Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 872 › Conversation 872-018

Nixon, Haldeman & Ziegler on POWs and Evening at the White House

Thursday, March 8, 1973 · 2:20 PM–2:50 PM ET · Oval Office · 43 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob"); Bull, Stephen B.; Ziegler, Ronald L.Conversation872-018 on Tape 872StartThursday, March 8, 1973 at 2:20 PMEndThursday, March 8, 1973 at 2:50 PMRecording deviceOval OfficeSourceNixon Library record for 872-018 ↗ · National Archives Catalog, NAID 417182895 ↗

President Nixon met with H.R. Haldeman, Stephen Bull, and Ronald Ziegler to discuss scheduling, including upcoming meetings with Henry Kissinger, John Ehrlichman, John Irwin, and White House Fellows, as well as a CEA breakfast and the President's speech on crime and drugs. They also discussed arrangements for an "Evening at the White House" event, including potential guests and toasts, and the upcoming visit of Lee Kuan Yew. A significant portion of the conversation focused on the logistics and potential impact of meetings with recently released POWs, Captain Jeremiah Denton, Jr. and Colonel Robinson Risner, including scheduling separate meetings with the President. The discussion also touched upon John Connally's potential party switch and the Watergate investigation, specifically the release of FBI raw files and the ACLU's reaction.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 13.6 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 3.1 MB

On March 8, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, Stephen B. Bull, and Ronald L. Ziegler met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 2:20 pm and 2:50 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 872-018 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 872-18
                                               -26-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

Date: March 8, 1973
Time: Unknown between 2:20 pm and 2:50 pm
Location: Oval Office

The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.

       President's schedule
             -Week’s events
             -Henry A. Kissinger
             -Rescheduling
                    -Afternoon meeting
                    -John D. Ehrlichman
                    -President’s speech on crime, drugs
             -Meetings
                    -John N. (“Jack”) Irwin, II
                    -White House fellows
                    -Janet Johnson
             -Breakfast
                    -Council of Economic Advisors [CEA]
                          -Timing

Stephen B. Bull entered at an unknown time after 2:20 pm.

             -Appointment with dentist
             -CEA breakfast
                  -Timing     -Program
                  -Thelma C. (“Pat”) Nixon
                        -Birthday
             -Newbold (“Newby”) Noyes, Jr.
                  -Meeting with President

Bull left at an unknown time before 2:46 pm.

       Leslie T. (“Bob”) Hope
             -Meeting with President
             -Performance last night
                   -Material
                   -Spiro T. Agnew
Show the rest of the log (274 more lines)
                   -John B. Connally
                                     -27-

           NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

Evening at the White House
     -Toasts to President
            -Protocol
                  -Arthur M. Wood
            -Maurice H. Stans
            -Necessity
                  -Haldeman's view
     -Hope
            -Toasts to President
     -Speakers after President
     -Toasts to President
            -Timing
                  -Singing
            -Protocol, Format
            -Value to guests
            -Publicity for country
                  -Television [TV]
            -Stag dinner

Lee Kuan Yew
     -Visit
            -Wife
            -Henry A. Kissinger
     -Stag dinner
            -Spouses
            -Women
                  -Anne L. Armstrong, Jewel S. La Fontaine
                  -Press
                        -Fay Wells
                             -Administration supporter
                             -Invitation

Charles W. Colson
     -Return to work
     -Location
     -Travel
     -Meeting with Haldeman's

Prisoners of war [POWs]
                                     -28-

           NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

     -Capt. Jeremiah A. Denton, Jr. and Col. Robinson Risner
           -Talk with Haldeman
     -Evening at the White House
           -Denton and Risner's opinion of timing
     -Previous visits
           -Congress member
                 -Tour of White House
     -Denton and Risner
           -Talk with President
                 -Value to President
                 -President's desire for meeting
           -Availability
           -Scheduling
                 -Camp David
                 -Families
                       -Son's graduation
           -Separate meetings
     -Meeting with unnamed officer and enlisted man
     -Denton and Risner
           -Separate meetings with President
           -Camp David
           -Residences
                 -Oklahoma, Portsmith
           -Desire to meet with President
           -Scheduling

President's schedule
      -Press conference
      -Meetings
             -Management Improvement Awards as type of event
                  -Stans
                  -Avoidance

Evening at the White House
     -Francis A. (“Frank”) Sinatra evening
     -Paul W. Keyes
            -Consultant role
            -Invitations
            -Arrangements
                  -Lucy A. Winchester [?]
                                           -29-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

      President's schedule
            -Meeting with Denton and Risner
                   -Length
            -Press relations
            -Denton and Risner

      POWs
         -Denton and Risner
               -Reaction to Evening at the White House
         -Wives
               -Invitation
         -Children
         -Publicity
               -Announcement
         -Invitations to speak, honors
               -William F. (“Billy”) Graham
               -Risner
                      -Schools
               -Denton
                      -Middlesex Club of Boston
                            -Award to President
                                   -Charles W. Colson
         -Meeting with President
               -Denton and Risner
               -James B. Stockdale
                      -Leader of POWs
                            -[First name unknown] Kassler [?]
               -Denton and Risner
                      -Separate meetings
                            -Value
         -Evening at the White House
               -Letter's effectiveness in remarks by President
                      -Congress
         -Support for President [?]

