President Nixon met with William Safire to provide strategic guidance on an upcoming speech regarding school busing and desegregation. Nixon emphasized the need for a simple, compelling narrative that positions his administration as decisive in curbing mandatory busing while maintaining a commitment to equal education. He directed Safire to cut technical legal jargon and focus on vivid, relatable examples of the hardship busing imposes on families to secure broader public support, particularly ahead of the Florida primary. The discussion prioritized immediate legislative action over long-term constitutional amendments to address public frustration with current court-ordered desegregation policies.
This clip was extracted from the full tape recording by Easy Nixon.
Listen to the full tape segment
Position in tape: 05:02:59 – 05:23:08
part C, 58:31
685a.mp3
685b.mp3
685c.mp3
685d.mp3
NARA Description
On March 14, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon and William L. Safire met in the Oval Office of the White House from 2:55 pm to 3:15 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 685-012 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 685-12
Date: March 14, 1972
Time: 2:55 pm - 3:15 pm
Location: Oval Office
The President talked with William L. Safire.
[See Conversation No. 21-66]
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was generated automatically by AI (WhisperX) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Names and numbers are often wrong; speakers are not identified. Do not cite it as authoritative — verify against the audio and the finding aid.
Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).
Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.
Drink, Sapphire, please.
Bill, I wanted to give you a little guidance with regard to this thing you're working on now.
If you know what you want, we want 10 minutes, so we're talking about 1,500 words in 10-12 minutes.
Second, with regard to tilt, the message, of course, will be given out the following day, and it naturally will be balanced, and if anything, will be tilted toward a reasonable approach.
The tilt on this one,
Because there should be any guilt at all.
There should be more toward those, toward the majority, basically.
In other words, in other words, you don't have to put in all the qualifying things about how, uh, this is my job, trying to, to demonstrate that this is not great and so forth and so forth.
A little bit going on that, but, but just so that people are covered.
But the main point is that this must be one that in effect says, we've got this problem, bust in, and we're going to do something about it.
And this is what we're going to do.
And this is why I'm against it, and so forth.
Now we're going to put in, of course, we're going to turn the clock back on education and so forth and so on.
Educations and so forth.
But as far as those concerns in that direction.
As far as what is said then, I, as much as possible, pick up, I mean, we just pick up on the rhetoric that we'll have in the message, because there's a lot of very good rhetoric in that original.
In other words, those lines are fine.
I don't mind adding some.
But in terms of what could be added, what should be added would be along these lines.
to make it understandable for the television audience.
I think if you're sitting out loud, you can put your mic to it.
I've had a chance to do things in business, and I've got it.
But I'd say, getting something in the building that doesn't, for example, we could say, leave the bus.
under a, I don't have one, an eight-year-old child is picked up by a, there's been violence in the school, which she can walk to and where we call it a corridor or a bus.
She has to get up a half hour, an hour early in the morning, and then ride a bus for an hour, both ways, or something like that, to a faraway, in other words, another area, etc.
You know, take that, this first, this is done in the name of basically attending segregation.
And of course, you carry out Brown, which
It certainly is detrimental to education.
And it's got to stop.
I'm against this.
This has got to stop.
And, you know, using it, putting in a vivid example, one of the most horrible examples that we hear so much about, we'll say, for example, that this is what's happening now.
This will drive it.
I don't want to discuss this with anybody.
Maybe it goes to Elliot.
And we land the rest of the wall because the point is, it's what I'm concerned about, it's what the country's concerned about, and also, they're right.
Now, it's true that there are many examples where that isn't the case, but it is that we're trying to get about, and that is stirring up the country.
Now, it's also true that a lot of white parents are disturbed about
sending their kids to black neighborhoods, black teachers, kids with such late minds, that's true.
I got it.
Two, you can tell this child is white or black.
I mean it.
I don't care what they tell Spider Black, the child who has to go past the neighborhood school.
In other words, that is where we should go.
