you've really got to watch Sapphire.
God damn it, Henry should have watched this, too.
All the way through the vibe, wherever they say China, of the People's Republic of China.
You know, he's got it in here four times.
China.
The United States and China.
You really shouldn't realize what that does to Taiwan.
It's linked forever.
That's China.
Goddamn, they know better than that.
And I just don't think Henry read this copy.
You've got to say Mainland China or the People's Republic of China.
The People's Republic is the thing to do rather than Mainland China.
Because then you're just saying there's two Chinas.
Just call it the People's Republic of China.
And you call it the Republic of China if you're talking to Taiwan.
So that's why those changes are there.
All right, make some other changes I can turn around.
Clear those.
Public, I'm done there again.
Four o'clock.
I know it's four o'clock.
I think it's a good little needle, too.
Sir?
I've got to do this to point out the fact that this is not my war.
Right.
Absolutely.
I've got to try, sir.
I've been in a war I did not begin.
And the fact that it hurt him, sir.
That's something wasted on the radio.
When you use unprecedented, the critics always say, well, I've been subjected to.
Uh, Constance Sharpe.
Constance.
Constance.
What?
Constance, you like it?
Figures.
Figures are much better than I do.
Figures are much better than I do.
Figures is a better word for some guys who do a great deal of criticism.
Figures.
Figures.
Huh.
Do you like figures?
I've got the word.
It's kind of weird, that one.
to make any criticism he believes would contribute to bringing an honorable peace.
But I would hope that anyone seeking the presidency would examine his statements carefully to be sure nothing he says might give the enemy an incentive to prolong the war after the election.
How does it sound to you now?
Pretty good.
Why don't you tighten this off, Rose, down to here and bring it through.
There's one thought I have.
It's a payoff cut, which would just go back out of there, right?
When you end this, I'll tell you what I had in mind.
The stakes are too high.
We must stop the killing and bring our prisoners of war home.
And our U.S., you know, our forces, there's a better way of saying that.
But that pays that off.
In other words, don't give the enemy the incentive to prolong the war.
There's too much at stake here.
Our prisoners of war
There's too much at stake here.
We must stop the killing of the bears.
We bring our prisoners home.
And I don't know.
Well, are you saying peace is true?
I mean, definitely.
I mean, it was beginning to end.
As I said in 1968, peace is true, and peace is what we're supposed to prefer for partisanship.
Are you saying the lives
Not with the liars.
See, what you're paying off would be the consequences of prolonging the war.
What are the consequences?
The liars are the liars.
We're the liars of Americans.
We're the liars of American men.
And the fate of our field of agency.
Let us unite.
It's called big unite.
Let us unite in supporting the policy to bring peace to these hostages.
Go again, not again.
It gets in more personal terms, don't you?
Mm-hmm.
You're not going to be tonight.
Say it.
Tell you that Ron's the delight of American men and the failure of U.W.
's.
So if you do that, they'll say, fine, just get the hell out.
That's the only thing.
They should be driving, you know what I mean?
They'll say, fine.
One point.
I don't know.
That's what gets you back into discussing the...
Yes, the particulars, which is just what you don't know.
Now, I have an idea about this, too, that...
from a technical standpoint, so as to get on the tube, to put this on the teleprompter.
But I don't want five cameras there.
If I'm on the teleprompter looking into one camera, and then all the others coming from the crash point, I'm not looking there.
Now, can we put it on our own teleprompter and our own camera?
And the district into the fire.
We should put it on our own teleprompter and one camera.
And it should have speedy.
They're cool.
They never can be sure they do that.
Well, they're cool.
Oh, absolutely.
I don't want it to happen to the speech.
You have to request to do this for television.
two, three, no, two, okay, you get it, it was.
Huh?
All right, fine.
Yeah.
Well, I just don't, you didn't say that the president will do a film, do a film my way.
And I'm going to do only this film.
I'm not going to give him any goddamn, uh, smart stories.
But I'll do only this.
One camera.
One camera.
And one teleprompter.
How about that?
And no, no newsman or
No, absolutely not.
Now, where is the best place to do that, Father, dear?
Right here.
Oh, can they set the camera, please?
Sure.
Put it right there.
All right.
Take them.
All right.
Well, I'll leave.
