President Nixon, H.R. Haldeman, and Alexander Haig discussed the Watergate investigation, focusing on potential CIA involvement, the role of various individuals like L. Patrick Gray and Vernon Walters, and the implications of their testimony and memoranda. They strategized on how to present their accounts, particularly concerning meetings with Walters and Helms, and the nature of any discussions about limiting the investigation or providing cover stories. The conversation also touched upon executive privilege, the release of documents, and the broader implications of the unfolding scandal for national security and the administration.
On May 11, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, Alexander M. Haig, Jr., and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House from 12:53 pm to 2:02 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 916-019 of the White House Tapes.
Nixon Library Finding Aid
Conversation No. 916-19
Date: May 11, 1973
Time: 12:53 pm - 2:02 pm
Location: Oval Office
The President met with H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman.
Watergate
-Haldeman’s meeting with J. Fred Buzhardt, Jr.
-62-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-Alexander M. Haig, Jr.
-Wiretaps
-Haig’s role
-Lt. Gen. Vernon A. Walters
-Memoranda of conversations [Memcons]
-Meeting with Haldeman, John D. Ehrlichman and Richard M. Helms
-Meetings with John W. Dean, III
-Buzhardt
-Wiretaps
-W. Matthew Byrne
-Morton Halperin
-Effect on job
-Walters
-Dr. James R. Schlesinger’s orders
-Henry E. Petersen
-Meeting with L[ouis] Patrick Gray concerning Central Intelligence Agency
[CIA] involvement
-Meeting with Helms, Ehrlichman and Haldeman
-Helms’s conversation with Gray
-CIA involvement
-Memcons
-Location
-Meeting among Helms, Ehrlichman, Haldeman and Dean
-Walters’s possible actions
-Haldeman’s and Ehrlichman’s possible testimony
-E. Howard Hunt, Jr.’s activities
-Haldeman’s and Ehrlichman’s conversation with Walters
-Gray
-Walters
Show the rest of the log (373 more lines)
-Memcons
*****************************************************************
BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 1
[National security]
[Duration: 7 s ]
-63-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
SOURCES
END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 1
*****************************************************************
Watergate
-Possible testimony
-Conversation with Gray
-Memcons
-Dean’s actions
-President’s conversation with Haig
-Haldeman’s conversation with Helms, Walters and Ehrlichman
-Watergate burglars
-Bay of Pigs
-Hunt and G[eorge] Gordon Liddy
-Possible testimony by Ehrlichman and Haldeman
-Walters
-Memcons
-Possible effects
-Haldeman’s conversation with Helms, Walters and Ehrlichman
-President’s order
-Bay of Pigs
-Helms’s concerns
-Walters’s possible conversation with Gray
-Walters
-Memcons
-Possible effect
-Ehrlichman
-Ehrlichman’s possible testimony
-Effects
-Pentagon Papers, plumbers, wiretapping of newsman
-Kissinger
-64-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-Possible release of information to Byrne
-Ellsberg
-Buzhardt’s previous meeting with Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Wiretaps
-Ehrlichman, Henry A. Kissinger and Haldeman
-J. Edgar Hoover
-Wiretaps
-News article
-Ehrlichman’s possible testimony
-President’s orders regarding Walters and Gray
-Executive privilege
-Dean
-Role
-President’s orders regarding Walters and Helms
-Bay of Pigs
-President’s meeting with Helms
-Haldeman’s meeting with Ehrlichman, Helms and Walters
-Ehrlichman’s role
-Facts compared to implications
-Haldeman’s meeting with Helms, Walters and Ehrlichman
-Haldeman’s motives
-Dean
-Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI]
-Walters’s memcon
-Helms’s possible testimony
The President talked with Haig at an unknown time between 12:53 pm and 1:20 pm.
[Conversation No. 916-19A]
[Begin telephone conversation]
Memcons
-Request for delivery to Oval Office
[End telephone conversation]
-65-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
Watergate
-Previous telephone call with Haig
-Memcons from Buzhardt
-Presidential papers
-National security
-W. Mark Felt
-Haig, Ruckelshaus
-New York Times
-Wiretap of Ellsberg
-Time Magazine
-Stanton, Smith [?]
-William C. Sullivan
-Tom C. Huston
-President’s meeting with Haldeman
-Lincoln Room
-Breadth of investigation
-Egil (“Bud”) Krogh, Jr.
-Robert L. Vesco
-John N. Mitchell and Maurice H. Stans
-Stans
-Mitchell
-Grand Jury
-Ehrlichman’s possible testimony
-Walters’s memcons
-Ehrlichman’s possible testimony
-Fake cover for CIA
-Gray
-Haldeman’s meeting with Ehrlichman, Helms and Walters
-Motives
-President’s order
-Ehrlichman’s role
-Daniel Ellsberg
-Gen. Robert E. Cushman and Schlesinger
-Affidavit regarding call from Ehrlichman, July 7, 1972
-Meeting with Ehrlichman regarding July 7, 1972 telephone call
-Request for memo
-Affidavit
-66-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-Ehrlichman’s testimony
-Possible testimony regarding President and Haldeman
-Myths compared to facts
-Ervin Committee hearings
An unknown person talked with the President at 1:20 pm.
[Conversation No. 916-19B]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[No discernable topic]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Walters’s memos
-President’s viewing
Haig entered at 1:20 pm.
