Conversation 778-005

TapeTape 778StartFriday, September 15, 1972 at 8:36 AMEndFriday, September 15, 1972 at 9:58 AMParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President);  Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob");  Connally, John B.;  Haig, Alexander M., Jr.Recording deviceOval Office

On September 15, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, John B. Connally, and Alexander M. Haig, Jr. met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 8:36 am and 9:58 am. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 778-005 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 778-5

Date: September 15, 1972
Time: Unknown between 8:36 am and 9:58 am
Location: Oval Office

The President met with H.R. ("Bob") Haldeman.

                                       (rev. Feb-24)

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 11/14/2022.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[778-005-w001]
[Duration: 2m]

       1972 campaign
              -Proposed speech for the President
                     -John B. Connally
                            -Delivery of speech
                                    -The President’s opinion
                            -September 14, 1972
                            -Speechwriter

*****************************************************************

         Sale of wheat to the People's Republic of China [PRC]
            -Earl L. Butz disclosure
            -Department of Agriculture
                 -Leak
            -John D. Ehrlichman
                 -Fact-finding attempt
            -Charles W. Colson's knowledge
                 -Butz's knowledge
            -Propriety of sale
                 -Possible problem
            -Butz
            -Administration's knowledge
            -Circumstances
            -The President's view
                 -Butz
            -Colson

The President talked with John B. Connally between 9:02 am and 9:04 am.

[Conversation No. 778-5A]

                                       (rev. Feb-24)

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 11/14/2022.
3m 3s segment cleared for release. 20s remain closed as 778-005-w002.]
[Personal Returnable]
[778-005-w002]
[Duration: 3m 3s]

       Greetings
              -John B. Connally
                     -Speech
                            -Mutual Broadcasting System, Incorporated
                            -The President’s opinion
                     -Five-minute segment

       John B. Connally speech
              -Foreign policy stance
                     -Style and tone
                     -Related to Administration policy

The President talked with John Connally at an unknown time after 9:02 am.

The President met with H. R. Haldeman after 9:02 am.

       The President’s schedule

       John B. Connally’s health

*****************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
[Personal Returnable]
[778-005-w002]
[Duration: 20s]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2

*****************************************************************

                                        (rev. Feb-24)

       John B. Connally’s speech
              -Rhythm
                    -The President’s opinion

[End of telephone conversation]

       John B. Connally’s speech
              -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman’s assessment
              -The President’s opinion
                      -Political speeches

*****************************************************************

Alexander M. Haig, Jr. entered at 9:05 am.

         Foreign policy
            -William P. Rogers's statement
                -Contact with Europeans
                -State Department's attitude
            -European Security Conference
                -Announcement
                     -Soviet Union proposal for meetings
                          -European view
                     -State Department

         House Armed Service Committee hearings
           -Gen. John D. Lavelle
                -Unauthorized North Vietnamese bombings
                    -Administration's stance
                         -Protective reaction
                    -Falsified reports
           -Bombing of North Vietnam
           -Gen. Creighton W. Abrams, Jr.
                -Testimony

         Vietnam peace negotiations
            -Henry A. Kissinger

                              (rev. Feb-24)

        -Status
        -Schedule
        -Meeting with Georges J. R. Pompidou
        -Edward R. G. Heath's meeting with Kissinger
        -Kissinger's meeting with Willy Brandt
   -Status of negotiations
        -State Department representative
             -Meeting
        -Rogers's reaction

Vietnam military situation
   -Quang Tri invasion
       -Viet Cong
       -Marine battalions
       -Casualties
   -Viet Cong offensive
       -Haig's view
   -Viet Cong military strength
       -Food
       -Sickness
       -Military Region [MR] 1 area
       -Hue
       -Ammunition
       -Effect of US military tactics
           -Mining
           -Bombing
       -Blockade's effect
           -World War I
           -Civil War

Foreign policy
   -Soviet Union grain deal
        -New York Times article
            -Soviet attitude toward Jews
                -Effect
            -American public opinion
                -Value of trade agreement
            -Most Favored Nation [MFN] status
                -Congress filibuster
   -Forthcoming meeting with Kissinger
   -Strategic Arms Limitation Talks [SALT]

                                        (rev. Feb-24)

                  -Vote

Haig left at 9:12 am.

