President Nixon, John Mitchell, H.R. Haldeman, and John Dean discussed the Supreme Court's recent decision on school busing. The primary focus was on the implications of the ruling, particularly its distinction between de jure and de facto segregation, and how the administration should respond publicly. They debated the strategy for a public statement, aiming to emphasize compliance with the law while distancing the White House from actively promoting busing or racial balancing, and ensuring the burden fell on local school authorities and district courts. The conversation also touched on potential Supreme Court resignations and the broader political landscape.
On April 20, 1971, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, John N. Mitchell, John W. Dean, III, White House photographer, Ronald L. Ziegler, unknown person(s), White House operator, and Sue Morrison met in the Oval Office of the White House from 4:20 pm to 5:14 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 483-019 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 483-19
Date: April 20, 1971
Time: 4:20 pm - 5:14 pm
Location: Oval Office
The President met with H.R. (“Bob”) Haldeman, John N. Mitchell, and John W. Dean, III; the
White House photographer was present at the beginning of the meeting
Supreme Court decision on busing
-Questions
-Chief Justice Warren Burger
-Administration's school aid program
-Impact
-Approach
-Take credit or distance administration
-Implications
-Local options
-Statement
Mitchell's trip
Photo
******************************************************************************
[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 02/07/2020.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal-Returnable]
[483-019-w006]
[Duration: 44s]
John N. Mitchell’s house
-Charles G. (“Bebe”) Rebozo
John N. Mitchell’s trip
-Fishing
-Bonefish
******************************************************************************
Supreme Court decision on school busing
Mitchell's visitors
Show the rest of the log (440 more lines)
Supreme Court decision on busing
-Implications
-De jure
-Application
-Los Angeles County case
-De jure
-Gerrymandering
-Unanimity
-Burger
-Implications
-Racial balance
-Necessity
-Opinion
-Charlotte-Mecklenburg case
-Incidents of racial balance
-Walter F. Mondale
-Abraham A. Ribicoff
-Guidelines
-Equity proceedings
-Dual school systems
-Previous decisions
-Neighborhood schools
-Desegregation/racial balance
-Non-contiguous school districts
-Charlotte-Mecklenburg case
-Future impact
-General principle
-Resegregation
-Washington, DC
-Possible effect on South
-Cities
-Neighborhood schools
-School districts
-The courts
-Department of Health, Education, and Welfare [HEW]
-National Association for the Advancement of Colored People [NAACP]
-Jack Greenberg
-Joe Brown
-Elliot L. Richardson
-Power under Title VI
-School districts
-Compliance under court order
-Procedure
-HEW "zealots"
-Non-contiguous districts
-Racial balance
-Whitten amendment
-State legislatures
-Racial balance
Ronald L. Ziegler was present at an unknown time after 4:20 pm.
-Leonard Garment and Dean
-Administration's legislative proposals
-Possible administration statement
-Local school board responsibility
-Local school authorities
-District courts
-HEW
-De facto segregation
-White House involvement
-Possible comment by the President
-President’s view
-Burger
-Administration's position
-Resignation to court decision
-Possible administration statement
-Spending for busing
-Administration’s attitude
-Ziegler's possible statement
-Possible wording
-Changes
-Local school authorities and district courts
-Compliance with Court's mandate
-Possible public effects
-Conveys administration’s attitude
-Burden on local school authorities and district courts
-Justice Department/HEW
-Ziegler's possible statement
-Local school district obligations
-District Courts
-HEW/Justice Department
-Public interpretation
-Compliance with the law
-Administration's position
-Obligation to follow law of the land
-Local school districts and district court responsibilities
-Ziegler's possible statement
-Federal enforcement procedure requirements
-HEW/Justice statutory responsibilities
-Federal role
-Edward L. Morgan
-HEW's responsibilities
-Redrawing of school district lines
-Administration's policy
-Arguments/controversies
-HEW's position
-Ziegler's possible statement
-President’s view
-President's statement March 24, 1970
-Law of the land
-Constitutional precepts
-President's statements on busing, neighborhood schools
-Law of the land
-Justice/HEW's statutory responsibilities
-Local school district and district courts responsibilities
-Justice/HEW powers
-Whitten amendment
-President’s March 24, 1970 statement
-Desegregation of school systems
-Context
-Law of the land
-Administration's position
-Press conference
-Law of the land
-Context
-Compliance
-Enforcement of desegregation
-Local districts/district courts
-Relevance of past decisions
-Law of the land
The President's schedule, April 21, 1971
-Meeting with Graham B. Steenhoven
-US table tennis team
-Vice President Spiro T. Agnew
Supreme Court decision on school busing
-Burger
The President's schedule
-Picture of the President and Mitchell
-Phyllis Slocum [sp?]