Watergate
-Walters’s memcons
-Meeting with Helms, Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Dean
-Dean
-President’s role
-Orders to Haldeman and Ehrlichman regarding Helms and Walters
-Motives
-President’s meeting with Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Ehrlichman’s office
-President’s knowledge
-Haldeman’s knowledge
-Walters’s meetings
-Dean and Helms
-President’s orders to Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-CIA
-67-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-Bay of Pigs
-President’s meeting with Helms
-CIA involvement
-Walters’s meetings
-Haldeman, Ehrlichman and Helms
-Gray
-Dean
-Authorization
-Memcons
-Gray
-Telephone call from the President
-Gray
-Testimony, May 10
-Conversation with the President
-President’s call concerning FBI’s prevention of San Francisco hijacking
-Walters’s memcons
-Meeting with Haldeman, Ehrlichman and Helms
-Haldeman’s statements
-Gray
-CIA
-Bay of Pigs
-Hunt and Liddy
-Pentagon Papers
-Meeting with Gray
-June 23, 1972 and July 6, 1972
-June 23, 1972
-CIA
-Mexican bank connection
-Kenneth Dahlberg
-Gray’s possible meeting with Dean
-Motives behind Haldeman’s and Ehrlichman’s meeting with Helms and Walters
-Hunt and Liddy
-Walters’s meetings with Gray
-Dean
-Dean
-Role
-Contacts with CIA
-68-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-Haldeman’s knowledge
-Timing
-Hunt
-Hunt
-Involvement
-Walters
-Memcons
-Executive privilege
-National security
-Location of copies
-Schlesinger, William E. Colby’s awareness
-Schlesinger’s order
-Elliot L. Richardson
-Haig’s telephone call to Schlesinger
-Haldeman’s forthcoming meeting with Buzhardt
-Colby
-Richardson
-Executive privilege
-Leonard Garment’s approach
-Dean
-Schlesinger, Colby
-Buzhardt’s possible call to Colby
-National security, executive privilege
-Watergate contrasted with memo in Ellsberg case
-Executive privilege
-Haldeman’s lawyers’ view
-Walters’s memcons
-Richardson
-Walters’s possible testimony
-National security
-Individuals with knowledge
-Walters’s possible testimony
-Walters’s memcons
-69-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
*****************************************************************
BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
[National security]
[Duration: 10 s ]
CHILE
END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 2
*****************************************************************
Watergate
-Walter’s memcons
-Hunt and James W. McCord
-Buzhardt’s view
-Innuendo
-Buzhardt’s meeting with Walters
-Gray
-Grand Jury testimony regarding CIA
-President’s order
-Walters’s memcon
-President’s conversation with Gray
-Walters’s possible testimony
-Walters
-President’s role
-Conversation with Gray
-Concern regarding CIA
-Buzhardt’s view
-Conversation withGray
-Walters’s memcon, July 13, 1972
-Dean
-Haldeman and Ehrlichman
-Walters
-70-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-Possible testimony
-Possible conversations
-Richardson, Colby, and Schlesinger
-Attitude toward the President
-Dean
-Haig’s conversation with Schlesinger
-Helms
-Possible testimony
-Conversation with Haldeman
-Meeting concerning CIA involvement
-Conversation with the President concerning CIA involvement
-White House reaction
-CIA involvement
-Cubans
-Walters
-Possible testimony
-Location
-Possible conversation with the President
Haig left at 1:55 pm.
Watergate
-Ehrlichman
-Dean
-Role
-Colby’s belief
-White House reaction
-CIA
-Hunt
-Gray
-Meeting with the President
-Walters
-Value of possible testimony
-Indictments of Mitchell and Maurice H. Stans
-Perjury
-White House response
-Goals of the President’s opponents
-71-
NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM
Conversation No. 916-19 (cont’d)
-President’s principles
-Ellsberg
-New York Times
-Ervin Committee hearings
-Haldeman’s forthcoming meeting with FBI
-Walters’s memcons
-James R. (“Jimmy”) Hoffa
-President’s role in clemency
-Recommended by Justice Department
-Dean’s possible statements
-Subpoena to Haldeman
-Federal Court, Illinois
-Dorothy Hunt’s plane crash
Haig talked with the President between 2:00 pm and 2:01 pm.
[Conversation No. 916-19C]
[Begin telephone conversation]
[See Conversation No. 46-3]
[End telephone conversation]
Watergate
-Haldeman’s mood
The President and Haldeman left at 2:02 pm.
Transcript (AI-generated)
This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.
NixonHold on. On the second on the situation, let me say first of all that Buzhardt thinks Trust him completely. He's all right, in my not- He's on our side here. On this.
NixonAnd I think that we might very well consider very well consider,
NixonI mean, because of the of that- Because it's only one memorandum in there. Buzhardt says, "Why don't we" In his sense, is, "Give that to them and say, 'Look,'" and give it to Byrne. Say, "This is national security, but here it is.
NixonSo he knows what- It was long before the Pentagon thing, and it resulted in the discharge of the employee involved."
NixonHe was transferred away from that post as a result. So I- And that's part of it. I'm not concerned about that. That's part of our defense. Morton Halperin's suit's over. Okay, you're concerned about the part of the And now, here's the thing Here's the thing now.
NixonThey have uh, they have uh, Schlesinger has called Walters back from France so that he would be available. The successor is now appointed,
Nixonof of the a of a testimony, apparently, from from Gray to the effect that Gray called, or said that he was told by Walters.
NixonIn fact, that Walter- There was a discussion between Walters and Gray about possible CIA cover and/or involvement in this matter.
HaldemanThe question was raised, "Was there any?" At least, that's what I was told by Helms.
HaldemanEhrlichman and I had met with Helms and and Walters Yeah. one morning, up in John's office.
HaldemanHelms, at that meeting, said that Gray had contacted him Right. Yeah. or the day or two preceding or something Yeah. to question whether there had been any CIA involvement, whether the CIA was in this, because there were some leads that looked like it was.
NixonAnd then Helms had told him, "No, it was not."
HaldemanYeah. Well, here's how the story is unfolding.
NixonFirst, Walters has several memcons that he's made. Fortunately,
NixonPetersen, Gray's lawyer, brought them back and they are in the White House at the present time, including a memcon of a meeting where Helms and I, Dean was present. Helms, you,
Nixonthe the uh the discussion was, or or the general discussion was to the effect that Walters ought to do what he could
Nixonto uh that that that that that that there were that that this Watergate is getting out of hand, effect,
Nixonand that Walters do what he can with uh Gray to uh because of a possible CIA
Nixonembarrassment and/or involvement. Now that, the main thing I want to tell you, I want to talk to you about is this, so that we so as to be sure that when, as in, you know, when you and John will be asked about it, so far
Nixonthat you will that John and you, I'm not concerned about you, will be on track in terms of what the story really is.