          Grain deal
             -Public opinion
             -Efforts by administration opponents
                 -John D. Ehrlichman's view
             -Profit making
                 -Grain dealers

          Democratic Party press release
            -Possible bugging of telephones
                -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] investigation
                -Circumstances
                -Fingerprints
                -FBI view
                     -Type of device
            -Jean Westwood
                -Little red box discovery
                -Edward Bennett Williams
                -FBI investigation
                     -Little red box
                -Possible bugging
                     -Vice President Spiro T. Agnew's view

          Watergate
            -Indictments
                 -John N. Mitchell's meeting with Dwight L. Chapin
                     -Grand Jury testimony

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 11/14/2022.
32m 53s segment cleared for release. 1s remain closed as 778-005-w004.]
[Personal Returnable]
[778-005-w004]
[Duration: 32m 53s]

       1972 election

                                (rev. Feb-24)

       -John B. Connally
       -Committee to Re-elect the President [CRP]
       -The President’s forthcoming September 22, 1972 trip to Texas
       -John B. Connally's health
              -Cold
       -John B. Connally's speech
              -Style
              -Content
                     -Democratic Party
                     -Bipartisanship
              -White House speechwriter's style
                     -William L. Safire
              -Content
                     -Criticism of George S. McGovern
                     -Political
              -Author
                     -Possibly hired by George E. Christian
              -Content
                     -US world stature
              -George E. Christian
              -Potential use in 30-second spot
              -Rhetoric
              -Content concerning Democrats

1972 election
       -Charles W. Colson
       -Media coverage
       -George S. McGovern
       -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman forthcoming talk with Ronald L. Ziegler
       -Campaign crowds
               -Numbers
                      -The President’s opinion
                      -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman’s opinion
               -Walter L. Cronkite, Jr.
               -Media coverage
                      -The President’s opinion
       -The President's campaign strategy
               -Possible surprise appearance by George S. McGovern
                      -Secret Service
                      -Potential response by the President
               -Debate with George S. McGovern

                         (rev. Feb-24)

               -Press' coverage
       -Campaign allegations by George S. McGovern
               -Attacks on the President by R. Sargent Shriver
               -Democrats' election strategy
                       -Lack of coordinated attacks
                       -Fund-raising
               -Eunice (Kennedy) Shriver’s involvement
       -John F. Kennedy
               -Time since John F. Kennedy assassination
               -George S. McGovern supporters
                       -Youth
                               -Memory of John F. Kennedy
-Forthcoming September 17, 1972 trip to Italian Fall Festival in Maryland
       -Attendance
       -Patrick Cardinal O'Boyle
       -Catholic community
       -Timing
               -Types of music
       -The President's schedule for arrival
               -Tricia Nixon Cox
                       Could not attend event
               -Italian constituency
               -Speech content
                       -Duration
       -Layout
-September 22, 1972 Texas campaign visit
       -John B. Connally
       -The President's schedule
               -High school appearance
                       -Potential merits
                       -Speech content
-George S. McGovern campaign strategy
       -Reliance on Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
               -Response to Herbert G. Klein
       -Gordon Wiles
       -Attack by the President's campaign
       -Evidence of the President meeting with people on a daily basis
               -Henry A. Kissinger
-Support for George S. McGovern
-Robert H. Finch
       -Effect of Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy support

                                   (rev. Feb-24)

                   -Youth support for George S. McGovern
                           -Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
                           -Percentages
                           -Population number
           -Walter L. Cronkite, Jr.
                   -Columbia Broadcasting System [CBS] News
                           -Harris poll results
                                   -George S. McGovern's strength
                                   -Media coverage
           -Polls in past campaigns
                   -Effects on the President's campaign
                   -George S. McGovern
                           -Evening Star article
                           -Polls
                                   -American Broadcasting Company [ABC]
                                           -Vietnam
                                   -Support in Texas
                                   -Democratic precincts
                                   -Labor support
           -Support for the President
                   -Potentially wider than understood
           -1968 election parallels
                   -John P. Roche’s observation
                           -1968 election
                                   -Opposition to Hubert H. Humphrey
                           -George C. Wallace's impact on election

*****************************************************************

BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 4
[Personal Returnable]
[778-005-w004]
[Duration: 1s]

END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 4

*****************************************************************

                                (rev. Feb-24)