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift during
                                            -30-

                  NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

chronological review 2007-2013]

      John B. Connally
           -Conversation with Haldeman
           -Party switch
                 -Decision
                       -Problem of timing
                 -Arrangements
                       -George Christian

*****************************************************************

      John B. Connally
           -Work with Jeb Stewart Magruder
                 -Commerce Department
                 -Watergate hearings
                       -Impact on Connally
                 -Timing
           -Work with Colson
                 -Private basis

*****************************************************************

[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift during
chronological review 2007-2013]

      Connally
           -Visit to Jamaica
                 -Charles G. (“Bebe”) Rebozo
           -POWs
                 -May 8, 1972 decision
                 -William P. Rogers
                 -Evening at the White House
                 -Letter
           -Party switch
                 -Conversations with Haldeman
                 -Press conference
                        -Timing
                                           -31-

                 NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

                      -Place
                            -Texas
                            -Washington, DC
                                  -Advantages
                      -Questions
                            -Coordination with Christian
                 -Other Democrats
                      -Opposition to George S. McGovern
                      -Strength of sentiment
                            -Support for President
                            Jobs

*****************************************************************

      Leonard H. Marks
           -Call from William J. Casey
           -Increase in number of State Department labor and business attaches
                 -Lyndon B. Johnson
           -Abilities
           -Presidential Library
                 -Johnson

     Richard M. Nixon Presidential Library
          -Preparation
          -Costs
                -Congress
          -Land in California
                -Value
          -Possible opposition
          -Commission
                -Edward F. Hebert
                      -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] clearances

     Evening at the White House
          -Tony Martin, Cyd Charisse
                 -Abilities
          -State Dinner
                 -Invitations
                       -Liza Minelli
                                               -32-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

Ronald L. Ziegler entered at 2:46 pm.

       Hope
              -Jokes

       Watergate
            -Donald H. Segretti
                  -Dwight L. Chapin
                  -Questions from press
                  -Links with White House
                        -Ziegler's answer
            -Raw files from FBI
                  -Release
                        -American Civil Liberties Union [ACLU] protests
                        -Ziegler's response
                  -FBI files
                        -Value
                        -Hearsay
                              -J. Edgar Hoover
                                     -[First name unknown] Brandon [?]
                  -ACLU position
            -Ervin Committee
                  -Samuel J. Ervin, Jr.
                  -Howard H. Baker, Jr.

       President's meeting with Newbold (“Newby”) Noyes, Jr.
             -President’s speech
                   -President's attendance

       President's schedule
             -Meeting with National Press Club
                    -President’s press conference [?]
                    -Value
                    -Publicity
             -President's meeting with Noyes
             -Camp David

Ziegler and Haldeman left at 2:50 pm.
                                            -33-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                            Conversation No. 872-23 (cont’d)

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 2 parts and the right one starts.

