Nixon White House Tapes › Tape 428 › Conversation 428-019

Nixon, Ehrlichman & Haldeman on Watergate scandal and E. Howard Hunt testimony

Saturday, April 14, 1973 · 8:53 AM–12:30 PM ET · Old Executive Office Building · 3 hr 2 min

ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President); Ehrlichman, John D.; Richardson, Elliot L.; Bull, Stephen B.; Haldeman, H. R. ("Bob"); White House operator; Dean, John W., III; Kissinger, Henry A.; Haig, Alexander M., Jr.Conversation428-019 on Tape 428StartSaturday, April 14, 1973 at 8:53 AMEndSaturday, April 14, 1973 at 12:30 PMRecording deviceOld Executive Office BuildingSourceNixon Library record for 428-019 ↗

President Nixon met with top aides John Ehrlichman, H.R. Haldeman, John Dean, and others to discuss the escalating Watergate scandal, including potential testimony from key figures like E. Howard Hunt and the legal strategies for dealing with the Senate Watergate Committee. They also touched upon foreign policy matters, specifically the situation in Vietnam and Cambodia, and debated the best approach to manage the unfolding crisis, weighing options like cooperation with investigators versus stonewalling. The conversation revealed deep concern over the potential legal and political fallout, with a focus on damage control and preserving the presidency.

Download MP3 (part 1) · 68.2 MB ·Download MP3 (part 2) · 110.0 MB ·Download MP3 (part 3) · 110.0 MB ·Download MP3 (part 4) · 46.1 MB

On April 14, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon, John D. Ehrlichman, Elliot L. Richardson, Stephen B. Bull, H. R. ("Bob") Haldeman, White House operator, John W. Dean, III, Henry A. Kissinger, and Alexander M. Haig, Jr. met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 8:53 am to 12:30 pm. The Old Executive Office Building taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 428-019 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 428-19

Date: April 14, 1973
Time: 8:53 pm - 12:30 pm
Location: Executive Office Building

The President met with John D. Ehrlichman
                                                -16-

                    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                                 Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

      Greetings

The President talked with Elliot L. Richardson between 8:54 am and 8:56 am.

[Conversation No. 428-19A]

[Begin telephone conversation]

[See Conversation No. 38-19]

[End telephone conversation]

      Boston Navy Yard
           -Edward W. Brooke’s actions on behalf of the facility
                 -Return from trip to Vietnam
           -Voting record
                 -Peace
                 -Defense budget cuts

Stephen B. Bull entered at an unknown time after 8:56 am.

      President’s schedule
            -Alexander M. Haig, Jr. and H. R. (“Bob”) Haldeman

Bull left at an unknown time before 9:00 am.

      Base closure issue
           -Budget battle
           -Length of debate
           -Brooke
           -1972 election
           -Budget impact
Show the rest of the log (595 more lines)
Haldeman entered at 9:00 am.

[A transcript of the following portion of this conversation was initially prepared for the
                                             -17-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                              Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

Watergate Special Prosecution Force (WSPF) and can be found in Record Group (RG) 460, Box
173, pages 1-57 and 79-102 and in United States v. Mitchell, Exhibit 18. The Nixon Presidential
Materials Staff reviewed the transcript and made changes as necessary. This transcript has been
reviewed under the provisions of the Presidential Recordings and Materials Preservation Act of
1974 (PRMPA). The National Archives does not guarantee its accuracy.]

[A transcript of the following portion of this conversation was also prepared Richard Nixon’s
Special White House Counsel for Watergate Matters and submitted to the Committee on the
Judiciary of the House of Representatives. This transcript can be found in Submission of
Recorded Presidential Conversations (SRPC), pages 408-514 (1-10). Please refer to the RG 460
transcript.]

[Begin transcribed portion]

[End transcribed portion]

     John N. Mitchell
          -Relations with William P. Rogers
                -Mitchell’s view of Rogers
          -Position on Cambodia and May 8, 1972 decision in Vietnam War
                -Rogers’s alleged position
          -Reaction to Ehrlichman
                -Supreme Court nominations problems
                       -Clement F. Haynsworth, Jr., G. Harrold Carswell
                -Justice Department operations
                       -Oversight

[Resume transcribed portion]

[End transcribed portion]

     Watergate
          -Independent commission
                -John Williams
                -Howard H. Baker, Jr.
          -Congressional relations
                -May 9 dinner
                                       -18-

             NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                        Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

           -Money issue
           -Cambodia

Clark MacGregor
      -Relationship with White House
            -Attitude towards Watergate
      -Press statements
            -Watergate
                  -Effect on 1972 election
            -White House Congressional liaison job
                  -MacGregor’s opinion of Bryce N. Harlow, William E. Timmons
                        -President and Ehrlichman’s handling of Congress
                        -MacGregor’s job performance prediction

Watergate
     -Ervin Committee
           -Ronald L. Ziegler
           -White House cooperation
                  -Cover-up
     -Press relations
           -Carroll Kilpatrick [?]
                  -Richard G. Kleindienst
                         -Executive privilege
     -Ervin Committee rules
           -Negotiations with White House
                  -Executive session
                  -Henry A. Kissinger
                  -Committee’s independence
           -Possible lawsuit
                  -[First name unknown] Lipschitz [?]
                         -Samuel Dash
           -Dash, Garment
           -Test case
                  -Motion to quash
                  -Federal District Court
           -Delay of White House staff testimony
     -John N. Mitchell
                                  -19-

       NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                  Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

      -Indictment
            -Charles W. Colson, David Shapiro
            -Donald H. Segretti
            -Press
            -Ervin Committee
                   -Judge’s delay
-Ervin Committee
      -White House cooperation
            -Options
            -Mitchell’s indictment
            -White House staff testimony
            -Cover-up
            -Watergate break-in
      -Segretti
            -Dwight L. Chapin
            -Haldeman’s statement
                   -Kissinger
                   -Mitchell, E. Howard Hunt, Jr. [?]
                         -Grand Jury
                         -Press coverage
                         -Ehrlichman’s commitment to Samuel J. Ervin, Jr., Baker
-Mitchell’s indictment
      -Paul L. O-Brien
      -Earl J. Silbert
-Jeb Stuart Magruder
      -Mitchell
            -Sources of information
                   -Shapiro
                   -Dean
                   -Silbert
-New York grand jury
      -Robert L. Vesco
      -Securities and Exchange Commission [SEC]
      -Vesco’s campaign contribution
            -Maurice H. Stans
            -Mitchell
            -Harry L. Sears
                                       -20-

             NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                      Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                 -Edward C. Nixon
                 -Quid pro quo
                      -SEC violation
                      -Mitchell’s telephone call
                            -William P. Rogers

Grand juries
     -Contractor Joel Klein [?]
            -Baltimore
     -Washington, DC
     -Spiro T. Agnew’s reaction
     -Klein case
            -Committee to Re-elect the President [CRP]
                  -Regional finance chairman
                        -Jews
                        -Agnew
                        -Stans
            -Alleged cash contribution from Klein
                  -Delivery to Mitchell
                  -Alleged promise of government contract
                  -Alleged acceptance of money by Mitchell
                        -Comparison to 1968 Presidential campaign
                              -Howard Hughes
                                    -Charles G. (“Bebe”) Rebozo’s role
                        -Attorney General, campaign manager
                        -Vesco case
            -Agnew’s associate [first name unknown] Wolfe
                  -Role as aide dealing with financial matters
                        -Baltimore County Executive, governor of Maryland
                        -Cash contributions
                              -Maryland law
                              -Contractor contribution
                              -Charles McC. Mathias, Jr.
            -Meetings
                  -Contractor targeting
                        -Wolfe’s notes
            -George Beall
                                      -21-

             NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                 -US Attorney
                        -Interrogation of Wolfe
                 -J. Glenn Beall, Jr.
                 -Wolfe’s transfer of notes to his lawyer
                        -Quotes about Agnew
                        -George White
                               -Call from Wolfe’s lawyer
           -President’s opinion of governor’s role
                 -Otto Kerner
                        -Illinois
                 -William T. Cahill
           -Agnew’s request to Haldeman
                 -Call to Glenn Beall
                        -George Beall
                        -Indictments
                        -Colson’s contact with George White
                               -Outsider communication away from White House
           -Agnew’s vulnerability
                 -Beall’s possible action
                        -Maryland politics
                 -Prospects for 1976 presidential campaign
                 -Vulnerability of Republican candidates
                        -John B. Connally
                               -Possible indictment

Ervin Committee
      -Lowell P. Weicker, Jr.
           -Vulnerability
                  -Campaign contributions
                        -$65,000 [?]
                  -Timing of action
           -Possible replacement
           -Intelligence
                  -Public relations
           -Staff leaks
      -Questioning of CRP secretaries
           -Committee staff
                                              -22-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                              Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                 -Weicker’s staff
                 -Relations between the staffs
                 -Cooperation
                 -Possible call to Ervin by Ehrlichman
                       -Weicker’s investigation tactics
                             -White House’s response

[Resume transcribed portion]

The President talked with the White House operator during the transcribed portion.

[Conversation No. 428-19B]

[Begin telephone conversation]

[See Conversation No. 38-20]

[End telephone conversation]

The President talked with Stephen B. Bull between 10:49 am and 10:50 am during the
transcribed portion.

[Conversation No. 428-19C]

[Begin telephone conversation]

[See Conversation No. 38-21]

[End telephone conversation]

Ehrlichman talked with John W. Dean, III at an unknown time between 10:50 am and 11:31 am
during the transcribed portion.

[Conversation No. 428-19D]

[Begin telephone conversation]
                                           -23-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

[See Conversation No. 38-23]

[End telephone conversation]

[End transcribed portion]

     President’s schedule
           -White House Correspondents Dinner
                 -Awards for Watergate reporting
                       -Robert U. (“Bob”) Woodward and Carl Bernstein
                             -President’s reaction
                                    -Press coverage
                 -President’s remarks
                       -Length
                       -Timing
                       -Event schedule
                       -Gift presentation
                       -Press relations
                             -Watergate
                             -Legislative - executive branch relations
                                    -Role of press
                                    -Stewardship obligation
                             -Accuracy of reporting
                                    -Criticism of the executive branch
                       -Events of 1972
                             -People’s Republic of China [PRC]
                             -USSR
                             -Vietnam settlement
                             -1972 election
                       -Accomplishments of presidency
                       -Tons of future reporting
                             -Substance

Haldeman left at 11:30 am.

     Ehrlichman’s forthcoming meeting
           -Haldeman’s presence
                                              -24-

                   NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                             Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                 -Haldeman’s forthrightness
                 -Allegations
                       -Silbert

Henry A. Kissinger and Haig entered at 11:31 am.

     President’s schedule
           -Meeting

Ehrlichman left at 11:31 am.

     President’s schedule
           -News reports on alleged meeting with Kissinger

     Kissinger’s actions

     Vietnam and Southeast Asia
          -Cambodia
                -Reports of enemy action
          -Laos
                -Situation
                      -Negotiation and withdrawal of forces
                            -Violations of Vietnam settlement
          -Vietnam settlement
                -Cambodia
                -Laos
                -South Vietnam

The President talked with Bull between 11:33 am and 11:34 am.

[Conversation No. 428-19E]

[See Conversation No. 38-25]

     Vietnam settlement
          -North Vietnam’s influence
                -Laos
                                -25-

       NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                               Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

      -Cambodia
-Support for possible action
      -Washington, DC
      -Canada
-Military situation
      -Confidence of populace
      -Army of the Republic of Vietnam [ARVN]
             -Attitude
             -Readiness
             -Capabilities
                   -Unrealistic expectations
-Effectiveness
      -North Vietnam’s adherence
-North Vietnam’s treatment of Prisoners of War [POWs]
      -Torture
-Enforcement
      -Lack of authority
-Possible military action
      -Air strikes
             -Frequency
      -Mining
      -Washington Special Actions Group (WSAG )
-Reconnaissance flights
      -Rogers
      -Frequency
-US military cooperation with Kissinger
      -WSAG
      -Proposals
-Possible meeting with Rogers, Melvin R. Laird
-December 1972 bombing decision
-Possible military action
      -Congress
             -Timing of notification
             -President’s justification
                   -Khe Sanh [?]
                   -Violations of agreement
                   -Cambodia
                                 -26-

       NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                 Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                  -Laos
            -Timing of notification
      -Public reaction
            -Haig’s son
                  -Georgetown University
            -Effect
                  -National interests
                  -Polls
                  -President’s credibility in foreign policy
                         -Peace movement
                         -[Arnold] Eric Sevareid
-North Vietnam’s violations
      -Timing
            -US response
                  -Avoidance
                         -Conflict between North Vietnam and South Vietnam
-Possible military action
      -Protection of national interests
      -WSAG meeting
            -Possible reaction
                  -Comparison to Cambodia
            -Richardson
                  -Adm Thomas H. Moorer, Gen. Creighton W. Abrams, Jr.
-Durability
-Laos
-Return of Last POWs from North Vietnam
-Possible military action
      -North Vietnam’s reaction
            -Restart of war
-POWs
      -Advocacy for US
      -Event
            -Henry Birl’s brother
                  -B-52s
      -President’s meetings with POW leaders
-Possible military actions
      -North Vietnam
                                      -27-

            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                     Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                -Joint Economic Commission
                      -Delay
                      -POWs
                -Arrogance
                      -Economic aid
     -Haig’s meeting with Richardson

Ambassadorial Appointments
    -Cambodia
          -Emory C. Swank
                -Removal
          -William Kintner
                -Possible Congressional reaction
                      -Military aide
                      -Bombing
          -Gen. Richard G. Stilwell
                -Military aide
          -Kintner’s approval process
                -Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] background check
    -William Byroade
          -Thailand
    -Henry Kearns
          -Pakistan
    -Telephone Calls
          -Haldeman
          -Rogers
    -Kintner
    -Byroade
          -Thailand
    -Memorandum to Rogers
    -Byroade
          -Drinking
                -Kintner
    -Kearns
          -Pakistan
    -Foreign Service
          -US Ambassador to USSR
                                             -28-

                    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                           Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                         -Recommendation
             -William Porter
                   -President’s commitment
             -Byroade, Kintner
             -Swank

     Haig’s trip
          -New York Times

     President’s schedule
           -White House Correspondents Dinner
                 -President’s remarks

Haig left at 12:02 pm.

     Press
             -White House Correspondents Dinner
                  -President’s demeanor

     Watergate
          -Advance information on Gallup Poll
               -Haldeman
               -Size of poll sample
               -Poll results
                      -Effect of economy and inflation
                      -Great Britain
                            -Edward M. Heath
                                   -Opposition
                                   -Inflation
                                   -Economy
                                   -Election trends

     President’s schedule
           -Forthcoming meetings
                 -WSAG
                 -National Security Council [NSC]
                 -Congressional leaders
                                     -29-

            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                    Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

Watergate
     -Mitchell’s handling of campaign director job
           -Martha Mitchell
     -President’s instructions regarding knowledge of Watergate
           -President’s responsibility
     -Need to seize initiative
     -Haldeman
           -Veracity
           -Leonard Garment
           -Possible resignation
     -Cooperation with grand jury
     -Congress
           -Executive session
     -Prognosis
     -Haldeman’s position
     -Forthcoming Congressional hearings
           -Revelations
     -Mitchell and Magruder
     -Comparison to Sherman Adams case
           -Bernard Goldfine
           -Adams’s position in White House compared to Haldeman, Ehrlichman,
            Kissinger
           -Dwight D. Eisenhower
     -Mitchell, Magruder
     -Lipshitz [?]
           -1966 wiretapping conviction
                  -Suspended sentence
     -Kissinger’s award ceremony on April 13, 1973
           -Charles L. Bartlett
           -Kissinger’s comments
     -Samuel Dash
     -Civil liberties issue
           -Bartlett
                  -Kennedy association
           -Watergate burglars
           -Communists
                                                -30-

                     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

                                                                  Conversation No. 428-19 (cont’d)

                    -McCarthyism
                    -Watergate burglars
                          -Length of Hunt’s sentence
              -Effect on President
                    -Discounting of polls and press attacks
                    -Emphasis on human factor
                          -Men involved in case
                                -Mitchell and Magruder
                                -Break-in

      Libya
              -Reconnaissance flight
                   -Mediterranean Sean

      Kissinger’s speech to Associated Press [AP] editors
            -Vietnam
            -Europe
            -Latin America
                  -Public interest
            -Vietnam
                  -Background
                        -President’s trips to PRC and USSR
            -Changes in the world over the last quarter century
                  -New assessments
                        -Europe
                        -USSR

Kissinger left at 12:30 pm.

This transcript was made by an AI model listening to the recording (gemini-3.8-flash) and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Speaker names are the model's inference from the voices and the participant list. Words and names can still be wrong — verify against the audio and the finding aid before citing.

Download transcript (.txt) · JSON data

Click a timestamp to play from that point; the recording is in 4 parts and the right one starts.

