Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 419 › Conversation 419-020

Nixon, Ziegler & Dean on Watergate and Executive Privilege

Wednesday, March 14, 1973 · 9:50 AM–10:50 AM ET · Old Executive Office Building · 54 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Ziegler, Ronald L.; Dean, John W., III; Moore, Richard A.; Bull, Stephen B.Conversation419-020 on Tape 419StartWednesday, March 14, 1973 at 9:50 AMEndWednesday, March 14, 1973 at 10:50 AMRecording deviceOld Executive Office BuildingSourceNixon Library record for 419-020 ↗

President Nixon met with John Dean, Ronald Ziegler, Richard Moore, and Stephen Bull to strategize responses to ongoing Watergate investigations and Senate inquiries. Key discussions focused on managing public statements, the administration's use of executive privilege, and the potential testimony of key figures like Haldeman, Ehrlichman, and Colson. They debated how to handle press inquiries and congressional subpoenas, aiming to control the narrative and minimize damage to the administration, particularly concerning the testimony of L. Patrick Gray.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 8.5 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 10.7 MB

On March 14, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, Ronald L. Ziegler, John W. Dean, III, Richard A. Moore, and Stephen B. Bull met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 9:50 am and 10:50 am. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 419-020 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 419-20

Date: March 14, 1973
Time: Unknown between 9:50 am and 10:50 am
                                           -27-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                              Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

Location: Executive Office Building

The President met with Ronald L. Ziegler and John W. Dean, III.

       Richard A. Moore
            -Attendance at meeting

       Watergate
            -Ziegler's press conference
                  -Time
            -Public statement on Senate questions
                  -Formulation
            -Executive privilege
                  -Henry A. Kissinger
                         -Statements
            -Executive privilege
                  -President's policy
                  -Senate questions
            -Testimony of H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman, John D. Ehrlichman and Charles W.
            Colson
                  -Problems
            -John N. Mitchell
            -L[ouis] Patrick Gray, III
                  -Nomination
            -UNINTELLIGIBLE
            -G. Gordon Liddy
                  -Questions

An unknown person entered at an unknown time after 9:50 am.

       Refreshments

The unknown person left at an unknown time before 10:50 am.

       Watergate
Show the rest of the log (230 more lines)
            -Dean's letter
                 -Subpoena
                 -President's response
                                           -28-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                             Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

            -Gray's testimony
                 -Press questions
                 -Position
                 -Confirmation
                         -Timeframe
                         -Watergate

Richard A. Moore entered at an unknown time after 9:55 am.

            -Congressional subpoenas
                  -Advantages to administration
                  -Court fight
                        -Delays
            -Prominence of issue
            -Cover-up money compared to facts
            -White House staff
                  -Vulnerabilities
                        -Haldeman, John N. Mitchell
                        -Ehrlichman
                        -Colson
                        -Haldeman
                        -Mitchell
                  -Responsibilities
                        -Compared to culpability
            -Donald H. Segretti and Dwight L. Chapin
                  -Impact
                        -Damage to administration
            -Public reaction to Watergate
                  -Importance of issue
                        -Level of public suspicion
                               -Haldeman’s, Mitchell’s knowledge
                               -Jeb Stuart Magruder
                               -Cover up money
                                     -Origin
                                     -E. Howard Hunt, Jr.
            -Administration strategy
                  -Consistency with President's statement
                  -Dean
                               -29-

      NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                 Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

            -Written interrogatories
                  -Answers
-Executive privilege
      -Use
      -Reaction of press
            -Targets
                  -Haldeman
                  -Mitchell
                  -Chapin
                  -Colson
-White House staff
      -Public perceptions of Haldeman, Mitchell
            -Newsweek article
            -Chapin's relation to Haldeman
      -Magruder
            -Relation to Haldeman
      -Haldeman
            -Involvement
                  -Dick Tuck
            -President's security
                  -Demonstrations
                         -Violence
                         -Tuck
                         -Organization
                         -Opposition to George S. McGovern
                         -President's campaign policy on heckling
-Public perceptions
      -White House staff
            -Gordon C. Strachan, Magruder and Chapin
                  -Link to Haldeman
                         -White House response
-Investigation
      -Segretti
            -Gray testimony
      -Chapin, Herbert W. Kalmbach
            -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] report
            -Segretti
            -Allegations of involvement
                               -30-

      NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                   Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

                  -Ziegler's response
                        -President's suggestions
-1972 campaign
-Public statements
-Ervin hearings
      -Work with administration
      -Problems
      -President's comments
-Segretti
      -President's knowledge
      -Response to questions
             -Illegal practices
             -Espionage and sabotage
                    -Legality
             -Campaign practices
                    -False mailings
-Demonstrations against President
      -Violence
      -Double standard
-Press questions and the administration's responses
      -Illegal activities
             -Demonstrations
             -Distinction from legal activities
             -Campaign practices
-Election campaign tactics
      -Sabotage and espionage
             -Violations of law
             -Legal acts
             -Demonstrations
                    -Publicity
             -Double standards
-President's press conference questions
      -Answers to questions for President
      -Demonstrations
             -Illegal acts
      -Questions on illegal acts
             -Tuck
      -Dean's report on Watergate
                               -31-

      NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                  Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

