← All participants

Stein, Herbert

Herbert Stein served as a member of the Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) from January 1969 to December 1971, helping to design the Nixon administration's 1971 wage and price controls. During the White House taping period, his role transitioned when he was promoted to Chairman of the CEA following the resignation of Paul McCracken, a position Stein held from January 1972 to August 1974. As Chairman, he frequently advised President Nixon on inflation and budget policy, serving as the administration's primary economic spokesman until Nixon's resignation.

Member, Council of Economic Advisers (January 1969 – December 1971)
Chairman, Council of Economic Advisers (January 1972 – August 1974)

Read more on Wikipedia →

March 26, 1971 · with Nixon, Cabinet officers & Rogers

President Nixon and his Cabinet met to discuss the ongoing challenge of inflation and rising construction costs, focusing on the administration's strategic options for economic stabilization. Dr. Paul McCracken reviewed current inflationary trends and labor market data, outlining a spectrum of potential responses ranging from maintaining current fiscal policies and targeted interventions to implementing more aggressive measures like wage and price controls. The meeting served as a forum to evaluate the efficacy of various regulatory mechanisms, such as the National Commission on Productivity and the suspension of the Davis-Bacon Act, while weighing the political and practical risks of further government intervention in the economy.

503-016Tape 5031 hr 23 min

May 21, 1971 · with Nixon, Shultz & Connally

President Nixon met with Herbert Stein, George Shultz, John Connally, and Arthur Burns to discuss the state of the U.S. economy, specifically focusing on inflation, sluggish recovery, and steel industry negotiations. The group debated the potential risks of government intervention, including wage-price freezes, while also planning a strategy to better communicate budget deficits and fiscal policy to the American public. Additionally, Nixon emphasized the need for a unified administration voice on economic policy ahead of upcoming international monetary conferences, urging his team to maintain a confident and assertive posture regarding U.S. domestic economic strength.

June 28, 1971 · with Nixon, Cabinet Committee on Economic Policy & Houthakker

President Nixon met with the Cabinet Committee on Economic Policy to address ongoing issues regarding internal leaks of economic strategy and the lack of a unified administration voice. He stressed the necessity of presenting a cohesive front to the public, designating Secretary of the Treasury John B. Connally as the primary spokesperson for economic policy. The President mandated that all advisors cease unauthorized contacts with the press and align their public statements with the official administration line to restore public trust and policy stability.

560-001Tape 5601 hr 3 min

August 10, 1971 · with Nixon, McCracken & Bull

President Nixon met with his Council of Economic Advisers, including Paul McCracken, Herbert Stein, and George Shultz, to assess the current state of the national economy and evaluate potential administration interventions. The discussion focused on economic indicators, inflation, and the political and psychological impact of potential wage and price controls. Nixon emphasized the need for confidentiality regarding major policy shifts, such as closing the gold window, while the group weighed various stimulus options, including tax relief and investment tax credits, to spur business confidence and consumer spending.

August 16, 1971 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon convened a large meeting with Vice President Agnew and his Cabinet to discuss the national economy and the "New Economic Policy" he had announced the previous day. Key topics included the wage-price freeze, import surcharges, tax relief, budget cuts, and the convertibility of the dollar. The administration sought Cabinet support for these initiatives and discussed their potential impact on international trade and domestic employment.

September 9, 1971 · with Bull, Solomon & Richey

President Nixon hosted back-to-back swearing-in ceremonies in the Oval Office for Ezra Solomon, as a member of the Council of Economic Advisors, and Frank C. Carlucci III. The sessions included formal oaths of office, family photographs, and the presentation of commemorative Presidential gifts, such as cufflinks and pins. During the meetings, Nixon engaged in informal conversation with the participants, reflecting on past professional associations and discussing the careers of the appointees, including Carlucci's previous work in Brazil and at the Office of Economic Opportunity.

September 11, 1971 · with Nixon, Cost of Living Council & Connally

President Nixon met with the Cost of Living Council to assess the implementation and public reception of the 90-day wage-price freeze initiated on August 15, 1971. The council members, including John Connally, George Shultz, and Arthur Burns, reported on the effectiveness of enforcement efforts, current compliance levels, and the complexities of handling exemption requests. The discussion shifted toward strategic planning for Phase II, emphasizing the need for sustainable economic policies, public leadership, and the critical role of securing support from business and labor leaders before the freeze's conclusion.

September 14, 1971 · with Nixon, Shultz & McCracken

President Nixon met with a large group of Republican Congressional leaders to solicit support for his administration's economic initiatives, specifically the New Economic Policy and tax reform measures. Key topics included the Job Development Tax Credit, depreciation reform, and strategies to secure bipartisan support for the Economic Stabilization Act as the program entered its second phase. The participants also discussed the necessity of public and business cooperation, as well as the international trade context of the President's economic agenda.

September 17, 1971 · with Nixon, Tower & Bennett

President Nixon met with a bipartisan group of Congressional leaders to discuss the progress of the 90-day wage-price freeze and to seek input on the development of Phase II economic policies. Treasury Secretary George Shultz provided an overview of the administration's administrative efforts, including the roles of the Cost of Living Council and the IRS in enforcing the freeze. The discussion centered on the need for continued cooperation across sectors—including labor, business, and agriculture—and the development of a framework for economic stabilization once the initial freeze expired.

September 30, 1971 · with Nixon, Ehrlichman & Evans

President Nixon met with leaders from various national education organizations to hear their concerns regarding the state of public education, specifically focusing on the financial crisis facing schools. Representatives emphasized the need for federal assistance, the reliance on inequitable property taxes for school funding, and the challenges of integrating diverse student populations. Nixon reaffirmed his support for education and his administration's commitment to exploring tax reform and alternative funding methods, such as revenue sharing, to alleviate the pressure on local school districts.