NixonHow are you?
NixonGood morning.
OperatorMr. Richardson.
NixonHello.
RichardsonHi, Elliot.
NixonHi. It's Elliot, though, I hope you get out.
NixonI noticed the story and like to uh- find something to say.
NixonBefore Richardson can always defend that. And he threw up those nonsense bases, all of a sudden-
Nixon[chuckles] The thought that occurred to me, and I don't know whether- that I hope you would uh- would do directly.
NixonWhy don't you told us from the Bureau of the Budget
Nixonthe cost of uh uh of- of retaining the forty-five bases we're closing.
Nixonand saying that fact that those who would open the bases that- would add 3 billion dollars or 5 billion dollars to it,
Nixonthat it wouldn't hurt to buy it for another billion and a half, whatever it is. You get my point? Maybe it's 800 million.
NixonBut if you put in a round number, in other words [laughter] they're- they're cut some base to- we can murder. Why do you- what is a curse that-
NixonWhat?
NixonYou see with all this business that let's cut the defense budget.
NixonThe whole point is that uh these guys can't have it both ways.
NixonBut uh-
NixonI- I don't know what the number is, but I'm sure that- that when you add forty-five together
NixonAnd then the- I just wouldn't do it on an annual basis, I'd say that-
NixonWell it's 400 million for per year.
NixonBut if you put it up-
NixonYeah, it'd say two billion dollars over the next five years.
NixonSomething like that, okay?
NixonWell you probably already said it, but I- I would- uh I'd zing in on that and- and uh-
NixonAs you know, we expected heat on- on close of the bases, and it's got to be done. What else can you do?
NixonThat's right, and that that's a very good way to get at it. You say, well, you're not going to-
Nixonthey can talk about this base, it's that the case that we are having, submitting a, a- a very lean budget.
NixonWe've closed forty-five bases and some of those, including some of the lists who had had the districts
Nixonand you know the- the- you know, letter with ours.
NixonAnd then they don't want their base closed.
NixonThere you are. Okay. Well, anyway, I just didn't want you to take the heat. It's your show and I know you, you won't take the back door. You do that.
NixonFine. Fine.
NixonBrooke's announcement he was return- returning from his inspection trip to Vietnam.
NixonTo save the Boston Navy Yard. For a person to save the Boston Navy Yard.
NixonThe guy that voted for- [sighs]
NixonWell, somebody ought to make the point.
NixonThese people ought to be hollering for peace, peace,
Nixonand- and- and cut armaments,
Nixonand change priorities, yeah.
NixonYeah. They want to change priorities, and keep the yard.
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
BullGood morning, sir. Mr. Haldeman
Bulland General Haig, sir. Shall I hold them? Or-
NixonHave they here?
BullYes, sir.
NixonYeah, hold them.
NixonWell, it's like the battle of the budget, you can't write off it.
NixonParticularly the Brookes and people like that.
NixonWe knew we were going to make them bleed for four years [unintelligible]
NixonWell the thing is
Nixonthat the fact is anybody that has been following either the budget
Nixonor the state of our race, it's very well known that it has to be done.
NixonSo, there's no surprise that that's it.
NixonBut that's- that's part of the
Nixonpart of the problems of being part of the country. And you're honest, yes, sir. Does it bother you?
EhrlichmanClosing bases doesn't bother me.
NixonNot a bit.
EhrlichmanClosing bases doesn't bother me a bit.
NixonGet him when they're all done.
NixonDid you talk to John?
EhrlichmanYes, he's here.
NixonDid you ask uh
Nixonto rethink the conclusions as to where we are right now and that?
EhrlichmanNo- no conclusions.
EhrlichmanDick Wilson, I think it is, has an interesting column this morning.
NixonI haven't seen it.
EhrlichmanWilson's far-
Ehrlichmannot a spiteful person.
NixonSo what?
EhrlichmanHe argues that really now-
EhrlichmanThe essence of this whole thing is too much money was spent.
EhrlichmanAnd so on, and that he-
NixonYeah, that's his favorite headline.
EhrlichmanYeah. And what everybody- that's what-
EhrlichmanNo, not everybody. That's a- a- one- the rest of my- one rude thesis that uh the rest of it
NixonThat's right.
EhrlichmanReston is on that side, and Tom Wicker.
EhrlichmanAnd that uh-
Ehrlichmanhere's an area he could sort of speak-
EhrlichmanWatergate doesn't take care of it, that uh
EhrlichmanI- I think he wants the President to speak out of a whole campaign issue, the money, the campaign, and all that, but uh he- he is specific on this. He says also that it's gotta-
NixonThat would be one way for us to speak.
EhrlichmanNow I'll tell you what I think. I think that the President's personal involvement in this
Ehrlichmanis important.
EhrlichmanAnd I don't think- I don't think it's a speech.
NixonWell, that's- whatever- whenever we can get at it.
NixonNow I was thinking of the uh
NixonBefore we get into that though that's in fact that's something that we'll develop. I'd like to get I'd like to go in,
Nixonif I could, to what your conversation with Colson was and uh what-
NixonWhat- what was his
NixonWhat- what did he and his lawyer advise? Can you tell me?
EhrlichmanThat visit That visit was to tell me that Hunt was gonna testify on Monday.
NixonYeah, how does he know that?
EhrlichmanUh how- how did he get such information?
EhrlichmanUh, Bittman is his attorney.
EhrlichmanBittman's sitting on her right now.
NixonWhy did- Why is Hunt testifying? Did he say or what did he say he's testified about?
EhrlichmanHe said, well, I'll tell what he said and then I'll tell you what I think the fact is.
EhrlichmanHe said Hunt was testifying because there was no longer any point to being silent.
EhrlichmanThat um
Ehrlichmanuh so many other people were testifying,
Ehrlichmanthat there was no- he wasn't really keeping any secrets,
Ehrlichmanthat kind of thing.
EhrlichmanUh, my- my feeling is that Bittman got very antsy
Ehrlichmanwhen the grand jury started focusing on the money,
Ehrlichmanand he- and Hunt may have gotten a call from the grand jury.
EhrlichmanAnd that he went to the U.S. Attorney, and said "Hey guys, it's way past my client. What
NixonWhat was uh, what did Colson and all- Colson seemed fearful that we ought to do, I mean, sir, get busy and nail Wilson and nail [crosstalk] That's what I heard-
Ehrlichman[crosstalk] nail Magruder.
NixonYeah, how's that gonna help?
EhrlichmanWell, they feel- they're- they're quite convinced that after Hunt testifies,
Ehrlichmanthat the whole thing's gonna fall in short order,
NixonRight.
Ehrlichmanthat Mitchell and- and Magruder will be involuntarily
Ehrlichmanbe uh indicted,
Ehrlichmanand the whole world will say and uh, and you will have lost any possibility of the initiative.
NixonSo, what does Colson ask to do?
EhrlichmanHe wants you- he suggested several things.
EhrlichmanHe wants you to persuade Liddy to talk.
NixonLiddy?
EhrlichmanYes, sir.
NixonThat's his- that is right, I know, but basically-
EhrlichmanLast night he did mention it.
NixonI don't thought that he had.
EhrlichmanMaybe he didn't make it. I didn't- I didn't get that he did.
NixonI refrained me from let Liddy, oh, to try you can't bring him in, he's in jail, but uh-
EhrlichmanNo, no, you could send-
NixonYou could send word to him that the President wanted him to make full disclosure or in some way you would be act as us on this score, huh?
EhrlichmanWell, the premise- the premise was that he's a good soldier and that Dean points out that uh-
EhrlichmanDean is not talking because he thinks he's supposed not to talk.
EhrlichmanAnd if he is supposed to talk, he will.
NixonRight. All he needs is a signal and you want him to give him the signal?
EhrlichmanYeah. But the fight [crosstalk]
Nixon[crosstalk] Now Colson wants it to be a public signal, is that right?
EhrlichmanNo, a private signal, but what-
NixonWhat would we do? What would you do, John?
EhrlichmanHe wants you to be able to say afterwards that you cracked the case.
NixonGo ahead, what else?
EhrlichmanWell, if you did, what then?
NixonWhat about uh uh
NixonWell, that's basically it.
EhrlichmanThat's basically- basically it. Um He- he feels that the next forty-eight hours
Ehrlichmanare the are the last chance
Ehrlichmanfor the White House to get out front on this.
EhrlichmanAnd once Hunt goes on the desk
HaldemanWell, you've got to be out in front earlier, more often, whatever, I mean, sorry not earlier, but publicly.
EhrlichmanEither by- either publicly or with provable, identifiable steps which can be referred to later as having been the prosecutive process.
NixonThe odd fucking thing is he thinks the President doesn't want to [unintelligible] it. According to them, I told you Mitchell's given him a promise of a pardon.
EhrlichmanYeah, that according to Colson and Shapiro, I don't know where they get that.
NixonMitchell has promised Magruder a pardon is it?
EhrlichmanAt other points, Colson made other mentions.
NixonWhatever it is. I have an uneasy feeling that that Magruder's story may have been planted, and, or it's true, and there's a third Magruder phone call, which I haven't heard that says that he didn't talk to the President, said
EhrlichmanSaid that he did talk to a reporter on Monday, and did not say any of the things he's reported to have said, and the way he said the words that the reporter- conversation he said he gave the reporter the same line. [crosstalk] That listening to Magruder's thing, I was convinced he wasn't completely telling the truth of what he was saying. As you get into it, I'm convinced that this that sort of a that that part was pretty much,
NixonWell.
NixonI became convinced of this. All these pieces must be put together now. I've become Magruder. Where in the hell does Colson get such a thing? Or is Colson Shapiro Shapiro says he has a very good press contact.
EhrlichmanWho has proved very reliable, and he says his his practice in this town depends on his knowing what's going on. He's cultivated this press contact. This is one of them.
NixonHe always found him to be so- if he's talking to Magruder, Magruder says so, so that Shapiro says, will never get past that that Magruder may have Magruder may have talked to some of the press, and then that that is it.
HaldemanMm-hmm. But that fits uh, that in a great detail with Colson, that he nailed Bob Haldeman. And the way Colson did it, he says we he had Colson in the tube, yeah, but but not in any way that was particularly uh, bad.
EhrlichmanRight. Well, I think, I think while so many things, this got this got planted as a little seed by Shapiro with Colson, and then it grew. And uh, well, let's look at it.
NixonNow let's guess what's happened. He's got this reporter, Colson does from Danny Harker, and that at the bar in the Bahamas, or Bermuda or something like, one night said to Harker, "Jesus, everybody is involved." He didn't, he said,
Ehrlichman"Everybody in the White House, Mitchell, Haldeman, Colson, Dean, the President." Magruder, Mr. President, he said the President, but Magruder doesn't believe that.
NixonNo. And I'm going to try to I wonder if he believes it? I'm curious, because, you think he believes this stuff?
EhrlichmanNo, this tape is very convincing. Hickey handled it so well that Magruder had closed all the doors.
NixonIs that right?
EhrlichmanAnd it sure beats the socks off of if he ever gets off with-
HaldemanCan you use Hickey, when Hickey is an illegal wire? It's illegal [crosstalk] is it not?
EhrlichmanNo, it's not. No, it's not.
HaldemanUnless you tell somebody.
NixonNo beeper on it.
EhrlichmanThere is no beeper required, you check your Washington law. District of Columbia is under federal law, and federal law does not require disclosure to the other party of recording of phone conversations.
NixonThe phone call was made to Magruder's lawyer's office, which is also in the District of Columbia. So, both ends of the conversation were in the District of Columbia, and there is no law requiring disclosure.
HaldemanWell, it's perfectly legal anyway. It may be inadmissible, but it's legal.
EhrlichmanThat's correct.
HaldemanThat's a new one.
EhrlichmanEach of them every while went down in and I thought it was-
NixonI know. I've never heard of anybody beeping, I know they do.
EhrlichmanIt's it depends on where you are, some the basic law in most states is you must disclose to the other party that you're recording the conversation.
HaldemanYeah. What is the situation? I want to I'll get past this thing in a hurry. What is the situation John, in your opinion, on what is Colson's and or Shapiro's motive in building up the Magruder story? I don't mean, but you don't believe Magruder?
EhrlichmanTheir their innuendo is that Mitchell has put Magruder up to this.
HaldemanI got mine.
NixonYeah, there's the motive.
HaldemanNow,
NixonI think that's it, honestly.
EhrlichmanI don't believe that [crosstalk] seriously.
HaldemanNot either.
NixonNot at all.
EhrlichmanI don't believe Mitchell has tried to Magruder's taking this [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanAnd and now that I've decided to prompt and then fell into Mitchell, he's going to be very unhappy with me, because he's solely responsible for this tape. He got this emotional fellow ready to crack. I I did. I have no doubt that he's ready to talk.
NixonWhy do you? He has his tears going.
EhrlichmanOh, won't he? Because, he's already been there. They won't get him a chance to
NixonHe doesn't think they'll give him a chance, but unless he comes running at them.
EhrlichmanA, they don't follow a suspect, and B, they don't recall a perjured witness.
HaldemanFine, what would you do if you were his lawyer? Wouldn't you advise him to go in and try to purge himself of this, to get rid of one charge at least? And that's if he's worried about that, certainly reduces it when he turns in all the other. What else, damn it? You're a lawyer. What else [unintelligible] See, there's contrary evidence already before the grand jury, other words.
EhrlichmanIt's a fact. It's a grand- grand jury already in fact had three other fact witnesses, exactly.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanAnd, and hey you take the circumstances then. There's none for the There's no first-hand that Hunt is going to come in and testify, and Magruder comes rushing in and says, "I want to tell all." And and, you know, Magruder's cut off all his-
HaldemanYeah, but I think he could approve of it. I think he really could help himself.
EhrlichmanWell, but
NixonNow it comes to the now it comes to the other thing that uh, that uh, Hunt that Colson says now that uh, Hunt's going to talk. What is Hunt going to say? Do we have any idea?
EhrlichmanYes, he says, for example, will he say that Colson promised him clemency? No, apparently not.
HaldemanAnd uh, the reason they the only the only possible involvement of the President in this is that apparently told, either you, or
NixonBob, or Dean. Somebody told him that they said Cole- told Colson, "Do not then discuss with him." I didn't. You didn't. How did Or how did it get to you then, John? How did you know that uh, the matter had been discussed with Hunt, or something?
EhrlichmanWell, how did this happen? I have I remember a conversation with Miss Davis about 5:30 or 6:00, that Colson only dropped it in for her apparent benefit, said, "I have a little problem today." They were talking about other things, and that uh, I uh,
NixonAnd Colson called me, and said told me about Hunt's wife, which is a terrible thing, and I said, "Obviously, we will do just we'll take that into consideration." That was the total of the conversation.
EhrlichmanWell, I had uh, we had had a couple of conversations in my office, that Colson went for uh, I had with Colson. Yeah. Well, how who was getting who was getting What made him get to Colson was after Hunt went?
HaldemanWho who No, Hunt Hunt had written to Colson.
EhrlichmanOh.
NixonAnd Colson, a very, high-pinned, damn blood letter. Yeah.
HaldemanWhen was this, John?
EhrlichmanAfter the accident, oh, yes. Yeah.
HaldemanSo, and how Colson who knew about the letter Colson came in to tell me about it.
EhrlichmanAnd he said, "What shall I do?" And I said, "Well, uh, go talk to I think somebody better talk to him, that guy is obviously very distraught." All right, okay, I feel bad as you do about that. And he said, "What can I What can I tell him about uh, uh, clemency or pardon?" I said, "You can't tell him anything about clemency or pardon."
EhrlichmanAnd I said, "Under no circumstances should this ever be raised with the President." Now, he raised it, I must say, in a tangential way. Now, he denies that I understand it, that he said they'd be out by Christmas. He says, "I never I never talked to Chuck about that, did you?" What did he say he said?
NixonI told him it's raised, and I said "Nothing."
EhrlichmanYeah.
HaldemanYeah. What did he say he said?
EhrlichmanWell, I tell you what I what Dean or somebody tells me he said. He said he didn't. He just tossed it, and saw saw fit and casual, you know, a phone or something like that, you know, "Christmas," and you said, "Oh." And you said and Hunt said, I you said I Well, now he said I
Nixonand uh, "Listen, I have reason to believe that I, I, I told him that I know about Hunt's concern about, about clemency. I, Chuck Colson, feel terrible about it because I knew his wife. And he said, 'I will, will go to bat for him, and I have reason to believe that my views will be, will be listened to.'"
NixonThe, the last part, the part that uh, well anyway, bring me up What what happened? He
EhrlichmanHe says he talked to Bennett, and Bennett was very skillful, but Bennett avoided him and [unintelligible] He said Bennett Bennett was pitching him, but that he wasn't catching.
EhrlichmanAnd he either has a tape of that meeting, or a tape of the conversation or substance. That's where he lost his thread. He said you and Dean told him to promise clemency. But he was smarter than you and didn't.
NixonYou mean, you and Dean told him?
EhrlichmanEhrlichman and Dean told him to promise. Well, anyway,
NixonWhatever the case might be. Let me ask the question. Is this little is this with Hunt?
EhrlichmanWell, it's so he reports.
NixonDoes does does does he indicate the date the fact that Hunt is going to talk to that subject for example, clemency?
EhrlichmanNo, he didn't say that.
EhrlichmanHe didn't say that. And I didn't ask him.
NixonWell, going back to the basics, John, as I recall this, they don't have any evidence. We don't know how they know Hunt's going to testify, but we assume that Bennett told them, right? A.
NixonB, we don't they don't have any indication based on the knowledge that Hunt's going to testify of what Hunt is going to testify to, except on the basis of Shapiro's meetings with Hunt,
EhrlichmanThe other day.
Nixonthe other day, and their assuming that what Hunt told him is what he'll tell the grand jury, but they don't know why they have any reason to assume that.
EhrlichmanI don't Shapiro's general comment was that Hunt would corroborate a lot of hearsay. Yeah,
Ehrlichmanbut that it also would be hearsay.
NixonAll right.
NixonHunt, however, and this is where Colson comes in, Hunt, Hunt could testify on Colson's pressure,
EhrlichmanYes.
Nixonbut what they what they say he's going to testify on the cover-up, what he's going to testify Now, wait a minute, and I'm talking about somebody earlier. We're talking about a little earlier. Colson, Colson wouldn't put it in anywhere in your office that Colson, Colson picked up the phone for breakfast here.
EhrlichmanRight, Magruder, yeah.
NixonNow, there, now Colson says that they didn't discuss [unintelligible] that morning. Hunt could say, "I went in, and I showed this whole plan to Colson and Colson told picked up the phone, and bought them Magruder's.
NixonDoes Colson realize his vulnerability there?
EhrlichmanWell, of course Colson claims he has no vulnerability because when Hunt and Liddy came in to talk to him, they talked in very general terms.
NixonI understand that. So, he doesn't acknowledge I he doesn't acknowledge that the same possibility. I understand that. But I'm just simply saying it's and you agree that Hunt and Liddy could, That's true, could, could
Nixoncould charge that. That's the point. They, they, if they talked,
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonI would assume they would get into that point with them if they cross-examined Colson.
EhrlichmanI've I've asked Colson specifically about that conversation, and he maintains that they were talking in general terms about intelligence. And when they said intelligence, he meant one thing, and, apparently, they meant another.
NixonQuestion. Uh or chapel uh is Hunt preparing to talk on other areas?
EhrlichmanWell, I couldn't I couldn't derive that. Okay? That's it all.
NixonHard to whitewash. Yeah, I couldn't
EhrlichmanI couldn't get that at all.
NixonThe U.S. attorney, I would assume, would not be pressing for that. Well, apparently not.
EhrlichmanNo.
NixonThey'd like to nail McCord, McCord volunteered this Hank Greenspun thing.
EhrlichmanThe Jewish [unintelligible] background.
Nixondid they did they break in to Hank Greenspun? I guess they were actually dying. For what?
EhrlichmanWell, now, Mitchell. Here's Yeah. Hughes.
EhrlichmanAnd these two fellows, Colson and Shapiro,
EhrlichmanColson threw that out.
NixonHughes on who?
EhrlichmanWell, you know, the Hughes thing is cut into two factions,
Ehrlichmanand they're fighting, and they're fighting. Right. Bennett,
EhrlichmanSenator Bennett's son, for whom Hunt worked,
Ehrlichmanrepresents one of those factions.
NixonYeah. So, he hired him to do it?
EhrlichmanWell, it has the marks of a of a bag job. The question is did they get something out of the bag? Now,
NixonFor that If who had broke his safe, they found something out of the Turn the airplane for way. Now,
Ehrlichmanas they sat there in my office That's other other delicate things too. I know, but, apart from my four damned-dumb brother, which unfortunately was forged a long time ago. Hubert Humphrey's son works for him, and, of course, they they tie O'Brien. I suppose that maybe they were trying to get something on that group. I don't know why, and they two of them put on a little charade for me, you know. They just Colson and Shapiro,
Ehrlichmanas we talked about this. It may have been genuine and it may not, but they said They didn't know anything about it. No, they said One said to the other,
Ehrlichman"Say, that may have something to do with the New York grand jury." In the Vegas grand jury, which is a long way.
NixonDid you take it Did they talk to Colson about that?
EhrlichmanI don't know. I don't think he I said he says he doesn't know who Hank Greenspun is.
NixonBullshit. Everyone knows that. Jesus Christ. I I take him at face value on that one.
NixonHe didn't know that either. Who? Hank?
EhrlichmanI, I know very well who he is.
NixonAll right, let me just take a minute further on Hunt thing in the grand jury. I want to get all of the pieces. Hunt's testimony on payoffs
Nixonwould of course be very important. Right? He's prepared to testify, apparently so?
EhrlichmanApparently so. That's what they say. That he will, and that he will implicate O'Brien and Parkinson.
NixonAnd then, of course, O'Brien and Parkinson, they're lawyers. Were they the ones who talked to him?
EhrlichmanWell, he says they were, and that they handed him the money. He in turn handed it to his wife, and she was the go-between to the Cubans.
NixonFor what purpose? That's the key.
EhrlichmanWell, I think they'll they'll both hang him up on obstruction of justice.
NixonWhy would he Why did he do that? Why wouldn't he simply Why would he, Hunt, testify for his purpose simply that they gave him the money to pay a legal fee? We're all hanging out there apparently.
EhrlichmanNow this is I don't think he's uh they spoke of
Ehrlichmanobstruction. That's right. And I don't know of any other information. All right.
NixonSo Hunt So Hunt's identifying the role. Now that that that traces the the problem on on on the part of Kalmbach as a possible one. In other words, to whether he was aware In other words, the motive the motive. This doesn't add anything to the Kalmbach problem at all.
NixonWhat happened? What happened is that Dean called Kalmbach. What did Dean call Kalmbach about?
EhrlichmanHe said, "We have to raise some money in connection with the the aftermath, or however he expressed it, then, uh,
EhrlichmanHerb said, "How much do you need?"
NixonWe've never discussed this.
EhrlichmanAnd uh Dean told him. And Herb went to a couple of donors and got some money and sent it back.
EhrlichmanDean said very flatly that uh Herb did not know the purpose of the money, and there's no problem.
NixonDean, then, told the grand jury?
NixonAnd Hunt testified So, so basically then, Hunt will testify that that was so-called hush money. Right?
EhrlichmanApparently so.
NixonAgain, high water can't rise any higher than the source. I understand. But,
EhrlichmanThat's that's their What? That's their What does that serve him?
EhrlichmanWell, the only thing it serves him is to what? Uh would it reduce his sen- hanging sentence, or something? It would serve the same purpose by [unintelligible]