I'm going to go over to the OB now, so they can set the camera up.
And, uh... Well, we can do that afterwards.
No, I can do it afterwards, can't you?
Right.
You should do it afterward.
I'd rather tell them.
I'd rather say to them, after this, you don't want to say this before you go on the air.
Oh, I see.
Right.
If I had, I don't know.
I want them to come and thank me for it.
I've heard this.
If you get this for Kevin, you tell him, and you say, yeah, I'm going to be glad to see the highlights.
And you go out and...
But I also like the highlights.
Absolutely.
See, and that'll be it.
And I don't think that takes more than a minute and a half when I get it straight.
About right, it's of it.
I think they'll, do you think they'll carry this line for sure?
Like how it sounds?
I think they'll carry this whole thing.
They'll carry what you want on it.
Well, every day I'm worried.
That's when some of the best stuff comes out.
Sometimes, sometimes it doesn't.
The point is that at least you go to the juggler in the middle of the night.
This is the best.
I think we could, uh, we get away without it.
And I didn't, I didn't have one for Rusty, because I think the story, and it's not, I mean, they'll, I think it's one that Ron Geary, I think Ron is probably correct, Joe Ron, Joe Bob, I think it's correct in the sense that this is moving from the news pages to the editorial pages, and they all mull it about the goddamn thing, but
I knew this about a place called Beebe today.
He's George Walsh's cousin.
It's a very close association.
He's an advisor to George in his Florida campaign.
And it's one of the reasons George is kicking the shit out of the Democrats rather than us at the moment because we kick ass very much.
Tell his cousin, tell Beebe that if he could get ahold of the cousin and say, look, we need a real opportunity for you in Florida with Beebe.
would be so that you're just not a one-issue man.
That Muskie, Humphrey holds himself up.
Muskie particularly holds himself up.
And that George, being the patriot that he is,
that he did not criticize Johnson.
He and I both, as candidates, did not criticize Johnson in 68, and that he might want to take Muskie on.
What I meant is I think it would be good to inject that into the Florida Democratic primary.
Would you agree that George should do it?
And that he ought to take him on for, that he ought to take him on for his, their undercutting the president, undercutting the chancellor for peace, and calling for
Surrendered to the end.
He might say a few things.
You can ask him what to say.
Don't draw again.
Yeah, good.
Try it.
But I said that.
But on the other hand, I was thinking of my deal tomorrow.
And I'm confident that the way these people are, you know,
and the rest of the day, they'll still press on about, I'm going to be cold as ice when I'm off the ground.
I stated my position yesterday on it, and I'm supposed to say it when I'm not on television.
Two things they have to do, too, because it's been covered in a briefing, because it's personal view, and then you challenge your view, so it locks off.
And if they begin to follow up, nothing puts them down faster than you just look them in the eye, you know, and just say, I have nothing more to say on that point.
What you can do in here, you can't do on the other side.
And that allows the China story, right?
China, we could probably go tomorrow.
Our statement, what I have said, what I have said, what the President has said is clear.
My position is clear.
There's nothing more to say.
Because then we'll just chop them off and make them feel, you know, ridiculous for trying to follow up on something.
You know, it's amazing, I mean, this is, you think about it, I was thinking about last night, this all kind of is a story.
It is.
It is.
It really is.
You know, all these grown men getting all excited out there and the pressure of God, you know, it's foolish to be resting right now in this stuff.
She said, you know, it's rather interesting.
NBC made the full transcript of the Hall of the Interview that was run on Monday.
available to all the newspapers and television news services on Friday of last week.
Not one of them picked up this point at all until after it was on the air Monday morning.
Then she twisted it her way.
She said, I guess it's because it was a woman interviewing.
They figured it wasn't worth taking seriously.
Very clear, though.
Don't let it set you off.
They have always underestimated me.
patriotic forces in the country.
Do you think so?
Or do you?
I think so.
I think this town has.
I think the people that we deal with.
No question.
There's absolutely no question at all.
It always should start with someone they find out that people put flags out on the roads and it comes into town and they wear flags and they lapel.
They don't like it again.