-Meeting with Republican Senators
Desegregation
-Burger
Haldeman and Dean left at 4:42 pm.
Ziegler left at an unknown time before 4:59 pm.
Supreme Court decision on school busing
-De facto segregation
-Ruling
-Dual school systems
-The South
-The President's position
-Garment
-Hypocrisy
-Opinions within administration
-Richard A. Moore
-Public reaction
The President's schedule, April 18, 1971
-Drive through Washington with Julie Nixon Eisenhower
Supreme Court
-Possible resignations
-Burger
-John Marshall Harlan
-Tenure
-Mitchell's conversation with Burger
-Herbert Brownell
-Burger
-Republican
-Harlan
-Burger
-Hill case
-Legal opinions
-William O. Douglas
-Hugo L. Black
-Thurgood Marshall
-Health
Mitchell's trip to Florida
-Meeting with Marshall and Whitney M. Young, Jr.
Florida
-President's meeting with American Society of Newspaper Editors [ASNE], April 16,
1971
-Mitchell and Charles G. (“Bebe”) Rebozo's call to the President
-Television
Influence of television
-Impact on nation
-President's speech on Southeast Asia, April 7, 1971
-Lieutenant William L. Calley, Jr. case
-President's visit to California
-Laos
-President's speech on Vietnam
-President's People's Republic of China [PRC] initiative
-Significance
-”Doves”
-Union of Soviet Socialist Republics [USSR]
-Economic report
-Stock market
-Rise
-Number of stockholders
National mood
-Psychology
-Mitchell's meeting with Lee R. Nunn
-Nunn's trip to Kentucky, Ohio, Illinois, West Coast
-Popular attitude towards the President
-Columnists
-Polls
-Press corps
The President's meeting with John L. McClellan
-McClellan's views regarding the President's supporters
-Democrats
-McClellan's support for the President
-Mrs. Norma McClellan
The President's schedule
-James O. Eastland
Eastland
-James C. Wright
**********************************************************************
[Previous PRMPA Privacy (D) reviewed under deed of gift 02/11/2020. Segment cleared for
release.]
[Privacy]
[483-019-w003]
[Duration: 8s]
James O. Eastland
-James C. Wright
-Personal habits
-Drinking
-John N. Mitchell’s opinion
**********************************************************************
James O. Eastland
-Support for the President
-Votes
An unknown person entered at an unknown time after 4:42 pm.
Refreshments
The unknown person left at an unknown time before 4:59 pm.
Jack N. Anderson
Haldeman entered at an unknown time after 4:42 pm.
The President's schedule
-Meeting with Eastland and Roman L. Hruska
-Mitchell
-Executive Office Building [EOB]
-Hugh Scott
Scott
Eastland
-Louisiana
-Support for the President
Southern Democrats
-Eastland
-McClellan
-Richard B. Russell
-Spessard L. Holland
-David H. Gambrell
-Lawton M. Chiles, Jr.
Republicans
-McClellan's criticism
Schedule
-Upcoming meeting with Republican Senators
-Supreme Court decision of school busing
The President's schedule, April 21, 1971
-Morning
-Afternoon
Mitchell's schedule, April 21, 1971
-Secretary Sue Morrison
The President talked with the White House operator at an unknown time between 4:42 pm and
4:59 pm.
[Conversation No. 483-19A]
[See Conversation No. 2-13]
[End of telephone conversation]
The President's schedule, April 21, 1971
The President talked with Sue Morrison between 4:59 pm and 5:01 pm.
[Conversation No. 483-19B]
[See Conversation No. 2-14]
[End of telephone conversation]
The President's schedule
-Meeting with Steenhoven
-Mitchell
-Meeting with national 4-H Club leaders
-Meeting with Henry A. Kissinger
Morrison
-Maiden name
Harry S. Dent
-Schedule
-Location
Supreme Court decision on school busing
-Impact
-Supreme Court
-The South
-HEW
-Possible shake-up
-Elliot L. Richardson
-Robert H. Finch
-John G. Veneman
-Lewis H. Butler
-Unknown name
-Order
-Morgan
-Dean
-Morgan
-Requirements
-President's position
-Butler
-Bureaucracy
-Richardson
-Finch
-Richardson’s possible response
-Non-contiguous zoning
-Busing
-Administration’s position
-School authorities' obligations
-Plans for District Courts
-HEW
-Plans for school districts
-Consultant role
Mitchell's schedule, April 21, 1971
-HEW
-Richardson
-Meeting with the President
-Richardson
-John D. Ehrlichman
-Timing
-Richardson
-Ehrlichman
Supreme Court decision on school busing
-Possible administration initiatives
-Leadership on issue
-Credit for decision
-Blacks
Southern blacks
-Support for administration
-1968 election
-White liberals
-Possible response to Supreme Court decision on busing
Desegregation
-Effect of integration on black colleges
-Black schools
-Black teachers
-Separate society
-Gradualism
Supreme Court decision on school busing
-President's position
-Staff meeting
-Law
-Demagoguery
-Instructions for Ziegler
The President's schedule
-Upcoming photo with Mitchell
The President's schedule, April 21, 1971
-Meeting with Haldeman and Mitchell
**********************************************************************
[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 02/07/2020.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[483-019-w004]
[Duration: 23s]
The President’s schedule, April 21, 1971
-Meeting with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman and John N. Mitchell
-Politics
-Finance
-Questions
-John N. Mitchell
-Discussion prior to meeting
-Dean Burch
**********************************************************************
An unknown man entered at an unknown time after 5:01 pm.
