Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 884 › Conversation 884-017

Nixon, Haldeman & Dean on Leadership quality and Watergate investigation

Tuesday, March 20, 1973 · 1:00 PM–2:31 PM ET · Oval Office · 1 hr 24 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob"); Dean, John W., III; Moore, Richard A.Conversation884-017 on Tape 884StartTuesday, March 20, 1973 at 1:00 PMEndTuesday, March 20, 1973 at 2:31 PMRecording deviceOval OfficeSourceNixon Library record for 884-017 ↗

President Nixon, H.R. Haldeman, John Dean, and Richard Moore discussed the President's schedule, including upcoming meetings with Congress and the Cabinet, and the declining quality of leadership in the US. A significant portion of the conversation focused on the Watergate investigation, with Dean providing an update on the administration's strategy for responding to Senate inquiries and potential media narratives. They debated the best approach to handling the ongoing investigations, including the possibility of a counterattack and the timing of releasing information.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 3.3 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 25.8 MB

On March 20, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, John W. Dean, III, and Richard A. Moore met in the Oval Office of the White House from 1:00 pm to 2:31 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 884-017 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 884-17

Date: March 22, 1973
Time: 1:00 pm - 2:31 pm
Location: Oval Office

The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.

      President’s schedule
            -White House Counselors meeting
                  -Discussion of programs
                       -Value
                  -Vetoes
                       -Vocational rehabilitation bill
                             -Justification
                  -Clean Air Act
                       -Second term goals
                  -Cabinet meeting
            -Congressional leaders meetings
                  -Value
                       -Gerald R. Ford
                       -Hugh Scott
                  -Purpose
                  -Changes over last 20 years
                       -Leader class in US
                             -Decline
                             -Helplessness
                             -Attitudes
                                    -Effects
                                          -Cabinets
                                          -Staff
                                          -Congress
                                          -Business community
                                          -31-

            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                        Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

                                    -John B. Connally
                        -Loss of character
                              -1960s
      -Meetings with Congress members
           -Value
           -Welfare
Show the rest of the log (465 more lines)
           -Dependence
           -Donald H. Rumsfeld
           -Cabinet
           -Minimum of effort
           -Harry S. Truman's approach
           -Issues for discussion
                 -Freshmen Congress members

Leader class in US
     -Business community
     -Cabinet officers, White House staff
     -Academics
     -Administration's efforts
            -Creation of weakness
     -Destruction of character
     -John Conlan
            -Example of leadership
                  -President's career
     -George P. Shultz's meetings with President
            -John D. Ehrlichman
            -Union of Soviet Socialist [USSR] Trade
                  -Henry A. Kissinger
                  -Frederick B. Dent
                  -Dealings with USSR
                  -Dent
                        -Control

Shultz’s responsibilities
      -International monetary situation
      -USSR trade agreement
      -Energy policy
            -William E. Simon
                                         -32-

            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

           -Treasury Department
           -Charles J. DiBona
           -Ehrlichman
      -Labor-Management Advisory Board
           -Report

President's schedule
      -Trip to California
             -Departure
      -Congressional relations
      -Cabinet meeting

Watergate
     -Amount of time
     -Ronald L. Ziegler
          -Handling of press

Press relations
      -Garnet D. (Jack) Horner
             -Story for administration
                   -Value
                   -Washington Post

President's schedule
      -Meeting with business community
      -Meetings with Congress members
      -Counselors
             -Ehrlichman
      -Cabinet meetings
             -Value
             -Subjects for discussion
             -Alternatives
             -Present Cabinet
                   -Make-up
                         -John A. Volpe, George W. Romney

Spiro T. Agnew
      -President's opinion
                                     -33-

           NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

     -Role in administration
           -Agnew's perception of role
           -Agnew's opinions
           -Public relations
           -Involvement in decisions
     -Haldeman's relations with Agnew
           -Comparison with Sherman Adams's treatment of President
     -President's tenure as Vice President
           -Haldeman's first meeting
                  -Relations

Congressional relations
     -Ehrlichman's responsibility
     -William E. Timmons's role
     -President's meeting with Hugh Scott and Leslie C. Arends
           -Timmons
           -Ehrlichman
           -Watergate
           -International Telephone and Telegraph [ITT] case
     -Ehrlichman’s role
           -Public relations sense
     -Herbert Stein, Roy L. Ash, Shultz
           -Work on substance
     -Ehrlichman
           -Programming of administration line
           -Public relations work
     -Ash, Shultz
           -Cole
           -Substance
     -Public relations
           -Role of Haldeman and Ehrlichman
           -William J. Baroody
           -Ziegler
           -Ehrlichman
           -Richard A. Moore
                  -Abilities
                  -John W. Dean, III
     -Dwight W. Chapin
                                       -34-

            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

            -Work with White House staff
                   -Moore, Tex McCrary, David N. Parker
      -Patrick J. Buchanan
            -Abilities
            -David R. Gorgen
      -New summaries
            -Preparation
            -Analysis
                   -Difficulty
                   -Republicans
      -Problem areas
            -Watergate
            -Food prices
            -Aid to Vietnam
            -Areas of concentration
                   -Ziegler

President's press conferences
      -President's additions to briefing books
             -Staff work
                   -William L. Safire [?]
      -Preparation
             -Ziegler's performance
             -Ehrlichman’s performance
      -Questions from press

Ehrlichman
      -Role in administration
            -Meetings
                   -High school students
                   -Intellectuals
      -Public relations responsibility
            -Substance
                   -Kenneth R. Cole, Jr.
                   -Ash

President’s schedule
      -Counselors
                                            -35-

                    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                         Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

                  -Cabinet
            -Ehrlichman
            -Cabinet meetings

       White House staff
            -Shultz
                  -Role in administration
            -Public relations issue
            -Administration's budget
                  -Congress’ reaction
                  -Vigorous defense

       Phase II
            -Business community
                  -Wage controls
                  -Complaints
                        -Profit controls
            -Stockpile release
            -Environment and safety restrictions
                  -William D. Ruckelshaus
                  -Oil companies
                        -Bankruptcy
                  -Los Angeles
                  -Herman Kahn
                  -Press-generated paranoia
                  -Sense of decline

Dean entered at 1:42 pm.

       President's meeting with Dean and Moore

       Ehrlichman

Moore entered at 1:42 pm.

       Watergate
            -A report for President
                  -President's approach
                                -36-

      NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

      -Ziegler's comments
            -Problems
      -Samuel J. Ervin, Jr.'s questions
      -Possible questions
            -Donald H. Segretti case
      -White House cooperation with Ervin Committee
      -Jeb Stuart Magruder interview
            -G. Gordon Liddy
            -Committee to Re-elect the President [CRP] intelligence operation
-Ervin Committee questions
      -Dean's answers
            -General answers
            -In response to Magruder
      -Hearsay testimony
      -Possible questions
            -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] investigations of Segretti
            -Dean's meetings with Segretti
                   -Dean's answers
                         -Gordon C. Strachan
                         -Segretti's reasons for contacting Dean
                         -Chapin and Herbert W. Kalmbach involvement
                         -Grand jury testimony
                         -Generalities
      -Number of questions
            -Ervin
      -Possible questions
            -Ziegler's response
                   -Segretti
                   -L. Patrick Gray, III hearings
      -Ervin, Samuel Dash
      -Written interrogatories
            -Administration position
            -Replies
      -Cross examination
-Written interrogatories
      -Strategy of administration
      -Agreement with committee
-Administration defense against Ervin Committee
                               -37-

     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                              Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

     -Story for Rowland Evans and Robert D. Novak or Kevin P. Phillips
     -Barry M. Goldwater
           -Double standard
           -Investigation by FBI of committee members' last campaign
                 -Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
     -Goldwater
     -William J. Baroody
     -Committee members’ vulnerability
           -Campaign contributions
     -Burglars
           -Appeal to court for exemption from hearings
           -Judge John J. Sirica
     -Use of American Civil Liberties Union [ACLU]
           -Committee rules
     -Charges of campaign violations
           -Goldwater speech
                 -Draft
                 -Baroody
     -Leaks to columnists
           -Charges of double standard
     -Investigation of George S. McGovern's campaign
           -Republican investigation
           -FBI investigation
-Democratic National Committee [DNC]
     -Discovery of bug in the phone
           -FBI investigation
-Administration counterattack
     -William H. Sullivan
           -Appearance before Ervin Committee
           -Democratic uses of FBI
                 -Disclosure
           -Gray’s confirmation
-Gray hearings
     -Gray's work with Ehrlichman
     -Richard G. Kleindienst
-FBI
     -Sullivan testimony
           -Cartha D. DeLoach
                              -38-

     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                              Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

