Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 224 › Conversation 224-015

Nixon, Haldeman & Ehrlichman on 1973 Inauguration

Tuesday, November 14, 1972 · 10:04 AM–12:40 PM ET · Camp David Hard Wire · 2 hr 24 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob"); Ehrlichman, John D.; [Unknown person(s)]; Camp David Operator; Ziegler, Ronald L.; Butterfield, Alexander P.; Jackson, Henry M. ("Scoop")Conversation224-015 on Tape 224StartTuesday, November 14, 1972 at 10:04 AMEndTuesday, November 14, 1972 at 12:40 PMRecording deviceCamp David Hard WireSourceNixon Library record for 224-015 ↗ · National Archives Catalog, NAID 417174711 ↗

President Nixon, along with H.R. Haldeman and John Ehrlichman, discussed preparations for the 1973 Inauguration, focusing on the religious services and the President's attendance, and debated potential second-term reorganizations of the executive branch. They also touched upon the 1972 election results and the role of Vice President Agnew in the upcoming term. The conversation included extensive deliberation on budget cuts and personnel changes within various government departments.

Download MP3 · 165.3 MB

This clip of the conversation was cut from the tape by the National Archives (catalog record ↗).

On November 14, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, John D. Ehrlichman, unknown person(s), Camp David operator, Ronald L. Ziegler, Alexander P. Butterfield, and Henry M. ("Scoop") Jackson met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David from 10:04 am to 12:40 pm. The Camp David Hard Wire taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 224-015 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 224-15

Date: November 14, 1972
Time: 10:04 am - 12:40 pm
Location: Camp David Hard Wire

The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman and John D. Ehrlichman.

        The President’s recent conversation with Mamie G. D. Eisenhower
             -Birthday

        1973 Inauguration
             -Church services
                   -The President’s recent conversation with William F. (“Billy”) Graham
                   -1969 inauguration
                         -Governors, Congress
                   -The President’s attendance
                   -Religious character
                   -Distraction
                   -Prayer breakfast
                   -The President's attendance
                   -Graham
                   -The President’s schedule
                          -J. Willard (“Bill”) Marriott, Jr.
                   -Invitations
                          -Edmund Ray [?]
                          -Thelma C. (“Pat”) Nixon
             -Preparations
                  -Comparison to 1969
                          -Abraham Lincoln
                          -Inaugural book
                          -Speeches
                                -Theodore Roosevelt [TR]
                               -16-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                   -[Thomas] Woodrow Wilson
-Church services
       -1969 inauguration
             -The President’s schedule
             -Edward L. R. Elson
             -Governors, Cabinet
             -Promotion of religion -White House
       -Knight errantry
Show the rest of the log (1391 more lines)
       -Statement
       -Prayers
             -Clergymen
                    -Greek Orthodox
                    -Jewish
                    -Catholic
                    -Protestant
-Mark Treisch
-Congressional role
-Parade
       -Control
-Inaugural committee
-White House
-John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts
       -Entertainment
             -Julie Nixon Eisenhower
             -Tricia Nixon Cox
-Julie Nixon Eisenhower
       -Job at foundation
             -Documentary film production
       -Work on inaugural
             -Pay
             -Travel expenses
                    -West
-Documentaries
       -Editors
             -The President’s trips to the People’s Republic of China [PRC],
             Soviet Union
       -Timing
             -Audience
                    -Compared to readership for book
       -1972 campaign
                                    -17-

          NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                 -Compared to George S. McGovern
           -Editor
                 -Advocacy

Winston S. Churchill
     -Biography: [The War That Churchill Waged]
           -[Earl of Cromer] George R.S. Baning
     -Lewis Broad
           -Quotation

Public relations [PR]
      -Image of the President
             -Robert B. Semple, Jr. article
             -Crucial decisions of first term
                   -Cambodia
                   -May 8, 1972
                   -PRC opening
                   -August 15, 1971 announcement
                   -Family Assistance Plan
                         -Courage
                   -Henry A. Kissinger
                         -Vietnam
                               -John B. Connally
                               -Vice President Spiro T. Agnew
                               -Bombing
                               -Barry M. Goldwater
      -Documentaries
             -Editors
                   -Viewpoint
                   -Darryl F. Zanuck
                         -Support for Dwight D. Eisenhower
                               -Crusade in Europe
             -Churchill
                   -The Finest Hours
             -Patton
                   -Book
                   -[George C. Scott]
                   -Producer [Frank McCarthy]
             -Honesty
             -Semple
                                  -18-

         NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

          -John F. Osborne
          -Frank Van Der Linden
          -Advocacy
                -1972 campaign
          -Expenses
                -Foundation
          -Supporters of the President
          -Writing
                -Conservative
                      -Patrick J. Buchanan
                -Abilities
                      -Poet
                -Hugh S. Sidey
                      -Compared to Theodore H. (“Teddy”) White
          -Churchill movie [Young Winston]
                -Techniques
                -Portrayal of Churchill
                      -Warmth
                      -Qualities
                            -Vanity, ambition
                      -Mother [Jennie (Jerome) Churchill]
                      -Father [Randolph Churchill]
                            -Syphilis
                      -Marlborough: His Life and Times

          -Editor
     -Supporters
          -Research
          -Intellectuals
          -Writers

Second term reorganization
     -Winston Churchill
           -Biographies
           -Britain
                 -Cabinet formation
                      -Benjamin Disraeli
                             -Hughenden Manor
                      -Resignations
     -Cabinet changes
                                   -19-

         NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

           -Novelty
     -Franklin D. Roosevelt
     -Lincoln
     -Dwight D. Eisenhower
           -1956 election
                 -Heart attack
                 -House of Representatives, Senate
     -Arthur S. Fleming
     -The President's goals
     -Robert Finch
           -Concerns
     -Telephone calls to Ehrlichman
     -The President’s schedule
           -Agnew
           -Connally
           -Roy L. Ash
     -Ash
           -Role in administration
     -Agnew
     -Legality

Budget
    -The President’s concern
    -Caspar W. (“Cap”) Weinberger
    -Frank C. Carlucci
    -Kenneth R. Cole, Jr
    -George P.Schultz
    -Herbert Stein
    -Impact on economy
          -George T. Humphrey's remark
                -Eisenhower
                -Recession
    -Cuts
          -Social programs
                -Weinberger
                      -Milk Fund
                      -School funds
                      -Judgment
                      -Department of Health, Education and Welfare
          -Return from Philadelphia
                                           -20-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                   -Changes
                   -Clean Water Bill
                         -Proposals for the President
                         -Certification of projects
                               -William D. Ruckelshaus
                         -Repeal
                         -Expenditures
                               -Ruckelshaus
                   -Environmental programs
                   -School lunches
                         -Problems
                               -Weinberger
                               -Shultz
                   -Model cities
                         -Gerald R. Ford
                   -Education
                         -Higher education
                         -National Science Foundation [NSF]

An unknown person entered at an unknown time after 10:04 am

        Refreshments
             -Delivery

The unknown person left at an unknown time before 11:36 am.

                   -Military
                         -Kissinger
                   -Central Intelligence Agency [CIA]
                         -Control
                         -Left wingers
                         -[Homosexuals]
                   -Defense Intelligence Agency [DIA]
                         -Waste
                         -Intelligence product
                                -Value

*****************************************************************
                                             -21-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
[National Security (B) withdrawal reviewed under MDR guidelines case number LPRN-T-MDR-
2014-015. Segment exempt per Executive Order 13526, 3.3(b)(1) on 04/29/2019. Archivist:
MAS]
[National Security]
[224-015-w002]
[Duration: 7s]

        DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2

*****************************************************************

        Budget
             -Cuts
                     -Personnel
                           -Pentagon
                                 -Alameda, CA
                                 -Washington, DC
                                       -Unemployment
                                 -Civilians
                           -Kissinger
                                 -Negotiator
                           -White House
                                 -Secret Service
                                 -Example
                                 -Nelson A. Rockefeller’s view
                                 -Charles W. Colson's office

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift during
chronological review 2007-2013]

        Agnew
            -1976 Election
                               -22-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

      -Presidential candidates
             -Agnew
                    -Compared to Charles H. Percy
                    -Compared to John B. Anderson
             -Edward M. Kennedy
             -The President’s support
-Role as Vice President
      -Limits
             -Staff cuts
             -Compared to the President’s service as Vice President
             -Strategy for handling
                    -Denial of the President’s support
                          -Second term independence
                    -Leverage
                          -Secrecy
-Chances of nomination
      -Compared to 1960 election
             -Eisenhower
             -John Foster Dulles
             -Christian A. Herter
             -The President’s efforts
                    -Compared to Agnew’s efforts
                          -South, Midwest
-Denial of the President’s support
-Office of Intergovernmental Relations
      -Contacts for Agnew
             -Mayors
             -Ronald Reagan
      -Political aspect
             -Advantages for Agnew
             -Disadvantages for the President
-Assignments
      -Bicentennial
             -Problems
             -Advantages
                    -Travel
                    -Visibility
-1976 plans
      -Current activities
             -Compared to the President in 1960
                               -23-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                    -Travel
                    -Television
                    -Golf
             -Image
                    -Republican delegates
      -Rivals
             -Kennedy
                    -Defeat
             -Connally
                    -Delayed decision
             -Cabinet
                    -Elliot L. Richardson
                    -Peter G. Peterson
     -The President’s choice
-Abilities as President
     -Energy
     -Leadership
             -Staff respect
      -Supporters
             -Buchanan
             -Right wingers
      -Compared to Goldwater
             -Intelligence
             -Candidate
-Supporters
      -Compared to the President’s supporters
             -Intelligence
             -Right wingers
             -Left wingers
             -Loyalty
             -Human Events
                   -M. Stanton Evans
                   -[Unintelligible name]
                   -Goldwater
-Views
     -Race
     -Liberalism
     -Spending policies
             -Inconsistency
-Foreign policy
                                            -24-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                    -Contrast with Connally
                           -Strength
                           -Judgment
                    -Stubbornness
              -Office of Intergovernmental Relations
              -Alternative presidential candidate
                    -The President’s support
                    -William E. Brock III
                    -Options
                    -Roosevelt
                    -Eisenhower
                    -Ambition

        1972 election
             -Media commentary
                   -James B. (“Scotty”) Reston, Thomas Grey (“Tom”) Wicker
             -Democratic party
                   -Internal conflicts
                         -Jean Westwood
                   -George C. Wallace vote
                         -McGovern statement
                               -Ronald L. Ziegler comment
                   -McGovern
                         -White House statements
                         -R. Sargent Shriver, Jr.
                         -Surrogates
                               -Attacks

*****************************************************************

Ehrlichman talked with the Camp David operator at an unknown time between 10:04 am and
11:36 am. Haldeman and the President can be heard in the background.

[Conversation No. 224-15A]

[See Conversation No. 183-1]

        Kissinger’s schedule
              -Trip to Paris
                                            -25-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                    -Announcement
                         -Ziegler
                         -Trip to Camp David

[End of telephone conversation]

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift during
chronological review 2007-2013]

        Agnew
            -Alternative presidential candidate

        Second term reorganization
             -Goals
                   -Access to the President
                         -The President’s inclination
                         -Cabinet meetings

Ehrlichman talked with Ziegler at an unknown time between 10:04 am and 11:36 am.

[Conversation No. 224-15B]

[See Conversation No. 183-2]

The President conferred with Haldeman at an unknown time between 10:04 am and 11:36 am.

        1972 election
             -White House statements
                    -Lawrence F. O’Brien, Jr.
                    -Westwood
                    -Shriver
                    -McGovern
             -Wallace vote

[End of telephone conversation]

*****************************************************************
                                      -26-

          NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Second term reorganization
     -Five principle areas
     -Policy making groups
           -Domestic, economic, foreign policy
           -Economic policy
                 -Foreign and domestic economics
                 -Stein
                 -Shultz
                 -Cost of Living Council
                 -Council of Economic Advisors [CEA]
                 -Treasury Department
                 -Commerce Department
                 -Labor Department
     -Office of Management and Budget [OMB]
           -Role contrasted to domestic policy making group
                 -Implementation
                        -White House staff
     -Assignments for five principle areas
           -Ehrlichman, Haldeman
           -Economic policy
                 -Shultz
                        -Dual role
                              -Secretary of the Treasury, advisor to the President
           -Foreign policy
                 -Kissinger
           -OMB
                 -Ash
           -White House staff
                 -Haldeman
     -Structure
           -Office of Management and Budget
                 -Ash
                        -Problem
                              -Compared to Robert S. McNamara
                        -Temporary assignment
                              -Reorganization
                              -Permanent replacement
                                    -Frederic V. Malek
                         -27-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

     -Malek
           -Temperament
           -Judgment
                   -Personnel
     -Ash
           -Outsider
           -Understanding
-Organization chart
     -Foreign policy
           -Kissinger
                   -Defense Department
                   -State Department
                   -CIA
     -Domestic policy
           -Ehrlichman
           -Super secretaries
                   -Natural Resources
                         -Interior
                   -Community Development
                   -Human Resources
                   -Natural Resources
                         -Secretary of the Interior
                   -Community Development
                         -Secretary of Housing and Urban Development
                                -Secretary of Agriculture
                                      -Delegation of authorities
                   -Secretary of Transportation
                         -Coast Guard
                                -Delegation to Defense Department
                                -Legal status
                                -John A. Volpe successor
                                -Melvin R. Laird successor
                                -Troop deployment, force levels
            -Justice Department
                   -Human Resources
                   -Richardson
                   -Weinberger
                   -Areas of responsibility
                         -Court appointments, prosecutions, anti-trust
                   -Attorney General
                                             -28-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                           -Relations with the President
                                      -Richard G. Kleindienst

Alexander P. Butterfield entered at an unknown time after 10:00 am.

        Telephone call from Henry M. (“Scoop”) Jackson

Butterfield left at an unknown time before 11:36 am.

        Second term reorganization
             -Domestic policy
                   -Compared to the Domestic Council

        Telephone calls
             -Birthday calls
                   -Mamie G. D. Eisenhower
             -Jackson
                   -Tel Aviv
             -Birthday calls

        Second term reorganization
             -Justice Department
                    -Attorney General
                          -Kleindienst
                          -John N. Mitchell
                                -Press story
                    -Changes
                          -Appointments
                                -Assistant Attorney Generals
                                -Deputy Attorney General
             -Councils
                    -National Security Council [NSC]
                    -Agnew
                    -Office of Emergency Preparedness [OEP] director [Gen. George A.
                    Lincoln]
                    -Domestic Council
                          -Cuts
                          -Policy making
                          -Members
                                -Super Secretaries
                       -29-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

          -Attorney General
                 -Mitchell
                 -Kleindienst
          -Natural resources group
                 -Policy group
                       -Secretaries of Agriculture, Commerce
          -Contacts with the President
                 -The President’s possible trip to Israel
          -Cabinet meetings
                 -Budget
          -Agriculture Department
                 -Secretary
                       -Conditions of job
                       -Earl L. Butz
                       -Dealings with farmers
                       -Natural resources group
                       -Economic Development Group
    -Public announcements
    -Purpose
          -Executive branch efficiency
          -Delegation of authority
                 -White House staff
    -Natural resources group
          -Rogers C. B. Morton
          -Congressional opposition
          -Title for job
                 -Counselor for Natural Resources
                 -Secretary of the Interior
          -Finch
          -Donald H. Rumsfeld
          -Policy group
    -Current role of White House staff
          -Mediation
                 -Butz and Morton
                       -Forest lands
    -Counselor Natural Resources
          -Butz
          -Morton
                 -George P. Herzog
    -Super secretaries
                              -30-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                -Offices
                      -Executive Office Building
           -Under Secretaries
                -Management responsibilities
           -Congressional approval
           -Counselors
                -Responsibility to the President
-NSC
      -Kissinger
      -Current set-up
             -OEP
             -Membership
      -Meetings
      -Foreign Policy Council
      -Generation of peace
      -Staff cuts
             -Kissinger
-Domestic Council
      -Staff cuts
             -NSC
      -Delegation of work to departments
             -Analysis, mediation, papers, speeches
-Economic policy
      -OMB
             -Impact on budget, management
-Foreign Policy Council
      -Meetings
      -Kissinger
      -The President
      -NSC role
             -Agnew
-Shultz
      -Office
             -EOB
      -Secretary of the Treasury
      -Responsibilities
             -Foreign and Economic Policy Council
             -Council on International Economic Policy [CIEP]
      -Peter M. Flanigan
-Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff [JCS]
                              -31-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

-Kissinger
       -Meetings
      -Vietnam
             -Settlement agreement
      -White House staff role
             -Haldeman, Ehrlichman
-Control of bureaucracy
       -Ash
       -Lines of authority
       -Independent agencies
             -Subordination
             -National Aeronautics and Space Administration [NASA]
-Rockefeller
-Ash
       -OMB
       -Public relations
             -The President’s Advisory Council on Executive Organization
               [PACEO]
             -Rockefeller
             -Blue room presentation [November 19, 1970?]
-Connally
       -Support
-Complexities
-Politics
       -FDR
       -TR
       -Lincoln
       -TR
             -Hyphenated Americans
                    -Jewish, Catholic appointments
       -FDR
       -Butz
             -Constituencies for departments
                    -Farmers
                          -Interior Department
                    -Environmentalists
-Super secretaries
       -Weinberger
             -Human Resources, HEW
       -Shultz
                             -32-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

           -Economic Development
     -Community Development
           -Secretary of HUD
                  -Under Secretary
     -The President’s liaisons with departments
           -Cabinet role
                  -Staff
                         -Conglomerate corporation
                              -Litton Industries
                                     -Ash
-Agnew
     -Forthcoming conversation
           -Cuts in White House staff
                  -Symbolism
           -Staff
                  -Quality
                  -Size
           -National Aeronautics and Space Council
           -Indian Opportunity Council
           -Youth Employment Council
                  -Human Resources
           -Role
           -Bicentennial
           -1976 plans
                  -Controversies
                  -Travel
           -Office of Intergovernmental Relations [OIR]
                  -Counselor for Community Development
                         -Rural, urban
                  -Governors and mayors
                         -EOB
                  -OMB
                         -Ash
           -The President’s reluctance
                  -Ash
-Councils
     -Leadership
           -Foreign policy
           -Domestic policy
                  -Ehrlichman
                             -33-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

            -Shultz
                   -Job title
      -Announcement
            -Emphasis on counselors, Cabinet
      -PR
            -Cuts in White House staff
                   -Impact on public
-White House staff
      -Labor leader
            -Colson’s view
            -Politics
      -Jews
            -Leonard Garment
-Labor representative
      -Labor Secretary
            -Role
-Jews
-Human Resources
      -Arts
-Science advisor
      -The President’s Science Advisory Committee [PSAC]
      -Office of Science and Technology [OST]
            -Science advisor
            -Eisenhower
                   -Sputnik
            -Special drug advisor
      -Cancer research
            -HEW
      -Independent agencies
            -Reporting channels
      -Economic Development
            -PSAC
                   -Military and Foreign Policy
-Arms Control and Disarmament Agency
      -Kissinger
-Kissinger
      -Responsibilities
            -Selective Service Administration
            -ACDA
-Ash
                                           -34-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

              -OST
                    -Division
              -John J. McCloy committee
              -The President’s Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board [PFIAB]
                    -Kissinger
              -Delegation of responsibilities
              -Cabinet officers
                    -Resignations
                    -Condition of employment

        The President’s schedule

The President talked with the Camp David operator at an unknown time between 10:04 am and
11:36 am.

[Conversation No. 224-15C]

[See Conversation No. 153-8]

[End of telephone conversation]

        White House operators
             -Transfer to Camp David

        Press relations
              -Trailer
                     -Briefings
                           -Announcement, November 17, 1972
                                -Kissinger
                                -Ziegler

        The President's schedule
             -Possible television [TV] appearance

        Vietnam negotiations
             -PR plan
                  -Meetings with Haldeman, Kissinger and Ziegler

        Agnew
            -Staff
                                            -35-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                    -Resignations

        Second term reorganization
             -PFIAB
             -Plans
                   -Deadline
             -Implementation
                   -Announcement
                         -The President's schedule
                              -Florida
                              -Staff work
                         -PR
                              -Raymond K. Price, Jr.