The President's schedule
-Picture with Mitchell
The unknown man left at an unknown time before 5:14 pm.
The President's schedule
**********************************************************************
[Previous PRMPA Personal Returnable (G) withdrawal reviewed under deed of gift 02/07/2020.
Segment cleared for release.]
[Personal Returnable]
[483-019-w005]
[Duration: 32s]
The President’s schedule
-April 22, 1971
-Time for discussion of unknown subject
-Harry S. Dent [?]
**********************************************************************
The President, Mitchell, and Haldeman left at 5:14 pm
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
DeanI'm not, I'm not sure that we want to be [unintelligible] our school aid program. This may or may not be a plus.
DeanAlso, it depends on how you want to approach this, whether you want to take credit for the court's decision, or whether you come and say the court has decided and now it's up to the school boards and the to implement it, and how they do it. The seven day is designed by the court to help out situations [unintelligible]
MitchellUn-unless, uh, unless you find some kind of, uh, de jure action there with the location of schools or gerrymandering of districts, things like that.
MitchellI'd prefer that, really. But, as you can imagine, to get a unanimous decision and to have this Chief Justice write the opinion, you know there were a hell of a lot of
MitchellWell, they did say in the opinion, and which was the Charlotte-Mecklenburg thing was, the district judge could consider, as one of the ways of accommodating this, the incidents of racial balance, but then went on to say that it wasn't a racial balance case because he didn't come out with racial balance, but is, racial balance is not a legal requirement.
Mitchellreally Mondale and Ribicoff were opting for in there, a hitchhiked into this thing.
NixonTook them all off, weren't they? They get court, really did. All they need is fashion about the decision.
MitchellWhat the, what the basis of it, interrupt you just a minute John, is, is they have put the cases in the nature of an equity proceeding in the courts where the courts are to use their extra, their equity powers to make sure that in these dual school systems that they are desegregated.
MitchellAnd, where the, opinion goes further than has been thought of in the context of the previous decisions and the activities of desegregation is that they explicitly rule out the neighborhood school.
MitchellAnd they specifically say that if, if it's necessary in this equitable procedure to obtain desegregation, it's safe with desegregation instead of racial balance,
Mitchellyou should use non-contiguous school districts. So, those are really the two areas where they've gone further
MitchellAnd, of course, as they point out in the Charlotte-Mecklenburg case, they used more bussing before to keep the school districts segregated than they did to desegregate it, and so that they couldn't complain about the requirement of bussing in order to bring about desegregation.
MitchellNow, the net effect of it, in which is important for the future,
Mitchellalthough, there's one other general principle they laid down, that has to do with the fact that once you've quote "desegregated" a school district, you're not required every year to keep some semblance of racial balance if you brought about your desegregation, and if you're not required to worry about resegregation, which was one of the problems of,
MitchellYeah. Well, as a general principle, that is helpful, so that you don't have this constant turmoil year after year after year, good.
MitchellNow, the net effect of it is, according to our early assessment, is that probably the majority of the school districts in the South will be in compliance with this decision.
MitchellThere are some of the major cities that are not, and this is where the major problems will come,
Mitchellbecause they stayed into neighborhood schools, into contiguous zones, and there'll be discussions back and forth as to whether desegregation there should go further.
MitchellAnd, of course, there are, oh, depending upon the nature of the case, some five or six hundred, uh, school districts in the South that are still in the courts, under court orders, where the courts will now take this decision as a guideline and come up with, uh, new plans, or modify plans for the fall term, in
NixonWell, those, those could be pretty drastic, I think.
MitchellI'm not, I don't believe too many. We haven't made an analysis of it, but I think where the pinch will come upon us
Mitchellis if, uh, HEW starts to decide, and I notice that both Jack Greenberg, NAACP, and Joe Rauh in their statements about the decision,
Mitchelluh, both of them went to the fact that now Richardson has got the powers under Title VI to require this, so they're trying to put the monkey on HEW.