NixonThe story is that they that Hunt had been with the CIA. Our story is that he had been in some national security work. Right. The story is, you didn't know the situation, isn't that why you asked this guy in?
NixonAnd that nobody ever suggested to Walters that Walters should uh should uh uh basically put up a cover story that it was a CIA business.
NixonThey had get Gray to to go along those lines. See, the Gray line is,
Nixonthis is confidential, a little on that line. Now, Walters is like a rock. Walters, God is damning. He would he would say, "I can't reveal it."
NixonBut he has his diary. He has photographic memory, which he will use, but each of them is necessary. Walters is going to say that
Nixonwhat happened was that he met here, that he was asked to talk to Gray, and he did talk to Gray about this matter and determined there was no CIA involvement,
Nixonand however, that that he has other memcons where, and most of which are Dean, harping at over and over and over again, "Goddamnit, you got to do something about getting CIA cover for this thing."
NixonNow, as I told Al, this again burns up the Dean thing.
NixonAnd the the point that I made, I said that I always said that I wonder whether this would Walters memcons, we're not going to get out. It's confidential, Al's sitting on that, Petersen.
NixonUh The uh what I mean the uh the uh problem is that,
Nixonthat may uh uh uh and then I'm not sure if you'll be asked about it, but you might be because basically he's Walters is uh oh he's so, he's so, but the fight is-
HaldemanWell, what did you do about Helms, then? Yeah, but Helms,
NixonHelms, your conversation with Helms was uh there was a conversation with him, and what did that-
HaldemanI don't I don't think I had a conversation with Walters, Yeah. other than that one with- What What was your conversation with Helms about? It was about the problem of these people being
Haldemanformer CIA people, the question of whether there was any CIA involvement. We didn't know.
Nixonand that you were asking him that question, and we're raising a problem, we're raising fond questions.
Haldemanand say, "We were raising a concern, I forget why, the Bay of Pigs came into it. And it was a concern of of uh making the point to Helms that if, if this if these people are drawn out"--
HaldemanAnd see, we had concerned at that time, that Helms, that Hunt and Liddy, and well Liddy not so much, right, but Hunt that were all connected with the Bay of Pigs, right?
NixonThat is right, they urged. Well, John, just be sure that you and John talk exactly that way.
NixonIt would be accurate. Now, let me tell you the reason why. Some of it, he says, well, Al has looked at it. Al believes that some of it would be damaging. He says not the President, because Walters, Walters said,
Nixon"He always asked what does the President approve of this? And I didn't want you to do this, and he couldn't get anything in writing from Dean on that."
NixonThank God! Nobody, I don't care about Walters' stuff with Dean, because I don't know what Dean was up to, and I know that Walters, the meeting with Walters and Helms, and me, and John Ehrlichman, would be the only one I'd be concerned about, because of Helms,
Nixonand how-- whether he would distort that somewhat.
HaldemanBecause that meeting was so clearly expressed correct.
HaldemanFor the purpose of uh of ascertaining the problems involved in it. In that these were Bay of Pigs characters, it was concern about the Bay of Pigs coming out. You told us, you know, "Get get in touch about this problem, because Helms--"
HaldemanI think you had seen always that I didn't know about that Helms was concerned about some Bay of Pigs stuff at that point, you know. Because Helms blushed at that meeting
Haldemanand said, "Well, oh, we have no concern about the Bay of Pigs, it doesn't matter what comes out," or something.
NixonThat's the part I remember clearly is is that the Bay of Pigs Well, I remember saying, "There are CIA people, and just forget them," and, "That's how I wish to keep them." But, well, that doesn't bother me. The only thing that bothered me is if we, if Walters were told to go over to Gray and say, "Look, cool your investigation, and that here's a problem, that here's a problem of a menkind, so you understand.
NixonAnd I can like it, and I'm sure you do. The problem with menkind does not involve you,
Nixonbut it does potentially involve John, according to according to Al. Now, Al should not talk to anybody, for the reason that it makes it appear-- it could make it appear
Nixonto talk to Gray to, basically, make it appear more like that it was more of an actual uh uh of a CIA and then uh that kind of a thing. Now, my point is John's story should be, certainly, and I hope you talk to John,
NixonJohn's story is should be, certainly, John should say his only concern was the whole CIA involvement, and so forth, and wanted to be sure that the, this investigation of Watergate, didn't get out of, as he put it, "didn't get out of hand." John used that term in his early conversation, "didn't get out of hand."
HaldemanWell, get in, get out of hand. Getting out of hand had nothing to do with with uh apprehending the Watergate criminals and and trying them. Getting out of hand had to do with exactly what has now happened. Which is unloading all this Pentagon Papers, track application type stuff, the leak, the plumbers operation type stuff,
Haldemanthe uh uh again uh, wiretapping of the reporters and and staff members type stuff, and we've still got another one, as we know, that that I think we've got to figure that one is going to come out anyway.
NixonI will, whatever is said will be what best. On a selective basis,
Nixonuh I'd rather think, you know, I mean I've been intrigued, thing back to our first subject, I've been intrigued by the idea of letting them, letting the goddamn judge have that those memoranda.
HaldemanI insisted, and John agreed with that, Buzhardt raised that without John and I just met with Buzhardt.
HaldemanAnd Buzhardt raised that with us, and uh uh Now, Buzhardt is under a a misunderstanding as to how that all worked. He thought John was the principal in that bugging operation.
HaldemanAnd as you probably recall, John had nothing to do with that. I don't know that he even knew about it. Yeah, I guess he did because he saw some of the output, once in a while. But that was basically Henry, and then it shifted to me.
HaldemanBecause it involved Henry's staff, and Hoover, who didn't want to talk to anybody at that point. He said, "I don't want to talk to anybody else. Why don't you talk to youth?" And then that shifted to John.
NixonAll right, so that we got a fight for that, and we're going to be on the offensive on it. Let me say, I'm not I'm not that he says I'm not pessimistic about this one.