NixonGuys that I recruited for this job, and I had, I got to take care of their family. We had a great deal of [crosstalk] That's right. That's what it ought to be, and that's got to be the story, and uh
EhrlichmanAnd that that would part of why said we had
EhrlichmanThat will be the defense of uh other people.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanThat was the line that was used throughout here.
NixonWhat?
EhrlichmanThat was the line that was used throughout here, that we've got to have money for their legal fees and and for support.
Nixonthey take care of them now. They raise— Remember the Scottsboro case?
HaldemanRight. The communist front, like, took a million dollars for the Scottsboro people, 900,000 went in the pockets of the of of the Communists.
NixonSo it's common practice now. Nevertheless, that's Hunt then saying everybody pays him.
HaldemanAll right, Hunt on other activities. Hunt then according to Colson was not [unintelligible]
NixonI don't understand what Colson meant about the door to the Oval Office. Now I have to get back at him on that. Miss Carroll was out there at any point?
HaldemanRight.
Nixon[unintelligible] Well, there was never the connection—
HaldemanNo, not it was in earlier conversations. It was said about the Magruder conversation, when Colson was—
NixonI think on the Magruder conversation, from what I've seen in the paper, is that Magruder doesn't go to the door of the Oval Office, he doesn't even come to that floor. You know, but he but he, is Colson's it's Colson's view that Magruder's coming would have the effect of bringing it there, because
HaldemanI think what he's really referring to, John, is that by reason that Colson by reason of Magruder nailing Haldeman and and Colson, that that's the door to the Oval Office. I don't know what else, because there's nobody else around, nobody's physically around.
EhrlichmanStrachan [unintelligible]
NixonWell, and sue. I don't think so either.
HaldemanAll right, and then this tape thing— Well, that is that tape is is invaluable, is it not?
EhrlichmanYes, he definitely wants you to keep it.
NixonI just listened to it.
HaldemanLet me just say a couple of things that you have to get from here. [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanWell, except that I retain With regard to your with regard to your your uh your your views and so forth and so on and how they uh Hey, last night, John, you and Bob or somebody was, were talking about
Ehrlichmansomebody going to see Mitchell. You suggested Rogers. Were there other better names? Why not go down up and down the list, find instead of Rogers?
EhrlichmanWell, I suggested Rogers because first, let me tell you the purpose of the mission, from where I view it. Purpose of the mission is to go and bring him to focus on this, and say the need here is a—
Ehrlichmanand the President strongly feels that the only way that this thing can end up being even a little net plus for the administration and for the presidency, and preserve some shred is for you to go in and and and voluntarily make a statement.
EhrlichmanThe statement that Haldeman, kind of, hints at here. The statement that basically says—
HaldemanIt's got to go beyond that. I am I am both morally and legally—
EhrlichmanYeah.
EhrlichmanNow the reason for Rogers is that he's clean, number one. Uh, he has been both uh attorney general and has this other investigative, and Senate committee background, and so forth.
EhrlichmanAnd there isn't anybody that Mitchell trusts except Rogers. He hates Rogers. I take that back. Trusts. Rogers, but he would know if Rogers came that it was that it was you.
HaldemanNow the other the only other alternative, going up and down the list—
EhrlichmanAlso, in from a public viewpoint, Rogers is the dean of the cabinet and is the logical man as a former attorney general to help him through. Like that might be good.
NixonThere are fifty reasons not to do this. You've pointed them out. Oh, yeah, yeah. There are there are the they and there have consistently been. You go back through the history of this. I know, but now is the time to do something, I think.
EhrlichmanNow is the only time, probably. And I'm I'm persuaded by that argument. Well, I am, too. Oh, I I agree. I'm not arguing about not doing it, I'm just trying to talk about the name.
EhrlichmanOkay. Um, in in going down the list, John Alexander's the only other one that I've seen through that in any way fit the person. Garment can't do it.
HaldemanWell, let me give you another name.
EhrlichmanAll right.
HaldemanLet me give you another name: Ken Rush.
NixonRush is a is a very fine lawyer. Highly clean, a long-time friend of Mitchell's, not a close friend, but he's known him, and uh they they're the people that kind of understand it all. Mitchell does not hate him.
HaldemanRush is credible. I don't know how able Rush is. I don't either. I doubt it. Uh, another name Two other names that occurred to me,
NixonGo ahead.
Haldemanuh one is Elliot Richardson.
EhrlichmanHm.
HaldemanAnd the other is um uh Connally. There is another possibility, and that's Henry Petersen.
EhrlichmanWell, that, of course, is that puts it into prosecutorial end and drags the President Yeah. Yeah. Petersen finally revealing that Mitchell had had contacts with the grand jury and all the rest.
EhrlichmanNo, I I must say I'm impressed with the argument that the President should be personally involved in it at this stage.
HaldemanRight. I agree.
EhrlichmanUh, hold on. John Dean got a had an interesting had a phone call from him about 12:30.
Nixon[unintelligible]
EhrlichmanI was working on something. I went home and I uh, well not much last night.
HaldemanYou mean another subject? Oh, no. I'm afraid there is no other subject.
EhrlichmanNo other subject. There is no other subject. Yeah, damn. Now, I tell you last night when I got home I decided that that uh I would sit down and try to put down on paper a report to you of what I've been doing since you asked me to do this. Right.
EhrlichmanUh, I'm concerned about the overall aspect of this, and and I want to talk about that before we're through. I don't know what your timing is like. No problem, we'll get back to it. We got plenty of time.
EhrlichmanDean called and he said, "All right, here's a scenario, we've all been trying to figure out where we should go." He says, "The President calls Mitchell into his office on Saturday, and he says, 'John, you've got to do this.' And, 'Here are the facts. Bing, bang, bang, bang.' And that's in this paper. And you've got to go do this."
EhrlichmanAnd Mitchell stonewalls it.
EhrlichmanAnd uh that's I don't know why you're asking me down here. You can't ask a man to do a thing like that. I need a lawyer. Uh what I'm facing—" He's just really, candidly, expects him to do that.
EhrlichmanUm, so the President said, "Now I have all turns." And with that, uh the President calls the U.S. attorney and says, "I, the president of the United States of America, and leader of the free world, want to go before the grand jury and [unintelligible]."
EhrlichmanWell, that's absurd. That's a foolish But I mean, we're typical of the thinking. We're running out every every line. So that was 12:30 this morning, and uh uh, but the, but I am, I go forward. I am
HaldemanThat's why I wouldn't bother about national television.
EhrlichmanUh, with Dan Rather?
HaldemanHuh?
EhrlichmanWith Dan Rather?
HaldemanWell, but, but, by putting it on national television, period. Uh, you're uh When your When your audience, basically, is not that big. But let's let's take it just as far as you call Mitchell into the Oval Office.
EhrlichmanAnd um And say, "Look, essentially, convinced that Mitchell is the lynchpin on this thing. And that if he goes in, it can rebound to the administration's benefit. If he doesn't,
Ehrlichmanthen we're off in the who-done-it, and we're dragged back. That's one. The other, if you have a report from me based on three weeks' work, and when you got it, you immediately acted to call Mitchell in as the, as a, probable wrongdoer,
Ehrlichmanand you say, 'My God, I've got a report here, and it's clear from this report that you are guilty as hell. Now, John, for Christ's sake, go on in there and do what you should, and let's get this thing cleared up and get it off the country's back, and move on.'"
EhrlichmanAnd uh—
Ehrlichmanwhat's, the other side of it is that that's the only—
NixonHe can always appear now.
EhrlichmanNo, from John Mitchell's own personal viewpoint, that's the only salvation for John Mitchell.
HaldemanRight.
EhrlichmanAny other way and, obviously, once you had him, he He hasn't got a basis anyway.
EhrlichmanAnother factor in that, to consider for what it's worth, is the point Connally made to me
NixonHave you talked to Mitchell?
EhrlichmanI don't know whether he said this to you or not. He made the point that you had to get this slate down
EhrlichmanThe, the only way it can hurt you is if it ultimately went to Mitchell, and that would be the one man you could afford to let get into boxes.
NixonHe worried New York, he, he thought so, he's so influential. Yeah, maybe because he sees the epitome of your down to hard-line.
EhrlichmanI think he's wrong about that, though. I think this was the worst. Well,
Nixondue, due to the closeness to the President and the time of the crime. But, would you reach on?
EhrlichmanWell, all it's that that's the way I see it, but what Connally also said was,
NixonLook what's, it's the President himself whoails with him.
EhrlichmanThen, then the President is glorified by being truthful. Can I pull all this into the larger, in the larger thing? We tend to live day-to-day with these things, you know, forget the the
Ehrlichmanperspective that will be put on this period you know, three months. But, the the point is whether or not I think I got the larger picture in my in and I, the point is this that we
EhrlichmanWe need an action before er In other words, let's give, like my, my feeling about having the grand jury do it, And courses, rather than the Ervin committee. Now they want the President to, rather than the grand jury. You know?
NixonI agree with that. Well you're doing it in aid of the grand jury. No, but I didn't mean, I didn't mean rather than the grand jury, but I mean to, to
Ehrlichmanto, to What would it true it, however, I, I the grand jury doesn't drag him in. He goes in as a result of the President's asking him to go in.
NixonWait a minute. Then, what are you at that point, can I urge him, refer him to go in? Because, I don't give the subpoena. Yeah. But, it's call him, you, when he came through.
EhrlichmanYou, all the stuff we talked about last night, that you don't want the confrontation, and that the solution here, if we can find it, maybe it's impossible.
NixonFor Mitchell to come voluntarily? Well, or for Magruder to come voluntarily and name Mitchell.
EhrlichmanThat the solution is, I believe that somewhere Where does Magruder come to, to me? Well, to the, to the US attorney. But, why does,
Nixonwhy would I urge Magruder to do it? I mean, let me, let me look at this. The urging of Liddy to testify, the urging of Magruder to testify,
Ehrlichmanand the Mitchell thing. John, run those, one by one. I didn't mean to stop your, oh, analysis, but I think, I think I know what your, what, what isn't that really the essence of it? I'm trying to write the news magazine's story for next Monday, right?
EhrlichmanMonday a week.
EhrlichmanAnd, if it is that grand jury indicts Mitchell,
EhrlichmanRight. the White House vain effort to cover up finally collapsed last week, when the grand jury indict Mitchell, that cracked the case
Ehrlichmanwith the testimony of a number of peripheral witnesses, who each of them contributed to developing a, a cross-triangulation and permitted the grand jury to analyze, and so on and so forth. And then, the final, the final straw that broke the camel's back was,
Ehrlichmanan investigator's discovery of this and that and the other thing. That's one set of facts. And, and then the tag on that is,
Ehrlichmanso at White House Press Secretary Ron Ziegler kept said that the White House had held, "I don't I won't. That can't be done. The other one, the other one goes,
Ehrlichman"Events moved swiftly last week, after the President was presented with a report indicating
Ehrlichmanthat, for the first time, that suspicion of John Mitchell and Jeb Magruder, as ring leaders in the Watergate break-in, were in fact, substantiated by considerable evidence.
EhrlichmanThe President then dispatched so-and-so to do this and that, and it may be to see Mitchell or something of that kind, and, these efforts
Ehrlichmanresulted in Mitchell going to the U.S. Attorney's office on Monday morning at 9:00, asking to testify before the grand jury. Charges of cover-up
Ehrlichmanby the White House were materially dispelled by the diligent efforts of the President and his aides in moving on evidence which came to their hands in the, in the closing days of the previous week."
NixonI, I buy that. Okay. The only thing, so we get down to facts. Now,
EhrlichmanI've been concerned, because since the end of March, I have turned up a fair amount of hearsay evidence that, that points at this guy.
NixonNow just take So did Dean. And, and so did John. Dean. Now, taking this, yet we tried,
Nixonvery honestly, we've tried to try to look at it the best way we could, haven't we? That maybe he couldn't, maybe he really didn't know. Well, it's hearsay. And so, you don't hang a guy, you don't hang a guy necessarily. We got to remember, Mitchell has denied it.
EhrlichmanBut, I stood, I stood over there in Paul's office and listened to that tape of one of the co-actors saying flat on the tape that he was guilty, and that Mitchell was going to, was going to fall, and all that, and I said,
NixonDid he say that? He said that? Yeah, well we can't And, and I said to myself, my God, you know, I'm a United States citizen and I'm standing here listening to this.
EhrlichmanWhat is my duty? Well, the point is you've now told me, that's the problem. That's correct. That's correct.
NixonSee the December thing, that the the the problem of my position up to this time, has been quite frankly nobody reported it to you. That's right.
Ehrlichmanwhich was guilt. That's right. Well, we still don't know it. I, I don't say that I know it. I will still argue that I think the scenario that was still spin spun out the Dean spun out to Mitchell,
Ehrlichmanis basically the right one. I don't think Mitchell did order the Watergate bugging, and I don't think he was specifically aware of the Watergate bugging at the time it was instituted. Well, let me Honestly, don't. That may be. Now, I think that Mitchell Here's what he told,
Nixonhe had okayed, but, but it's for your, for your information, here's what Mitchell told Rebozo, I will never forget it, that's it.
NixonThat's why I asked, happens to be a lawyer. [laughter] You tell Mitchell, and that will get Bebe into this, I hope. Boy. Well anyway, let me tell you what he told Rebozo,
Nixonright afterwards, a couple or a month ago, he said. He said, "You know and the actions here, now we're pushing to fight that ITT thing, all right? I made a hurt in my soul, but I sure did know Miss [unintelligible]."
NixonWell, there you are.
EhrlichmanSee, I still think that that could that could easily be correct. I think so. See, that's what he told Moore. And, he believes that. What did he say? What did he tell Moore? Well, remember I, I asked Moore to find out what Mitchell had testified to. Yeah. Oh yeah, Moore had talked to him, and then, he had said, "Well, you're not"
EhrlichmanHe, he was never asked the right questions. Now, uh uh as far as the quality that grand jury is, is, that's right. As far as the quality of the evidence is concerned.
NixonHey, I just, uh, digress for one point that has nothing to do with this, except we've got to fight the bull on everything, and so on. Essential that Rogers' departure be delayed until this is over.
NixonI the hell with Henry on this. The point is, any member of the Cabinet, except Kleindienst, leaving during this, there's no way to get a, you finally banged him. And uh, you've got to talk to, Ben, you've got to guess, and Henry, it's not appealable.
NixonYou've just got to say to Henry, there are bigger things here, Rogers isn't leaving. Huh? He just come, you can say, "All right, fine. Then brush that. Just say Rogers' going to stay until this thing's over."
NixonRight, John? You agree? Absolutely. See, Rogers is gonna leave the 1st of July. That's uh Well, maybe, we maybe out of the woods by then. It might be over by Out of the woods? No. Well, to to go back to
EhrlichmanAll right, well let the I only mention Bebe because, to say that. Let me, let's keep to the, to that. Well, all I was going to say is that,
NixonAll right, I don't have evidence. I'm convinced. what you, you don't have evidence. If, if I I'm not convinced he's guilty that said, but I am convinced that he ought to go before the grand jury. That's, uh and, and it what I did last night,
Ehrlichmanor this morning, was to write out, what would, with effect, be a report to you, All right. of, of this, of this whole And I got Hold on to that. John,
NixonAll right, go ahead.
EhrlichmanI, all I know about my relationship with Mitchell from his side, is what others have told me. He is never, he never
NixonThe Mitchell problem, the Mitchell problem Rogers is in no position to handled. I don't see how
NixonMy point is Mitchell thinks he's a snake and uh has not been loyal, which he has not been. We've had Rogers be disloyal and and wrong, but in a sense of
Nixonwell according to, Mitchell was standing up on Cambodia and May 8 Rogers was skulking out.
EhrlichmanLet's put it in setting. Mitchell has felt
Ehrlichmanfrom the days of [unintelligible]
Ehrlichmanthat I disapproved of him and that I and and, in fact, it
Ehrlichmanfell to my lot to second-guess his operation of the Justice Department day after day. All right, wait a minute.
NixonAll right, now let's come around let's come around again, though. You know the case.
NixonYou conducted the investigation for me. You reported to me. I've asked you to go up and lay it on the ground with Mitchell and to tell Mitchell, look, there's only one thing that can save him.
NixonI think John's got to hear that kind of talk, and I think he's got to hear it from somebody that knows. Now, I was thinking of bringing Rogers and telling him to go on this deal
Nixonbecause goddamn it Mitchell will wind him around his finger. Well, here's our problem.
EhrlichmanIf you want me to go, I'll go. The message The message to Garcia has got to be carried by
EhrlichmanBob has a pretty good feel of Mitchell's attitude toward me that I don't have.
NixonWell, Mitchell's attitude toward you is not going to be
NixonFirst, it wouldn't be any better towards Rogers. It wouldn't be towards Rush. Yeah.
NixonNow how in the name of God, Rush is smart.
EhrlichmanAnd he's tough. And uh he's a man, incidentally, that we can consider
EhrlichmanHe can't argue the facts of this case. That's the problem.
NixonRush is a man that I would the new name a special man in the White House. I was thinking last night
Nixonthat he is the best man I could mission to bring over to advise the President on this goddamn thing, and hold and examine all the White House things,
Nixonto look at all the FBI files, to look at jury reports, Dean's reports, the FBI files, and give me a report.
NixonHe's articulate, he's he's uh be good on television, he's uh respected, one of the one of the towering figures in the ambassadorial world, and the bar.
NixonHe's no slouch. What about an outsider? Good God, it will take so often.
NixonRush I trust. Rush is a friend. He's a total White House man, and yet he's not not tied into this.
EhrlichmanHe's exactly the kind of guy we need. Now, I don't know how if he hasn't practiced law for a long time that's not a that's not a real drawback, but uh he has the lawyer's mind.
EhrlichmanYou've got to get him somebody to help him like uh a has it overtaken has event's overtaken that project?
NixonOh, no, no, no, no, Bob. For Christ's sake, we've we've [laughter] The point that I make is, let's suppose they get Mitchell,
Nixonthen they're going to say, "Now what about Haldeman? And what about Chapin? And what about Colson?" and the rest. I've got to have a report indicating that oh we've got a whole Segretti craft in it.
NixonI want somebody to say, "Now look here. Here the facts: None of the White House people were involved.
NixonThere are no other higher-ups. The White House was not involved in the canter, and and, second, more than that, and then take the Segretti craft.
EhrlichmanI uh I in in parsing this out, Dean remains a problem, and and uh here's uh let let me just read you what I've come to on that score.
Ehrlichman"John Dean has not involved himself in this matter as your counsel for several months, and properly so. I should not continue to feign to differ with him. The the
Ehrlichmanfor several reasons, including the impermissible demands on my time, you need a full-time Special Counsel to follow these related problems, who can advise you the legal niceties from his experience in constitutional, criminal, and governmental practice.
EhrlichmanI'll be happy to continue to consult with him, and so on. I do not recommend that Dean take a leave.
EhrlichmanThat is neither in nor out. He has involved himself in the extent described above. Either that requires dismissal, or it does not,
Ehrlichmanand that choice should be made at once. If he is discharged, the U.S. Attorney, grand jury should be informed,
Ehrlichmanbut I think he's you've got to bite the bullet one way or the other pretty quick." All right. What does Dean say?
EhrlichmanThat kills him. Dean says that kills him.
Nixon[unintelligible]
Nixon[unintelligible] And he got off with plea bargaining, a misdemeanor, which to me misdemeanor, yeah.
NixonThat's all the goddamn thing ever was.
EhrlichmanHe got a suspended sentence, it was suspended. That's right. He never served an hour in in
NixonDidn't serve in jail. Name But not only You see, Bob was indicted on a felony, was not indicted on a felony, then through a plea a plea bargains to a misdemeanor,
Nixongets off with uh no sentence and so forth, and and Dash defends him, and says that, and Lipschultz goes out and the Post prints reams of stuff, "He's an honorable man," and so forth. Now why, could he have been indicted on two levels?
EhrlichmanHow the hell, who got the who got that story out in that? Now we don't seem to be able to get Dash told, apparently, that uh the the two or three papers got wind of it, but the interesting thing is that Dash had made a moral judgment earlier that that didn't disqualify him to deal with that.
EhrlichmanAnd Dash has a beautiful statement in the front page of the paper, which is, "A man wouldn't be as good an investigator if he hadn't"
NixonUnless he knew how to bug stuff.
Ehrlichman"No, unless he had been in trouble a couple of one or two times." Ervin must've loved that.
NixonI bet Ervin loved that. Did he talk about another thing saying a man wouldn't be a good campaigner if he hadn't had a flank or two either?
NixonWhat I'm getting at is this:
NixonWhat's his posture here, not for Dean?
NixonWe're talking about Dean. Mitchell.
NixonI know. I've begged your indulgence, John. I don't give a damn about it.
NixonAll of these are interrelated, John.
NixonIt would be one thing if you carried the whole thing,
Nixonand you war empty office, and cleared it all,
Nixongave them full pardons.
NixonThat's what they had to have, John. Right. Do you agree? Yes. I sure do.
EhrlichmanWell, you hadn't asked me how I come out of this, and so I just I just brought it to a focus, I think. You have to decide up or down on Dean now. What do you think about that?
NixonWell, let's see. What what does Dean say when you told him that?
EhrlichmanHe doesn't agree with that.
NixonI know he doesn't agree, but what does he think?
EhrlichmanWhat does he do? He wants to stay and just disconnect himself from this case.
EhrlichmanAnd he says, "Yes, that's right. Make your decision now, but make your decision that I should stay."
NixonHe needs to decide that right this I've urged you not to. If we bodies are talking about Rush, that relates to this general subject.
EhrlichmanI think our tactic for the moment The only thing that I would Yeah. I reach.
EhrlichmanAnd and um get back to the get back to the Mitchell thing, which really is uh like today.
NixonI know. It's like this morning.
NixonI don't think there's anybody that can talk to Mitchell except somebody that knows this case.
NixonThere are only one or two people and I I first myself, I don't want to know the goddamn thing, but I'm not sure that I want to know.
NixonI want to say, "Mitchell, look, I have been informed that you're the attorney for the committee, O'Brien, and I found out this, and I found out that, and I found out that the grand jury is going this, didi-didi-didi-dee."
NixonI just don't know. I just don't You know what I mean? You talk about my going out as uh
EhrlichmanI agree. I'm not trying to duck. I if it were my job, I'd say I'll take this in one minute.
NixonYeah. The problem is that there's nobody really to do it except you,