      -Campaign ethics
      -Chapin's departure from White House
             -Segretti case
                   -Haldeman's knowledge
                   -Chapin's role
                   -Kalmbach's role
                   -Allegations
                          -Substance
                   -FBI investigation
                          -Campaign activities
                          -Hunt
                          -Liddy
                   -Dean's investigation of FBI files
                   -Illegal acts
-Dean's investigation
      -Segretti
      -Chapin
      -Strachan
      -Segretti
             -Vulnerability
                   -Chapin
                   -Kalmbach
             -FBI investigation
                   -Gray's testimony
                   -Chapin interviewed
             -Activities
                   -Allegations
             -Line of questioning
             -Ziegler's statement
      -Ervin Committee
             -Impartiality
             -Investigation of both sides of campaign
-Public attitudes
      -White House knowledge
             -Dean investigation
             -President's role
             -Watergate break-in
                   -Hunt and Liddy
                                           -32-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

                                       -Magruder
                                       -Hugh W. Sloan, Jr.
                                -Dean investigation
             -President's statements for press
                   -Segretti
                          -Overblown rhetoric
                   -Demonstrations
                          -Violence
                          -Double standard of press
                          -Involvement of McGovern supporters
                   -Segretti
                          -Allegations
                          -Ziegler's statement

Stephen B. Bull entered at an unknown time after 9:55 am.

       President's next meeting

Bull left at an unknown time before 10:50 am.

       Watergate
            -Ziegler's press conference
                  -Preparation of statement
                  -Ervin Committee
                         -Ziegler's comments
                               -Formulation
            -President's comments
                  -Responsibility for break-in
            -Exploitation by opposition
                  -Rhetoric
            -President's comments to press
            -Gray hearings
            -Robert L. Vesco case
            -Executive privilege
            -White House staff

       President's meeting with Dean and Moore
             -FBI investigation
                                            -33-

                     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 419-20 (cont’d)

Ziegler, Dean and Moore left at 10:50 am.

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 2 parts and the right one starts.

NixonNow uh, is there anybody else here you would want to sit in? Dick Moore?
DeanDick Moore would be very helpful. You've got nobody else you'd want here.
NixonYeah, I think Moore would be good. Why don't I have Stephen Bull
DeanAll right.
Nixontell him to come over to my office.
DeanAll right.
NixonSteve? Would you find Dick Moore and ask him to come over here now. Yeah, right away.