The President talked with Jackson between 11:36 am and 11:41 am.

*****************************************************************

[Previous National Security (B) withdrawal reviewed under MDR guidelines case number
LPRN-T-MDR-2014-015. Segment declassified on 01/10/2018. Archivist: MAS]
[National Security]
[224-015-w009]
[Duration: 2s]

[Conversation No. 224-15D]

[See Conversation No. 153-009-w001]

*****************************************************************

[End of telephone conversation]

        Second term reorganization
             -Secretary of Defense
                   -Jackson
                         -Problems
                               -Daniel J. Evans
                                    -Republican
                                              -36-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift during
chronological review 2007-2013]

        1972 election
             -Republican Party
                    -Credit for victories
                         -Evans
                         -Ford
                                 -Robert P. Griffin
                                 -John G. Tower
                         -Evans
                                 -Ehrlichman’s trip
                                 -The President’s telephone call

*****************************************************************

        Second term reorganization
             -Replacement for Jackson
                   -Pressure on Evans
                   -Democrats for Nixon
                         -Goodwin Chase
                               -Anthony G. Chase
                                    -Small Business Administration [SBA]
                               -Background
                                    -Banking
             -Secretary of Defense
                   -Jackson
                         -The President’s previous offer
                         -Edward M. Kennedy
                         -Religion
                               -Catholic, Lutheran
                         -Kennedy
                               -Campaign manager
                         -Richardson
                               -Congressional relations
                                            -37-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                         -“Message to Garcia” [Nguyen Van Thieu]
                               -John A. McCone
                         -Presidential aspirations
                               -Vice Presidency
                                      -Kennedy
                         -“Message to Garcia” [Thieu]
                         -Plans
                         -Age
                         -Governmental Operations Committee chair
                         -Retirement pension

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift during
chronological review 2007-2013]

        Second term reorganization
             -Secretary of Defense
                   -Henry M. (“Scoop”) Jackson
                         -Wealth
                               -Warren G. (“Maggie”) Magnuson

*****************************************************************

        Second term reorganization
             -Secretary of Defense
                   -Henry M. (“Scoop”) Jackson
                         -Family
                                -Age
                                -Children [Anna M. Jackson, Peter H. Jackson]
                                -Wife [Helen Eugenia (Hardin) Jackson]
                         -Political views

        1972 election
             -Henry Jackson
                    -Support for George S. McGovern
                         -Washington

        Second term reorganization
                               -38-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

-Defense Department
      -William Clements
            -Republican
      -Jackson
-Appointments
      -Notifications
      -Henry Jackson
      -Gordon L. Allott
      -Jack R. Miller
      -Alcott
            -Age
            -Loyalty
            -Complaints
                  -Interior Department
                         -Under Secretary
                              -James D. Schlesinger, Jr.
-CIA
      -Schlesinger
      -Personnel cuts
            -DIA
-Defense Department
      -Personnel cuts
            -Kissinger
            -Alexander M. Haig, Jr.
            -Necessity
       -Jackson
       -Richardson
      -Clements
-State Department
      -[David] Kenneth Rush
            -Support
                  -Problems
                         -Managerial ability
            -Berlin
            -Loyalty
            -Conditions of appointment
                  -Under secretary
      -Rockefeller
      -Richardson
            -Foreign Service
                             -39-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

      -Under Secretary
      -Under Secretary for Political Affairs
            -U. Alexis Johnson
      -Under Secretary
            -Frank C. Carlucci
                  -Foreign Service
                  -Personnel cuts
                  -OMB
                        -Management performance
                              -Rio de Janeiro embassy
                                     -Staff cuts
                  -Office of Economic Opportunities [OEO]
                        -Legal services project
                              -Los Angeles
                  -OMB performance
                        -Shultz’s view
                              -Arnold H. Weber
                              -Malek
                  -Cabinet post
                  -Under Secretary for Political Affairs
                  -Rush
                  -Special projects
                        -Foreign Service
            -Kissinger’s recommendation
            -William J. Casey
-Internal Revenue Service [IRS]
      -Casey
            -Interest
      -Appointment
            -Loyalty
            -Credentials
-State Department
      -Under Secretary
            -Credentials
            -Loyalty
                  -James T. Lynn
                        -Background
            -Casey
                  -Background
            -Malek
                        -40-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

           -Rush
-Under Secretary for Political Affairs
     -Johnson
     -Foreign Service
     -Kissinger
     -Age
     -David R. Young, Jr.
     -David Osborne
           -Counsel General to Hong Kong
           -Loyalty
                  -PRC
           -Desire for change
           -Political views
                  -Foreign Service
     -Charles Whitehouse
           -Kissinger
     -Eugene Carson Blake
           -Whittier
           -Adlai E. Stevenson, II
           -R. Sargent Shriver
           -Relationship by marraige
                  -Joseph W. Alsop
                  -White House
                        -Loyalty
-Under Secretary
     -Carlucci
     -Paul H. Nitze
           -“Georgetown set”
           -Relationship to Dean G. Acheson
           -Loyalty
     -Casey
           -Economic issues
                  -William P. Rogers
                  -Flanigan
     -Titles
           -Under Secretary for Economic Affairs
                  -Irwin
           -Under Secretary for Political Affairs
                  -Johnson
           -Under Secretary for Coordinating Security Assistance
                               -41-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                        Programs
                        -Curtis W. Tarr
            -Tarr
                   -Expertise
                   -Age
                   -Selective Service System
                   -Rogers
            -David M. Abshire
                   -Political views
                          -Conservatism
                   -Foreign Service
                          -Rogers
                   -Relationship to Adm. George W. Anderson, Jr.
                          -[Carolyn Lamar (Sample) Abshire]
            -William B. Macomber, Jr.
            -Abshire
                   -Congressional relations
                   -Foreign service
            -Macomber
                   -Abilities
                   -Loyalty
                   -Work with Shultz
                          -Walker
-Treasury Department
      -Schultz’s view
      -Paul A. Volcker
      -Walker
      -Volcker
            -Loyalty
            -Intelligence
      -Walker
            -House Ways and Means Committee
            -Replacement
            -Under Secretary
      -Flanigan
            -Work with Shultz
            -Confirmation problem
            -Other Under Secretary positions
                   -Interior, Agriculture, Transportation Departments
                   -Dillon, Read, and Co.
                                   -42-

         NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

     -State Department
           Under Secretary positions
                -Title
                       -Economic affairs

Second term reorganization
     -Henry Jackson
           -Schedule
           -State Department, Defense Department, ACDA
           -Meeting with President
     -State Department
           -Secretary of Defense
                 -Malek
                 -Kissinger
                 -Rush
           -Under Secretary
                 -Casey
     -IRS
           -Casey
                 -Malek’s candidate
                 -[George D. Webster]
                       -Confirmation Problem
     -Casey
           -State Department
     -Richardson
           -Defense Department
           -HEW
                 -Plan for personnel cuts
                       -Block grant approach
     -Weinberger
           -IRS
           -State Department
                 -Under Secretary
           -Federal Trade Commission [FTC]
           -State Department
                 -Washington, DC social set
     -Rockefeller
           -Secretary of Defense
                 -Kissinger
           -Recruitment
                              -43-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

             -Difficulties
             -Gains to administration
      -State Department
-Jackson
      -Israel trip
-Richardson
      -HEW personnel cuts
      -Personnel cuts at the Defense Department
-Personnel cuts
      -Proposals
             -Morton
             -Peter G. Peterson
             -Butz
-Richardson
      -Attorney General
      -Civil rights approach
             -HEW
      -Justice Department
             -Mitchell, Kleindinst
                   -Symbolism
                          -South
-Kleindienst
      -Retention at Justice Department
             -Conditions
                   -Subordinates
                          -Loyalty
-Appointments
      -Meetings with Haldeman, Ehrlichman
      -Possible written agreements
             -Congressional pressures
-Rogers
      -Departure from administration
             -Other cabinet members
                   -George W. Romney
                   -John A. Volpe
-Departures
      -Romney
      -Volpe
      -Laird
      -Romney
                             -44-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

-Cabinet officers
     -Resignations
            -Timing
                  -Romney
                        -Richard C. Van Dusen
                               -Recess appointment
            -No exceptions
     -Replacements
            -Recommendations
                  -Connally and Mitchell
            -Romney
            -Volpe
            -Rogers
                  -Timing
                        -Vietnam
                               -Settlement agreement
                  -Conflicts with Kissinger
            -PR
                  -Announcements
                  -Stories on changes
                  -Presidential TV appearances
     -Meetings with the President at Camp David
            -Announcements
                  -Ziegler
                        -Ash
     -Announcements
            -Jackson
            -Timing
                  -Leaks
                  -Publicity for each officer
-Announcements
     -Staff cuts
     -Reorganization plans
            -Ehrlichman’s role
     -Cabinet officers
            -Order
                  -State Department, Defense Department
     -Independent agencies
            -Shultz
     -Cabinet
                             -45-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

            -Shultz
                   -Economic policy
            -Kleindienst
            -Butz
            -Rogers
            -Morton
                   -Problems
                          -Congressional relations
                          -Relationship with the President
                                -Anne (Jonas) Morton
                   -Retention
                          -Bureau of Indian Affairs
                          -Butz
                   -Ambassadorship to Canada
                   -Departure
                   -Tenure in office
-Cabinet officers
     -Orientation session
     -Butz
            -Appointment
                   -Interior Department
            -Loyalty
     -Shultz
            -Loyalty
     -Richardson
     -Weinberger
            -Department of Housing and Urban Development
            -Credibility
            -Super secretary
                   -Community development
            -Revenue sharing
            -Background
     -Richardson
            -HEW
            -The President’s views
                   -Education, health, busing
            -Political orientation
            -Credibility
                   -Humane
            -Busing
                               -46-

    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

-Orientation session
      -Weinberger
            -HUD
      -Ash
      -Richardson
      -Butz
      -Kliendienst
            -Attorney General
            -Retention
                   -Conditions
            -Reform of Justice Department
      -Henry E. Peterson
            -Retention
                   -[Watergate]
            -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] directorship
-FBI
      -Jerry K. Wilson
            -Loyalty
            -Reputation
            -Managerial abilities
      -L[ouis] Patrick Gray, III
            -Departure
            -Confirmation
                   -Problem
                   -Deputy Attorney General
-Gray
      -Under Secretary of State
            -Background
                   -Adm. Arthur W. Radford
            -Loyalty
                   -FBI
-Casey
      -Securities and Exchange Commission [SEC]
      -CIA
            -Schlesinger
      -IRS
      -State Department
            -Under Secretary
-Gray
      -FBI
                                   -47-

       NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

       -Under Secretary of State
       -Toughness
       -[Watergate]
       -Subordinates
            -Problems
-FBI
     -Removal of officials
            -Wilson
                  -Desire for job
            -Gray
     -Wilson
            -Washington, DC police department
-Walter E. Washington
-George H.W. Bush
     -Loyalty
     -Managerial ability
     -Cabinet position
     -Personality
     -Interior Secretary
            -Abilities
                  -Compared to Morton
     -Background
            -Texas
     -Indians
-Morton
     -Departure
            -Butz as counselor
                  -Farm Belt
     -Ambassadorship to Canada
            -Pipeline
            -Work with Canadians
                  -Successes
            -Pierre E. Trudeau
                  -U.S.-Canada relations
                         -Minority government
                  -Wire to the President
                  -Political orientation
                         -Chou En-Lai
                  -Constituency
                         -Quebec
                                             -48-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

        The President's schedule
             -Haldeman’s and Ehrlichman’s meeting with Ash and Malek
                   -Timing
                          -Harry S. Dent

Ehrlichman and Haldeman left at 12:40 pm.

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).

Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.