581-011Tape 5811 hr 5 min

September 30, 1971 · with Nixon, Shultz & Kissinger

President Nixon met with George Shultz, Herbert Stein, and Henry Kissinger to strategize the administration's economic policy for the post-freeze 'Phase II' period. The discussion centered on the necessity of establishing a tripartite board to manage wage and price controls, balancing the need for inflation control with the political requirement of securing labor cooperation. Nixon decided to keep his personal involvement in the technical details minimal, tasking Secretary John Connally with leading the public-facing aspects of the transition while aiming to avoid a crisis-heavy presentation to the public.

584-003Tape 5843 hr 55 min

October 5, 1971 · with Nixon, Haldeman & Butterfield

President Nixon met with his senior staff and economic advisers to finalize the rollout strategy for Phase II of his economic program. The discussion focused on establishing an effective, low-key announcement strategy for the upcoming wage and price controls, balancing the need for public cooperation with the desire to avoid the appearance of a crisis. Key decisions included keeping the address concise, maintaining a tone of confidence, and utilizing prime-time news slots to maximize reach while minimizing disruption to entertainment programming.

November 15, 1971 · with Nixon, Cost of Living Council & Connally

President Nixon and the Cost of Living Council convened to discuss the efficacy of the administration's economic stabilization program, specifically the transition from Phase I to Phase II. Participants evaluated the success of existing price and wage controls and addressed the future of the Pay Board and Price Commission ahead of the 1972 calendar year. The meeting concluded with a formal vote to adopt an amendment to 'Option 2' regarding economic policy adjustments.

November 18, 1971 · with Nixon

President Nixon calls Herbert Stein to check on his recovery following eye surgery and to express the administration's need for his return. During the informal exchange, Stein shares a humorous anecdote about Dean Acheson and a Harvard reunion. The conversation concludes with Nixon advising Stein not to rush his return to work and lightheartedly joking about maintaining a political bias to the right.

November 24, 1971 · with Nixon, Kissinger & Haldeman

President Nixon and his advisors, primarily Henry Kissinger, discussed U.S. foreign policy toward the India-Pakistan conflict and the People's Republic of China, with the President emphasizing the need for a firm stance against Indian aggression. Economic matters dominated the latter half of the meeting as Nixon finalized the transition of Herbert Stein into a new leadership role within the Council of Economic Advisers to serve as a strong, assertive voice on the national economy. Additionally, the President met with Peter B. Wilson to discuss political strategy and preparations for the upcoming Republican National Convention in San Diego, aiming to maximize favorable media coverage.

December 15, 1971 · with Nixon, Mansfield & Scott

President Nixon met with a bipartisan group of Congressional leaders to brief them on his recent diplomatic discussions with French President Georges Pompidou and the status of U.S. international economic policy. The conversation focused on efforts to address the global monetary crisis, the necessity of realigning exchange rates to restore the competitive position of American goods, and the importance of burden-sharing among trade partners. Nixon highlighted the recent breakthrough in negotiations with France as a critical step toward stabilizing the international monetary system and advancing domestic economic goals like job creation and inflation control.

January 13, 1972 · with Nixon, Sheehan & Smith

President Nixon hosted a swearing-in ceremony in the Oval Office for John E. Sheehan as a member of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. The event was attended by Sheehan’s family, Federal Reserve Chairman Arthur F. Burns, various governors, and several U.S. Senators, including John Sherman Cooper. Following the formal oath and a photographic session, the President engaged in a private discussion with Senator Cooper regarding the political landscape, including U.S. foreign policy toward the Vietnam War, upcoming trips to China and the Soviet Union, and international conflicts.

January 20, 1972 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon met with his Vice President and Cabinet to discuss the state of the U.S. economy, the administration's fiscal policy, and the upcoming 1973 budget. Key areas of focus included interpreting unemployment data—specifically the impact of new entrants to the workforce—and managing inflation through Phase II price and wage controls. Nixon urged his department heads to aggressively implement approved spending programs to stimulate the economy, while simultaneously directing them to more effectively communicate and promote the administration's economic achievements and social policy investments to the public.

January 26, 1972 · with Nixon, Agnew & Scott

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew and Republican congressional leaders to discuss strategy regarding his recent speech on Vietnam and the administration's upcoming FY 1973 budget. The President and Henry Kissinger briefed the attendees on the Vietnam peace negotiations, emphasizing that the U.S. had made comprehensive offers while denouncing North Vietnamese intransigence and political maneuvering. Economic advisors, including George Shultz and Herbert Stein, presented the administration's fiscal plans, highlighting the importance of balancing the budget while supporting a transition to a peacetime economy through controlled spending and wage-price stabilization. Participants agreed on the necessity of maintaining a firm stance on defense and economic policy to solidify public support and improve the administration's negotiating leverage.

656-027Tape 6561 hr 21 min

January 26, 1972 · with Nixon, Connally & Burns

President Nixon met with John Connally and key economic advisors Arthur Burns, George Shultz, and Herbert Stein to conduct an extensive review of the U.S. economy, including unemployment data, retail sales, and the federal budget. The participants discussed strategies to accelerate federal spending to stimulate growth, concerns regarding the lack of confidence among international financial institutions, and the delicate nature of ongoing trade negotiations with Europe, Japan, and Canada. Nixon directed his team to prioritize the rapid deployment of authorized funds and ordered a follow-up analysis on identifying the specific demographics of the unemployed.