— 1 min 9 s with no transcribed speech —

NixonAll right, Steve, what time did you ask Moore to come over?
BullRight now, sir.
ZieglerJohn, the easiest question with the press was what did the President say about [unintelligible] today? What is the status? Could it be uh the questions would be would be responded to as written questions?
DeanThey're trying to pull that bag over their ears. It's totally off. Not up. It's killed, sir.
ZieglerWe should say of course we will respond to appropriate written questions.
NixonWell, suppose I haven't heard that part. You used words like appropriate written questions.
DeanI would I would view that the other way, that I would keep the issue on all fours with this reason, that we can observe uh the uh the availability of going to a non-sworn versus sworn, I think is better off down the line as a precedent.
NixonSure.
DeanIf another member of the staff gets a subpoena that could be sworn in that's why they may ask some questions. That's why
ZieglerThat's why John feels that they could tend to bite their own tail. Try to do that with Kissinger, and they've got this all cried. They're back at it. They're trying to.
NixonThey've got to want to They can't they didn't hurt they can't hurt him and that situation because responded to that in sworn statement. Whereas, he did indeed take a bath on that measure. Heutterly resisted that. One or the other resisted that. He has a protection assistance.
DeanThis response is that I said they would be answered, responded to consistent with the president's statement. The president's statement says that we're going to preserve in the text the constitutional principle. So, if they go across the boundary even in an interrogatory
ZieglerRight.
Deanthey're doing in effect, uh indirectly, what we're not going to allow them to do directly. Fight the show the appearance and all that.
NixonRight.
DeanSo, that fits that fits uh the wording that this is subject to the president's statement.
NixonYeah.
ZieglerWell, what uh what other uh court letter would would come to this body?
NixonMr. President I did I wouldn't want this tossed around frankly with too many people around here. This is why you're taking your [unintelligible]. I told John this morning, Haldeman, Ehrlichman, and Colson
NixonI don't want Haldeman in it, and I don't want Ehrlichman in it. They are targets.
ZieglerAnd Colson.
NixonExcuse me for interrupting. Colson is definitely a target.
DeanThey shouldn't they couldn't would not be good, right?
NixonDo you agree or not, Ron? Well yes. We totally agree.
ZieglerYou agree, Mr. President? Mr. President?
NixonYes. I think their judgment is always good, but in this they could be.
DeanI don't see what they could bring to bear. I don't want them to think they're out of loop, and why else would you be with them, say you're pissed off with them for that matter.
NixonThat's why It's not a question of pissed off. It's a matter of
DeanWell, they're they're
NixonThey are too deeply They're more critical than John.
DeanYeah.
NixonThe others would be dead. If they go online, that would drag us into the whole fight.
DeanReally. It's a pretty good idea.
NixonYeah.
ZieglerAll right, this one, what then, Dick, brief reality deeply. Discussion about a [unintelligible] this morning with [unintelligible]
NixonRight.
ZieglerAll right, we uh The question is, I guess, uh now, what should be the next step?
NixonWell, proceeding to the Attorney General, well, I mean, the all right. Earlier, what did the Attorney General report to you?
DeanHas he talked to has he talked to you guys, too?
ZieglerYes, talked to you.
DeanHas he?
ZieglerHe just pressed.
DeanRight.
NixonProcesses release, well, they wouldn't want it this morning until afternoon.
DeanNothing's been through it. It's strictly these questions about Gray. First problem is this, What if Gray wants to take a break?
ZieglerRight.
DeanA lot of what his positions are with Pat. If they give him until tomorrow they'll throw to the positions of Mitchell.
NixonWell, they won't they won't give him a lot of
DeanI don't think they will say everything. We lay on a degree that the view of this, Gray might be the first one to go after why did, they do?
NixonWhy?
DeanYep. If they do that they will work it.
NixonYeah.
DeanI tell what will really help build it. Doesn't mean it's nothing to think for. I think it would be a foolish move on their part if they did it. What they have done definitely with that part of the report is wide open right to the Fourth Circuit.
NixonYeah.
DeanAnd that ties up the executive privilege issue probably for a better part of a year and a half, long after Watergate everybody can't do a damn thing until that litigation gets resolved.
NixonHere's an idea then. Have they gone to court, what do you think? If they send subpoenas and all first of it if they do, I mean
DeanIt really would run into that. They can't
Nixonyou can run all around what they do. Only what happens that uh if all that we, we can't
Nixon[unintelligible] Oh yeah. Oh yeah.
Nixon[unintelligible]
Nixon[unintelligible]
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonWell, we know she never hides. That's, that's what, that's always been a cover up.
NixonAs a matter of fact, the fact is that they were, uh, why do you want to cover up? Why did, uh, [unintelligible]? Well we spent a hell of a, you spent a hell of a lot of [unintelligible] Colson, Hunt, any of those, any of those in the group. Well, that's basically all it's all about, isn't it?
DeanWell, as I see it, they have plenty of money. They had, you know, they had plenty of, early on. But Colson, I don't really believe they should have had money to pay for his defense [unintelligible].
DeanBasically, what it's all about.
NixonAnd I said all, not necessarily. I'd go out and say they were, that uh, well, we knew they were [unintelligible]. There's no doubt about it. And it was possible for the people around him Right? The Chinese took very nice suits [unintelligible] of mine. That's why he got into a lot of problems. There was opening up right there.
DeanWell, there's a big difference between this, you know where this responded to? The secretary, he responded well, he had the money. And the next group of dollars, I don't know where it came from. I feel nothing and then,
DeanI don't know whether the, maybe they had another [unintelligible] idea that you would buy, buy that over. We could've gone to the other side and uh, but that, I think that the, that the
NixonNone of that ever was, came to my attention and so and therefore I'd never raise, I don't believe I want to raise that question. I can't ask you, well, if you know anything, but both would deny it. I want them to deny it.