NixonWell, [sighs] I had a call from Mamie. It was dear Mamie's birthday.
NixonOne small item. We turn to this inauguration church thing.
NixonIn talking to Billy Graham on the church, he's calling this whole church, that church service thing,
Nixonhe said, well, the—these groups had all agreed, and he hoped it was, well, I can't do more, Billy. But
Nixonthe point is that those jackasses that did it last time, remember I told you this. I just knew there was something up there.
NixonSo, they're having all the Governors, and all the members of the House, and the Senate, that's not their inauguration, like they did before, and they invited them to come.
NixonSo, I just want to be sure that it's turned off, as far as I am concerned. He said, he said, he said to me, Billy, on his own, said that if you want a copy this afternoon, it'll be fine. Well, as I should remember, in '68,
Nixoncame over because he, you know, we're going into inaugural, like that, inaugural morning.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonWhat am I going to a damn church service at seven o'clock on inaugural morning?
NixonThe inauguration itself is basically a a partially religious exercise with prayer and all that sort of thing. And it just to go through that half-assed little thing, and know what those things, it's just terrible. I remember.
HaldemanWell, basically nobody knows you did it, anyway. I mean, it doesn't—it isn't a—
NixonWell, the point is it's wrong. You don't do anything other than the big day that detracts from the day.
NixonI mean, now the inauguration comes at twelve o'clock.
NixonSo, I'll go at twelve o'clock.
NixonAnd I think you ought to tell them now, cuz you know they're—that same group bother us in with all those others, that if they want to have their service later on, you know, their prayer breakfast in the rain,
HaldemanYeah.
Nixonthat's something else again. I might do it,
Nixonalthough I don't want to do that, either. But uh, but I'm, I'm not going to do it on inauguration day.
NixonI am going to have that, Billy Graham, like if you turn the Sunday thing into that, for the Governors and the rest, like that, no. It's not wrong. It's the wrong first,
Nixonand it's the wrong people, and it wouldn't be good. But I didn't tell him that. As far as I'm concerned, it's fine for Sunday.
NixonSo, I've got all that set with him. I just want to be sure that well, Marriott, or whoever it is down there that's working on my schedule, doesn't say, "Well, of course, the President will consider it." Cuz I won't. Right?
HaldemanRight.
NixonAnd there's one thing I will not do, is inauguration day,
NixonI'll do anything after the inaugural speech, and anything in the afternoon, and I'll do a heavy evening, and all that sort of thing.
NixonI don't think it's possible. Right? Before, absolutely nothing.
HaldemanNo.
EhrlichmanYeah, and then it'll be raised as an [unintelligible] else here. How the hell would he know? Well—
HaldemanWell, because that's what they did. That's their standard procedure. They get it all set, and the invitations engraved saying, please join President Nixon and Mrs. Nixon at prayer, at seven o'clock in the morning. And then, they then they remember to tell us. Don't you remember that?
Nixon[unintelligible] I know. Don't you remember?
EhrlichmanYeah, well, see I didn't go. And and and so, I don't know what happened here, but I remember that, that flap at the last minute.
HaldemanOh, you've been you've been dragooned into—
NixonWell, the thing was, John,
Nixonyou know, the preparation, it won't be this year, the the second inaugural—
HaldemanGod, damn bit of difference, anyway, nah. The only one that everybody anybody ever remembers is Lincoln. Lincoln, right.
NixonAnd there was a reason.
NixonSo uh, we may have something, but not like that.
NixonNotice that eh, do you ever remember any other second inaugural?
EhrlichmanIn fact, you don't remember any first, do you?
NixonNo, that's that's right.
HaldemanNo, you do, no. If you read the book of inaugurals, the first inaugurals many times have a lot to say.
NixonLike I take TR's, of course, his first, of course,
Nixonhe only made one, and damn good.
HaldemanWilson's first was excellent. His second wasn't.
NixonNothing, nothing to say.
HaldemanHis second just dragged on.
NixonAll I'm getting at is this: this frankly the point is,
Nixonthat day was about the last day I should have been drugged out at eight, you know, whatever, 8:30 in the morning, to spend an hour, an hour and a half, going over there, having to walk in there, and sit through all those damn you know, these everything else. And all the clowns damn sucked, and all their daddies, to be peer-ridden. All
Nixonthe Governors, and everything else.
NixonThe Cabinet had to come,
Nixonas if, you know, it's it's another it's a promotion of religion.
HaldemanI know. Well,
NixonI'll do it, well, you know, I'll do it in the quiet of the White House, but I'll be damned if I'll go through that.
HaldemanThe next day,
EhrlichmanThat's the way to do it. That's the thing.
HaldemanSunday, it's quiet.
EhrlichmanYou know, this this goes back to the to the uh knight praying before he goes into battle, kind of a thing. It's a sort of a hark back. Kind of a I guess, you know [unintelligible] I think you have to say
Ehrlichmanwe're just saying that that in your own way,
Ehrlichmanyou are uh, uh
Haldemanconducting your own your own religious observance in the White House, before you go up to the inaugural. We're going to have it the next day.
EhrlichmanAnd then, you're going to have a public thing the next day.
HaldemanSure.
NixonBut I think uh uh they don't have to have prayers, and have three prayers at the inauguration.
HaldemanGod, what? No, four.
NixonJesus. We'll have the Serbian, that [unintelligible]
HaldemanGot to have that Greek Orthodox in there.
NixonDon't get
HaldemanYou've got to have the Jew, you've got to have the Catholic, you've got to have the Protestant, Greek Orthodox, right.
NixonI just don't think it makes so much difference. They talk theirs so damn long, anyway.
EhrlichmanWell, that it gets to be kind of a farce, and so on.
HaldemanYeah, God yeah.
NixonDo you remember last time we had them all?
EhrlichmanWhy don't we do the same three at the inauguration as you do at the church service the next day?
HaldemanSpread them around.
EhrlichmanSpread them around. Have the little goodies.
HaldemanSee, you've got the three. If you if you get through, come on, Billy Graham.
HaldemanAnyway, it's it's it's if you the inaugural will get out of hand in any event, because you'll get Mark Evans running it, you know, all that sort of thing.
EhrlichmanNever less. And wasn't that the one that ran it? Right.
HaldemanSure, and that's the problem. It's run by the Capitol, you know.
EhrlichmanYep.
HaldemanThat's their ceremony, that portion.
NixonYeah. Well, the rest of it we've Well, we'll run it better than we did last time. Now, the parade is not theirs, is it?
HaldemanNo.
NixonNow, the parade is the inaugural committee's. And that we definitely can control and shorten.
HaldemanI would really control and shorten it. Everything except the Capitol Hill ceremony is is at uh—
NixonSee, that's what ruined inaugurals, they said.
NixonSee the other thing we have, John, here that's so marvelous, that we didn't have last time, we've got the White House.
NixonAnd we've got that Kennedy Center, right?
HaldemanNow, you've got that Kennedy Center for three straight nights, but but let me see the plan. I want to see that myself. That is the one that I'll look— The last one I'll be doing, I want to look at it.
NixonYeah, right. First get some thinking on it first, though.
HaldemanYeah. Well, we've got somebody that—
NixonI want to I don't want to get into the details, but I want to ideas of what what's to do, and let's get everybody in, and run it by Julie,
Nixonyou know, to get her per—perhaps she she wants—
HaldemanJulie is uh is uh on the payroll of the foundation now as a consultant on documentary film production.
NixonDid you tell her?
HaldemanNo, you want me to tell her?
NixonYeah, you talk with her. Very nicely, you would.
HaldemanYou could say this, they put her on at 1,000 a month. Is that all right?
NixonOh, sure. Sure.
HaldemanYes.
NixonSubstantially more than that then. Whatever they, the assistant, whatever you would be.
HaldemanWhatever the whatever the thing the standard is. Then, of course, and then her travel expenses.
NixonOh yeah, it was worthwhile.
HaldemanI would suggest this though, that as a as a beginning, why don't you tell her that she ought to do some thinking about the inaugural? And so, that the inaugural should be a nice show.
NixonGoddamn, I just hope we can get a good editor for that documentary. That's, that's what—
HaldemanWe've got both We've got something, we've got gold.
NixonI stop to think, John, China and Russia, and all the rest,
Nixonwhat could really be done
Nixonyou know, for documentaries. It could just be you know, books, unbelievably, unbelievably better.
HaldemanYeah.
EhrlichmanWell, and the point is, you put you put a documentary on at at 4:00 in the afternoon, and it will get more viewers in one run, than all the readership of a book in 100 years.
NixonI was thinking, too, that one—
Nixonwe want it done, however, with a—
Nixonlet me put it this way, I think I I'm from what I've heard, that the stuff we did for the campaign was good.
NixonEverybody says it was, at least, professionally better than McGovern's.
NixonWell, that means something.
NixonI have a hunch
Nixonthat it
Nixondid not have that
Nixonsort of the chemistry that that that grabs, that well, that well the chemistry that sells, and so forth, because basically you did not have
Nixonan editor who was an advocate. You must have an head—an editor who is an advocate.
NixonCronkite sent me over Ike's, asked me what he thought was one of the better, you know, biographies, sent one by Lord [unintelligible]
Nixonand uh,
Nixonit was very interesting.
NixonI mean, he approached,
Nixonwhere that I have not seen emotion, Churchill, some he's writing.
NixonAnd uh,
Nixonwho, who else he thinks when this book comes out will say it's true of Churchill. Who your larger-for-failing did you ever intend to rank myself of those 10 years mind, to be equated with all
Nixonsuperiority of understanding, stubborn neck and stiff knee as it resists devolution in a heathen temple.
NixonI have protested by such wholesome examples which would be useful to check the mean spirit of lesser men who help to debase the standards of our public life.
Nixon"Men had known how to bow to it," it being greatness, "and its greatness could assure a great reward in satisfaction. However, he provided for graves continued by apologies a firm promise for the past, by yields by high admiration for those who had greatest servant of the public cause,
Nixonhas been the cause for immense satisfaction by trying to shore up my name for everything to his own mortality." Now, I'm not suggesting that we need somebody that's going to write about Nixon like this guy wrote about Churchill.
NixonI do however suggest that we have gone overboard to have people in everything that we do to take the typical eye. I mean, "Well, like that Samuel Kahn, you know." "Well, he was lucky." "He was stubborn." And so forth, you know.
NixonAnd, and to miss the really tough events. I mean, uh, you when you come back, the great decisions of this administration, there were four: there was Cambodia, there was May 8th, there was China, which was a great decision that I made by myself. And of course,
Nixonthere was the August 15th, another great decision. None of which required guts. I mean, Family Assistance didn't require any guts, vetoing uh this or that or the other thing didn't require any guts. I mean, these were just things to do.
NixonBut the point is that those decisions were decisions that were made alone. There you were, and even Henry, who claims to have been in it,
Nixonhe was the guy that at the last would come in, remember, weeping? I mean, he went through all—and he should, all the tortures because he was afraid each of doing the wrong, doing the wrong advice. Sure, Connally and Haig and the wobblers would say, "Go ahead. Do something. We're on the bastards." And the wobblers, so they have to do it,
Nixonbut they didn't take the responsibility. What I'm suggesting, though, I I'd like to get an editor. If you can find one, there may not be an intelligent editor that's for us. There just may not be. But I think you've got to get somebody who at least shares our viewpoint.
NixonI think that was the problem, if I if I can suggest it. If there was a problem with our documentaries, we had people walk in in these routines, Walter, the bastard, you know, with the beards, and so forth and at least one of them was not for us. He was not against us, but he was basically, you know what I mean?
NixonAnd I don't know, maybe you got to get—well, I mean, let's look at it like, Daryl Zanuck did something well for Eisenhower because Zanuck was for Eisenhower. That's why Crusade in Europe, even though it was a little
Haldeman[unintelligible]
Nixoncorny today, because it isn't, but it's a hell of a good thing.
HaldemanRight.
NixonWhy was the great Why Why was Churchill's Finest Hours good? Not because it didn't show warts. It showed plenty of them. It showed plenty. Why was Patton good?
NixonPatton was a great book. The actor was a son of a bitch that did it, but it was a great book and it showed the warts. But it was shown by a fellow who was not trying to run him down. We seem to have a passion our for being honest, is because we're all taking it, we're sort of taking that that it's the fact that we got to be so honest
Nixonin terms of showing the bad side that we all that we end up too often like the simple or the dumb ass or this or that or the other. Now of course, you don't want to go like Frank Vandermeer, did they? And uh people like that. I'm not talking about that.
NixonSomewhere in between, there is a fine Somewhere in between, there is a great editor. That's what I mean. I just don't want it done by a cold professional this time.
NixonI think that was the problem with the documentaries, the coldness, the uh, the you know, the failure to to really For somebody who was an advocate to sit in there. Let's see. If you've just got to have an advocate
HaldemanWell, it was done by advocates, and I don't I don't think they were failures. I think they were highly successful for what they're targeting, which is a different purpose than what you're after here, because there you were trying to make some points in a different kind of way than you will in the—
NixonAll right, well then I just want to be sure. I know that I know we spent a hell of a lot of money on those, and maybe they were marvelous successes, fine, let's concede that. The point is a hell of a lot of money will be spent for this foundation.
NixonLet's be sure it's spent for people that are for us. You see, guys, I'm not sure I'm not sure there are very many intelligent people that are for us, I might I got to admit that.
NixonAnd therefore, you're going to have a hell of a time finding them. And you'll probably end up with pedestrian people doing the writing. And and, but god, there might be a good conservative, there might be a Buchanan with judgment.
HaldemanOr a Safire? Yeah, but the problem you've got is it isn't Buchanan that you want, because it isn't, no on on the stories of this thing, you can't have this belief in No, not on that. Not on the right wing or these. You want both of them both at the same time.
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanBit of the poet. You know, Ray, right.
NixonPoint is, there's there's some stuff there. What you want, really, and you'll throw up when I say it. What you want is a Hugh Sidey who's on our side.
Haldeman'Cause Sidey can write. Sidey can write, I know. He's so slow, awful. He's terrible. I think what you want is, who I think you want is a Teddy White who's on our side.
NixonThat's Well, that's what Sidey puts—
HaldemanSidey puts a lot more drama and poetry into it than Teddy does. Teddy is more analytical. Ted Teddy is a Teddy has a great sucker asser.
NixonOh, that's for sure. Have you seen that the uh Winston Churchill movie? It's just out. Young Winston, I read about it. Oh, it's very good.
HaldemanYeah, it's uh, they used some techniques that I think are are kind of distracting, but uh, I think they are very It's very faithful to the um to the story of his early life, I mean.
NixonIt's got to be faithful. It's got to show the warts. You know, it shows his vanity and his ambition and his mother's ambition and all that stuff. And they're very uh uh very faithfully. His father's
HaldemanSyphilis.
NixonYeah. And then, his decline and uh what it does to the kid, and all that. It's It's pretty well developed.
HaldemanIt's a tremendous uh It gives great hope to parents that you don't have to worry about your kids. They'll turn out fine if you, if you're a if you're a lousy parent anyway. God, that poor Churchill kid, you know? His father and mother were sleeping with everybody in the place. His father was insane.
NixonOh, really? What we have here is, what we have is, we don't have the time.
HaldemanIt took twenty years to write it.
NixonAnd he's Marlborough's [unintelligible] 20 years to fire his father [unintelligible].
NixonI think my guess is we're not going to find such a man, and so and I And it really gets back, I'm talking about rather that, a research thing. We've got
Haldemanuh
Nixona very fine group of They are dedicated people, taken a lot of heat to be for us. It's hard for an intellectual to be for us, that's for sure. Hard to find these people, it's just not in most of us. Could be, I suppose, if that's all that you did. But I don't know, look at our trainers, and so forth.
Haldeman30 years ago, that's just not funny.
Nixonnot a writer.
HaldemanHow would you like a nice, shiny new government?
NixonThat's what's good, too. You know, I was thinking of that, when you when you read this Churchillian stuff, I mean,
Haldemanpurpose.
NixonIt's one of the great things, John, about the British system.
NixonWas that after an election, they always take the government, you know that? And they'd sit down, and the making of a cabinet, was a big deal, right? Disraeli would go down to Hughenden, and he'd sit down, and everybody would come fawning, and this and that, and then, finally, they'd put out a new cabinet.
NixonSometimes they took people in, but normally they cut about half of them. Out they'd go. It's never been done. Interesting thing is, Well, I know. It's never been done before, that's why I say what we're doing here is much needed. I don't think it's been done before. You've got to say this for Roosevelt. Roosevelt threw a hell of a lot of people out, Franklin Roosevelt.
NixonAnd, Lincoln was loyal to the most vicious, fight, bunch of bastards, but he canned a lot of He canned a lot throughout the period, but he never had a chance to make this huge change. Eisenhower just, you know, bubbled along with it.
NixonWe just won a great victory and [unintelligible] who wasn't able to win the House and the Senate.
EhrlichmanArthur Flemming sees that as a great lost opportunity. He leaned over the other morning at the set meeting. He thought the whole structure, not to win the House and the Senate.
HaldemanNot at all. Not at all. Change. He's for making these changes.
EhrlichmanThe place to get us started, though, on on it is the question of how how you want to work with them, and how far do you want to go in trying to put together something that'll that will work the way you want to work with it, and how do you define the way you want to work with it?
NixonOh yeah, but the point here, other thing we have to remember is well, like, start with 34 conversations and we'll never get another chance to do it. That this is the last chance. That's why I'm willing to bite a hell of a lot of bullets. I don't want any regrets. There will never be any other chance, see. As for a lot of people I I doubt
Nixonjust want to temporize [unintelligible] Did you ever find out what the hell's eating Bob Finch?
EhrlichmanNo, I have a call--
NixonIt's very important for you to get him that, Bob. Tell him to come back today. There must be something up there.
HaldemanWell, I have a call in for him, too, and he hasn't returned it.
NixonWell, I've had one in incessantly. You understand I don't want to appeal to him. No, but he can't very well play the role of a rejected lover. What what's eating him? What's going on?
NixonWhat it is, I guess, is that everybody and his dog is calling everybody he knows with the idea that we shouldn't change everything up.
EhrlichmanMm-hm.
NixonIs that what it is?
HaldemanI think so. There's a lot of that going on around. As you know, we cut our phone calls off, so we have not been we've not been listening to it, but I just looking at my call list, it's pretty obvious that that there's a lot of that around.
NixonWell, cover those. It's well that tomorrow I see Agnew. I can get that handled [unintelligible] I see Connally. I'll also chew that.
HaldemanThe thorough thing, too, before we go to structure because that's [unintelligible] the whole Who's coming up today is Ash. Ash. Ash, this afternoon. We'll meet with him at noon.
NixonI don't know how useful it is for me to spend a lot of time with him, Roy. I don't think he wants to spend a lot. See, I know his it's Ketchum.
EhrlichmanYeah, we know some [unintelligible] some stuff we'd like to take you through this morning, and then you can kind of see whether where Ash fits in this thing. The first thing is one of those crossroads questions. Yeah, and there are two or three others like that that you're going to have to chew over.
NixonThese are all things, John, we can do under the law?
EhrlichmanOh, yes. Yeah, we won't give you anything that we haven't got a legal thing. That's what I've been doing while we've been thinking about it.
NixonAll right. Who is he's taken over? Who's helping with the budget thing? Who the hell is who the hell is doing the working on that?
EhrlichmanWeinberger Weinberger, and Luce, and Cole.
HaldemanWell, Cole has a Stein, and Shultz as backup, are working on it. They're back to the drawing board. I'll have something in writing again today, and we're just keeping their their nose to the grindstone on this till it gets done.
NixonNow, now you've got to remember this, too. You've got to have a damn honest look at uh what's the effect on the economy, Bob.
HaldemanThat's why Stein's in there.
NixonStein's got to be in this thing and Shultz. I'm not going to bowl the thing Remember George Humphrey made his famous hair-curler remark the first year of Eisenhower's second term. It helped to plunge the country into recession, just a remark, not what happened, not what he did, huh? But here--
HaldemanWell, we're trying to we it's what we if if things that we cut do not affect the economy adversely, it's going to be a lot different deal to me than others.
NixonI mean, social programs, and that sort of thing. I mean, they don't start a riot. Maybe maybe maybe we take the risk of a few riots, if that's what's really involved here. But I don't I know I know Cap's Cap's problem's sure.
NixonAnd he always and oh yeah, he's got the milk fund and the lunch, the school lunch. He can't do that.
HaldemanWell, those are things you don't put in things that are going to be, make you look like a goddamned hardhearted brutal bastard. Don't borrow trouble there. Uh--
EhrlichmanIt isn't as bad as uh he put on It's not as bad as it was in the first graph, Cap, was here, Cap has no judgment on such things.
NixonWell, I don't know. But that's the one problem, mister, of putting him in HEW.
EhrlichmanWhen we came back from uh When we came back from Philadelphia that day, you know, from that session there, we sat down and we went through his $10 billion in cuts, and we made a we made a major change in direction at that point, which he's been working on ever since, to try and clean the thing up and get it on
NixonLet me ask one simple question, sir, if you get into this: What did you do about the water thing? I wouldn't put nothing into water.