1972 election
       -George S. McGovern
              -Early stages of campaign
                      -Democratic nomination
                      -National poll
       -George S. McGovern support
              -National exposure of both candidates
              -Lawrence F. O'Brien, Jr.
                      -Positive aspect of George S. McGovern
              -Supporters of Democratic Party
              -Kevin P. Phillips
              -Charles W. Colson's view
                      -New Republican Party majority formation
       -New majority
              -Margins
              -Shifting away from Democrats for Nixon
              -Voter mindset
                      -Ford/Chevrolet comparison
              -Parallels to Franklin D. Roosevelt
                      -Victory in 1932 election
                      -Franklin D. Roosevelt's first term
                              -The President’s opinion
                      -1940 election
                              -Wendell L. Willkie’s performance
       -George S. McGovern
              -Need for traditional Democratic Party support
              -John B. Connally’s importance
       -Charles W. Colson
              -Republican Party
       -Robert J. Dole
              -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman’s opinion
                      -Potential role in campaign
                      -Difference from Rogers C.B. Morton
                      -Negative outlook
              -Support for the President
       -Campaign strategy
              -Clark Macgregor
                      -Ability to attack and defend
              -Role for Robert J. Dole
                      -Attack Lawrence F. O'Brien, Jr.
                      -Jean Westwood

                                     (rev. Feb-24)

                           -Attack George S. McGovern
            -Campaign role for Robert J. Dole
                   -Republican Party workers
                   -H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman’s opinion
                   -The President’s opinion
                   -Attack George S. McGovern campaign
                           -Lawrence F. O'Brien, Jr.
                           -George S. McGovern
                           -L. Sargent Shriver
                   -Charles W. Colson
                   -Understanding of Edward M. (“Ted”) Kennedy
                           -John B. Connally
                           -Charles W. Colson’s observation
                                  -Robert J. Dole appearance on Today
                           -Clark Macgregor
            -Herbert G. Klein and John D. Ehrlichman
                   -Attacks on George S. McGovern [?]
            -Democratic Party allegations

*****************************************************************

        Watergate
          -New report of bugging at Democratic Headquarters
               -FBI inquiry
          -Maurice H. Stans's libel lawsuit
               -Demeanor
                  -Effectiveness

        Foreign policy
           -Possible US-Soviet Union summit
           -Press coverage
           -Trade deal with Soviet Union
               -Butz
           -European Security Conference
           -SALT II announcement
               -Haldeman's view
               -SALT I
               -Timing

                                        (rev. Feb-24)

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 11/14/2022.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[778-005-w006]
[Duration: 3m 23s]

       The President's October schedule
              -Henry A. Kissinger's return to Washington, DC
              -The President’s opinion
              -October 10-15, 1972

       1972 election
              -Indiana visit
                     -Ohio
              -Radio speeches
              -Motorcades for cities
                     -Atlanta
                             -Press conference
                     -Boston
                     -New York
                             -Taped speeches/radio
                                     -Timing
                             -John D. Ehrlichman
                             -Elderly citizens home
                                     -Radio
                                     -Visiting compared to speech
                                     -Younger constituency

*****************************************************************

Haldeman left at 9:58 am.

This transcript was generated automatically by AI and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Do not cite this transcript as authoritative. Consult the Finding Aid above for verified information.