MitchellWell, he has, he has the power if, uh, if they uh, street fight if a school district is not in compliance with a court order,
MitchellHEW has a procedure by which he's supposed to cut off funds. We haven't done that, and this is what they're trying to do, is force us to move the system.
MitchellSo, as I say, the important political aspect and practical aspect of this is to make sure that these zealots over in HEW just don't go run down, and draw, and re- start redrawing every damn line to make it non-contiguous,
MitchellThat that's where where our problems will come, if they come. Also, on the part the question all over the place,
Mitchellon the subject matter, and the net result of the opinions of my initial reading is that the whitten amendment is out. That's, you cannot hide behind the Whitten amendment.
MitchellYou just cannot. Or can state legislatures uh legislate in the area against bussing and a racial balance, and anything like this if they are required uh to carry out a desegregation plan and the elimination of a dual school system.
NixonYeah. And you just don't say anything about it. It's too complicated historically. That's all. Well, Or you take that right out? Well, I've got one, let me uh, one other point which You have to say something.
MitchellWell, I don't think so. There's one other point that still's valid that has been made by Len Garment and John which the more I hear of it, the more I'm against.
MitchellAnd that is to tie in this decision with your legislation that's up there, the billion and a half dollars.
NixonHell, no. The line against the legislation, let alone the decision.
MitchellNow, there's but if if a statement is required, uh there is, in my opinion, a simp- simple approach to it.
MitchellStarting out with two initial premises: number one, the court has acted, and it is now the responsibility of the local school boards and district courts to carry it out.
MitchellNow, if we say the court has acted, this will mean that we don't, don't particularly care about the decision.
MitchellWe can start that introduction in a different way, and say uh this landmark decision has come down from the court. In other words, to flatter
Mitchellthe court's action, depending on who wants what. Well, [unintelligible] the court has acted, and then you would want to point it is now the obligation--
NixonJust say, now the court has acted, the uh it is the obligation of the
NixonIt is the obligation of all concerned to uh to uh follow the uh
MitchellWell, let's let's get this the local school authorities and the district courts in there, and get it away from us, because that's where--
NixonNow, it is the obligation of the local school districts.
MitchellThe local district? You want to say the local school districts?
NixonNow, they try to pressure HEW, and all that kind of thing.
NixonIn other words, you're, you're, you're you don't say it's a great decision. It's not a landmark decision. We're not interested in anything. It's a terrible decision, actually.
HaldemanWell, I don't, we don't, from the White House, have to get into any degree of discussion of the aspects of the uh--
ZieglerWell, I don't even have to hand it out, but what they're looking for from the White House and will press on is, "Okay, this is a Supreme Court unanimous decision. What is the President's view of it? Was he pleased by the decision? Does Burger
NixonI will not comment on the decision, whether I am pleased, or not pleased. It's simply the decision. The Court has acted, and uh it's that's it. We resign. What?
HaldemanYou use John's language. What you have got to push on, how does this affect the South, the statements?
ZieglerWell, so they will do that, too. I mean, they'll ask, "Well, then, for a while,
Mitchelland a very big, long statement on the school desegregation.
NixonIf you, if you would go back and look at that statement, Ron, I think you will find that we fudged it.
ZieglerNo, it's fudged to the degree that, that that when Times just read it, and it would say, "President does not feel that money should be spent on buses and so forth in order to achieve racial balance, as well as, there are more important things to spend money on. So, if there is a gray area to move,
NixonWell, let's uh, covering de facto thing. What I want you to do is to just I don't want anything coming out of here indicating play for this decision, approval of this decision,
Nixononly the fact that the high court has acted. So, just put it that way, just--
ZieglerThe first paragraph of this, can I just read this to you, and see what your impression is? And what what what is the reaction to it? "The Supreme Court's
Zieglerdecision represents an important clarification of the law relating to the desegregation of the dual school system. The principle stated by the Chief Justice in the Court, the Court's unanimous opinion, will, of course, be followed by the executive branch."
NixonPeriod. You don't want that. You don't want that. Strike that out, Mr. Ziegler. I don't want a word of clarification. I don't think we need either of those two first sentences at all.
MitchellNow, that the Court has acted, uh, it's I mean to see that you're, you're not You don't praise it.
NixonI would simply say, the Court is uh they uh the You say, the Court the Court has acted. The Court has acted in this field, and that's that's that. I just uh I think what John has sketched out nice. Uh,
MitchellNow Now that the uh Now that the the uh Court has acted, or spoken, on this matter uh it's important that the limited number of
Mitchellschool districts that are not in compliance with the Court's ruling,
Mitchellmove to the local school authorities and the district courts,
MitchellAnd that that shows that we're, number one, not in a--
Ziegler"Move through the," would be the proper What did you say, "move through the"?