EhrlichmanWe are going to propose two things to you. One that, see, Ruckelshaus technically can withhold certification of projects, so that's a control point, and we're already working on that. The second is to go in with a bill at a proper level and and try and get, in effect, repealing legislation.
EhrlichmanMeanwhile, we can control the expenditures by Ruckelshaus just not certifying the projects.
NixonJust don't approve the projects.
EhrlichmanAnd so it will just--
NixonWell, I would just take that whole environmental thing, at this point, we just can't afford it till we get down to the [unintelligible] And I I feel strongly. And I I mean there is one like let's face it. Maybe it's better to clean up the air and the water than it is to have school lunches, higher school lunches are broad.
NixonSo the school lunch thing is one that you can't win on. I told Cap this, I told George Shultz this, and it keeps coming back. So that's the reason up to We can't be back. Every penny.
HaldemanSure.
EhrlichmanDon't you agree, Sir?
NixonYou bet. You can't do that. Now, the other hand, Model Cities, including Jerry Ford's thing, and the rest. The whole thing is slush. Whatever it is, flush it, all of it.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonThat doesn't bother you.
HaldemanAnd let Jerry Ford squeal. Well, we're heavy on this. This is the type of thing that we get into now.
NixonOn the education thing, I just cut in half. You know, higher education, frankly, cut in half. We can't afford it anymore. That's all. We can't do it.
EhrlichmanNational Science Foundation, half.
NixonAll right, and then let me say on the military.
NixonThere we're really going to have to rub Henry's nose right in the shit on this. You've got to get at the intelligence. I'm not referring just to the CIA. I want to get at the CIA for control purposes, because to get the left-wingers and fairies and so forth out of there.
EhrlichmanUh-huh.
NixonHuh? Most of the expenditure for intelligence is in the military. DIA. DIA. It is a horrible waste. That's one place where we can cut the military without cutting the muscle.
EhrlichmanMm-hm.
NixonBecause basically, John, their intelligence isn't worth a shit. It's duplicating and the rest, and so on that part of the military, we cut it back.
NixonBut but on Henry's point, you've got to get Take the take the Pentagon. I know where the personnel are. I don't want the personnel Rather than, if I may, please suggest, rather than cutting personnel at at Alameda, California,
Nixoncut it out of the heart of this nation's capital, where unemployment is the lowest of any goddamned area in the nation, 2 1/2 percent.
HaldemanUnderstand that.
NixonAnd cut and cut the damn Pentagon. I want to go right down the line. I would take but there I wouldn't do it on a 5% basis. I would just tell them tell the civilian people in there, "You're going to take 25% out." See, that's what it 25% across there. Go or better and have 50 and then go to 25. That's double.
NixonAlways in dealing with Henry on budget, remember he's a rag merchant.
Ehrlichman[laughter] Always, Order high, come down. [laughter]
NixonHe is. [laughter] That's why he's a pretty good negotiator.
NixonWait, see, nobody really seems to understand what I feel about personnel, like in the White House. I know it's going to be hard, Bob, to cut the White House staff. We're going to cut it. We're going to cut the goddamn Secret Service down. Cut it.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonThey've got too many. Too many guys are carrying briefcases for other people. Too many people are doing useless things. So the White House should be slim and lean and a hell of an example. And that's so that may lead to what you're going to do here. I know the Rockefeller want is to enormously increase the White House so that you can run the government.
NixonI want that White House down. I want less people to have contact with me, and I just want us and like what I talked to Colson last night. I want it clearly understood: Colson will be invaluable in what he does here to get them, while he stays here, but we have just simply got to take that whole office over there and flush it, because we don't need it anymore.
EhrlichmanWell, then that leads right into what what I think we ought to cover this morning, which
NixonAll right.
HaldemanStart in on that.
Ehrlichmanis All right. Well, that's what I that's that's that right?
EhrlichmanOkay. The problem with that, though, is is first of all, everything flows out of a basic decision. You may not want to make it.
HaldemanBut if you've made it, then we ought to have it into your consideration and that is '76.
NixonWell, the basic decision You can usually change that basic decision. I understand that. If you make the basic Let me put it this way:
NixonI recognize that we may be stuck with Agnew.
NixonI recognize on the other hand, I mean, but having in mind the fact that if the choice is between Agnew and Percy, I'm for Agnew. Let's clearly clearly understand that.
NixonIf the choice is between Agnew and John Anderson, I'm for Agnew.
NixonI'd rather lose with Agnew than win with Percy. Let's clearly understand that, clearly understand.
NixonBecause to have that kind of person in, oh, would be a disaster. He'd be worse than Teddy Kennedy.
EhrlichmanBut the other other way at that is
Ehrlichmando you want to hold him or do you want to build someone else into that role?
EhrlichmanAnd how much to how much extent do you want to chop Agnew off?
EhrlichmanHow far do you want to single him out?
NixonWell, the way the reason we chop him off is that we chop him off only by saying we're chopping the hell out of everybody else in the White House.
NixonAnd we'll put Agnew back where the Vice President was when I was Vice President, you know.
EhrlichmanCould I could I frame it a little different way?
NixonI don't know, let me say this on Agnew so that we understand it.
NixonHis various offices and perquisites and so forth,
NixonI think if you come that that if you get at this point right after the election you come up and he doesn't that if he if he doesn't accept
Nixonthe with grace the decision that is made See, the idea the way I would put it to Agnew is look, we got a goddamned tough thing to do here,
Nixonand everybody's everybody, we're just going to reorganize this top to tail. I'm not
NixonAnd I want to say, I'm going to cut the White House staff in half. I'm going to cut your staff in half.
NixonWhy not? How would you frame it?
EhrlichmanWell, I'd like I'd like to pull back to this basic question as to where he goes.
EhrlichmanIt seems to me that up until now, we've had his forced cooperation because he didn't know who's going to be on the ticket and there was uncertainty and all this and that.
EhrlichmanNow that's behind him. He's he's in, he's he's got nothing to lose Except your support in '76.
HaldemanHe's naked. He's He what?
EhrlichmanHe's got nothing to lose at this point except except your support.
EhrlichmanIf we signal at this time
Ehrlichmanthat he doesn't have it and he won't get it for any reason,
Ehrlichmanthen, of course, he's a free agent.
EhrlichmanHe's uh He's out to feather his own nest at your expense and, and he's got nothing to lose.
HaldemanAnd his friends will be free to attack the other [crosstalk] people.
EhrlichmanSure.
HaldemanYeah. Which is worse.
EhrlichmanAnd his staff will start a war. They're well they're nuts.
HaldemanThey're worse.
EhrlichmanSo I think I think you got to you got to keep what leverage you have over him as long as you can keep it.
HaldemanI agree.
EhrlichmanAnd so you don't That's why I say don't bring it off. That's why I say don't get caught at it. Sure.
NixonFrom a public standpoint you don't get caught at it, from a private standpoint to him, you just say, now look, that's all
NixonThey're going to step down. So go ahead.
EhrlichmanWell, then
Ehrlichmanat the same time,
EhrlichmanI think you you ought to
Ehrlichmandecide in your own mind whether you want to further his interests or not.
EhrlichmanIf you don't want to further his interests, then there's some things we can do right now.
HaldemanOh, we can decide that we don't want to further his interests.
NixonOkay, well then, the options basically, let me let me put it this way.
NixonAgnew's chances of being nominated are not going to make one goddamned bit of difference with what I do.
NixonI mean, we we talk about furthering an interest and so forth.
NixonI was nominated. Eisenhower was not pushing me for renomination.
NixonThe only thing that we got was was Dulles working out the trip to Russia. Dulles and Herter following, that's what we got.
NixonEisenhower was playing the game of, you know, a whole lot of other people and so forth. He was not unfriendly, but after we went in, he knew it was he knew it was there and he was not unfriendly, so. But I went out and did it on my own. I got the support.
NixonAnd Agnew will do exactly the same thing, in my opinion. He'll go gassing around through the South, out through the Midwest, and all that sort of thing. And whether we are for him or not isn't going to make one hell of a lot of difference until we get to the crunch.
NixonSo, my point is that right now, I would I don't want him to be in the appearance of being the fair-haired boy and heir apparent, if that should develop.
NixonWell, that's but on the other hand, I don't want to be in the appearance of being, deliberately trying to push him down.
EhrlichmanI understand. So there are some there are some subtleties in this. Go ahead. For instance, the Office of Intergovernmental Relations.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanHere's his contact with all kinds of organization people out across the country, a lot of a lot of mayors and so on and so forth.
EhrlichmanIf he follows his typical pattern, he will skim all the gravy off of that. He will deliver the good news,
Ehrlichmanbut when Reagan wants to call somebody and eat him out, he will refer the phone call.
EhrlichmanAnd my my strong feeling is that if you leave him with the Office of Intergovernmental Relations, you are furthering his interests,
Ehrlichmanat your disadvantage,
Ehrlichmanbecause you'll get all the negatives, and he'll get all the positives.
EhrlichmanNow there are two or three different kinds of things like that. On the other hand, there are some things that he could do
Ehrlichmanthat come under the heading of don't get caught at it, that could be assigned to him,
Ehrlichmanthat are distinctly a mixed blessing.
NixonFor example?
EhrlichmanFor example, the Bicentennial,
Ehrlichmanwhich is, right now, very damaged goods.
NixonAnd Well, yet it ought to be a hell of a show, and that's an opportunity.
EhrlichmanAnd you can plead that you can plead to him that it's a that it's a good thing for him to get into, and that it will get him out around the country, and he can go abroad and he can do all these things.
NixonFirst, I don't know what Agnew, but I mean I I have no we have no contact with any of him or his people as to what the hell he's planning for '76.
NixonIs he determined to go? And, we don't know that. See, that's the point.
HaldemanWho knows?
EhrlichmanI suspect that he he is semi-determined to go.
NixonYeah, he's ran around the country. You see you have to have
NixonThe thing that he's done, John, that is very different from things that I did like,
Nixonwhen I look at his schedule, sure, he did quite a bit.
NixonBut compared to what I did in '56, it was a goddamned cakewalk.
EhrlichmanYeah. He had three-week three-day weeks.
NixonMind, in '56, remember Oh, yeah. Jesus Christ. I was hitting it all over the country. I was doing the nationals all the I did two or three nationals always, you know.
NixonSo, it's just I carried the whole load. I really got to know the country.
NixonAnd, with Agnew, you know, he skips around. He's playing golf on the weekends and all that sort of thing.
EhrlichmanOn the other hand, in today's climate, he may be, that may do us more That may be do him more, that may have done him more good than having been sawed
HaldemanYou're You're '56, yeah, general, and you're talking about two different things. It may have been good for his image.
EhrlichmanRight.
HaldemanIt may not have done good for getting those delegates and so forth and so forth that we
EhrlichmanWell, what we're really saying is that we approach his assignment as if he if as if '76 weren't a factor. That's right. You go at it on the basis of what's the best things for him to be doing for the
NixonRight, but having in mind that having in mind the fact having in mind the fact that we
Nixonif there arises on the scene
Nixona responsible man
Nixonwho could
Nixonhave a chance to beat Teddy Kennedy,
Nixonwe would of course take him over Agnew. That decision we can't make for about a couple of years from now,
Nixonbecause there is no responsible man now. The only one,
Nixonthe only one that could do it is Connally. And Connally isn't about to do it right now, in my opinion.
NixonI mean, he's going to wait and see what's going to fall.
EhrlichmanA poker player.
NixonAnd he would have problems. But he's the only one that's got the the ability frankly, to do it. None of these people like Reagan. I mean, they talk about Reagan someone being for President, that's a joke, hell.
NixonPercy someone for President, shit, that's a worse joke. Peterson, I mean, that's just an illness.
EhrlichmanMadness.
NixonAnd Bright Young Man, you know.
HaldemanYeah.
EhrlichmanWell, of course, the Agnew isn't what you want, you side with him. Here's the guy I want to succeed me. He is.
NixonNo, there's no there's no disrespect to him to ask who the hell should be President. That's right. I wonder if anybody should.
EhrlichmanWell, it may sort down, as you get to the crunch, that he's the best of a bad lot, and then that's what you do. It's very unlikely.
NixonIt's very unlikely, in my opinion, that it will come to that that that because I
NixonI, frankly, think that Agnew lacks, is
NixonOne, I think he lacks the energy. I agree. I think there's a lack of energy there.
HaldemanNow use him as an administrative assistant [unintelligible]
NixonOver there on the right, there are some intelligent people who are not particularly with us.
HaldemanThat's right.
NixonSee, the problem is, the right right-wingers aren't for us, and the bright left-wingers aren't for us. We've got the we've got the people in the middle, who are not very smart, but they're loyal.
HaldemanSo, there we are.
EhrlichmanWell, that's you've got the the Human Events crowd. Isn't that sort of what you're talking about?
NixonThat's right. The Santa Ana Register, that's what Evans was talking about at lunch.
EhrlichmanThat That is They would be for Agnew.
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanThat's right.
NixonBecause, just for the same reason they were for Goldwater, because they think Agnew is a racist, which he is. You really have to He's not a conservative though.
EhrlichmanWay they think he is.
NixonOh, Christ! Agnew is much more liberal on a lot of this crap, you know, than I am.
EhrlichmanHe's got some funny bumps. Oh, he It's It's very hard to know how he'll stand.
NixonOn key issues, but not in any consistent fashion.
EhrlichmanNo.
NixonHe feels strongly, but not in a consistent fashion. And like we say, and the place that I'd be very the most concerned about him, of course, is foreign affairs. He just doesn't have the stroke.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonConnally, we know, is an up-and-down guy and so forth, but Connally is a hell of a big man, and a hell of a strong man. His first reactions may be wrong, but he's a guy that does talk to people, you know, and he does hear them.
HaldemanAnd he changes his mind.
NixonAnd he will change his mind like that, and Agnew doesn't. Yeah, that's true.
NixonAgnew's great problem is he will not change his mind when he's faced with facts that are just incontestable.
EhrlichmanOkay. Well, start with what you would have him do.
HaldemanHow do we get that damn intergovernmental relations thing off him?
EhrlichmanWell, I'll explain it. I'll show you. I'll show you as we develop this.
HaldemanLeave it out, because that comes in later.
EhrlichmanBecause that can be saved. That's a good thing to get him out of.
NixonI must say it. And the other thing that we might as well face, that if there were around this goddamned world,
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
Nixonthis country at the present time, somebody to build up, let me know. Brock?
EhrlichmanForget it now. That's the does the other thing. That's another thing we ought to think about.
HaldemanYeah.
EhrlichmanThe thing is you you don't have to decide that now. What you decide now is that you take a benign neglect position on the vice president and you can't get on with it.
NixonI want to face and build a presidential candidate. At least four years. At least four.
EhrlichmanThat's right. The fourth.
NixonThat's right.
EhrlichmanThat's But, we've got a bigger problem of, you know, putting the government together to start. I know.
NixonThat's why That's why I would say that when you ask me, "Do I want Agnew?" Who else?
EhrlichmanMm-hmm.
NixonThe answer is I don't know.
EhrlichmanOkay. So, that's that's a good that's a decision. You leave it right there.
NixonNow, then then the second thing: I think the answer is we don't want Agnew.
EhrlichmanAll right.
NixonWe don't want to get him any help, but we can't get caught hurting him.
EhrlichmanRight.
NixonHow's that sound?
EhrlichmanAnd, by next April or so, and no later than that, we ought to really get into a conscious thing of whether there aren't two or three people that we could give try a boost to, to challenge.
NixonThat's right. For the presidency. That's right.
EhrlichmanAnd and let's try some. So, and it ought to be two or three. We ought not to focus on one. We ought to really work to build
NixonRemember, that's the FDR scheme. And build a fight.
EhrlichmanBecause Eisenhower, you see, whether he ever had a The guy who wins a fight will be a hell of a lot better candidate than a guy you anoint and pour oil over, because, we know--
NixonOh, I'm going to get candidates for us. Yeah.
EhrlichmanYou got to get a guy who wants it worse than anything in the world and who will do anything to get it.
NixonI know. There may be some.
EhrlichmanThere may be some.
HaldemanYeah, and if we give a little encouragement [crosstalk]
Nixon[crosstalk] can do it. Did I understand--? [clears throat]
NixonListen.
EhrlichmanGo ahead.
NixonMr. I think no reason to at this time, this summary.
HaldemanThat's you.
NixonI never felt There's nothing in I never believe in reading post-mortems and I think smarter could better concentrate, and so, otherwise, you know, you get you get dreaming about this or that or
HaldemanWell, we're Well, we're planned and on the, on this
Nixonpost-mortem.
HaldemanAll I want All I want is to see it all in perspective, because if you start reading what Scotty Reston and Tom Wicker, you'll soon be affected by it. I don't want to be affected.
EhrlichmanThe main political stuff right now is a is a war in the Democratic Party and it's focused on Jean Westwood, and that's the only place for it to be.
NixonYeah. I see where McGovern was saying that, "Bill, that really, really hurt them, because Wallace out on the race." Yes.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonWell, that, too, took courage to write that.
HaldemanZiegler Ziegler called for some guidance.
NixonYeah?
HaldemanAnd I just said, "No comment. The election's over." Or was he trying to say something?
NixonI just uh the the guidance I gave him was that that's a real insult to the American voter to comment of that kind. And that he's hurting that the implication, I just heard it crack
EhrlichmanWhy would Why wouldn't you ignore the fact that he ever existed from now on?
NixonZiegler should ignore the fact, yeah. McGovern says, "I have no comment." I really think that's better.
HaldemanOkay. I think you better tell him.
EhrlichmanAll right.
NixonWhat time is it?
HaldemanIt's plenty of time. I can call him right now.
NixonThe thing that I was going to say is that I want that with McGovern. Now, the way the way to handle him and Shriver is to ignore the fact that they ever existed, except to have others attack the shit out of them.
Haldeman[unintelligible] You tell him? Call him up. Incidentally, Bob,
Nixonis John Ehrlichman going to have Ron Ziegler Can't Ziegler come up here, say, on Thursday? Can't they make this announcement Friday?
HaldemanI want this announcement, for Henry's going back, to be made by Ziegler from here, not the White House.
EhrlichmanYeah.
HaldemanWhy shouldn't he come up Friday? He and Henry should come up Friday, and then he goes out and announces it, and Ziegler responds.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanWell, he Maybe it'd be better to have him come up Thursday and spend the night, and
HaldemanGet away from me.
EhrlichmanYeah, come with you, I mean, just just for cover.
HaldemanThey'll play back, you see.
NixonGood.
EhrlichmanWell, let's see how we feel about this. I've I wish there were a guy out [crosstalk]
Nixon[crosstalk] Once that's agreed on
EhrlichmanYeah, but once we show Let's start with Shultz. Shut up and let's wait a month, and then start on that.
NixonWe
Ehrlichmanwe'll get this set now, by now.
NixonJohn, I think on that basis, we ought to ought to forget Skip the vice presidency. Go into the other structure and then go back to where our That would fit. Because we've got the I got the feeling here that the possibilities [crosstalk]
Ehrlichman[crosstalk] The the premises from which we've been proceeding: Number one, that you just mentioned, that you should be able to deal with as few people as possible.
NixonNumber one.
HaldemanAnd, so, having mentioned this, do you think this is a good idea?
NixonWhat?
HaldemanTo deal with as few people as possible?
NixonThat's the way it has to be.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonEverything that we're going to that's suggested to you are things that we believe in, right? And you believe it, and you're not suggesting it only because of my own prejudices?
EhrlichmanNo.
HaldemanNo.
NixonBecause I have some prejudices that you know are no, they're not
EhrlichmanBut they do, in all fairness, they take into account your prejudices.
HaldemanBecause, you see, you can't We can't come up and suggest that you deal with uh a daily Cabinet meeting, because we know you won't do it.
NixonNo.
HaldemanHello?
EhrlichmanRon?
HaldemanThe president would like you to just, "No comment," that McGovern crack about the uh Wallace people.
NixonAnd also
HaldemanAnd also, just, consistently, "No comment," anything McGovern says from here on out.
NixonAnd Shriver.
HaldemanWe'll get at And Shriver, and we'll get at him through others.
EhrlichmanAnd O'Brien, Westwood, or anybody.
HaldemanWell, having through others, except that, you know, from from you or the White House, you just act as if they didn't exist.
NixonO'Brien, Mrs. Westwood, Shriver,
HaldemanRight. Yeah, that's their whole problem.
NixonThe whole crowd.
HaldemanWhat'd he say?
NixonThe Wallace people would've would've were would have gone to us, huh?
HaldemanOf course they did.
NixonThat's a judgement on the Wallace people.
HaldemanNo.
EhrlichmanThat's a That's your cue, though. You just don't have any comment on political matters, you see.
NixonYou make that judgment. All right.
EhrlichmanYou just say, "Well, see, the election's over, and you just don't have any comment on any political recriminations."
HaldemanSee, but you don't say that, you just say, "No comment."
Ehrlichman"No comment."
HaldemanOkay?
EhrlichmanYep.
HaldemanThanks, Ron.
EhrlichmanFine, a good time, no problem.
EhrlichmanThere are, incidentally, there's all kinds of uh this getting down to the screw of basic workable group. There're all kinds of very solid, substantive reasons for doing it that go beyond I guess [crosstalk]
Nixon[crosstalk] You go ahead, I want to listen to those.
EhrlichmanWell, let's sketch out a little bit of of how we see it, really.
EhrlichmanYou can get away with com-pacts in in five principal areas.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanThe three at the top are basically policy areas: domestic policy, economic policy, and foreign policy, and that's mostly
NixonIssue stuff. By "economic policy," what are you talking about?
