Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 21 › Conversation 021-094

Nixon phone call with Haldeman on Busing speech and Public reaction

Thursday, March 16, 1972 · 10:57 PM–11:07 PM ET · White House Telephone · 10 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob")Conversation021-094 on Tape 21 (tape position 03:38:37–03:48:53)StartThursday, March 16, 1972 at 10:57 PMEndThursday, March 16, 1972 at 11:07 PMRecording deviceWhite House TelephoneSourceNixon Library record for 021-094 ↗ · National Archives Catalog, NAID 646310188 ↗

President Nixon and H.R. Haldeman discussed reactions to Nixon's speech on busing, with Haldeman relaying positive feedback from various individuals and groups, while also noting some criticisms. They also discussed strategies for generating supportive correspondence to Congress and briefly touched upon the ITT case and the shredding of Dita Beard's file.

Download MP3 · 23.6 MB

This clip of the conversation was cut from the tape by the National Archives (catalog record ↗).

Listen to the full tape segment it comes from

Position in tape (archivists' log): 03:38:37 – 03:48:53

part B, 1:35:16

021a.mp3
021c.mp3

On March 16, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon and H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman talked on the telephone from 10:57 pm to 11:07 pm. The White House Telephone taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 021-094 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 21-94

Date: March 16, 1972
Time: 10:57 pm - 11:07 pm
Location: White House Telephone

H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman talked with the President.

     Busing speech
          -Opinions
               -Arch A. Moore
               -D. Tenant Bryan
               -Frank W. Burke
               -John Loeb

      -Felix McKnight
      -Joe D. Waggonner, Jr.
            -Department of Health, Education and Welfare [HEW]
            -John D. Ehrlichman
            -Leonard Garment
            -Raymond K. Price, Jr.
      -William S. Broomfield
      -Richard R. Wainwright
      -Harold E. Hyde
      -Mario Machuochi [sp?]
      -President of the National Association of Post Office Employees
      -Editorial page editor of the Birmingham News
      -Donald Goodenow
      -Ken Morrell
            -Attorney General
            -Ehrlichman
      -Clark T. Reed
            -The President’s view
                  -Edmund S. Muskie
                  -George C. Wallace
      -Cruise Palmer
      -Everett D. Collier
      -Brady F. Black
      -County Executive of Onondaga County, New York
      -Cabinet members
            -Earl L. Butz
            -Rogers C.B. Morton
            -George P. Shultz
            -James Hodgson
                  -Minorities
Show the rest of the log (31 more lines)
      -Robert H. Finch
      -Mayor Allen, Columbus, Georgia
      -Martin S. Hayden
-Ehrlichman
      -Talk with John B. Connally
            -Connally’s schedule
-Opinions
      -Edith Green
-Wires and letters
      -Congress
      -Herbert G. Klein
      -Charles W. Colson

                      -George T. Bell
                -Ehrlichman
                -Colson
                -Bell
                -International Telephone and Telegraph [ITT]

     ITT case
          -Dita Beard’s file

     Busing speech
          -Wires and letters
          -Colson
          -Civic groups
               -American Legion
               -Jaycees
               -Unknown person
          -Committee to Re-elect the President [CRP]
          -Finch

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the page address then links to that moment (e.g. #t=125).

Each line starts with a timestamp button; press it to play the audio from that point.

