Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 683 › Conversation 683-007

Nixon, Berman & Garment on National Endowment for the Humanities

Monday, March 13, 1972 · 12:18 PM–1:07 PM ET · Oval Office · 50 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Berman, Ronald S.; Garment, Leonard; Powell, William J.; Sanchez, ManoloConversation683-007 on Tape 683 (tape position 02:54:00–03:44:22)StartMonday, March 13, 1972 at 12:18 PMEndMonday, March 13, 1972 at 1:07 PMRecording deviceOval OfficeSourceNixon Library record for 683-007 ↗

President Nixon met with Ronald Berman, Chairman of the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH), and Leonard Garment to discuss strategies for using the arts and humanities to counter the ideological influence of radical intellectuals on college campuses. They evaluated the potential for government-sponsored film and literature programs to appeal to a moderate, middle-class constituency that respects traditional education and values. Nixon emphasized his desire for content that highlights historical and biographical themes rather than current ideological trends, while Berman reported on efforts to bring more moderate academics into the administration's orbit to combat the influence of university radicals.

  • National Endowment for the Humanities
  • Campus Unrest
  • Intellectuals
  • Cultural Policy
  • French Revolution
  • Education
  • Public Relations

Download MP3 · 69.2 MB

This clip was extracted from the full tape recording by Easy Nixon.

Listen to the full tape segment

Position in tape: 02:54:00 – 03:44:22

part B, 51:52

683a.mp3
683b.mp3
683c.mp3

On March 13, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon, Ronald S. Berman, Leonard Garment, William J. Powell, and Manolo Sanchez met in the Oval Office of the White House from 12:18 pm to 1:07 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 683-007 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 683-7

Date: March 13, 1972
Time: 12:18 pm - 1:07 pm
Location: Oval Office

The President met with Ronald S. Berman and Leonard Garment; the White House photographer
was present at the beginning of the meeting.

     Photographs
          -The President and Berman

     Garment
         -Public relations

     National Endowment for the Humanities [NEH]
          -Berman
          -Conservative publications
          -Subsidized art
               -Peking
          -Government control
          -Constituency
               -Status conscious compared to moderate individuals
                     -Example of House of Representatives
                          -Middle class attachments
                          -Midwest
                          -Respect for education
                                -Art compared to humanities
          -Programs
               -Professionals
               -Public
                     -Television

     -Good cinema art
           -Example of Laurence Olivier
                -Henry V
                -Hamlet
           -The President’s view
                -Biographical
                -Historical
                -Midnight Cowboy
           -Olivier
                -William Shakespeare
                      -Elizabethan England
                            -Example of Elizabeth Regina
Show the rest of the log (194 more lines)
                                  -British Broadcasting Corporation [BBC]
           -Movies in the White House
           -Definition of humanities
                -Movies
                -Radio
                -History
                -Literature
                -Biography
           -Comedies
                -Shakespeare
           -Drama in the US
                -Ideological bias
           -Biographies
                -Documentaries
                      -Orville and Wilbur Wright
                            -Portrayal of US spirit
                      -Lorraine Hansberry
                            -A Raisin in the Sun
                            -The Young, the Gifted, and the Black
           -Sports
                -Brian’s Song
                      -American Broadcasting Company [ABC]
                      -Brian Piccolo
                      -Gale Sayers
                      -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman
                      -Race relations
-Audiences
     -Novels
     -Biographies
-Education

      -H.G. Wells
            -Writings on the French Revolution
                 -Thomas Carlyle
                 -Jean Paul Marat
                 -Georges Danton
                 -Maximilien Robespierre
                 -Marat
                       -Benjamin Franklin
                       -Charlotte Corday
                 -Characteristics of revolutionary leaders
      -American-British history
      -Russian Revolution
      -French Revolution
            -Napoleon Bonaparte
                 -Waterloo
-Motion pictures
      -Patton
            -George S. Patton
            -Dwight D. Eisenhower
            -Bernard L. Montgomery
            -Omar N. Bradley
      -French Revolution
            -Edmund Burke
            -Carlyle
            -Marat, Danton, Robespierre
            -American Revolution compared to French Revolution
            -Danton
            -Robespierre
            -Present revolutionary practices
            -Wells
      -Musicals
      -Government sponsored
            -Freedom and diversity
      -Commercial
-Intellectuals
-Movies
      -French Revolution
-Writers
      -Burke
      -Carlyle
      -Wells
            -French Revolution compared to World War I

                            -Battle of the Somme, 1916
                            -World War I compared to World War II
                            -Deaths
                                  -Bastille
                -Revisionist historians
                      -French Revolution
                            -Intellectuals
                -The President’s talk with Georges J.R. Pompidou
                      -Indira Gandhi’s previous trip to France
                      -Golda Meir compared to Gandhi
          -Intellectuals
                -Plato’s Republic
                      -Shoemakers compared to professors
                -Universities
                -Academic freedom

Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 12:18 pm.