EhrlichmanForeign and domestic.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanLumping it all together: Stein, Shultz, the whole works: Cost of Living Council, uh CEA, uh the Treasury, and parts of Commerce, parts of Labor. The whole business can come at you from that one direction.
NixonUh-huh.
EhrlichmanEvery economic issue through one avenue.
NixonRight. Okay.
EhrlichmanOMB
NixonNow, I know what foreign is, I know what domestic is. What's OMB?
EhrlichmanWell, OMB is your Office of Management and Budget, and it has uh-
NixonWell, how is it different from domestic?
EhrlichmanIn a different way, all right, because domestic there, the only thing we're talking about is policy. We're talking there about developing what it is you want to do.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanOMB is one of your ways of getting it done. The White House staff is another way of getting it done.
EhrlichmanSo, basically, those three units across the top--
NixonWait. Why Why don't we talk about who works, what people are?
EhrlichmanWell, I don't want to do that until after Well, after we resolve this.
NixonTalk about those people.
HaldemanWell, who are these five?
EhrlichmanYeah, all right. Ehrlichman, Haldeman--
NixonWho's economic?
EhrlichmanEconomic would be Shultz.
NixonEvery kind?
HaldemanYes, he can do it.
NixonHe can do it.
EhrlichmanAt least the hypothetical for OMB man.
NixonThe White House OMB man.
EhrlichmanRight.
NixonGood. Now that's the five people. That's the five--
EhrlichmanThey go to head of people.
NixonAll right.
EhrlichmanAnd through those five people, by that structure, you have a route to every facet of the executive branch of the government.
NixonOMB is the whole, you know, damn good man for OMB.
EhrlichmanWell, we're we're thinking seriously of Ash as a as a recommendation to you.
NixonWell, the Ash The problem I see with Ash which we might as well talk people over, too. The problem I see with Ash is he's a McNamara type. And I I'm afraid that he's a little impetuous.
EhrlichmanSupposing his assignment were to come for eight months to do two things. One, to reorganize OMB to make it an effective management tool. Two, to pick a full-time, permanent OMB man to stay with you the balance of the time.
NixonRight. And who would he pick? Could he pick a permanent OMB guy from the outside he'll know very well?
EhrlichmanWell, it may not be from the outside. That's right. Somebody like Malek. It might be somebody else.
EhrlichmanAsh could come in as a cutting edge, as a new broom. He could He could cut heads off over there. He could rejigger that place, set it up as a management entity, which it's not now.
NixonI think it's very important, if I can just move for one thing, this theme of personalities.
NixonPart of that, Malek is mean enough, vicious enough, [laughter] and too, and also good enough judge of people that he will get some good people. We've got to do better on people except we've got to do better on people.
EhrlichmanWell--
NixonThat's Absolutely, and that's for we're And who has, I wouldn't have much confidence in Ash, you know. He's outside.
EhrlichmanOf course, Fred is working on people right now. Ash is Ash is completely outside though, and Ash is the one guy who understands the concept of the OMB in the way that it ought to be shifted.
NixonAll right.
EhrlichmanHe is not, in my view, the ideal guy to run it.
NixonMalek might be.
EhrlichmanCan we move on? Right ahead. But let's-- Let's move to the next rank here. All right. You see those five dark circles are the five circles you had on that first one.
NixonNext rank. All right.
EhrlichmanAnd behind them now are, like over there with Henry on the foreign side, he's got Defense, and State, and CIA, and the various makeups of the the various constituents, so to speak. Now, look at the domestic side. This is where we begin to shift into the reorganization mode,
Ehrlichmanbecause behind me, so to speak, on the domestic side are three secretaries:
EhrlichmanSecretary of Natural Resources, Community Development, and Human Resources.
NixonNow, how do you do that? In other words, you're going to just tell the secretary of Let's take Natural Resources.
EhrlichmanRight.
NixonTell the secretary Which one of the Cabinet are you going to demote?
EhrlichmanWell, no, we're not. He's going to be the secretary of Interior.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanAnd, let's take Let's take Community Development as an example. We appoint a secretary of HUD. We say to the secretary of Agriculture, "Mr. Secretary, when you take this job, you have to delegate
NixonRight.
Ehrlichmana certain number of your uh authorities to the secretary of HUD." This is legal.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanSo by delegation, that secretary becomes a super secretary, because he now has control over some things that belong in Agriculture, even though he's the secretary of HUD.
NixonRight. And that we would tell the pen we would tell the new secretary of Transportation that he or she delegates the Coast Guard to the Defense Department.
EhrlichmanYou can do that. You can't quite do that, [unintelligible] that.
EhrlichmanNow, what happens is that, organically, and law, they're still over there under Transportation, but he has delegated Volpe's successor has delegated to Laird's successor certain prerogatives with regard to the deployment of ships, and that that force levels and things of that kind,
NixonRight.
Ehrlichmanwhich the lawyers tell me it's possible for them to do.
NixonYeah. Now, I have to Again, back to that little diagram. Behind on the domestic side there, you've got
EhrlichmanJustice Well, now, we don't know. I, personally, prefer to tuck Justice in under the Human Resources guy.
NixonBob-- Never.
EhrlichmanWell, ever Okay. Bob disagrees. What do you mean?
NixonYou'd give that to Elliot Richardson?
EhrlichmanOh, no. No, no, no.
NixonNow, you're not talking about Elliot Richardson here.
EhrlichmanCould be Weinberger.
NixonIt It might be Weinberger.
NixonTo get to have him make decisions, uh, and recommendations about who's going to go into the courts and all that? No, no, no.
NixonProsecutions about antitrust, about You've still got--
EhrlichmanYou've still got an attorney general and he's running the Justice Department.
NixonGeneral, you know, got to have a special relationship with the president.
EhrlichmanOkay, well then that That's fine. That's what that dotted line is. The merit to that also is that that keeps you within the reorganization thing. You stay with the the form of the reorganization.
NixonReorganization. And, in that case, we've just got to, now, what I would do, I don't want to have Kleindienst rushing in here every 5 minutes. So what I will do in this respect, you've got to have a relationship between you and Kleindienst.
EhrlichmanThat's right.
EhrlichmanWhich would make which would make Justice a fourth of those. Oh, that's what we did. See, that's what that fourth circle is there.
HaldemanCentral circle there.
NixonYou want to keep Kleindienst, Dick?
HaldemanWell, I don't know. The only thing, that's all he proposed last evening. He's recommending that he be kept. But, I don't know whether he is or not.
NixonListen, Dick's a good fellow, but damn. Well, we'll see. We'll decide that later.
EhrlichmanNow, the way this would The way this would function somewhat like the Domestic Council set-up that you have now. Looking just at the domestic side,
Ehrlichmanexcept that--
HaldemanOne one small interrupt in my practice.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanThere're still 7 or 8 birthday calls.
NixonI know, but I'm not doing calls.
HaldemanAnd, mainly, because it just isn't right. Send either wires or letters. Or, unless they're having a party or something,
Nixonthen I'll then I'll make a call.
NixonI call Mrs. Eisenhower, of course, because that's something different.
HaldemanNo, we're holding those. That's the only This is one that I do think you have to make, which is to Scoop Jackson who's in
NixonWhere?
Haldemanin Tel Aviv, but he called and said he wanted to talk to you in related to his last conversation with you. You'll know what it's all about. In other words, it's important from your standpoint to be talking to him.
NixonYeah, yeah.
HaldemanAll right.
NixonAnd, uh, he's He went up to that place.
HaldemanHe wants to talk with you between 11:00 and 12:30 our time today, which is anytime in the next hour and a half.
NixonAll right, we'll do it. That's all.
NixonGlad to call him.
NixonThe others are birthday calls.
HaldemanNo, that's it.
HaldemanThat's that's the only call I have.
NixonOkay, go ahead. And you say Mitchell assigns Kleindienst to be tackled. What the hell was that?
EhrlichmanWell, that's the story that's We're reading that in the paper. We don't know whether that's so or not.
HaldemanI could just talk to Mitchell and find out. Did he have a fight with him?
HaldemanYeah, I think you should call.
NixonI'm going to.
NixonWell, goddamn, that department's got to be changed. All those all those assistant AGs and deputy AGs, they all have to go. Up and down the line.
HaldemanUp and down the line.
NixonAnd we must have a lot of good young lawyers, haven't we, that are loyal? Oh, we can find people for that.
HaldemanYes, we can. That's no problem.
EhrlichmanThat's no problem.
EhrlichmanNow, what becomes of the National Security Council? What becomes of the Domestic Council, and so forth? I think it would be possible
Ehrlichmanto to reconstitute some of these councils so that you can say to the vice president, and to the head of the OEP and people of that kind, "Look,
HaldemanYeah.
Ehrlichmanwe're operating under a different mode now." And we drop out of the Domestic Council about 11 people.
NixonGood.
EhrlichmanAnd you end up with a with a Domestic Policy Council, which is not the Domestic Council.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanDomestic Policy Council, that's different. And you only have those folks on.
EhrlichmanThe three super secretaries, so to speak, attorney general,
NixonRight.
Ehrlichmanand your and your I would have the attorney general on it.
NixonWell All right, we can drop the other.
NixonThe attorney general, that's The attorney general, frankly, shouldn't be sitting in there, unless he's a man of superior qualifications. Why do we have Mitchell on various things? Because of what his judgment Sure, sure.
NixonWhy the hell do we want Kleindienst? Okay, anyway.
EhrlichmanOkay. That will work out all right, because behind that, you see, the the fellow who is the secretary for Natural Resources can have his own policy group,
Ehrlichmanconsisting of the secretary of Agriculture, the secretary of Commerce, so forth.
NixonHow do I have contact with these poor bastards that are going to be members of the Cabinet, then?
EhrlichmanYou don't.
NixonYou don't. Well, put some on the personal thing, though.
EhrlichmanWell, you have a party for them, or you can, uh, you can call them in for a, for a, uh-- And you could have a meeting with them time to time, or you talk about--
HaldemanYou know, you report on your trip to Israel or something. Yeah, but But, uh, we should I think we should have Cabinet meetings for that kind of purpose,
NixonYes.
Haldemannot for very important big things that cut across all the agencies, so god--
EhrlichmanThey'd like to watch it.
EhrlichmanWhen the secretary of Agriculture's picked, this ought to be reviewed with him, so he has no illusions about his function.
EhrlichmanHe's in a secondary capacity. If he doesn't want it, though--
NixonThat's right.
Ehrlichmana department's breath.
NixonYeah, absolutely.
EhrlichmanHe's got to work through natural resources or economic development, whichever it happens to be, fits in.
HaldemanThat's right.
NixonAnd he would set—really, how much of this to make public?
HaldemanAll of it.
EhrlichmanI think you would say this is a revolutionary approach to the administration and business of the executive branch.
HaldemanWell, let's go to the next step, but let's take these individual—
EhrlichmanFirst of all, let me explain why this is important as I see it.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanYou have two motives: one is, of course, to make the executive branch work better, the other is to permit us to get a lot of stuff off of your desk and out of the White House and cut down the White House staff.
HaldemanPush decisions down where they belong.
EhrlichmanSo, when a—when a decision comes in, we say, "Look, that's a decision that can be handled within the natural resources group
Ehrlichmanamong you fellas. Mr. Secretary of Natural Resources, it's your job to resolve that.
EhrlichmanThere's no reason why the president has to referee between—"
NixonWho do we name [sighs] Rogers Morton, Secretary of Natural Resources?
EhrlichmanUh, I don't think he's up to it.
NixonWell, that's the whole point, then we get a new guy there, then he has to go.
HaldemanRight.
EhrlichmanRight.
HaldemanAnd you don't name him secretary of natural resources. We've got to call him a different name, you see.
NixonYeah, but we've got to find a way so that it gets around the congressional thing.
HaldemanWell, the the way, and it you won't like it because of its precedent, but the best title for it is the one John came up with, really, which is counselor for natural resources.
HaldemanNow, you're not adding any cabinet-level type thing. You're using counselor in that sense.
EhrlichmanThat's right.
HaldemanAnd you have a counselor for natural resources who is the Secretary of the Interior, and a counselor for—
NixonYou'll give him an extra title, counselor.
HaldemanHe has two portfolios. That's right.
EhrlichmanWhich is perfectly proper.
HaldemanNow, we'll we'll go on to talk about another aspect to that.
NixonThat's all right. You buy that? I buy that concept. The counselor doesn't bother me, it's how you use it.
HaldemanI know. You just didn't want a bomb—
NixonI don't want a bomb, Finch, and—
Haldeman—everybody counselor.
Nixon—Rumsfeld and no fifth-wheel counselor.
HaldemanThese aren't fifth wheels. These are in wheels.
NixonAll those people sit around the cabinet table.
EhrlichmanBehind the counselor is his own council.
EhrlichmanAnd he brings together the cabinet officers concerned with natural resources maybe once a week.
EhrlichmanAnd they talk about their mutual problems, and they try to iron out their conflicts, and they work out
Ehrlichmancoordination among their respective departments in that subject-matter area. And those things don't get to your desk.
EhrlichmanNow, of course, what we spend so much of our time on is when what Butz and Morton can't agree on forest lands.
NixonThen we have to referee it.
EhrlichmanNow, the counselor for natural resources will referee it, and he'll decide it.
NixonI've got a thought. Why not make Butz counselor for natural resources?
EhrlichmanCould be.
NixonButz is a buttoned-down, tough political guy.
EhrlichmanPolitical guy.
NixonRight?
HaldemanAnd let Agriculture take the lead instead of Interior?
NixonYou see my— You see what I mean?
HaldemanSure.
NixonYou see my point?
HaldemanSure.
NixonAnd, and then that way, and then and then, then you can keep Rog.
HaldemanFart around with the with the parks. He can do very well with that.
NixonIndians and so forth.
NixonJust another small thing, remember that Hartzog has got to go, please, pretty soon.
HaldemanAbsolutely.
NixonYou work on that?
EhrlichmanYes.
HaldemanYou were saying, "Do you publicize this?"
HaldemanThe way A way to publicize it and a way to make it work is the thing John alluded to the other day.
HaldemanThose three people, supersecretaries, you put into offices in the Executive Office Building.
HaldemanSo they are part of the president's staff in their role as counselor.
HaldemanAnd you set up they don't bring the big apparatus in, they just bring there you know, an administrative assistant and a secretary.
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanAnd they spend a major portion of their time in the EOB.
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanNow, obviously, they have an office in their department, too, and they do spend some time over there. But the concept would be that the undersecretary runs the department.
NixonRight.
HaldemanAnd that this guy, the counselor, is not responsible for running his department day-to-day. The undersecretary is.
HaldemanThat leaves you within your your, you know, existing legislative—
NixonNow what do we do in the meantime? Do we continue to press for our reorganization thing?
HaldemanAbsolutely. Try to get all of the—
EhrlichmanAnd we demonstrate that it's working.
HaldemanWe demonstrate the viability of it.
HaldemanYou have a hell of a dramatic thing if you pull this off.
HaldemanThen you move those guys in, you set them each up in the EOB, and you set up—then you have your your council
Haldemanthat works. They're there together. They can talk to each other. They are presidentially oriented instead of departmentally
Haldemanoriented, which is the whole crux of the problem we have now.
NixonLet's talk a minute about the other areas.
HaldemanOkay.
EhrlichmanHere's Here's Henry's side: instead of the NSC with the—
HaldemanNow, you've got another problem. The NSC is set up by law.
EhrlichmanIt is set up by law, but it doesn't and the law doesn't say it has to meet.
NixonThe membership is set—
EhrlichmanThat's right.
HaldemanAnd you leave it and you can have a meeting of the NSC once in a while.
EhrlichmanSure.
HaldemanBut your working unit is the Foreign Policy Council.
EhrlichmanIncidentally, in here, Generation of Peace is a hell of a lot better thing to talk about than the National Security Council
Ehrlichmanbecause it is foreign policy.
EhrlichmanThe NSC staff services it, but, uh, the NSC is a—
NixonHave you Have you pitched Have you pitched that to him? I, I don't mean bring Henry's apples into it because they are related to it.
EhrlichmanYes.
NixonAre you Have you, did you praise Henry about the fact that he's got to decimate that goddamned staff of his, too?
EhrlichmanYes. He's got to go with the rest.
HaldemanHe agreed to. We had dinner with him the other day. Yeah, he's working on it. Yep.
NixonWe've really just ruined our— Everybody that comes in they just they work.
EhrlichmanWell, you see, going back to the domestic thing, I could cut out 80% of the domestic power—uh, the Domestic Council staff.
NixonYou don't have many people, do you?
EhrlichmanWell, I have 29 or something that's, you know— But I could cut down three or four—
NixonYeah, that's already small.
EhrlichmanYeah, I can cut down to three or four professionals.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanUh, because we'll force all the work back down through the counselors into their own staffs
Ehrlichmanto get this analytical work done, get the refereeing done, get the papers written, get the speeches written, and all that kind of stuff.
EhrlichmanNow, there's a there's a similar thing you can do with the economic side.
NixonWhy do you put, uh, OMB and assistant for economic policy in there?
EhrlichmanWell, because so much of what goes on in there in the way of development of policy affects budget, affects management, and, hopefully, OMB will be the way—
NixonWho leads that council?
EhrlichmanShultz.
HaldemanThe point is you never meet with that council primarily.
EhrlichmanAnd then the whole system would have to be with him and he'd sit in on whatever—
HaldemanIt would be said You wouldn't tell him you're going to meet with them, and you're not the chairman of it.
NixonRight.
HaldemanAnd, ha, I would see that council as probably never meeting. I'd see that council as really only a paper device in order to to bind those people into that category.
NixonWell, have you talked to Henry about this concept?
HaldemanYes.
NixonDoes he agree with it?
EhrlichmanYes, completely.
NixonWhat does he What does he say about the papers and so forth, you know, that he likes to get in and warm up before the NSC?
HaldemanWe'd still do that.
EhrlichmanHe'd still— You'd have to keep your NSC mechanism for for control purposes.
NixonAlso, that's this the reason this has to be raised that that's part of the aid thing.
HaldemanAll right.
NixonAid is a member is a statutory member of the NSC, so—
HaldemanWell, you don't ever say to anybody we're going to do anything about the NSC. You just don't get around to having— You haven't had a meeting for six months anyway.
NixonAll right. Okay. Every time I've got to the point now—
EhrlichmanNow, we think Shultz ought to move into the EOB, also.
NixonWell, how about secretary of the treasury?
EhrlichmanAnd he should coordinate and operate a a, uh, policy council that is both foreign and domestic.
NixonI agree. Can't have both. Can't separate those anymore.
EhrlichmanThe CIEP, if it if it continues to exist as a coordinating mechanism, it's run at a low-level staff office within his economic policy council.
NixonYeah.
NixonRight. Anyway, Shultz understands that better than anybody else.
NixonI mean, he's a—you know what I mean. But when I say better than anybody else,
NixonShultz is a is a sounder,
Nixonuh, more economist, that is.
HaldemanYeah, and frankly, let's let's face it, Pete and Peterson didn't have the answers either.
EhrlichmanYeah, he just knows more about the subject.
HaldemanWell, and and and his judgment will be better.
EhrlichmanUh, the the CEA would, on uh according to statute and so on, have a direct line to you,
Ehrlichmanbut you would say that direct line comes through Shultz.
HaldemanRight.
NixonOh, sure. So does the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs have to have a direct line, but it comes through Henry.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonThat's right.
EhrlichmanFine.
HaldemanOkay. But you you walk—
NixonYeah, I've got to pass some deals anytime I go— I've got to be brave with that because
Nixonwe've got to find ways that Henry—
NixonHenry has one problem, we got to guarantee him.
NixonHe He is
Nixonhe's passionately insistent
Nixonthat he must sit in on every meeting I have with anybody, and he cannot do that anymore.
NixonThere will be occasions when I've got to sit down with De Gaulle alone.
NixonI could have avoided some of the problems on this summit, if I had—
HaldemanWell, let's Let me suggest, with with the risk of sounding so certain, that one of one of the things you can do there that solves that problem
NixonTell me what you said.
Haldemanis use your White House staff for that.
HaldemanIn other words, that's your own personal staff—
NixonThat's right.
Haldeman—which is different than your policy staff.
HaldemanAnd then you cover that is through me, and I can assure Henry that it's going to be covered,
NixonYou report to him.
Haldemanand I can tell him whatever needs to be covered, or John, in the case of domestic.
NixonThat's right. That's right.
HaldemanAnd it's a way that you can play both games, which you need to do sometimes.
NixonThis is all right.
EhrlichmanThe other, in the way of in the way of controlling the bureaucracy is something I don't think we need to take a lot of time on except to say that that we're going to work with Ash so that every agency, every bureau,
Ehrlichmanevery aspect of the executive branch is brought into the system through one of either the super secretaries on the domestic side or through one of the principal assistants.
HaldemanThere are no independent independent agencies. Nobody reports directly to you from an agency, NASA and all that stuff. What do you do with the law? Why, don't worry about the law. You delegate-
EhrlichmanSee, you delegate your authority to the secretary, which you have a right to do.
HaldemanSo, they report to you via somebody else. That's all.
EhrlichmanWe'll do all paperwork. We can structure this thing so that it'll hold water legally.
Nixon[unintelligible]
EhrlichmanThat's not That's not a problem. But the main thing here is-
NixonWell, why don't you try to sell- If you could, [unintelligible]
HaldemanNo, there's no question. I think she could if you decide on the way to do it. And that's why I would like to bring Roy Ash in instead of OMB is is to use Roy Ash for selling a lot of this stuff. You've got the Ash Council mystique.
EhrlichmanHe'd be perfect with Rockefeller, John. He'd He'd babble on for for eight hours, and when it was all done, Rockefeller wouldn't know which end was up, and and he'd say, "My god, that guy is brilliant."