Nixonand I know how Mitchell feels.
NixonThe fact you've conducted this investigation, I the way I would do it, and you'll forgive us, I would go up and say,
Nixon"The President's asked me to see you and to end the day with this report.
NixonThese are the cold facts, indicating a person's about to be indicted, the grand jury's moving, etcetera, etcetera,
Nixonand who will be indicted, you may.
NixonUnder the circumstances, I, as the President, can't be in a position of having you,
Nixongrand jury etcetera, etcetera, etcetera, and say I am responsible, I did not know.
Haldeman"I assume the responsibility. Nobody in the White House is involved, and so on and so on."
HaldemanWe did try to help these defendants afterwards, yes. You probably could not deny that anyway, they probably would not ask that, I don't know at your time. But just to defend, defending the title of that.
EhrlichmanWell now, you're, you're bossing.
EhrlichmanI don't think he can do that.
HaldemanAll right, I wouldn't want, I wouldn't want to. All right, anyhow.
EhrlichmanOh, all right, fine, fine.
HaldemanWhat would you say, John?
EhrlichmanLet me, let me hear, hear your pitch. I'd say you did, you know, basically the jig is up, John, and I've listened to the burger, and, and, he's got, he's, in my opinion, he's about to blow,
Ehrlichmanand that's, that's going to be strong. And also, Hunt is going to testify too, much sooner. We've got to, we've got to take this thing, stand with the President. I know you have been right along,
Ehrlichmanand that's the reason we've been conducting ourselves as we have.
HaldemanRight.
EhrlichmanIt's, it's now time, like this to think what best serves the President.
EhrlichmanAnd, also what best serves you in the ultimate outcome of this thing, right?
EhrlichmanAnd we have to, we have to recognize that you are not going to escape this thing.
EhrlichmanNo way.
EhrlichmanAnd it's far better, far better, that you should be prosecuted on information from the US attorney, based on your conversation with the US attorney, than on a taintment by a grand jury of, of 15 blacks and 3 whites,
Ehrlichmanafter this kind of a, this kind of an investigation.
HaldemanWhere, right at the door of the White House were trying to protect him.
EhrlichmanIf the grand jury goes this way, you've been dragged in by the heels.
EhrlichmanIf you go down first thing Monday morning, or yes, this afternoon, and talk to the US attorney,
Ehrlichmanand say, "Okay, I want to make a statement."
EhrlichmanThen two things happen: One, you get credit for coming forward; two, you serve the President's interest.
EhrlichmanAnd I am here in behalf of the Pres- well, and three, you get the people that are after him the distress is, the officers yeah [unintelligible] spend them in a, there what could get him. And, and, I am here at the President's request, to ask you to do that.
HaldemanYeah.
EhrlichmanHe has reviewed the facts now. Right. He has no alternative, John, but to send me here and ask you to do this.
HaldemanWell, if you want to hear it personally you, pick up the phone.
EhrlichmanWell, come down and see him.
EhrlichmanI have a couple of modifications, one a minor one, not for what you say, but for the setting it up.
HaldemanYeah, go.
EhrlichmanI think that if I call Mitchell and say that the President wants you to talk to him, there is no question that his mind [unintelligible]
HaldemanRight, right.
EhrlichmanRight.
EhrlichmanAnd secondly, that if at all possible you should come down here.
Haldeman[unintelligible]
EhrlichmanWell, my argument for it is, A, you get it here under your circumstances; B, if you make your case, which you make, you don't know what his mind is, he may be on the same topic, maybe at the same point.
HaldemanThat's right.
EhrlichmanIf he is, you might be able then to swing, well, let's
Ehrlichmanget it over with right now. Go on over.
EhrlichmanC, he may say, "I've got to talk to the President before I do this." And then, we're ready to do it.
HaldemanWell let me say, let me say this: I've, I've run, run through my mind thought. The idea of Rogers if you've done, Bob will tell you it's not, it's not one that, that I don't think it's potentially good. I was hoping you'd say that.
HaldemanI, I know Rogers like the back of my hand, and Rogers does not fight real mean tough problems.
EhrlichmanHe won't fight then.
EhrlichmanHow about if Rogers is official?
HaldemanMitchell will say, yeah
Nixon"-know what I know. You know, these kids over at the White House are, you know, they're really-"
EhrlichmanYeah.
Nixon"What do you know? What I know? What about them?" Well, he can roll his eyes and, and practically no one worried about it.
NixonYou see John, somebody has to talk to him who knows the facts. That's the point.
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
Ehrlichmanand here it's an area that we'd be worried about to say Magruder. Well, all right, I can't say it quite that way. What if he has-
HaldemanI can I can say that Magruder's going to testify.
NixonWe have learned from, I could
HaldemanWe have learned that Magruder is going to testify.
EhrlichmanI can say, "Well, I can start out by saying 'Look, I can't vouch for any of this first-hand. Tremendous amount of what I know is second-hand, like
Ehrlichmanmy conversation with Paul O'Brien.'
Ehrlichman'But, I have every reason to think that Magruder's in with the U.S. Attorney right now'
Ehrlichman'and doing uh, and talking everything'"
Haldeman"That Hunt's going to go Monday." Well Monday-
NixonMonday, and Liddy. Well, you can't say Liddy. Maybe Mitchell has a [crosstalk]
Ehrlichman[crosstalk] "I have I have reason to think Liddy's already talked"
Ehrlichman"and, uh, that Raw Flank goes to them on and and outside for that."
Haldeman"So they're obviously going to be having a cover up on that."
NixonSee, if Mitchell went in that might knock that whole week into a cocked hat.
HaldemanWhy?
EhrlichmanWell, would they care about the cover-up then?
NixonWell, they might, but they'd See, if Mitchell, if Mitchell gave them a complete-
HaldemanWouldn't, wouldn't-
EhrlichmanMust be the panic.
HaldemanWouldn't- Huh?
NixonIf Mitchell gave them a complete statement-
HaldemanIt shouldn't, I mean you're right.
HaldemanI mean the the cover-up is except that uh
NixonWell, it basically is a second crime. Isn't that right, John? Do you think they'd keep going on the cover-up, even if Mitchell went in?
EhrlichmanI would assume so. I would certainly assume so. You see,
Ehrlichmanthey've got to explain to the grand jury someday why they blew this.
EhrlichmanAnd they've got all the They're really not shoes to stop at this point. They would certainly be burdened
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
EhrlichmanEverything that relates to this, and all of it so and all the and any other
Ehrlichmanmake their decisions, so-
NixonWhat if, uh,
HaldemanWell, try to go, point out, "what did, what did they have that that related to the Grand Jury?"
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
NixonI like the Dean approach there.
EhrlichmanI didn't say that.
EhrlichmanI didn't say that, but I think it's, it is, is it an independent question?
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanIf you are in a situation where Mitchell stonewalls,
Ehrlichmanthen, and walks out, and he says, "The hell with you guys, I've got I've got to live with my wife."
HaldemanLet's see uh we've got uh uh what's uh What if uh my watch stopped?
NixonYou've got thousands of matters morning. Excuse me. I've been there since 8:00 this morning.
HaldemanThat's why.
NixonThis damn stuff has been so heavy today, more than that.
EhrlichmanNow that's my problem, I've got a heavier one tonight.
EhrlichmanUh, John Dean, how would that go?
EhrlichmanNow let me get around that by, suggest to you what I think would be his response.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanHis response would be, "Look, you're supposed to be a lawyer. You know better.
EhrlichmanFor somebody who is a target in a inquiry like this scan
NixonOh, yes, you've got-
Ehrlichman"You're supposed to tell me uh
Ehrlichmaninstead of that, you just suggested that I divest myself of all my rights, and you've asked me down here for a highly improper conversation, and you haven't even suggested that I bring my attorney. I take it what you're doing is, you're acting as a prosecutor in this case. How do you come off doing that?
NixonHe won't do that. I don't think he will.
HaldemanI think he's far likelier to say, "Well, goddamnit, look, John, you know that there are people in the White House that're deeply involved in this, you know, and Colson and all of them know." He may say this. Pressure this poor boy over here. I think Magruder will take the offensive on John, won't you think, Bob?
EhrlichmanSee, I'm not at all sure that Mitchell may think I am involved. And I'm sure he probably thinks Colson's involved because Magruder has used that, you see. And I guess the line Magruder has used with Mitchell,
Ehrlichmanand you have to place Magruder's thinking, Magruder planning to go see Mitchell?
HaldemanYes, sir.
EhrlichmanAnd if he decides to go, if he decides to blow, decides to talk, and he's about on the verge.
EhrlichmanI gather from that conversation, what he has decided, either he talks or he takes the fifth. He's not going to lie.
NixonThey're not calling him. They may not call him back. That's the thing. That's right. That's good. They won't ever try him. Well, that depends. They'll try him, himself.
EhrlichmanHe says, "I know I'm going to be arrested."
NixonThey know where they're going.
EhrlichmanAll right. If Mitchell comes back with a line like that, you're, "You're not serving the President well. You had made any kind of investigation, surely you'd know people in the White House are involved." What do you say? I'd say, "Look, John, we're past the point
Ehrlichmanwhere we can be concerned about whether people in the White House are involved. We're not protecting the President by hoping this is not going to go away.
EhrlichmanThe thing is not going to go away, John. And by your sitting up there in New York and pretending that it is, it's just making it worse. It's been getting steadily worse on account of your sitting up there for the last couple months, we're at the point now where we have no choice but to ask you to do this."
HaldemanAnd you know, you can say we have a whole series of people who have remained mum in order not to create problems for you, who, it's unfair to them
NixonI mean, like Hunt, but they, no. I mean like Paul and Dean.
EhrlichmanI could say, when I got into this, I discovered that there were all kinds of people sitting around here who had bits and pieces of information, they were hanging on to them. They didn't know whether to dud. Well, and because they were afraid they would hurt John Mitchell.
EhrlichmanAnd I have had to put this whole thing together, and now having put it together,
NixonThere's no escape, John. There's just no escape.
Ehrlichmanit's got to be done. It's a necessity, fighting. Nobody else can do it. He won't be able to persuade anyone else. The fact of it is that nobody else can do it. And also,
EhrlichmanLet me digress a moment before we get to the side with Mitchell. Another indication of the problem you've got here. We talked about it last night, about the fact that they are eager to get to anyway.
HaldemanI just think we're in an impossible position frankly with regard to White House people on this thing, whatever they do. And you've gone over that with Ziegler, and he still thinks we can hold on.
EhrlichmanI hear you've got it's not tough in the line, for today. Out here, you've got Dean. I've just looking in the paper this morning. Saxbe,
NixonSaxbe. Mathias.
EhrlichmanThose aren't new names, remember? But they're all there. They're trying to build that up into chorus of Republicans. There're more. They're going to find a day for the next month. What they do, and what's interesting, is not universal chorus, you must appear before the committee.
EhrlichmanWell, see, you've got Sam saying that they've got to set up a way to take secret testimony, you have to set up [crosstalk] an executive session.
Nixon[crosstalk] That's right.
EhrlichmanYou have John Williams uh uh
NixonYou got also even Baker.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonFine, Baker does not stay healthy.
EhrlichmanHe's protected himself on that.
EhrlichmanLetter's very strong. The guy said, "Set up a way and such a procedure." Exactly.
NixonYeah, and everybody has felt that our own people are all saying that we're having a big confrontation.
EhrlichmanIt's so hot. In fact they had a a May 9th dinner, I think that's the I think a lot of that is bullshit, frankly. I mean we heard that at the time. You know, when we did Cambodia, you said that it never the story's not true, it's just what the papers said.
NixonWhat in the name, Bob, let me ask you a curious question. I thought our relations with MacGregor were not strained. I thought he's all through with it. Yeah. But he has always been holier than thou on Watergate.
NixonAnd why does he go out and say that it cost a million and a half votes? What did he want to win by? Want to win by 20 million?
EhrlichmanWell, that's a that's Clark MacGregor's boys, yeah. They say, "Well, the"
NixonBut he doesn't realize at that place, look at the
EhrlichmanNo, he doesn't.
EhrlichmanAll right, well Clark, Mr. President, Clark MacGregor thinks you screwed himself up time after time in press conferences where he said things he didn't want to say.
EhrlichmanWhen he came in as White House Congressional guy. Yeah. He was quoted all over town over and over as saying,
Ehrlichman"Bryce Harlow is a stupid ass who took this, fucked it all up, but I've come here to save it. I saw the dumb flaws by Ehrlichman and the President don't know how to handle Congress, but fortunately, I can save you." [laughter] In fact, that I think
NixonThe question that I have there, John, and let's come back to the Congressional committee. What, in the name of God, is Ziegler's uh What does Ziegler suggest as an alternative? Stone-wall the committee?
EhrlichmanWell, when you when you get to that, well, if he recognizes that there's a problem, and
NixonYou see, the point is the point is, uh I believe that cooperation with the committee might at least indicate no cover-up. That's what I'm hoping.
EhrlichmanWell, and that story will come out. Uh, all right, we're going to go through a a period now where we'll take some gas. All right.
EhrlichmanUh, for instance, uh, Kilpatrick was on my radio this morning. Just tape, Kleindienst, the part's on. Terrible.
NixonKleindienst didn't report that out.
EhrlichmanNow that was a tactic. Kleindienst took a hard line up there, because if he had softened at all,
NixonYeah.
Ehrlichmanthat would've really hurt our negotiation.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanAnd so uh we're going to take some temporary gas from that, but I think, you know, in the long haul it'll come out okay. Now, I may be wrong with that, but I think it will.
NixonWhat do you think, Bob? We just continue to negotiate?
HaldemanYeah.
NixonWhat is your view, John, as to how the committee then ought How do you want to come out of your negotiations?
EhrlichmanWell, I have to I'm going to be a little busy tomorrow. I understand. I'm going to see Sam.
EhrlichmanAnd then I've already reserved my house and I'm What do you want? Call a meeting. What do you want to You sent for paper? Is that what Well, I'm going to I'm going to go to our Executive
NixonYeah.
Ehrlichmanour Executive Session. Uh and set this up for it. The story to way that we can do it for all kids, right, including Kissinger and and take the take the poison out of the whole relationship and so on.
EhrlichmanThey're going to They're going to say to me, "Well, it's been nice meeting and we appreciate your courtesy, and the orders have been great. We're now going to go off and write our own set of rules. You understand, we can't be bound by your point of view."
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanAnd, "Then you guys in the White House are just going to have to decide whether you can live with our rules or not, take it or leave it, and you'll say."
EhrlichmanOkay, fine. Well, let's then talk about procedures for a lawsuit, cuz I think that's where we're heading.
EhrlichmanUm, let's let's uh I'm going to I'm going to dig him about uh Mr. Lipschutz and soften him up a little bit if I can. But then I'm going to say, "Let's not take
NixonWhat are you going to say about Mr. Lipschutz?
EhrlichmanWell, I think I think we can have quite a lot of fun with that. In terms of this whole thing.
Ehrlichmaneighty days to do it. You know. And and I'm going to try and work out a process with them
EhrlichmanDash to Garment.
EhrlichmanIf they want a test case, we'll frame a test case. They'll serve a subpoena.
EhrlichmanWe'll either move to quash it or uh they can go through the uh the contempt process. But I think the motion to quash is the best way to go about that.
EhrlichmanAnd figure out how we can do a stipulated record. And do it fast.
EhrlichmanAnd do it before the before the Federal District Court.
EhrlichmanNow, I think they'll agree to that.
EhrlichmanI certainly have not given them any reason to be antagonistic.
NixonAnd that may be the one Wow. Take that plus out of this prosecuting effort. Do we want to
Nixonuh
EhrlichmanWell, now here's here's what I'm We don't want a court Here's what I'm getting at.
EhrlichmanThe court case will delay
Ehrlichmanuh any appearance by any White House people.
EhrlichmanWe agree that we'll abide the outcome of the case.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanThen, if Mitchell does get indicted,
EhrlichmanMitchell's lawyers are going to, somehow, move to stop the Ervin hearings.
NixonWho is the that's your analysis or Shapiro's?
EhrlichmanThat's Shapiro's analysis also, and I have respect for his for his uh ability. He was quite on that ground.
NixonIn Washington you can't get a fair trial.
EhrlichmanYeah. What what do they say? Well, how about making Segretti, you want him?
NixonWhy can't they limit their Why can't they
Nixonsay, "Nothing to Watergate. We done Watergate, the rest they've thrown everything out the five out of the world." Is it does that mean Segretti's lost his
HaldemanWell, the problem the problem you've got here is that they've got Mitchell.
EhrlichmanThey have to move.
HaldemanSure.
EhrlichmanThey've got this The press has inextricably linked the Segretti's.
NixonThat's what we tried to separate.
EhrlichmanWell, and all they have to do is take a look at Ervin's big long resolution of scope.
EhrlichmanAnd the judge will take a look at that and think, "Geez, I can't let this go on
Ehrlichmanwhile I have this defendant here charged with these things."
NixonJohn, is that better than the cave in?
EhrlichmanOh, I don't have the option of caving in at any time.
NixonDo you want to cave now?
EhrlichmanNow let now let, let me let me put it this way, Mitchell.
NixonYes, I do. Let me put it this way. Say, why can't Why can't Putting it in quite candor,
NixonMitchell uh,
Nixonis going to break tomorrow.
EhrlichmanThat's the Watergate.
NixonAll right.
NixonGetting at is that uh it would be better
NixonFrankly, if after Mitchell is indicted, then if we cave.
NixonI don't think that's very good.
NixonI think it's a hell of a lot better for us to be forthcoming before he's indicted. But, but that problem is not for you to consider.
EhrlichmanYou asked me, "Do I want to cave now?"
EhrlichmanMy
Ehrlichmanmy feeling about this whole thing is
Ehrlichmanthat we ought to be looking in every nook and cranny for every
Ehrlichmandevice that there is to be forthcoming.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanAnd this is a this is a place where we can do it.
EhrlichmanAnd my sense of this whole case is that our best defense
NixonIs to do it.
Ehrlichmanis that, hell, the President's always wanted this to happen.
EhrlichmanAnd that and that we weren't being cute about this at all. All right. That's conquered.
NixonUh but let's go on to the other side. You say tell them, see our guys up there in the dock and then they're like convicted criminals and doomed in the bad for the White House.
NixonYou're going to have that continuing thing, "Cover-up, cover-up, cover-up, cover-up, cover-up."
EhrlichmanRape is inevitable.
NixonThat's the problem.
EhrlichmanIn life, that uh Well,
EhrlichmanI'm not so sure you are going to have the continuing fear cover-up if you fuss it.
NixonYeah, but
Ehrlichmanobviously that there the Ervin thing goes on and you got all of us and all that, but you're down to a different level of stuff
Ehrlichmanthan you are if you cluster the Watergate case.
HaldemanYou're down to a level of of uh who hired Segretti and I think I've got to get out front on that.
NixonBefore, before it comes out there.
HaldemanWell, I think Chapin gets out front on that too. That's sure. Because I think we should make a statement.
NixonHow does that come along with Henry's thing?
HaldemanFunny you think. Can I Can I digress a moment to to Segretti? I would like to get that son of a bitch out of the way, but uh what did you do?
NixonLike I But you haven't talked to Stan then?
HaldemanYes.
EhrlichmanIf the Mitchell thing breaks
Ehrlichmanand it's done, let's say they'll sit and go ahead with that, starts breaking. And again, if you get into a big vomiting up of Watergate,
Ehrlichmanit seems to me that's the best possible time, place, and atmosphere
Ehrlichmanfor my statement to come out.
EhrlichmanThe timing being that, obviously, I couldn't go out publicly and say this. I've been sitting here wanting to tell my story, waiting for the Senate committee to get off its ass.
EhrlichmanAnd uh nothing's happening here and I couldn't go out unilaterally and do it while while this uh process was running in the grand jury. But now they've
Ehrlichmancome to their conclusions and uh the people in Watergate did that. Now,
Ehrlichmanlet's get the rest of this story covered, too. Because that doesn't the rest of it doesn't involve criminals.
NixonNo, accept
EhrlichmanExcept he stepped in the middle of it.
NixonWell, I got that problem. That's it.
EhrlichmanYou got a you got a kid who's staying in the middle of it.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanNobody knows that yet.
EhrlichmanWe do.
EhrlichmanNow, here's what here's what you might do.
EhrlichmanErvin Ervin says that on Tuesday they have that committee that hope with their rules.
EhrlichmanThey will also take their date for hearings, Tuesday.
EhrlichmanMay the 1st, May the 8th, May whatever it is. During recess or something?
EhrlichmanThat's the same, this is our last regular meeting. You see, prior to the recess.
HaldemanFine.
EhrlichmanUh,
Ehrlichmanif you come out then in response to that and say, "Well,
Ehrlichmannow they announce they're not going to have their meeting until May.
EhrlichmanI've been sitting here waiting.
EhrlichmanI can't wait any longer.
EhrlichmanHere's my statement.
HaldemanI wouldn't off-skate it with the grand jury and so forth. That makes it look like it was dragged out of you. And also it also gets it all into it it
HaldemanThe one that says, "And also today,
HaldemanBob Haldeman admits that he was behind the Segretti thing." I'd rather have the story separate uh
EhrlichmanThat's my problem, you know.
HaldemanThat's your contribution.
HaldemanYeah, I I don't feel comfortable with his relating it to the grand jury at all. He just said like, "Well, this is all coming out anyway. So I'm going to make a statement."
EhrlichmanWhat's your reason?
HaldemanHow did How did you relate it to the committee when the committee has not called you yet?
Ehrlichman"I wanted early hear- I wanted to be that's it." You could Ehrlichman could come out and say that Haldeman, at all, has urged Ervin early hearings.
HaldemanAs soon as we get some.
EhrlichmanOh, all right. So, as soon as they they piss me off and publish their rules, or whatever. Well,
HaldemanEhrlichman doesn't have to get out. I can get out,
Haldemanput out my statement, say that that I had urged early hearing, and they're
Haldemanand and that that he's tried to work that out and they won't. I'd like to have I'd like to get I'd like to get that story out right now, frankly.
EhrlichmanYeah. "Ehrlichman has urged early hearings."
HaldemanWell, don't you see, we don't want early hearings.
EhrlichmanUh Number one,
EhrlichmanI don't want. Number two,
EhrlichmanI I have a commitment to Ervin and Baker.
NixonNot to discuss.
EhrlichmanThat I won't discuss these negotiations until they're over.
EhrlichmanAnd uh unless I want to blow them sky high, I shouldn't do that.
NixonWell, we're just spitballing, Bob.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonAnd and uh coming back to that, and I think John's scenario, Bob, is better. I'd like to separate the two cases, and I get the goddamned Segretti thing out.
HaldemanWednesday, Wednesday maybe uh
Haldemanthe day.
NixonWednesday, why?
EhrlichmanBecause they meet Tuesday.
HaldemanOh, I see. In other words, Ervin's committee says Tuesday that they to deal with it, it's not time that that's too long, you you could put out a statement which says, "I had nothing to do with Watergate.