It is a state that can be made in this town.
to assume that this is the audience .
You just got to remember you're in London right here.
Did your mom say, you know, he goes out to the show last night, that there's still a few hardhats around?
Was there any money made for people at the Alameda quarter air last night that came up?
Did you manage to get a wife?
Who was that?
All of the number of people, all of them.
A lot of them.
There's a friend in Texas called Anna Chenault, don't you?
She's like... And she grabbed the Chinese ambassador who was over there and brought in one of them.
A little man, you know, and he said...
Very pleased with what you set up for the television program.
The Chinese ambassador, obviously.
When you see Ron Benny being posting the messages, don't let him...
The best thing, and it's hard to say what's the best thing, but I think the best and most cunning thing that's been written is Crosby and I.
You see, that thing was probably written before this story broke.
God damn, didn't he come to rescue his son?
He's done it.
He's followed that one in a couple of times.
Now, he is, he's no wild man.
No, he's not.
Not, uh, not always for us.
Usually, not always.
But Jesus Christ, didn't he slice them up, you know?
Of course, it's surrender.
It is.
Get out.
Bug out.
Well, they had this escalation.
To that, I mean, so that, because the war is in the people's minds, of course, it's get out for a while, it's good, and everybody was saying, great.
I remember the 70 campaign.
Everybody said, isn't it wonderful, or wasn't peace an issue, or was the war an issue?
It wasn't wonderful at all.
Do you understand?
You agree?
Hell, those Southern Mexicans are riding around in these ties and wearing flags and all of a sudden they didn't realize they were undercutting the president.
We should go the other way.
The war is a bad issue for us.
Yeah.
But the peace in Vietnam is a good issue for us.
And if I play down the war as an issue, we can make the mistake of also playing down the peace.
I'm playing down the fact those veterans got us in and I've got them out.
And there's no question that they're on it.
Do they get that much?
Yes, they are.
I think even the... No, let me say what you said, with that one's a lot.
But that's what our chiefs speak, really, about it.
If they had an effect, the major effect they have on it.
But it's on the side of the pieces.
But they run those charts.
They run the charts of the number of in and the charts of the number of in.
I think, I don't think there's any question...
The impression is certain in this country that you are moving to end the U.S. involvement in Vietnam.
I think we are beginning to set the impression, and I don't think it's certain yet, that there are forces attempting to undercut your efforts.
And that is why you and I have talked about it.
We're tied up here in this town about it, but it takes a while for that type of thing to permeate the whole, you know, the thought process of the doctrine.
That's why I said, I think the worst thing that can happen to us, but I don't know, the worst thing that can happen to us now, of course, is to be feared by the critics.
Beared by the critics.
That's why it would have been a mistake.
I wish to hell I hadn't said Aiden the vet because that's the finest treason.
I didn't want to give him a treason, but that's too bad.
On the other hand, if I had just said something, he wouldn't have gotten mad at me.
So maybe it was worthwhile.
Whether it was or wasn't, it's in the pot.
The thing now is from where the ball is now.
We make a terrible mistake if we try to, I think, if we try to back off and say, oh, no, they're all doing a noble thing.
And keep in mind, this is the last day that there's, and never, never, never, please, make any kind of fucking resting.
And resting, look at these, this is honest.
I haven't minded him of it, but on a day when he's very calm, feeling good, won't you?
Went over to Rebson's house, talking to John Gardner, and said, hey, we're rolling, what can you do?
The son of a bitch has read nothing but bank columns since he was there.
Am I wrong or right?
When he said, when Henry said he had tears?
Yeah, well, the tears, that's because we were getting somewhere.
He tears in his eyes also because he had grabbed Henry Kissinger as the hottest property in town.
They all, on one hand, reached dinner.
Sure.
He goes to the wrong places.
Well...
This whole thing is over with.
It's $40,000.
Well, it takes a lot of time today.
Sure.
And the president...
magazine.
Not in two months.
China's going to be there.
They'll be there and they'll fart around on it.
Some of the Democrats will squeal around about it.
But I thought today was the day to pop it, rather than to let it wait till tomorrow, rather than another day of farting around.