Haldeman[unintelligible] I I keep going back to the Blue Room episode where Ash tried to sell OMB. Never use him with a group. Yeah.
HaldemanNever use him with a group. And John Connally sold them the group.
Ehrlichman[Laughs] That's right. But Connally will back you up on that. Yeah. I think Connally Connally-
NixonDid you talk to Connally about this, now, John?
EhrlichmanA little, yeah. He likes this. Basically He basically wants a chief. Now, we've gotten into the details in this thing because we haven't We've been This is a hell of a complex thing we're trying to untangle and simplify here. And it's-
NixonLet me come Let me come back. You see, we've got to also work politically into this. If you will read the history of of the of the of the better political presidents, FDR,
NixonTR, and Lincoln. They're about only ones that up in our that it is in the last 100 years. But in every instance, they ran the show the way they wanted to run the show, right? But
Nixonthey they took into the fact the political thing. Like, like TR, TR, of course, always said, "I'm hyphenated, but, you see, you got to get a Jew, and you got to get a Catholic, and call them all that." He did it. FDR did it quite open. And so I come to the same thing. But that's why I come to Butz.
NixonNo reason to have you see, the farm constituency, as distinguished from the Interior constituency- Right. is a terribly brutal one.
NixonSo, you put them in charge, and you soothe farmers. Think of them rewarded. Their man is in charge of it, rather than having some asshole that we will get for Secretary of the Interior.
HaldemanI agree it'll work, too. And Butz is a I think will prove he's a ballplayer. He's smart as hell.
NixonThat's right. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's what I-
EhrlichmanI had a talk with Butz. Interestingly enough, he came to me with a suggestion not too far different than this, as a as an idea. You see, putting him in charge of Interior.
NixonRather than Interior in him. Yeah. Sell all the farm problems. He agrees that the single, isn't that plus instead of the minus.
HaldemanAnd it singles that the environmentalists and all of that, that that isn't the overriding consideration. Exactly.
EhrlichmanWell, more than that, you're picking him as a man in whom you have confidence, and with whom the farmers identify. That that's a-
HaldemanYou're picking Weinberger as a man in whom we have confidence. That would be who we're doing the presentation.
EhrlichmanHe would be the Human Resources guy, but the Secretary of HEW. Yep. And you pick Shultz for the Economic.
HaldemanRight. And Then the one for Community Development, you still have to get him, right?
EhrlichmanHe would be, probably, the Secretary of HUD as well, but you'd get a strong under secretary to run HUD,
Ehrlichmanand you'd put this guy in the EOB. See, the the thought here is that these three secretaries become the President's men out to the departments rather-
HaldemanWhat you're doing is making the cabinet your staff, and using them as your staff, rather than having them as independent fiefdoms. And this is exactly the concept that a corporate, a conglomerate corporation uses. Litton Industries and Ash.
HaldemanThis was not Ash's idea. This was our idea, or the idea that Ash, but Ash was ecstatic when we went over it. He said, "That's exactly how we want to run them." All of our sub
Haldemancompany heads, our group vice presidents, our group presidents are housed in our hey, I'm headquarters.
NixonHow worried Where do we come out with Agnew on this? Let's not bite Agnew. Isn't that Aren't you ready to talk about that? Well,
EhrlichmanI think it's a It's almost peripheral. You say that, "I do want to go to this new mode. It will enable me to cut my White House staff about X percent. It is a very important signal to the country that I am doing this.
EhrlichmanI'm looking to use to do the same kind of thing with your organization, but at the same time, I think you and I can agree that your staff has not been of adequate quality
Ehrlichmanto discharge the the kinds of heavy responsibilities that I would hope you could take on in the next four years." You can't say that.
NixonWell, you can't.
HaldemanNo, he's one thing about Agnew, he's a oversensitive man. I'll I'll tell you He's said this to me one time.
EhrlichmanHe told me that he recognized that his staff was not adequate. Here's a chance for you to upgrade your own staff. Okay. Well, that's the way to do it. You can do it better than I can.
NixonThey can say, "Fewer and fewer people, and better people. What I'm doing, I have confidence in all my staff, and they're wonderful people. But I'm going to slaughter them out to the-
Nixonfor the thing. You've got to do the same to have few people only around you, but have them better. And then And I'll say you're going to be judged for the country by what kind of people you have around you."
EhrlichmanIn the process, you will, see he doesn't have a very He doesn't have as much He has an enormous staff, but it isn't his own personal staff, he draws on a lot of other things and you can collapse some of those, could you start down the list.
EhrlichmanThe National Aeronautics and Space Council, our intention would be to to collapse it. Is that set up by law?
HaldemanYes, but all you do is you don't hire a director and you don't ever have a meeting of the council. It It doesn't have to meet.
EhrlichmanAnd there's nothing in the world that it does either.
HaldemanAnd you assign its responsibilities to the Vice President, what other, what other, what other
EhrlichmanHe has a He has an Indian uh, Opportunity Council. Shit. He has a Youth Employment or uh, app- apparatus of some kind and that we can tuck into Human Resources.
NixonYeah, but why don't they run Could you tell him that he could of course work on all these things as a- I wouldn't. No, I wouldn't. Then he'll screw it up. He'll get into it. What What you should say to him is, "Look,
Ehrlichmanwe're taking all of our independent agencies, and we're tucking them in under the departments. You should do the same.
HaldemanNot you should, we're we are doing yours. We are going to your-
EhrlichmanAnd we're doing the same with yours. But there is an enormous challenge that we all have to give attention to and I think you're the man to lead his whole month and that's the American Bicentennial.
NixonI can also tell him, "I don't know what your plans are for 1976, but if I were you, I would stay off of all these controversial domestic wrestles. I'd go into something the whole country's for, and travel abroad, and travel around the country.
NixonGet helping states on its rests."
EhrlichmanNow, the Office of Intergovernmental Relations is the other one that he has, and he has it because you gave it to him. It is not by law. It should come in to the federal government under this Counselor for
EhrlichmanCommunity Development, because that's both rural and urban. The whole The whole thing that the that the governors and the mayors want is an avenue to you.
NixonYeah.
Ehrlichmansay, "Sit down. What about that?" He comes in with it. He doesn't want to take it, he just signed. Well, he's got to take it.
NixonOr do you think I ought to sit down, explain all these charts to him, so on, charts charts? No.
HaldemanIn fact, you can say we I think you ought to talk to him first, rather than our explaining it to him first. Because we explain it to him first and he'll come in and appeal to you.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanI think it's better for you to talk to him first and say, "We are, I am in a sharp end-of-the-year review of this. I've had Ash working on it, as you know. He was up here yesterday. We've gone lots of stuff track, and we've got it worked out. I've made my decision, all this we're going to go in. And now I want to have John explain it to you in as much detail as you want."
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanThat's the way to do him. Yeah. Yeah.
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd that's loop.
Nixon[unintelligible] This is not the Matter of a Little Circumstance Show, but this is a matter of a bloody, bloody.
HaldemanAnd we're going to have to be ready for the blood, because some somebody's going to come in and say, "I got to talk to you about that." You can say, "No, Charlie, you talk to Sam."
EhrlichmanI'm sure you realize there's one major problem, which is the only one of these that [unintelligible]
HaldemanNo.
EhrlichmanDomestic Council is headed by
HaldemanThe Domestic Policy Council is headed by Ehrlichman.
EhrlichmanI know, but he's not Cabinet officer.
HaldemanThe only one that is, as a matter of fact, is Shultz. And he's not heading it as a Cabinet officer, he's heading it as a as a, as a your assistant for economic policy.
Nixon[unintelligible]
EhrlichmanNow, we I would think, in, in talking about this to anybody, you would downplay the councils.
HaldemanOh, absolutely.
EhrlichmanI'm not sure you even even announce the existence of the Council.
HaldemanYou play the Counselor. The Counselors.
EhrlichmanYeah.
HaldemanBecause they are the Cabinet and and the way this should be written is, the President has moved to a strong, lean, small Cabinet.
EhrlichmanYeah.
HaldemanAnd the emphasis is on the Cabinet instead of the staff, which is true. We don't talk about that.
EhrlichmanThe main thing in selling it to the public, the lean, small Cabinet will be a, you know, interesting political science, those of us who know [unintelligible]
HaldemanFor the public the most important thing is, we're cutting the White House staff.
EhrlichmanStaff by 50%.
HaldemanAnd cutting out bureaucratic red tape. Yeah. And just as you said, cut White House staff 50%. That will have one hell of an effect, Mr. President.
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd thoroughly do it. Now, that gets into the conflicts that are going to bother you. Like Colson said, you got to keep a labor man on the White House staff. Now as soon as you have a labor man on the White House staff, you're shooting down this concept.
HaldemanAnd and maybe you want to there. Maybe you politically, you feel that that's what you have to do. But every one of those you do is going to, is going to eat away at that staff.
NixonWell, I don't give a damn about labor man on the White House staff. I suppose it's the idea of a labor man in the White House. But then do you have a Jew, to keep what, to keep track of the Jews? No.
HaldemanNo.
EhrlichmanSee, you, you've got What I would, what I would like to have, to have a labor man
HaldemanUh-huh.
Ehrlichmanis your Secretary of Labor should be your labor man.
HaldemanAnd a direct line to you on on labor relation matters as contrasted to labor policy matters.
NixonWe must not build that. We must break over with the Jews, the arts, and all this other stuff.
HaldemanI agree. All, that's what we're talking about, dump all that. Give it to the departments, make Put the arts in the in the human resources department, that's where it belongs. Let them screw around with it. Then get the right people with the right concepts on it, too. They come
HaldemanAnd you get rid of your science advisor, you don't have a science advisor anymore, and you don't have a President's Science Advisory Committee.
NixonThat's set up by law, though?
HaldemanYes, but you don't staff it.
NixonI just don't appoint one.
EhrlichmanThe Office of Science and Technology.
HaldemanNo, you've got the Office of Science and Technology
Ehrlichmanunder
Haldemanthe, the Economic
HaldemanScience advisor is not set up by law. The Director of the Office of Science and Technology is.
NixonIs that so?
HaldemanSo what you do is you put him over someplace else.
NixonCan I do that?
HaldemanSure.
NixonYou can?
EhrlichmanPutting that, putting that for housekeeping purposes, so for orderly, orderly cut out duplicated [unintelligible]
HaldemanThe point is you don't need a separate science advisor. 15 years ago Eisenhower did because you had a Sputnik problem, and help. It made sense then.
HaldemanNow, you can argue that you do need a special drug adviser, maybe, because that's the big war now.
HaldemanJohn thinks you do, I'm not so sure. It's, I'm scared to death because it sliced over anything then.
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonHow sure is he about the cancer thing?
NixonYou talk about the cancer thing too. HEW?
NixonYeah, but HEW will drown it.
HaldemanNo, not if you run this right. You can You see, with something like that that you want to give high visibility to, you don't put it in a department.
HaldemanPut it as a an office that reports directly to the counselor on That's right. Human Resources,
Haldemanwhich means directly to the President, in effect.
NixonScience directly to Economic, right?
HaldemanBecause basically it is now an arm of economic development.
NixonWhat about PSAC? Is that still around?
HaldemanYes.
HaldemanBut you see, you're removing it an additional step away from you.
NixonThe only thing that bothers me about PSAC, it covers military and
HaldemanThat's why these, that's why you use the economic guy because he covers military, he covers both foreign and domestic.
NixonI didn't think he covers military.
HaldemanSure he does.
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanWhat you do is, you sub What do we do with our Action? You know, we're behind Henry's in that.
NixonThat whole set of things, yeah.
HaldemanHenry's got a whole cluster. He's got Selective Service and Action and uh uh a number of odds and ends of agencies that are sort of presidential agencies over there.
HaldemanSome of those will collapse totally, some of them you can decline substantially.
HaldemanI would argue, we haven't looked into it, Ash probably has, we'll get it this afternoon, that the Office of Science and Technology, for example, what you do is you decimate it. You divide it up and you have a science advisor to to to the Defense Secretary, a science advisor to the uh Agriculture Secretary, and a couple of other science advisors scattered around, instead of one whole, overall science advisor, which doesn't make any sense, and all science is
NixonWhat about that McCloy committee? Is that set up by law?
HaldemanI don't uh uh I'm not sure. It's so
NixonWhat about the PFIAB? Is that set up by law?
HaldemanYes, yep.
NixonWhat do I do with that?
HaldemanWe can play with all those.
NixonYou have to, see, there is the problem, those take up a hell of a lot of time, and [unintelligible]
HaldemanSure. If every one of those PFIAB is under Henry's operation, it puts it, be put behind one of these, one of these principal uh uh departments.
NixonNow and then, I would meet with them.
HaldemanIf you like. At your option.
HaldemanThe point is that they have a way of working that doesn't require their meeting with you, and they and they know it.
HaldemanWell, and and all of the expectations are taken out, because you sit down with all those people right now since you've got everybody's resignation, and you say a condition of your reemployment, or a condition of your employment is your subscription to this mode of operation.
Nixon[unintelligible] between 11:30 and uh
HaldemanNo, you've got another half hour.
EhrlichmanYou got another hour.
HaldemanCall for 12:00, why don't we come back? Do it now, it'd be better.
NixonUh Senator Jackson of uh Washington is in Tel Aviv and has been trying to reach me. You can place the call anytime now. As soon as you get it, put it through. Senator Henry Jackson of the state of Washington. He's in Tel Aviv.
OperatorRight, sir.
HaldemanI think you ought to get the White House operators up here.
NixonI don't know.
HaldemanHow hard do you agree?
EhrlichmanYes, sir. I do, uh I've been right on the verge of doing it. I think these guys are great, but, you know, they're they're over their heads.
HaldemanYep, they are, and we get too much going through here now.
EhrlichmanAnd this move to thank you.
NixonDid we get the trailer to work on, then?
EhrlichmanYes, sir. Be here this afternoon.
NixonGreat.
HaldemanYou're going to get a good, you know, big 10x50 foot trailer, a nice big room, is what it is.
NixonHeat, does it have a lavatory?
HaldemanA lavatory and you know, have electric power and uh a little refrigerator. We'll have plate refrigerator in there, and have table, and we'll set a bank of telephones so they can file from there. And then a little lounge area at the other end for the briefings.
EhrlichmanI'd like to have a meeting for the Friday announcement.
HaldemanIt will be.
EhrlichmanIt will be, so that Ziegler can say
HaldemanZiegler goes over there and briefs. Yeah.
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanSo, sure you know what you want to have this, so
NixonAll right.
EhrlichmanHave somebody--it might be you, it could be John Mitchell--who's got to sit down on him and Ziegler.
NixonLay out a PR program for us for the next, for the balance of the interim period.
EhrlichmanYeah. So that it doesn't bleed, bleed, bleed, bleed.
NixonLeak and have a, have a leak. I don't mean that, no, I agree with what he did, but you can't, well, because you've got a situation where--
EhrlichmanNow uh, first thing then, is tell Ron this afternoon. We should call him personally and be very, uh, firm.
NixonBe our plan for this, too. Oh, and uh say, when we talk to the Vice President, for instance, it ought to be under the agreement that nothing is said by him to his staff or anybody else.
Ehrlichmanuntil he asks for the resignations of his staff, because until that happens I don't know that he was asked yet. I don't know whether he's had a--
NixonWell, we can now.
NixonThe, the way I see this, with the kind of loose ends that we've just been talking about, FIAO and so on, it's probably going to be the day before Thanksgiving before we have this what?
EhrlichmanYeah. Pulled together.
NixonPulled together. But the point is, it must be put in place
Ehrlichmanbefore--
NixonOh, sure. No question. Sure. But supposing we were to hypothesize this. Let's suppose we could get it all pulled together. You then can say, "We've had a We've had a good two weeks. I'm now going to Florida for a couple of days off. We'll have some announcements when I get back. Staff work uh is going on while I'm gone,
EhrlichmanRight.
Nixonputting the finishing touches. So the, either the last day or two of November, or the first day of of December
Nixonyou could make an overall announcement on this.
NixonPR, what I would, my view of the PR is so important that every job, until it's thoroughly understood, is that it be a brief, very, very crisp piece. And that there, that there can be, there could be whisked into first draft some good, elegant language into it. Don't have Price write it, but, you know,
EhrlichmanEle-
Nixonelegant in terms of, like on the trolley press, because this isn't good prose, but good prose. Strong prose.
NixonHello.
JacksonYeah.
NixonYes, your voice is loud and clear. I hope you're having a good trip.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonGood. Naturally, you would know you would know to extend my warmest regards to the Prime Minister here, and to our friends there, and also uh particularly to the Shah. You should have a good talk with him. He's He's our He's our great friend. And the Saudis, of course.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonYes. And the Saudi uh their troops. Right, right.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonWell, he's he's not well, anyway. So it's the, what is it, the Secretary of Defense? Yeah.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonWell, he's a he he's he has the authority anyway.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonRight.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonCertainly can be uh most helpful. Let me tell you that on the one project we discussed, ACDA uh I if anybody feels more strongly about it than you do, it's me. So uh I can assure you that uh we uh I've uh I've I've I'm working on it in uh every possible way. Part of the problem, Scoop, with some of these things like ACDA, as you know,
Nixonthe Congress, in its wisdom, uh set the damn things up, but I find that, but I find on the other hand, I have no obligation to appoint people. You know what I mean? Or to staff it. Isn't that your point? Yeah.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonYeah. Exactly.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonRight. Right.
NixonThen the you gave us the name. I I have that in mind too. But you gave us the name of this the fellow in Europe?
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonYeah. Uh-huh. His name.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonRight, right, right, right, right.
NixonDo this uh so that I can have it. Just wire me those two names again on that point. And uh also now, as far as the names of people down in the woodwork, I know one uh who came to who that you mentioned, and I had him marked. But uh good. Can your is is this uh is the uh
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonYeah.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonYeah. Well, but I need also the people that ought to be out. I I need I need that I need that list from you.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonWell, all right. All right. Well, I'll I'll dig it out of his uh office, then. Fine.
NixonRight. Right. Good. All right. If he's got it, I know I've got That's all I need. That's all I need. You don't have to bother.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonNo, no, I got it. I uh we've already talked about it, and if he's got everything you have, Scoop, I'll get it from him, and uh it's fine, cuz
Nixonin foreign trip, when you get back, I'd like to see you, uh around after December 3rd, right?
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonGreat. I'll be here, and I'll see you. I'm I'm not taking off on any vacat- I went to Florida for three days, and I But I'm at Camp David now. We're doing a lot of reorganization. It's going to be quite exciting. And uh we'll we'll we'll need we'll need your support on it. Well, it's good to talk to you.
Jackson[unintelligible]
NixonBye. Thank you.
NixonYou don't think this would be a time to get Scoop in the government?
EhrlichmanNo. What would he do about Evans? I I just wondered.
NixonEvans, dear Evans got re-elected, so he'd be facing that same problem he was facing four years before. Turn, turning over his seat to a Republican, well,
EhrlichmanDid he ever declare for Evans?
NixonWell, we made God damn Evans, wanted me to deal with him, so uh, damn if Evans, they can deal with this guy, big deal.
EhrlichmanGood God, I called the fellow. I think we get a little credit for him, don't we? I don't think we get credit for anybody else. Jerry Ford was telling me how [unintelligible] had done it on his own. Tower said, "Oh, he did it on his own," and all the rest. Hell, then sure they did.
NixonWell, let's just shake it.
EhrlichmanAll out there campaigning for three days for Evans, showing them the way in. And you remember the call I made, sure, which got [unintelligible] to play,
NixonSure it did, sure it did.
EhrlichmanYou ought to be able to put a real crunch on Evans on a But can't can't Evans point it out, crap, how would it how would it satisfy you? You could point, done, you know,
NixonThere's a point. But look, he can appoint a Democrat for Nixon. He could point Goodwin Chase,
EhrlichmanMhm.
Nixonwho is a good guy, and who also probably was a, was he, could he have been a Jackson Democrat?
EhrlichmanHe undoubtedly was a Jackson Democrat. My point Goodwin Chase
NixonHe would be Goodwin Chase would be acceptable to both of those Senators.
EhrlichmanWould he go into the Senate?
NixonGoodwin Chase? Yeah, boy. Excellent.
EhrlichmanWould he? I bet anybody would.
NixonYeah. Anybody would. No, his son is in the administration.
EhrlichmanIs Tony Chase is our General Counsel of SBA.
NixonUh-huh.
EhrlichmanAnd uh uh Goodwin uh is a banker, but he's a senior citizen sort of type.
NixonHe's
EhrlichmanGod, that'd be a hell of a You know, I think putting Scoop in there now would be an awfully good, Scoop Jackson would consider it, but I never offered it to him last year before, if he would consider it.