MitchellYeah. Well, your, your whole statement was a lot better when you summed it up, John. It says the same thing. You just said, the court has now acted. It's the obligation of the local school authorities and the district courts to carry out the mandate of the Court. I think you've covered the whole subject, haven't you, with that?
MitchellAnd this will have have the effect a number of effects. Number one, it'll be construed as we're not happy with the decision, which I think is correct. And number two, it'll it'll point out the fact that the court
Mitchellhas placed the burden and responsibility on the local school authorities and the district courts, and not here in the Justice Department or HEW to see that this is done.
NixonThis court, this decision, in your opinion, does deal with that particular problem, rather than with the Justice Department and HEW? It deals with this.
NixonThis Now, why did you start with this, "This court's decision, the court's decision," why did you say this? Uh we first must recognize, relates to the the uh the uh
NixonNow the obligation is of the local school districts and the courts in the matter of desegregation. Now the court has acted. It is an extraordinary action. See, they said, "What about HEW? What about the Justice Department?" This court decision does not deal with that particular problem. So that is correct.
MitchellYes, now this line is a purely legal one because this is going to be interpreted as full of how about that? Like federal government's not going to make it.
NixonI see. Then you wouldn't do it. Yes. I see what you mean.
MitchellWhat you're doing is detracting from and mitigating the one substance that you've always had in your statements and that is that the law of the land should be complied with and that was the third point that I made in that short statement there.
DeanNow the court has acted and the reporter said, "What is your view then?" How's the President said, "Now that the court has acted, it's the obligation of everybody concerned to obey the law of the-"
NixonIt's the law of the land. Supreme Court has said this is the law of the land. It's the law of the land. There's that-
DeanThat doesn't put on any federal act, it responds to the responsibility of the local school districts and the courts to enforce the law.
ZieglerI don't understand the point that you want me to make at the end. If I'm asked, well, "Are you saying by this statement that it's the law of the land, it's an obligation of local school districts and district courts to carry out the mandate, are you saying there's no federal enforcement procedure required here?"
MitchellWell, I think for your purposes, you could just say, "Why, of course, HEW and the Justice Department will continue to carry out their statutory responsibilities, and not trying to get into a dialogue as to where they are, but-
DeanWell, this doesn't modify any of the statutory fights that this except they clearly said no limitation lower court discretion. Yeah, I say.
MitchellIt does not modify what Justice or HEW does.
NixonYeah, well, let's understand one thing, Bob. You get Richardson in, he's to be told to get whoever it was that handled this before. Mardian. Have this- Well, let's hope it's gone now. All right. Or Mardian's still here. Well, whoever it is, whoever is to be assigned on this, they need to watch him.
NixonHEW is not to do anything in this field except what is called for and required frankly. That's what you want.
MitchellAnd this is what we're going to have to do. If they go starting in there and redraw all these lines, we're just going to get into the most hideous situation. In fact, this one, and that one, and the next one. We just got to stay away from it as far as we can, and let the courts do it with school authorities do their own. Right. Now, we're going to obviously get into some arguments,
Mitchellcontroversies, and physician, and so forth, but the idea is not to have HEW out in front, charged in. That's right.
NixonThat's right. Not that we're taking the initiative.
HaldemanYou don't say that in this press briefing. That isn't the case.
ZieglerWell, no. Oh, you're damn happy. I will try to stay away from it.
MitchellYeah. No, wait a minute, I would like to suggest that the President doesn't have to be pleased or displeased with the decision of the Supreme Court, as long as-
Mitchell[crosstalk] That that that's what that's what I retain. So that's- No, I'm not-
NixonCourse he I'll just break that out. I don't comment on Supreme Court decisions as being good decisions or bad decisions. Once the decisions are made, they are the law of the land.
DeanHe can refer to his April 24th statement, or March 24th, where he had analyzed the law. He didn't make any comments, right, or whether it was good or bad. He said the law-
NixonAnd say the law once again that the Supreme Court has the final interpretations of what the law of the land is. Now, the court has spoken, this is the law of the land.
ZieglerI think what I should probably lead with, well, how does this appear to follow up questions on neighborhood schools in the South, and then, in discussing this with the with the President, the Attorney General came in early this afternoon, frankly, late back and discussing what the President said in terms of analyzing the laws that existed before, this is the law of the land, it will be up, it it-
HaldemanThe law has been- There there were a variety of This There were a variety of decisions and opinions before. Once the Supreme Court has spoken, that is the law of the land.
ZieglerRight. And that the and the President has said that-
Zieglerhe's pointed in the past, as long as it has, that it is the obligation to enforce the law of the land, and there's nothing else to do.
HaldemanWell, then they're going to say, "Well, will the Justice Department and HEW enforce the law of the land?"
Ziegler"They will continue to carry out their statutory responsibilities."