DeanSee, my point is, however, that you lay, that that same fact hang out, it's gonna appear just as sure as hell, that they didn't know.
NixonWell, that's stupid. In the exercises we went through yesterday, even last night, even when we get into
Nixonthey think, they're so smart when they're making, going back over the whole business again. It becomes so much in part with the apology, back, on that road.
DeanI can't go back in there. You can't ever go back, and the best thing that we could do
DeanWell, I think they have, uh, that they've put together a lot of problems, I think. You compare the so-called Watergate, uh, as we last discussed, it's uh, but I, uh, I think the worry here is what's to prevent, to carry out seven break-ins. Ah, here, they can ask if that that's good. These seven break-ins have been a disservice to
DeanYou see, and they've forced people to have made some phone calls and eight persons so afraid and so self-interested and uh, they're they're appalled at what they're gonna hear, but but they will never know that the standard FBI, when I tell you second, they are, with the problem that they wouldn't have understood that they can get.
DeanAnd that's that. And they've only had that question
DeanSome of them are legal and always they were, there were things they couldn't back down. The money was,
NixonThere's, there's, there's, that's the other wire. And then of course, the money. Well the money didn't come from them either, did it? They just put it back, that part they got.
DeanAnd they were screwballs, all of them.
NixonWell, anyway, that don't, there's nothing harmful in going on, on, after that. What about your [unintelligible] you think the Senate, this Senate hearing this week, will it affect you, uh,
DeanNo, they would want to meet, that's fine.
DeanUh, no, they have asked, they've asked me a question to that, they're gonna find it. Uh, I would only vote for that if they do it in some kind of an informal forum, where we don't have to face a hearing.
ZieglerRight.
DeanWell, that has to be, it has to be, the testimony has to be considered. We'll send our, we'll send our statement. And I'm I'm going to qualify it in one way, that if they believe they have a relevant, uh, question, but they have the right here to and secondly, it has to be consistent with the, uh, statement.
NixonThey wouldn't agree.
DeanNo, I I just frankly, couple or three, however many questions, I would get it that way and uh, if they, if both panels will sign a statement or in writing to [unintelligible]
NixonWithout the questions.
DeanUh, I will be the one who will respond to them. I don't have to respond each
ZieglerIt's a one time thing. Alright, and you can only ask the same thing. You've had a extensive, written interrogatory, and you get an arrogant response that I am, that I am taking this question, because I've done it. Your questions, the question raised in these things with, that I didn't find them anyway. If you want us to do this, we can stand up,
NixonAnd anyway, you can, you can answer for a charge that you were, had an answer to something like that. Right? And you can hard,
DeanYeah, do you mean these questions, they are the interrogatories related to the certain questions that I could answer?
NixonYou can answer all nine questions that's under, you're not going to be [unintelligible]. I am under, with the FBI and all other departments.
DeanWell, to make that a formal submission of interrogatory, the best, the safest that has to be and the best that that they pay for all of their legislative purpose, when they surely had no legislative purpose.
NixonYeah. That never [unintelligible] Colson. But they aren't going to be satisfied with any of this.
Unknown[unintelligible]
ZieglerI agree [unintelligible]
Unknown[unintelligible]
NixonThe ears in this town, but in the public mind across this country, as what we're talking about, Haldeman and Mitchell and everybody are the administration. As a whole. Right. They tend to consider it to be much closer than in fact it was.
NixonWell, and that's natural. In fact, if I didn't feel they were that close, they wouldn't be around me. And didn't make a distinction, they're they're they're very close. They're very close to the President. Right hands, and so on. Yeah, I think, well then naturally the thing to knock it down. Knocking them down, I always consider the best, the way to beat them, though, is to turn it on them.
ZieglerYeah. Yeah.
NixonAs, of course, Stennis and Eastland and McClellan, when each of them took over, were hammer hammer hammering at this administration. Senator Fulbright, yeah. The thing about the career, didn't he? He was he had all of them up there. He had all the bad guys, go over to this.
DeanThat's right. And so, uh, I mean, you can't be responsible for everybody there, but, uh, I know, that's what we—
DeanWhatever concerns we have, we're gonna have to evaluate them. But Haldeman was aware that, um, our people were making an effort to find if they could tap into, find people to put into these supposed events, they were planning against us.
NixonWell, he was, I mean, I certainly, I certainly was, too. In fact, he and I, and I stayed thoroughly convinced that they were, and I certainly wanted to know what the hell was going on. For example, I wonder I wonder if you're going to have We always had check and inquire whether, I wonder if there's check. Whether we're going to have a demonstration. Right. We have to check with the Secret Service about what we're going to have.
NixonWe have to check our own people to be sure that they get definite proof. I mean, I've been very disappointed in our counter-actions, because we haven't done enough. [unintelligible] we haven't got people [unintelligible] on the other side.
NixonYou take each of these men, they are brilliant. Staring right at everybody.
NixonGoddamnit, they were violent, and they were massive. And and they came directly from the other side. Now, this was not Gillette, this was not big puckers, and wasn't puckers at all, it was Vegas, and it was pretty goddamned crude. And we regarded that, also, besides the fact that we suffered what? One armed attack
DeanRight.
Nixonagainst our campaign headquarters, and God knows how many firebomb attacks against others.
DeanAnd headquarters shut down.
NixonShut down. Try
DeanThey never shut any act down, that we do remember.
NixonThey have They never shut us down! Never, never, never. I didn't make a speech without having some attack to shut down. You're right. Fire alarm at [unintelligible]. Every secret that I ever had in my own, but damn it [unintelligible].