HaldemanYeah, that that there, I don't know if you read this Sunday paper, but there's a London one, the London paper says that some guy, right, and uh Levin, or some guy, I don't know, and he says uh, he says, "What the hell is wrong with the United States government trying to protect leaks to their secrets?"
Haldeman"That's perfectly legitimate, they did it."
NixonI I think this thing, in connection, I think, what we're sure,
Nixonthat John doesn't indicate that the President directed him to get Walters to get Gray to turn this off. In the first place, that wasn't true. First, he wasn't trying to do that.
NixonI hate it this way. In this particular case, I think the more, you know, that we talk about it, the thing we talked about the other night, you talk about yesterday, it seems to me that, more and more, Dean grew through the heights.
NixonFrankly, is concocting a whole goddamned story. It's astonishing that we weren't, I mean, a lot of that happened, apparently.
NixonWell, that's true, who knew what he was doing though, you know? But, in the, what did Walters remember, I suggested getting in Walters, that's true.
HaldemanBecause Helms told me he said there is no problem on this.
NixonOh, I told you that we did it just straight straight out on this thing, and he assured me there was no problem on that then.
HaldemanIn that meeting that we had with Helms present and Walters,
HaldemanEhrlichman did virtually all the talking. So whatever Walters says would have been in the memcon, would have would basically have been John. I don't think I said much.
NixonThat's right, John did it. There's nothing on this, Bob. Let me say, there's nothing on you on this.
HaldemanWell, I'm not That's not my concern. My My concern is how we deal with the implications of each of these. See, I don't worry about I don't worry about the facts in this. I'm worried about the implications in each one of them, because that's what they drive on. They don't pay any attention to the facts, you know.
HaldemanThe implication of oh, go The very meeting itself poses poses the problem obviously.
HaldemanBut it's a perfectly rationalized problem. What the hell! It looked like, and the FBI We were told, I was told by Dean,
HaldemanAnd so we were trying to find out, and that was one of the points we were wanting, because if it was a CIA operation, that was another factor.
HaldemanOr if there were CIA involvements to it, which was another possibility. That was the
NixonAnd by the way, [unintelligible] the only implication that could be bad here would would be the implication on the part of Walters to the effect that uh
HaldemanThat's why I sure would like to look at that memcon if I can, and like to see what he implies.
NixonSchlesinger has seen that memcon. I'll bet Helms made it.
HaldemanNow that shouldn't be much of a problem. I don't see why there is any problem. It gives the FBI
HaldemanWhere did that go? I can't even tell you how that paper seemed to be, I've had all kinds of thoughts, but that puts the that's one national security item. What awful we say then, on account of national security things,
NixonAnd he's the one who leaked it to the New York Times the fact that there was this uh this this this earlier fucking developed, for whatever that is. He's furious because he was not made director.
HaldemanAnd that's why this is going to be so special.
NixonNevertheless, this would come I mean, he's a tracker of uh of uh
NixonWatergate and all the rest. It's probably kill Sullivan. Sullivan can't be director.
NixonSullivan can't be, according to Haig, Sullivan is wrong.
HaldemanHe's emotional? He's emotional right now, or is he emotional?
NixonI mean he's he's a he's a You serve a copy of that?
NixonWell, I think you took a chance [unintelligible].
NixonIt's just it was good to talk to you. Now we we have no choice, and I don't mind the choice, as if they are to fight like hell. We're We're right, and we're not going to allow this, damn it. We can't We can't.
HaldemanCan't let them, for all of this press bleeding as well. You know, this is the worst scandal in history and all that kind of crap. It isn't the worst scandal, is it? It is really a scandal.
NixonIt's broader and not deeper. Because the act,
Haldemanit's broader because because it's unraveling into these are unrelated things, really. Like Krogh's operation, they tie that into Watergate. What the fucking thing to do with Watergate, extraneous.
HaldemanAnd if they if he is, he'll he'll he'll come out of that all right, because when he goes to trial, you have to have some faith, as Maury said last night, and I'm sure he means it. He has faith in God, he has faith in American judicial system,
Haldemanand that when he has the opportunity to defend himself, which you don't. The grand jury is a terrible you know, it's a valuable instrument obviously in bringing criminals to to account.
HaldemanBut it's a terrible, frightening thing, because you go into a big dark room, with these these hostile people in there, and this merciless prosecutor,
Haldemanand they tear you up, and you have can you have no lawyer there. You're all alone, and you feel like a like a bull at a bullfight,
Haldemanand where everybody's sticking pic-s in you, and everybody in the gallery's cheering.
HaldemanAnd uh, there's nobody there on your side. And your your accusers aren't there. You don't know what you're being accused of.
NixonNow let's be sure that John, in anything that he says when he goes from time to time, I don't mean his case, but particularly
Nixonour case with these terrible, terribly delicate facts, whatever's in his memcon uh indicating that we were uh in memcon something that could [unintelligible] in church,
HaldemanI think that John raised the question of whether there was a CIA involvement, whether this whole running unraveling this did pose a problem for the CIA, and that it did pose and he was thinking of the Pentagon Papers stuff. I'm sure of the other antics. And I was concerned about it.
NixonThat's right, and the [unintelligible] antics.
Haldeman"That the FBI apparently has a feeling that there's a CIA factor in this, or that the CIA's involved in this.
Haldemanuh if there are problems here, they're going to unravel CIA stuff, that I think it was directed to the idea of limiting the investigation to the Watergate, yeah, and avoiding getting the thing going beyond Watergate into other activities of these principles.
HaldemanAnd that was a matter of concern. And I think we've got to admit that it was. I don't think we can pretend it was.
NixonCertainly it was. Oh no, no, no. It was legitimately,
Haldemanand I think we can show that it has undone, and it's been damaging that it has.
NixonSure, that that it's gotten into these things. Hunt running Ellsberg. That's right, for one thing. Even though the CIA
HaldemanThen the other thing, then you've got a strange thing there with Bob Cushman, too, that we saw Schlesinger about when we were walking over to the Bazaar. And he says Cushman today, filed this morning, affidavit,
Haldemanthat says that Ehrlichman called him on July 7th and told him to provide uh CIA support for Hunt and Liddy, whatever it was.