But five minutes away is the neighborhood school where all of her friends go.
Because, I'm sure you've heard it, because of the corridor, you see, she has to get out of the way, get out of the way, an hour or two, right at the school lunch for an hour, clear across town, another school, another neighborhood, another neighborhood.
This is wrong.
This is going to stop.
You see what I mean?
It is on that that we must make that positive example that will make this that we talk.
All the other outcomes is of course important, but the message the following day is always one of the editorials that we have to seize upon and largely by the legislation and the press.
So what I'm really saying is make this as simple as possible.
Don't have to go into any detail in pointing out the exceptions and the fine points and the rest about what the moratorium does and does not cover.
I mean, let that come the next day.
It's just enough that it's honest.
But so the country, the people, including over 50 percent of the black that are watching their kids, they will say, oh, my God, he is saying what we believe.
See, now that's clear enough of the record.
And this has to be to say that, you know, the idea that
This is not a black and white issue.
We don't want to turn the clock back on segregation, on desegregation.
Let's all move forward together, et cetera, et cetera.
I want to lie in so that, because I think it's necessary to enlighten the country a bit here, too, and not just make a waltz kind of speech.
But what I'm concerned about is here,
The Sympathetic Answer, as you know, is a constitutional act of assaulting and busting.
Now, we're redacting that, and we're even redacting the Sympathetic Mortarium.
We're not going as far as some of the more liberal people want.
It's just made as assaulting means nothing.
They're still leaving them harassed in courts.
One of them that I think is certainly worth looking to get the hell out of the courts is that phrase that I added as a regard to, well, it isn't in there yet, but I do think it would be better to see that the court decisions in here are contradictory, confusing, AI-ed.
It's harassed, amazed, it's a scandal, it's about what have you.
And not because, of course, you can't do that.
No, it's not your Congress's stuff, isn't it?
and build this factory and so forth and so on.
But my answer is a court decision because it gets the money off our back with what, with regard to what's already happened, you see.
Well, I don't know what this is talking about, but at least it'll give you a little bit of a feel of that.
I mean, 20,000 workers is what I want to get out of 1,500.
Yes, sir?
Well, I think so.
I mean, I do feel different.
I feel that some of these stations are going to be closed.
I think we've got to grab right into it.
I mean, I'm not sure what way the way it starts in there isn't too bad, as you would say.
But I ought to talk about an issue that is, you know, after all this will be two days out of the Florida primary, that an issue that is of concern to everybody.
uh, all Americans, or something like that.
You know what I mean?
It's an issue that affects every American.
The issue of busing divides sometimes.
The issue of the United States education, a little of that, the monarchy, sorry.
But, and then I would say, my position on busing, well, I'm against it.
I've said it many, many times.
My position also with regard to segregation is I oppose, as do the great majority of Americans, and on segregation, I oppose that.
The question is how can we deal with desegregation?
in a way that does not result in inferior education, because the purpose of Brown, of course, was not primarily desegregation.
The purpose of Brown was better education.
I mean, that was what they thought.
That case was not.
We can't say that.
quite in those words, but that's what Brown, Brown was about, but it's highly suggestive.
It was about education, not the segregation.
And it was because segregated education was found to be, as we saw with Brown and Green, inferior education that they said segregated education is unconstitutional.
See?
Now, so that makes it.
Now, we, there have been many, many suggestions over what we must do as students.
and maybe tie up what is a constitutional amendment rather than a so-called constitutional amendment, and then blast it out by saying that a constitutional amendment is the way to look at it.
But the main trouble is that there's a gobbledygook together with another gobbledygook.
The majority of them would have to pass, of course.
It would be a matter of years.
And what is needed, it would take too long.
And this is, of course, not the time to do it.
What is needed is action now.
And therefore, what I have is a program to deal with now.
And the way to get action now is by looking at the program.