DeanYeah. Okay.
NixonAnd answer your questions.
DeanYeah.
NixonWe have not responded.
Unknown[unintelligible]
ZieglerOne thing is obvious, it's turning into a pissing match. Namely, that when this comes out, people say, "The press would have you think that Humphrey, Muskie, and Jackson, and Humphrey could look like a that could fool us. The problem is and, um, are we going to say, "Oh, the President went out and laughed and said, 'No, he was completely unaware of it,' or are we going to—
NixonOh, you shoot this that far, Ron. Yes. What are you doing that is doing that?
ZieglerYeah, that's what we shouldn't do.
DeanThe main problem right now is what the committee wants right now is Gray. Okay? Now they have nothing else right now, but they're stuck on Gray. He's one that he went up there yesterday, and he said, "Once you get that motion, and they'll just dive in, on on the raw and on the raw reports.
ZieglerAll right, well they're going to say Gray went up today. You'll guess you get that the FBI investigation released. What is the difference? The whole, the Capitol, FBI interview, they said under oath, that, uh, they've read the quote, question, "Have they covered people who were asked here?
DeanAnd we've always said we've got nothing further to say on this, so it still falls back on it, still falls back to being on you. They ask you, sir. "Wait a minute. Why did you What briefing did Hasan have before he went to the committee?
NixonYeah.
Dean"Did the White House concern that?" If we did, he says, we did not tell them. That the whole thing was that those questions But you didn't hear about those questions. What about the F What about the FBI reporting sheet?
ZieglerYeah.
Dean"Did he read it? Did Gray pass it on? Was it for Segretti's undercover operation?"
ZieglerWell, sir, that's not what I am saying. I don't I don't I'm not calling [unintelligible]
DeanRight.
ZieglerThat's the, that's in fact what are you saying now today? Mainly, they're saying, "Look, you, you, you had the [unintelligible] set up.
DeanRight. I don't think we can hit him first with that question, about Segretti, Chapin, Colson. Well, oh, why don't you stick to the thing, "I'm not going to comment on that, this is a matter of"—
ZieglerThey can say that over and over, they kept doing what I had in mind then, when I, uh, er, closed off.
Unknown[unintelligible]
NixonWait, and always remember, you always have situations where people say, "Well, you didn't have an answer to this, or you can't take it." Now for the press conference, when I have to do that, I always consider it more or less a handicap, certainly on our side, partisan, that the other side isn't going to be convinced by anything.
ZieglerNo.
NixonAnd you cannot, you cannot, because if you give them one day, they can say, "Look, see, they can't answer it, they haven't got the" But, good, that's shouldn't be the thing that they they got they got other things. That shouldn't be the end of you, then, in other words. Actually, sir, or maybe you better you go see Byron about what we should do that day, there's no business.
ZieglerNo, they got to stand by what I have to say. I would advise not doing this briefing today. Fact is, Mr.— Well, maybe do that, you just say to this [unintelligible] of this verse today. Well, damn it, as if, you think you shudder, I am pressing this, you think, look, it's either, I either I am prepared to go out. As I see it, Ron, you can't get it out on a Wednesday.
NixonNo.
ZieglerOn the other hand, you can't go out and fight. I must gag him.
NixonAll right, you've referred back to 2 days for a center prong. Keep the questions if you want to answer. No, but I respond, I've already responded to the same
Unknown[unintelligible]
ZieglerCall me a coward.
DeanAll right.
ZieglerAll right, of course. It's not it's not a matter of not being afraid, but the whole fact is an action. So you want to view the transaction that I get to the table. Let me get in to touch with.
DeanWell, here's the thing: I didn't, because the way I was handled. Well, I would say, they know who Chapin is, and they know who Colson is, and they know about [unintelligible] It's the matter of the whole seven point seven to eight point nine.
Unknown[unintelligible]
DeanWhat do you think, Ron?
ZieglerWell, each question is a, is a [unintelligible]
NixonWell, that's the reason that's the line that I would like to take, Ron, because only in that way do we take on Ervin hearings. Now, one thing that does do
DeanIt reverses your moves, the possibility of sometime having an open Ervin hearing.
NixonNo, hell no.
DeanThat's we've been creeping closer to this.
NixonNo, they always say we should reserve the right, however, otherwise all suggestions, Mr. Ervin, as long as the hearings, as long as the hearings are irresponsible.
ZieglerRight, I'll, so when they come to me, because we found that Senator Ervin, while there are others who appear, what's he appear for, for partisan political purposes?
NixonAnd I reserve the right to set the record straight at any time that things go on at this hearing. But my point is when it's a negative thing, I didn't say, I, in other words, get behind the shield.
Dean[unintelligible]
NixonI don't comment on the hearing. When it's something that we want to get across positive, then I will comment. They won't, the hearing is irresponsible, far as you're, irresponsible.
MooreWell, see what what would you do today then, Ron, this morning?
ZieglerWell, as I said, have you, uh, had a discussion with, uh, yeah, how would what would be the response to the question on this?
DeanWell, the other ends the reasons you're doing this form is to clear it.
MooreTo clear it.
DeanDid you, did you condone, were you aware that this was taking place?
ZieglerNo. Yeah, I'd have to say no to that. I'd have to say that they're totally unauthorized.
NixonWell, then aren't you on the hearing?
DeanThat's the slippery slope.
NixonNow, I wouldn't think I would say, Well, no, you deny that. Now, wait a minute, wait a minute.
MooreCan that be handled?
NixonNo, I, I would say that's a matter for the, that's a matter for the, the committee to decide.
MooreUh, I, I think normally, Ron, you could you could deny knowledge. You must deny knowledge.
DeanYou must deny knowledge. This kind of knowledge, that's the whole, that's not commenting. You're saying, "I didn't know anything about it." That's taking the position.