January 28, 1972 · with Nixon, Ehrlichman & Bull

President Nixon met with John Ehrlichman and various guests to preside over the presentation of the Encyclopedia Judaica, which included discussions on U.S.-Israeli relations and the significance of Jewish heritage. Following the ceremony, Nixon and Ehrlichman transitioned into a private strategy session regarding domestic policy, specifically addressing the administration's stance on busing, the potential for a constitutional amendment, and the political implications of housing integration. They also evaluated ongoing projects, including the Bicentennial park proposal and the political viability of implementing a Value Added Tax (VAT) in an election year.

660-008Tape 6603 hr 2 min

January 29, 1972 · with Nixon, Haldeman & Eisenhower

President Nixon held a wide-ranging meeting with H.R. Haldeman and several other key staff members to discuss political strategy, personnel matters, and public relations. Key topics included the appointment of Marina von Neumann Whitman to the Council of Economic Advisors, the political fallout and press handling of a protest at a recent White House dinner, and the administration’s strategy regarding potential 1972 Democratic presidential challengers. Additionally, Nixon and his staff reviewed polling data and preparations for his upcoming trip to the People’s Republic of China, emphasizing the positive reception of his recent Vietnam peace proposals.

February 7, 1972 · with Nixon, Seymour & Keller

President Nixon met with United States Attorneys and Justice and Treasury Department officials to emphasize that drug enforcement was the administration's top priority. He urged the attorneys to prioritize the aggressive prosecution of drug peddlers and pushers while improving their public relations efforts to demonstrate the federal government's commitment to the cause. The President encouraged these officials to coordinate more effectively with local law enforcement and to reassure their respective constituencies that the administration was actively tackling the national drug problem.

February 29, 1972 · with Nixon, Cabinet officers & Rogers

President Nixon met with his Cabinet and senior staff to debrief them on the results and implications of his recent diplomatic trip to the People's Republic of China. The President emphasized that the primary success of the visit was the establishment of a new communication channel between the two nations, which he argued was essential for managing long-term stability and reducing the potential for future conflict. Nixon shared his impressions of Chinese leadership, particularly his discussions with Chou En-lai, noting the stark ideological differences while highlighting common strategic interests, such as peace in the Pacific and balancing influence against the Soviet Union. The discussion concluded with a focus on how this opening could be leveraged to reshape international relations and manage regional tensions across Asia.

679-013Tape 6791 hr 38 min

March 7, 1972 · with Nixon, Connally & Shultz

President Nixon met with John Connally, George Shultz, and Herbert Stein to coordinate administration strategy on key economic policy issues, particularly rising concerns over Social Security, the federal budget deficit, and minimum wage legislation. The group discussed maintaining a hard-line stance against excessive spending increases, including a potential 20% Social Security hike that they viewed as inflationary, while also preparing contingency plans to address a possible longshoremen's strike. Nixon emphasized the necessity of a unified administration position that favors economic discipline and reaffirmed his refusal to return to currency convertibility.

March 13, 1972 · with Nixon, Bull & Whitman

President Nixon hosted a ceremony in the Oval Office for the swearing-in of Marina von Neumann Whitman as a member of the Council of Economic Advisers. The participants included Whitman’s family, members of the Council, and other White House staff. The conversation featured personal pleasantries, photographs, a discussion about the importance of accessible economic reporting, and lighthearted commentary on White House history and decor.

March 21, 1972 · with Nixon, Bull & Manescu

President Nixon met with a Romanian delegation, led by Manea Manescu, to discuss the ongoing development of U.S.-Romanian political, economic, and cultural relations. The participants reviewed the impact of Nixon’s recent diplomatic initiatives in China and the Soviet Union, with Manescu expressing Romania's support for principles of national sovereignty and non-interference. Nixon reaffirmed his commitment to strengthening ties with Romania, promising to prioritize the country's economic interests, including the pursuit of Most Favored Nation (MFN) trade status.

March 22, 1972 · with Nixon, Ehrlichman & Bull

President Nixon met with his senior advisors and cabinet members to finalize strategy for an upcoming press conference and address recent developments regarding the Pay Board. The discussion focused on responding to the withdrawal of AFL-CIO leadership from the Pay Board, managing public perception of inflation and economic policy, and formulating official stances on contentious social issues including busing, abortion, marijuana legalization, and Social Security increases. The group debated the optimal timing and format for the President to announce the administration's economic adjustments to ensure maximum impact and clarity while minimizing political vulnerability.

March 22, 1972 · with Nixon, Ehrlichman & Haldeman

President Nixon and his senior advisors, including John Ehrlichman, H.R. Haldeman, and John Connally, met to formulate an aggressive administrative response to the resignation of George Meany and other labor leaders from the Pay Board. The group discussed the timing and format of a public statement intended to demonstrate decisive presidential action and secure political leverage against Democratic opponents. They also debated potential replacements for the labor positions, reviewed strategies for handling the national economy, and coordinated the President's upcoming press conference to ensure it effectively overshadowed current controversies like the IT&T investigation.

March 23, 1972 · with Nixon, Cost of Living Council & Connally

President Nixon met with members of the Cost of Living Council and other key economic advisors to assess the efficacy of Phase II wage and price controls. The discussion focused on controlling inflation, managing food prices, and navigating political pressures from organized labor and Congress. Participants evaluated the impact of economic policies on the public interest and discussed strategies for future price stability across various sectors.

March 28, 1972 · with Nixon, Richardson & Scott

President Nixon met with Republican congressional leaders and cabinet officials to strategize on the administration's legislative agenda, specifically focusing on revenue sharing, welfare reform, and the Equal Educational Opportunities Act. The discussion addressed the political and procedural challenges of implementing a busing moratorium and the importance of countering Democratic criticism regarding the economy. Nixon emphasized the need for a unified party strategy to leverage economic accomplishments and maintain pressure on Democratic opponents leading into the 1972 election cycle.