HaldemanAnd uh Ehrlichman says he did not make that call. And then when when Cushman first recalled that Ehrlichman did, Ehrlichman talked to him and said, "Bob, I didn't make that call." And Bob said, "Well, somebody from the White House did. I thought it was you, but it was you or Dean or somebody who called me."
HaldemanAnd that was the way that was left, and then John said, "Well, I would like a memorandum from you to that effect, because it's it's you know, and there's there's a thing now saying that that uh uh"
HaldemanAnd so Cushman wrote him, as I understand from John, that says, "I did not I do not recall that it was you who called me. I know that there was a phone call."
HaldemanNow, he's today filed a sworn affidavit saying it was Ehrlichman who called him.
NixonWell, of course, was got that John probably approved Hunt being hired, Ehrlichman did.
HaldemanAnd that whether the follow-up, again, it's a small-pitiable thing, but well, at one point they were saying maybe Hunt called and said Ehrlichman wants wants this given to me, or something like that.
HaldemanAnd that could very well happen, without Ehrlichman knowing it.
HaldemanThat's the problem we've got here, in all of this, and it's a problem I'm sure is going to come to haunt me when when I get into this. It's where a lot of people are going to say, "Well, I was told Haldeman wanted this done, or I was told Colson, you know."
HaldemanAnd people talk about it as if they heard it from me.
NixonGo, guys down the line used big names in order to get their, yeah, orders carried out.
HaldemanRight. That's haunting. Uh that's happened, and that's very hard to defend against. You can't-
NixonI know. I know. It would sound as if, well, that's not- And you get through credibly. That's right. And by golly, that's why, in my mind, I'm almost bound to think the all the problems with the hearing and folly, we may be better off in the hearing than the court.
HaldemanI tend to agree, and I'm frankly, I'm not worried about the hearing.
HaldemanThe hearing is tough. I think, look, the myth, little guy's smart cracks, as we said all along, the myth that's held in people's minds about all this is much worse than the fact. And the hearing is, will, I think, be show much more the fact.
NixonI was only interested in one had to do with uh you know, with the
HaldemanOf course, he thought it was a meeting with Helms. You're talking about that. Yeah. It should be a meeting with Helms and with Dean was not there, he's telling.
NixonSee, did you you imagine to me that Dean was in. I told you I know Dean had a separate contact with Dean. Dean will blow it up. He'll say I was with Dean when they [crosstalk] in with the CIA and so on.
NixonHere, this is In other words, I don't want to read it, but I just want to be sure that uh Bob knows uh uh Just just take the second, you don't mind. I won't listen. Let me say my purpose, my purpose here is, all of you get the facts, so you got the facts, and uh
Nixontake it, please. I don't need the end of it. Here is the facts, which are basically, I,
Nixonwhen I heard, uh at one point, when I was informed of this thing afterward, that the CIA was involved, I told uh
Nixoncheck Bob to meet with Helms and Walters, and find out what the Is that true?
HaldemanYes, sir. That's that's exactly the way it should be. You told John and me,
NixonAnd I remember I said, "Yes." I said, "Find out what the hell the story is." Because we didn't know. We didn't know, and I said maybe Chrysler, that we're getting a bad rap
Haldemanto meet. And you remember you called me into John's office,
Nixonbecause he's cover us so far. We didn't know. Believe me, that's how how unknowledgeable. And I don't think you knew.
HaldemanAnd as I said, there was something You hold Helms in, and Helms Helms took That's how this This is the meeting, you know, when you just you just mentioned that you weren't sure. So, I was trying to I thought you said there was a meeting with in which Walters, Dean,
NixonDean was not in. That would be serious, because that'd look like I ordered Walters, my old friend, order to do some cover up work on Dean. That was [crosstalk] You think I want
NixonAnd that's what I said. And I said to them, "Find out what the hell. This is a situation here."
HaldemanI said, and the and the because if the CIA is involved, or CIA people are involved, we don't want the CIA to be pulled in to this Watergate bug.
NixonRight. Now, that basically is where Is that approximately what your recollection is of what I said, or what?
HaldemanYes, and there was, as I mentioned, there was there was a In the back of my mind, there's a Bay of Pigs connection in this.
NixonYeah, well, that's what, the reason was, that, see, I also said, "I understand that Hunt and the five people were all in the Bay of Pigs. And so, therefore, they ought to get in and find out."
HaldemanAnd we were concerned about raising And we raised the point, I think, in this you can say it, to Helms, about the Bay of Pigs.
NixonThat it'd blow it'd blow it up. [chuckles] Blow this result of these guys. All right, now that's my recollection, too. Okay.
HaldemanAnd later on, Helms told me here's that very cryptic comment after a meeting. He says, "I checked this whole Watergate thing and the CIA had no problem in it." Period.
HaldemanSo that's what that's that's what that is, basically.
NixonWell, I just whether anything later uh is no. There's what I just wanted to be sure to know how the meeting came about. Well, that's just the fact.
HaldemanSee, the way the way it's described, it would seem to me that I know what you did the framing. It was a meeting where Bob and John called up Walters and said, "Come over here. We're going to concoct a story to go over to you know, to get Gray to get the hell off the trail, and stick this with the CIA." That was not-
NixonNo, no, no, no, and that's not the conversation in that meeting either, isn't it? But the subsequent discussions with Dean are very clear on that.
HaldemanUh does Dean imply that he's acting on anybody else's direction?
HaldemanBecause I don't think that I had any knowledge that Walters had any dealings, or that Dean was having any dealings with Walters. I thought the only
NixonYou ought You ought to look at them, Bob. The hell That's the best way to do it. You can get a feel for it.
HaldemanWell, I don't think you Does it mean you read that the Dean almost-
NixonAnd he expressed his concern about it. And I told him I told him to go ahead and carry on the investigation. Does the hearsay carry that out to the end, or not?