            -Closed sessions
            -Political use of FBI
            -Leaks by White House
                   -New investigation of past abuses
                         -Joseph A. Califano
-White House staff testimony
      -Claims of privilege
      -President's concern
            -Precedents
-FBI
      -Use by administration
            -Lyndon B. Johnson
            -False accusations
      -Use by past administrations
            -1968 campaign
            -Telephone surveillance
                   -Spiro T. Agnew
-John N. Mitchell
      -Talk with Dean
      -Testimony in Robert L. Vesco case by grand jury
            -Questions
                   -Range
                   -E. Howard Hunt, Jr. and Segretti
                   -Ehrlichman
                   -Dean
                   -Donald A. Nixon and Edward C. Nixon
                   -Prosecutors
                         -Appointment
      -Vesco
            -Dealings with administration
                   -Value to Vesco
                         -Murray M. Chotiner
                         -George A. Smathers
      -Reaction to grand jury
      -Questions
            -ITT case
                   -Securities and Exchange Commission [SEC] documents
                         -Harley O. Staggers
                               -39-

      NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                               Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

                         - Justice Department
                                -Senate Judiciary Committee
                                     -Possibility of perjury by Kleindienst
                         -Jack N. Anderson leak
                         -Release of documents
                   -Antitrust problems
            -Senators' problems
            -Contacts with Agnew by Harold S. Geneen and Edward J. Gerrity, Jr.
                   -Peter G. Peterson, John B. Connally
                   -ITT officials
                         -Divestiture of company
-Vesco case
      -Comparison with ITT case
      -Contribution to 1972 campaign
            -Returned to Vesco
      -Democratic exploitation
            -Political uses of case
-Ervin hearings
      -Media coverage
      -Questions for administration
            -Written interrogatories for Dean
      -Executive privilege
            -Edward J. Gurney
                   -Today Show
                   -Debate of John V. Tunney
                         -Dean's assessment
                   -Defense of administration
                         -Risks
-Strategy
      -Next step for administration
      -Questions for administration
            -Ziegler's response
            -Potential headlines
                   -Dean involvement with Segretti
                   -Kalmbach
            -Administration handling
                   -Options
      -Counterattack
                                -40-

      NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                 Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

           -Tone
                   -Sullivan
                         -Testimony on past abuses of FBI
                   -Goldwater
                         -Investigation of Democrats
            -President's view
                   -Sullivan
-Senate hearings
-A report for President
      -Ehrlichman
            -Review
      -Ziegler
            -Review
            -Moore's opinion
-Gray
      -Hearings
      -Segretti
-Dean's report on Segretti
      -Segretti's meetings with Strachan
            -Number of contacts
      -Dean's meeting with Segretti
            -Generalities
      -Dean's knowledge of activities
            -Part of investigation
            -Knowledge of illegalities
                   -Questioning
                   -Statements for press
      -Conclusions
            -White House involvement
            -Generalities
            -Dean's involvement
                   -Purpose
-A report for President
      -Ehrlichman's review
      -Revisions
      -Ziegler's review
      -Possible release
      -Review by senators
                                           -41-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 884-17 (cont’d)

                        -Charles McC. Mathias
                        -Committee chairman
                        -Howard H. Baker, Jr.
            -Ervin hearings
                  -Gurney
                  -Support for administration
                        -ITT
                  -Presidential involvement
            -Vesco case
                  -Gurney
                  -Grand jury hearing
                        -Prosecutors
                              -Left-wingers
                              -Jews
            -Need for counterattack
            -Sullivan
                  -Testimony on Democratic illegalities
                        -Impact of FBI, Johnson, J. Edgar Hoover
                              -Embarrassment
                              -Need to be careful
            -A report for President
                  -Ehrlichman's review
                  -James O. Eastland's review
            -Strategy for counterattack
                  -Vesco
                  -FBI revelations
                        -Sullivan
                        -Use by Democrats
                  -FBI investigation of Congressmen

Dean and Moore left at 2:31 pm.

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 2 parts and the right one starts.