HaldemanYeah, "They'll continue to carry out their statutory responsibilities."
ZieglerAnd then go on to say it's the obligation of all concerned, the local schools, and the district courts, which have the jurisdiction to carry out the mandates of the court. Right? And leave it at that.
HaldemanWell, and they'll say, "Well, now what what about the obligations that-"
DeanI think you can't say that this, what you got to remember is, this specific case, I think you should say, does deal with does deal with the Justice Department, HEW, doesn't it?
MitchellNot not with respect to their powers, other than so far as it gets into the application of them, but-
DeanIt would affect a lot of cases that came out. Fine. All right. Come on.
ZieglerIf there was a line that I could throw in there, if you feel it's- [crosstalk] Well, if I could say that the President, as he pointed out in his March
Zieglerstatement, very clearly indicated that his record is long been that he is for desegregation in the school system and for the segregation occurring within our society,
MitchellThat that, Ron, that again out of context, it borrows trouble. This is not about that. Desegregation. I I know it's hard, and I know that they'll want the press to go at you, but my point is it's the entire idea this is the law of the land, there have been differences of opinion, uh, in the past on this matter,
Mitchelland now the court has spoken, it's the law of the land, and it's up to everybody to obey the law of the land. Just as simple as it is possible. Period. And I'd keep it I would just I would simply say that's always our position. The law of the land, once it has been finally determined, must be faithfully executed and carried out by all concerned.
ZieglerYou see, I treated this the first thing this morning, that I wouldn't comment on it because we haven't had a chance to look at it, but they'll say, "Now you've had a chance to look at it." I should say, "Quite frankly, yes. It's our decision that there had been a variety of opinions in the past, and where nothing will be served by talking about the past, this is the law of the land, and it's up to everyone to-"
MitchellRon, by staying with that short statement, with the context of it, you get both sides. Now that the court has spoken, it's everyone knows it will this a damn Supreme Court again. You see, the court decided that, not us, and yet you go on to the point that it is the law of the land, you have to comply with it, so that means that you're on the side of those who would go to enforce desegregation.
ZieglerAll right, and if you say now that the court has acted, it's the obligation of all concerned to comply. Just
HaldemanAnd that you start with that. Now that the court has acted, it's the obligation of all concerned to
ZieglerLocal districts, district courts, [crosstalk] carry out the mandate.
HaldemanYeah, and turn down all, and others concerned, and so forth, and that, "Well, what about the decisions of the past? What about the statements of the past?" Those, those are not, are not-
Nixontrouble. Now, that's what the President's made, it's what the President's always said: "Once the Court has acted, that's the law."
Mitchell[unintelligible] Stennis won't come in tomorrow morning, wait until Thursday [unintelligible]
NixonDid that clear with the Vice President? [laughter]
NixonWell, that's a tough one, and I think that, yes, [unintelligible] what do these actually mean. The difficulty, as we all know, is that we should never have started on this, on the whole busing [unintelligible]
White House photographerMr. President, can we do the roast at the end of the meeting? It'll be a little darker outside if you don't mind. If you don't mind [crosstalk] it'd be a much nicer picture [unintelligible]. When you're ready--
NixonThe only trouble is with picture of Attorney General [crosstalk]
White House photographerWe're still four minutes from when they come.
NixonThey're only ten minutes, though, and they'll have to do it at 5:00. I've got these damned senators coming in here.
White House photographerFine, we can do it five minutes to five or--
NixonLet's call it five o'clock. We can have a picture--
White House photographerYes, sir.
NixonYeah, we can take it outside, by the way. At 5:00. Not so--
White House photographerYes, sir.
NixonI was going to say, we all know, John, you try to see this thing, so we think that this desegregation is been bad and now everybody knows it, but you can't turn it around. And so, Burger sat back so long and, frankly, it stands that way.
MitchellThe most pressing problem, Mr. President, is that if they have got into this de facto thing, we have had all the country.
NixonWell, did they? But did they have a chance to get into de facto?
MitchellI don't see how they can waffle, balk, fool from it. Just take a look at that last paragraph and you'll see. But what they what they did leave open was, uh, in connection with other types of go-of governmental action,
NixonWell, the fact is that the less I know about it the better, and you know that. I agree with everybody that doesn't have a thing to do with this except, frankly, you know, we'd have
NixonGarment, and some of the other folks over here with the best intent, they'd just have me call a landmark decision, great decision by the Supreme Court. No, sir. I know, first of all, how can you be so hypocritical? I don't believe that.
MitchellI would agree with that, and we started heading that off early this morning, and uh--
NixonAnd, incidentally, a lot of other people in the country. You know, you go around, John, you drive around, I went through, around Washington Sunday, drove through this area, saw the kids, saw the schools, saw the neighborhoods. Jesus Christ! I mean, the way these Negroes live. It is awful. Blacks are bad enough, but it is unbelievable.