May 8, 1972 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew, Cabinet members, and senior staff to discuss the administration's recent escalation in Vietnam, specifically the blockade of North Vietnamese ports. The President articulated his rationale for the decision and sought unified support from his team to manage potential congressional and public opposition. He emphasized the necessity of leadership during difficult times and urged his Cabinet to present a cohesive front in defending the policy to the public.

June 21, 1972 · with Nixon, Shultz & Burns

President Nixon met with his economic advisors, including George P. Shultz, Arthur F. Burns, Caspar Weinberger, and Herbert Stein, to review the status of the U.S. economy, specifically focusing on inflation, unemployment rates, and price stability. The discussion covered the political implications of economic indicators ahead of the 1972 election, particularly regarding potential campaign issues against George McGovern, and touched upon international currency problems and foreign policy matters involving Latin America. The group debated the efficacy of various economic interventions, including wage and price controls and potential actions to address rising meat prices, while weighing the impact of these policies on business and public perception.

June 23, 1972 · with Nixon, Shultz & Weinberger

President Nixon met with his economic advisors, including George Shultz, Caspar Weinberger, and Herbert Stein, to address public and political concerns regarding rising food and beef prices. The group analyzed potential government interventions, such as suspending import quotas, utilizing government food stockpiles, and the political implications of implementing price controls. Following this, the President consulted with Kermit Gordon regarding the administration's economic policies and engaged in a broader discussion concerning the political orientation of intellectuals and the Brookings Institution.

June 23, 1972 · with Nixon, Rumsfeld & Haldeman

President Nixon met with Donald Rumsfeld, H. R. Haldeman, Herbert Stein, and a production crew from the Wolper Organization to coordinate the filming of an upcoming documentary. The discussion focused on logistical instructions regarding the President's movements and camera placement within the White House. Additionally, the group touched upon the President’s past interactions with the Brookings Institution and his upcoming schedule at Camp David.

June 23, 1972 · with Nixon, Rumsfeld & Haldeman

President Nixon held a wide-ranging series of meetings with advisors and staff to discuss economic policy, pending legislation, and emergency disaster responses. Key discussions included plans to reduce government stockpiles, the political implications of food prices and busing legislation, and the federal government's mobilization efforts following Hurricane Agnes and the Rapid City flooding. The session also incorporated administrative coordination for upcoming film projects involving the President and members of the Wolper Organization.

June 24, 1972 · with Nixon, Haldeman & Camp David Operator

President Nixon and H. R. Haldeman met at Camp David to strategize for an upcoming televised press conference, focusing on techniques to maintain control through shorter answers and a more controlled format. They also discussed logistics for the 1972 Republican National Convention, specifically regarding family schedules and hotel accommodations for the First Family, while evaluating the political implications of George McGovern's campaign. Additionally, the President issued instructions to Herbert Stein regarding Argentine beef imports and expressed relief regarding the status of the Watergate investigation.

June 24, 1972 · with Nixon

President Nixon consulted with Herbert Stein to provide cautionary instructions regarding Federal Reserve Chairman Arthur Burns' upcoming trip to Argentina. Nixon expressed skepticism regarding the long-standing health justifications for restricting Argentine beef imports and tasked Stein with coordinating with Secretary of Agriculture Earl Butz to ensure Burns did not inadvertently make unsustainable trade promises. This conversation served to manage potential diplomatic fallout and domestic political complications surrounding international trade policies.

June 26, 1972 · with Nixon, Shultz & Ehrlichman

President Nixon met with his economic and policy advisors, including George P. Shultz, Herbert Stein, and John D. Ehrlichman, to deliberate on fiscal strategy, federal spending constraints, and the administration's legislative priorities. The discussion focused on managing the federal budget for fiscal years 1973 through 1975, specifically addressing inflation, revenue sharing, welfare reform, and potential veto strategies to control congressional expenditures. The participants also explored the political ramifications of proposed spending cuts and tax policy adjustments ahead of the upcoming election cycle.

June 30, 1972 · with Nixon, Cost of Living Council & Shultz

President Nixon met with the Cost of Living Council to address surging food and meat prices, emphasizing the need to combat inflation without imposing direct price controls. The discussion focused on managing supply-side pressures, including reduced military food stockpiles and potential adjustments to meat import policies, while coordinating a "jawboning" strategy to encourage price restraint among industry leaders and labor unions. Nixon urged the council to publicly highlight the administration's commitment to fighting inflation while cautioning against speculating on a price freeze, which he warned would destabilize the market.

July 21, 1972 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon met with his Cabinet and senior staff to discuss strategies for achieving a balanced federal budget by 1975, emphasizing the necessity of immediate spending cuts and potential vetoes of congressional legislation to curb inflation. Budget Director George Shultz outlined the administration’s plan to issue "ceiling letters" to agency heads to enforce strict fiscal guidelines and reduce government deficits. The participants also reviewed recent positive economic indicators, including growth in the Gross National Product and declining unemployment, while noting that the public generally views government spending as a primary driver of inflation.

July 25, 1972 · with Nixon, Bull & Coleman

President Nixon met with various administration officials to review the progress of the Property Review Board, focusing on the management and transfer of federal lands for public use. The President expressed frustration with bureaucratic inertia, citing a specific case at Camp Pendleton where beach access was hindered by poor facility planning and lack of oversight. Additionally, the President urged his staff to better publicize positive economic trends, such as inflation reduction and job growth, to provide congressional candidates with a more effective campaign narrative.

July 31, 1972 · with Nixon, Colson & Haldeman

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and key staff, including George Shultz, Caspar Weinberger, Herbert Stein, H.R. Haldeman, and John Ehrlichman, to refine the administration's public relations strategy regarding the economy ahead of the 1972 election. The group evaluated the political impact of inflation, unemployment, and food prices, concluding that the public primarily associated rising food costs with processors and middlemen rather than the administration. Nixon directed his team to avoid getting bogged down in minor press interviews and instead focus their efforts on high-impact television appearances and providing economic talking points for political surrogates to utilize in their campaigns.