NixonI'm taking notes, what are you doing?
Haldeman[unintelligible] that counselor's meeting in general so far [unintelligible]
NixonI guess I guess really you have to sit down and talk to the people about the programs, don't you? So at first
HaldemanThat's why I doubt whether [unintelligible]
NixonHow would you veto a vocational rehabilitation bill? Uh, so,
NixonWe sure had a clean air act. What a [unintelligible]
HaldemanI think what you got to chalk it up to, this is this is not [unintelligible] so much for what it accomplishes as it is the mere fact that you know, [unintelligible] you've taken this on faith. At least this is sort of human nature.
HaldemanIt does them good, and they are the people who you're trying to get, you know, mileage out of with other people. And it's a matter of going back to the fountain, getting some of the water. Sure. Fine. And it may not be worth keeping on doing, but I think the question is
NixonThe wonder is whether it's, frankly, worth doing in terms of the full cabinet, you know? Do it. More and more, I think they are like these leaders' meetings are useless, I mean, wasting that stuff on Ford and Hugh Scott. Christ, they'll just get in there, and the whole wild crowd and Jackasses around this damned thing.
NixonIt means a big thing to them to be in there. Am I not correct?
HaldemanI, you know, I haven't started going to leaders' meetings for a while because I have changed, and I haven't been in-- I've never been to one.
NixonScott would complain if you didn't have every, Oh, I know, I mean it's,
HaldemanI don't think I mean I don't think you can have a leaders' meeting for basically they're there, it's almost essential though so that the, your, your own troops figure that they that the White House has their back up. I think part of the problem we have here
Haldemanwith the, with the Carsons and the Taylors, like what I said about the businessmen. The reason why it's changed so much since the time I remember is that is that the whole leader class has changed. And they are just hell. We weren't green in those days.
HaldemanI'm not trying to step up to things and not trying to help the man. I'm not coming saying please cheer me up, please what are you going to do for me and so forth. But they come in in a helpless, weak, and that's that's virtually true of with almost no exception.
HaldemanThat it's an attitudinal thing which affects your cabinet. It affects, not all of them. There are exceptions. But it affects your staff. It affects the Congress, the business community in spades. I think that's what, now and then you run to a Connally. Now and then you run to a real tough son of a bitch who wants to do something. But, mostly,
Haldemanthey're all infected by this virus of the 1960s where people, frankly, lost their goddamned character. They just don't have it anymore. They don't have it.
NixonHow are you going to get around that? Well, I don't know how you are, I mean, I think we're, I think we're in a position to be appearing to something to be catering to something that is useless.
NixonIt's like welfare. You don't help the welfare people by giving them more welfare. You make them more dependent. Now, these people, I wonder if maybe you don't make them more dependent by catering, servicing having the man holler at them. I understand. I feel like that I have every right to do nothing about that kind of work.
NixonWell, I have the feeling that maybe on this, Rumsfeld is correct. That maybe it doesn't work at all.
HaldemanThat's I would agree with that to the point where, oh, so that it doesn't work with you to do that. But you still have to do it, uh, you have to do the basics of it so that there isn't validity to the charge that that you haven't done it. But then doing it, you got to not kid yourself into thinking that doing more is going to do more good.
HaldemanOh, it's just this is a ritual they have to do, that you have to do. Oh, absolutely. That you you just got to, I think every Congressman and his wife [unintelligible] to the White House to be entertained and washed in there, the sooner they come, the better, so they can say that they did.
Haldemanuh had the old way of doing it and that's you you see Truman, how Truman did it. Maybe he was absolutely right. So, he knew he knew it wouldn't do any good.
HaldemanAnd all, but he knew also it was essential.
NixonIt's a whole part. That's right.
HaldemanIt was cold-bloodedly he stood there and he said, "Okay, file by, shake my hand, get your ass out of here, don't bother me anymore."
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanPress out. Time with the Congress. We've gone, seen the leader-
NixonThe problem is, in the second term, more than anything else we've got to spend our valuable time. I don't think they're helping the country.
HaldemanI don't I don't know, I think you're right about that, and you may be right. Now, I'm hard to believe that this that this thing, if you don't see them, you don't talk-
NixonWell, you don't see them. You see, when I'm talking to them, they know to get the freshmen all in here and talk to them, well, that's not the way to do it. It helps a little, I know, because you can go on the issues, but,
Nixonlike when I went down to the White House, we'd sit down three or four questions.
HaldemanNo, the president doesn't sit and have I think, not there at the time.
NixonThat one.
NixonNo, I don't know. I am well, what I understand I have a I am referring to much broader subject. I relate it to the business community. I relate it to the
HaldemanYou relate it to the cabinet.
NixonI relate it to the basically sad people, John. To the academic community.
NixonOh, yeah. Nobody has I can't run the will, but I'm just saying the whole care and feeding of people and and,
Nixonmaybe that our our attempts to take care of people,
Nixoninsure me,
Nixonmaybe, that we create weaker and weaker
Nixoncharacter, and that,
Nixonby leaving them alone, they would develop more strength themselves. Probably not. Probably not.
NixonIt's hard to argue that the care of the people has pretty goddamned well destroyed,
Nixonthe leadership, the leader class in this country. It's true.
HaldemanIt's too bad they ruined it.
HaldemanDo you hear that, hey? Connally is a is a
Haldemanproblem though he may be, is an example of the opposite. He's fight for position. He wants to get out front.
HaldemanHe wants to move in and it's it's sneered at. They say, "Ambition." Well, maybe it is.
HaldemanRichard Nixon was ambitious, obnoxious, 25 years ago, too, maybe to some people when they were looking at, and he was moving ahead on something. But it did some good.
NixonThe other thing is they're afraid of ambition. They want to set up in front of the crowd.
NixonIt's just too-
NixonSir Mike, John Connally is smarter than that.
NixonAnd Shultz
Nixondid make me upset. What did he do with uh George Shultz, who, of course, is uh the problem, we can't let it through.
NixonAll right, and then that and that one thing, you know, John's talking to me. I had ordered John's order, and you had too many balls in the air. Shultz Shultz took a fling at Shultz's soul,
Nixonfor him to stand up to know that
Nixonhe's backing the leader because Shultz's around so many and it doesn't make that much difference. Bob,
Nixonand we can't hang with that sort of thing again. So I wanted him to do that, and he will have done as well, but it didn't make any Well, they didn't
HaldemanHe would've done exactly what Henry told him, and that's all you're interested in.
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanIn fact, I would argue that Dent would have been better than Shultz.
NixonI would too.
HaldemanBecause he wouldn't think. He he'd do what he was told, and he wouldn't know. He'd be afraid to go beyond, and that's sure.
NixonYeah. Shultz wants to do. But anyway, he got down there. Dent's
Haldemantotally controllable, totally-
HaldemanNo, he's got no clout with them. There are no real big pluses, but he's not screwed. He's presentable. He's honest. He'll do what he's told.
HaldemanHe's a nice guy.
NixonThat's fine. So, oh, we go with uh
NixonGeorge Shultz? Okay.
NixonI'm tired of some of this.
HaldemanShultz.
NixonWell, which one's uh
HaldemanWell, you're actually monetarily, they found out they can't belong to that big [unintelligible]
NixonThere isn't much to do there at the moment. Yes.
NixonThe problem is solved, you know. They got a temporary solution. They'll wallow around for a while.
HaldemanCan't you pull him out of Soviet energy? It's too late now. He's sure he can.
NixonHell, yeah. Why not take it?
HaldemanYes, I would.
HaldemanHe sure as hell can be pulled out of energy. There's absolutely no reason for him to even know that there is energy.
Nixonmy thought is we'd get George in before the Labor-Management Board, get a report from him. And have a think for a couple 3 days. And see after I do whatever I do with my statement.
NixonOur California plan is now to leave on Friday. It's a two-day plan: Friday, Saturday. We go Friday morning.
NixonYeah. Friday, 1:00.
NixonWe'll have this time to carry me through.
NixonYou know, in the other cases, go around and around and around like this.
NixonHow about Ehrlichman's pattern, Bob?
HaldemanIt always comes around the whole circle on all these things. At first you want to do too much, why, why not? And then let's go on, let's slightly aggressive on the other. You decide that that doesn't do any good, it isn't exciting, right, but that it doesn't do any good, so let's move.
HaldemanAnd then the true blues will do something, and you don't have that feeling. Some facts you can press and press and press on the other end.
HaldemanYou know, we found, when we did try the opposite, we didn't get very much. Just didn't work.
NixonIt didn't work at all. Uh, with a few rare exceptions, then Humphrey's thing did work, but a Humphrey, you know, they reacted the other way, favored favored it.
HaldemanWell, yeah, but it both- Yeah, it didn't work as much. Well, no, it did, it still helped build them up. But it built them up,
Haldemanand it got a story that we wanted to get across, across. And, and, and we used it