     Books
         -Residence
              -Wells
         -Library
              -Russell A. Kirk

Sanchez left at an unknown time before 1:07 pm.

     Intellectuals
           -Berman’s book
                 -Berkeley revolution
                      -Vietnam War
                      -Takeover of universities
                      -Unrest on campuses
                            -Cambodia
                            -Kent State
                            -Separate dorms
                      -Tear down traditional institutions
                            -Family
                            -Community
                            -Corporation
           -The President’s view
                 -Marxists compared to radicals
           -Education

                -Chinese compared to Americans
                     -Parents dedication
                -US
                     -Desire for education
                          -Blacks
                                 -Busing
                                      -Inferior education
                          -Trade groups
                          -Virtue

Sanchez entered and left at an unknown time between 12:18 pm and 1:07 pm.

                     -American attitude compared to British and Soviet attitudes
                         -Winston S. Churchill
                     -Middle class
                         -American ideal

     Writers
          -The President reading from a book
               -Carlyle on Marat
          -Painting
          -Books
               -List of ten best suggested by Berman
                     -History
                           -British
                           -Revolution
                           -Men
          -Writers
               -Carlyle
                     -The President reading from a book
                           -French Revolution
               -French Revolution
                     -Robespierre
               -The President reading from a book
               -Burke

     NEH
           -Berman
                 -Recommendations to the President
                       -Books
           -Movies
           -Intellectuals

                   -Sidney Hook
                   -Vietnam War
             -Individuals requesting employment
             -The administration
                   -Henry A. Kissinger
                        -Daniel P. Moynihan
             -Berman
                   -San Diego
                        -University of California
                              -Herbert Marcuse
                              -Production of intellectuals
             -Education
                   -Vietnam
                   -West Germany
                        -Garment’s recent visit
                        -University system
                              -Berlin
                              -Professors and students
                   -Japanese system
                        -Chinese
                        -Foreign policy ramifications
                   -US domestic stability
                   -Germany
                   -Japanese studies
                        -Possible efforts by NEH

     Gifts
             -Cufflinks

     Garment

     Lawyers

Berman and Garment left at 1:07 pm.

This transcript was generated automatically by AI (WhisperX) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Names and numbers are often wrong; speakers are not identified. Do not cite it as authoritative — verify against the audio and the finding aid.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).

Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.