NixonSee Gray can't claim, now, that he was restricted in this investigation, because I talked to him and told him on the 5th of July, I think it was.
NixonHe said that he was, "Some of your boys were using the were doing some service to the President." And I said, "Go right ahead and, you know, carry on your investigation and all the good."
NixonWell, I can't believe Gray, good God Almighty.
NixonAfter what the hell I went through for him, for that poor double son-of-a-bitch.
NixonWhatever, misrepresent, now, what I said to him.
NixonHe raised a point about this whole CIA crap, and he And I said
NixonHe was worried about this this whole about the investigation, and I said, "Pat, you go ahead and do it." I mean, I didn't know what the hell it was all about.
NixonNow, what's that say? He was instructed by me to talk with Gray?
NixonTelling him the investigation not be pushed further.
NixonHe gives a whole lead-in, and it says: "Haldeman said the whole affair was getting embarrassing and that it was the President's wish that Walters call on Acting FBI Director L. Patrick Gray and suggest to him that since five suspects have been arrested, this should be sufficient, and it was not advantageous to have the inquiry pushed, especially in Mexico, etc.
Nixon"Director Helms said he had talked to Gray on previous day and made quite clear to him agency was not involved in this matter, and he had told Gray that none of his investigations touch on the covert activities. Haldeman then stated that I could tell Gray that I had talked to the White House and suggest that the investigation not be pushed further."
NixonNow, Haldeman's talking to Gray, is that Haldeman?
Nixon"Haldeman stated that I, Walters, could tell Gray that I, Walters, had talked to the White House and suggest that the investigation not be pushed further. Gray would be receptive as he was looking for guidance." Now, that I remember.
NixonThat Gray had had raised the question here or we had been told
Nixonthat Gray had raised the question how, you know, where was he supposed to push it in this?
NixonGo ahead. "Director then repeated the agency was unconnected with the matter. I agreed to talk to Gray as directed. Ehrlichman implied I could do this soon, and I said I would try to do it today. On arriving at the White House, they discussed the matter briefly with the director. Returning to the office, I called Gray, indicated a matter of some urgency. He agreed to see me at 14:30 that day." Is there a Is there a June 23rd 14:30 meeting with Gray?
NixonDoes that then tell you what Gray would say that Walters got out of that meeting?
NixonOkay, perfect. "While a further investigation of the Watergate affair had not touched any current or ongoing covert projects of the agency, its continuation might lead to some projects.
Nixon"I recalled the FBI and the agency had an agreement in this respect. It was suggested to Gray was aware of this and understood, as we made his problem was how to low-key the matter now it was launched. He said a lot of money was involved, matter of check on a Mexican bank for 100,000 made through to a DA in Washington. Gray said this was the most abortive blunder and watch and see what he could do, but repeated investigations if were pushed south of the border, could trespass on some of our covert projects.
Nixon"In view of the fact, five men involved were arrested, it would be best to taper the matter off there. And we parted, and it seemed to him that they had to he would have to talk to John Dean about it."
NixonGray said, "we look forward to cooperating closely."
NixonGray said he would have to talk to John Dean about it.
NixonSee this is where you get into the implications, again.
NixonYou'll get one hell of a mess on what it implies, even though what's there is no promise.
NixonNow what this There's no question we were concerned about this this investigation going beyond Watergate.
NixonUh now, what what this did so that so that you get this in Gray, I mean, they are
NixonWalters Walters and Helms were called in for the purpose of seeing that the investigation
Nixonuh dealt with the Watergate, but did not get into covert operations of the CIA,
Nixonother covert operations. I didn't None of us knew what the hell they were. That basically what the what the thing is.
NixonThat, plus we did know, I didn't know in any specific that here was this project with Hunt working in the in the leak business, the Plumbers operation, and we didn't want him getting into that.
NixonNow, and we did want them pursuing Hunt and Liddy as they're involved in here, they had arrested them, they had them there and they had them on the on the thing. How many did they have then?
HaldemanYou see, now, Walters, in his discussions with Gray,
Haldemanuh, keeps hitting upon the fact that some middle-level White House guy, he's referring, not by name, to to Dean,
HaldemanIt uh, it just absolutely, uh, really uh It makes the other history quite I I don't believe I had any knowledge
Nixonfrom Dean that he was dealing with Walters at all.
NixonI thought their only contact with the CIA, and I knew, I mean you recall when you raised this. I remember the meeting with meeting Walters and Helms.
HaldemanWell, maybe not. Had Hunt been arrested by then?
HaldemanSee Hunt wasn't arrested for later, remember? He was loose for about four weeks.
HaldemanSo this may have been when we were concerned about getting Hunt under arrest, about Hunt getting arrested, and all that. At that point we didn't know Hunt was in the Watergate, either.
HaldemanSo Walters' turn over the He'll turn over the originals uh What is he going to say he delivered them for?
HaigHe's going to say that he brought them over to the Counsel
Haigbecause there were national security issues discussed in them, covert methods and things that went way beyond this thing,
Haigand that we were were to review them for impact on the national security.
HaldemanWell, okay, but another way to get at that, whether they if they contain such things and the CIA Well, they even have them there yet for that purpose, sure.
HaldemanOn the wire Are they going to Is Elliot going to want to see the memcons at the FBI? If Colby knows there's memcons, and so forth and so on,
Haldemanis Elliot going to wind up insisting on seeing them?
HaigHe can't see them because we've got them, and we have they're under executive privilege, and they'll stay that way. That's the only thing we can do.
HaigThat's why I want to get them, uh, get the originals, and be safe.
HaldemanThat's what The point of being, for my purpose, tight on raising the privilege thing all the time is just that we can explain all those things, and we can probably
HaigWell, he has a big- a good testimony. This way, if he's damaged,
HaldemanIf you took If you took one government's approach and put all that out, we could wade through it, and, and, pull out what we need to get it untangled, but, the- in the meantime, you couldn't survive.