Haldemanas an instrument to build, but it's better to host it than start a fight from both. Anyway,
Haldemangetting back to this thing, I guess we've got to do some analysis of, uh, where we are and tense, and really get some total rolling and thinking about scheduling and where-
NixonI know that, I'm at the end with this, with this troop. Just [unintelligible]
NixonI think they can't take it now, but what what we come up with, do you agree? I have some thoughts.
HaldemanYeah. Why do you get into this conflict?
NixonCongress something a lot, maybe, maybe not the Congress,
Nixonmy view of the 24th was we had, had everybody in. See my point? I got them. The council idea is a good idea, I think. I'm not sure what the whole Cabinet should sit around here and gas about these things.
HaldemanWell, aren't not anyone of those subjects. I concurred with these people, but the whole Cabinet sitting here, that's what I mean.
HaldemanDo you have that much time to bring the Cabinet in?
NixonHey, here's, you got, it is for the Cabinet to decide which is good.
NixonProper answer for the Cabinet to bring them all in, say, "Well, we'd like to talk a little today about-"
HaldemanWell, those, those subjects you're, you listen, the whole subjects that are on, those subjects that are on the agenda today, that he's got on there, the whole Cabinet we got here. I mean, we'll do a half an hour on the Continental Shelf.
HaldemanAnd another thing, sort of come out of this meeting when he stalled today, and we could come out of the cabinet meeting with Mike [unintelligible]
HaldemanSo, you see what I have. We, we sort of come full circle on that. The idea rather than having scheduled, someone actually has to- What's happening is
Haldemanwhen we have nothing to discuss, we frankly discuss it with everybody. See?
NixonYou're correct. You don't really mean that that that everybody. You had to fight with the leaders [unintelligible]
HaldemanWell, you had a better chance to do that with the candidate riding the horse. You don't have Romney in. You don't have guys going off on their own. It's still gonna fight better, which is a problem.
NixonYes, that's true. God, that's true.
NixonOh.
NixonHe really didn't, did he?
NixonI think that [unintelligible]
NixonGod, damn, it's strong. I don't know.
NixonThat brings us up to [unintelligible]
HaldemanWell, that's misconception his role, which is instead, we tried to, he thinks he's got to be a part of the decision-making apparatus to help you avoid the errors of your ways, rather than thinking that he's got to be a part of the dissemination
Haldemanapparatus. And we don't think-
HaldemanWhat he needs to be told, and it won't do any good now, I don't think, anyway, is that nobody gives a shit what his opinion is,
Haldemanthat all they want is for him to get off his ass and sell whatever someone else has decided, and more the people more able than he are making the decisions. All people who have the responsibility are making- Vice Presidents do not make decisions.
HaldemanThey support the decisions of the President. Period.
HaldemanNot only do Vice Presidents not make decisions, Vice Presidents don't participate in decisions.
HaldemanThat's the problem we have, that is that he's been led to believe by your kindness and, and the the cow towing that we've done to him because we, in spite of all the shit that we get about the arrogant,
Haldemandomineering White House staff, you know, we over go that goddamn it. I run over to that guy's office. I sit on the phone
Haldemanwaiting for 10 minutes, you know, to for him to come on and, and I call him Mr. Vice President and I, I stand when he approaches the vicinity and, and, you know, go through all this crap, now.
HaldemanHell,
Haldemanyou know, Sherman Adams didn't treat you that way. Uh-huh.
NixonHe was all right.
HaldemanWell, on a formal basis, yeah, but, oh, he never, he never- He called you Dick. Called you Dick, right. Sure. He called you up and said, "I need to talk to you," and you said, "Fine, I'll be down at 3:00."
NixonThat's right. And you came.
HaldemanCan you picture the reverse?
NixonNo.
HaldemanIn fact, I, as expecting it, but I'm not so sure we're right, and, and that we wouldn't pull ahead. Well that, I can mean, it's a little ludicrous here.
HaldemanIn '56 was 17 years ago.
HaldemanJesus, 17 years ago, now.
Haldeman17 years ago, so, I was 29 years old when I first met you and was working in the campaign, you were Vice President of the United States.
HaldemanAs a young kid and I called you Dick, not Mr. Vice President. In private conversation, sure. Public, always, of course, Mr. Vice President.
HaldemanAnd now, here I am, practically the same age as this guy, uh, senior position, though, and I can't call him Ted.
NixonI know.
HaldemanAnd that's a little absurd.
NixonHuh.
HaldemanIt just makes it worse because, it, it, puts him, it puts him in a position he doesn't fall off.
HaldemanI don't mind the raises, cause I think now's a good time for you and Ehrlichman to grapple with this thing, and I must say that looking at tenants then maybe the answers is we should give the job to Ehrlichman, we'd have that sorted out. Ehrlichman must realize that, by God,
Haldemanhe's got the responsibility. Well, I think over time I can't, this thing here. He said, "Maybe I didn't get far enough, but
Haldemanthe President should not have called those people into his office after the meeting." He said, "There is a plan set up, and it is set up for them to get the guidance the other way." Now, maybe it doesn't always work as well as it should, but it should not work by them coming in here.
HaldemanAnd, uh,
Haldemannow, that's one thing. Bill is never- If you say, "Come in here," Bill is never gonna say, "No, no." It's because we're taking over that, uh,
Nixonand, where John will, if John had been there, he would have, he would've called me and would've said "Well, we're, we're going to be meeting over here [unintelligible]" But, I suppose that I knew that John would not ask him the questions that I knew they had to have answered. I knew that Watergate is what would be on their mind, and the ITT was. I raised those questions and told them the line. You understand?
NixonYeah, that's kind of the thing that I think has to be done in the morning so that the guys know there isn't going to be, kind of like, "Well, you get that thing, his, his view of that and that, sir," and I don't much enjoy that, frankly. But, if somebody else doesn't probe that, I've got, it's gotta be done. You can't just sit back. You, you can't expect, and you can't, and John can't delegate this to say "Well, today, Herb Stein will have a program." Herb Stein can't program anybody.
NixonOr today Roy Ash can. Roy Ash can start [unintelligible] or the, George Shultz can't. That won't check. It's basically, this programming, I think it can only be done by Ehrlichman, out of the people that I know around, you know, that he's, who's got enough of a jugular instinct, and also enough of an understanding. But I think what he would have to do would be to sit down in the morning, that's what I mean, every day.
NixonI think what is needed, Bob, is a PR meeting, not a goddamn meeting on the substance of whether or not we want to
HaldemanWell, there's another The group The substantive group meets. The problem is we have this suitors group that was supposed to be Ferd, Herb Stein, and Schultz, Ash, you know, and we're playing this game of the five principles, as the President's Assistants. It's an expulsion too. Expulsion.
NixonUh-huh, and I think we ought to toss Ehrlichman I mean, Ash, Schultz Yep. back to the substantive meeting where they belong. That's right. With Cole. That's right.
NixonAnd let them work on that, and John and I should sit down with the guys who've gotta get the action and headlines across, and go at it. We need John there because we need, I can't do that. Well, we've got to hammer it down.
HaldemanQuite frankly, I think you're, I think your whole start on it's sees it, that's right. The problem is, you need John, and you've got to be there, though, You know, you can look at all our part in it, it doesn't do it. Yeah, I know. I had no idea, that's who you needed.
NixonI don't know whether, I mean, I hope Rumsfeld is as good as everybody else thinks he is. And he may be, but I, you've got to say that John and I, that's funny.
HaldemanMaybe Moore.
NixonHuh?
HaldemanMaybe Moore, bring Moore, Moore's especially, bring Moore in here, yeah, Moore and Baroody, they can fall off, and that's sessions. Right.
NixonWell, I look around. I mean, If you gotta have a fast-moving group, you got to haul this group in here, and having through your having Macs, that's right, and Moore, I don't know about fast-moving.
HaldemanNo, I found like Tarton, then Buchanan's an idea. I am shying, because he He's damn good, but he's, but he's He's you've got to deal with him in a different way.
HaldemanAnd that's really cool, right? You, That's one of, this is where we miss Chotiner. Chotiner was awfully good at getting the stuff out of the people like the Moores and the Tex McCrackens. Pushed, you know, where you'd be just waste a hell of a lot of time. He'd talk to
NixonOh, yeah. Can Baroody do it, who's
HaldemanYeah, Baroody can't, and he's, he'll, he's learning. He isn't as good, but partly because he hasn't, you know, tried. He's trying, been through the battles. He knew of her kind of deal.
NixonMacGregor, somebody like that. MacGregor can't be helped, can he? Buchanan can do that, certainly. Yeah, Mac's just Buchanan's pretty heavy. He's, Buchanan, absolutely. And, I think Gergen and all that bunch over there, somebody once got to squirt a little, that, I mean, they're neat.
NixonThey're maybe too good for us. We happen to have any that are cutthroat, Bob. Yeah.
HaldemanYou need a PR group.
NixonLook. You know the easiest thing to do? It will be the easiest, I mean, although it takes a lot of work. The easiest thing to do, is to write the damn summary, and give it to Ziegler to read, as to what the problem areas are, sure. That's the easiest thing. Every, everybody loves to do it.