All right.
Do you want to leave that student class up here?
Yeah, I'll leave it there for a while.
For a while?
Yeah, go ahead.
Well, how are you?
Nice to see you.
And shoot a picture of the two of us together.
Let's put your character out here.
Last time, our expertise are only intellectuals.
We're serious fellows.
Well, we're, uh, we, uh, on some land courses, try to be your public relations man.
And, uh, we really think this is a very important
has received, I suppose, in some courses proper attention, but everybody's interested in the arts.
Not much about language.
Oh, actually, so forth, the humanities.
I don't think it's your job, but I think it's our job because we've got a good man to do the job.
Why don't you tell me what you think is worthwhile?
I don't know.
publications and critics, because we had critics close by certain European people.
We're sort of in the middle, which is all right.
Anyway, they raise hell about any kind of subsidy of the arts, arts and humanities, et cetera, as you know.
And a pretty good case can be made against it if you see what happens to totally subsidized art, as we saw it became.
On the other hand, it seems to me that in this instance,
if we can avoid going over that brink to a government-controlled activity, then maybe we'll have the best of both worlds.
How do you feel about it?
making the best deal we can remember.
There really are two kinds of constituency as far as arts and humanities are concerned.
I think, frankly, arts support comes from people who are really high-status, who aspire to have arts.
I do agree.
Well, some in Paris.
A lot of them do.
That's true.
A lot of them do.
I think some of them do.
Prove something, learn something.
In other words, how can you get burned a few times and buy a few faves and all of a sudden become experts on the arts?
I agree with you.
That's the biggest of the system.
And that's the kind of supporters of the arts.
Generally, people who are kind of visible in a culture, they're well-heeled at that.
The papers report they're going on.
But we've uncovered a kind of new constituency for the humanities, which feels, and they've always felt, a little bit hostile toward dilettantes and connoisseurs.
And you could call this the kind of moderate skeleton, the backbone of people in the House of Representatives, for example.
A lot of young, very old Republican congressmen who have traditional middle class attachments, not to art, but to learning.
The learning edge is out.
Art is something to do and keep down there.
But it's a very American, I think it's a very middle American, I'm from the Midwest, that you should really do that.
I'm originally from New York, but I've worked in the Midwest down there for some years.
And there's a tremendous constituency based on this old American respect, not to say reverence, for education and what it will do for you.
It's not that, and it's really not a whole great thing.
I think middle Americans feel the way about education that a kind of upper-class people feel about art, which is in itself virtuous, some good thing.
And so we have a lot of support there, I'm very happy to say.
I think in the long run, humanity's support may be, as a matter of fact, more efficacious than our support.
Because this other constituency is middle American constituencies.
To them, we represent education.
We represent, really, the future, where as argument is something.
It's hard to understand.
It's an entertainment thing.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Ron, I think Fred might be interested in some of the program ideas that you've developed to flesh this out.
Yeah, there are two audiences for the National Endowment.
One has got to be professional, although a lot of people resent this.
I think there is congressional opposition, for example.
to giving away large carloads of money to professors.
I think we have to keep this up, because it's like basic research in science.
But we're moving with much more emphasis into public programs now, by any age, and through movies, especially designed for television.
I want to get as much of a public audience as possible.
If my whole thesis is right about middle class support for education as a good in itself, then I agree with him.
Then we have to do something about it.
So I'm putting as many millions as I can lay my hands on into
series that I think you or I would really like to see, or that anyone would really like to see.
For example, you probably know how hard it is to have access to a really good cinema art that says something to you, like Lawrence Williams, like his hammer.
They appear once in America, and they evaporate.
Obviously, they're not X-rated pictures.
and they put in storage.
My idea is to get these things out and put in series, very much like...
The other day, I mean, now let's see if we'll be able to get by with him.
the movies most worth seeing.
You mentioned those passing on.
10 or 15.
That's exactly what we're planning to do.
I bet that where I can tell them I must be on the call and I can see those movies, I particularly like the biographical, the historical, the rather than Midnight Cowboy.
You see, I couldn't agree more.
Someone that had created tremendous performance just doesn't sell.
And we want to risk it, but our idea is, in a way, is focused.
I mean, that's an advantage.
You see, you're going to put me in a series like that.
A Hemp Does an Olympiad, which is on Shakespeare.
We'll go on a program that brings the American, in some sense, to Elizabethan England.
Now, this doesn't seem to be a red-hot seller until you look at Elizabeth Regina, what it's doing on TV to American audiences.
It's amazing, isn't it?
It's enjoying just tremendous people.
Is it really?
Yes, that's true.
Because I think the issues, the issues in Shakespeare are the issues.
So listen to Regina.
On the BBC, by the way, on the BBC.
Yes.
So you're going to put that on the white house so we can see it right over here.