HaigHe's He's damaging now because of the sequence of time. First, you have a big, high-level meeting with Helms, and, and Walters, and then, suddenly, these contacts start
HaldemanAnd Dean, they'll say that he was ordered to go. Trace it. Well, there's no proof. They'll say that anyway. Well, that Well, I know, I, I know that. But, if you put it in that context-
HaldemanUnless Schlesinger Whatever Schlesinger understood, Colby has. It was up to him. His ass was up here, you know. He's-
HaigNow, I'll have Buzhardt call Colby and tell him that we are holding these memcons here.
HaldemanWait. Well, yeah, say we're holding these memcons because they do involve national security, and that we're but that we have a flat rule that that we we can't waive over on on on on this sort of-
HaigAnd that's Buzhardt's schedule, too. He just called me. He said, "We just have to hold to the executive privilege."
Haigwith the case and it's a a document which the judge has requested
HaldemanAll right. All right. All right. Now, suppose now this comes down to the Watergate trial.
HaldemanThey request documents that they think that has to do with the Watergate trial.
HaldemanThey're kind of tied, rather than being bound.
HaigWell, there we hold to what we've held uh all along.
HaldemanThe other point the lawyers make, which is you can fight, our lawyers make, and they study, and your guys, I'm sure, will, come up with the same thing, is that executive privilege is
Haldemanis a objective and selective judgment on the part of the president.
HaldemanAnd it can be made It's totally selective. It can be made paper by paper. Now obviously, you weaken your case every time you you let the bar down at all.
Haldemancauses they got the information. Because the papers have other information. He will testify totally on everything
HaldemanWe, you know, executive privilege isn't the basis you're holding, it's national security.
HaigNational security, covert actions, etc. And, and this is that. First, Buzhardt says that, by having Walters go over and say, "I'm ready to testify.
HaigHe said that he doesn't And no one knows about this except Schlesinger, Colby, and his secretary,
Haigwho typed them, who's been with him for also Paris and
HaigThey won't know about it, they probably won't even ask about it. They'll say, "Do you have written record?" He'll say, "Yes, I used my diary, and made some notes.
HaigTo the Counsel to the White House, because there were some very important national security interests. Covered covert activities that were were in the notes.
HaldemanPart of it part of it part of it. Who did? I don't I don't know who. All I think had to have stand by himself in Watergate as a cover. Must have been McCord, and in order to get a cover for to prove that everything he did with the CIA entertained or something.
HaldemanWell, now you've got you've got this set up. It's very important for all the people involved here. Buzhardt's got to realize Now, he's just read this paper, does he also talked to Walters, Buzhardt? Oh, yeah.
HaldemanSo, I don't want Buzhardt to have an implication from just reading that goddamned paper. Oh, no.
HaldemanThat what this is is a is a basically a cover-up on the part of that. That first paragraph where it says, "The President told Haldeman to get the CIA to- What did it say to do?
HaldemanTo talk to the FBI about not pursuing this further or something like that.
HaigTo talk to the FBI But Buzhardt understands that the purpose of that talk had nothing to do with not pursuing the Watergate.
HaldemanI said to this, I knew that this could not have been what it appeared to be in sequence of time, and that's why we couldn't have these papers go out. And he said, "I agreed with you." He said, "Christ, to get in the innuendo, and it's all innuendo."
NixonThat's it. And that's that's our biggest problem in this case: Every damned, every event has been goddamned implications.
HaldemanRight. And you never get a chance to give the facts. Right. And when they--
NixonAnd then they live on the implications. They foster these statements. That is the part of facts. It's the facts.
HaldemanYou see, but Buzhardt sat there and heard Walters uh, not only what he would testify and, God, I mean, it was very clear, there isn't any implication.
NixonGray, did Gray in effect just say what Gray is apparently thing we think is testified to the effect that he was warned by the CIA, was he, Helms? Uh Gray, or in the hearing, he exposed himself.
HaldemanWell, I think the only thing that Gray said uh, it's nothing to do with the meeting with I don't mean in there, I mean in the grand jury.
HaldemanI thought he said that you had discussed this with him and uh you told him to go on with the investigation.
NixonThat's someplace in there. They saw it yesterday. I don't if it came from Gray's testimony.
NixonI don't know whether he told the truth or not, but if he did, it may have I don't know whether it's the truth or not, I mean, recollection may be wrong, but I'm sure it was such a cursory conversation that I said, "Go ahead and do it."
NixonI think here isn't any question about it. This is very good, this is.
HaldemanGray advised the case could not be covered up. They were talking about the I should hope not. Right. And he can't involve the FBI or CIA in this, because it can only prove a mortal wound,
Haldemanand would achieve nothing. The President then said, "Then I should get rid of whoever is involved no matter how high." Gray replied that that was his recommendation.
HaldemanThe President then asked what I thought, and Gray said my views were the same as his. The President took it well and thanked Gray.
NixonYeah, I mean, Gray that's something that that Walters has got, a hitch. And it does damn good stuff to frankly leak out. Walters would be a much better witness than Gray.
NixonWalters is so fundamental, and he's his recollection is so sharp. So right. That's that. Can you underline that part, make sure? Marked by a paper clip. A paper clip.
NixonWell now, that does that hearten you a little about my role? I don't know if you ever doubted it.
HaldemanHell, I never doubted your role, sir, for a minute. I told Gray to get whoever it is no matter how high up. said that all the time.
NixonYou were constantly saying, why can't I Gray said, no, Christ, was like all those squirrels in the CIA, and Gray didn't bother. I thought that's why they had them all come over, Walters No question. I did it, Bob.
HaldemanThe only thing that bothers me really about the whole thing is that there are so many goddamned creeps around here that are walking around always thinking the worst, and it's all innuendo. And I'm convinced we're going to knock this ball right in, you understand?
NixonCheer up. But you, please, mark that for Buzhardt so that he's neat that way. Do I know Gray, or is he secret? Or do you think that Buzhardt needs to see some chance?
HaldemanI am not worried about Buzhardt. In fact, if you Well, I don't care about him worrying, I want him to believe.