NixonThe hardest thing, is the reasoned summary to say what are these [unintelligible] What the hell are we going to do on our side? That's why usually Republicans lose elections. Now the point is, look the fact is that here, we've got a situation where, as I see it, Ziegler comes in, and PRs, and, and, and, follow
Nixonall day long, 90% of the time, just beating the offies away. Now really, Ron, damn it, but then, Watergate problems are here, and they're going to be terribly, aren't they? We're going to have this problem, you mean, made the shield, maybe this thing is going to be the blue prize, you know, you've got to watch out about aiding Vietnam, and you've got to work on the price Everybody knows Everybody knows all this.
NixonThe point is what, what should be concentrated on? What should we concentrate on? And you see, Ziegler has to spend all his time frankly, when I prepare for a press conference, I usually prepare it myself, reading to answer the provocative questions, and I thought I didn't care to go into details, but what I had to that reading book, and what I had to teach press conferences, doesn't come out of that book.
NixonIt should. But what I had, it's my own feeling. That's why a line or two, maybe a phrase, or maybe a, a direction, which they all suggest. You know, now if you get inside, cancel it. This is a place where we are, this always balls up,
Nixonand his, his lines are useless. I mean they're, uh, Ziegler, so we don't have that positive guy, I guess. We take them, but hell, I can do that, that's my problem. But I'm just thinking that soon,
Nixonwhen he goes up, every day, Ziegler should make one of our points, our points. Herb, when he goes out, should make one of our points. I think John will, but I think that all of you should be thinking in those terms now. Here are all the daily questions they want to ask. The whole damn game really is to keep us on the defensive as commenting on their questions,
Nixonplaying their damn field. Our game is to come out on our questions.
NixonI hate to disrupt a program, but I think John, you see, if he moves around so he gets more of an eyeball, will realize frankly the uselessness of PR. Let me say, fine. The uselessness of seeing high school kids, by and large, and the intellectuals, frankly. Oh, he's got to do a little this because he likes to relax. But the other thing is he's got to see, he's got to see that isn't the proper, good use of his time,
Nixonto spend any time on substance. Get somebody else to spend the time on substance. He and I will do quite as well. Cole, anything he can do on substance, push it down to the others. And, uh, and, frankly, by news, like, that,
Nixonand Cole happens to, can handle a lot of responsibility, and he's just got goddamned good judgment. Yeah. And he'll follow through, will do it damn well. And, uh,
NixonWhich, you could raise with John if you would, the idea of what we have with cabinets and counselors. You know, already you know, he watches in one hand.
NixonNow John's answer will be, "Well, gee, it's it was a good, a good session a couple of weeks ago." Last week, he asked Foster, and they sat around and talked, and everybody enjoyed it, and so forth. Nothing happens. I'm in a ring here. They've got it. It's good just to get people together.
NixonThe question is, whether we can't use that same presidential If I've got, if you get people here in order to stir them up, why not stir up more? Have more of them in for dinner.
NixonI say to John, very bluntly, that we shouldn't bother with cabinet meetings, and so the right, and the rhetoric.
HaldemanOh, we wouldn't bother with Yeah. Yeah, they're trouble.
NixonFrankly, if the idea is so, we might have a cabinet meeting for fun. We may, or we may not, you know what I mean.
NixonThe order is to do the best you can.
NixonIt's just too bad, and John's having the devil of a time.
HaldemanWell let me say this: whether it was me or whoever in our shop, uh, don't don't beat poor masters to death when they say, "Look, you've got a problem." Not John's has got a problem, reach across.
HaldemanWe don't talk to each other enough to say, "Look, you got a problem, what are you gonna do? You got a great opportunity to help me out." That's what that's what was in the bill. We should bring them in, yeah. And, uh, that works pretty well. We've got a there's the automatic reaction within here is is a try to help the other guy out.
NixonIt really is.
NixonIt really is. In the Cabinet's, it's fascinating to watch the the lack of cannibalism in the in the strong.
HaldemanOh, I don't mean they cannibalize each other, they don't give a damn about each other.
HaldemanWhat I'm saying now is when when you can reach across and say, "Hey, you got a serious problem and you're trying to figure it out,"
Nixon"Congress isn't gonna slice your budget, they'll just budget-cut, which you probably don't realize."
HaldemanYeah. Or even deeper. That's the danger is the damn belaboring the obvious, you know, telling somebody something he's so painfully aware of already that that it's That's it, George, then it's how do we
NixonSure it was George? I mean, look at what happened today.
NixonGeorge, you can't imagine, what did I say? And he had forgotten the freeze, something of that sort. And and stuff like true. And we are going to do it that way. We're not going to worry about him, we're very definitive, defended figures. There's no reason to say, well,
Nixonlook, uh, uh,
HaldemanSigns. They make you talk signs. You've gotta watch that, too, and say, well, with all the businessmen saying, "These freezes are hell,"
Nixonwe'll see.
NixonThey have the right answer. But if they certainly went to Phase II,
NixonThe businessman, what they want, now, what they want, but shouldn't we go through a what this is something
HaldemanThey want a chance to, they don't want, by due,
Nixonthat's pretty goddamn cheap. Wait a minute.
Haldemanthey want us to bite the bullet for them. They do not want wage controls.
HaldemanThat's right. They want you to put a flat 5.5 on wages, period, so they don't have to negotiate anymore.
NixonExactly. That's what they're bitching about, they're not bitching about that, oh, that's why the whole shit stream lines separate things. And that's why I'm so loving the whole setup on the other hand. And that's why I'm gonna love the big guy we got lined up coming in tomorrow.
NixonEvery time we can stick that industry or any other for doing it, if it doesn't really hurt the child some, but that's why in the bargain, not proposed to screw this goddamn hog wild on us,
Nixonthose restrictions of
NixonBecause the auto company is gonna go broke.
NixonThey won't go broke, but they're crying all the time.
HaldemanDon't you agree?
HaldemanSure, and both the the farm restrictions and safety restrictions are ridiculous anyway. You put stuff on that doesn't help.
NixonI agree. In the long haul, they're right on the environmental thing. You've gotta eat cars, you know, what they are. You can't let things get what they are in L.A., everywhere.
NixonYou know what it is on safety and so forth?
NixonSafety is bullshit. The whole thing, the auto is it's both the bumpers and the horrible, the horrible, but they shouldn't let goddamn awful bumpers in, either.
NixonMain thing is you put them on the suits and the so it's this
NixonListen to me, we get into the can stuff, and a lot of the stuff is true, and it makes this this paranoia attitude on the part of the media,
Nixonand the intellectuals to say that everything is going to hell, man. I'll be in here for third and fourth. How do you do?
DeanGood afternoon, Mr. President.
DeanSo, John Foster-
HaldemanWhile he was in, I want to bring up What'd you think of [unintelligible] today, John? No, let's sit in here, uh-
DeanWell, listen to what the recently arrived [unintelligible] had to say. He said that he had just had a conversation with-
HaldemanYeah. It's it's all on the ground, why not? I mean, all the and they know where it is, and we don't have to say anything.
NixonOkay. Just leave her in here.
MooreWe have, by now, this would be our, this would go to, here we go, uh,
DeanI mean, as we agreed, uh, as to how we'd deal with doing it, and you've agreed you'd call me down. That's, in fact, what he put down already. He wanted you to read it that's why it took so long to get it off here, to make sure it was what you wanted to do.
DeanI think you should read it. The press people said that you're a quick reader.
HaldemanWell, the point is, what are you going to do with it? Do you want to read it to find out? Or is it a draft, you see? I don't want to read it [crosstalk] to approve it. But, then I want to read, well, what do you feel?
NixonWell, what what what what do you fellows feel?
HaldemanWell, if we don't have, he might suppose to read it to find out what he's going to make a decision. I'm just saying Well,
MooreI don't know, I think if you want to read it with a critical eye of should or should it not be done, and I think that the reason is because we ran a copy by Ziegler about 20 minutes ago and Ron read it and- And it will prompt the answers to this question, that question, that question, that question.
DeanHe said, "Your document right here, while it is responsive as far as we're concerned,
Deanyet it's going to raise as many questions as it answers. And can you answer all those questions?"
DeanOf course, once you answer another set, then it opens up a whole other set of questions.
HaldemanUh, it's what everyone says. Bang, off the shutter.
DeanWhat's his, you know, he said, "Try to answer all them." That's fair.
DeanBut, each one of these does suggest an answer from an urban saying, "This is exactly why we want him here to cross-examine him because I don't I want some more facts about what he says."
NixonI'm still thinking that you read it and you and you and Ziegler think that it's probably bad.
DeanWell, to me, it's one more go-around. We did the best we could under the time limits.
DeanIf we can solve a couple of of of, uh, of the eight paragraphs here, I think there are about three that the troublesome, then we can agree,
DeanI hope, how we should go. For example, uh, there will come this Segretti question that Ron raised.
DeanUm,
Nixonhow the White House how the White House cooperated