Well, I used to have that, yes.
We had such lousy movies that they couldn't get from you.
When you talk about emanation, I'm pretty sure you didn't do it with emanation.
You did it with multiplication.
Well, we have to stick to the humanities themselves.
So it has to be something dealing with history or literature.
My idea, for example, is to also put on
some of the great comedies, obviously they're easily put on film, they're easily put on TV, and I think we want to see some great Shakespearean comedies and other things, but the drama in this country suffers from the same kind of ideological bias as a lot of the other media, I'm sure.
I'll say, sometimes even more.
But now, apart from the, apart from the,
What, for example, do you do in the field?
People who write and speak.
good biographies, good history.
I have to brag a little about this, because this month we've received a tremendous load of reviews of two things exactly in that line.
One is what they say is about the year's best documentary produced by the Wright Brothers.
which is not just about flying, but about how around 1900, there's kind of something of national education television that's funded by us.
We've done this.
And it's a story of how there were different qualities in American life at the turn of the century, kind of optimism, a kind of conviction that you could master the material world.
But that's really come across in this film.
So that Orville and Wilbur Wright have come across as philosophers who kind of sum up the dominant American spirit around this time.
A second is on writers themselves.
Lorraine Hansberry, who was the author of A Raisin in the Sun, kind of middle-class Negro lady, not very great intellectual pretensions, but good, good, solid playwright.
I think she's enjoyable.
We wrote a movie of her called To the Young, Gifted, and Black, which is just super, and it's got a whole book full of writers.
I think you might enjoy some of these.
But we don't precisely know that the biopsy ran good as part of our mandate.
You know, the field of sports is in person, so we are very moving, and it relates to time.
So, again, we're in athletics union.
But I thought that the motion picture was not ABC.
Brian's song.
Did you see that?
Yes.
I read of that.
It's probably called Piccolo.
It's a character.
It's a well.
Did you see it?
My son saw it and was so moved by it.
There's a lot of great music.
I think they're great pieces.
I'd like you to, you can get it over here.
Yes, sir.
I'll tell you what you do.
Get it, I feel told to do it, but get it.
Sure.
It's good.
It's good.
It's practically, it's good television.
I mean, it's good entertainment.
It's good to read wonderful stories.
And perhaps in terms of race relations, it's the most subtle.
They're not being a message.
They're possibly, you know, it's good to come to investing.
And I don't know who produced it, but apparently this is true.
Maybe ABC played the production, but it was on television, as I recall.
It was a television, but it was an ABC show.
It was playing in Chicago, and it was picked up.
And I just happened to see it, and somebody called me, and showed up there, and so on and so forth.
But if you heard, they were encouraging young, talented writers and so forth to do better than you can.
And that's what I said to the president of the castle.
Actually, what we're trying to do is not really encourage the creation of things so much as a wider audience.
I mean, somebody writes a great novel or a great biography or something of that sort, and nobody cares, then it doesn't matter.
In other words, I don't know if I started those things and put them out.
I couldn't agree more.
It'd be hard for me to stimulate a great novel, but I can tell the American public about how great novels come about.
Yeah, I see.
I see.
I was just reading this.
What you saw, what you saw, what you saw.
You know, Wells' outline, if it has one central theme, is that education is the answer to problems.
That is, if societies become better educated, that's good.
They will not have war, they will have more prosperity, et cetera.
to be more rational and so forth.
Perhaps, looking at the line, perhaps the educated society is just finding ways to kill each other.
But nevertheless, I was reading a section in the beginning of the French Revolution, and his vivid descriptions, I must say, borrowed Carlisle to a certain extent,
You see, if you just sit here,
He swam so well.
So, as a matter of fact, others who swam in the rope group.
He had a terrible skin disease, and he had to sit in a hot bath in order to be able to concentrate and write.
He was sitting in his bath, writing.
And, of course, his speeches.
That's Pierre.
The whole story, the fighting point about all three, we talked about the, the most important one is that Mike, that Mike, their will was made, so these were handled in the lower level class, and not part of the, certainly the royalists, but each of them was, in its way, a, maybe he wouldn't have called them intellectual giants, but they had,
rather outstanding intellectual capabilities.
They were also people who were extremists.
They were fanatics.
They were purists.
And of course, eventually, they estranged one another.
But I was thinking, I read about those three, that you wanted to have another.
We do so much in the various great, our own background in the British system.
Now, of course, it's quite common that we see a lot about the Russian Revolution and so forth and so on.
But I don't know anything that's been done recently on the French Revolution.
Up to the time of Napoleon, I mean, stuff has been done on Napoleon.
And I saw something recently that was very
or Waterloo or something, but it just didn't get enough.
But a great motion picture, in my opinion, this is what made Patton a great movie.
It wasn't the war that made it the movie, it was the man.
You could see Patton, the allies in our era coming on stage, and what kind of a man he was.