I assume I'm right in the position I'm taking now, which is I won't talk to anybody about any of the two.
Never.
You should not.
Never.
Is that it?
You know, they all, that's where we want to get in.
I don't know who sent the phone.
You, then?
Oh, of course.
They just never return calls, and they need batteries.
I wish more people around here could follow that line.
Have your own.
Be very considerate.
He won't get his views if he finds out.
I mean, it's marvelous, possibly, but he had one.
What did you think?
I used to say, I don't anymore, so I don't know what he used to think.
I had fun with him, and I sat with him, and I said, don't worry about it.
And I knew he would say what.
I don't know what.
So I said, what do you mean?
I said, I don't know.
And he looked up and said, I don't know.
And I...
Are you on the thing?
Yeah.
You go ahead, you go ahead.
What?
Are we going to get this first?
I mean, why?
Now, we've got to get this, well, Rose is packing, and we've got to get that put on there.
But when we get it on the front door, why don't we get it on the back door?
I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn't, I didn
Now, I mean, I just want to do that and make sure that the rest of it can be started from now.
The rest of it can all be done with the insert.
I just want to check once more for my line.
Okay?
Okay.
You know, the...
JCC groups, they're always, they must say, they're always a stimulating group.
There's a goddamn enthusiasm.
They're good people, too.
Where they searched up this, Jim, was that?
Yeah, I could build this area.
I found it, I want you to make a note of this, there are conventions in Atlanta, Jim.
And I think it's a very, a very unlikely possibility that this is the hell we're going to go to Atlanta.
We have very confident that we're going to go to Atlanta.
Also, if you talk to Tom, I've got a friend in Abilene, Texas.
I told him that I'd like to go to a small town in Texas.
And it's an honor.
It's a Houston, probably the only publisher in Florida.
It's a hell of an event.
But Appleton is a damn good town.
It's by three colonies.
Hard to send us.
And there's an event that we can do in March any time.
That might be a good way to go to Texas in addition to the other one.
And then there's the Rotary.
The Rotary is in June.
The Rotary is June 11th.
The week of June 11th, the JC's is the following week.
It starts at 20.
And the Campus Crusade is also the week of June 11th.
Well, we... Maybe that's not what we're looking for.
Well, not necessarily.
Darn it.
We haven't been to Houston.
Yet the governor's conference is in Houston.
I'm not going to do the goddamn governor's conference.
Who the hell is pressing that?
Nobody's pressing that.
It's the week before, the week before.
This is a national governor's conference.
I know.
I'm not going to do it.
I'll tell them I'll be right there.
But remember, after this is done, hard on you.
You didn't know anything about it.
No, absolutely.
And you didn't know anything about it.
Yeah.
He didn't like the, he thought the speech needed a little testing, so he put it in.
Let me tell you, I got to ask you.
You could have been played anyway, but now I'm going to get a play.
Huh?
All right.
Farewell.
You know, we sneered at the other stuff.
I'll tell you, that environment thing yesterday got a hell of a good flood.
Yes, one of them.
Two of them.
And I didn't see it, but I guess it was fine.
It has to be done with one camera.
It looked all right, but when you get the camera...
No, no, don't worry.
The, uh, I forgot to say, you, uh, you've left out, uh, the next, the top of the next table.
Yeah, that's all right.
That's the next thing.
Tom, it's in that stage, yeah.
That's right.
All right.
And you want it to go?
Where'd it go?
You know, it's, it's page 88.
It's called that page 88.
It's not in the book.
The other night.
See?
It's between 9 and 10.
Yeah.
This is the bottom of page 9.
Okay.
No, that's a very sharp name.
Yes, sir, it is.
It's got the beauty of being very clear to the public in the way you want to be clear to them, but it has some super subtleties in it that are going to be goddamn clear to some other people.
Okay, brother.
Okay.
Do you want to do that?
No.
I'll have Jerry come and get it in a few minutes because we've got to get ready to hand out a lot of those sections.
I'm going to hand it out to them.
We're going to have to have those.
Keep it quiet.
Make that 9-8.
Don't bother re-typing the stage.
There's no way to get it done.
I can't read it over again.
Do you have it back?
I'll be back in a couple of minutes.
Fine, I'll be back in a couple of minutes.
Fine, I'll be back in a couple of minutes.
Fine, I'll be back in a couple of minutes.
I want you to take advantage of it and go on.
Why don't you try to go to the candidate?