HaldemanI think at this at this I would say,
Haldeman"But second, I want to say what we what we did, and I had this to do with Segretti." I wouldn't worry about the fact that that it could come back and say, "Well, what did you do about this or that or this point?"
HaldemanI just think that's making a forthcoming statement that can be sent to everybody, that'll buy us some time.
EhrlichmanYou can buy them time, Bob. Now, if you do it under the umbrella of Mitchell
Ehrlichmanindictment now, uh
HaldemanThe Mitchell thing will come later.
EhrlichmanIn fact, it may not come. So, I don't mean that fact, but uh The thing is if they go
Ehrlichmanforth fast,
Ehrlichmanif if Mitchell today agreed to this,
EhrlichmanAnd he and O'Brien, their other lawyers, are going over to see Silbert this afternoon.
NixonAnd give a statement.
EhrlichmanRight.
NixonHe could put it out. He he he
EhrlichmanHe could.
NixonHe could get in this murder before that happening.
EhrlichmanSilbert could file an information as early as Monday or Tuesday, so he wouldn't have to give that eight-business-day thing.
NixonYeah.
HaldemanWe don't even know yet what Magruder's going to do.
NixonUh-huh.
EhrlichmanWell, does it does it really matter?
HaldemanNo.
EhrlichmanSee, once you're possessed of this information—
HaldemanYeah. What's Dean going to put out now? That's what I don't know.
EhrlichmanNeither does he.
HaldemanI think What Whether Mitchell, that's who you're bargaining with, Mitchell, I mean.
NixonMitchell's going to say, "Well, I don't know what—" Jess, how do you know Jess's going to do that?
EhrlichmanI don't. I don't, but it doesn't matter, now.
NixonOthers, they've got other information that says it.
EhrlichmanRight.
NixonHow do you know that, John?
EhrlichmanWell,
NixonWe got some sources inside the inside the U.S. attorney's process?
EhrlichmanRight.
NixonI don't know how good they are, John.
EhrlichmanSo, is another attorney [unintelligible]
NixonYou watch out. We've just been uh But uh everything that I've been
HaldemanYou think John's the bad sources, is that the problem? You're trying to give him a little bit of a shed.
EhrlichmanWe don't our sources. Our sources are are are Shapiro. All right. Dean Dean Dean and his lawyers have sources in the U.S. Attorney's
NixonHold on. Right. Right.
Ehrlichmancourt, and they got the other two grand juries [unintelligible].
NixonTell me, uh can I spend a minute? I That's the thing that I wanted to know. I knew about the New York grand jury.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonWhat in essence is that? Vesco, I I
EhrlichmanIt's a runaway It's a runaway grand jury. Yeah. It started out as an SEC action against Vesco
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanRight. uh for a violation of the Securities Act.
EhrlichmanThey then bumped into this $200-some-thousand donation to the campaign.
NixonAll right. Right.
EhrlichmanThey have been on that since. And they've had Stans up and they've had
NixonRight.
Ehrlichmanhad Mitchell in. And they're working on the question of whether or not Vesco procured an appointment with the Attorney General of the United States in consideration of a $200,000 campaign
NixonOh, my god.
Ehrlichmangift. And Harry Sears talked to that. Violation of Section 201.
EhrlichmanNow, they have a witness who was sitting in the room with Vesco and Stans.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanNow, Vesco came in and said, "Mr. Stans, how does a guy get to be a big contributor?"
EhrlichmanStans said, "Well, the word big means $200,000."
EhrlichmanAnd Vesco said, "Cash or check?"
EhrlichmanAnd uh Maury said, "Either one."
NixonAnd he said, This is after my poor brother had talked to him?
EhrlichmanI'm not sure. I don't know if before or after, maybe. I just don't know, but, in any event, he said, uh, "Well, how does one work out quid pro quo?"
Ehrlichman[laughter] And Maury said, "Well, what's your problem?"
EhrlichmanAnd he said, "Well, I'm afraid the Justice Department is after me on an SEC violation."
NixonMm.
EhrlichmanAnd Maury said, in effect, uh, "I don't know what I can do about that, but let's see."
EhrlichmanVesco then got a phone call, allegedly, from John Mitchell.
NixonMm-mm.
EhrlichmanNow, that's enough to indict.
NixonWhew! They're done.
EhrlichmanBecause Vesco, as a result of the phone call, got an appointment to go in. It was like that.
NixonI'm afraid they're done.
HaldemanYou know, I mean, I I can imagine that.
NixonOh, man. So, we're in a bit different Now, that may not be enough to convict, but it's enough to indict.
EhrlichmanNow, that may not be enough to convict, but it's enough to indict.
NixonAll right, what's the other case? The other case, Bob knows more about than I do. It's some contractor named Kline.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonWhere is he, in Baltimore? And it's a And the And where is the grand jury? Here in Washington? Here, DC.
EhrlichmanDC. Right.
NixonDC. What is it?
EhrlichmanYou probably know about the other things. This There's a third [unintelligible] because the Vice President that's who he wants to jar us into being worried about him, but where it boils down to, he says, we should be worried about Agnew, not just about him.
NixonThere's a grand jury in Baltimore.
EhrlichmanBaltimore.
NixonWell, that isn't about us, I hope, for Christ's sakes.
EhrlichmanNo, he tries to get us to He does, in order to jar us into being worried about him, but where it boils down to, he says, we should worry about him over the other one.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanUh because he says, if that thing runs its course, he will be through.
NixonHuh.
EhrlichmanI think I can't I don't know how Kline is involved except that it relates to a guy named, what the heck's his name? One is regional finance chairman, Ralph Christman.
NixonThey're Republicans?
Ehrlichmanfor the Committee to Re-Elect. Huh?
NixonUh, who was Was he Jewish?
EhrlichmanNo.
EhrlichmanUh, he was a a an old crony of Agnew's.
NixonOh, this finance guy that's became Stans's regional chair.
NixonMost of these are Jewish though, in Baltimore, but go ahead.
EhrlichmanNo, this one isn't.
NixonI don't care, it doesn't doesn't prove goddamn thing.
EhrlichmanAnyway, so, John, on that side, that finance chairman of CREEP Go ahead, go ahead.
NixonGo ahead, go ahead.
Ehrlichmanthat guy is involved in this Kline business.
EhrlichmanAnd what the Vice President told John, in the effort to jar us into being worried about his case, is that Kline
Ehrlichmanon the Kline grand jury they've developed that Kline came to Mitchell's office
Ehrlichmanwith a bag of cash which he turned over to Mitchell.
NixonWhat point in time?
EhrlichmanWe don't know when, but it was allegedly involved in his receiving some very good government contracts.
EhrlichmanWhy the Vice President's worried about that, which may get us worried about, so that we'll worry about what he's worried about, which is the Baltimore
NixonLet me tell you, Hal's the name, for God's sake, did you give government contracts? I mean, did you got Kline a government contract as a result of this?
EhrlichmanHe doesn't have to get them. He just has to be promised.
NixonOh, I see.
EhrlichmanAnd uh—
NixonMitchell didn't That Shapiro Mitchell would Mitchell
EhrlichmanShapiro told That's who told this to John.
NixonI can't believe that. I can't believe that John Mitchell would take money in his goddamn office.
NixonA candidate never takes money, for Christ's sakes.
NixonYou take this uh You take this Howard Hughes thing, you know, that they they they try to get in. And then the beauty of uh having a guy like Bebe around the system,
Nixonyou know, they they tried like hell to give the money to me in 1968. And Bebe kept saying, "Not only to me and that you're not going to be choice, but take the fucking checks."
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonYou know? And, thank God, finally
EhrlichmanWell, if this had been after Mitchell left Justice, it may have been that Mitchell was a campaign manager. But, it's a different matter, he's not guilty then.
NixonWell, it depends on whether he is Attorney General.
NixonI don't know, as Attorney General, that's what John says, based on the telephone calls to Vesco, that'd be a prima facie case. Well, that is what they're telling me. I don't I don't know any of the laws.
HaldemanAll right, what's the Vice President's What's the Vice President's problem?
Ehrlichmanis that there's a guy named Wolff,
Nixonsomething Wolff.
EhrlichmanAll right.
Ehrlichmanwho worked for him over the years as as the county executive and all through the years up through governor, and brought him over here to the to work in the
NixonMm-mm.
EhrlichmanSpace Council or something. Now, he and then he left. And now he's a consulting engineer.
EhrlichmanThis guy was the Vice President's "D" on all financial stuff when he was governor and county executive.
EhrlichmanAnd in Baltimore and Maryland, there is a campaign contribution law that prohibits contributions in excess of $2,500.
EhrlichmanTherefore, everybody deals in what they call Maryland money, which is cash.
EhrlichmanAnd, in cash, deals, apparently, greatly in excess of $2,500 came from Kline and other contractors.
NixonHow much did Mathias get, some?
EhrlichmanAnd that he's contended that there is no problem, legally,
Ehrlichmanin this, that this is money in a PR problem, because, in these meetings,
Ehrlichmanhaving this governor or county executive,
Ehrlichmanthey would review lists
Ehrlichmanand say, uh, "Who got this contract for the for the Frostburg bridge?" And it's fun to hear. Who is this guy? How much support did they give us?
EhrlichmanWell, they've got it, now go hit them for $X, get this underground edge.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanAnd that kind of stuff.
NixonGovernors governors governors.
EhrlichmanThis fellow, named Wolff, sat in these meetings and wrote these comments down
Ehrlichmanverbatim.
NixonWolff, Agnew's assistant?
EhrlichmanYes, right. W-o-l-f-f. And kept his notes.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanHow about that? And when the grand jury started bouncing around on this stuff, and the U.S. Attorney got to him, the U.S. Attorney happens to be Glen Beall's brother.
Ehrlichmanthe U.S. Attorney said you've got to put down your things you better get a lawyer. Wolfe ran to a lawyer and handed him all these notes that have all sorts of little spiral notebook pages [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanWell, and his lawyer got a little shook and called George White. White has buddies and lawyers out there and said, "I think you've got a problem." I wonder if this happened. Well, it's possible.
NixonThe white-collar conviction. White came down. Said, "Thank God I was never elected to the." [laughter] Well, the governors John, you know, this is so common for the [unintelligible] every governor of Illinois, look at Kerner. Didn't tell you about Kane?
EhrlichmanGovernor of Maryland, Governor Agnew had the whole damn thing on his desk. He pulled out the scissors and the same problems in Maryland. Right, well hell, Hell, well hell! That's it. Well,
NixonSo, is so what do they want us to do?
EhrlichmanWell, they wanted me to call Glenndell to tell Glenndell to tell his brother to get to lay off of these guys, that they had no indictable action there, that they'd already indicted the guy who received all of this, and that's all they needed. And,
EhrlichmanAll that. I said, God, I you know, I shouldn't I shouldn't be doing this. Hell, he said, "You've got problems. We're we're stuck. I don't know what's to be done here."
EhrlichmanAnd as a result of that, I all I did, and what I did was push it Chuck Colson in touch with George White. White was out here and asked, what are we supposed to do? Chuck said, "I don't think you can do a damn thing, and Colson asked, "What are we supposed to do? I said, "I don't know, but damned if I'm not going to be back there.
NixonThe way to always handle all well, no I'm done. Is to always say, look, we can't do a thing here. You might call Colson or somebody like that, or get outside and hire you a lawyer.
EhrlichmanThat's what I did. That's, I talked to John before I did it. Yeah, and then Colson,
EhrlichmanAnd I called Colson and said, "You will be hearing from George White of some problems and they want to talk to you about it." And, "What am I supposed to do?" He said, "I talked to White. White's sitting outside my office. What am I supposed to do?" I said, "I don't think you do a damn thing. What did White say?
NixonNo, I wouldn't call him. Well, I'd stay away from him. Oh, so would I. Like, I wouldn't we can't we can't squash the case. I don't think they're going to. I don't think they'll do it. No. I don't think that's indicted.
EhrlichmanNot either. Now, Maryland politics is mysterious. I did, too, sure. But I just can't imagine Glenndell's brother getting the Vice President's taking him, you know, into this and so forth. Oh, there's no question that there is nothing indictable on the Vice President. How
Nixonthat's how we're going to get hurt, though. The evidence to use in indicting others which will implicate the Vice President. That's, well, he's just got to ride that through. What the hell! So, we're going to have an agreement. The promise that he said
EhrlichmanAnd he thought that I have that 1976 would be totally down the drain. Well, it's done. Yeah, that didn't help. Yeah, the Vice President. Hell, yeah. I don't get you know, the problem,
Nixonthat is the major wonder of all of our candidacies. Who comes out of that? I suppose the thing questions is that sticks out there? Yeah, yeah. And, thank God, it's his brothers who has been into this shit. And uh that's bad. Any governor,
NixonSenator [unintelligible] on phone. I wonder if you shouldn't use 65 on this problem, Weicker now, rather than farting around and waiting for Bobby [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanI I'm They're not set yet. I'd like I'd like to get Weicker working.
EhrlichmanSure, but let's wait a and see. They kicking off the committee right now, and and we wouldn't really have got I'd rather get that committee composed, get it started with its hearing. Weicker's integral part of it.
EhrlichmanAnd then blast him off there. That's true. He'd be better off if he could kick off. Yes, sure. He was the former Attorney General.
EhrlichmanAnd it doesn't you see, it doesn't fight any battle, damn you, if you get Let me say this, too. Weicker, being what he is, he'll make a lot of headlines, and all that, but he is not, fortunately, very smart. And, I'd rather have him up there kind of trying to do it with all this PR techniques, than a smart son of a bitch who could who could really Well, it's good having one, because everybody now, pretty much, is against
NixonWell, he makes problems every every day. He's got, these dog gone kind of problems, gave marvelous newspapers wanting to Weicker's staff is what is horrid.
EhrlichmanUh uh, that's what I told him this morning. The guy came up and said, "Hey, Weicker's staff men are calling every secretary who ever worked at the Committee and asking them questions. Do you know? And uh, what what should we do? And I said, well, who are you? Well, the secretaries are asking for instructions.
EhrlichmanWell, you tell them that they will only speak to a duly-authorized staff person from the Ervin committee. Mayor's staff, of course.
NixonAs I know there's friction between Ervin and Weicker about this business of Weicker's staff. Why didn't you just slip that in? Let the Ervin have Ervin that's right
NixonWhy shouldn't you deal with the Senate? What do you want us to do, Senator? Do you want us to cooperate? Should our people We want to cooperate. And, as you know, they are cooperating with your staff. On the other hand, Mr. Weicker's calling everybody, he's he's pissed off. And we just want to know who is running the show here.
EhrlichmanPick a fight soon then. We can also throw in Kleindienst. See, what that gives me, though, is an excuse to call him. Yeah.
NixonYou haven't heard from that secretary yet? No, what was it, a full report one of the secretaries who the guy talked to. You have it? Yeah. He's questioning. And she kept him thinking about it. After, called him back. She said, "Why are you asking me all these questions?" "Well, honey, you know, we'd be just as interested, she's a girl who works on the White House staff.
EhrlichmanShe used to work with him. Said, "Honey, we'd be just as interested in you if you were working in an architect's office." And gave names and dresses. Uh that's just typical of what she did.
NixonDid a good job. You might want to talk to the girl. Supposing you call him and say that we've had this problem, Senator. What do you want us to do? Yeah. The only Member of the committee, I want to know who is doing this investigation. Because our people are perturbed now, the secretaries and the rest of them. And we want to cooperate, we want to go with you, as they have.
NixonWe just can't take every individual Member, the Senators having conducted their own investigations, now. Whatever you say. Say, I want, so that when we turn Weicker down, it will be Ervin's question. And it's and it's a little difficult here, because our people have agreed to cooperate with your people. You could say, that you could say, "Senator, now, we are not going to turn this down, unless you tell us to. We just want you to know that that you want us to go ahead, well, we'll arrange for them to do it. But we want you to
Nixonto go over that, you know, I mean.
EhrlichmanGet the specific calls, and help him, could be on the phone. OK, John. Thank you. Okay, Chuck Colson. Maybe on the 10th. If they're free.
NixonTell somebody today. You've got to make this move today. If it fails, uh you've got to get a backup position. Then you want to call Burger?
NixonI agree. If you call Burger not yet? Well, so that means between now and when you want to go in. Ran through, Burgess offer to Burgess.
EhrlichmanThird, we've got the Hunt thing in terms of huntings.
HaldemanNow lunch up which is going to be about 40 minutes [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanIt's really nine o'clock. And you're white? Yeah. Who is your personal visitor? She has, you see the point is
NixonI'll take that.
EhrlichmanTell him the basis [unintelligible]. Yeah. Say that the evidence is not clear. I can't simply say that it's thought other people with
Nixontime to dismiss Jeb although although he may blow.
EhrlichmanI can say I can say that there's a a uh that I have I have come to the conclusion that it is both John and Jeb who are our liability.
NixonAnd uh. Well, but no, what I meant. Yeah, go ahead. I was going to say didn't would not telling you John was because Jeb is in the prayer or if you're going to get an order to be in as well to the grand jury past that point where they've got the case made. That's right.
HaldemanHe'll say, "Well, I think they're bluffing, John." What do you say?
EhrlichmanThere's no question of bluffing. Nobody has made any representations to us at all. Nobody's tried to bluff us. Uh it's just a question of putting together all of the facts.
EhrlichmanAnd anytime someone if the US attorney's office goes through the process that I've gone through, they'll have all the facts.
EhrlichmanInevitably and they don't get them all from any one person, so that it's some from this one and some from that one and it's a typical it's a jigsaw puzzle.
NixonNow how does Dean incidentally, what is the What is the What is the liability of uh Hunt?
EhrlichmanAll right, now we hang up I think on the payoff thing. Yeah. But that's business somebody had done.
EhrlichmanDean Dean has said told me about the problem of Hunt's lawyer uh wanting having come This was a few weeks ago.
Ehrlichmanneeded uh needed $60,000 or $40,000 or something like that. Do you remember? And we talked. He said, "I don't know where you can get it." I said, "I would uh I mean I frankly thought
EhrlichmanMike tried to get it, but I didn't know where." And then uh he left it off with Mitchell and then Mitchell then said it was being taken care of. Am I correct?
HaldemanMy recollection that's highly, approximately correct.
NixonDid he talk to you about that?
EhrlichmanHe talked to me about it. I said, "John, I wouldn't have the faintest idea how to get it." I saw him later in the day. I saw Mitchell later in the day.
EhrlichmanThat's correct. I came home with you. Yeah, I helped with whatever. And he just said it's taken care of. Mitchell raised the problem, turned to Dean and said, "What have you done about that that other problem?" And Dean said, and kind of looked at us, and then said, "Well,
EhrlichmanI I don't have anything."
EhrlichmanAnd Mitchell said, "Well, I guess that's all taken care of." And it turned out that LaRue took it in. Yeah. LaRue.
NixonDid you ever talk with him?
EhrlichmanDean told us LaRue. Dean Dean saw and talked with LaRue.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanAnd LaRue said this whole thing was ridiculous now, said, he was the one that said, yeah, then
EhrlichmanHe said, "If I were in charge of this now, what I would do is I'd get a large bus, and I'd put the President and we and uh and everybody we got around here in it,
Ehrlichmanand I'd drive up to the Senate, and I'd have the President open the door, and I'd say, 'You all get out and tell them everything you know, and I'll be back to pick you up when you're through.'"
EhrlichmanHe says it's so out now, there's just simply no use, he said, I can, and he said LaRue also said, "Now, I can't figure out how I got into this.
EhrlichmanI don't have to be candid with you, but I I it seems to me all of us have been drawn in here and trying to cover up for John." For Mitchell? Yeah. Which is exactly what's happened.
NixonLaRue said that?
EhrlichmanYes.
EhrlichmanFair and square. And if LaRue is called, LaRue is is is just as thorough as they come, isn't he? Yeah.
NixonNow. What will be be his defense? I don't know.
EhrlichmanHow did you cross? I don't know. I don't think he has Maybe he doesn't have any.
NixonNo, I know. His obstruction would be the rule uh that I was helping you out.
EhrlichmanAll right, the way Dean talked, LaRue wasn't thinking about defenses. I don't think LaRue cares. I think LaRue's figured that jig is up.
NixonWell, then incidentally, what about this if there is that there is money to small.
EhrlichmanNow, if Dean's cover story, which he fed to the Ervin committee, to lay it all back in the White House.
NixonYeah.
EhrlichmanIf they don't buy it, they will know that if they do, will always stand.
EhrlichmanSo long as Mitchell stands. Lay it in the White House. That's all he has.
NixonThat's it.
EhrlichmanAnd uh. Well, he couldn't lay it in the White House. But bear bear in mind, Shapiro was giving me this in the whole litany of things that were
Ehrlichmanthat were persuasive [crosstalk] in other words. He was also a friend of Shapiro, wasn't he? What he said to me, "That's very odd.
EhrlichmanThat is uh that wouldn't be through the White House."
NixonUh but what I had uh Mardian very quite that uh that is say, I don't think that Mardian or LaRue or Mitchell
Ehrlichmanor LaRue or anybody wanna hurt the President [unintelligible]. Exactly.
NixonColson? How How about Colson?
EhrlichmanHe he I Present will do everything he can not to hurt the President, Yeah.
Nixonthat has got to be the attitude of everybody. Because it isn't the man, it's the goddamn office, you know? But, also, it happens to be true.
EhrlichmanRight. Entirely. By everybody except Dean.
EhrlichmanThey they don't have that that doesn't apply and they could, I think, rationalize to themselves that hurting or getting anybody else
Ehrlichmancould be tracking good for the President rather than bad. And that could be Ehrlichman, Haldeman, Dean. Oh. Certainly Colson.
NixonColson will be the top of those. Colson first,
Ehrlichmanthen Haldeman, then Dean, then Ehrlichman.
NixonYou see, I think of Mardian started the conversation frankly, that Colson [unintelligible] the heat on. Maybe. If he's got to the White House, the actors would be worried,
EhrlichmanMaybe Haldeman,
NixonMardian.
EhrlichmanI don't I mean, I don't think he has any personal desire to get me, but I think he would. I know he hates Colson.
NixonDoes he?
EhrlichmanTerribly.
NixonAnd every Mitchell person does. Every Mitchell person. You could make you see you can make a hell of circumstantial case on Colson.
EhrlichmanSure.
NixonHe's the guy that you know is Dean's buddy. And uh Liddy who well apparently was close to Colson.
EhrlichmanI'm sorry, I'd say with Hunt. Yeah, that. Of course. Right, say.
NixonWhat you know. But Colson is closer to this to the crew, the robbers, than anybody else. That's the problem. Colson Colson's got courage.
EhrlichmanWhere did he go, by the way?
NixonWell, then Hunt's Uh Hunt is the central core. Hunt, takes this money. says he want additional money. Well, they got to get in touch with Hunt. I don't know. They could get him into the grand jury.
Ehrlichmanthey wanted to give him a secret additional [unintelligible] they could have sent him