NixonHello?
OperatorMr. Haldeman, Mr. President.
NixonYeah, okay.
HaldemanHello.
HaldemanHi, you want to run down on what we got now?
NixonYeah, j- just a brief, brief, okay.
HaldemanGood comment from Arch Moore who says it's, uh, especially pleased with the immediate moratorium, wants to see the legislation.
NixonAll these people, Bob, are just, you know, jackassing around, so.
HaldemanNo, they aren't.
NixonThey aren't, uh, they don't, they don't understand, you know, you've got to, you know, bite a terribly difficult problem in a tough way.
HaldemanThey do. Tennant Bryan says if I had thought of several nights, these comments couldn't have been better. All of us know that something like this takes time and to quote the story, even the Lord couldn't create a two-year-old colt. I'm extremely pleased with the line the President has taken particularly because this is substantive and not rhetoric.
HaldemanIn Richmond, where we have such a major problem, this will be extremely well-received. Mayor Burke says the President said all the right things and gave all the right reasons.
HaldemanHe might be criticized for coming out after the primary.
HaldemanJohn Loeb agreed with the approach. Legal thing is going to be a problem.
HaldemanA lot of people raise that because, of course, they haven't seen the legislation yet. That's true.
NixonNow what will be a problem?
HaldemanFelix McKnight says well-planned, well said, very valid all the way. I had four couples here tonight, two very liberal. They all agree with the President's summary and his, he had a magnificent summary and he came through very strongly on all aspects.
HaldemanJoe Waggonner says it was poor. He is very upset about the forced busing in effect, which is all due to HEW and nothing in the proposal changes that, but we can turn him around.
HaldemanUh-
NixonWell, that shows you the, the thing about Ehrlichman and, uh,
Nixonand, uh, Garment, you see, who, I mean,
NixonEhrlichman doesn't believe it, but Garment does, and Price, that, you kind of, you know, they want it much softer. My God, I, this is the toughest thing that you, that, that anybody would agree to.
HaldemanYeah. That's, you're not getting any, you know, very much on that and, and Broomfield of Illinois says great, right on target.
NixonHe's in Michigan, Michigan.
HaldemanYeah. Right. Excuse me. Thought he beat the Democrats by talking about the help to poor schools. He thinks he'll get it out of committee soon and through this Congress.
HaldemanMayor of Brockton, Mass. Well, let's skip that. Uh, President of Plymouth State College, New Hampshire: many things need to be said.
HaldemanWe've overemphasized desegregation instead of quality education. This was an extremely well-made point. However, pulling this off will be more difficult than you can imagine. Can't be done overnight.
NixonAll right. Right, right.
HaldemanItalian leader Mario Machuochi in Detroit.
NixonThat, that doesn't matter, Bob.
HaldemanOkay, uh, president of the National Association of Post Office Employees believes he's right. Busing is no answer; equal education is. Must rectify the shortcomings in the poor schools.
NixonThat's good.
HaldemanEditorial page editor of the Birmingham News, it was excellent and right to the point. We'll get good reaction here. I thought that the President was wise in separating the issue, that being anti-busing isn't being anti-black.
NixonThat was something I wrote in.
HaldemanYeah. Don Goodenow the, at the LA Herald Examiner: President really came across. Forceful statements, a logical coverage, a compassionate and practical approach to education. Position can't lose, needed to be said.
HaldemanKen Morrell of the Nashville Banner was disappointed because he offered no assistance to specific cities, but we can turn him around.
NixonDoesn't understand the, right.
NixonThe Attorney General said.
HaldemanThat's right.
HaldemanUh-
NixonYou got this, you got to get Ehrlichman busy on this sort of thing, Haldeman.
HaldemanRight. Well, I'm just looking through the second group of Clark Reed,
Haldemanuh, Southern Chairman: excellent, seize the initiatives. Pres- Pres- seized the initiative. The President clarified the issues, that you can be against busing and not be a racist.
NixonThat's, that's the important-
HaldemanRight.
NixonYou know, you see, you think, you see the thing about the Muskie approach, is he attacks everybody that voted for Wallace as racists, and I didn't, you see.
HaldemanRight.
NixonAnd some of our guys have got to point that out.
HaldemanWell, right. Cruise Palmer, Kansas City Star, said it is the only answer, well thought out.
HaldemanThe implementation might be a question, but it was badly needed particularly to divide the country. Everett Collier of Houston Chronicle said President made quite clear his position against busing, but it's not clear what his legislation contains, which was that.
HaldemanOne of the best things he did was at the end when he said being against busing was not being anti-black. That was something that had to be said.
NixonAll right, right, right.
HaldemanBrady Black says, uh, President's proposal was excellent, well-stated, and the majority of Americans who will support it time is much needed. Busing does not work, and education is the first priority.
HaldemanCounty executive in Onondaga County in New York: it's a new approach and I think it would be quite acceptable in this area. The placing of the problem in Congress is a very sound idea.
HaldemanThen I've got the Cabinet guys who, uh-
HaldemanButz: very effective message, hit the issue on the nose.
HaldemanMorton carefully avoids the legal complexities, I'll be in Atlanta tomorrow and get a good
Haldemanrun
Haldemanthe how it went over there. TV picture was perfect, color very good.
HaldemanShultz says, you know, that this he set us up very well for our job of explaining the context of the bill.
HaldemanHodgson, it's kind of interesting, he's at the Statler with with a group of manpower professionals, said, "The total reaction here is the best speech made to date. He wisely put emphasis on tone and feeling, not on detail.