MooreNow beyond that, I would take the answer, "Now the hearing, the question you're asking assumes that's accurate, which is the whole problem with this hearing. There's been no chance to cross-examine and fairness and the venom of this investigation, accusations have been submitted." Now, what about the other question? What about the question: What about this kind of practice? What, what do you think of this kind of practice?
ZieglerRight.
NixonThat's where the thing gets.
ZieglerNow, we've already indicated we disapprove of wiretapping. Now, if any of if any practice was illegal, I certainly disapprove. There you go.
MooreAll right.
NixonWell, we indicated disapprove. You're in You're in back to 2 months ago. We make we made it very clear in briefings.
MooreNobody in the White House practiced.
NixonThat's right, espionage and sabotage or unauthorized, illegal
ZieglerThat's, yeah, that's the point that I'm making. Everybody here's using the words "espionage" and "sabotage." Espionage and sabotage is illegal, only when against the government.
NixonHell, you can have espionage and sabotage all you want, can't you, unless you use illegal means?
DeanThat's right. Uh, there are some there are some statutory violations. If a mail if a mailer is put out,
NixonYeah, I know. Without the writer's name on it.
Deanthat's a violation. If that, uh, affects the work of a campaign, it's a violation. Uh, if you cause such demonstration that the candidate himself cannot, uh, speak or the like, there are violations that hit into civil rights, etc., in business, so you get some of that.
ZieglerI think I should refer to the fact, too, that we've tried our best to avoid that in our, about that too.
DeanSee, we got we got a case there, though, of all the boys that flew across.
NixonUh this massive, uh, this massive demonstration, including violence, has no, uh, has no comparison, so I think if anybody takes up the other, I would hardly bring it up.
DeanWell, we we have just now completed a massive, uh, study on that. Now, you ought to look at it, because you can cross to cross the six states that they tossed eggs, they
ZieglerGeorge Wallace is a good instance. George Wallace was brutally and personally insulted with the, uh,
NixonI would try to avoid it. Now, at least say, I tried to run a campaign without that kind of thing.
DeanNow, listen to this. This is This is a point to make, though. I think that
MooreYou don't want me to explain that, right?
NixonNo, I don't think so. Now, the point What I'm trying to say is whether or not I, I take your position.
Dean[unintelligible]
NixonWell, let's turn back We're getting away from the damn question. What would you say then, Ron, for, uh, then if I would throw out, "Did you condone that kind of activity?" What would you say? "Well,"
Dean"I think you must deny it."
Nixon"Hardly not. But, then how would you press it?" What did he do? What if you clarify that by saying the President hates, you know, the mission of politics or the
Mooreactivities of bothering each other and stuff like that. I know the people don't like it. But does that happen? Now, I don't know that you say that that's a part of it. We have to set a line somewhere.
NixonYeah. What if you took the tact that, uh, they've been doing this, we haven't tested that?
ZieglerWell, why don't we say that, weird, you could, why don't we say that the in politics, they're they're, uh, as everyone knows, you have blatant demonstrations. I mean there was a massive amount of that at the convention.
NixonAnd it's covered in the hearing. Could I say that?
ZieglerI'd say, why then our campaign, that was avoided, the other side. As far as the activity of this sort is concerned, they go on whatever campaign.
NixonDon't go on and say illegal, don't say illegal activity.
DeanI wouldn't.
NixonHuh?
DeanI think with some people they thought they were just pulling pranks, and didn't think about the legality, with others it's out of line. It's the latter who should run into these into these things.
ZieglerWell, are you saying the question is saying that everything that went on
Moorethat everything that's coming out now has to be technically against the law? What he's doing is despicable. Isn't this so?
ZieglerYeah. Is that is that fair, John?
NixonThat's right, and the problem is, it's despicable.
DeanWell, the point, that, my point is, does this, this little factor style the point that I thought we'd say, that, "Of course, I don't approve of such activities.
NixonYeah.
DeanAnd I'm, and I'm not going to answer that question because I think you'd, you'd like to see that not that we are butchering, but whether the rest of [unintelligible] actually is so big. Isn't this the area that, that, that, that I thought so, well, that's not
MooreWell, all these think that the the ticking toxins are meant to imply that, well, it's that's the extent that's what, you really wanted that get that ticked off on our side, because we have always been the victim of it.
NixonWell, listen to this, this this is the point of view then. On the walks themselves, when they're gonna have that, don't get straight onto that.
ZieglerYeah.
NixonYou're not going to go, that means, would you agree, you might, so why didn't you fire him?
DeanCan this repeat this, whole thing, the other aspect with the
ZieglerYeah. What if we say that, see we haven't ever dwell on that, this man was a, as a matter of fact, did play a role, not interfering with the board, actually, on the Watergate. I thought, I thought, I kind of said
DeanHe wasn't, he had no reported prank, that I know of.
ZieglerWell, he looked into it. I did. Okay, we've got to go. We're getting closer.
Deanit wasn't anything with your new labor standard that need be reported under [unintelligible]
MooreWhy not?
DeanWell, one it was not it wasn't the law wasn't even accepted at that time. An investigative report on the Watergate matter was this kind of an activity, wouldn't have to be paid, wouldn't have to be reported [unintelligible]
MooreOr anything else, either.
DeanThat was not being investigated by Segretti.
MooreWell, let's see now. If Segretti will furnish the documents down to the period of time, then they will address the questions.
MooreIf you do not furnish them they will then say, what is this meant to do?
MooreWhy did- why was there a money and investigation to look into the activities of the candidate?
MooreOr to find out what else was happening and stop it.
MooreNow, this I think was giving this to Gray, is initial-
Moorebecause I think it's a mistake for the President, mistake for open-
ZieglerI think in the press conference-
MooreWell that's fine. I mean in a statement the Press Secretary or the spokesman-