— 1 min 41 s with no transcribed speech —

NixonNow that's the point. That's the fallacy in the whole business, Howard, is that unless I had stepped up to him and said, "Look fellows, it's too bad, and, and, and I, I, I'll give you executive clemency late tomorrow,
Nixonwhat the hell do you think do you think Dean I mean do you think that that the bodies uh, the Cuban were going to sit on their ass in jail for four years and their families not taken care of?
EhrlichmanThat's the point. Now where did Hunt get the money for that?
EhrlichmanThat's the reason this whole thing falls of meaning that it's it's that that hides that that astonished me about the Mexican bank thing, probably.
NixonNot only very probable, there's no way he could get the money today. Who was it, Tom Pappas they have used?
NixonSee the, did you hear anything about Pappas?
EhrlichmanHuh?
NixonDid you hear anything about Pappas?
EhrlichmanI can remember you telling me to see him, oh, that, that somebody was helping out, was happening, you're seeing him, and you were seeing that Pappas was a contributor.
HaldemanAppreciate the work you're doing for us, and I have mentioned what it was.
NixonThat's right.
HaldemanIt was Mitchell's contact. Good old Tom is raising money apparently, doing this, this thing that's his concern.
EhrlichmanI know that he is, but uh the word the word never came up [crosstalk] that's uh
NixonI do. I do it. For the purpose of helping the poor bastards through the trials, but you can't have for that kind of You can't. Or could you? I guess you could. Legally?
NixonCould you could you build a support program for these people for for four years and, and—
EhrlichmanWell, they've supported other people this way, Harry Bridges and, and somebody Huh?
NixonI say, I don't know how the Berrigan brothers and some of those They all have support parades and the both cases.
EhrlichmanYes, there are a lot of defense funds and do-gooder defense funds. I guess that's who some of them But not to hush up.
NixonThat's right.
EhrlichmanThat's the point.
NixonAll right.
NixonOne final thing, Dean.
NixonYou don't think we have to bite him today?
EhrlichmanWell,
EhrlichmanI'm not so sure.
EhrlichmanUh I'm I'm inclined,
Ehrlichmanit's not bite him, it's simply a matter of making a decision, in in my opinion. Well, I've made the decision, he has to go. Well,
EhrlichmanI'm not sure that's the right decision. That's, by, by framing the issue, I don't mean to imply that oh, I see. I thought, oh, I thought,
Nixonoh, I see. I thought, no, I thought.
NixonAll right, well then you say you didn't agree with my, sorry, I thought that was one of the recommendations in your paper. No, my, my recommendation is that you recognize that
Ehrlichmanthat there's a go, no-go decision that has to be made right away, because, see, here's your situation, as I, looking again at the big picture: you now are possessed of a body of facts, right, and you got to you can't just sit here,
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanRight.
EhrlichmanYou got to act on it. You got to make some you got to make some decisions, and the Dean thing is one of the decisions that you have to make. You may decide, hold him, keep him on.
NixonYeah, I can find, fine shot. And then, you're not And then,
EhrlichmanYou've got to dispose of it one way or the other, um, um.
EhrlichmanThere may be, and and I'm, I'm,
NixonYeah.
NixonWhat's the uh, that uh, thing with uh, uh, eh, what time you got on him?
EhrlichmanQuarter after. On your calendar it's 20 after, but we can move it up.
EhrlichmanI tell you, I am still heavily persuaded that we affect
Ehrlichmanthe grand jury and the U.S. Attorney's treatment of Dean favorably by keeping him on.
NixonOkay.
EhrlichmanUh, and that that's important. Now, why, why would they Because they like him? No, no.
NixonNo, they,
EhrlichmanNo, but they treat him differently if he's the President's counsel than as a dismissed person. Exactly. Yeah. It's just a It's a very heavy psychological fact.
NixonWell, this will be done, because there's another reason, too. It isn't like you. Dean is not light-hearted, and let's face it. That's right. Dean is not light-hearted in this sense, too.
NixonDean, on, tried to do what he could do to pick up the goddamn pieces, and everybody else around here knew it had to be done. There's no doubt about that. Let's face it. I'm not blaming anybody else. I understand that. That was his job.
EhrlichmanI have I have great trouble in
Ehrlichmanin the light of the known involvement that he had. In the aftermath.
NixonRight.
EhrlichmanBut, but the involvement in the aftermath was for a, was what was understood here to be an improper purpose. That's, that, that's the question: what is his motive?
EhrlichmanYou bet. That's number one. Number two, there's nothing new about that.
NixonThat's right.
EhrlichmanAs I develop in this, and I'd like you to read this,
NixonYeah.
Ehrlichmanthere were eight or ten people around here who knew about this. Knew what was going on. Bob knew, I knew, all kinds of people knew it.
NixonWell, I knew it. I knew it. And it was not a question of that. Now, I do, I must say, though, I didn't know it,
NixonI must have assumed it, though,
Nixonbut and, fortunately, and I thank you both for arranging it that way, and it does show why the isolation of the President is a valuable thing at times.
NixonThe first time that I knew that they had to have the money
Nixonwas the time when
Nixonuh Dean told me that they needed $14,000. I hadn't been ref- In fact, I just I couldn't I closed my eyes, and I read about that paper on a little envelope. I didn't know about the envelopes on the doorsteps and all that stuff.
EhrlichmanWell,
NixonThe The But others didn't know.
EhrlichmanThe point is that that if Dean's, if the wrongdoing that justifies Dean's dismissal is his knowledge that that operation was going on,
Ehrlichmanthen you can't stop with him. You've got to go through the whole place wholesale. Fire the whole staff.
EhrlichmanThat's right. It's, it's a question of motive, it's a question of role, and I don't think Dean's role in the aftermath, at least on the facts that I know now,
Ehrlichmanachieves a level of wrongdoing that requires that you terminate him. And, and, and the other thing I think you made a very powerful point to me that that
Haldemanstrictly pragmatically as well as for everything else, in other words, cut your losses and get rid of him. Get an order, maybe they won't go after the main quarry.
HaldemanHe can't go. It is too obvious now that they know. And, more than that,
Ehrlichmanwe've made Dean a focal point of the grand jury proceedings, right,
Ehrlichmanand he will become a focal point of the Ervin panel. Oh, he'll have to. Yes, except that And he could go down, and if you dismiss him he'll still be the focal point.
EhrlichmanHe'll be a focal point, even if he, a deep frog. with less, with less protection, that's right,
Ehrlichmanand with less incentive. Well, the point that I have I think, John, you're quite right.
NixonThe problem with Dean's position on this, this, this whole process, yeah, in terms of the higher good, But Dean,
Nixonyou've got to have a talk with Dean, I feel that I should not talk to him.
EhrlichmanI have talked to him.
NixonWhat about, I mean about motive. I have talked to him.
NixonWhat did he say about motive? Did he say it was hush up?
EhrlichmanNo. He says he knew, he, he had to know that people were trying to bring that result about.
EhrlichmanAnd he said, "You know, the way I got into this was, I would go to meetings in, in campaign headquarters, um, and uh
Ehrlichmanwe'd get through the meeting and Mitchell and LaRue would say to, would say to uh, or, or LaRue would say to Mitchell, 'Now you've got to do something about this.' And Mitchell's stock answer was, to turn to John Dean.
NixonSay, "What are you going to do?" "What are you going to do?"
EhrlichmanAnd, uh, so John said, "I had to be a kind of a, of a kind of a water carrier. I came back from those meetings, and I came in to see Bob or maybe or somebody else, and say, 'Well, Mitchell's got this big problem,'
Ehrlichmanand then," he'd say, "they'd say to me, 'Well, I don't know what, what'll he do?'" When he came in to see Bob and you, what would he say, was it Bob? Uh, he'd say, "These, these guys uh, uh, Hunt's getting uh, jittery, and uh, and says that he's got to have umpteen thousand dollars, and uh, Mitchell's terribly worried about it,
NixonWhen he came in to see Bob and you, what would he say, was it Bob?
Ehrlichmanand uh, uh, it was never expressed, but it was certainly understood.
NixonGood, good. For beyond the question of motive, then, all of these conversations would be put in perspective.
HaldemanThe motive was never discussed. Never discussed with me, and those are the facts.
NixonThe motive was to help defendants who were, by God, who worked for the campaign committee. That really got that far, because
Ehrlichmanat least my conversation with John always was, well, that's interesting. I just don't know what to do about it.
HaldemanYeah. It may have gone further with Kalmbach.
EhrlichmanWe were turning to Kalmbach. You aimed him at Kalmbach. I aimed him at Mitchell. That's as far as we came close to being involved, really, in it.
HaldemanThe one thing where it did go further, if you want to argue that, was in the sense that the $350,000, which was, after all, our money, was given through the back door then for this purpose. You can make a argument on that.
NixonWho asked for it?
HaldemanNobody.
EhrlichmanI don't know who. Who could have asked for that? Who put the move on for the 350?
HaldemanLaRue. Gordon Strachan came to me after the election and said, "You have $350,000 in cash, do you want to deliver it—"
NixonThat was not requested by LaRue.
HaldemanOf course. Well, the problem was getting him to take it back. They wouldn't take it. See, they didn't know how to [crosstalk] LaRue didn't know what to do about it.
Ehrlichman[crosstalk] LaRue wanted it. But Mitchell wouldn't let him take it. He didn't know how to account for it. Well, it doesn't make—the bank wouldn't let him account for it. He was enough of a
Haldeman70-mile [unintelligible] who is in personal receipt, the grand jury knows, of $328,000 in cash, delivered to him, part of it by Gordon Strachan.
NixonThe witnesses to that transaction are Strachan and LaRue.
HaldemanAnd Strachan has testified to that, what happened.
EhrlichmanWell, LaRue's got a problem. What did he do with it? At that point, it's his problem.
HaldemanHe's got an IRS problem. He can't— Now, can he clear himself by virtue of saying, "I used it for hush money, but I don't know who else did." Now, can he package that up?
NixonWell, that certainly doesn't help us.
HaldemanThe other thing he says, "Well, I've retained it in a fund for future campaigns?" Yeah, sure. "Can I have it?" "Sure, you can't have it."
EhrlichmanWell, I'm not sure, either, but I assume that it'll fly right out to today's people. That's my assumption is it is.
HaldemanIt might have. Not all of it did, but [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanDean says, he said, "We have only two problems with the aftermath: no more than that."
HaldemanOne is the fact that we made a referral to Kalmbach and that can be explained. That's our only major problem. The other is the $350,000 and that can be explained, and neither is that big a problem, it can be clearly explained.
EhrlichmanAnd we have no, no problem with the aftermath. I'm writing the 350 into my statement.
HaldemanOh, yes. Put it in there.
NixonWell, as a matter of fact, I think it's been—there's been something written about that, hasn't there? The account. Nothing that I know of.
EhrlichmanIt is 11:00.
NixonAll right, 11:00 is when the armistice was signed, so off we go.
EhrlichmanMitchell is probably two hours away, at best.
NixonIf he's got to come down here today, I think— What?
EhrlichmanBob, I think you have to go out and call him now, and ask him if he can come down.
NixonI will send an airplane for him.
HaldemanYeah.
EhrlichmanI don't think you mobilized an airplane to go send for him.
NixonNo, I know. He may be gone. But the point that I make is this: that if he's out to play golf, just say we have a [unintelligible] You can say that events—
EhrlichmanUrgent events.
Nixonevents are moving very fast this weekend and he should come down.
EhrlichmanHe should come down. If he says, "I can't come," you just tell him, say, "Well, then John Ehrlichman will be up to see you."
NixonYeah, if he says, "Well, I've got a dinner tonight," or "I've got that," said, "John, this is very important. The President considers this of the highest urgency that you be aware of these developments, and that's not to be—" Call it that, so that he just can't be postponed.
EhrlichmanCan't be postponed.
NixonWe, uh, cross—
EhrlichmanAre you going to fire anybody while I'm gone?
NixonSir? [Chuckles]
HaldemanFire?
NixonYes, sir.
HaldemanWho?
NixonCall me?
HaldemanOh, okay. Is he there? Yeah.
NixonOur last conversation?
HaldemanCan you give him to me now?
NixonOh, okay.
EhrlichmanI I think for the for the other reason. We're We're quite It is not cover-up though. That's just what That's what the [unintelligible]
HaldemanThe direction is to go testify.
EhrlichmanHoney, Well, my point is my point is that that the three of us talked here, I realize, that frankly, Mitchell's case is guilty. Dean's case is, eh, it's the question. I do not consider it guilty, but it's all there is to that.
NixonWell, because if he's If that's the case, then, hell, who is he? That's what I'm saying. He's He's guilty of really no more except in degrees. That's right.
EhrlichmanUh, and uh Then uh others. And and a lot of And frankly, that I have been, since uh a week ago, hell, two weeks ago.
NixonSee, that is the That kind of knowledge that we had was not action knowledge, like the kind of knowledge that that I had put together last night. I haven't known really what's What's been bothering me this week, you know. But what's been bothering me is that with knowledge, we are still not doing [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanThat's right. That's it, exactly. The law and order. Goddamn it, that's the way I am. I, you know, it is painful for me to do anything about it. Mitchell thing is goddamn painful.
NixonSure.
HaldemanHi.
Ehrlichman[unintelligible] but it's not clear what your what plane you're on, so we picked you up. He says no, and he'd be willing to hang in there.
HaldemanHe went over his He's delayed a meeting with Magruder to see you. I don't think it really matters, just cover his whole bag having knowledge of having done that. Go on.
NixonMy point is that I think you better see Magruder before you see
HaldemanJohn.
NixonNo, I didn't mean, you know,
HaldemanNo, it doesn't matter. In my view, to see Magruder today, that's the main thing. I think we ought to make a seminar call.
EhrlichmanWell, if I do, I should call Dean, you know, say that events had developed and that I was
HaldemanYeah. What if I got John on, and just said, look, that it's no big deal, John, we've got an old memo, you know,
EhrlichmanNo, you'd better say that, because
HaldemanYeah, but I, for yesterday, I stayed with John, it would take probably 37 seconds for him to turn up on your doorstep, and all that. That's right.
NixonThat's all right.
HaldemanI think you should do it before you see Mitchell,
Ehrlichmanor you.
HaldemanNow, as I say, I think it's almost immaterial as to which I see first.
EhrlichmanIt's the fact of doing it, rather than any particular sequence.
NixonBecause Mitchell won't be here, can't be here until—
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonYeah, I think In my view, in my view, John, you can't wait to act, and you should see John Magruder and say,
Haldeman"Now, Jeff, you've stepped on—"
EhrlichmanNo way. No way.
HaldemanWhat I'd say I wouldn't quite say it that way.
EhrlichmanI'll say, "I don't know if you know what I have been doing here.
Ehrlichmanarranging, or is the whole subject matter trying to bring to the President something more than John Dean was trying.
NixonAnd tell him, you can talk to him that what he says is attorney-client, you know.
EhrlichmanOh, that's all okay. I'll I'll simply say that you know, he did an investigation, which determined whether or not the White House was involved. My responsibility is broader, it was to reign over the whole thing, and that I've and that the President, as new new information has actually been added.
NixonYeah.
Ehrlichmanhas hurried on what transpired, and from what I have been able to to gather I have advised the President, and he made this morning, and he has directed me to immediately contact you.
EhrlichmanSee, uh I think I've accepted point of view in all of this. People should not disclose what they know, because it somehow serves the President.
EhrlichmanApparently, the Serb who had all gentlemen decided what to do from your own standpoint. Now, what you have is a message from the White House, not in any way to do it. It's serving his purpose.
EhrlichmanYou've decided what to do with your own personal stamina. In any way, in your if there ever was an effort in you're coming forward by reason of your
Ehrlichmanimpression of a of a of assumed or otherwise of what the President wanted. I think it's my job to impart to you what is actually the case.
NixonI would also oh I put a couple of personal notes. Wouldn't you?
Nixonstart here by talking about the President's affectionate regard
Ehrlichman[unintelligible]
Nixonthis is painful as it would be his kid, but his own brother and all that. He said, and his own brother and all the rest. And this would break his heart. And he said, "This is the very painful message for me to to have to give to you. But but I must do it. And that is that."
EhrlichmanRight. I'll do that.
NixonAnd also, I just put that in so that he knows that I have a personal affection. That's the way that's that's the way this whole damn country is going to view it.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonSo John Mitchell's get do the same thing with Mitchell. Oh, Mitchell.
EhrlichmanYeah.
NixonHell! You could say that Mitchell, I hear that the President said, the President said that this decision was the toughest decision, he made tougher than than than than Cambodia, May 8th, and December 18th put together. And that he, uh, just can't bring himself to talk to you about it. He just can't.
EhrlichmanDirectly about that.
NixonSee, what I'm doing John is putting you in this same position. John Mitchell, you'd never say, "will never go to prison."
EhrlichmanI agree with that [unintelligible].
NixonI think what will happen will be he will put on the goddamndest defense. But, why do you have Your suggestion would be that he not put on the defense. Your suggestion is to go ahead and say, "Look, I am responsible here. I had no knowledge. But I am responsible, and I I nobody else has and that's it. It's over. That's it, and I want to plead."
Nixon"And this this business has got to stop. Innocent people are being smeared in this thing."
EhrlichmanHe won't stand, but that.
EhrlichmanIt's possible, but that once you are possessed of a reasonable body of knowledge, uh you have an obligation to do something.
EhrlichmanRather than simply to turn it over to the U.S. Attorney, the thing that you are doing in the first instance is giving him an opportunity to come forward, or, rather than having a special prosecutor, because if it keeps on, there's special prosecutor, the President rejects the uh, idea that uh the U.S. Attorney
Ehrlichmancall him in, which I could do, and uh or call in the Attorney General which I could do, but I have obligations because because this, cuz I can't have an Now, of course, he's going to act well now, John, what knowledge do you really have except hearsay? And I don't have anything
NixonExcept hearsay. Yeah.
EhrlichmanExcept, you know. But I do know that there There's no I have no documents and I have no affidavits.
NixonThat's Magruder. Magruder's speaking, though.
EhrlichmanRight. Right. There's no question about what's going to happen. There's an insurance.
NixonThat's right. That's right.
EhrlichmanUh, and uh so he won't have to He'll blow that because he's made the point. And uh you say that he's been screwed all along.
NixonWell, that's why they want to leave him at the point that Dean's or Magruder's, or testimony is a significant, so that that's that's the point of that.
EhrlichmanOther thing I would say that the President has stood frankly strong on on executive privilege thing. It isn't my purpose to prove your satisfaction you're guilt, or that you're going to be indicted.
EhrlichmanBut, it's my purpose to say that the President has in possession this,
NixonI believe you should say to him, what are you going to suggest to him? "Well,
EhrlichmanWell,
Nixonif he asks me what do you want me to do?" I would say, "If you would do what I ask, what I would suggest, you would pick up the phone, and you allow me to pick it up, and call Earl Silbert and make an appointment today to go over and talk with the U.S. Attorney about this case."
NixonWould you say, "The President wants you to do it?"
EhrlichmanNo.
NixonGood.