NixonOh, we got plenty of time.
HaldemanThe more we talk about it, the worse it seems to get, you know?
NixonYeah, but it's we've got to walk through it, though. Oh, yes, sure. It's we've got to get in it. Yeah, okay. All right. I don't know what I'd come on.
HaldemanWe're going to drop the 4:00.
NixonYeah, well, it's 3:00. He said he would, his shop, Mark McCormack, he said he would much prefer you spend the time on the speech, and uh, he didn't have anything pressing.
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanNow we got a hell of a mess this past couple of We're we're past the Why didn't Johnson write us all those fast herbs? Well, Janet Johnson you have to do some point, but you do her and get her done, then
NixonWhy have breakfast tomorrow morning?
HaldemanSure.
NixonWant to see the [unintelligible] Oh, that's next week. That's next week. Well, good. I'm glad to hear that.
HaldemanWait, wait, we don't have that next week, either. Oh, yes, we do. Oh, I thought it was next week. I told Steve. No, the sixteenth. Hell, I told Steve the sixteenth, it's not the breakfast at 8:30.
HaldemanOh, see it's not on here, though. It is, that's what we had it, the sixteenth.
NixonSteve, uh, was wrong. That dentist can't be at 9:00. It should be 9:30 or 9:45, but the CEA breakfast, that's what I'm confirming, is the following day, right?
BullYes, sir, it's the week from today, after they're when they're probably done. So I was sure it was 8:00. For that CEA breakfast, it's 2 hours.
BullFirst 19th meeting for White House Fellows, and Janet Johnson.
NixonYes. Yeah.
BullIt's Pat's birthday.
NixonAnd, uh, tell Newby Noyes that [unintelligible]
BullAll head. See if they'll [unintelligible]
HaldemanHe did a good job last night. I I was fascinated to see how he would, you know, just what you said, whether he could whether he could do that. I saw you send John over to tell him at the end of the singing, you know, you were going to call on him, and and uh I wondered if he could do it. You always do, but uh he obviously dredged up some some some of his routine material on like flying and stuff like that while he was thinking, but then he had some pretty good, fresh stuff about, you know, his Agnew and Connally.
NixonYeah, that had to be. That kind of fell out. Well, I told him, when I saw he was there, [crosstalk] I said, "Don't say anything yet until after the singing. You'll enjoy the singing, and then you'll have to get on it." The thing that, yeah,
NixonYeah, well, yeah, but, first, he likes to do that, second, they all liked it, and they just uh, they got a Well, and it's good to let someone else talk, because all those people want to say what how they feel about you, and what a great job you're doing, and stuff like that, and yet none of Like, I was sitting next to Art Wood, and uh
HaldemanSears Roebuck. Yeah, and he said, "What-" He said, "What's the protocol of something like this? Is Is Is any of the guests allowed to to, uh, make a toast to the President, because there should be one?" I said, "Well, protocol, I guess, is that the President speaks first, and then if there were a group here, the leader of the group would respond, but in an informal group like this, there's no leader."
HaldemanAnd, um Well, actually, if they wanted to have a toast, of course, they could have. I thought about it, but they're not going to get up and throw that kind of I don't think it's necessary anyway to have a toast. I'm not so sure. I I think we always- I think, in sitting through that last night as a guest, and there was one handshake that way, I think it leaves a void in their minds, because
Nixon[unintelligible] they don't just they don't expect to come in just to hear you explain what you're doing. They There was a very strong thing, and they did it by standing and applauding. Yeah. But, there was a strong feeling there of wanting to say "Thank you." Now, Hope did it, but he didn't really do it as well as Because, he had to do it in Hope's style, and he had to mix it up with the the the jokes. Yeah.
HaldemanSure, but The problem with the hand reception, you've always heard that, "Well, you never know if they're by any chance going to gas on too long." You never want to have that frankly, you never want to have that. After after I finish, that should be it, because it's always an anti-climax when people get up and gas on and on and on, about and uh so-forth, and,
HaldemanWell, the time to do it is before is after the singing, and before you get up. It's not protocol, I'm sure. Why, but I don't know why a guest can't rise and say, "Mr. President, if I may presume,
NixonI'd like to speak for all of us." And then then say for about, you know, "our great pride in what you've done, and and our satisfaction in having been a part of helping this administration, and all that, and, gentlemen, I'd like you to join me in a toast to the President of the United States." Oh, well, it doesn't make that much difference. No, it doesn't. They have They have such a big time when they come in there. They really do, and a great You know what I mean, they all feel that it was all worthwhile. The stag's for you.
HaldemanIt's for It's all that, say, it Well, your I think the poem they all liked. That's just great. I think it sort of moved them. Well, I had that the night before. Yeah. [unintelligible] It gets them that moral that everybody wants to hear about, the spiritual thing, right, which they deeply feel and don't know what the hell to do about, without my having to preach about it.
HaldemanWell, and they all, afterwards, you know, guys made a point coming up to me to say, "How can we get that on television? People in the country ought to hear that." Yeah. Well, "Shame to waste that on us." It's all right, but they're "President at his very best," and all that. But, it was a good thing. Stag dinners are a good thing. I was thinking that the Lee Kuan Yew, if his wife is not coming, that whole If
Nixonwe're going to have We don't know. Henry doesn't know. Well, if she doesn't, we can just as well invite her, because if she does, I'll go with her, too, but if she doesn't, I think you're bothering up having some women there. It's too But not wives, not wives, we would not have Spouses. No spouses, right. I'd have Ann Armstrong, for example, but not not
NixonWe have a few, uh, people like that, like the black woman who's over in Jewell LaFontant, and just a few women, and, therefore, it's that will real stick it, and, uh, maybe out of the press assholes you could pick one of the, one of the women that's on our side. Faye Wells? That's right.
HaldemanWonder if she'll, they don't usually pay out. She would be glad to do that. Just get somebody who'd be straight on, straight flat out on our side, and throw them outside the city anyway. Just say these are all guests who're from outside some people. Faye Wells, probably, wouldn't mind being, and no, it's being, in front of ours. That's the whole thing. These people are so goddamned sensitive about,