107-001Tape 1072 hr 8 min

August 8, 1972 · with Nixon, Weinberger & Scott

President Nixon met with a large group of Republican Congressional leaders to coordinate legislative strategy and discuss the administration's economic record ahead of the upcoming election. The conversation focused on countering Senator George McGovern's economic proposals, with the President and his advisors emphasizing that the administration's policies had fostered recovery, reduced inflation, and increased civilian employment. Key action items included distributing briefing materials to counter Democratic attacks, pushing for a government spending ceiling to avoid future tax increases, and planning strategy for upcoming votes on controversial appropriation bills and foreign aid legislation.

107-002Tape 1071 hr 23 min

August 10, 1972 · with Nixon, Cost of Living Council & Shultz

President Nixon met with the Cost of Living Council to review the performance of his administration's economic stabilization program, including successes in lowering inflation and fostering rapid economic growth. The discussion emphasized the necessity of maintaining fiscal discipline through a proposed $250 billion federal spending ceiling to prevent future inflationary pressure. Participants also addressed specific challenges, particularly rising food prices and the potential impact of government spending on tax rates, while strategizing on how to communicate these economic gains to the public ahead of the election.

September 11, 1972 · with Nixon, Council on International Economic Policy & Rogers

President Nixon met with the Council on International Economic Policy and senior advisors to discuss U.S. trade relations with an expanding European Community. The group debated four strategic options ranging from maintaining the status quo to aggressive confrontation, with the President ultimately directing that the administration maintain a firm, "tough" stance while avoiding specific, provocative threats until after the upcoming election. Nixon emphasized that trade policy should not be viewed in isolation but as a component of a broader strategy concerning global power balances and U.S. national security commitments in Europe.

777-002Tape 7772 hr 1 min

September 14, 1972 · with Nixon, Ehrlichman & Bull

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and staff to plan the logistics of an upcoming revenue-sharing bill signing ceremony and to discuss future tax policy and budget strategies. The President emphasized the need for political carefulness regarding tax reform, expressing a strong desire to avoid any perception of a tax increase while seeking ways to provide property tax relief for senior citizens. The participants debated the merits of various tax proposals, including minimum tax adjustments and simplification measures, ultimately focusing on balancing fiscal responsibility with the administration's political objectives leading up to the 1972 election.

794-002Tape 7941 hr 25 min

October 9, 1972 · with Nixon, Shultz & Burns

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and staff, including George Shultz, Arthur Burns, and Caspar Weinberger, to coordinate administration messaging and planning for the post-election period. The discussion focused on maintaining a firm stance on congressional spending, specifically concerning upcoming vetoes of water and education legislation, and establishing a strategy for economic policy, including the transition of wage and price controls. Nixon emphasized the need for long-term domestic initiatives and urged his team to use the post-election period for deep reflection and strategic planning rather than immediate political reaction.

October 27, 1972 · with Nixon, Committee on the Health Services Industry & Dunn

President Nixon met with members of the Committee on the Health Services Industry, along with administration officials including Herbert Stein and Donald Rumsfeld, to address the escalating costs of medical care. The discussion centered on balancing price controls with the need to maintain quality, specifically debating how to curb the proliferation of unnecessary services and the duplication of facilities without stifling the voluntary health system. Nixon emphasized the administration's goal of fostering cooperation with the medical profession to ensure federal health spending remains efficient and avoids a shift toward socialized medicine.

December 20, 1972 · with Meany, Lyons & Dennis

Herbert Stein, Donald Rumsfeld, and George Shultz met with prominent labor union leaders to discuss the state of the economy and federal productivity initiatives. The discussion touched upon current economic indicators, including farm prices, and featured planning for an upcoming productivity exhibit at the Smithsonian Institution. The meeting served as a consultative session between the administration and labor representatives regarding ongoing economic policy and the Productivity Commission's objectives.

December 20, 1972 · with Nixon, National Commission on Productivity & Meany

President Nixon met with the National Commission on Productivity, including various labor union leaders and administration officials, to express his appreciation for their voluntary service and to emphasize the necessity of labor-management cooperation in national economic policy. Nixon encouraged the members to offer input beyond labor issues and reaffirmed that his door remains open for direct engagement between the White House and organized labor. The discussion also touched on specific policy concerns, including maritime programs, grain exports, and the challenges faced by local unions.

January 9, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Ehrlichman

President Nixon met with George Shultz, Herbert Stein, and John Ehrlichman to strategize on economic messaging and upcoming policy announcements, specifically regarding the Cost of Living Council and rising food prices. They discussed plans to implement targeted administrative actions—such as reducing export subsidies and adjusting stockpiles—to mitigate inflation while framing congressional overspending as the primary threat to the nation's economic prosperity. Nixon emphasized the need for an aggressive public relations campaign to highlight the administration's economic record and to shift the political burden for potential fiscal instability onto the Democratic-controlled Congress.

January 24, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

In this meeting, President Nixon met with his Vice President, Cabinet, and senior staff to provide a briefing on the impending Vietnam cease-fire agreement, scheduled for signing on January 27, 1973. National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger detailed the arduous negotiation process, emphasizing that the agreement achieved key U.S. objectives including the return of POWs, the withdrawal of American forces, and the right of South Vietnamese self-determination. Following the Vietnam discussion, the President transitioned to a briefing on the fiscal year 1974 budget, where Director Caspar Weinberger presented plans for spending cuts and program terminations designed to maintain a full-employment balance and avoid tax increases.