HaldemanI particularly liked stressing the neighborhood theme and uh unity. People liked that. Really good. He has a great ability to become very calm, reasoned, and compassionate on issues which are the most controversial." Listen to that.
HaldemanThis is interesting. He said, "Another thing I noticed which was good, he mentioned the Mexican-American, the Indian, and others before he mentioned blacks." That was extremely shrewd. Those minorities are going crazy with delight, I I assure you.
HaldemanThen Finch says, "Best speech ever, and I really mean it. It was moving, clear, crisp. Glad he didn't go into much detail. That would have been a mistake. The color was excellent. The President looked superb. The whole thing was a ten-strike."
HaldemanAnd uh the mayor of Columbus, Georgia, Mayor Allen, "The President's message was excellent, his sincerity is unquestionable. He placed the blame where it belongs, on the lower federal courts."
NixonUh-huh.
Haldeman"The statement that Congress has the key is correct. The mayor will be communicating with his own congressmen tomorrow. He believes that not just the South, but the whole nation, has been waiting for the President to speak positively on this subject, provide the leadership which is needed. This he has done." Mayor is issuing a statement to the press along with--
HaldemanPaul Hardin, "Right thing. He expressed the line we've been taking." Not clear about whether the money's coming out of his old and new month. That doesn't matter.
NixonWhat's the situation? Did Did Ehrlichman ever get to Connally? Because I told him--
HaldemanI'm I'm sure he did, cuz he he called me and said he was trying to reach him. Connally is having a dinner party tonight. Yeah. So uh I don't know whether he he got got in ahead or not.
HaldemanUh Edith Green says, "I thought the President appealed to the best parental instincts and that equal education was is concern of equal concern of all of us. Hope Congress will act immediately." He and uh
Haldeman[unintelligible] stop busing. Dividing the nation that's that's the spring nights that's That's about it. That covers the calls we took. We'll be uh touching base on the outside.
NixonRight.
HaldemanConnally's got
NixonWell, the main thing is whether They got a few things whether whether your people, you know,
Haldemannot not stir them up to really show that they got any muscle, but that they get a few wires, letters in the pipeline.
NixonYeah.
NixonWho Who is doing that? You or Klein?
HaldemanKlein and Colson.
NixonNo, hell, no.
HaldemanKlein isn't doing it.
HaldemanColson. That's uh through the Colson apparatus and with George Bell's contact type.
NixonOh, that's good. They're all at they're all around the country with the organizational.
NixonI'd really put it to him. Sure.
NixonDoing wires, letters, and so forth.
HaldemanYep.
HaldemanYep. I think you'll get a lot anyway, cuz you
NixonI think they will, too.
HaldemanI mean, even if we don't lift a finger. We obviously will because you can't
NixonThe only thing is, then they won't admit it. Only our friends will admit it.
NixonThe thing to do is to get the goddamned things in, Bob. Yep. And then And then of course, then say that they put us through and sent them.
HaldemanYep.
NixonCourse [unintelligible]
HaldemanYep.
NixonWe should have hit Colson harder on this, would you? Yes, sir.
NixonGets Bell and all the other fellows to get off ITT and for this week- well, this weekend.
HaldemanRight.
NixonThe ITT, they can't do a goddamned thing about this week, you know. That's right. Big news. Big news, shredding the goddamn it.
NixonThey hold that funny, that's the thing that makes them so
HaldemanSuspicious. You know, stupid thing, but
NixonWas it Was that the news item? Oh, yes.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonThey shredded Dita Beard's file.
HaldemanRight.
NixonI would have done it, but I wouldn't have got caught doing it.
HaldemanWell, and you wouldn't have shredded everybody else's file too.
NixonWell, hell,
HaldemanThey make it look so clumsy, it's funny.
NixonOkay, I think it's doing well. But let's let's put the heat on getting some wires now. That'll be the total eat everything around.
HaldemanAll right.
HaldemanYes, sir.
NixonWho else did you call beside the Colson?
HaldemanWell, through there we've got a tremendous network. That's will go through them. It'll go through the American Legion groups, the Jaycee groups that that they've got set up.
NixonAll right.
HaldemanThey've got a whole machine for that. Re-election Committee has some, but they aren't nearly as effective yet.
NixonTry to know the Re-election Committee, try everything you can, everything. Tell Finch and the rest to get right
HaldemanYeah. Turn both of them loose.
NixonOkay. Okay.
  • 021-092 10:31 PM · 7 min — President Richard M. Nixon and H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman talked on the telephone from 10:31 pm to 10:38 pm.
  • 021-093 10:40 PM · 8 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Julie Nixon Eisenhower, and [Dwight] David Eisenhower, II talked on the telephone from 10:40 pm to 10:49 pm.
  • 021-095 11:07 PM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 11:07 pm and 11:12 pm.
  • 021-096 11:12 PM · 6 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at 11:12 pm.
  • 021-097 11:12 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at 11:12 pm.
  • 021-098 11:13 PM · 4 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John D. Ehrlichman talked on the telephone from 11:13 pm to 11:18 pm.
  • 021-099 11:18 PM · 8 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 11:18 pm and 11:19 pm.
  • 021-100 11:19 PM · 7 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Robert H. Finch talked on the telephone from 11:19 pm to 11:26 pm.

Conversation 021-094, March 16, 1972. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 646310188). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/021-094 (accessed November 19, 2026).