Nixon"Well, we don't want to go if it's going to reflect negatively if you're screw, and they don't want to do that, too." I want that list carefully closed down. And so, that was it. Colson's back? Is he back? When did he get back?
HaldemanJust He came in He may be back today, or he's He may have come back last night. He's He's either coming in or had is in. He called to say he was going to be over at the office this afternoon. Uh-huh. You should have a little talk with him before I see him. Yeah.
NixonAll right, well then I'll call then, tomorrow, while he's here back at the inn. Also get him launched on some of the things he needs to be. I talked to both Captain Denton and Colonel
Haldemanright. And they're both rush at this stuff. Just in talking to him on the phone, Denton is a much more articulate guy, seemed to be, than Risner.
HaldemanBoth of them said that the idea of waiting till June was exactly right, said you shouldn't push it, but get the word out immediately. And the earlier they said the word out, they were both very disturbed. I mentioned the fact that that uh
Haldemantwo POWs had already been here and that you had had a chance to see them. And uh
HaldemanThey said that's They said, "Who was it?" Immediately. And I said I didn't know, that it was a couple of fellows that their congressmen have brought them in. And he said Denton, no, Risner
Haldemansaid, "Did they pull that on the President? Did they maneuver that to get in there?" And I said, "No, not at all, that their congressman called and didn't ask to see the President. He called our visitors office and asked if they if he could bring them on a White House tour.
HaldemanAnd we, of course, said, 'Yeah.' And an officer over there said, 'Charles Knox was over.'"
NixonOh, yeah.
HaldemanI did tell both of them that you would like to talk with them, and they both very much want to talk with you. Feel that would be very useful to you and to them, uh and that it would be a very good idea. And they're both
NixonThat's okay.
HaldemanYeah. As long as it's off the record, and as long as it doesn't get into a thing, you know, where you're not doing it where you're not being trapped of it. Said you had neither of them asked for it, but I said you had asked, and they said, "Well, if the President wants it,"
NixonYeah.
Haldemanthat uh but and I said you had felt that it would be helpful to you just to have a chance to talk to to them and to one of them and get a a general feel, what what you ought to know that you can't get from the official reports.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanPersonal basis.
NixonGood.
NixonI want to do it, and I don't want just to get them for more.
NixonI want [unintelligible]
HaldemanWell, I think you should. And and that's what they and if I they're both available on call, would very much want to come. Probably better not to have them on a weekend because of their kids being home from school. The one thing they both, it's obvious, they're just, you know, spending every sec, like one of them said, "I would hope I wouldn't have to come on March 28th because that's the day my son graduates from college and I've missed so many graduations and I hate to miss that one." He said, "Of course, I will if if that's
Haldemanthe day." And I said, "Good lord, if you have anything"
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonWhy can't we even speak to that effect?
HaldemanThey think it's just suit- Yeah.
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonFinally, the the other day when you had this group, one of them said that, "Who's this guy?"
HaldemanOne officer?
NixonWell, there was one enlisted man that was.
NixonI forget, yeah, that was Giles, but anyway,
HaldemanBut then there's this one officer that's out today, and uh and that's kind of so completely overridden by the others.
NixonI wondered
Nixon[unintelligible]
NixonHow about 20 on Saturday morning? That would be wholly [unintelligible]
HaldemanProbably not.
HaldemanI I'll tell you they're so anxious, they they would be They're just They, you know, they especially Denton. He is uh so I mean, he said, "I I just can't tell you the the feeling I have for for the President."
Nixon[unintelligible] this office.
NixonThat's right. Well, I've seen one [unintelligible]
HaldemanYou're in pretty fair shape next week if you do.
NixonTomorrow, I think Well, I'm thinking of the press thing though, we've got to get that [unintelligible]
HaldemanI think we can do that Thursday.
NixonWell, we got to clear it so we can.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonOne of the things our staff did, we can clear out on Saturday afternoon. Well, I'm counting on you to keep me out of management. They'll have three or four flags standing in my shade so, that you're doing all of those [unintelligible] you know, perhaps little [unintelligible]
HaldemanI think that's that's beyond pale. That'd be crazy.
HaldemanPaul Keyes, in his new consultative role, I have asked to come to the Evening at the White House and to the Sinatra [crosstalk] evening so he can see how these things He's never been to an Evening at the White House and
NixonSure.
NixonWell, on Bryan, the Lucille Ball thing? And Bryan.
HaldemanOkay. They're They're pretty well set on uh on those two, I think, but we'll see.
Nixon[unintelligible] We could have one come Monday morning, and one Monday afternoon if you want.
NixonAll right, you arrange it.
HaldemanUnless there's something else you want to do more. But if we have the press thing then you would have them already then Tuesday night, fair enough.
NixonI think that's good.
NixonCan Wednesday be cleared? How about that?
HaldemanIf you do it in the morning, then Thursday.
NixonYeah, do it.
Nixon11:00 [unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd get Denton and Risner in on Monday.
NixonVery fine. God, I hate to park it myself.
NixonBut they're uh they're really up and eager to go.
HaldemanOh, just tremendous enthusiasm.
NixonThey all agree that June 15th is a good date, and you told them and they agreed why.
HaldemanThey thought that would be marvelous for the boys. I didn't raise the question of kids. Why? Because we didn't want to do that. And why would we start getting the word out? Denton felt very strongly it should not be before the 14th, that that was an ideal time.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanRisner said, "Maybe maybe it could be a little earlier." But then he said, "No, it's it's better to do it better to hold it off if you get it announced." And he said, "I'm concerned that we start getting into piecemeal type stuff." And he said, "I don't want to get Billy Graham wants us down there, you know, and all the rest of it.