You could see Montgomery, and you could also see Bradley, just as the book was a description of the man.
Take that and take some of the men.
Take those three men.
It'd be bloody, but a lot of people want blood.
How do you see it grow?
But on the other hand, it was an event that had more effect.
And it's hard for us as Americans to realize this in the American Revolution.
Because of its effect on the whole of the crown, that's the original appearance.
It would make a .
Because of the .
Sure.
Yeah, from that, that was a big, strong figure in the great order.
That's a great little guy.
It's a little name.
Yeah.
But on the other hand, totally honest.
And of course, it's totally crazy.
But what a fascinating subject it is.
Particularly, it will then relate to present revolutionary activities such as when is the revolution good, when is the revolution bad?
And it's a well-sourced good, which on balance, on balance, even though it
But it's that, when I think of the kind of drill we have to see on television, and I think of the lousy movies that are coming out, honestly, I don't, I mean, I like a good racist movie or this or that or the other things, maybe a nice musical and the rest, but everything should be deadly serious and gory and the rest, but Cotter is a place for something that really is the message so much.
It's the fact that it really is great theater and
And the greatest really is not really taking, is not making, as so often we do, is to take Spaceman 19 or 2040, something that is unreal, take something out of our total experience.
You have potential subjects there.
It's a very ironic thing that, in this case, the government will be moving more and more toward freedom and diversity, whereas the commercial movies are moving more and more toward a kind of clique, coterie-type.
Satisfying other people.
Yes.
They took out one kind of same thing after another.
I know.
They said, oh, god, this is the thing this year.
And then it just goes over and over and over again.
President's comments on the French Revolution put me in mind of what we were discussing in my office just before you came over, Ron.
But the problem now of the intellectuals and the expectation of actuality is in the very...
I'll pick up the...
As I said, if I were a writer, or if I were to make a great movie, it would have to be one of those long ones.
I don't know whether it can be done.
I mean, a character, a translation.
I could follow down there, particularly if you take the man, if you want a man.
How would you do it?
I would follow your first kind of intuitive insight into the fact that there's Burke on the one side and Carlisle on the other.
Hasn't it weighed in on the left?
The progressivist is seen in a blessed event commensurate, let's say, with the Immaculate Conception.
And you have to go all the way through this whole gamut of responses and see exactly how many times you've used this revolution in your life.
One interesting thing is if Burke saw a soil against one side, then he talks about how everything went down.
I think the other side, you see Wells making the point that, well, during the period of the terror,
So there were 4,000, 4,500, like that many of which were innocent.
And he said that, and yet, and this is of course, I think it's a very valid point.
He said, we have to remember that that was a terrible thing, that more were killed in the first day of the Battle of the Slam on the British side in 1916
So that proves something.
I can't be persuaded, but I haven't said it at all.
See, that's the way it is now.
You can't reverse it.
So that was on the termination.
But it's going to be in the casualties.
We talked about 3,400,000 to 3,000,000.
When he talks about 4,000 or 5,000 people, one would have liked to have been around and said, Mr. Wells, how many people have died under that seal in order to bring about this revolution?
The answer, of course, would have been practically none.
One of the things we're talking about, the damn fat seal, the...
The so-called revisionist historians, the ones who rewrite history of the last generation, very, very good.
And their whole point has been that the French Revolution has exacerbated and exaggerated
has been exaggerated by modern intellectuals for a very important reason.
Modern intellectuals like to look back to the French Revolution, because at that time, men of the sort you described, like Ben-Johannes Manet, Manet got power.
And so I think that crucial then for modern intellectuals, and one of the hardest things it is for us to try and cope with, I think myself, is being in the university.
One of the hardest things to do is to cope with the willpower of intellectuals.
And they have, I guess, well, they have as a matter of fact what you consider what really motivates people to believe that.
And it's the hypocrisy that turns me on.
And I don't want anybody to be in the power to be, well, to be solely...
We had an issue.
This is an historical footnote.
And when I was talking to the monitor, it was right after this.
But he was comparing the two women, Mrs. Conti and Mrs. Meyer, both of whom he both knew.
And I had seen both of them in the last month.
And as he had, which was one of the greatest of both.
And he said, look, there's another lady that I want to see.
Mrs. Mayer.
She's tough, she's ruthless, and she's not a bit apologetic about it, not a bit sanctimonious about it.
She's tough, she's ruthless, and she's like everybody else in the world about it.
They're both very formidable women.
and a very vulnerable people, part of the faculty.
But believe me, I prefer to have my colleagues and a little assistance.
I'm cased in a whole lot of hypocrisy, of course, and it has to be sometimes dealt with in order to meet properly.
But this is, and our intellectual friends, they've been so,
and others seeking power.
They're quite terrible.
On both extremes, I think they would like to take away the franchise from ordinary people.