— 2 min 51 s with no transcribed speech —

HaldemanWell, just to matter of fact,
Haldemansuch that during the course of the interview, that he when he interviewed Liddy, that they discussed Liddy uh establishing an intelligence gathering operation for the reelection committee.
HaldemanDid you tell that to Gray?
DeanYes, Gray, I did say that Liddy was being recruited.
DeanIf it were I better I better be highly honest about that, uh,
DeanI should say, sure, I believe Liddy was limited to problems involving campaign law compliance.
HaldemanAnd I and I would say and uh and and and at never at any time were there any instructions that had anything to do with intelligence gathering operations on the part of the committee.
MooreI'd I would say I'd put it in the general statement rather than than your your But you have to deal with what Gray said. rather rather than discuss what you just testified this. I can't recall the conversation. Never did we just just say the general thing. We never had a discussion that had to do with intelligence gathering.
DeanWell, Gray probably did come up. That's the reason uh

— 1 min 21 s with no transcribed speech —

MooreThe more general, you know, Right, understand. [cough] You see what I mean? The more general the better.

— 1 min 43 s with no transcribed speech —

DeanI would suggest on those uh the third, what they call hearsay, you know, that we uh association
DeanI suspect that might be a little bit too far.
DeanMaybe not that clean, but such
Haldemanversus
Haldemanrather than than getting the facts.
NixonHow about the 300?
DeanUh, now, a question ends of the figures uh that have been cited uh say, the 300, and several other questions. Well, take a hypothetical for instance, to be sure uh the ones that I have been alleged to have shown FBI is Dawkins and Segretti.
NixonDid you show them to anybody else?
DeanThat's the question. Uh, they were shown to other counsel. Uh,
DeanThere's three- four other, there are several other questions. Well, take a hypothetical one here, for instance, the one that I, it's been alleged that I showed FBI interviews to Segretti. Did you show them to anybody else?
DeanThat's the extent of it. Now, then they would ask, did I meet with Segretti, also? Yes, I did meet with Segretti. How did I meet with him? He called me.
MooreThat's the question.
DeanThey were shown to other counsel. Who put him in touch with me? Gordon Strachan. Why did Gordon Strachan put him in touch with you? Because Gordon Strachan had been called by him, telling him that he was being interviewed by the FBI, and wanted to know what it was all about. What did you tell Mr. Segretti when you met with him?
DeanI told him that, uh, when he went before the grand jury to tell the truth. He was concerned that he would have to give up the names of Strachan, Chapin, and Kalmbach. I told him that if came to that, he'd have to do that.
MooreIn your own office, or-
DeanThat's the extent of it. Now, then they would ask, did I meet with Segretti, also? Yes, I did meet with Segretti. How did I meet with him? He called me. Who put him in touch with me? Gordon Strachan. Why did Gordon Strachan put him in touch with you? Because Gordon Strachan had been called by him, telling him that he was being interviewed by the FBI, and wanted to know what it was all about. What did you tell Mr. Segretti when you met with him?
DeanI told him that, uh, when he went before the grand jury to tell the truth. He was concerned that he would have to give up the names of Strachan, Chapin, and Kalmbach. I told him that if came to that, he'd have to do that.
MooreI would summarize that in one sentence. I would say, my only my only contact with Segretti was on the- I would some-
Mooreand uh, Segretti, uh He called my office to, in one sentence. I said, my only
DeanAnd, that's-
Moorewith regard to his, Segretti, uh, was on the, uh, with regard to his,
Mooreappearance before the grand jury, and I directed him, and I directed all who made such inquiries to forthrightly report every damn thing that you did to that grand jury, and I directed him, and I directed all
DeanWell, I suppose Ron's theory is that that to do it- and I'm more and more convinced we have to do something along this line, that the, who made such inquiries, to forthrightly report every damn thing you did,
MooreWe have we've said we'd cooperate, we'd explain, the make-up is much better if we do it than waiting for them to hits us over the head and spice it. And and
DeanWell, I suppose Ron's theory is that to do it- and I'm more and more convinced we have to do something along this line, that the, we do it than waiting for them to hits us over the head and spice it.
Moorehow much heat we can take and it's just a matter of how much heat we can take. You'll get They'll say, "Well, Ron, how did-
MooreYou'll get They'll say, "Well, Ron, how did the the, other ways, the Strachan once had contact with Segretti, with the, with the, with the-
Mooreother ways, The Washington Post wrote and said that. How many other times did Mr. Dean ever talk to Segretti?
MooreNow, Ron can say, "I don't know." But, uh, then then you'll have to respond to those, once you answer other times. He'd run,
DeanCan't respond. Yes. Well,
MooreWell, the concern is that Ron has here Ervin will come up with 100 questions as a result of this letter, and he'll say,
Moorehow many other times did Mr. Dean ever talk to Segretti? Now, Ron can say, "I don't know." But, uh,
Moorethen then you'll have to respond to those, once you answer other times. He'd run,
DeanCan't respond. Yes. Well, that's the very reason that we can't operate this way.
MooreAll right. What are the answers to these questions? Bang, bang, bang. Well, the concern is that Ron has here Ervin will come up with 100 questions as a result of this letter, and he'll say,
DeanThat's the very reason that we can't operate this way. All right. What are the answers to these questions? Bang, bang, bang. And then when they ask these, how do I know that, uh, they won't have more questions?
DeanAnd then when they ask these, how do I know that, uh, they won't have more questions?
MooreWell, there aren't too many of those, John, to be-
MooreThere aren't too many of those, John, to be- I bet it'd come up to be eight, all told.
MooreI bet it'd come up to be eight, all told. If we're lucky. Well, and it won't take many to
Deanimpeach the the approach. Right. If we're lucky. Well, and it won't take many to impeach the the approach. Right.
MooreAnd what the press asks uh uh, Ron the Committee will ask the next day, And what the press asks uh uh, Ron the Committee will ask you, will ask you that the next day.
DeanUh-huh.
MooreRon could reply, Ron could reply,
MooreWell, um here maybe here you have to put in saying Ron, "Now, I I am responding to this letter, the questions that have been raised, Well, um
MooreDid I should be glad to furnish any further information if other questions are raised." here maybe here you have to put in saying Ron, "Now, I I am responding to this letter, the questions that have been raised,
DeanOther If other questions are raised, other In other words, you don't even have to Then let them raise them, and respond as well as you can.
MooreWell, it is it's better to respond this way, but then raising the other questions, and we're going to dissuade If other questions are raised, other In other words, you don't even have to Then let them raise them, and respond as well as you can.
Deanthe whole bunch. Well, they seem I want to get Ron going off on the Segretti area. They're getting into areas Well, it is it's better to respond, and get into going off on this Segretti area. They're getting into areas this way,
Mooreof irrelevancy. but then raising the other questions, and we're going to dissuade the whole bunch. Well, they seem
Deanof irrelevancy in the Gray hearing. They seem to have zoomed in on these as the relevant questions.
MooreThat's legal- uh Yeah. of irrelevancy in the Gray hearing. They seem to have zoomed in on these as the relevant questions. That's legal- uh Yeah.
MooreThey'll still ask you questions in the press, you know, Adams of the of the Post, but this comes back to the point of how much we can and this
Mooremight soften, lighten by biting this week, before the end of the week to see how how far we go if you start having that chain of questions about it. Yeah.
DeanAnd, uh, it did. Yeah, it did, yeah, it did. I doubt it, Dick's right, you kind of put yourself in a position, the other side. A smart lawyer, dash,
Deanhurt. Said, "Now, see, ah, how, see what you got." They'll still ask you questions in the press, you know, Adams of the of the Post, but this comes back to the point of how much we can and this
Mooremight soften, lighten by biting this week, before the end of the week to see how how far we go if you start having that chain of questions about it. Yeah.
DeanAnd, uh, it did. Yeah, it did, yeah, it did. I doubt it, Dick's right, you kind of put yourself in a position, the other side. A smart lawyer, dash,
Deanhurt. Said, "Now, see, ah, how, see what you got." Ah, they didn't answer that. Oh, they didn't answer that. That's not the answer. That's just a response.
MooreSo, we need an issue. Now, my point is, that's what the other way, if you hold written interrogatories, they come on for 11 I'm trying. All right.
DeanThat's why. And I that's why Oh, they didn't answer that. That's not the answer. That's just a response. So, we need an issue. Now, my point is, that's what the other way, if you hold written interrogatories, they come on for 11 I'm trying. All right.
DeanThat's why. And I that's why I think that if you take it We got But my point is, but I will say this, this is not attempted to be, uh, I wouldn't can't say that it wasn't, uh, family
Mooresafe, full, and talk. I am answering the questions here, and I'll be glad to, and to reply, apprehend, to any other questions that you raise. You're going to get those questions anyway.
DeanI I had a, uh, paragraph in an earlier draft, that raised I think that if you take it We got But my point is, but I will say this, this is not attempted to be, uh, I wouldn't can't say that it wasn't, uh, family safe, full, and talk.
DeanI am answering the questions here, and I'll be glad to, and to reply,
Deanany questions, to any of the questions that she raised. You're gonna get those questions anyway.
NixonI I had a paragraph in earlier draft that raised the very fact that, about cross-examination, that you can't cross-examine a piece of paper, I appreciate that.
DeanHowever, I've given the essence of every question, I mean the essence, answers to every question that's been raised.
NixonNow obviously, a person who is seeking just to keep a side show going can ask more questions. Somebody who wanted the facts has now got them.
DeanYeah. And also, you could go on to say that that that if there are other questions, we'll be glad to answer those in the same way, whatever.
NixonWhat I get is this: I'm looking at what what our options are.
DeanLet us suppose that they
Nixona cross-examination, that you can't cross-examine a piece of paper. I appreciate that.
DeanHowever, I've given the essence of every question, I mean the essence, answers to every question that's been raised.
NixonNow obviously, a person who is seeking just to keep a sideshow going can ask more questions. Somebody who wanted the facts has now got them.
DeanYeah. And also you can go on to say, well if there are other, if there are other questions we'll be glad to answer those in the same way, whatever.
NixonWhat I, what I get is this: looking at what what our options are.
DeanLet us suppose that they,
Deansuppose they took our, suppose they took our offer, wrote back a letter, "We have offers"—
NixonI don't think they will, but whatever. I'm talking about it. They probably wouldn't. All right. Now, that could happen, on the other hand,
Deanit's possible they would never reach that offer and would blink and break, and we have offers
NixonI don't think they will, but whatever. I'm talking about it. They probably wouldn't. All right. Now that could happen, on the other hand,
Deanit's possible they would never reach that point because they would say, "Hell, no, we aren't gonna take any interrogatories. We're going to insist that you be called down here." And I mean we will fight it and never have it at all.
NixonWell, this comes back to a very fundamental point, that our basic strategy is one of the defense against a rather strong