NixonLet look at, let's let's look at from his standpoint. He looks down the road. I suppose he could look down the road and say, "Well, Teddy"
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
NixonJackson is
EhrlichmanAnyway, Jack Jackson though, he was the, was was the campaign, Teddy's. I don't, I just can't believe that he could be such a hell of a Teddy enthusiast, but he is. He's a devoted Democrat.
NixonThe other hand, he's a deeply devoted patriot.
EhrlichmanAnd uh,
Nixonso he'd even be a better Secretary of Defense now than Elliot Richardson.
EhrlichmanMuch better.
NixonMuch better.
EhrlichmanHe'd spend a little more money, too.
NixonThat's all right. He'd sure be good on the Hill.
EhrlichmanThat's for sure. Tremendous.
Nixonand maybe these-
EhrlichmanDonahue said,
Haldeman"Who can carry the message to Garcia?"
Ehrlichman"To find out, we try to money before we use John McCone for [unintelligible]."
NixonJackson considering? He probably thought we were going to make him four years, but now he's had his run for the presidency. Got the shit kicked out of him.
HaldemanHe's never going to make it on the national scene except as a candidate for vice president, perhaps, with Teddy. That would be That would be Teddy's [unintelligible]. Right. Well,
Ehrlichmanthat's one where you've got to carry the message to Garcia.
NixonI know.
EhrlichmanBecause without preliminary exploration he couldn't put his put his foot in the fire.
NixonWell, that's why I don't want to get committed on that, but that's a whole other I really think that I just follow it the other way. He said, he says "I want to I want to help. I'll be back December 3rd and all." Whether that means anything. Who knows? You can never agree with any Democrat.
Haldeman[unintelligible]
EhrlichmanCould. He's got to be thinking about where this all goes.
HaldemanHe's right age.
EhrlichmanHe just of course ascended to uh uh non-operational chairman.
NixonFour years as Secretary of Defense?
HaldemanIt's pretty good.
EhrlichmanIf he's interested concerned about finances at all, it makes a hell of a lot of sense, because it bumps his retirement rate up to the to level one. It'll make a lot of dollar difference to him.
NixonIf he's got Well, I don't know what his problems are. Maggie's rich, but I don't think he's so [crosstalk]
EhrlichmanHe's very modestly fixed. Uh-huh.
HaldemanWell, Maggie will inherit media. But his federal retirement If his federal career ended finishing his last three years at a level one, would make an enormous difference in his retirement.
NixonPlus he's got a young family.
HaldemanYeah, he has. He has young kids. He married late.
NixonHe married young? Yeah.
HaldemanNo, no, he married very He was a bachelor.
NixonYeah, he married late.
HaldemanThey have children.
NixonYeah, they have two, yeah.
HaldemanYoung kids. Five and eight, or sound like that.
NixonThat's interesting.
EhrlichmanHe has a nice looking family.
HaldemanWell, she's very attractive. I've always liked Scoop. Yeah. I mean I don't [sighs] Let's face it. Sure.
EhrlichmanHe wasn't a Nixon Democrat, but the next closest thing to it. We don't know of any Jackson people that were against us, do you?
NixonNo.
HaldemanNo, they didn't He laid back, and he wouldn't campaign with McGovern for four trips into Washington. Finally, the fifth trip, he appeared with him.
EhrlichmanBecause he was just blackjacked into it. You're committed to Clements is definitely,
NixonAll right. Well, Clements will be a hell of a deputy, and Scoop is the kind of a guy that can-
EhrlichmanWell, he's a Republican, so that's plenty.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanSorry, who?
EhrlichmanBill Clements.
HaldemanI think Clements is a Republican [unintelligible].
NixonI guess he is, he is.
NixonLet me say that on appointments,
Nixonwe are not going to fritter off this so that we don't have whine, and bitch, and so forth. I don't know how we're going to do it, but we might just [crosstalk]
EhrlichmanSame way we did the campaign.
NixonThey'll be told.
EhrlichmanYes.
NixonThat you're-
HaldemanThat you do. Once you open that door, then you'll keep them out.
NixonRight. Scoop is looking for a damn fast, if I could court Clements, [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanHe's probably the worst pain in the ass other than Jock Malone that we have up there, heads up there. He's 64 years old,
Haldemanvicious old man. He is, and he expressed his loyalty in very peculiar ways. I'm sure he was loyal, but he's
NixonBitch.
HaldemanAnd he was he was quiet.
EhrlichmanRemember he almost shot the Under Remember when Mark Schlesinger as Under Secretary of Interior? whipped around there and organized against him and chopped his right down in front of his-
NixonI think Schlesinger, Dan Beale's to be run off from. I think we ought to get a cracking on that. All right. To begin with one, let people understand how we're going to cut back, cut that personnel down, and that Dan came off that.
NixonHigh level cut the guys. He doesn't have [unintelligible]
NixonNow let me say, you understand John, neither Henry nor Haig is worth a damn when it comes to cutting the Vance.
HaldemanRight.
EhrlichmanWell, you're I'm sure that's right.
NixonThat's for sure.
NixonNow Defense can be cut horribly.
HaldemanPartly with the personnel.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanSo Defense ends up with Scoop maybe, and just a long shot at this point, and the other guy otherwise,
HaldemanRichardson with Clements underneath.
EhrlichmanState, are are you are you happy with Rush, yep, in your own mind?
NixonRush is my first choice. You've had no support for him from anybody who analyzes it, because he's not a good man, lousy manager, past track record, and all that sort of stuff. But
Ehrlichmandid a hell of a good job with Berlin.
Nixonhe's loyal, and we need a Secretary of State that's loyal, who'll play as, you know, kiss ass upwards, and kiss ass down, and basically that the whole name of the game. That's right.
HaldemanI'd like to have a Secretary of State that's [unintelligible]. If it's understood he's got to understand what what his under secretaries are going to do.
NixonHas anybody Anybody got any better names? No. Well, who'd you take?
HaldemanNo.
EhrlichmanRockefeller? God, he'd be a disaster.
NixonRichardson, could Richardson pull it?
HaldemanBe good in Defense Richardson's one of them.
EhrlichmanIn State, then, the second big critical appointment is the under secretary. Right. Deputy Secretary, whatever it is. Under Secretary, yeah.
HaldemanAnd, uh Well, there are two jobs. There's the Under Secretary, and then there's the Under Secretary for Political Affairs, whatever it is, which is the Johnson job.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonWell, that Johnson job ought to go to, I think, if we can, Carlucci adds up, you think, that kind of a Foreign Service man.
HaldemanYeah, that is a that is the job that is the guy that does the cutting.
NixonHe does run it.
HaldemanHe does it. He's a hell
EhrlichmanThe Carlucci evaluation is low. or whatever it is. Yeah. This is low. His management performance at OMB has not been good.
NixonHmm.
EhrlichmanHe performs well on special one shot projects and that's his that's his forte.
HaldemanLike what fire things? They got to get into something like Rio embassy, he did a superb job on cutting down the staff there. At OEO,
Ehrlichmanhe did adroitly in a tough place, but on one project, legal services in L.A., that's what he concentrated on, and it was superb and he did a hell of a job. But it was a one project operation.
HaldemanHe doesn't have a strong management background, he's not a good analyst, and he's not a good manager. Shultz thinks he was a real let down from Weber, and was his major mistake at OMB, according to Malek's know-all.
NixonAll right.
HaldemanHe doesn't think he's forceful, nor would he take the lead on anything that was difficult.
NixonWell, all right. Who else who else you got?
HaldemanAnd their conclusion is he's an extremely good man, but not ready for the tough management task of a cabinet post or the Under Secretary of State.
NixonThen make him under secretary some place else.
HaldemanWell, you could use him as the Under Secretary for Foreign for Political maybe, although he's not really stature for that on foreign policy. Well, all right.
EhrlichmanWell, supposing you were to attach him to Rush as a special project's dog, or to the under secretary, or is he As a As the guy to help you bust up the Foreign Service. to say "Frank, you're going in there to do this job, and when you get all done with it, then there's murders everywhere so in your career, Henry recommends him.
HaldemanHenry does?
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanWell, Frank [sighs] Frank that that would be that would be tough planning so.
NixonWell, I don't know, we get him off.
HaldemanThe other ones are so crazy [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanYou're afraid to go outside, then I think you stay in house.
HaldemanGot this is so sensitive. Bill Casey's another one.
NixonThat's a good possibility.
HaldemanHe'd do what you said. Ruthless.
NixonHe is.
Haldeman[snorts] Okay. IRS came up with Casey somewhere along the line in a casual conversation and he indicated a strong lack of interest in the job, but that doesn't matter, I mean-
NixonYou got Have you got another man? We don't even need uh
NixonI just In IRS, even a good young guy in charge who's our guys all the way.
HaldemanWhat do you think, John?
EhrlichmanWell, there's one where in order to get away with it you got to have some credentials. And, uh, that's that's a that's different than the others. Now, Under Secretary of State,
EhrlichmanI don't know how much in the way of credentials you have to have. Seems to me we could take a good, loyal general and put him in there and tell him what his job was and turn him loose, or take a guy like Jim Lynn, for instance, who probably doesn't have enough background to to be credible as Under Secretary of State.
NixonCasey is a hell of a possibility.
Haldemanthat is, what does Casey bring? For what, and Rogers would love that.
EhrlichmanWell, maybe. Maybe, on on some kind of a theory or other, you take a Malek type,
Ehrlichmanand you just send him over to say that this is the year of reorganization, and that the principal function of the undersecretary will be to accomplish
Ehrlichmanthe the president's reorganization. Well, you've got a figure. You've got Rush at the top of the budget, a good, strong guy to ride shotgun, you know.
HaldemanYeah. That's what you can sign out.
NixonAnd then you've got to take an Alex Johnson, from the Foreign Service.
EhrlichmanMm-hmm. That's one. For the political thing.
NixonPolitical thing. Basically, handle these other handle Foreign Service. Well, Henry may be able to find somebody out of all of his contacts.
NixonMaybe somebody his office will go to that job. I want a young man in that job. And young. It'd be a hell of a signal to bounce out to the that part.
NixonAlex is 64 years old.
EhrlichmanGood night.
EhrlichmanOf couple that come to mind. Dave Osborne. No. This guy Osborn, who's been the the consul general in Hong Kong,
Nixonwho is your your great advocate,
Ehrlichmanon China. In because of China.
EhrlichmanHe's a radical in the Foreign Service. In the he's a revolutionary. He wants to change.
EhrlichmanAnd maybe too liberal. He could be. He could well be. Well, he's not he's not dovish. He's
EhrlichmanI think a little a little too hard-line for the for the Foreign Service. It's It's someone we might check. Some of the guys who are in the Out of Foreign Service, there just must be somebody.
HaldemanThere's What's that guy White House that Henry's always pushing? Or his brother-in-law, Blake?
EhrlichmanWho? We hear Blake? You know Blake? Utter disaster.
NixonIs he? Utter disaster.
NixonHe was Stevenson. Then he was Shriver. He was Shriver's That's second, well. He was Shriver's minister. Oh, yeah. That and that.
EhrlichmanWell, now, see, Alsop and Blake and Whitehouse are all related by marriage.
EhrlichmanWhitehouse is a little pansy-like, like all the Alsops, but But he's been a good man.
NixonPossibly.
NixonWell, I want to know where his loyalty is. Is it to the Foreign Service, or is it That's why Carlucci appeals to me. In other In this context,
EhrlichmanPaul Nitze's name came up a while back. I don't know who He's a disaster. I don't know anything about these people, but Paul Nitze is part of the Georgetown set. He's Acheson's brother-in-law.
NixonOh, is he? Son-in-law.
HaldemanUh-huh. I get it.
NixonAnd, basically, Paul Nitze is not a Nixon man. He turned on us a couple of times. Huh?
HaldemanHe turned on us a couple of times.
NixonYeah. He's vicious. He's vicious, but clean. And that's just what they're going to try to It's just too bad Casey has an intriguing possibility.
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd they could just say, "Yes, we want an outside man, for the purpose of, for economic, having great experience in government."
EhrlichmanYes. And totally recognized. I mean, that there's no argument there.
HaldemanYou could You could also say we want an undersecretary of state for another argument. Good argument for Casey.
NixonBill Rogers has said for a long time, you know, the State Department, now it's going into the economic deal, and it's terribly important that it be that we horse for the new role. Why not a man like Casey, whose experience is economic?
EhrlichmanCan't fight it.
NixonSell it that way. That's That's the way to sell Peterson. The title is Undersecretary of State for Economic Affairs, you know.
EhrlichmanYes.
NixonReally? Is that the title of to S- That's Irwin's title now. Well, Casey, Undersecretary of State for Economic Affairs. Alex is Undersecretary of State, Political.
EhrlichmanRight. Well, there's the point. And you got a third undersecretary in there.
EhrlichmanCoordinated Security Assistance programs, Curtis Tarr.
NixonSecurity is And he's an undersecretary too?
EhrlichmanYes, sir.
NixonHow's he?
EhrlichmanGood guy. He's young. He was at Rogers.
EhrlichmanHe's able. We brought him, you know, he ran the Selective Service. We moved him brought him over. We shoved him in. Rogers did. Yeah.
NixonYeah. Good. So you just had a good man in. They tell me the fellow he's had working the Hill is loyal too. Abshire? Mhm.
HaldemanHe is. Abshire's very right-wing, very conservative.
NixonYou could put Abshire in. Abshire might be a guy to move in as a son of a bitch to work the Foreign Service over, if he's tough.
HaldemanI don't know whether he's a I will say that anything working the Foreign Service over to us is very important because
NixonI'm getting that I owe a huge debt to eyesight. That makes a break. No, we'll never make it unless we get Rogers's. Oh, yeah.
HaldemanAbshire's Admiral Anderson's son-in-law or something.
EhrlichmanIs that right? Abshire and Ray Macomber.
NixonI think Abshire and Macomber are both good men, and I would move them both out of State.
EhrlichmanI think you're right.
NixonInto responsible positions in other departments.
EhrlichmanI think you're right. They've stayed there too long. I think I think so. You see, with Abshire, um, when you've expect Congressional relations, that is such a
Nixonterribly delicate thing. Maybe Abshire should stay. Well, then, Abshire He's so- But I wouldn't ask him to commit fratricide over there, um, at that Foreign Service. The Foreign Service, man.
EhrlichmanI understand, but he's lived with those guys now for four years. That's right. That's right.
NixonAnd It's got to be a new new blood.
EhrlichmanThe same with Macomber. I think we ought to have new ones up and down the line. I just can the whole bunch. Macomber is is good undersecretary material. Macomber could run that department.
NixonIs he that good?
EhrlichmanHe's He's quite good, and he's very loyal, and he tracks well. And he's the sort of fellow that you can trust to, uh I think, to run that department with your back turned.
NixonYou know, I think moving people into different departments is good. We've got him as a retained transfer.
EhrlichmanYeah. Why, here's another thing you could do: put him over with, uh, with Shultz. You might. I think that's right.
HaldemanYou know who wanted Charlie Walker? I don't know.
EhrlichmanShultz. Got any ideas? He's gone. He wants to kill Everybody wants to keep Walker and keeps Walker and keeps Wants to keep Volcker, does not want to keep Walker.
NixonMaybe he has to keep Volcker.
EhrlichmanHe thinks he does.
NixonMy guess is he does. Man, Volcker's not loyal to anybody.
EhrlichmanNo, but the but he's brilliant. Let's face it. He's a big wheel.
Nixonin the whole financial, House Ways and Means Committee that George sees, you know, a plus or a minus. But, on balance, he thinks Walker should go.
EhrlichmanHe's got to, on the basis that that, under the new structure, George is not going to be the secretary of the Treasury. That undersecretary has got to be the secretary of the Treasury, and that can't be Charlie Walker. It's got to be a Nixon man.
NixonGeorge can turn his back on. Put a dagger in George. George would George would be in bed. Can George take Flanigan?
HaldemanI don't know that George would seriously object to Flanigan. I think you could But you get a confirmation problem. Yeah. Confirmed.
EhrlichmanSerious. Not so much So I don't mean under I don't mean serious in terms of anything Peter's ever done. Like, but I just think serious in terms of opening up the goddamned ITT business.
NixonOh, that's true. Tough. Very tough. In in Treasury. I think Pete could be an undersecretary in, uh, in Interior,
Ehrlichmanundersecretary of Agriculture, undersecretary of Transportation, maybe, but very tough Treasury.
NixonBecause of his conflicts. Because of that the whole Wall Street business.
EhrlichmanI think it'd be easier getting confirmed undersecretary of state.
NixonPossibly.
EhrlichmanOne of those three undersecretaries. The one he wants of course.
EhrlichmanIf you take the labels off those It may not be. I'm not sure what the label is now.
NixonIt isn't in the It isn't in the book. It says, you know, "it's Graybook."
EhrlichmanYeah. It originally was economic. When they made the two undersecretaries, they may have dropped economics on that.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanYou got an awful It is a long shot. He's too much of a what you'd call a wheeler dealer. That's so.
EhrlichmanUh, if he's not going to be back till the 3rd of December,
Nixonhe may say, "I don't want to be in." Well, if you say to him the President wants State, Defense, Ag, and everything else in. And the President thinks that these are going to be made before Thanksgiving. Could you postpone the second leg of your trip,
Haldemanand come back and have a talk with the President? He'll certainly fly to have a talk with you, Mr. President.
NixonYes. But our mains are all worked.
HaldemanWhatever. But every time that he comes back, I'll see him any day that he gets back.
Ehrlichmancould move forward and be useful, is very useful, right.
Nixonand they don't, I mean it's good to learn, it's too late.
EhrlichmanAnd he said, well, I guess you can't, can't throw it.
EhrlichmanAnd I thought it was very fine, though. What they know that he is interested.
NixonThat's a that's a very good way to find out without, by having the group, anyone in the first place.
Nixonand see if he'll take it.
HaldemanNow Fred later today is gonna be bringing us more more material, whatever he doesn't really understand, he's got have somebody first that can work with it.
NixonWell who have you got on that list, Russell?
EhrlichmanThe Secretary of State isn't one that that a Malek search project is gonna turn up. You you've That's still the other secretaries gotta work, those cases.
NixonWell there's Bush. There's Bush, he's under Secretary of State.
HaldemanWell, so far they don't have anybody for IRS, but Malek's gonna find us somebody, right? Well,
Haldemanwe've been working with we came up with a Casey Casey for IRS. Malek's got a couple other possibilities that are not really, we have what about him?
NixonGetting him back into the packs tax lawyer thing with other problems with both concrete execution. Well, I have to work on that. If if Casey were to go to State,
EhrlichmanSimilarly, if Richardson does not go to Defense,
Ehrlichmanthen you've you've got Richardson available. And almost
Ehrlichmanyou've got a very heavy gravitational pull to keep Richardson in HEW.
NixonOh, god, you've got to, that'd be bad.
EhrlichmanI think, well,
NixonOr would it? I don't know.
EhrlichmanI'm not so sure. It's kind of interesting, Elliot asked to see me the one day we were back in Washington. He came in with a complete plan for cutting the personnel at HEW and and
Ehrlichmanshifting to almost a total block grant approach to away from categorical programs in the solution of health, education, welfare.
NixonNow Weinberger, how about Weinberger for Sec, State, or IRS? Could you put him in HEW?
HaldemanNo.
NixonHEW? Weinberger as Under Secretary of State? Could he take that?
EhrlichmanAt FTC, and he just had the guts out of that, sorry. That's why OMB was cutting.
HaldemanSee what we're getting at here is that basically Washington, social set, that captures every Secretary of State, Under Secretary of State, they always do.
EhrlichmanWeinberger'd be all right over there, I think. How about Weinberger? If he
NixonInteresting, see whether he'd take it. That's
NixonHenry raised Rockefeller a couple days ago [unintelligible]
HaldemanAt Defense?
EhrlichmanWell, Henry, in talking with us about it, made the point that he didn't think Rockefeller, he thought it would be hard to get him to take it, but that you probably could if you really wanted to, but that there you had the real question of whether you want to. Much prefers him at Defense than at State.
EhrlichmanHe feels State would be impossible.
NixonA lot of trouble [unintelligible] Rockefeller, do you want him?
EhrlichmanI don't see what you'd gain. You don't gain anything from it. It's a payoff, and, frankly, you don't need to pay him off that way.
Nixon[unintelligible] that I'd like to talk to him anyway, after that is.
EhrlichmanWell, you could see, you could take, just to buy him ground, he wanted to report to you on his trip to Israel.
NixonRichardson, [snort]
Nixonwill cut HEW? Certainly he would cut Defense.
EhrlichmanMore likely to cut Defense, sure, than he would HEW.
EhrlichmanHe's got, they've got to break through his heart, Mike. These guys are all rebending before the wind. They can all see which direction you're moving in, they all read the Horner piece, and they're all coming in now with their own, with their own proposals and their interpretations of detail.
EhrlichmanMorton's working on a big plan, Peterson's got a big plan, you know, they're all, Butz's got a big plan. They're all moving.
NixonThey've got executive side through every, sure, sure.
NixonHow about Elliot at Justice?
HaldemanI've thought of that, except for
EhrlichmanThe area I would question would be civil rights, but he has not been a problem to us in civil rights at HEW, and he could have been an aggravated problem there.
HaldemanBut he is the wrong signal to our southern constituency.
NixonThat's the whole point.
HaldemanI think we've got to have, Kleindienst, I think you're saying if fallback should be Kleindienst will be replaced,
NixonRight.
Haldemanthat's a real that's a real slap in the face. He and Haldeman,
Ehrlichmanthese are symbolic, Rich.
HaldemanHe is symbolic in the South.
NixonOh, it's wrong.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonKleindienst has got to stay, I agree, for one,
HaldemanDoesn't mean you don't agree with that.
NixonWell, the other thought was worse, than the cash deal.
EhrlichmanI think there's a variable in there. I think when you sit Kleindienst down and you say this is the new plan and you are gonna have to accept a whole lot of assistants and a deputy that are acceptable to the president,
NixonYour guys have gotta go. That's all. Can that be done by you folks?
EhrlichmanSure.
NixonBecause I don't want to whack these cabinet [crosstalk] people.