NixonThat's right. I don't want them used. Everybody wants them for their conventions, everybody wants them to trot them out for this and that. And that's going to kill the whole thing.
HaldemanWell, they're starting to do that, and then you can't stop them, either. Basically, they have the right to do it. They're Everybody will want to honor them, but finally, it's going to get
HaldemanLike Risner said, though, he said, "I've got, of course, a lot of requests to do things." And he said, "The only thing I'm doing, I have a very strong feeling towards children, and I'm doing some schools. Going to speak at some schools."
NixonWhich I want to do. No problem.
HaldemanAnd he said, "I'm not going to do anything else."
HaldemanNow uh, Denton
Nixon[unintelligible]
Haldemanuh of uh Boston.
NixonYeah.
Haldemanhas gotten ahold of him, and said that they're presenting you
Haldemanwith their super peacemaker award or something,
Haldemanand they want him
Haldemanto come up and make the presentation. And said you aren't going to be able to be there, but they're hopeful that some member of your family, or
Haldemanranking member of the administration would be there. And they said that Chuck Colson, senior member of your staff, will be there.
Nixon[laughter]
HaldemanSo, they're having that.
NixonHe must be, you know, proud of the honor. Talking that much, he thinks it's a hell of an honor, he thinks the White House should be used for it.
HaldemanWell, that's one of them, yeah.
HaldemanNow let's do these on that because there- it's those two-
NixonThen, he'd had one at 3:00 and one at 4:30. Basically,
Nixonokay? We can catch them a little further, closer together, so-
HaldemanThose two, go ahead.
HaldemanThose two plus Stockdale.
NixonUh, how about Alvarez?
HaldemanWell, apparently he's not one of the leaders or something, there's it's these two plus Stockdale. Stockdale was the senior Navy man. And Risner, I guess, was the
Nixonsenior Air Force man, huh?
HaldemanYeah. And for some reason Denton served as the-
NixonRight.
Haldemansenior Navy man, or something.
HaldemanAnd they're they're wanting a meeting to go over some of these things, the three of them,
Haldemanat some point. And, it'd be good for you to talk with them first.
NixonYou call them back.
NixonYeah, if you call them back you might ask [unintelligible] I'd like to see each separately. You might tell each of them I'll see the other, but I want to see that person. Right?
HaldemanI told Risner because I didn't want him to talk to Denton and find out I'd already talked to-
NixonI want to see these two only, and I want to go and, uh, I'll see them there after I see each separately and I want to talk separately. We shouldn't talk as a group. I just want that. Stockdale? No, wait a minute. Okay. Plus Stockdale.
HaldemanOkay, plus Stockdale.
NixonStockdale. Oh, well, all right. You might see Denton and Risner together.
NixonNo, they're both here. I mean, they'd both-
HaldemanI'd see I'd see them separate now.
NixonI'd like to see them separate too. You'll get more out of a person [unintelligible]
HaldemanYou'll get much more of them.
HaldemanAnd, they each of them is going to
Haldemanbe much more free without the other guy there.
NixonYou know it's an interesting thing. The, uh,
NixonIt's really, uh, that that, uh,
NixonDid you notice I kept that out of that letter?
HaldemanYeah.
NixonIt's very good point.
HaldemanYou left out the Congress thing, didn't you?
NixonYeah. Well, another thing is, too,
NixonYeah, and I didn't want him to get in trouble frankly. With you reading it it's [unintelligible] Why did he say it frankly?
HaldemanThat's why he said it himself probably. But, nevertheless.
NixonI left out the Superman.
HaldemanYeah, well, that seemed [unintelligible] He's terribly brave, and
NixonAnd, you didn't need the Superman anyway. He said he's terribly brave. He said he was, and then he said he was brave when it came to, when it comes to war and that, anyway.
NixonThat whole letter had a powerful impact on people on the, particularly in the, on the air in that kind of remarks, you know, people would go hurrah [laughter] in front of me.
NixonIn fact, they would hear it and remember, remember that far more than eating in the White House. Far more than a dinner probably.
HaldemanYep.
HaldemanAnd, because it's personal. They felt it was personal. They felt they had an insight into what you were really trying to do, and what you thought.
HaldemanI had a long talk with Connally, and he is,
NixonUh-huh.
Haldemanhe's all set to switch. He's-
NixonHe is?
HaldemanYeah, and he says, "I made a mistake. I should have done it two weeks ago, but I got all screwed up on some other things, and I just didn't get everything in place, and so I didn't make the move." He said, "Am I too late now?"
HaldemanI said, "You're not too late, but you're getting down to the point where, you know, it's getting to be a problem."
NixonIf you wait too long,
HaldemanAnd, uh, he said, "I've got it set up that George Christian's going to come with me." And, and, uh, and I- and-
NixonGood. Uh, how about others?
HaldemanAnd I said, "Well, I know you've been," I said, "I know you're talking to Jeb," and and, uh, he looked a little surprised.
Nixon[laughter]
HaldemanAnd I said, that would Jeb could be very helpful to you. Uh, let me suggest that we got him over in the Commerce Department swapped out and you shouldn't openly get him involved with you until after all these hearings get done.
HaldemanI said, "Don't let any of this crap scrape off on you," that, uh-
NixonRight. I thought of that later, that I don't want him to go there because I would want Connally to have him go.
HaldemanRight.
HaldemanAnd, uh, that's what I said. Just do- I said, "Just we've got Jeb taken care of. He's in Commerce, and he can make any commitment he wants to you down the road. But, for now, uh, just steer clear.
HaldemanI also said, I also said, "Steer clear of Colson, too."
NixonYes.
HaldemanBecause, uh, you just-
NixonThe candidate Colson can work for. In private practice, he don't have to publicly work for him.
HaldemanThat's what I said. That's it.
NixonHe should, but he's shady, you see.
HaldemanConnally Connally, uh,
Haldemanis planning to make it today.
NixonOh, no kidding.
HaldemanUh, he called tonight. Well, they went to their house. They had take- Bebe there, and, uh, and I know John's [unintelligible] Connally came in and so forth. And course like somebody had [unintelligible] They looked over it. Boy, he was really cheering that,
NixonWas he?
HaldemanYes. He was very He thought that
Haldemanthe letter He thought the whole talk last night, but the letter in particular, he was he thought that was just superb.
HaldemanAnd he, I finally I'd It It had just sort of been together so I said, "John, I just, you know, of all the talk about you and everything, I purposely never raised the question,