EhrlichmanNo. "You're asking me, and I'll lay it down that if you're guilty, I would say, 'What can you say? You're the only one who knows. You can face it, and face it and lie, or you can go and decide that there is that fool with what you know, and the alter action occurring, for what you might ask the punishment.'"
EhrlichmanI can't make that judgment for you. I don't have any right to make it for you. All I'm saying is you're looking at this thing from the standpoint of the President. Today is probably the last day, that you can take that action if you're ever going to take it.
EhrlichmanDo the President a bit of good.
NixonDo you realize, John, uh that uh that uh that uh in the White House, uh Colson, maybe Haldeman are going to get balled in this thing, too?
EhrlichmanWell, here again, we're looking at this thing, not from the standpoint of any other individual, only from the standpoint of the President, and that's the only way, I think, you and I can approach this.
NixonI I'd go further, and say the President has said, "Let the chips fall where they may."
NixonThat's, that's alright, but at least you, having accumulated all this knowledge this week,
Nixonhave tried
Nixonto get this thing out. So that sometimes, two months from now, three months from now, a year from now, and there's a panel, you can say on the 14th of April—
Ehrlichman13th. Yesterday. On the 14th of April, or the 14th, yeah. Friday was the 13th, yeah.
NixonYeah. Friday the 13th. On, on the 14th Oh, it's Saturday the 14th, that's right, the 14th. That both urged— Goddamn, the boil had to be pricked. That's, in a very different sense,
Nixonthat's what December 18th was about, they prick a goddamn boil and take the heat. Now, that's what we're doing here, we're going to prick this boil and take the heat.
EhrlichmanMy only reservation— We don't really know that.
NixonNo, I don't think it'll lance it right now. [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanHistory has to be, the history of this whole prick the boil thing now, you know, the history of this thing has to be that, that you did not prick this under the rug
NixonAll right.
Ehrlichmanyesterday, or today, and hope it would go away.
NixonNo.
EhrlichmanNow, even in this scenario, is early to go out and tell people that I've done this. It all depends on how it all turns out. If you does not go to the U.S. attorney,
Ehrlichmanyeah. And if Magruder decides to stay clammed up,
Nixonright, how would you proceed then? But that, but suppose, but suppose they still indict.
NixonWe don't want them to indict and then have to say, "Well on, on, on, on Saturday, the 14th of April you John Ehrlichman"— You see
EhrlichmanWell, see, like the press briefing things at least you've got the record, yeah.
NixonThe problem is that if you were to go out with this kind of hearsay,
Ehrlichmanand say we don't damn
Nixonand prejudice their rights— And then the hear— The thought is, you can out it beforehand. No. No. The thought is just to make the record that you did it.
EhrlichmanWhen somebody comes to us How was the White House doing this? We're in a position to say, "Well,
Ehrlichmanwe began to investigate three, and and, based on external circumstances.
EhrlichmanAnd we came to some conclusions, and we acted on those conclusions." John Ehrlichman conducted an investigation for the president, and we And earlier than uh
EhrlichmanNo, 13th of— It may be that what should happen is that if they both stonewall,
EhrlichmanI ought to sit down with Silbert and just say, "Now, I don't have a lot of evidence"—
NixonI agree with that. I agree with that.
Ehrlichman—"but I have an accumulation of hearsay and the president wants you to go forward on this. And I will turn over to you the report that I made to the president for whatever it's worth.
EhrlichmanAnd I want to tell you that I've that I have had contacts with two of your targets to make clear to them that nobody in the White House wanted them,
Ehrlichmanin any way, to be reticent. Beyond that, I don't have anything to say to you."
NixonWho's that?
EhrlichmanSilbert. Well,
Nixonsee, now, let's let's see what these guys do. But uh I think maybe like tomorrow
NixonI'll see Silbert. I agree.
NixonI think the record should be made with the proper person, so that he knows that the President has moved on this. That action That, that
Ehrlichmanputs the And that we saw the U.S. attorney, turned over our information to him, and all the information we had.
EhrlichmanI would like a record of my conversation with both Magruder and Mitchell and first, maybe I ought to get my office geared up so that I can do that.
NixonHow would you gear it?
EhrlichmanNobody can go there anyway. Well, I thought you meant for my meeting with Henry, but I don't know.
NixonNo, I think it's better if I do them. Why don't you just get it geared up? You have a way to gear your office?
EhrlichmanYeah. I'll go clear him. That's true. Right, might as well do it.
NixonNo.
EhrlichmanNo. Well,
NixonNo. I think that's too It would just I would just have it so that you know, that [unintelligible]
NixonI don't want to hear the record of the show. We got enough hell about the other. That is right. In other words, you have it for the same purpose, for your use in an inquiry.
EhrlichmanI think, well, that's it does hurt or it's a witness, for that matter. Do you know those people will question?
EhrlichmanSee, if you've got anybody else in that problem.
NixonMitchell, Mitchell said, "Bob, no, you were in this, too." What's Bob's answer to that?
EhrlichmanWell, it's better He won't. He won't.
NixonI think Bob should sit in. He's evolved in this uh No, no, I think so. I think that gives you the witness.
NixonAnd also, it Mitchell feels he's got a friend there. And he knows that you're not just doing this on your own freewheeling. Bob says, "We've talked it all over.
NixonWe feel we can't sit on the information, whatever it is. And we don't know that it's an issue. Get the information. I think the White House staff is going to be exactly the same position."
EhrlichmanGoing to throw open Chapin, fine.
NixonIs that at my office or?
EhrlichmanDid you ever report today, huh?
NixonIncidentally, any uh You going, any of you going to the White House Correspondents' Dinner?
EhrlichmanI wouldn't miss it for the world. I wouldn't. All the best, all the prizes are going to the Watergate people.
NixonHow how did that happen? You're going to give a standing ovation for Woodward and Bernstein?
EhrlichmanI wouldn't cheer.
NixonWell,
EhrlichmanYes, I guess you got to, you don't want to be noticed as the only one. No, so much, you just stand up and let the, the applause pass.
NixonIt's better not to clap, though. Doesn't mean anything. It'll be The point is, your standing up is Then it will be no stir, your failure to stand up, it will be one stir. It's recording, for It's better than trying to water eyes to have to be wired.
NixonYou're goddamn right, stay out of the. I got stung once that way. And incidentally, Bob said they want me to go in and speak at the end, very briefly. Yes, sir.
NixonIt'd be a long show. "Thank you very much. Delightful." Not kiss their ass at all.
HaldemanIt's simple.
NixonYou agree, John?
EhrlichmanI don't know why they would need They usually sleep. He arrives for coffee and dessert.
HaldemanCoffee and dessert, and then the entertainment. The they coffee and dessert and introduced the new officers and all that sort of thing.
NixonAnd then the picture. And then they have the entertainment. I, at the end, get up and thank them for a very pleasant evening for a delightful uh uh
HaldemanThey have the entertainment and they present they give you, they present you with a gift, and I say how much I appreciate the gift, and I will try to use it well.
NixonNo comments about relations with the press, and all that sort of thing. I'm going to wonder who's the president. That is my present intention. You agree, or do you want me to
Nixongas a little about, you know, we like to get along with you all, and so forth?
EhrlichmanTalk about Watergate, sir. How about start with— You want to look out for the exits.
NixonYou scoundrels. You might like to hear a little bit about what I've been doing the last couple days.
EhrlichmanI I would be inclined to take a little substance into it.
EhrlichmanOn the on the subject of legislative-executive relations, and the fact that White House correspondents are an important breed,
Ehrlichmanpart of two major organizations. Yeah, yeah, the fact that there really isn't any opposition that that
Ehrlichmanby the responsible treatment that some White House correspondents have given this subject is is
EhrlichmanAnd then, or maybe not even calibrate. Just say that we all have a stewardship here, that we're all custodians of an obligation to the American people to make clear the true essence of that relationship. And some, you know, some talking along that line.
EhrlichmanTo try and show that you're that you're thinking about them about them as a whole institution.
NixonYeah, that we do care about our relation. They've got a they got a damn important function, and I happen to want them to do their job.
NixonAnd I respect their their rights to criticize and uh and so forth.
EhrlichmanDo you mean the press, or do you mean the broadcasters? The White House correspondents are both of course broadcasters.
EhrlichmanMore than their criticism, it is their their accuracy
Ehrlichmanin reporting the essence
Ehrlichmanof the executive. Not the executive as a person, but the executive as an institution.
EhrlichmanThe the American people do not have as clear an understanding and impression of the American presidency as they ought to have.
EhrlichmanAnd it's a continuing task of the White House correspondents to try and improve that understanding.
EhrlichmanAnd the only way the system is going to work is if people have that or, you know, something something rather than just [unintelligible]
NixonOh, yeah. You're right. I've got to say something like that. So, I'll figure out this. Well, but I, that's why I'm going. So,
EhrlichmanTheir their tendency is to report the color of your shoes and and how many strokes in your golf game and that kind of stuff, rather than to elucidate the institution.
NixonWe've We've been through a historic year. Never have the White House correspondents traveled further. We've been to China. We've been to Russia. We've covered the end of the American involvement in the longest war in history. And and we have we've covered an election campaign. And we had an election campaign, and the aftermath of that election.
NixonI'll say that. And we're at the White House now, honest, error-free correspondence.
NixonAnd that I that I've that I've I've only tried to respect your right to be to the American people.
NixonNot just what the President had for breakfast, and so forth and so on, but what the presidency is about, what we're trying to accomplish. Not allow that to be obscured by the [unintelligible]
EhrlichmanA little of that that's good. One last thing. You have to rush? Well, I want to get this set up for Alex. [unintelligible]
NixonUm, yeah. Okay.
EhrlichmanI can have Bob in here for a few minutes. Did you order Bob not to give any horseshoe badges out, ever, on promise?
EhrlichmanHe claims he is and also, everybody who talks to him about Bob they should see him, and he decides.
EhrlichmanI think you ought to know, and you should also [unintelligible] All right.
NixonCome in. There's a whole gang of them with Bob. Now you can come in.
NixonCome in, Al. How are you? Good morning, sir.
NixonNice, our meeting we had yesterday, when you came back. Yes, sir.
NixonDamn, I tell you, I read the papers and find out that I had meetings that I don't even remember.
HaigGreat if we'd done that. So, actually, I've got all the the first hands as to where we go.
HaigThere's no reason for respect for Cambodia, the panic button's not as bad there as you thought?
NixonNo, it I read this morning I read in the morning reports, they seem to every day they lose another road, or another ammo, or another breath in somewhere, but the other hand, the hikers don't know.
NixonNo, I think that the thing is, the enemy actually is [unintelligible]
HaigNo, I think that we don't have a sanity situation. But I think we have a a serious situation, hit-and-run tactics, which it doesn't it doesn't trick you into any one day, or any one week. Did you go to Laos?
HaigYes, sir. I think that we're important that that's a very worrisome situation, simply because the enemy hasn't done one thing, as far as their forces, they had done that, we're in good shape, but on that other hand, they still seem to be negotiating.
HaigRight now, it's uh, they have that, who is in violation of the agreement, because the 14th division keep high dead officers so that they've been by Monday, then we deliver. After that, they were supposed to move.
HaigThey are both there. Now, as long as long as they negotiate with no reason to be forced to stay out, with no intention to move to back that. We're not quite sure.
HaigI I we don't know if it's Cambodia, we're out of Laos, we're out of South Vietnam, we're out of this.
HaigLong-term it's uh, all part of [laughter] a load.
NixonLet's see uh, uh tell Paul Hughes that uh, I can't speak Friday night, but that uh they'll return in a while. Tell him that I got tied up here.
NixonI'll see. But uh, or better still, I'll tell you what I'd like to do. Let me uh, why doesn't he come
Nixonover to the White House, after the White House correspondents' dinner? And I can chat with him. We'll be together then.
NixonTell him that after the dinner, after the No, I guess I shouldn't have that late. We'll see.
NixonOkay, after dinner night time. Dinner starts 4:00, huh? I'll be there at 5:00. Okay.
NixonLet's see. You've talked to both, Laos and Cambodia, and Vietnam.
HaigMore than anybody in Washington, except I'm sure the us, but that they shouldn't even know.
HaigThey have sightings. You come up there. But that shows you how bad it is.
HaigOnce a week [unintelligible] But it was very, very help-
NixonNow, how is the situation in Vietnam?
HaigThe situation is that uh, that it's all loaded in there, and the the fighting isn't twice the same [unintelligible]
NixonSouth Vietnam, how do the South Vietnamese feel about the well?
HaigIf there's a big problem there, uh the people are very confident, and the areas controlled by the GVN, like that, peace is returning, and commerce, and all roads are open, they've lifted the curfews,
Haigthe orchards, and that kind of stuff, it's uh remarkably, that's in very good shape. Now the ARVN, people are at the edge of the spill, up, and what I had to spend the weekend doing, is increasing their confidence.
NixonYeah. What's right?
HaigThey are also deluding themselves a little bit, and they think they're out of it, a heavy fight, like this with the big bang that's uh, with regular, why can't we just uh, maybe, well, you know, they think that they can, in their mind, that they they think that
KissingerIf they think we're going to bomb Laos
Kissingerand bomb Cambodia, or if they charge us with that, very, very good. They'll charge us.
NixonThe situation, I agree with you, couldn't, couldn't look much worse at this point. They've been through it all year.
KissingerWhatever, General Abrams, even when he had unlimited troops, he was a very cautious commander. The first time he lost in battle, that was the end of that.
KissingerHis system was, one thing that is very clear: the assumptions that underline the settlement, the settlement. The settlement if they kept it, if they kept it.
NixonThat's right. Damn the settlement. That's what we've got to say to him. Communist barbarism continues.
KissingerWell, the settlement said that they won't, that they'll enforce it.
KissingerIf we couldn't enforce it, then we would expect that the settlement [unintelligible]. If we couldn't every two weeks, I mean, I don't think that we can do it, but if we had enough authority to launch it,
Kissingereven one massive strike every two weeks, if they went outside their [unintelligible]
NixonThey don't, they don't want us to.
KissingerIt's beyond settlement, Mr. President.
NixonBecause if they, they won't hold it, why the hell should we hold it?
NixonWe've got to protect the national interest. That's one thing we can argue: we've got to protect our national interest.
KissingerYes, I agree. In the taking of stuff in western Cambodia, the problem you have, Mr. President,
Kissingerfive months we've now been bombing Cambodia.
KissingerSo, shutting off 50 sorties, flying 450 instead of 500 by order,
NixonI know.
Kissingerthere again,
Kissingersix months from today everybody's likely to forget it.
KissingerThat's why I call the wet-blanket treatment. I have no resentment for anyone, including Haig,
NixonAll right, well I'm, I'm pretty much set for, how about having, a uh, bipartisan group of, of Rogers, Laird,
KissingerI think if you don't mind, Steve wasn't for this because they're effective, Mr. President.
NixonSee, here's the problem: we cannot lose this trip.
NixonThe matter is this, Henry: who would argue on that? Now another point is, I've been thinking, Henry, if we do that, oh shit,
Nixonthe congressional leaders,
Kissingercould you have them in there? Sheer logic would have the congressional leaders.
NixonYeah.
KissingerWell, you don't have to. You're going to get hit on that anyway.
KissingerI would do it during the mid-state and call them in in the evening. Call them in at
NixonAt about 12 hours after the deadline was begun?
KissingerWell, after it's begun.
NixonYeah. Call them in because of the-
KissingerWe come to praise them.
NixonI'm talking, they talk, and in the evening they're talking about the fact to say that I can't overlook here, that what has happened here, these are violations of the agreement, which are, you know,
KissingerNot only
Nixonthe violations. This agreement, Cambodia, Laos,
KissingerMr. President, for the reason to-
KissingerCall them on the morning, suppose you did it on a Monday, and Tuesday the attacks would be over by the time you called them, and 24 hours later it would be finished.
NixonSee, I'm trying to think of the reaction.
KissingerSure.
NixonThe public, the reaction here, I can't judge it.
KissingerEverybody'd be happy the war's over. Who started the war?
NixonLargely the Republicans: "I don't see why our sons come home to form pounds of children's bones and, uh, what's happened?"
KissingerThe national constituency, Mr. President, and that's the national issue.
KissingerThe great percent of the U.S. issues, man, that'd be awful. I would like that. On its, to speak, that will ever come naturally out of this,
Kissingeron, and that they, uh,
Nixonfor four years we've Henry, understand, I don't give a damn, with the opponent's frame. I don't care what happens in terms of the polls or anything else.
NixonWe've got a massive, uh, we have massive credibility in this country in the field of foreign policy, [crosstalk] at the moment.
NixonAnd, uh, it's uh, piece by piece, tore into fragments by an all, several items, uh,
Nixonafter we've got little or no guts.
KissingerAnd we've always been, it's not staying with us, Mr. President.
KissingerHell, they attack us 15 months from now, we would take a different view. If they turn around every year and harried for the eight months run,
Kissingerif they accept, if they accepted our beef on that, they accepted them and have played with us, laid upon us that the communist party could accept it before three weeks.
KissingerAnd then the-
NixonGot to do that for the got to, got to protect the national interest.
KissingerThat is because of what I had to do, to call the wet-blanket, uh, treatment, on Monday. You might consider having a foster parent, say, by Tuesday. Tell the wet-blanket group you've decided to do it.
KissingerYou call them for, for an executive action.
KissingerIn fact, that may be, like I've told you, that you overruled, tell them that they feel it's [unintelligible]
Kissingerand you take full responsibility, because they can't. Hey, what're you going to do? Tell, tell them that-
NixonWait a second, let me think. Tomorrow,
KissingerThat way, you see-
NixonNo, I don't, I think, uh, that's the better way to do it, because Richardson is now in the crush, for a while, listen.
KissingerWhat will Richardson do? What? Nothing.
NixonNothing.
NixonAnd you and you do this, uh, just get, give orders to Abrams and all to put that pressure back on there, damn hard.
KissingerWell, we don't need to. We'll-
NixonSee, that will help a little. I mean, think, and, like that, if, if anything does happen, at, at, at bottom,
KissingerRight.
Nixonthat otherwise you'll say, 18 months from now they'll all go down the drain. All this peace dues things that we have now will be "Jesus Christ, who fought this war for nothing?"
KissingerSee, again, Mr. President, 18 months from now, it can happen from the situation in peace 50 months out, but if this, but if the Vietnamese step with it that day, which is what we are likely to get,
NixonLook, it is bad, it is bad this time, because-
KissingerWell, Western Cambodia [unintelligible]
NixonFirst Henry's recommendations, like crossing Cambodia, getting Laos uh,
KissingerWe'll let the sweet by and by [unintelligible]
NixonWe've got them, we have got them.
KissingerOver my dead body, we're not going to let them screw this agreement after what we've been through so long.
NixonThank God we have got the prisoners back. And thank God that's out of our hands.