DeanBecause they would say, "Hell no, we aren't gonna take any interrogatories. We're going to insist you be called down here." And I mean we will fight it and never have it at all.
NixonWell, this comes back to a very fundamental point, that our basic strategy is one of the defense against a rather strong offense. We've done nothing to attack that offense up there.
DeanLast night, I threw a lot of—at, this morning, I've began to think about some ideas that would really tie them up in knots.
Deanmorning, I began to think about some ideas that would really tie them up in knots.
DeanOne is, a well-placed story, you know, Evans and Novak, or somebody here, Kevin Phillips,
Deanthat there was information to indicate that members of this committee didn't have their own house in order
DeanOne is a well-placed story in Evans and Novak, or somebody here, Kevin Phillips,
Deanthat there was information to indicate that members of this committee didn't have their own house in order and were conducting an investigation for their own standards.
DeanUh it's should, you know, would be in the paper. From that, you would go to the Senate floor with somebody like Barry Goldwater, that have the guts to pull something like this off.
DeanSay that there are rumbles, and there are reports around Washington that they are, investigators are studying from a double standard,
Deanfrom their own standards.
DeanUh it's should, you know, would be in the paper. From that, you would go to the Senate floor with somebody like Barry Goldwater, and have the guts to pull something like this off.
DeanSay that there are rumbles and there are reports around Washington that they, our investigators, are studying for a double standard,
Deanand we've got to, and we've got to solve that. And I therefore am asking every member of that select committee to
Deansubject themselves to a full-field investigation of their last
Deanto solve that, and I therefore am asking every member of that select committee to subject themselves to a full-field investigation of their last campaign by the FBI.
Deaninvestigation by the FBI, the same thing that they've asked for.
DeanAnd any man that can't stand that test should resign and any man—
DeanFBI, the same thing that they've asked for. And any man who can't stand that test should resign and any man
Nixonthat may have conducted, that investigation could be, that's why we're asking for both the Republicans and the Democrats on the committee to submit to that, and I'm also asking for all the members to dish theirs.
Deandish theirs. That's, go forward, truly to go to all around.
NixonYeah.
Deaninvestigation, that's why I'm asking for both the Republicans and the Democrats on the committee to submit to that, and I'm also asking for all the members to dish theirs.
NixonAll the members.
DeanTruly to go to all around. Yeah.
NixonTeddy Kennedy.
DeanWell, see, I was thinking of it this way, though, on the, on the, on the narrow problem, hell, you know, have Goldwater just keep banging the Ervin committee.
Deanbanging the Ervin committee.
NixonHe might well make an issue out of the fact that they're not
DeanAre you quite sure that there is much vulnerability, John?
NixonI would, I would venture that there's no, venture that there's no member of that committee that could stand a full-field investigation.
DeanI would, I would venture that there is no, venture that there is no member of that committee that would could stand a full-field investigation.
NixonOf his campaign?
DeanYes.
NixonContributions,
Deanthat's a member of that committee that could stand a full-field investigation.
NixonOf his campaign?
DeanYes.
NixonContributions, contributions whether they had a secretary or the other office, everything, everything, just [crosstalk] Just across-
DeanJust put a full-court press on. And if they—
NixonJust across, just put a full-court press on, and as a result, they—
DeanAnd if anyone said, "Yes, I'll take it,"
Nixontake it.
Deanwhich I doubt anyone would,
Deanwhich I doubt anyone would,
NixonThen they all, we call upon them tomorrow
Deanto submit their, to submit their entire campaign to full field investigation.
NixonThat's right.
Deanentire campaign to a full field investigation. That's right.
NixonWell, the other thought, the reason, the Forest Service person in China, this other, the other slant, uh,
NixonWell, the other thought, the reason the Forest Service person in China, this other, the other slant, uh,
DeanWell, the next thing is
NixonWait a minute. Go ahead.
DeanThe next thing is
DeanI think we've got two men, I think we've got two men that are gonna be out on appeal.
DeanUh it seems to me their lawyers ought to go up and, and go to, can go up and can go before a court and try to get every witness who's connected
Deanwith the Watergate enjoined, for a court and try to get every witness who's connected with the Watergate enjoined from appearing before this, from appearing before this committee during the pendency of their appeal.
Deanpendency of their appeal. So you've got an interesting side, an interesting side
Deanissue going between the courts and the Congress. Well, I think that how, like Boggs, we might, it just never has been tried and no one's really put it, and no one's really put it together.
Nixonissue going between the courts and the Congress.
DeanWell, I think that how, like Boggs, we might, it just never has been tried and no one's really put it, and no one's really put it together.
DeanBoy, we've got a bad judge in—have to get out of Sirica's, have to get out of Sirica's hands to do it. There's no way Sirica would do it.
Deanto do it. There's no way Sirica would do it.
NixonYeah.
DeanUh then it seems to me we've gotta get the ACLU, uh then it seems to me we've gotta get the ACLU pouring in there and demanding that their rules be accepted.
Deanpouring in there and demanding that their rules be accepted.
DeanUh try to, somewhere, get court, somewhere get court jurisdiction on that to tie this committee up. jurisdiction on that to tie this committee up.
DeanWe need We need just a barrage We need, we need just a barrage against the committee, its fairness,
Deanbarrage against the committee, its fairness, its decency, we need, its decency, we need people attacking, attacking whether this is the best thing,
Deanwhether this is the best thing for the institution, for the institution of government for government for for them to star- for them to start throwing stones in a glass house, throwing stones in a glass house.
NixonThat's right.
DeanStart throwing stones, fuck the damn wing breaks. Not just Water-
NixonThat's right.
DeanNot just Watergate, that's right, so we're concerned about it, so we're concerned about it.
DeanThey have got they have got damn well their vulnerabilities, they have got damn well their vulnerabilities.
NixonIs Gold- is Goldwater going to make that speech? Is he gonna is he gonna is he gonna stop it? If the, if the stuff—The stuff is not that good, speech drafted is not that good. A speech draft is being prepared this afternoon.
DeanA speech draft is being prepared this afternoon, and I just talked to Herb, talked to Herbie about it and he's sent
Deanand to holler about it. Uh, he said the holler, though, he thinks that, though, he thinks that, uh, there's not that for Goldwater to go on. He's planning for next next Thursday. I'd rather use Goldwater on this other thing. I'd rather use Goldwater on this other thing first,
HaldemanYeah.
Deanfirst, if we can, if we can put it together.
HaldemanWhat do you, what do you need as a basis for it?
DeanIt's, it's just finding the, finding the lead. You know, we
Deanaccount on the, the investigators are, are, uh, are,
Haldemanthere's falsehoods told and avoided.
DeanThe point about us is we don't blow anything, we just keep digging for that.
HaldemanWhat if, what if, what, what's that story?
DeanThat still didn't help our cause too much.
HaldemanThat is for sure.
DeanThat's the end. The timing had a lot to do with it.
DeanThat this the only thing that's, uh, the Democrats have to play with right now. And they're just running that on every front.
HaldemanCleaver.
HaldemanThe matter of getting this established as a political, a blatantly political toy that a debate about people in this administration, rather than getting the facts is something we have to work at and work up to.
HaldemanThe media has a great role in this for political and monetary tags, isn't it?
DeanIt's true. It's so, so film-oriented, television. I watch so very many TV programs.
HaldemanThey know what they're doing then.
DeanIt's going to be a media, uh, prosecution.
HaldemanMy, my, my whole, my, uh, uh, idea is, and it sounds right, is naked quietness,
Haldemanuh, and I, and say I can see the problems of doing that. So what about other questions?
HaldemanWell, my point is, what are the problems with not doing it? And what do you do? What what's the what's the line? You've said that. What
DeanWhat court? We're fostered now. The other, it's always a possibility that as a result of the Senate's meeting today and I don't have any report or feedback from their morning session. Uh, my belief that it is today. And I think so too. They might well themselves reach the decision to send
HaldemanGo ahead.
Deanquestions down to me. I would doubt it, though, however, cuz that sets a precedent they don't want to get involved in. That this [unintelligible] So, the other thing is we've stood We're in a posture, we've stood ready to answer any questions they want to ask.
HaldemanRight.
DeanUh, they've asked none. They don't They're not concerned about the facts. They'd rather have the sideshow.
HaldemanRight.
DeanGurney, incidentally, was on television this morning on the Today show debating Tunney on executive privilege. He did a spectacularly good job. He was just superb. He had all the It sounded like you speaking at your press conference, where he described what the President's doing is not executive privilege, it's the preservation of the Exercise responsibility to preserve separation of powers. He
Deansaid they these people are cooperating down there. And don't forget, they have offered to give you the information. But people don't want the information. They want the issue. Uh,
Deanit might be, uh That's a really, very open sign that Gurney is wants to help in every way he can.
HaldemanWell, he's risking his political career, too.
DeanThat's right.
HaldemanHe may be risking it the right way, too.
DeanYeah. He would in Florida. That may be right, babe.
DeanNow, the point is, though, that you can't hand it to them at this point, as I see it. Going through this, I'd like to I'd like to go back through and see if we can't answer every question that Ziegler raises.
HaldemanThat's That would be the next exercise, right?
DeanAnd if, you know, we can, then we just go with it. If we If there's reservations, it's tend to raise more questions than it'll solve, then I'd say that we, uh, Ziegler can keep saying that we've offered to cooperate any way we can, uh, they've not asked for anything from us.
HaldemanHow would you mean Well, supposing we know said that between you and that, that John Dean did meet Mr. Segretti in Miami, briefly, on a sidewalk, wasn't it?
DeanIn front of front of Howard Johnson's.
HaldemanUh, now that's a headline. Dean in- enters into that, Segretti, and the follow-ups that we've talked about now.
DeanYeah.
HaldemanIf we put this answer in a dope, it'll undoubtedly talk, Jim. But it'll undoubtedly come out at some point.
DeanI'd rather put it in now.
HaldemanYes, but I mean you're aware that that that that's going to be a big major headline at this, uh Bit by bit, it's coming out, and I can see it now. We damn, that, came out about Kalmbach, now it turned now it turned out that Dean was in touch with Segretti.
DeanUh, well so what, what's your point, though?
HaldemanThat just that we recognize so we're in that this the war, we're going to have to take the heat on this one, but it's fine. If it doesn't get out now then we get caught holding it back.
DeanAll right, well, my [crosstalk] point is,
Haldeman[crosstalk] That's right. My point is, this is just caution, isn't it?
DeanYeah.
DeanI like it.
HaldemanWhy they decided to come on it.
DeanMuch better.
HaldemanI mean, who's not around? They are, or we are.
DeanI mean,
Deanthe only other thing, we do it willingly or un- willingly here.