ZieglerI think I think that for me to get into the idea of what the efforts of the campaign or that we reported something,
ZieglerI just think that I should say that, "I'm not going to get into the instances of the matter [unintelligible] campaign, but will respond to that."
DeanWell, a firmer position is you've taken all these questions. You took comments about the hearing.
ZieglerYeah.
DeanUh that you won't comment. You're very well aware of the testimony. It speaks for itself and that's it.
DeanMr. Jones-
MooreThis is an attempt to inject this into the FBI hearing, a White House aide, a paid senator.
DeanAll right, well then, what do we say to Senator Kennedy?
DeanKennedy together with Tonight guys and so forth. But you didn't understand that [crosstalk]
NixonKennedy hasn't fallen, properly, into it because Kennedy is an idiot.
DeanAnd also they'll say, why was it kept- kept a secret?
NixonWell, who cares?
MooreWhat would you say to that?
DeanWell, they can say, uh, they might- they had called- and I honestly feel, if one side were to publish
Deanthat he would get all their- that they would get all their hurry-
NixonFine. What ever [unintelligible]
NixonBecause [unintelligible] to check the truth.
ZieglerSomebody got the motion-
DeanYeah, but-
NixonHe's not-
DeanHe's not correct, that the, uh, if all of them know it's retained them, but once they know, I think they know it.
NixonAll right. Who knows? I don't think they're going to win with Gray, do you think so?
DeanOh, they can't. That would be real. Even if Chapin hired Segretti,
Deannot- he didn't know Segretti as Segretti uh someone was out there who knew trick- trick stuff. He hired them.
NixonYeah, yeah.
DeanNow that's hurting, and I'm sure he knew that.
DeanAnd if we don't have that part of the campaign, can't hold it, well, sure.
MooreWell, I think you've go to hold back and say that-
MooreHe didn't know anything, but-
Mooremotivation, damn little. That was part of
Moorethe whole thing, and done.
MooreOnce you go over the hurdle,
MooreMr. President-
DeanWell, of course, our view was once we crossed that line-
Deanwell of course, we [crosstalk]
Unknown[unintelligible]
DeanWatergate,
DeanWatergate Segretti had nothing to do with Watergate, so cheer up about it.
DeanOne of the- one of the things I I've definitely got onto the committee is the reason we can't start
Deanconfirming or denying, what Chapin did do or what Kalmbach did do, or not,
Deanis because the allegations against Segretti are are totally unsubstantiated.
DeanYou can go out and talk to a lot of people and ask if they'd do this, that, and the other, we don't know what Segretti-
DeanThe FBI has never investigated Segretti, per se, for what he did, and how did-
DeanNo sir, they only asked him what his connection was with Howard Hunt and Gordon Liddy,
Deanbecause they came across a telephone toll Segretti's phone number.
DeanAnd he didn't know anything about the Watergate, and they said, "What were you doing?" and "Well, I was out here pulling pranks."
DeanAnd they went on.
DeanThey never went into his his pranks.
MooreYeah, but to seek what you have in the issue you've turned on-
Mooreyou haven't had [unintelligible]
MooreNever had the FBI investigation [unintelligible]
MooreSo the only appropriate information we have now, is the material
Mooreis the material, that was obtained,
Mooreproperly, through the federal trials-
MooreJustice [crosstalk] Department. It was one, Segretti was involved
Moorein trailing candidates, and trying to get into candidates-
NixonDo you have that? Where-
DeanI that that is the information I have in my file. I was furnished, when I went through the FBI files, I did see all the files.
MooreSecond, would-
DeanI did have access. One thing I didn't- I never had any [unintelligible]
DeanWell that doesn't factual say that I did. Uh I It was not until after the fact, that they had squandered-
DeanMy my real whole link to Segretti was on the tenth of, uh, November,
Deanwhen I sat down with Segretti and debriefed him.
DeanAs to what did this mean for Chapin, or for Haldeman, or anybody at the White House. Uh so we could make an assessment.
NixonAll right, fine. Tell you this, will you please find [unintelligible]
DeanMy view, I would provide no information if they get into doing illegal actions, might just say that.
NixonYes, sir.
DeanThey're out, and you
Deanyou see this [laughter] as far as Watergate, it's all illegal, and as far as Chapin and as far as Kalmbach,
Deanand uh, Kalmbach, they didn't know. You know, they're not to judge. Mr. Segretti has has fought felony,
Deanmisdemeanor type offenses. He's putting out flyers without the FBI knowing about it.
DeanAre you telling me it's totally like there would be anything to worry with Chapin or Kalmbach, as well as anyone in the White House? I I can say it's crazy.
NixonRight.
DeanThey have said that the FBI has done that. Well, they they said that uh, he was briefed, and well the other guy was, so I better say that to get the help.
DeanIf you pay it, they'll open the door for that question. Actually, as Gray testified-
Deanand the reason he didn't investigate Segretti, was that after the interrogations, they decided that there were no illegalities. That was the FBI.
ZieglerRight.
DeanNow that's about the same thing.
ZieglerYeah.
DeanThat the Department of Justice, the Criminal Division, they'll they'll tell you that they are still looking into the transcript, but they have refused, and they have the FBI was set off by someone that they had reason to go to talk to Chapin again, for his third interview.
DeanThere's glaring gaps in his interview, as to what his relationship was with Segretti,
Deanbecause there's already gaps in there, because I was on the fall schedules, thinking about China, later planning advance for Russia.
DeanAnd I didn't have to deal with the fellow.
NixonTrue.
DeanWell, he can't wash it out. I talk to Dwight all night, did not have the degree in the following to the one which Michael Stone on the outside had that, but they uh, they are checking the transcript
Deanof their investigation in the Criminal Division to see if they find any violations by Segretti.
NixonSo, we're going to assume-
DeanAnd they went into the four points, which really, which is the only accurate information they hold now as to what Segretti did. Following people, part of the time he was in Florida, sending out mailings, stealing the files, and,
DeanAll of which, to approve. But that is what the initial Segretti story charged.
DeanThey have no basic information to assess that October 12th story to refuting [unintelligible]
NixonWell, let's come back to, let's come back to [unintelligible]