There's a problem there, apparently.
I'm not sure what it is.
That's one of the things we're talking about.
Earthman is assembling the people who are knowledgeable about it to get the facts, because apparently this is sort of out of the law to have a good direction, and we don't have one.
And that's the fact of the law, I guess.
Colson seems to have them, but they, you know, they sort of come out bit by bit.
And I don't think he knows, but apparently the whole story.
There is a problem here, that something was done wrong, apparently.
Something by someone.
But not by Colson, to you, as I understand it, is that Butts doesn't even know.
Or didn't.
Well, of course not.
I know.
And what happens is that sometimes these people, the department's called.
And apparently it was not something that was,
I think everybody thought that it wasn't
He was wondering, ask you how you get that thing over to Rogers.
Yes, sir.
I think he's very comfortable.
He's got a call from the Europeans.
They've done that, and we coordinated on the instructions.
They had a couple of mid-picks that they wanted to improve, which we accepted, and he's, I think, very comfortable.
How does it work now?
We don't announce matters.
No, what will happen here is the Europeans now have the note that the Soviets gave us, which they've gotten through state channels.
And that calls for a schedule of meetings.
But we may very clearly not have an answer until we consult together and decide on what the scope is.
Well, the system will come back.
I don't think so, sir.
I've been watching it.
We don't have one.
We told them that, but we didn't.
We didn't want it done stupidly, and where the guy made a hell of a mistake was that he falsified reports, and this wasn't necessary.
He did it in a very deliberate way, in which he involved a number of people in this falsification.
Yes, tonight.
It would be interesting to see how this meeting goes.
We'll really set the stage if there's going to be any progress at all, I believe.
Did he see him?
Yes, he did.
He's had him for a minute.
He's waving around.
Did he see Brown?
I don't know.
I don't see him.
I don't know.
And the state representative is with him in all the meetings, and I've reported back the substance of the conversation, which we're not really shaking at all.
He had three people with him.
Well, I think that... And there wasn't anything of the kind of substance to be done that would have been particularly sensitive.
Well, I don't find it the Secretary's upset, especially about this trip he was originally, mostly because I think he felt he was snookered on in scope.
Oh, to a degree he was, yeah.
But it didn't make any difference.
I guess you're right.
I guess you're right.
It looks like they're close to taking Quantree this morning.
They've got two Marine battalions in there, right, taking half the city and bugging half, although they're sort of trapped against the river in the west.
They're fighting like hell.
Both sides.
But the casualties have been very one-sided
The attack, our Marines have only lost eight, and the enemy's been, I think they've got over 120 killed in just a day's action in this assault.
Well, I still think we'll see it.
I'd say within ten days to two weeks, but I don't think it's going to be a big one.
I think it's going to be a big one.
You don't think they have it?
I don't think they have it.
We've got increasing evidence today of shortages of food, sickness among the troops all up in the MR1 area at Western Way.
Shortages of ammunition.
It's funny, Cal, that we don't get these reports because the press looks for all the other stuff.
Well, the point I'm trying to make, Al, is that we all know that we might be bombing
You know, I thought it was huge, you see, this great, great deal of the Soviet money.
I don't think so, but I think we'll have trouble getting MFN through for a bit.
They can block that.
Okay, thanks.
I'll be...
But Henry had sent all of them, you know, where you let me know about when and all.
And Saul was very good.
Yes, I thought it was great.
He ate the two or whatever it was.
Great.
All right.
See you at the right of the day, Henry.
That's right.
If this had happened two years ago, it would have been a blip.
All the way together.
And it has to be humanized somehow.
You've got to get a guy who made something out of it.
I hope nobody in the government did
We were thinking that bugging business.
Now that new... Well, you know, the Democrats found that bug in the telephone yesterday.
They put out the story.
One of the equipment that was sold.
last night anyway, I haven't heard this morning, but the phone that it was in was one of the phones that the FBI thoroughly checked when they did their survey of the premises.
They walked in, so they know the bug was not, it was an obvious bug.
It was not any problem detecting an obvious device.
And so they are certain that it was not in the phone at the time.
working on that last night and i guess they're doing some checking they think the bureau thinks that did somebody get rid of it one of them may be bugging each other well they may be bugging each other or they may have it's an old unsophisticated buggy device and it may be that someone you know just so they can make the story out of it they went and bought a buggy device put it in the phone and called in the cops and said look what i found
And they could ask everybody over there.
Also, there was that big story that Jean Westwood discovered the Louis Hart box and everything.
She turned the box over to Bennett Williams and that's disappeared.
The FBI now have a basis for getting that.
They wouldn't turn it over to the FBI.
They're now going to insist on it.
I think it does.
I'm all for it.
And when I saw it, I frankly was delighted with it.
God.
Actually, he alluded to it yesterday.
He said it's not funny about the fact that they come up with it and put it on the telephone and behave like that.
It raises suspicions that way.
I'm bouncing it.
I had this in mid-day today.
It's a good thing, still.
My dad mentioned me yesterday, and he apparently did a very good job of answering and wrapping things up.
I think we may have some knowledge there that the
and saying that he's, it's a personal suit to defend his own reputation, but that it could also be considered a class action suit defending all the people that are being maligned by this.
But he's, he's a pretty, this is a good kind of role for Stanton.
So effectively, that's it.
And he looks, you know, when Stanton comes out,
He just looks on us.
That's been a disadvantage in some of these hearings and stuff, because the guy isn't able to dissent at all.
But it's a plus when you go on to the attack on the offensive.
I think...
I think it'll be good somehow to go to this.
I think very much so.
And the fact that you're announcing things that have to go on all in the future is good.
So the work isn't done.
The timing worked out fine.
I'm glad they got the salt.
I think it's good to have salt done before you come back with salt, too.