EhrlichmanWell, what we had planned to do, once once we see the the situation here, is begin having them up, one or two at a time. And we'll work 'em over and and explain the system. And what I would like to do, and maybe this is too extreme,
Ehrlichmanbut I would like to enter into a little written agreement with these clowns that uh well, spells it out.
HaldemanI think you're right. I think you're right.
EhrlichmanGet them to sign it.
HaldemanNo, you just say the president wants no misunderstanding. We make a memorandum of conversation,
Haldemanagreement, memorandum, and so forth, this is the way the understanding is the way it's gonna be done, so if there isn't any crying, there isn't any sort of congressional pressures [unintelligible] and so on.
EhrlichmanAnd then, I think you can see them and knight them, send them on their way.
HaldemanNow, we had any signals from Rogers yet? Dick, what have you got?
NixonWell, Bob, it's an idea. I think you could do the talk next. I think you've got to sort of broach it with Bill.
NixonNow for the way I think it's done, I'd say, Bill, look, last night, you know, say Bill,
Nixonall the people who have been in the cabinet four years are going, so the president's supposed to see you right. All who have been in the cabinet four years should go.
NixonI mean, it's had had, it's a bill that's pretty very candid: Romney, Volpe,
Nixonuh, uh, who else has been in for four years?
EhrlichmanLaird, although he announced
NixonYou were kept, they are not. But, we're not going to have any regard to this organization.
NixonAnd we feel that we could feel that the best thing for you to, not shout, uh, sort of in a blaze of uh a uh
Nixonarrest, but to do, that he should take the leadership. In other words, he should be the one to say, look, four years is
Nixonenough for these new men.
HaldemanDo you feel I can do, or do you think I should just call him and talk?
EhrlichmanNo, I think,
EhrlichmanI think you should, I don't think either, but I think you should have to raise it that he should know what what's happening when he comes into you, Henry. And, you still that may not preclude a sticky scene for you, but at least preclude your having to open it, but if he says no,
NixonI mean, if he says he doesn't agree,
EhrlichmanObviously, we'll know that.
Nixonthen you have, in other words,
HaldemanWell, he's flat out.
EhrlichmanYeah. And, Bob can hear it first. Same with same with Romney. I think uh, Romney on timing,
NixonWe are, what say, uh, to
NixonWell, I told him he could stay till the inauguration.
EhrlichmanYeah, that the end of the term. Oh, yeah.
NixonOh, no, he never agreed to that.
EhrlichmanThat's right.
NixonYou were there, weren't you?
EhrlichmanThat's right.
NixonDid I agree to that?
EhrlichmanNo, sir, you said before the inauguration. Now, but you see he's changed that.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanAnd, uh, See, there again, you can say, "Bill, we've got a problem with Romney, we've got a problem with Volpe, and we've got a problem"—I don't think we've got one with Laird. Laird is saying, he's said so.
NixonNo.
EhrlichmanBut anyway, we've got a problem with those two in particular. Also, with some shuddering Bush, the rest. But, I don't know any way around that except to just say, look, the President's giving this a lot of thought for two weeks, and and,
Ehrlichmanuh, Secretary Romney has decided that he wants to change, and, uh, we're not gonna have any carry-overs.
NixonNow, what would you have them all resign then? I mean, what would you have them
EhrlichmanWell, in Romney's case, uh, there's a question whether you'd wanna uh give Van Dusen a bone and and have him a recess appointment or something. No, no, no, none of that.
EhrlichmanWell, then I think you're effective, uh. Well, if you're gonna go to That's the strategy, do you want to think about it, is whether you wanna go for recess appointments on the new people?
NixonNo.
HaldemanNo.
NixonI think the best thing to do, what I kind of had the feeling to do,
NixonI think that you just send the damn things down,
Nixonthe day Congress opens, right?
NixonThe day Congress opens, and until that and ask each of the secretaries to stay on till they're confirmed.
HaldemanCorrect.
NixonCorrect? Well, or would you?
Nixonand uh Romney and the rest, it's got to be—George has got to understand it. And everybody is going to get it. And we can't-
HaldemanAnd the citizen is new and asking for help. The old guy is, obviously, that's what—[crosstalk] not for section. I didn't hear Romney say past the first time
NixonWell, this is a recent contrivance. Because you remember, he said the uh that we would uh he wanted to stay through the balance of the term. You know, he wanted to leave early. I said, "What's that?"
HaldemanHe said, but first he said through the election. That's right. And then he said um through the balance of the term. Then There was a there was a time in there when we were talking about Van Dusen for a recess appointment, and then he could go earlier. And now he's talking about getting several months into the new term.
NixonNo. No way. And uh No. No, he's out. That's all. He's had his comeuppance. Everything else has gone.
EhrlichmanEverybody's gone, so that's it.
HaldemanWell, I think you didn't, no way out of it. Not only that—
NixonOne of the one of the best whole outs is I'm wondering if [unintelligible] putting a signal on the whole shit damned thing. Yes, the effort to make a change.
EhrlichmanThat's it. Fresh, whole-blown. Can't be exceptions.
HaldemanWell, let us work on the on the dates and the timing on this thing and see what we can come up with.
NixonNow names, if we could talk about— Now names who got to get with, that's what the whole point. So, I'm ready to talk about the names.
HaldemanAll right, well let's do the names. John and I are ready to go over them.
NixonI do want you to, as I said, I'm going to talk to Connally about any names that he has. I do want you to talk to Mitchell, hello, so he could be sure he has his input then. But he didn't do any beyond John Mitchell. Glad to get anybody that's been four years on a re- so, you got some strategy.
EhrlichmanYes.
NixonAnd then, we're not going to have the whole thing. Now, we got problem. Romney wants to stay, Volpe wants to stay, and we don't know about Rogers, but I had a hedging thing. But, take Volpe first. I think Bill should take Volpe first.
HaldemanDon't you agree?
EhrlichmanOh, sure. Bill Yeah, he did take the lead. He says I shouldn't. Why? But he should should do it, in terms of uh
NixonAnd it really is, Bill If Bill gives it even a second thought, he should just welcome the chance to get out right at the top of his game.
EhrlichmanHead of the game, sure.
NixonBecause he's going to have this continuing problem with Henry. Right? And he's just going to have it.
HaldemanWell, now, how do we raise the problem? Is Henry going to be Secretary of State, of course not. Rogers is going to stay on. On the PR end of this,
NixonYeah.
Haldemanthere are several ways we could go with announcements of that kind. We could have a story a day for for two months on changes. Or, you could have a blockbuster on organization and a blockbuster on personnel.
NixonUh, remember we went through that before, we get a story every—
EhrlichmanI'm not going to do— I'm not going to do it. I'm not going to go on television. Oh, no. You don't have to do that.
HaldemanI would argue that you want to do you you should do the the reor- we should start getting people up here before Thanksgiving, if we can. We should start these meetings with Cabinet officers and stuff. As soon as tomorrow, with Bill. But we should not announce anything about it and those
Ehrlichmanmeetings would be, ostensibly, under the purpose of the reorganization question of, you know, functions and restructuring of their departments, and all that, which the word is out there supposed to be working on. Then, as you get it settled with each of
HaldemanThen, you announce the reorgan- then tell them what the reorganization is.
NixonAnd for that matter, you can send their White House, the back of me by the edge here. Yeah.
HaldemanAnd That's right. That'll be another signal, too. Put out that you talked to Scoop Jackson.
NixonWell, that's that's his dish. You can do that. I did He'll talk, but that would be a signal, that what the rest see, I think our I talk to several people out there.
HaldemanThen, I would think, after Thanksgiving, a paced out series of of announcements of the new secretaries would be better than trying to lob a whole new Cabinet in at once.
NixonThat's so.
HaldemanYeah. Because you have a terrible problem. Logistically, it's very hard to do, and you start talking to somebody, it starts leaking.
NixonIt gives each of the Cabinet officers a chance to, and whoever he chooses, a chance to have his day in the sunshine. His story. A lot of kind, but they got to have a hell of a lot.
HaldemanWell, you've got you've got a lot of interest in White House staff. It seems to me that ought to be done as one story, bang! And the the the thing that comes out of it is reduction, and uh trim, and economy, and slim, and all that.
NixonThe point is, what what you should do is let the reorganization plan go out first, a tightly-written statement which, I guess, you would brief, is that right? Or, would you brief?
HaldemanBrief for background, or something, to get our angle into it.
NixonYeah, that should be uh and then, then you come on beginning with the secretaries, should state to talk first, and then the others right down the line.
EhrlichmanIn days.
HaldemanAnd then announce one or one that stays, and then one a new one, so that so that you don't get into a Yeah. That kind of a deal.
EhrlichmanWell, and you've got some you've got some agency decisions that'll be important. Um the Shultz one first, I think, to lock the economic thing, you know, the structure and all that. Because that's what that's sort of the key Cabinet appointment, anyway. The way this falls together, yes.
HaldemanAnd then come out with a new one or two.
NixonExcept Shultz and Butz. And, and Butz. And Rogers.
HaldemanRogers, yeah.
EhrlichmanIs that a problem for you?
NixonYeah, personally. You see, he's got so goddamned many friends on the Hill, and they're my friends, and he's my friend, and he and his wife, worse than everybody, his wife worked they work they really, you know, he's Rogers personally, as far as himself, is that a total loyalist.
EhrlichmanYeah, in his in his way.
NixonThat's the problem. Yeah. And the damn thing, and provided, except I wouldn't do it, though, except that we take over all the administration European affairs, and so forth, maybe he will want to stay under that basis. But-
HaldemanThat's another thing, though. When you start talking to these fellows about staying under budgets, you know He may prefer to be Ambassador to Canada, or something like that.
NixonCanada's what I'd like to offer him, as Ambassador. I would think-
HaldemanYour thing is you have a problem of dumping Rog, but you don't have a strong feeling that you want him to stay under no circumstances. So, they serve them to do the job. So, if it works out for him to go, that would be the best. But, if he goes happily. If there's any stickiness in his going, you'd rather have him stay.
NixonThat's right. But there can be no there's got to be no other And as to how long he's been here, over four years.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonCan you imagine? It's been over four years, going.
HaldemanYou know, we can have a counseling session with these guys, where we put up this organization and we say, "Now, this isn't going to be everybody's dish of tea, and it's going to be tough for some guys that have worked under the old system. And the President's decided to do it this way. The question is, do you feel comfortable?"
NixonI am I am convinced, uh I'm so I'm seldom sure of anything [unintelligible] sorry, but I'm convinced the best political thing, politically, is the Butz. And, far better than putting some interior asshole into an Interior Department. And, taking, actually, his men, Butz is the man, he can do it.
EhrlichmanHe's one of the President's inner counselors.
NixonTotally loyal. Shultz is totally loyal. So you got two.
EhrlichmanGood. Let us fool with some of these names then.
NixonHow about uh is uh You could put Richardson in HUD, I mean Weinberger in HUD.
EhrlichmanYes. That's another possibility. You could. And, if you could put that, he'd be credible, Archie. Well, and would he, would he be As the super secretary for community development.
NixonThat's right. Yeah. Weinberger uh Weinberger knows revenue sharing, he knows all the other-
EhrlichmanWell, and he you know, he had a uh I think Weinberger should be in the Cabinet. He had a uh community development uh career uh in private practice and as a as a state
NixonWhat would you put over there, at HEW?
EhrlichmanElliot Richardson. At HEW. Provided we have an understanding, I don't know, about busing. I just don't know whether Elliot Richardson, I I want Richardson to have he's got to have clear understandings. First, the organization, but second, on my feelings on education, on my feelings on health.
HaldemanHe will always And, my feelings on busing.
EhrlichmanHe will always move to the left in HEW.
HaldemanHe will always It's it's just uh as the night the day.
NixonThen, I suppose you got to keep one person in the goddamn government that is considered to be sort of human, sort of interested in people. You see, he has that.
EhrlichmanSure, he's credible on that.
NixonNo question about it. Do you agree that he would be good?
EhrlichmanOn busing, will there be any question? That is one that I That He's he gave us that uh open-handed, like, we had no problem. There again, this is a matter of sitting down at a counseling session and
NixonThere can be no compromise.
Haldemanask you all the rough questions and if the answers don't come out, then you don't do it. It's got to be-
EhrlichmanSeems to me with Weinberger at HUD, I'd like people in this inner group, and I don't want either of them, with the possible exception of Ash.
HaldemanAsh is relatively non-political. No, he's not.
EhrlichmanHe had better be, Ron. But you see, the beauty of Weinberger each time you get rid of Richardson. That's a good place for both of them.
HaldemanYeah. That's one of the choices. And uh- You're free and then you're Attorney General. Another nasty scene.
EhrlichmanKleindienst with just a year left uh is uh is going to be here.
HaldemanWell, how would you approach Kleindienst on this basis? You think we should get rid of him, next.
EhrlichmanWell, I would- Not get rid of him. I mean to approach it head-on. I would hold all of this, and if he, if he Lay down the price he's got to pay to stay, he wants to stay. And you say, "We understand that, and, and, on the right basis, it would be very productive for you to stay.
HaldemanI don't think he's got the right basis. And I find his He's talking way, way too much.
EhrlichmanIt's It's I know exactly how it's going to go. He's going to say, "Well, you guys, you bastards in the White House have always been against my guys, and I got to have running room. And I want to talk to the President about this." I'll wager.
HaldemanAnd uh John, look, we can't make an exception of your department, Dick. We're cleaning out all the departments, so out you go.
EhrlichmanHey, I can, I can hear it in my mind's eye. And I think we have to be in a position to just say, "Look, this is a, this is a Take it or leave it deal." and if he says, "Leave it." [crosstalk] If he says, "Leave it" then it's, then it's that that the whole and it's everybody's going. We just aren't making exceptions with the possible exception of small Petersen.
HaldemanPetersen? You might keep him.
EhrlichmanI don't necessarily want to, but we've got to.
HaldemanYou can keep that close to him. He's got the keys to the kingdom. Right. Keep him.
EhrlichmanNow, he's, he is a, a possibility for the FBI job, as a, outside possibility.
HaldemanHe's a career type.
EhrlichmanDepends on what, kind of a face you want to put on it.
HaldemanI like Wilson.
EhrlichmanOkay.
HaldemanI like a cop for the FBI and uh Yep. You're sure of he's a mole there. Completely honest. He's kind of a Make a lot of the Anton type is what he is, yeah. He's uh Everything I know about him's good.
EhrlichmanNo, there's no question about that. His, his, his ability to administer uh an outfit like that [whispering] in a bureaucratic sense [/whispering] is uh something I don't know.
HaldemanAnd that's going to be a tough place to run.
EhrlichmanIt sure is. I'm doing some checking.
HaldemanI think though that Gray should go. I don't, I think I don't want just I just don't want Gray to have to go up for a butch. That's the problem with Gray.
EhrlichmanNow, for all I know, Gray is still um acting deputy director. No, but he is still Deputy Attorney General. Right.
HaldemanWas he confirmed? He wasn't confirmed, was he?
EhrlichmanDamn, no. He had to be confirmed for DAG. He resigned.
HaldemanHe resigned? That's right.
EhrlichmanHe resigned. Yeah.
HaldemanGray could be confirmed.
EhrlichmanHe could be confirmed. Yeah. And uh How about this? How about Gray as Undersecretary of State?
HaldemanWell now, Gray is a tough son of a bitch. He hates State Department. He was Radford's assistant. He's uh, you know, Captain, whatever he became in the, Admiral of the Navy, and uh you could go over there and shoot 'em.
EhrlichmanSo, play with that one a little. Gray is a loyalist and should be kept, but not in the FBI. Right. You can put him over there.
HaldemanHe'd be uh the uh who else are you going to appoint over there at that day?
EhrlichmanStay where he is. That's one tip. Very much. That's one tip.
HaldemanOkay.
EhrlichmanIn the SEC? Where he is now. SEC. Yes, let's see.
HaldemanCasey we had in mind for IRS. We'd originally thought of him as CIA, but are you just sure he won't take IRS? The service to his country?
EhrlichmanNo, I think he will take it. We've had We've had a rumor, a second-hand rumor, service to this country. On this, he questioned He, I That was the report we got was, if the only way he would I really think I really think service to his country. God damn.
HaldemanAt the end of the chapter, he has got the goddamned thing organized. We don't want to make any promises and get stuck on that because, if he forgets, then he'll want to stay, and Casey could uh
EhrlichmanAt the, at the State Department, Curtis is a good name now. Curtis would be a good name for him as the Undersecretary.
HaldemanI like the FBI. I know he's Undersecretary of State. He's tough, Gray is.
EhrlichmanIf you, I know you had problems with him, but he is a, he had a hell of a problem. We, we had no serious No, but what's you know the problem? Put yourself in his position. You'd been having having his ass eaten out all the way up. He knew there was hanky-panky around here. He didn't know how much and how deep and ran. You know what I mean? He wanted to help, but yet he couldn't uh-
HaldemanWell, he's being sandbagged by his subordinates.
EhrlichmanThat's the main point. He, he couldn't trust the people around him.
HaldemanWhat's he going to do with his subordinates?
EhrlichmanWell, whatever that one. I think we got We would I I'm at the point now where I think you got to clean out this top flight of guys, just retire them and start over.
HaldemanGray will never do that for you. Jerry would have to do it. I just don't think he could survive. Does he want the job?
EhrlichmanI think he does. Does he? He, he just asked Pat to do it before he left and let Jerry help him to come in and help me department.
HaldemanI, I have been told that, that Jerry would like that job. I've also been told that he is going to leave the D.C. police department either way.
EhrlichmanYeah, that's definitely true.
HaldemanWell, I'm sort of delighted to know it.
EhrlichmanYou get another- The water commissioner was such a show-boat genius, you know, so I don't know what I'd do.
HaldemanThe other, the other thing is though you've got George Bush. Who's a loyalist,
EhrlichmanRight.
Haldemangreat talk and so forth. Is he any kind of a manager?
EhrlichmanDo we know?
HaldemanWe don't know. We don't know that he isn't. But, the point is why can't you put him in one of those if you could, Cabinet, for instance?
EhrlichmanHe is such a sweet guy. He's like a terrier. So fine. He could be every bit as good as Morton.
HaldemanYeah, another eastern-
EhrlichmanOh, he's Texas.
HaldemanI keep forgetting. No. Texas. Everybody loves him.
EhrlichmanIf you can get Morton out of there and put him in a jury George Bush is is uh He's a hell of a follower. And he becomes a political property.
HaldemanRight. And then you tell him, all right, on the Indians and all the rest, we're going to do this and that. I think with Rogers Morton you really ought to lay it out to him.
EhrlichmanIt should be Rogers Morton, yeah.
HaldemanAnybody that's been in over two years, that's the rule that applies. It's about him, so-
EhrlichmanWell, I think you could argue this way to Roge: "Look, Butz is going to go in as the uh a counselor. This would mean a loss of face for you,
HaldemanYeah.
Ehrlichmanand uh we don't want you to suffer."
HaldemanAnd, you can say, "We got to put Butz in as counselor for a fundamental reason. He represents farmers."
EhrlichmanSure.
HaldemanAnd, you know it, Roge. He's a politician now. Awesome menace. President proved.
EhrlichmanI don't think you want Rogers The best one he thinks which which is terribly important is Canada, because the pipeline and all that stuff is getting into high gear now. If it's the pipeline that uh
HaldemanWell, Roge had some conspicuous successes with the Canadians.
EhrlichmanThat's right.
HaldemanYou could say "And we have some serious problems in Canada and so forth. He's close to the President for that."
EhrlichmanIt's rocky times there with that minority government for awhile. Trudeau has got an ice water demeanor.
HaldemanI didn't send him didn't need to torture him because he doesn't care who else is going to be in Cabinet. You know? He's not a good man.
EhrlichmanHe's a leftist uh in uh every meaning. I don't mind his being left, but I uh I'd like him to be polite. He's sort of a half John Lindsay. At least he has good pedigree.
Haldeman[laughs] That's true. He, though, has a hell of a problem because half his seats now are French Quebec.
EhrlichmanOh, sure. How does he juggle that?
HaldemanGo to Ash and Malek. Go over there. All right, fine. You can get that and uh
EhrlichmanAnd if you want, 3:30, whatever you want to do.
HaldemanWell, why don't you lose your own 2:30's fine, 3:00. Otherwise take all the time you need with Ash and Malek. All right? How do you find the fact that MacGregor is here? All right. And then Doug's not coming up today. So,
EhrlichmanGood.
  • 153-006 9:54 AM · 19 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Camp David operator talked on the telephone at Camp David at 9:54 am.
  • 224-012 9:54 AM · 18 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Camp David operator met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David at 9:54 am.
  • 224-013 9:54 AM · 26 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David at an unknown time between 9:54 am and 10:02 am.
  • 153-007 10:02 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Mamie G. Eisenhower talked on the telephone at Camp David from 10:02 am to 10:04 am.
  • 224-014 10:02 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Mamie G. Eisenhower met in the Aspen Lodge study at Camp David from 10:02 am to 10:04 am.
  • 153-008 10:04 AM · 25 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Camp David operator talked on the telephone at Camp David at an unknown time between 10:04 am and 11:36 am.
  • 183-001 10:04 AM · 49 sec — John D. Ehrlichman, Camp David operator, President Richard M. Nixon, and H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman talked on the telephone at Camp David at an unknown time between 10:04 am and 11:36 am.
  • 183-002 10:04 AM · 1 min — John D. Ehrlichman and Ronald L. Ziegler talked on the telephone at Camp David at an unknown time between 10:04 am and 11:36 am.

Conversation 224-015, November 14, 1972. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417174711). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/224-015 (accessed November 1, 2026).