— 7 min 20 s with no transcribed speech —

DeanRight now, the whole focus, what you've got to get around, Ziegler pointed it out, I think we're safe on having another line to lean back to, is the question, "Well, then why not Cooper?" Right now—
NixonWell, that's why, I wanted Ronald to read mine. [unintelligible] ask with the Dean question, the Cooper question,
DeanThat's right. The report doesn't say that.
Nixon[unintelligible] That isn't the same. The Cooper proposal, which I had, that it would be improper for me to involve the Cooper proposal. Maybe that that would help.
DeanThat's correct. You don't have to say that—
ZieglerLook, if I don't give it this morning, then Ron, the Chief could give it.
DeanSo I should give, at least, our position out. The reason I think we respond to Ervin's letter, our effort is to cooperate.
ZieglerThen the next question, should I put this burden on Ervin?
DeanPosture on it. The Senate sends this headmaster to Ervin to make this investigation, this uh,
ZieglerErvin's committee hasn't even met yet.
DeanHe said the other day that the subpoenas wouldn't be issued until the middle of April. I said yesterday, look, we just don't have the time to sit around and wait for them to decide.
NixonAll right, here the question, he does not give an answer. Then, what about Pat Gray? Pat Gray come out, so forth, and say, you know, we have this question
DeanSure.
NixonAre you handling this thing well in the Gray committee?
DeanOthers, yes. Kleindienst had, or earlier, always said,
NixonAlways keep that distinction between Watergate and outside—
DeanOutside.
NixonSegretti and chapels, and all that, probably Segretti, but Segretti's outside, chapels outside.
DeanAnd outside of our campaign organization, or whatever it is, and then the whole dirty tricks thing is their own in-the-inside, their own dirty campaign, which they've got their right to tell us about, sure. That they're entitled to tell us.
ZieglerAll right, let's look at this.
DeanSure, go tell him. I don't care. It's fine. Nothing to worry about.
NixonNo, no, I know that. [unintelligible]
DeanWhat are they worried about? If they're concerned about this whole pattern of what they did as being the acts of sabotage, they've won a lot of it. The Watergate was a specific act, uh a specific act that everyone has focused on, that has been convicted on. Now, that's what it should be.
DeanAll this talk about sabotage necessarily, has nothing necessarily, it is separated entirely, uh uh an investigation that will find out about that.
NixonNobody can do that.
DeanThat's right. And they shouldn't allow the Senate to do that now. We've got a prior uh pending case before the judge, it's should be sentenced. We ought to be more honest and do it right now. Right.
DeanThey can't really argue that answer because they're going to fight.
NixonWhy can't you dad, say now listen, and as far as you're concerned, damn it all. If it has to turn out that I'm taking the heat, I'll take it.
DeanThat's right.
NixonOf course, I don't care how they are about this here. That's, that's true. Now there isn't, there's you know, there's been either one of the other for two years. They have you for a year, yeah, right.
DeanWell, we've walked it. See, they went through this with the ITT thing, and they wanted this, and they wanted that, and we just marched right into it.
NixonYou marched all the way through it. Well, that's right.
DeanThe president's feelings this morning is, [unintelligible]
NixonWell, go ahead, Ronald, and shed [unintelligible]
DeanUh they're just going to ask this damn question. Now, what else is happening? Other things, uh
ZieglerNow listen, this is the week where they begin to listen to that, they're going to talk about the Gray hearing uh and the fact this morning it is it has not, the trouble to reach the subject.
ZieglerI don't know what they got to talk to you about. There is a committee, they haven't asked any questions about, the uh, uh, Vesco case, of course, they got caught. And this area of of what, what kind of corruption in the Nixon administration. The increasing heights, the uh, that could totally wreck this entire administration,
Ziegleruh. How about those allegations they threw about you to the public and everything, the bad and every system that it is? That's the kind of question. "Are you concerned, Mr. President, about the increased tempo of allegations and of the planning and walked out like this secretly?"
DeanWhat should we respond to it, Ronald? If they give you that, well, it has not been investigated, they haven't seen anything. You know, they are probably just they're probably going to touch the other questions today on what they did after on the partisan thing that came out last night,
Deanwent out on the network news and all of that, and uh,
NixonWhy does someone have to say it? We have the uh accusation,
DeanThere's no relation between the two.
NixonOkay, that's what, that's what I go with the car, just hang around then. Right. You bet.
NixonWhat about, what are their best skills, that key, where do we leave it then?
DeanWell, yeah, they knew we were going to have a hearing, in fact they already knew that.
NixonYes, so take that. All we can do anything about our people around here, I, I'm glad, that do like to tell them and they're always worried about this, and about that,
DeanYeah.
Nixonand they shouldn't.
DeanYeah.
  • 037-099 8:55 AM · 4 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John W. Dean, III talked on the telephone from 8:55 am to 8:59 am.
  • 419-015 8:55 AM · 4 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John W. Dean, III met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 8:55 am to 8:59 am.
  • 419-016 8:59 AM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Manolo Sanchez met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 8:59 am and 9:25 am.
  • 419-017 8:59 AM · 9 min — President Richard M. Nixon met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 8:59 am and 9:25 am.
  • 419-018 8:59 AM · 5 min — President Richard M. Nixon met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at an unknown time between 8:59 am and 9:25 am.
  • 419-019 9:25 AM · 30 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Henry A. Kissinger, and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 9:25 am to 9:50 am.
  • 879-001 10:54 AM · 7 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Geoffrey C. Shepard, Vernon D. Acree, Albert Seeley, Paul Boulad, Robert Nunnery, Richard Hopkins, and Gustave Fassler met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 10:54 am and 11:01 am.
  • 037-100 11:01 AM · 13 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 11:01 am and 11:02 am.

Conversation 419-020, March 14, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/419-020 (accessed November 20, 2026).