And you know, one has to only have ordinary people.
Well, they think they should go, but they don't think they should come.
So Plato had a great point in the Republic where he points out that shoemakers, he uses the example of shoemakers, so you know something, shoemakers are really more sensible than professors, whatever the Greek equivalent for professor was at that time.
And he seems to be quite right after all.
But the intellectuals at the university today are very sinister people.
When the troubles began a few years ago, nothing was more common than to suddenly meet academics who came out of the wall somewhere saying, after the revolution, you're going to be up against the wall.
Or after the revolution, you're not going to talk this way.
And I was just really astounded to see that, finally, all the other issues were kind of, they just weren't big.
They weren't invidious issues.
They didn't care about academic freedom.
They didn't care about the curriculum on campus.
They didn't care about .
I'll go over to my bench fan and bring the book that's on the top.
It's Wells.
It's called Wells, you know.
And then I'll go over in the library in the city and you'll see a book by Kirk, K-R-K, small book.
Just on there you bring in a book by Wells.
Wells, very new book.
He's done a piece in there, isn't he?
He's done a little series.
In fact, I wrote a book, and every author likes to, I suppose, say something about himself to the president.
I only did so on a very narrow basis.
But in this book, I looked over the Berkeley revolution, for example.
And I'm pointing out that the year before this, before it happened,
These people on the intellectual left had been arguing that we should take over the universities as a base of power.
So when all the movements happened on the university campus, the claim was made that it happened because of Camp Bolivia, because of Kent State, because girls weren't allowed in dorms after 10 o'clock.
But there are literally papers in existence, which I've identified, quote, from a catalog, and I would show that in spite of many issues.
They want a university in Indiana.
There's a suitable staging area.
Well, they want to start out with the universities, which are very vulnerable places, and feel that over a generation or two, they can educate the American public through succeeding classes of graduates to come around to their viewpoint.
Which is?
Not reform the country, but to tear it down.
The way they plan on doing it is through this social structure.
They tear down all the existing institutions.
The institutions are bad.
The family, the relationship between the woman, the generations.
Yes, especially the community.
Through new relationships.
Exactly.
Through new relationships.
They'll tear down the corporation by so-called... And they replace it with what?
Replace it with...
Well, everything from huddling and bundling.
You see, the difference is that where I have much greater respect for artists is that, basically, I have that respect for artists.
from what I have seen of all the university radicals, they want to carry on everything.
But none of them thought through what they would replace it with.
Whereas our Marxist friends, whatever we say, they got a plan.
They want to carry it out, and they're going to replace it with something else.
And what they want to replace it with is terrible.
They want to go hidden.
But it's much better to want to replace it with something than with nothing, because certainly,
something that is organized is that I'm sure university people will not agree with that.
They think a chaotic, anarchic situation is better than one that should have good leadership.
I think that's absolutely the point.
So they would agree if they disagree with their Marxist view.
Yes, they would.
Let me say one thing that's not about education.
This is not the issue in this case.
This is not the issue.
I don't know.
But needless to say, we have very great differences as a people versus philosophies and all the rest.
It's interesting to note that they read both Chinese and Japanese history and traditions and so forth.
And particularly the Chinese and Americans, we have a common word,
both peoples, as people, are totally dedicated to the idea of education.
The Chinese, the Chinese in, this goes way back past Confucius,
The parents were star in learning the kid education and stuff.
And we in this country, you know, the mama out in a little miserable town in Texas to save up money to have the kid take piano lessons, soccer stages, or any of that sort of thing.
And I got the kids kind of learning to play the piano.
or to send them off to college.
Some guy that's earned $30,000 with a bricklayer says, well, my son ain't got a leg correction.
I'm going to see that he goes to the University of Northwestern so he can earn $20,000 as an assistant instructor.
We are that way.
It's an interesting thing about the passion for education that runs through this country.
Because I think it motivates a lot of our Negro friends
Yes, they're a real concern.
At the present time, there's a terrible problem with busing in this authoritarian country.
But they don't want those rights implemented at the cost of inferior education for their child, if it's inferior education.
Because they want that black child.
And it's a great opportunity to set up a child, preferably in an integrated school, but it's not possible in this area.
You can see why.
They see that's where people get places.
I'm not sure they're right.
I'm not sure they're right.
I see what a plumber does.
Why the hell is a plumber a good educator?
Depends what you want him to like.
I think even the plumbers, even plumbers, have this kind of sympathy for their education because of the second thing I mentioned before.
In fact, there's a good in itself.
Right.
Like virtue.
It's just like .
Like virtue.
Let's see if I can find this description.