MitchellAnd to take a nice, clean, white, little five-, six-year-old girl and put them in a school--
NixonWell, no, sir, I must say, um-- No chance any one or more of those judges are going to resign, eh?
MitchellWe haven't heard of any yet. But Warren keeps his ear to the ground up there, and he doesn't find any reasons.
NixonYou know, Harlan's an end, though. That's unfortunate.
MitchellYes, it's too bad. Well, he lost the Dewy think, when I saw him, and his, you know, he just looks like the, like death warmed over, doesn't he?
MitchellAbsolutely. And Chris, I don't know why he doesn't set himself on fire the way he handles those cigarettes and matches.
NixonYeah. What what what why doesn't he go out? He really should, shouldn't he?
MitchellI've talked to Warren about that. He ought to.
MitchellI've talked to Warren about it, and he said that at the right moment, that he could talk to [unintelligible] He's got to speak to somebody else. Excuse me, Warren didn't say that. Warren said that he
MitchellWell, Herb, of course, was close to Harlan, he put him, put him in there. And Warren, Berger, thought it would be better that to tell, for Herb Brownell to talk to him.
NixonWell, matter of fact, we've got to do it from the standpoint, we've got to get one Republican judge in that damn place, another another Republican judge. I mean, that doesn't mean anything, but at least who holds one,
MitchellWell, you know that he and Harlan has peculiar ideas in some of these areas. It's the principles of law that is carrying him away from our philosophy.
NixonI know. He's uh--I remember he was against us in the Hill case, but, nevertheless,
NixonSo glad you went down to Florida. My God, that was a good idea. I think the, uh, I, uh, yeah, I know you worked while you were down there, but, you know, uh, you live in a different world there, don't you, John? You certainly do. It's get away from, this thing--
NixonPress [sighs] they, uh, could believe they were frantic. Could cry that, uh--
NixonThere is this enormous, there there This country goes through great agonies, and and ups and downs because of the enormous influence of television. And, uh,
Nixonmy God, it's hard to realize, but about three weeks ago, this was before I made my speech on April the, well, just before Calley, when I was in California, remember? It became the Calley case. Then there, and that turned out to be a break, in a way, because it left, let people let off steam. But you remember everybody was squealing about
Nixonthe Laos, how bad we'd gotten in Laos. When the boys came out, although it turned out to be a pretty good operation, it turned out that, as you know, you notice they haven't attacked since then. Casualties are starting to go down, everything's happening the way we want, more or less. Country is sick of the war, they want to get off, and so forth. Some of the hawks deserted, everybody's ready to defeat it.
NixonThen came Calley, then came the April 7th broadcast, then came that silly little break on China, which is enormously important for reasons that the doves don't realize. It helped with the Russians, so on. But the other thing is that, and and then, of course, came the, uh, third, the first quarter economic report,
Nixonany fair-minded person knows it's something. And, uh, and also, John, you see the Dow at 948, that somebody thinks there's some right, the herbs. Twenty-three million in stock always. Yeah.
MitchellTwenty-three million in stock, always, yeah.
NixonAnd now, my point is that I I have a feeling that in the country, in the country, that the psychology is a hell of a lot better. I don't mean that it's I mean, it's it's it's very volatile, I understand, but I I have a feeling that the psychology is a lot that in, that in a month, it's, it's rather substantial shakeup. I don't know, do you evaluate it?
MitchellI believe that, and I've met with Lee Nunn this morning, and he volunteered that.
MitchellWhich would you prefer, Mr. President, uh in the afternoon at 4:00 or in the morning?
NixonWell, why don't we check, see what your schedule is? I'm free both times, you see. Wednesday is the day that I keep free for writing,
Nixonjust my own work. And I see people kind of informally.
MitchellYou got plenty of writing to do on this [unintelligible].
HaldemanWell, the best He does more done on Wednesday, when we don't schedule anything, that he does on the other four days when we do schedule. See, that's why
NixonYeah, I wanted to see what the Attorney General's schedule was tomorrow morning. Would you check to check to see what has he what you've got for him
Nixonuh between say uh say uh 9:00 and uh 9:00 and 11:00? I'll see both of them.
Nixonnow. So this is partly written records. Took it away from HEW [unintelligible]
MitchellWell, I think you've got to shape HEW up. I mean shape them up. That's got to be done, you're entirely right about that. But who's going to do the shape up produced and with Finch
NixonYou'll find he'll say yes, and then do the other [unintelligible]
MitchellI'm not sure that we can get past Marland and Butler and the rest of the crowd over there.
NixonThis is an order. It is an absolute cast iron order as of today.