HaldemanI'd rather do it willingly, by far. I'd rather have us at this point where we can't Yeah. You know, you didn't have to deal with that anyway.
DeanThe only the alternative they now can have, yeah, they don't know that. There's no way they'd know that.
HaldemanRight.
DeanNo.
DeanObviously, if Toby knew, it would open up a whole new channel, but, uh, the one thing we are not doing right now, I think, we should be doing is getting the counterattack going again, damn. You know, then maybe assess whether we should be volunteering information.
HaldemanGood.
DeanMaybe try to change the tone of this thing a little bit. Get a Sullivan out. Uh, by God, there's a week or two of headlines. Uh, get a Goldwater out demanding
HaldemanYeah.
Deanthat these people that are investigating be investigated themselves, and, uh, and let him bang every single day.
HaldemanYeah. Get all of them together to cry for counterattack.
DeanYeah.
HaldemanYou don't think he's delayed getting some?
DeanNo, I'm on counsel. No, I think he's
HaldemanYou get that stuff in today.
DeanI will do that, sir, at 1:00.
DeanUh, if he's back in the office today, I'll tell him I have to have it this afternoon. Good. Soon as I get out of here, I'll go in. Good.
HaldemanUh, if the Senate doesn't act today, they don't- it doesn't appear to me that set out questions. In which, we don't have to rush this out today, tomorrow, or any- any- But
Deantoday [crosstalk] hurry up to ask.
Haldeman[crosstalk] you have your great confirmation, neither. Tomorrow morning.
DeanI don't think so.
HaldemanWell, that's the other The reason I thought you had to have a rush, it's because the other half.
DeanI thought they might, too. Now, maybe maybe one individual senator may well ask me questions. I don't know.
HaldemanPossible.
DeanWell, if they do, then, you can respond. Yeah.
HaldemanAround here, I don't know anybody else worth looking at this to see, except Ehrlichman, maybe, if he should, uh, peek at it.
DeanUh, I, one more judgment, but I don't know what should be a ball of this. I, I, I think Ziegler's the- the one that has the feel for exactly He just [unintelligible] you rattle off five facts that he can get in that brief, you get it?
HaldemanWell, he can dump them in in the press, and like a couple in the Senate.
DeanI think it's most possible.
DeanWe can rattle that out.
HaldemanI don't I don't think that meeting Segretti's going to be all that [unintelligible] should be, except the problem
Moorehe can—you don't have to say, "Every day I wanted each day, whether it's the 6th or"
HaldemanThat's all you did. You didn't do any analysis. You know, you didn't analyze all his activities.
DeanWell, we went—we went over him after on November 10th so we could make a judgment as to
HaldemanYeah.
Deanwhat it all meant on the Segretti side. I did debrief Segretti as to everything that he could remember he'd done during the campaign.
MooreOh, yeah.
HaldemanRight so—
DeanWell, I thought we had to. We had to had that information [crosstalk] for ourself.
MoorePart of their investigation.
HaldemanWell, that's part of it.
Moorepart of your investigation. You can just say, "I put the question to this—"
HaldemanAnd that you had, part of your investigation
DeanYeah.
Haldemanwas a debriefing.
DeanThat's right.
MooreYou you questioned extensively. It's part of my investigation under the direction of the President, I questioned him extensively.
DeanExtensively. That's right.
MooreIn other words, spell that out. You know, you make—you can make that sound, sure, we don't have that side of the question, but how about that?
DeanYeah.
MooreIt's not against the law to leave blank, or something like that.
DeanI see. Right.
MooreThere are ways, sometimes, of the answering that totally—you might want to enter in chapter and detail and verse belaboring the fact it's just laid out. They may not let that through.
DeanYou say the conclusions, in other words.
MooreI mean, it's not well. Just simply,
DeanYeah.
Moorecould conclude the fact to him that he was doing—it was directed and controlled by anyone in the White House. You know. That's—which is the key of the—
DeanI I I I questioned him I I questioned Segretti with regard to this.
MooreSecret.
DeanI find that not directed by the White House, he turned me [crosstalk] down.
Moore[unintelligible] I put that out. In other words, and then that put out that gives you what Segretti's keeper meant.
DeanRight.
MooreSee in other words the way I would look at it say, "I'm not—I didn't shield Chapin." You said, "I sir, segregated with whatever the fact. I did this fact." You don't even have to mention Chapin.
DeanRight. And my my my—or something so that, "Yes, sir, my purpose was I talked to Segretti about this this and the other thing.
MooreAnd then and farm for Chapin's files, "My purpose to talk to Segretti was to find out whether he engaged in activities of the White House. I found that not, period."
DeanRight.
MooreThat's the way I handled it. At least I I think you can handle things like that in a way that you bring it as a subhead to something else rather than "Yes, I do this." And I better do it.
DeanWell, the only other man around here that is worth as I say Mike may have an early look at it, maybe not. Maybe he's uh, because if he offered his judgment on me,
MooreHe's a very good editor and a very good lawyer. And uh, well [crosstalk] the question of whether you wanted him—
HaldemanWell, why don't you go forward and I'll, uh, what are you going to do now, John?
DeanWell, I'm going to work on this thing, the cover the eight points right and see how much we can expand it to be as completely Candid as possible. Right.
MooreRight. What what what Rod's other points are, right. And then see if they're having them bring more holes. And when we get to the point that people can't dig holes in it, it's right to release.
HaldemanYeah.
MooreNow how would you release it? A written piece?
HaldemanI would think so. That's, that's the best thing. Yeah. Unless we come in and say, "I might in the interim I get questions from—"
DeanWhy not an interview? Then we could—
MooreI would never do it in an interview.
DeanNever, never. We we've learned our lesson.
HaldemanI don't think you can do that.
DeanMy chair can remain see my articles
MooreI agree.
Deanlike they make them look like some of their how polite that says it.
MooreCourteous.
HaldemanNever, never.
DeanWell, so your assertion, question is if he's can't hear this question, that's why.
HaldemanThere's one discussion John, trigger there as to whether we could encourage Howard Baker to throw out some questions to—
DeanUh-huh. Well, I don't—
MooreI think I don't think Gurney, yeah.
DeanI think Gurney is solid about that, though. Gurney, yes sir.
MooreHe did very well during the hearing.
DeanYeah, I was I was going to put in a telephone request today to the—to call Gurney and tell him he's just such a a good soldier on this thing that—
HaldemanThe problem the trouble, well, is this that I don't believe you find you should call [unintelligible]
DeanYeah.
Haldemancalling Gurney or anybody else on these hearings.
DeanFine, fine. Good point.
HaldemanSee, if you tell, you know, anybody else,
DeanGood point.
Haldemanthe President certainly, but not you.
MooreNo.
DeanGood. In fact, we had—I'm not doing that then.
HaldemanThese people who talk to him, why should you tell him? Why should you call him on the phone, when a word could could be passed to Marcy Davis or whoever or anybody else to send him a note that that was a hell of a performance
DeanYeah.
Haldemanand that people will not forget it?
DeanRight.
HaldemanThat's all he needs to hear.
MooreGurney's cautious. I don't know who you'd—
DeanYou know, when you think who’s best with him, remember Gurney is still—
MooreHe sure is, he sure is. What is it?
DeanMarsh?
MooreHe sure is, plenty on him. Gurney flies out those seven fifty-two's, and so on and so on.
DeanYeah, oh, yeah. He lost him on a little passage in that shot, but you always catch him a cold naturally, was a fight with that.
MooreWell, he's learning. Don't be afraid. He cheers with me. He's got a bad tongue.
DeanWell, on Friday,
MooreAll right.
Deanwe said coming, put a stop to it and make the suspect feel guilty, you know, he's getting duped with what's expected,
Moorethat that would probably encourage a system all over there.
DeanIt will be, they can't hear.
HaldemanIf you kind of gather up some thoughts to take down to your next meeting, I mean, I think that would probably be some of the stuff they'd be needing.
DeanPart of the reason you didn't have the facts, enough facts, but that also you see sometimes
HaldemanWe don't have enough facts. Now that I've got some vehicles, we ought to—I'm conceived of that we ought to get things started, hoping so.
MooreMakes it an offensive then. Good god, I want to see that. Yes, sir, I want to see that. I want to see what is.
DeanAnd we may have things that are going to be tough on the girl, tough on the Johnsons.
HaldemanHi. We shouldn't,
DeanAs as long as it's not us uh, because we have we're getting really very badly treated with something. It's so distorted, and the fact that some hanky-panky is blown up into a major or could be threatening to a major situation like that.
HaldemanAnd we've got to fight them. Fight back. And if it embarrasses the memory of, uh, Johnson or Mr. Hoover, well,
DeanI guess it's a little bit funny to embarrass him. He's not
HaldemanFine. But, uh, just so long as that, uh, as it is productive. In other words, I wouldn't want to end up with uh big, uh
DeanA shootout.
Haldemana shootout, and we end up in the—as you say, if we do a thing to protect ourselves and end up with a bad deal. The stuff has to be good.
DeanRight.
HaldemanNow whatever, if it's if it'll do the job and we showed we did the job, then the risk uh and we don't have the risk of that, but if to blacken their name and and the stuff the stuff that doesn't
DeanRight.
Haldemanstand up,
DeanOh, we
Haldemanwould be very serious for us.
DeanWe're in the course [unintelligible]
HaldemanWhat is this?
MooreWe're not going to be doing it, that's why it's got to be someone's uh, you know,
HaldemanFBI, can they ever ask the FBI? That's his role.
MooreThat's why we can't have this like this. We've got to stay in field where he
DeanRight.
Moorehurts him and hurts him and so Christ, they were really bees,
DeanRight.
Moorehe's why, try to sort you not us.
HaldemanIf you did it, if it would come sooner, I knew it would come like that. If it could have been done quicker.
MooreWell, no. The way I would look at it, we had a little bit of a proceeding there, and there is none at all. That, but I need is once we decide we're going to use it, I don't think it should be used until the siege.
HaldemanYeah.
MooreI would far better have an earlier state of siege.
DeanFigure we'd get you know.
MooreWe wanted to hurt them. Did you, did you tell sir what he said here, honestly,
DeanYeah.
Mooreall this, or did we just stick it out here?
DeanOkay, well, how soon are you going to be? 10 minutes?
HaldemanWell, of course, they they've got to realize they're saw this thing through wire taps and so forth.
MooreThey uh
DeanThey uh they hired him and they're the mister.
MooreThat's what they uh There There isn't dead yet. There isn't that. You know, you saw that they were found that uh
DeanReally, somebody's thought there'd be no true uh, nothing under the Watergate though either. Leak like that.
MooreNo.
DeanSo we just fight with that whole damn can.
  • 037-166 12:59 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John W. Dean, III talked on the telephone from 12:59 pm to 1:00 pm.
  • 884-011 12:59 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John W. Dean, III met in the Oval Office of the White House from 12:59 pm to 1:00 pm.
  • 037-167 1:00 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 1:00 pm and 1:05 pm.
  • 884-012 1:00 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:00 pm and 1:05 pm.
  • 884-013 1:00 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:00 pm and 1:05 pm.
  • 884-014 1:00 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:00 pm and 1:05 pm.
  • 884-015 1:00 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:00 pm and 1:05 pm.
  • 884-016 1:00 PM · 24 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:00 pm and 1:05 pm.

Conversation 884-017, March 20, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/884-017 (accessed November 16, 2026).