January 24, 1973 · with Nixon, Cabinet officers & Agnew

President Nixon met with his Vice President, Cabinet members, and senior staff to conduct a briefing on the upcoming federal budget. The discussion focused on the necessity of fiscal restraint, including the reduction and termination of certain government programs, to avoid tax increases and curb inflationary pressures while maintaining an expanding economy. Cabinet members analyzed projections for the 1974 and 1975 budgets, emphasizing the shift in spending priorities from defense toward human resources and the importance of presenting the budget to Congress and the public as a responsible alternative to higher taxation.

January 24, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon and his Cabinet members strategized on how to promote the administration’s 1974 budget and defend proposed spending cuts against inevitable Congressional and lobbying opposition. The participants emphasized shifting from a constituency-based political strategy to a national message centered on fiscal responsibility, specifically using the themes of 'jobs' and 'taxes' to appeal to working-class voters. Nixon underscored the necessity of forcing Congress to accept accountability for spending, ultimately positioning the administration to blame Democrats if tax increases become required to fund legislative priorities.

January 26, 1973 · with Agnew, Shultz & Mansfield

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew and a broad bipartisan group of Congressional leaders to outline the administration's 1974 federal budget and economic strategy. Economic advisors Herbert Stein and George Shultz presented data highlighting a strong 1972 economy and stressed the necessity of fiscal discipline to curb inflation and maintain growth. The President urged Congress to support his proposed spending ceilings, emphasizing the need to avoid the inflationary deficits experienced during the late 1960s, while briefly acknowledging progress toward a Vietnam peace settlement.

January 26, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Shultz

President Nixon met with bipartisan Congressional leaders, cabinet members, and staff to outline the administration’s strategy for the 1973 and 1974 federal budgets, emphasizing a commitment to avoiding tax increases. The President defended his use of impoundment to control spending and curb inflation, arguing that Congress must share the responsibility of fiscal discipline or face the political consequences of tax hikes. The discussion also addressed the economic impact of the Vietnam cease-fire, defense budget priorities, and the need for greater cooperation between the executive and legislative branches to manage spending levels.

January 31, 1973 · with Nixon, Solomon & Whitman

President Nixon met with Herbert Stein and staff from the Council of Economic Advisers in the Cabinet Room to sign the 1973 Economic Report. The discussion touched upon the timing of the report's release in relation to Vietnam policy announcements and media coverage, specifically referencing reporting by Hobart Rowen. The meeting concluded with Nixon distributing pens and commemorative gifts to the attendees while offering lighthearted remarks about the staff's work on the report.

849-001Tape 8491 hr 19 min

February 5, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Ash

President Nixon met with his key economic advisors—George Shultz, Herbert Stein, Roy Ash, and John Ehrlichman—to assess the administration's economic policy, particularly the transition to Phase III of the wage and price controls. The group discussed the political and economic challenges of managing inflation, maintaining a $250 billion budget ceiling, and navigating potential labor strikes, with Nixon emphasizing the need for a unified strategy and public confidence. The participants also addressed international trade tensions, the devaluation of the dollar, and the necessity of managing Congressional relations to sustain the administration's fiscal objectives.

February 7, 1973 · with Nixon, Dunlop & Ehrlichman

President Nixon met with John T. Dunlop and several senior administration officials to formalize Dunlop’s appointment as the new chair of the Cost of Living Council. The discussion centered on the challenges of implementing Phase III of the administration's economic policy, specifically emphasizing the necessity of fiscal restraint and cooperation from labor and management to combat inflation. Nixon expressed his confidence in Dunlop’s unique ability to bridge the gap between business and labor interests to stabilize food prices and the broader economy.

868-008Tape 8681 hr 43 min

March 3, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Burns

President Nixon met with his economic advisors—including George Shultz, Arthur Burns, and Paul Volcker—to discuss the state of the domestic economy, concerns regarding inflation, and the ongoing volatility in international monetary markets. The participants debated the merits of federal intervention in currency exchange rates versus allowing a transition to a more flexible floating regime. Nixon emphasized that any economic strategy must account for his broader foreign policy objectives and the need to maintain strong political relationships with European allies, ultimately tasking Henry Kissinger to join the group to further weigh these options.

117-007Tape 1172 hr 18 min

March 9, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon and his Cabinet met to launch a strategic public relations campaign, titled the Presidential Spokesmen program, aimed at pressuring Congress to support his budget priorities and oppose spending-heavy legislation. Nixon urged his officials to frame the budget debate not as a constitutional conflict, but as a direct choice between the economic interests of the 'New American Majority' and the fiscal irresponsibility of the opposition. The session included briefings on foreign policy, defense spending, and law enforcement, emphasizing the need for administration spokesmen to maintain a positive, disciplined narrative while avoiding defensive posturing on 'false issues.'

March 9, 1973 · with Nixon, Simon & Dunlop

President Nixon met with his economic advisors to address rising inflation, specifically focusing on the political and economic instability caused by soaring food prices and labor's wage demands. He instructed his team to aggressively bypass bureaucratic resistance and increase the supply of commodities by selling off federal stockpiles and grain surpluses to stabilize the market. Nixon emphasized the need for a more visible and proactive administration stance, including the possibility of issuing a white paper on the food situation to reassure the public and unions.

March 13, 1973 · with Nixon, Cabinet officers & Butz

President Nixon met with his Cabinet and key administration officials to address the national crisis of rising food prices and related supply chain bottlenecks. The discussion focused on agricultural production, the impact of labor costs on retail food prices, and the implementation of strategic stockpiling policies to stabilize the market. The President instructed his team to prioritize the transportation of farm produce, explore measures to increase production, and maintain clear accountability through regular reporting to manage public concern and inflation.