— 3 min 31 s with no transcribed speech —

Like in this sentence, this teamster guy has a thing.
I might call him, but don't.
But things were sure.
I don't want to.
And I think we're going to leave out now.
I mean, I just got to send letters to people that, you know, some guy should save the policeman's life and this and that and the other thing.
I really didn't leave.
I don't think I can get into that very much right now.
I mean, it's pretty deeply political.
to do it now to send me notes.
Actually, I've been looking the thing over.
It's hard to be sure, but I think we're getting better mileage out of the notes than to get out of the phone calls anyway.
Yeah, yeah.
Simply because, what, I don't know what to do about the phone calls.
That's right.
I don't know whether it's a person with a note.
It often gets printed.
It's amazing how many times that note gets printed.
The picture of the letter itself gets printed in the paper.
Those are just standing in the back in a local paper.
They're not worth it anymore.
I shouldn't have spent
The phone calls, have you done enough of them?
I don't think there's any questions.
Maybe once in a while, it'll be once in a great while, it's a John Harley motion or something, I will let you know.
But I think the letter is something that, like the New York police, you were concerned that you didn't get phone calls on.
What's the name of the thing?
John, go there.
Hello?
We don't see the money doing that, but it's getting tough to talk to those parents of a boy who, because they are terribly difficult, you know, they carry you up.
And that's why we shouldn't have to leave them off.
And we've accomplished the same thing.
The notes can be warm and great.
That's right.
And they are.
We've got some awfully good notes.
And we've got those down in the short ones.
Yes, and we're doing a hell of a good job now on the one-liners.
Are you great?
Yes, sir.
And Shane, I thought your speech was great.
Great job on the speech you did last week.
All right.
You know, his back kind of thing, just sort of punching things at the guys is going to be great.
It's great.

— 3 min 5 s with no transcribed speech —

Let me say, though, that I am totally resigned to expressing I'm not going to press myself on these kinds of edges.
I mean, I think that I've been reading on that for press things.
I mean, we have to do it anyway.
breathing books and are asking far around screw it i mean i'm gonna go here and do what i've been talking about china pick a few other questions and finish in 30 minutes especially here where you're not on tv your phraseology and christmas is not that important no no and that's where you have to do the work it's really you know how to answer the question on substance yeah i don't make any
any serious consequence.
I just made Papa go hard.
Well, they don't use them no matter how much it takes.
They write what you say rather than do your words.
Now, they do get a couple of papers printed, transcripts on their part.
Nobody reads the transcript.
Nobody reads it, that's right.
Oh, the funeral, that's the name, I guess.
That's the 12th.
Oh, yeah.
Oh, boy.
If you want to do it, go.
I don't know.
He was a good friend, you know.
Well, my view is that he should not.
My view is that he should not.
But it's just because he's too low-level a guy.
Yeah.
And he's a big barge.
And has no public appeal at all.
Yeah, right.
Let it go.
And anyway, I'm doing it.
Another thing, for whatever it's worth, Henry was sat by Missy Chandler, because he's everything done by Missy.
And he said she just turned around 180 degrees.
She's with us.
And Bob Pinch says that Otis is much better now than a while ago.
And Otis says the economy is really moving in California now.
I don't know.
We get apparently that out of the planet.
It's beginning to come along.
Yes.
It's a pretty good run.
Yeah.
They really are.
And I've been watching that.
They're going to get it poured with some effort.
It does some good.
Yeah.
Because, you know, we have poured effort into this.
They've poured a lot of effort in.
Finally, we did.
But it takes time.
You can't pour it in on two shanks.