Well, yeah, more than that, we have in there, if you read the message, we have actually, we're asking for other reasons too, but basically, to be the same, that there is a part of the subject from some of the great questions that arise, whether constitutional amendments would work and so forth,
A, for those that are interested in doing something, it does not speak to the problem now.
We've got it now.
It takes two years.
And one year of a child's life is worth saving on one year of a period of education because the cost is too high to pay or something like that.
And then you come to the left for one, the moratorium.
We're going to stop all of us at this time.
We have a chance at two.
We're for equality, equal opportunity, education, action, and work, and health.
improve education for our kids to live, and so forth and so on.
Three, to be sure we get a little bit stronger in this one, I instructed the agencies of the government to take that in, agency planning, regulation, all agencies of the government, and every government.
to carry out the spirit of this message and their actions.
You see, the radio devil is here.
Bill reminds us that people are Justice Department lawyers, P-H-E-W-N, here in the 40s.
And I ought to be the one to say that.
And I've also instructed the Justice Department to intervene in cases where this is not being carried out.
And then it comes in with some more oxymoron rhetoric at the end.
I do not believe, I don't think you need to put in that long defense.
The fact that I am really for equal rights, I mean, that's just, I mean, it's not our record that matters.
That can be any other message.
You can say it in a sentence, but you don't need to put up all that.
I'm just telling you these are things you can drop out at great length.
You can drop out all that rigmarole about how the one's worked in California.
You can all drop that out and just say it in a sentence.
But I'm mainly interested in getting across the fact that this is an issue for the busing people.
What I'm concerned about is that there is no way, let me say, that you can get support from the people that are pro-busing.
They're going to get this, they're going to get anything.
What I am concerned about is that we will not get the support of those, I don't mean to get a waltz, but we will not get the support of the decent people like the Baylors and the Rocks and the rest, and the Ricketts who have constitutional amendments.
We've got to get their support.
And unless we speak to that issue, very effectively we won't get that support.
It's that that we have to do primarily through this message, you see.
and also through this message for everybody we want to put the president strong on the side fighting against boston the question is how to build it how to build the right way i don't have a reason i don't have the luxury of identifying about it and being simplistic about it this is a very complicated thing we want to do the right thing we want to do this we want to have uh we want to deal with this problem without
without stopping, you know, turning, without violating constitutional rights of people.
You know?
Yes, I have, but I have something that actually is a blank thousand words to the Congress.
I urge all of us to read it carefully.
I've been working on it.
I've been working on it for weeks.
I have the people from all over the country who have varied reasons to discuss it.
That's my best thing.
My lesson is that the best, the fairest, the most decent solution to a terribly difficult problem is the most difficult domestic problem that I have encountered since the present, and perhaps the most difficult one that has confronted this nation in a hundred years, to put it that way.
Also recorded on March 14, 1972
021-066 2:55 PM · 20 min — President Richard M. Nixon and William L. Safire talked on the telephone from 2:55 pm to 3:15 pm.
021-067 3:15 PM · 7 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 3:15 pm and 4:18 pm.
685-013 3:16 PM · 8 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the Oval Office of the White House from 3:16 pm to 3:24 pm.
685-014 3:24 PM · 56 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the Oval Office of the White House from 3:24 pm to 3:25 pm.
685-015 3:25 PM · 47 sec — President Richard M. Nixon, Debbie Wright, George H. Mahon, Raymond L. Schafer, Macon T. Edwards, James T. Hazelwood, John E. Nidecker, and White House photographer met in the Oval Office of the White House from 3:25 pm to 3:31 pm.
685-016 3:31 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 3:31 pm and 3:37 pm.
685-017 3:31 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 3:31 pm and 3:37 pm.
685-018 3:37 PM · 14 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Stephen B. Bull, Tricia Nixon Cox, Luci Johnson Nugent, Patrick L. Nugent, and White House photographer met in the Oval Office of the White House from 3:37 pm to 3:49 pm.
Conversation 685-012, March 14, 1972. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/685-012 (accessed November 17, 2026).