March 20, 1973 · with Nixon, Dunlop & Scott

President Nixon met with Republican Congressional leaders and economic advisors to discuss strategies for addressing rising food prices, inflation, and the ongoing transition of the wage-price stabilization program. Key topics included the administration's efforts to increase food supplies and imports, the management of labor-management relations, and the necessity of maintaining party unity to sustain presidential vetoes on spending legislation. The meeting underscored the administration's focus on economic control and the importance of Congressional support in implementing fiscal policy.

900-028Tape 9001 hr 22 min

April 18, 1973 · with Nixon, Bull & Shultz

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and cabinet members to discuss how to manage persistent inflation and public frustration with the economy following the recent passage of the Economic Stabilization Act. Arthur Burns and others proposed various policy adjustments, including a potential return to some Phase 2-style controls like pre-notification, while Roy Ash and Herbert Stein argued for staying the course with Phase 3 to avoid further distorting the market. Ultimately, the administration emphasized the importance of fiscal restraint and maintaining a consistent long-term strategy rather than implementing impulsive or overly restrictive controls that could trigger a recession.

April 18, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Burns

President Nixon met with his economic advisors, including George Shultz, Arthur Burns, and Roy Ash, to discuss the administration's ongoing struggle with inflation and the potential implementation of Phase III economic stabilization measures. The participants analyzed the political and psychological impact of price controls, the efficacy of pre-notification requirements for major corporations, and the necessity of maintaining public confidence amid rising prices. Nixon emphasized the importance of fiscal discipline, particularly regarding the federal budget, while rejecting broad, disruptive price freezes in favor of targeted economic management.

123-002Tape 1231 hr 57 min

April 20, 1973 · with Nixon, Cabinet officers & Casey

President Nixon met with his Cabinet and key staff to coordinate messaging and strategy on pressing administration priorities, specifically energy policy, economic inflation, and the ongoing Watergate investigations. Nixon urged his officials to actively support the administration's legislative agenda, particularly in the face of rising economic concerns and energy supply challenges. He emphasized the necessity of a unified, firm stance against political pressure, framing the current crises as manageable problems rather than catastrophic failures. Additionally, Nixon underscored his commitment to a thorough investigation into Watergate, stressing the need to maintain public order and confidence while the legal process unfolded.

May 2, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Dunlop

President Nixon met with the Labor-Management Advisory Committee, including George Shultz, John T. Dunlop, and various labor and business leaders, to discuss the ongoing management of the national economy and inflation. The discussion centered on the successes and challenges of the administration's economic stabilization efforts, particularly the transition from Phase II to Phase III of wage and price controls. Participants deliberated on the importance of maintaining public confidence and business compliance, with the President emphasizing the need for continued cooperation between labor and management to ensure stability without excessive government intervention.

909-003Tape 9091 hr 24 min

May 2, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Shultz

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew and his key economic advisors to assess the national economy, focusing on rising inflation and the status of the Phase III wage and price control program. The group evaluated the success of recent industrial wage settlements, particularly in the meatpacking industry, and discussed the potential necessity of fiscal and monetary restraint to avoid a future recession. The President and his team ultimately decided against implementing a new price freeze while considering the political feasibility of a variable investment tax credit with Congressional leaders.

May 10, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew and his Cabinet to discuss the ongoing impact of the Watergate scandal on the administration, personnel changes, and the need to maintain governmental stability. Key topics included the appointment of a special prosecutor, the selection of Elliot Richardson, and the importance of professional coordination between the White House and Cabinet departments to ensure the administration's 1972 election mandate remained the primary focus. Nixon emphasized the necessity of improving Congressional relations and maintaining morale within the bureaucracy despite the political distractions caused by the Ervin Committee hearings.

May 15, 1973 · with Nixon, Dunlop & Scott

President Nixon met with a broad group of Republican Congressional leaders to propose the creation of a bipartisan, independent commission on federal election reform. The President outlined the commission's broad mandate to study and recommend improvements to campaign financing, ethics, disclosure rules, and potentially the length of election campaigns. Nixon emphasized that the commission, which would include both public members and Congressional representatives, should serve as a catalyst for practical reform and generate public support for legislative action without preempting the authority of existing Congressional committees. The meeting focused on establishing a non-partisan framework to address the inefficiencies and technical challenges identified in previous election laws.

124-002Tape 1241 hr 13 min

May 25, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon and Vice President Agnew met with the Cabinet and senior staff to discuss major foreign and domestic policy priorities and internal administration management. The discussion centered on upcoming diplomatic summits with Leonid Brezhnev and Georges Pompidou, negotiations with North Vietnam regarding the ceasefire, and economic challenges including inflation and energy policy. Additionally, General Alexander Haig briefed the Cabinet on the administration's efforts to stabilize internal governance, improve relations with Congress, and manage the ongoing political fallout from the Watergate scandal.

929-017Tape 9291 hr 8 min

May 29, 1973 · with Nixon, Haig & Shultz

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and staff to discuss growing concerns over inflation, the stock market, and the public's perception of the economy. The group analyzed the potential effectiveness of various measures, including a possible excise tax on gasoline, an investment tax credit, and a compulsory savings plan, while considering the political challenges of implementing such a package with Congress. Ultimately, the President decided against immediate, piecemeal action, opting instead to have his advisors develop a comprehensive economic package for review at a follow-up meeting.

932-001Tape 9321 hr 6 min

June 5, 1973 · with Nixon, Haig & Shultz

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and John Connally to evaluate potential policy responses to the national economy, specifically focusing on the impact of food prices and the potential implementation of an export freeze. The group debated the efficacy of a 60-day price freeze versus alternative measures to curb inflation and addressed the political risks associated with such interventions. Additionally, Nixon and Connally discussed Connally's ongoing advisory role, navigating the potential for public speculation regarding his conflict of interest and the administration's need to maintain a strong, proactive image amid the escalating Watergate scandal.