KissingerThank God they are back here. If we hadn't acted, if this had happened before Senator Gravel sent him in [unintelligible]
Nixon[unintelligible] I guess the suspence was here. Well, the damn thing's off.
KissingerYeah. [unintelligible] well,
NixonLike, uh, oh yeah, Burroughs' brother, Henry Burroughs' brother.
KissingerOh, you mean the White House photographer?
KissingerHe, uh, I will [unintelligible] we've got to hit that [unintelligible] right away. He said, you realize that if we double hit this, if the basic [unintelligible]
NixonJump up and down and cheer and cheer and say you've got to stop that.
KissingerThen go then go to hell.
NixonLet me politely talk about the top four or seven beers. They think that I'm basically [unintelligible]
Kissinger[unintelligible] I could go out of whole on all fronts.
KissingerSimultaneously. If they took the [unintelligible] DRV, why not? Say we did good at that.
KissingerI don't think we could get into, uh, I don't think you can do that in summer. And, uh, I think [unintelligible]
NixonWell, I'm sure I've put it into writing.
KissingerBecause we may want to stop that up again [unintelligible]
NixonNo, we want to stop it, start it up.
KissingerOh, I see what you mean, can't start it up.
NixonUnless we we put it in writing. Then, then, then we would not be able to start it up. That's, that's what, that [unintelligible]
KissingerThat's still been going on? Oh, yeah. All the personality-wise, everybody else thinks they're helping Henry. The fact is they really want the meeting.
NixonYou really think you're still going to have a meeting with them?
KissingerThat shit. If they think, uh, [unintelligible] that they can both get the aid and screw us, that's [unintelligible]
NixonI want to be sure you get You be sure to stir up these people with the fact you what have they already done [unintelligible]
Kissinger[unintelligible] And when we talk about the goddamned thing, I want you to go move on this thing like Bull [unintelligible]
KissingerThey still can't [unintelligible]
NixonCan we send that name in right away? I'd send to, I'd send [unintelligible]
KissingerYou don't think we're going to get that much clack from the Congress, oh boy, what are we doing here to bomb that out, uh, Stilwell [crosstalk] Stillwell doesn't require any confirmation.
Nixon[crosstalk] See, Stilwell, let me say this. Let me say this, Henry, I think we send Stilwell,
KissingerSee, he doesn't require any confirmation, definitely not.
Nixonand Stilwell out there is such an outspoken military doll. You get him, and that will that will [unintelligible]
KissingerWe call Richardson and say we want Stilwell out there, and that when he goes out there, he'll have the charter [unintelligible]
KissingerI will watch this through the [unintelligible] one quick, the master.
NixonRight on time, and a strong voice in the [unintelligible]
Kissingerpersonal adviser. All right. Fair enough.
NixonSecond point, regarding Swank. You see, Kintner will take time to get approved, but, uh, I think his name, get that nomination in immediately, immediately.
KissingerYou don't have to make an FBI check, all that crap on him. He's probably had a clearance, anyway, [unintelligible]
NixonKintner later, in 6 months, he won't do it.
KissingerAll right, call Kintner to see if he'll do it. If he won't, Byroade. We need Byroade.
NixonAll right, Byroade to who? How would that Byroade,
KissingerByroade to Thailand, and how about sending Curren to Pakistan?
NixonAll right, you make those calls today, now, I've decided.
KissingerAll right, ask Curren to go to Pakistan, so tell him you're appointing Simon, can tell Kintner to go to, instead of Rogers calling [unintelligible] I'll be glad to do it.
NixonTell Rogers, you tell him Rogers called, tell him Rogers called, that's fine.
KissingerWell,
NixonYeah, yeah.
KissingerWell, that's what, yeah.
NixonBecause I am NOT going to wait and let this ball screw it. I want Kintner, I want, uh, [unintelligible] and I want, um, Byroade,
KissingerByroade to to Pakistan.
NixonByroade. Byroade, Byroade would be ordered, they haven't done that yet.
KissingerSend the name into the Senate, I guess, Monday.
NixonByroade's got to go to Thailand.
KissingerThe way we can do it, if we can trust them [unintelligible] that on Monday night that I decided to make the following appointment in China, because they had to be implemented, need to send Byroade to,
NixonYeah, that have it to me, have it to me to, uh, memorandum of the Press Secretary's statement.
KissingerThat Press Secretary's statement.
NixonPress Secretary can denote it's a shock.
KissingerThey object to Byroade, really. Rogers just doesn't like Byroade. I barely know the man, except that everyone
Nixontells you He doesn't like him because he drinks, that idiot.
KissingerAnd he had bad luck, but that doesn't mean that he's a bad, he's a hell of a second.
NixonAll right, he goes. I like it. John knows troops. Boo! Boo! Kintner drinks?
KissingerWho cares?
NixonWell, you know Kintner. You like him?
KissingerYeah, he's tough, he's tough. The trouble with Kintner is that it's a combat zone for all, for all these people.
NixonOh, I understand, yeah, but, I want, we need tough, hard line. That's my point.
KissingerNow, you call Kintner from up there, that he'll take it for 6 months, so you call him, tell him it's a personal request from the President.
NixonCall him today [unintelligible] call, uh, call Henry Byroade,
KissingerHe wants to go to Pakistan, and to go, it's a personal request from the President. Fair enough.
NixonNow, as a little carrot for the goddamned State Department thing, and Foreign Service, give them Moscow. We don't give a shit who goes to Moscow,
KissingerAnd say, uh, should that Rogers know, or who, who would you like? Oh, uh, Porter.
NixonWell, so Rogers knows he's going to have that out of the top four.
KissingerJust call Porter and say, "Look, the President wants your recommendation wants the recommendation of the best career man to go to Moscow [unintelligible] we want a fellow [unintelligible]
NixonFair enough. Let's get his ass over there to the Moscow thing, now. And you can inform Porter [unintelligible]
Kissingerthe President has made a decision on these other three, and it involves personal commitments, that he made personal arrangements.
NixonI have personal commitment to Byroade, too. I gotta. Kintner and the rest, it's a personal commitment. It's a personal commitment. See?
KissingerI think that gets gets Swank the hell out of there, anyhow.
NixonWell, Henry, we're glad to have you back. It's a good trip, uh, I guess you made the front page of the New York Times.
KissingerThat's That's right.
NixonHenry, are you going to go to the thing tonight?
KissingerYes.
NixonOh, you've got to? Well, I'm not going to say much. I don't think I should.
KissingerNo, I wouldn't. Sit there through a hours' entertainment.
NixonNo, I think you'd better.
KissingerConfidence,
NixonOh, yes.
Kissingerhe's on war, and all that, the watching.
NixonDo you want to Do you want to stay here for a minute, Henry? We might put you in the side room.
NixonAl Oh, I don't want to hold you up. Maybe you want to sit over in that Have you met with Al, and come back here later? Oh, okay.
KissingerWell, don't worry about it. I'll take care of it tonight. Yeah, come over.
NixonThe only thing I'm concerned about might be coffee, tea, soup, or something.
HaldemanThat's right.
NixonI don't know. I'd love to go there just to take a ride and go up.
HaldemanHell, this might be the evening where Brooke would say, "General, I salute you. Good cheer." And that might be
NixonUnfair to the spirit of the people, kind of thing.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonWhy not?
HaldemanThe interesting thing, Bob has the view that the polls for the month of April there were, which is a 3,000 sample instead of 1,500 sample, and taking over a period and all and what have you,
NixonWell, the it was better than the layout, but
Haldemannow, the reason it's down, even to 60, and it was 65, and it was as high as 68, but that was the first part. That was just a blip, he said. That's good. But the reason it's down, it's down and not Watergate.
HaldemanOnly 5% of the people are anywhere near 5% what happened.
NixonThey don't It must have been It's the economy. You see, the White House Press, press
HaldemanThat's another thing. They takes heat anywhere from the press corps. He had the press corps with him. They've kept his opposition so that they they just went through an election,
Haldemannobody talked about the goddamn inflation. They kept thinking, reading through the polls, for that. Were they? Yeah.
NixonGood heavens, the meat, for months, meat and eggs, because they bought it all the time. But don't do it before the meat boycott. But they bought it all the time they went through that. That is funny, isn't it?
HaldemanSure. Sure. But, nevertheless,
Nixon66%, 62%, whatever it is. He is not that, uh, nice guy.
NixonI'm just thinking whether I ought to go. Maybe I ought to go on Monday evening. I think the other way to do it
Nixonwould have to wind back on Monday, then back to the NSD on Tuesday. But if he doesn't have leads in Department of Defense by then, fine.
NixonFine. There's no reason why going
NixonI just fallen behind on the things I have to do.
NixonWell, that's good. At at least, gotten this damn thing squared away.
NixonWell, Mitchell would be out of this wholly. Very, very hurt. It's smart, you know,
Nixonand whether, uh, they fall with that, well,
NixonMartha is squawking. It's a special problem.
NixonI would hate to think of anybody having a problem with a wife, or woman like that,
Nixonputting, in effect, pressure like that. What a way to live.
HaldemanIt's great, isn't it?
NixonWhy doesn't John don't leave her? Why does he stay with her? I don't think John
HaldemanI don't know that John
HaldemanJohn's thought you, when you asked John, did you stand with her, because the big issue is
NixonYeah, I kept I kept, you know, asking.
HaldemanAsking him, and he went and would never really answer. It went back on this
Haldemango to the need, kids, the morals of the boy, and that, and the other thing.
NixonHe has an objection.
HaldemanYeah.
NixonWell, how do you analyze it?
HaldemanI think that a little bit of both of the things happen to be true, John.
HaldemanThe main concern is that by him leaving, and that then everybody could tell her she had a right to talk.
NixonShould've.
HaldemanAnd then the guilt. And he came out here, they said they'd turn a lot of his staff
Haldemanthat he's practically desperate, you know. He'd never even thought about it before.
HaldemanI didn't think of it. No.
NixonAt every time I've had one telephone line with him, they might say they might tell him that I called. Do you think
HaldemanThey might they might not find him.
NixonBecause I would never do it in should call. He's my friend.
NixonPresident cannot have knowledge. I haven't had knowledge of this, but I had knowledge about the White House that that was clean. I believe it and it proved correct, up to this point,
Nixonexcept for this damn [unintelligible] thing.
NixonSee, it has not been my responsibility of individuals with the Committee.
NixonNow, however, I've gone further. I've said, now, wait a minute, what about the Committee? You see, the Chief Executive of this country cannot sit on such knowledge.
HaldemanWell, but what bothered John, apparently, was what he called the dean of the Committee.
HaldemanNot that John is an officer, and he feels he couldn't get out from under it. He couldn't leave it, but
Haldemanhe can't be you can't cover for that kind of stupidity. One thing, I believe, shouldn't be done in there,
Haldemanbecause the because of the damn necessity that it's blaming John.
HaldemanThat, uh But the some of the people getting hit, as you know, I proposed you all the fall.
HaldemanAnd you having it's good business.
NixonGreat. And also you propose to have the only the focal player.
NixonAll right, I think. And also Haldeman is an honest man.
HaldemanI know that, sir. Uh, and I don't think anybody will pick up on
Haldemanthe nonsense of talking about things after the fact, which is regarded as,
Nixonwell, so forth, and so on, and so on. But that's always in campaign.
HaldemanI know, but what happened after that's what, uh,
NixonThat's right. That's another thing altogether.
HaldemanRight. Uh, but, uh
Haldemanand, my view is the whole leadership, I don't know if that's right. The view that he'd be he'd hold on to it, if he assumes it all.
HaldemanIf he cannot take on, then he should resign the head of the group.
NixonOnly man who'd honorably that that would ease money, would be
HaldemanIs it for that, I don't.
NixonI I think it would, either way, I
HaldemanI think it would be good. That's what I am interested in.
NixonThat would be a terrible blow to John, Mitchell.
HaldemanYeah. He's a fellow who deserves a chance, and as that, we've got to give him that chance.
NixonI agree. It's a rough day, but we'll survive.
HaldemanThat's uh Don't give him the first blow, at least the first blow come out with the looking into it.
Kissinger[unintelligible]
Nixonand then, however, we have to cooperate with them in order to We are cooperating with the grand jury. That's what we're doing today.
KissingerAnd we're cooperating with the Congress. What I've done, I'm trying to get that on an executive session basis. There is no other way.
NixonThe thing to do, Henry, what I have to decide, one, tells if it's going to come out. It doesn't matter a damn bit, whether it's going to come out whether we cooperate or not. What if it's going to come out No, no, no, no. What I meant was, whether [unintelligible]
Kissinger[unintelligible]
Nixonbefore the Congress or not, it's going to come out.
KissingerNow, but if it's going to come out, then the question arises whether, you know, once and for all they take take some brutal measures.
NixonWell, there are no more brutal measures than I'm taking. You have to understand that just because of the the [unintelligible]
NixonI don't like it to work this way because [unintelligible]
KissingerWell, what I feel about this is, while courage would be, you know, don't hear all the time [unintelligible] But my worse reflection would be [unintelligible]
NixonI don't think the country feels that much in it.
KissingerLet me, let me say this, You're talking to a bunch of establishment people, this is a terrible thing to say. But the fact that everybody is concerned about the moral failure
NixonDon't worry.
KissingerIf this one goes on it would leave a disgrace and as as left disgrace
Kissingerevery year of [unintelligible]
Kissingerfirst uh [unintelligible]
KissingerWhite House. You were the biggest you're the biggest fish they ever called in here.
KissingerYou would hold this country about 20% of [unintelligible]
NixonSure.
KissingerI told him.
NixonPresidents must, however, maintain their authority [unintelligible]
Nixonand to- I've got, that's how I feel. Come on, Henry.
KissingerIf they can get the facts, they can inform everybody [unintelligible]
NixonYou might heard this night say [unintelligible] and they will then make accusations for months without proving it.
KissingerWell, the fact they've got they have accusations now. When you take the paper this morning, check with everyone on the street.
NixonListen.
KissingerListen to sheer panic. There's to be a [unintelligible] God damn it. You've got an issue here.
NixonThey're getting an issue.
KissingerI see in this morning's paper, think of the bugging.
KissingerA uh private detective for instance, he bugged uh a hotel room, and put something uh connected, case last week,
Kissingerinvestigate it and they got a shit, misdemeanor. He'll get charged with a felony, they plea-bargained it down to misdemeanor.
KissingerHe got a suspended sentence, he never spent an hour in jail. They agreed,
Kissingerthat's always proper, but I made that case. I was, I was target of a board last night, and several sitting beside me.
KissingerI was law clerk, [unintelligible]
Kissingerand fought our standard child father and uh misdemeanor.
NixonCome on. You didn't believe that.
KissingerSo, uh [crosstalk] but I, I go on all the I go on the attack.
KissingerI, I sailed into the area,
Kissingeroutrage to make this an appointment. You had another case, I said. Well, we've been in New York law for 10 years, and studying for five. Suspended sentence,
Kissingerand, uh, and we see it, you see it, it must be the, uh, [unintelligible]
NixonYou know what they say then? That we reverse our name for him after all. The chief investigator in in his case, he became,
Nixona case like this has to be got from the White House.
KissingerThen I said, I pointed this thing, possible that basic [unintelligible] I said the difference between us and you is, I say look, made this an issue of civil liberties. And they believe it's overcast the line for people whom you think are no good.
KissingerThe good guys always get a lot of protection anyway.
KissingerSo, I'm damned to that that people who did the bugging are my kind of guys. That's why they need protection.
NixonSure, that's why they protect Communists.
KissingerThat's I said that's what they cast into your protection. But they of course What about car thieves, 25 [unintelligible]?
KissingerAnd then I made your case. [unintelligible] I said what if this guy gets 3 years for burglary and 3 for this? 30, 35 years. A guy who has never done anything before, never would do anything again. No flags deciding if might be 40 years for bugging.
KissingerI think you ought to denounce this Mr. President. That would turn it.
NixonYou've got to move on it.
KissingerOh no, I think you have to move on, but I think it turn us out at 11:00.
NixonSure.
KissingerSee what I'm-
NixonAll right, Mr. President. You've got another thing to [unintelligible]
KissingerI have not overlooked.
NixonI got to- I have to worry about this because it hits me personally. It hits me personally. I'm not referring to holy [unintelligible] I'm referring to an act, that's it.
KissingerWell-
NixonI agree. Because I'm concerned about the good faith and good conscience, also decent men. Very decent men. Very decent men. Goddamn it, the people who were doing this were they were misguided. They were wrong. They were doing it for one
Kissinger[unintelligible] that it needs to do uh-
Kissingeron the [unintelligible]
KissingerUh, Mr. President, uh two things.
KissingerUm, there's uh the uh the Vietnamese, like they're going to do in another 2 days.
KissingerSincerely a question. It's not necessarily the whole thing, but if they hit that drive on Sunday or Monday, they're going to make that run.
KissingerAnd I uh am speaking to the AP editors, on the 23rd,
Kissingerand, I'd rather not talk about Vietnam, but talk about uh Europe, if you agree.
NixonFine, fine.
Kissingeralong the lines of what you've said to [unintelligible] that Europe had an excuse then, but they have no excuse now,
Kissingerand uh they have to take the steps,
Kissingereven, that it's just Everybody, when they say, Henry, let me argue about Europe and Latin America.
NixonThe press always say we pay no attention to it, yet I go over there and I make some pretty heavy comments about Latin America and about its priority and about
KissingerThey don't cover it.
NixonNobody gives a damn, Henry. They don't care about Latin America.
KissingerNo.
NixonTruly, it's not news. And you're not going to get much on Europe, but talk about it.
KissingerAnd I thought it would be it would be better If there is nothing I can say on Vietnam, it won't be [unintelligible]
NixonNo, what I would say on on Vietnam, I would give them a little overview. The spirit first was must be maintained. The world has changed. And the idea that uh for 25 years,
Nixonuh we have seen enormous changes happen. Uh our policy for that, and we must deal with the world as it is. Part of initiatives first begins, deal with situations with it. Deal with the world with it.
NixonAnd now with Europe, we must deal with Europe with it. Exactly. And that's that's why we need to move toward Europe. Exactly. Move on it.
  • 038-016 8:44 AM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 8:44 am and 8:47 am.
  • 038-017 8:47 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull talked on the telephone from 8:47 am to 8:49 am.
  • 428-016 8:47 AM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building at 8:47 am.
  • 428-017 8:47 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Stephen B. Bull met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 8:47 am to 8:49 am.
  • 038-018 8:49 AM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 8:49 am and 8:54 am.
  • 428-018 8:49 AM · 9 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator met in the President's office in the Old Executive Office Building from 8:49 am to 8:54 am.
  • 038-019 8:54 AM · 2 min — President Richard M. Nixon and Elliot L. Richardson talked on the telephone from 8:54 am to 8:56 am.
  • 038-020 9:00 AM · 11 sec — President Richard M. Nixon and White House operator talked on the telephone at an unknown time between 9:00 am and 10:49 am.

Conversation 428-019, April 14, 1973. White House Tapes, Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, National Archives. Audio and AI transcript via Easy Nixon, https://www.easynixon.org/tapes/428-019 (accessed November 20, 2026).