Haldemanand I don't want you to think by silence that that in any way I have any different view than what you know my view is."
NixonRight.
HaldemanAnd, uh, he said, "Oh, I know that." And, said, "I realize, you know, it is better if we don't talk about that. We can both say we haven't." And, he said,
HaldemanThen, he immediately started into it.
NixonHow's he going to do it, you say?
HaldemanHe said he's been debating on that. He said, "I've decided the way to do it is just call a press conference."
NixonWhere?
HaldemanHe said, "What I'll do is I'll call it for about two or three days ahead.
NixonAll right.
HaldemanHe said, "Let them stew." He said, "You know, ah damn this press corps ever to turn out." Anyway, in Texas it could be a problem.
HaldemanHe may come up here, be smarter to go up there, or he could come up here and [unintelligible] I think that's what he'll end up doing.
NixonHe ought to call a press conference right up here in the whole White House press room.
HaldemanUrge him to do that. Fine. And uh and I said, "I think you must do it because,
NixonHe's got that free, nice press here.
NixonMore uh more controversy about it too.
HaldemanYeah. And, he said He said, "I've I've wondered about that because of all of these questions and everything." He said, "But I've thought it all through, and I don't And, I talked to George and, uh, I think I can handle the questions." And, I said, "Jesus,
Haldemanyou will have no problem at all in handlin' questions."
NixonYou know it was significant that last night because he was there and had all the Democrats, including three at my table, including Ford, so 15 or 20 so that means they feel better [unintelligible] about their being a guest for dinner.
NixonAlthough, a lot of those were guests for us to, now, in major part. There's no question. Our Democrats.
Haldeman[unintelligible]
NixonIt's unfortunate. [unintelligible]
HaldemanHe's probably not.
HaldemanI I'll tell you they're so anxious. They they-
Haldemanthey'd be they're just staring, you know, they're especially Denton, is uh so
HaldemanThey said, "I I just can't tell you the the feeling I have for for the President.
NixonWhat are they going to do about the ones that came to this office? [unintelligible]
HaldemanThat's right.
NixonWell, let's see one [unintelligible] try to see them both.
HaldemanYeah.
HaldemanYou're pretty pressed for shape next week if you do it.
NixonMore I think, well, I'm thinking of the press thing, though. We got to get that [unintelligible]
HaldemanI would, I'm thinking of doing it Thursday.
NixonWell, we've got to clear it so we can.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonOne thing that should be done. When I talked with the CEA about management, and we've got more, if Stein, Maurice Stans, so far as he's concerned, you know, [unintelligible] He or, you know, would perhaps [unintelligible]
Haldeman[unintelligible]
Nixonto do. I want, that's all. I think that's that would be honored [unintelligible] wouldn't you agree?
HaldemanYep.
HaldemanPaul Keyes, in his usual consultative role, I asked to come to the evening at the White House and to the Sinatra Sure. evening so he can see how these things He's never been to an evening at the White House and and while Bob Hope and Lucy, and that's not Hope. Okay, they're they're pretty well set on those two I think, but we'll see.
NixonHope was telling that thing that if they come Tuesday morning here and Friday there is that they have an hour each one. I think they should feel [unintelligible]
HaldemanThey had one come Monday morning and one Monday afternoon. Do you want Not Tuesday morning.
NixonNo. Unless there's something else Tuesday morning. But it's planned the press thing that
HaldemanWell,
Nixonyou would to have, they've already agreed, Tuesday night, right?
HaldemanRight.
NixonI think that's good.
NixonKeep Wednesday clear.
NixonHow about that?
HaldemanYeah.
HaldemanYou could do that morning then? Tuesday?
NixonYeah. Tuesday morning.
NixonOne at 11:00 and then the other at 12:00.
HaldemanAnd get Denton and Risner in on Monday.
NixonAll right, Bob. You saw
NixonThe paper had it really up here, didn't they?
HaldemanOh, it just total cap.
HaldemanThey all, Jim and the jeans because he you told them how and why.
HaldemanThey thought that would be marvelous for the wives. I didn't raise the question of kids. Why do it?
NixonNo, you couldn't. Couldn't do it.
HaldemanAnd when should we start getting the word out? Denton felt very strongly that it should not be before the 14th, that that was an ideal time.
NixonMm-hmm.
HaldemanRisner said, "Maybe maybe it could be a little earlier." Then he said, "No, it's it's better to do it, better to hold it off if you get it announced."
HaldemanBut he said, "I'm concerned that we start getting piecemeal type stuff." That's right.
NixonHe said, "I don't want to get Like Billy Graham wants some down there, you know, and all the rest. I don't want them used. Everybody wants them for their conventions, everybody wants them to
HaldemanYeah.
Nixontrot them out for this and that. That's going to kill the whole thing.
HaldemanWell, they're starting to do that, and you can't stop them, either, they feel.
NixonI know.
NixonBasically, they have the right to do it. They're Everybody wants to honor them and finds that it's going to be backfire.
HaldemanWell, like like Risner said though, he said, "I've got, of course, a lot of requests to do things." And he said, "The only thing I'm doing, I have a very
Haldemanstrong feeling towards children.
HaldemanAnd I'm doing some schools. Going to speak at some schools.
NixonWhich I want to do, no problem.
HaldemanAnd he said, "But I'm not going to do anything else."
HaldemanAnd, uh,
HaldemanDenton,
Haldemanthe Middlesex Club in Boston has gotten hold of him and said that they're presenting you
NixonYeah.
Haldemanwith their Super Peacemaker Award or something, and they want him
Haldemanto come up and make the presentation. They said you aren't going to be able to be there, but they're hopeful that some member of your family or ranking member of the administration will be there, and they said Chuck Colson, senior member of your staff, will be there.
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanSo, and, uh,
Nixon[unintelligible]
HaldemanAnd,
Nixonthey must be, you've got to somehow talk to them as to how they should be used.
HaldemanSo that's one of the, yeah. They'll have some views on that, because they're It's those two,
NixonMaybe one a tree, one one or three, maybe. Okay. Catch them a little further apart, closer together, so they can
HaldemanThose two, go ahead.
Haldemanthose two plus Stockdale.
NixonHow about Kasler? Kasler, too.
HaldemanWell, apparently he's not one of the leaders or something. It's It's these two plus Stockdale. Stockdale is the senior Navy man,