124-006Tape 1241 hr 16 min

June 7, 1973 · with Nixon, Cabinet officers & Agnew

President Nixon met with his Cabinet and key legislative leaders to discuss the restructuring of domestic policy operations, the appointment of Clarence M. Kelley as FBI Director, and strategies for improving congressional cooperation. Nixon emphasized a team-based approach to policy formulation, delegating significant oversight to Mel Laird, and urged Cabinet members to actively engage with Congress to pass the administration's legislative agenda. The discussion also addressed the administration's response to inflation, the importance of maintaining public morale amidst the Watergate crisis, and the necessity of presenting a unified, forward-looking policy front to the American people.

935-007Tape 9352 hr 49 min

June 11, 1973 · with Nixon, Haig & Connally

President Nixon met with Alexander Haig to discuss personnel and political strategy regarding Watergate, specifically focusing on the role of Attorney General Elliot Richardson. Following this, Nixon convened with John Connally, George Shultz, Herbert Stein, and John Dunlop to debate the administration's economic response to mounting Congressional pressure for a wage and price freeze. The group evaluated various options, ultimately deciding on a strategy that balanced political necessity with the risks of economic uncertainty, while preparing for a follow-up consultation with labor and management leaders.

125-002Tape 1252 hr 9 min

June 11, 1973 · with Nixon, President's Advisory Committee on Labor-Management Policy & Dunlop

President Nixon met with the President's Advisory Committee on Labor-Management Policy to discuss the state of the national economy and potential strategies for curbing inflation, specifically focusing on the recent surge in food prices. Participants, including key labor leaders like George Meany and Leonard Woodcock, debated the merits of various policy options, including a possible price freeze versus maintaining the flexibility of Phase III controls. Nixon emphasized his administration's goal of returning to a free economy while acknowledging the need for potential short-term actions to restore public confidence and address the public's anxiety over rising costs.

June 11, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Dunlop

President Nixon met with George Shultz, Herbert Stein, and John Dunlop to discuss economic strategies for curbing inflation, specifically focusing on the implementation of export controls and potential wage-price freezes. The participants debated the necessity and credibility of these measures, particularly regarding food prices and foreign aid, while considering the political implications of upcoming electoral cycles. Nixon expressed a determination to eventually move toward a strengthened Phase III economic policy and tasked the advisors with developing a concrete plan to manage these economic interventions effectively.

938-003Tape 9382 hr 32 min

June 12, 1973 · with Nixon, Haig & Shultz

President Nixon met with his senior economic advisors and staff to deliberate on a strategy for stabilizing the national economy, specifically focusing on a proposed 60-day price freeze on food and gasoline. The discussion covered the implementation of Phase IV economic controls, the necessity of securing congressional support for trade and spending measures, and the political challenges of potential vetoes on agricultural and minimum wage legislation. Nixon emphasized the importance of public education regarding his administration's economic goals and requested that his cabinet members and advisors actively advocate for these policies to build public and congressional confidence.

June 13, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon met with his Vice President, Cabinet members, and senior staff to announce the implementation of a 60-day price freeze as part of a strategy to combat inflation. He explained that this measure, aimed at stabilizing food and gasoline prices, was a necessary pragmatic step to preempt more extreme, mandatory controls favored by Congress. Nixon emphasized his commitment to maintaining a free-market economy and tasked his Cabinet with actively promoting this policy to the public and opinion makers. He also highlighted the administration's broader accomplishments in foreign policy, including the end of the draft and the upcoming U.S.-Soviet summit.

126-002Tape 1261 hr 6 min

June 13, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Shultz

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew, cabinet members, and a bipartisan group of Congressional leaders to announce an upcoming economic policy address and discuss the administration's new strategy to combat inflation. The President detailed a 60-day price freeze—excluding wages and raw agricultural products—and sought legislative assistance regarding export controls on food and gasoline supply allocations. Additionally, the President arranged for key Congressional leaders to receive ongoing briefings from administration officials during the upcoming summit with Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev to ensure better oversight of the resulting agreements.

July 10, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Shultz

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew, top economic advisors, and a large group of Republican Congressional leaders to discuss the administration's current 60-day economic freeze and the development of a subsequent "Phase IV" program. The primary challenge identified was managing inflation and supply shortages—particularly in food—while avoiding the long-term economic damage of permanent price and wage controls. The President and his advisors sought Congressional support for a balanced budget and specific legislative measures, such as the release of strategic stockpiles, while acknowledging the significant political difficulty of passing unpopular fiscal reforms. Participants emphasized the need for a careful balance between short-term political relief and long-term economic stability to avoid the pitfalls of past rationing and supply-side distortions.

July 10, 1973 · with Nixon, Shultz & Ash

President Nixon met with his economic advisors and Cabinet members to debate the design of 'Phase IV' of his economic program, focusing on the appropriate speed for removing wage and price controls. The discussion centered on balancing the political need to curb inflation with the economic necessity of incentivizing production, particularly in the agricultural sector, where export controls and price ceilings had created supply shortages. The President and his team also addressed the critical need for a balanced federal budget to bolster business confidence, ultimately agreeing on the necessity of a tough, credible policy to stabilize the economy.

July 11, 1973 · with Nixon, Agnew & Cabinet officers

President Nixon met with Vice President Agnew and his Cabinet to discuss the transition from the current wage and price freeze to a "Phase IV" economic policy. The President emphasized the need to balance controlling inflation with maintaining domestic production, while acknowledging the political difficulty of removing controls due to congressional and public pressure. Key developments included the administration's resolve to move toward a free-market economy as quickly as possible, coupled with a renewed commitment to fiscal austerity and a balanced federal budget to bolster economic confidence.