— 4 min 3 s with no transcribed speech —

because at that point we were in the Dallas busing business and we had to keep you isolated.
I'm going to hand these letters to Mrs. Thompson, sir, because it's such a safe place.
One is dear Jane, one is dear Mrs. Thompson.
One is dear Jane, yeah.
She's got you now.
She's got you now.
She's got you now.
She's got you now.
Oh.
On the teleprompter, you want page 8, page 9, and page 9.
Let me suggest something.
This is a radio speech.
Why don't you leave the microphone on your desk and read it?
Why teleprompter?
Yeah.
Let's face it.
Let's try it once that way.
You can't lose attention.
And I agree with the teleprompter.
Well, I didn't see you at the end of the night.
I'll have to rerun it, but let me look at this.
Well, I know.
And who's mad at us?
You have a little camera box over here or this side of the room.
Now, good to know that at the last run.
You really should have.
Because, you know, and I know, and I figured, and I didn't mention it to him, because I figured what had happened is that Ron's office got, you know, buggered.
It could be to say, we've all got a cover now with our cameras.
It could be.
God damn it.
So it's Ron's center.
I'm staring right here and there.
And they're shooting deep in the side.
Of course, that's usually the way it's done.
When you're talking, I was standing up and so forth.
But...
That doesn't show the judgment.
Somebody should have thought that true.
I saw it the moment I walked in the room.
I said, well, for Christ's sakes, I said, I said, I said, I really think it's all these cameras.
He said, yeah.
So they're all in there.
What probably happened is that the press office set it up, not knowing either teleprompter or anything.
Well, why should they not know?
Because those were playing well in advance.
There was no last minute type thing on that.
And I'm going to do it again that way.
I'm going to call Robert.
But with a full camera.
A full camera.
And also a little shorter.
I told you.
Yeah.
If I got to just get there and do the teleprompter, and I can do more, and I would be glad to do more.
Particularly if I, it doesn't require a lot of moving around.
There's good things to do.
And, you know, I can send messages down, Doc's driving around, and they can see me on there talking right into that camera for a minute.
But if it's 45 seconds, nobody's going to get a missed call.
That's exactly right.
They expect to see the president on the news.
Yeah.
Yeah, a few minutes.
Part of what's happening today is what the president did.
You're on gross.
We leave at 4.

— 1 min 55 s with no transcribed speech —

You go right on 330, I'll go 345.
Right on.
Chopper 4.
Chopper 4.
Do you need any time to re-type this one, thanks for it?
No.

— 3 min 50 s with no transcribed speech —

a separate kind of craze or that sort of thing.
I just realized the job of everybody on the president's team, the leaders team,
Let's think of him first.
That's right.
Not themselves.
That's really what we get to.
Really, that's what we get to.
Yeah.
Rather than thinking of, they walk into this office while I have all these damn problems and what's he going to solve?
It's the national phobia.
Of course, yeah.
I mean, everybody, a businessman would come in and sit on there.
Yeah.
But here's my question, what are you going to do about it?
Yeah.
You want to find a way to prompt your people, Jim?
  • 020-078 8:39 AM · 37 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and John M. Zwach talked on the telephone from 8:39 am to 8:40 am.
  • 668-007 8:39 AM · 3 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John M. Zwach met in the Oval Office of the White House from 8:39 am to 8:40 am.
  • 020-079 8:40 AM · 7 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 8:40 am and 8:44 am.
  • 668-008 8:40 AM · 18 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 8:40 am and 8:44 am.
  • 020-080 8:44 AM · 44 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Walter R. Tkach talked on the telephone from 8:44 am to 8:45 am.
  • 668-009 8:44 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Walter R. Tkach met in the Oval Office of the White House from 8:44 am to 8:45 am.
  • 668-010 8:45 AM · 3 min — President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, and Stephen B. Bull met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 8:45 am and 9:19 am.
  • 668-011 8:45 AM · 4 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Alexander P. Butterfield met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 8:45 am and 9:19 am.

Conversation 668-012, February 9, 1972. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/668-012 (accessed November 16, 2026).