Of course, one of the interesting things is this idea is associated very particularly with American culture.
You don't have in Europe, for example, this passion for education.
Not the British.
We don't understand the British.
We always talk about the British and the British attitude toward education.
It's a leading business.
Exactly.
And let's look at our Russian friends.
The final important reason why education is valued by our mid-class, which is that it leads right into the heart of the American idea.
It is not about education, in other words.
It's about the American concept of what man is.
What a road he has traveled.
Here's Carlisle on the run.
What a road he has traveled.
It sits now about half past seven o'clock, stooling in Slippervan, starving, ill of revolution fever, excessively sick and worn, poor man.
Precisely eleven pence have many ready, many paper in Slippervan.
strong, free-looking stool, gray, and violent, a squalid, washing woman for his sole household.
That is a civic establishment, medical school street, dither and not elsewhere, as if you were a medic, heart-grabbing, abusing the woman's voice, abusing Peter Jenkins as a citizen.
who would be friends of service, were not recognizing her when they arrived.
And Minner, a young hero, offered to give him some necessary information about the counter-revolution in Japan.
And as he was occupying the meeting, he noted the fact that she stabbed him with a large
It's good, right?
Yeah.
Do you know, sir, there's a famous painting?
Have you seen this painting?
No, I haven't seen these things.
I'll try and get a copy of it sent over.
It's quite amazing.
It's almost like a biblical subject.
You said there were some good books in the last... Give me a list of the 10 best.
Historic history.
Oh, and Revolution.
What?
Well, no, I...
Well, the British revolution this, or any of that sort, revolution so forth, but more where it's about men rather than about that, excuse me, I'm more interested in the men than I am in some of the, well, yeah, what makes revolutions do.
I guess it's very interesting.
Now, let's see, there's a very beautiful kind of story here.
Then Tom, he said, no weakness.
The grotesque thing, he really didn't care, was that he was undoubtedly honest, far more honest than any of the Voodoo men who succeeded.
They say he was inspired by a consuming passion for water and human life.
Here's where he differed from them.
He did have some ideas, what he wanted to face with them.
As far as he could contrive of the Committee of Public Safety and the Emergency Government Control, which now has decided to imagine a construction scale, we should start to construct this through panels all over the country.
The problem should be constructed today.
We're backed by certain general solutions.
Temperature can equalize property.
And Bob, now you know.
He talks about his panel disorder and so forth, but maybe they have a reason to all be crazy.
You know what I mean?
If you could say...
That's terrible.
Then he goes on, in Britain and America, all the territories in France, far more people were slaughtered for offenses, very odd, quite trivial offenses, against property that were condemned by the revolutionary tribunal for treason against the state.
Of course, they were very common people indeed, but in a rough way, they suffered.
Now that's miserable, too.
Man, stop it.
For treason against the state, this is good.
He's at the worst of both possible worlds.
A lot of people were killed when he says they weren't important enough to worry about.
One of the interesting things, Mr. President, about the men who led the revolution, have you noticed they didn't have dangerous appetites?
They're puritanical, very confined.
And in a way, that's one of the things that, as we've been repeating this story, they're puritanical.
Yes.
They don't really have large appetites for golden epaulettes, for wine, women, and song.
They're very restrained individuals.
Their real appetite isn't material.
And so you tend to pass over their importance.
In a way, it seems to me it's very much like the intellectual sense of the French Revolution.
The academic intellectual is the man who doesn't have wild material ambitions.
True.
That's why they say materialism doesn't matter.
Yes.
And of course part of their attack on the environment is about materialism.
I mean, although there's legitimate issues, a lot of them attack the whole thing about the hell the monster builds and all this and the other things.
They're very oblivious of the material world that the rest of us have to live in.
and I was waiting for this.
When a man is both a professor and an intellectual, he just rolls.
When he's a professor and an intellectual and an ideologist, roll into one, he is unbearable.
Wow, I can't get that taste record for this guy.
Yeah, I got some today.
Talk to them anytime.
All of us.
Well, there's always a chance to look at the index.
Most indexes aren't worth a damn, though.
I'm sure people who like the book, it's finished.
It's been very .
Well, anyway, I think you'll have an interesting time.
I hope you'll have an interesting time.
Maybe spare the animals a little.
Well, I hope so.
Give me some recommendations.
I will promise to read the books.
I might look at them.
I might look at the movies.
I did want to add one thing, sir.
Speaking of intellectuals, thank God they aren't old bad.
A number of them can't stand up.
terms, I think, with the realities in American culture, which is to say, with your administration, and on a very, very minor scale, like my 10-hour effective humanities.
And we're getting awfully good at living with people who are coming in as panelists, consultants, leaders of our council.
I think you're familiar with the name of Sidney Hook.
He's a person.
back in our generation.
Yeah, he's quite a follow-up.
Now, we're strengthening this organization by bringing these teams, and some of us, and some of us at the National Council.
So, I just wouldn't like that.