NixonYeah.
Haldemanand Risner I guess was the senior Air Force man.
NixonAll right.
HaldemanAnd, for some reason Denton served as the section, senior Navy man or something.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanThat they're they're planning a meeting to go over some of these things, the three of them, at some point. It might be better for you to talk to them first. You call back,
NixonOr if you call them back, you might ask, you know, "I'd like to see each separately. He might talk to each other and see the other, but I want to see that." You see?
HaldemanRight.
HaldemanI told Risner, because I didn't want him to talk to Denton, find out I'd already talked to him.
NixonI want to see these two only and I want to go and do we think that after I've seen each separately, and I want to talk separately, we should talk to this group?
HaldemanMm-hmm.
NixonWhy don't you ask them that? To get what their plan is,
HaldemanOkay.
Nixonbefore you get committed.
HaldemanThe three plus Stockdale?
NixonAll of them, how about Kasler? You might ask,
HaldemanYeah.
Nixonthey're both here. I think I'd see them separately.
HaldemanI like the separate ones. You get more out of a person. You'll get much more out and they, each of them, is going to
Haldemanbe much more free without the other guy there.
NixonYou know it was an interesting thing the, uh,
NixonI wonder if I kept all of that letter to read the wives.
HaldemanYeah, it was read.
NixonYou left out the Congress thing, didn't you?
HaldemanYeah.
NixonI thought I would've.
HaldemanI didn't like to raise It's too important to Yeah. I didn't want to get him into trouble frankly.
NixonWith you reading it, it's like, why didn't you get [unintelligible] in trouble? If he'd said it himself, I wouldn't have, but nevertheless,
HaldemanI left out the Superman.
NixonYeah, well, I can see that. That is terrible. And you didn't need the Superman anyway. I agree.
NixonHe shot great sentences and he writes, and he says he writes for himself, so it's a part of that. But anyway,
Nixonthat whole letter has a powerful impact on people, and particularly coming at the end of that kind of remark.
HaldemanYeah. What would people in the world, and so forth.
NixonHmm.
NixonIt's unique and they'll all remember they will remember that far more than eating in the White House. Far more than a dinner at the White House.
HaldemanYep.
HaldemanAnd, because it's personal. They felt it was personal. They felt they had an inside into what you were really trying to do and what you thought.
HaldemanI had a long talk with Connally,
NixonYeah.
Haldemanand he is he's all set to switch. He says, He is?
HaldemanYeah, and he says, "I made a mistake. I should've done it two weeks ago, but I got all screwed up on some other things, and I just didn't get everything in place, so I didn't make the move." But he said, "I'm not too late now."
HaldemanAnd I said, "You're not too late, but you're getting down to the point
NixonYeah.
Haldemanwhere, you know, the speculation is getting to be a problem."
HaldemanAnd, uh,
Haldemanhe said, "I've got it set up that George Christian's going to come with me." And and uh Good.
Haldeman"What about others?" And I said, "Well, you don't need many others." I said, "I know you're talking to Jeb." And and, uh, he looked a little surprised.
Haldeman[chuckles] Yeah.
HaldemanAnd I said that would Jeb could be very helpful to you. Uh, but let me suggest that we've got him over in Commerce Department slot now,
NixonYeah.
Haldemanand you shouldn't publicly get him involved with you until after all these hearings are done, because it's I said, "Don't let any of this crap scrape off on you,"
Haldemanthat uh, we've got will do.
NixonI told Brad later that I don't want him to go to the, because I would want Connally to have one to go Right.
HaldemanAnd, uh, that's why I said just don't I said just, we've got Jeb taken care of. He's in Commerce, and he can make any commitment he wants to you down the road. But for now, uh, just steer clear.
HaldemanAnd I also said I also said steer clear of Colson. Yes, sir.
HaldemanCuz you did, then he told me that Colson can work for him and try to make him Yeah.
NixonIt's fit and then there they are. You're so good. Those guys, they've come around. A lot of
HaldemanA lot of them are [crosstalk] eager to come. In fact, they came up to me and said, "Well, you know, at this point, I want to help. What can I do? I, you know, I
Haldemanwe've talked to some of them about taking jobs, and a couple of them came up to me and said, "You know, I I wish I could move up, I just can't do this." And I said, "Well, you've got to help us get some Democrats, because we we want some and you guys, I'm glad you understand that." A few of them.
NixonWould you get to tell Bill Casey that I want him to get Leonard Marks a call, and so forth, and getting more business and labor attachés in the State Department.
NixonBecause Marks was going to do that for Johnson. He had when he set it up, Johnson set it up for him. And he was very strong. I mean, he doesn't want to work. I'm talking about doing a regular job, Marks is getting on, right?
NixonMarks is a real operator. He's an able man. He's a damn able man.
HaldemanYeah. He talked to me about the library, and we've talked Yeah. about that. Yeah, and I I'm sorry that he [unintelligible] but I assumed that you're going to I told him to talk to you, but
Haldemanhis point is so right, it's the point I've been making that now we've got to get oh, yeah in charge, done before we before we
NixonThey started on the library what? 1 year after Johnson was in office. 1 when the poor guy didn't even get reelected yet. Yeah. And they started the library. Johnson was so passionate about building for himself. Now the point is, we ought to really get going. Would this be a good time to get,
NixonI guess the hearing committee's going to handle it, but what committee is going to handle it, to get those people out there, to go out there, a house,
Nixonwho was it, that's talking about? In other words, I can get the riders in California at this time, it's a damn good time, you know, put one of plain, and have them take a look at the ground.
NixonWe should move on that, don't you think? Or is it a bad time? My god, there's never a good time. They say, "Well, you got problems in Congress."
HaldemanScrew that, because all this crap about it doesn't cost any money. Doesn't, no. It doesn't cost anything. It doesn't cost,
NixonThat land is not being used. It will never be used. It'd be worth the land, that's right. Right? It's the only only thing you get on that is just meanness. If some somebody just decides to fight it just to be a son of a bitch, they can they can fight it.
HaldemanThe problem I have, but the some some commission that they're on, so we've got to get done for him, which we're doing, and we've gotten through that, but then there's supposed to be an FBI clearance for some.