NixonMake sure to mark that. I mean, Buzhardt needs really believe, not just because he believes because he wants to, but because I want Buzhardt, by God, to read that plan because that's something that hasn't been written lately. That's something that was written at that time. That's what, in fact, Gray said.
NixonI said, oh, sure, pick up people that fall, and that call. And watch the press on it. Be careful that we don't start hanging people by innuendo instead of Now we were worried about and be careful that we don't get swapped over into what these people were doing in national security.
HaldemanLook at this concluding statement from Walters: "I believe that in my view, the President should be protected from his self-appointed protectors," he's talking about Dean,
Haldeman"who would harm him while trying to cover up their own stances."
NixonYou're sure he's not talking about Ehrlichman and you?
NixonBecause I'm not so sure that that he didn't feel that we were acting without without authority. I don't think that. No. I don't know. That certainly doesn't apply to [unintelligible] anyway.
HaldemanWell, it was after his contacts with Dean. Dean. It's the June meetings.
NixonWalters is not saying anything bad to Ehrlichman. Or to Dean. You're early.
NixonLook. As to Walters, there's no problem there. Uh the main the main uh the main point is so that I want him to be cheered. But everything else, he's got it nailed. And now, when can he get over and I said, "Wait."
NixonNow, Walters talked with Richardson, and talked with Colby, and to and Schlesinger. Gosh, I don't Colby and Schlesinger don't have any doubt, so that's How about those two? I cannot appoint two men to the highest position in this government.
NixonAnd then, has he read this, they read these things?
HaldemanYeah, and I don't think these they've talked to Walters. I don't know how closely they've read them, but they've talked to Walters, and I'm just comforted that uh uh that there It's not you that there's any concern about.
HaldemanDean? Back to the fact, they know that Dean is up Dean, I know.
NixonThey also, on the first memorandum, President indicated that the President said, "Let's limit it," or some damn thing.
HaldemanWould be inconceivable to me. I've talked to Schlesinger every day, twice, three, four times a day.
HaldemanHe hasn't ever had a conception of everything.
NixonNo, I don't think so. That's, after seeing these memorandums, he has such a conception.
HaldemanHe saw them some time ago, for instance. Some time ago, yeah.
HaldemanMatter of fact, he's the one that, when Walters came out yesterday and praised him, when he brought Walters back.
NixonDoes that bring Helms back, too, then? All day.
NixonHelms That's what I was concerned about there, is what Helms will say. Helms wouldn't be capable of putting a twist on it, I suppose. Helms is malicious, but if I Helms, then he interests me. What if I call Helms,
HaldemanHelms have to be malicious to put a bad twist on it. If if he if he [crosstalk] tells the truth.
NixonThe truth. I don't think Helms is a bastard. I think that he would not do anything to harm the President, I know. He knows damn well that I didn't uh I couldn't.
HaldemanNo, you treated him very decently, and he felt that. He He told me that other times how much he appreciated the way the whole thing was handled.
NixonI asked them it's clear from that Memcon that that that I had asked them, had directed that they get together with them for the purpose to see what the what the CIA, or what did the CIA or, I don't know.
HaldemanIt's not that clear, but it isn't that It doesn't suggest otherwise, either. It's uh
Haldemanand all the way they've assured me they'd say it was not an order, did not have no concern, they've said it behind--
HaldemanAt that point, hell, that was only a few week a few days after the break-in, so it was a question then, we didn't know what the hell was was the and the soot there.
HaldemanThe FBI was convinced for quite a long time.
NixonWhy, the stories in the Miami paper was about Cubans, you know, and going with this and that for personal purposes. Why, damn it, I don't support back, they have got it from there, you see.
NixonOh, but they concocted this whole thing up and did it because of their this whole alley.
NixonAnd I wondered whether this, when I read about Mexico, I thought it must be a CIA involved.
NixonGray? He can't, oh God, what the hell he's up to. Although Although, that's a very very hell to say, oh the mission, his part, right? He's a go-getter, and whoever is up at the top there,
Nixonhe can't say, on the basis of that, Walters could be a star witness in this, and that's got to leak out.
Nixon[unintelligible] Finally, what really is my, is sort of my frame of mind today, anyway, what I've just sort of,
Nixonfinally, faced up to the fact that there is nothing else to do. I don't give a damn what happens here, but fight it. This is true to the finish. I mean, they're not after the sheriff. No, they're not after you, they're not after, that sounds- pardon me, they're not after John. They took- they're not after you, John D.
NixonThe FBI is, is on this now, huh? Three different things they're after now. What are the, now,
Nixonones of that? Yeah. Well, what did they do to be on Hoffa then? What'd they talk to you about Hoffa?
HaldemanOh, they inquired, what do they, in the Hoffa thing, oh, about a pardon?
HaldemanI don't, I don't know. Don't know what I did with the Hoffa,
NixonWhy, nobody ever gave him clemency. That was the recommendation of the Department of Justice, and everybody else you know, there was no goddamned question about it.
046-001 12:03 PM · 12 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 12:03 pm and 12:07 pm.
916-015 12:03 PM · 10 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator met in the Oval Office of the White House at 12:03 pm.
916-016 12:03 PM · 36 min — President Richard M. Nixon, unknown person(s), Alexander M. Haig, Jr., and Pierre E. Trudeau met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 12:03 pm and 12:43 pm.
046-002 12:11 PM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Pierre E. Trudeau talked on the telephone from 12:11 pm to 12:13 pm.
916-017 12:44 PM · 6 min — President Richard M. Nixon, John C. Slemp, and Stephen B. Bull met in the Oval Office of the White House from 12:44 pm to 12:50 pm.
916-018 12:50 PM · 33 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 12:50 pm and 12:53 pm.
046-003 2:00 PM · 22 sec — Alexander M. Haig, Jr. and President Richard M. Nixon talked on the telephone from 2:00 pm to 2:01 pm.
916-020 2:02 PM · 1 min — United States Secret Service agents met in the Oval Office of the White House at an unknown time between 2:02 pm and 11:59 pm.
Conversation 916-019, May 11, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/916-019 (accessed November 20, 2026).