Well, also, if they can all feel that they don't have to be, they don't have to be, we don't need to listen to, I don't know, the parties and shit for the rest, and that they can get the war out of them.
I mean, they're all talking about the war.
I mean, everybody all, intellectually, sort of, but because they don't understand,
but be that as it may, get some of these things up and maybe they can concentrate on them.
Yes, things are looking good.
There's no question.
I think they are very much conscious now of reality in New York, and how hard it is to do something, and how good it is that we have done something, considering the difficulty I've been approached by.
A great many moderate people want to work with me.
Really?
Good.
By the way, incidentally, nothing but kind things to say to your own administration.
That's beginning to develop in some interesting ways.
He can't go home again.
Because if he does, we're entering finances.
So we've got two people in Harvard who will speak to him.
I spoke to Pat the other day.
He sounded pretty cheerful.
And he's tough.
He's always tough.
He's very tough.
He's great.
I was surprised that Ron was in San Diego and the whole student .
Yes, sir.
It's the same place we're from.
San Diego City?
No, the University of California in San Diego.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
That's right.
Yeah, yes.
If any of these states are really going for producing elections, it is.
Yes, and they're very politicized, too.
I've been here a couple of years before coming here.
This is vacation.
You had a what kind of year?
Pretty colorful, a few years before coming here.
You know, I've heard the president talk about the fact that student and promotion would exist without reference to the war in Vietnam.
And I had, on this recent trip to Germany, in Berlin, what I was seeing was the transpiring of a free university in Berlin.
I mean, the whole German educational system is in an uproar.
He's tearing himself apart.
What's the reason for that?
Well, in Berlin in particular, I think it's because of the nature of Berlin.
They have a lot of fellows who
avoiding conscription, going to Berlin.
The Russians from East Berlin are able to benefit.
The money can get over to the other side.
And they built into the law a system of participatory involvement of the students and the assistance to the professors who were students, so that the voters waited on the side of the...
You mean it's hitting them just a little later than us.
And with the same kind of ferocity.
And because there's not an inherent kind of stabilizing influence in their life, as there is, I think, in Larry's life.
Because it has a schizophrenic problem anyway.
Sure.
Poor damn Germans.
Torn between guilt and ambition.
The other thing is that I wonder what's going to happen to Japan, because it's the same thing that happened there too.
You look at the Japanese, and the actual Chinese trying to say, we just got out of the Pacific and the rest of the world is fine.
The most unreal approach toward a policy is to say that Japan will be neutral and unarmed.
Huh.
And if Japan doesn't have the internet security guarantee, Japan either is going to be armed or it's going to be able to go to so-and-so because no people who are
with all their potential, with all their background, with all their frustration, and they've gone through it, and all their pride and their arrogance are damn well going to sit there and be a great big economic giant a little bit.
So I hope to see some problems there always.
We do have more stability.
We can survive a lot of, you know, very few folks.
We're at the bank in Santa Barbara and the rest of them.
But they can't.
Isn't that the difference?
I think so.
Yeah.
The German plane is a real problem.
So it sounds to me as if we, in my little outfit order, invest some money in Japanese studies.
We've been debating how to do that.
I think we're going to be able to do that.
It would be very interesting.
Very interesting.
Well, anyway, don't let him lead you straight.
He's also a little liberal.
But he's not too liberal.
If he's not a liberal, he doesn't seem to get us out.
That's a lawyer.
The trouble with the lawyers, they never see anything straight.
They always see two sides.
They leave it to me to make up.
Make up to the Nazis being the lawyers and the Nazis being the liberals.
I don't know quite why.
All right.
Goodbye.
  • 021-050 11:16 AM · 4 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Croby S. Noyes talked on the telephone from 11:16 am to 11:21 am.
  • 021-051 11:21 AM · 7 sec — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 11:21 am and 3:50 pm.
  • 021-052 11:21 AM · 2 min — H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman and Constance M. Stuart talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 11:21 am and 3:50 pm.
  • 021-053 11:21 AM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 11:21 am and 3:50 pm.
  • 683-005 12:02 PM · 1 min — Stephen B. Bull, Alexander P. Butterfield, and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 12:02 pm and 12:05 pm.
  • 683-006 12:02 PM · 12 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Stephen B. Bull, unknown person(s), Marina von Neumann Whitman, Dr. Robert Whitman, Malcolm Whitman, Laura Whitman, Josephine Pierce, Herbert Stein, Ezra Solomon, George P. Shultz, William L. Safire, Barbara H. Franklin, Paul McArdle, and White House photographer met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 12:02 pm and 12:17 pm.
  • 683-008 1:07 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:07 pm and 1:10 pm.
  • 683-009 1:10 PM · 51 min — President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, unknown person(s), Clark MacGregor, and Manolo Sanchez met in the Oval Office of the White House from 1:10 pm to 2:02 pm.

Conversation 683-007, March 13, 1972. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/683-007 (accessed November 17, 2026).