NixonWhat about for an evening at the White House, uh, Tony Martin, Cyd Charisse, they'd love to come. Not an evening, but, uh, entertainment, please. She dances, you know. Right. She's a damn good dancer and he sings, and you know,
Nixonand speaks down to people.
HaldemanThat really is, to a uh state dinner audience, the older people, it would be a hell of a The thing about Tony Martin, too, he's been with us steadfastly. He's not He's not still that good, but for our he is damn good entertainment.
NixonYeah. He could even do an evening, I mean, we don't have to you don't have to be too concerned, you know, about they aren't that bad, but, uh,
Nixonsee, she'll, I wonder if, by now, that state dinner we've got to add people that get-Now they're one of our friends who wants to come. By God, he's come before we get Lena Horne’s husband, or whoever it may be. Yeah.
HaldemanYeah.
HaldemanAll right, that'd be good.
NixonYeah. Well, how'd you get on? Good. Is Bob Hope's after with this golf? Ugh, dryer. Still with jokes I wanted to write. That's a great guy.
ZieglerUm, just one quick thing for uh Look, uh, they're kicking the hell about Segretti today, the way they made that, how tight, and then to actually smoke my rap, this very 400. It's ridiculous. Here's a goddamned headline that, of course, they said this March darling, the White House has said did it all the way. It's the story, you infected him, was the one that hit Haldeman.
ZieglerRight. And I also achieved it, too. But see, we never denied that. So they were, we're on the tests that But it was great today.
Haldemanthe prose of the press corps said, you know, you're all solid beyond this and make it In other words, in terms of ever lying about we never lied about a thing. We just But it was great today, because I stood behind the ACLU.
NixonWhy? Did they come out? Well, the ACLU wrote a letter and raised hell about uh the FBI releasing the raw data.
ZieglerYou know, they're opposed through It's a violation of civil rights and they're frightened summary, so I said, "Oh, we completely agree. The ACLU's view of the the abrogation I'm not going to cause chaos with all the [crosstalk] unevaluated data.
NixonWhen this FBI raw data is written by a pursuivant, a fellow with a clerk mentality, That's right. and it just brabbles on, and it's no conclusion. It's hearsay at its worst.
HaldemanWell, anybody who reads FBI files, all you had to do is read one or two files. Oh, I Hoover used to bring in Hoover used to bring in those things, you know, for friendship. Dulles' goddamned things ever read. Well, but a lot of it is awful stuff, too. Said, you know, you get to the Oh yeah, Charlie and and, you know, what did the FBI, We couldn't clear hardly anybody on the White House staff if we had to base it on files.
HaldemanYou know what I mean? You also couldn't clear a single guy in that press room. Oh, shit. I told Ron just say, "You ought to see say, you ought to see what we got the basic one who said.
NixonI mean, did he was screwing his secretary or or, anyway, screwing his secretary, so that meant that she was screwing him, so and well, but Well, a lot of horse shit. You get through all the Finally, he's often has been seen here and there, and he's been known to do this and he's known to have psychopathic fits, go ahead.
ZieglerFuck the ACLU letter. It's the Judiciary Committee really takes them on, you know. Releasing this material.
NixonWell, I don't know what Ervin's playing the game is. I hope that the little fellow, Baker, eventually starts behaving a little. Well, their committee hasn't started. No, but Ervin's like all sorts of things. Yeah, but he's doing it on Judiciary. Everything he's doing.
ZieglerWhat else? Yeah. Just before you see Newby Noyes, I'm going to tell him, before he meets with you, that you will not be able to do the AP speech in New York on April the 23rd,
Zieglerand he may raise it with you, and I've already told him that you won't be able to do it, so it's not going to get crushed. I don't think you should do that.
ZieglerNo. But, as they said, they they need a tend to advance it for a while. You think this next week would would be better, uh, advised maybe this next Thursday, to do the Press Club down here, than do the press thing out here? Well, no, I don't think so. I thought I like the Press Club idea,
Zieglernot not at this, my immediate As a matter of fact, we need the Press Club, going to do the goddamn thing at night, do that at prime time and let them carry that, and cheer, and all that bull, you know, because most of them are not press people.
NixonI would do it at night. What the hell! We should bring in SD. They are our people, you know. Maybe he's our friend, he's a damn good, Do it at night? Fun, where are they? It deserves better news. Whether they play it or not, I don't know.
NixonI don't think they'd have to. Hey, they'd have to, don't they? Sure. The president addressed national National Press Club. They'd have to carry it. Sure.
NixonIs it being a press conference?
ZieglerWell, I wanted you to be aware that uh he may raise that with you. Well, it's what's that you're talking about, so Uh, Newby Noyes.
NixonNoyes.
NixonYou go to see Newby?
BullNo hurry.
NixonAll new.
BullI'll see you.
NixonThat's good. We'll get some decent quiet.
  • 872-012 1:16 PM · 6 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Dr. Jerome H. Jaffe, Robert V. Davison, Mrs. Robert V. Davison, Allen G. Kaupinen, Mrs. Allen G. Kaupinen, Robert A. F. Reisner, Mrs. Robert A. F. Reisner, Jane S. Eberle, Carolyn K. Muse, and Gary Axelson met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:16 pm and 1:21 pm.
  • 872-013 1:22 PM · 11 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Tony Martin, and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:22 pm and 1:33 pm.
  • 872-014 1:33 PM · 15 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:33 pm and 2:20 pm.
  • 872-015 1:33 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:33 pm and 2:20 pm.
  • 872-016 1:33 PM · 8 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:33 pm and 2:20 pm.
  • 872-024 1:33 PM · 11 sec — unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 1:33 pm and 2:20 pm.
  • 872-017 2:20 PM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House at 2:20 pm.
  • 872-019 2:50 PM · 41 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Lelsie T. ("Bob") Hope, unknown person(s), H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, White House operator, and Henry A. Kissinger met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 2:50 pm and 3:34 pm.

Conversation 872-018, March 8, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417182895). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/872-018 (accessed November 20, 2026).