NixonGod damn it, we're not going to let those people screw us on this thing. I don't know how we can get around it. Do you think Mardian did very well before, did he, when he was herding that thing?
MitchellI I would say that Mardian could do a much better job this year than Marland. He's got so much other stuff to do.
NixonAll right, take him off of it. This is more important.
MitchellAh well, I really think it is. I mean, he can do this too, just just get him some help on the other thing. Ah
Nixonyou Well, I don't know what what it requires. I tell you what, you sit down and talk to Mardian and see what is required. And I don't I just want I'd sort of like to have it one step removed from me. I shouldn't have to call in the likes of Butler and like that, and say, you know what I mean, and get all through the bureaucracy. But I want to know that we have Justice finding Us. Or whoever it is, Goddamn it. All right.
MitchellI I I don't think it should take too much time if it's nipped in the bud, so to speak. If somebody will sit down and talk with Elliot within the parameters that look, we don't want to get yourself started down the same road you worked before, and
NixonSee, Elliot rides herd on his own troops, which he is capable of doing if Finch was not.
MitchellWell, it's it's so that somebody's got a program. Because, otherwise, if you leave Elliot by himself, he's going to say the court has spoken and we are going to go back and start non-contiguous zoning and bussing, and
Mitchellsaying he does not have to do that so long as these cases are before the courts. The courts The first ball is to follow separate school district obligations to do so.
MitchellThe school authorities will be required to present their plans for the district courts. Now, if the courts should follow what
NixonHEW wants to step in and make up plans, is that it?
MitchellThat's it. And, of course, that wasn't that because what we did was get into the courts and then the courts would call HEW and there's a consultant
Mitchellin that they actually bring [unintelligible] I have a thought, I have a thought. You are going over to HEW tomorrow, Elliot's going to be there. In addition to the meeting, before you come over, right after with Elliot, you and Elliot and I will have breakfast. Yeah.
MitchellAnd get Ehrlichman. Get Ehrlichman to see Ehrlichman's being programmed. I really want to get This I've got to write this I feel very strongly about this frankly strong because I don't want a damn revolution in this country.
NixonThat's right, and I'll just tell him how strongly I feel that I just we just got to avoid this thing. And John, you get uh Did you ever talk to these senators? You get to these falls uh
NixonAnd that, I mean, in other words, that after all that this is a landmark decision and that we should be out in front, and then in other words, we,
MitchellI don't know. Do you know that you got 37% of the black vote in the South?
NixonIn the South, yeah. I mean, my point is, my point is, I'm not against
NixonI don't think getting up and rip-roaring around and demagoguing these white liberals is going to help us with the southern black. I'll bet you those 37% in the South wouldn't be happy with this decision either.
NixonDo you know what integration is doing? It's destroying the black colleges because the black, the good black kids and the good black teachers are going north.
NixonIt's destroying that. It's destroying the black schools.
NixonAnd, look, black teachers are not capable of teaching, a lot of them, the whites, they're not up to it. And they're not going to be for 25 years, maybe 50.
NixonI believe that. So what the hell is happening is the blacks need a separate society for a little more time. Gradually, you know, working it in.
NixonSo I'm telling you, I'm not I'm not one of those rip-roaring around with this thing and, God damn it, I don't want to do it.
NixonAnd I want that, Bob, if that comes up in staff meeting in the morning, you stomp on it, that it's not my view. Just say that we are going to, we've got to go straight down the line, we're going to carry out the law, but we are not going to go beyond the law.
UnknownAll right, I asked him to call, see if you can step in for a second, please.
Also recorded on April 20, 1971
002-008 3:47 PM · 1 min — President Richard M. Nixon and John B. Connally talked on the telephone from 3:47 pm to 3:48 pm.
002-009 3:48 PM · 5 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 3:48 pm and 3:54 pm.
002-010 3:54 PM · 47 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and James D. ("Don") Hughes talked on the telephone from 3:54 pm to 3:55 pm.
002-011 3:55 PM · 3 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 3:55 pm and 4:04 pm.
002-012 4:04 PM · 3 min — President Richard M. Nixon and George H. Mahon talked on the telephone from 4:04 pm to 4:07 pm.
483-018 4:10 PM · 9 min — President Richard M. Nixon, Rose Mary Woods, Ronald L. Ziegler, Fred Maroon, Manolo Sanchez, unknown person(s), and H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman met in the Oval Office of the White House from 4:10 pm to 4:19 pm.
002-013 4:42 PM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and the White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 4:42 pm and 4:59 pm.
002-014 4:59 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon, John N. Mitchell, and Sue Morrison talked on the telephone from 4:59 pm to 5:01 pm.
Conversation 483-019, April 20, 1971. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives (NAID 417176653). Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/483-019 (accessed November 20, 2026).